Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
10, 1994
Translated from Denshi Joho Tsushin Gakkai Ronbunshi, Vol. 76-B-II, No. 9, September 1993, pp. 765-772
Masaji Sato, Shoichi Kuramoto, Members, and Koichi Matsuoka, Minoru Ohta,
75 ISSN8756-6621 /94/0010-0075
1994 Scripta Technica, Inc.
Current I
Surrounded
area A
76
equivalent circuit is shown in Fig. 2 when an integrator simply proportional to the current. However, if CO
and a measuring instrument with an input impedance of R^ + i?j, Eq. (6) can be approximated as follows:
R^ are connected.
Vx= Vo= (8)
If it is assumed that the mutual inductance in the
winding is negligible, then IQ is given in the following
equation for the inductance of the coil and Q is given if Since the current-voltage conversion factor is pro-
it is represented by the static capacitance between the portional to frequency in this case, the output voltage V^
parallel twin wire replacing the spiral winding [4, 5]: is a differential waveform of the current /. In general,
the input impedance of the measuring instrument is 10
kQ to 1 MQ. Hence, if the measuring instrument is
(3)
connected directly to the Rogowski coil, a differential
waveform such as Eq. (8) often is obtained.
o
Since the resonant frequency f^. in the foregoing is Next, consider the case where a CR integrator is
the usable upper limit frequency, it is important in the connected. If the conditions identical to Eq. (6) are con-
design to minimize LQ and Q as much as possible. sidered for RQ, LQ, and Q in Fig. 2, the output voltage
V^ to the measuring instrument is given as
Let us consider first the case in which a measuring In Eq. (9), the condition for the output voltage V^ to be
instrument is connected directly to the Rogowski coil in simply proportional to the current / is given by the fol-
Fig. 2. If it is assumed that C^ is extremely small and lowing equations where the corresponding relationship
negligible and also CO^LQQ < 1, the voltage V^ measured between V^ and / can also be approximated:
in the instrument is given as
(10)
(6)
(11)
Further, in the case where CDLQ >-RC + R^in Eq. (6), the
output voltage V^ to the measuring instrument is given as When the solution of the quadratic equation of co is
follows when Eq. (2) is substituted: obtained in Eq. (10) and the condition of R^ <. R^ is
considered, the range of o) is as follows:
1/ _ VQRX _ Rx T
^ jcoLo nl (7)
(o>-
2Lo
Hence, the current-voltage conversion factor in this case
is independent of frequency and the output voltage V^ is If 4Lo < RXs, then
77
sensitivity characteristics of the Rogowski coil in the
Measured time domain data frequency axis must be compensated. The procedure is
shown in Fig. 3.
x~ "T" Fourier inversion In Eqs. (13) and (14), the relationships of the frequency
to the sampling time interval t^ and to the number of
Revised time domain data samples A^ are
/max-2^
(15)
Fig. 3. Revising methods for the measured data.
(16)
78
Table 1. Design target of Rogowski coil
for columns 0.5 to 1.5 m long with circumferential to be i?^ = 10 kQ and C^ = 1.5 nF such that the condi-
length of the radio relay anterma tower. tions in Eq. (12), 4Lo < R/C^ and R^ < R^.
(2) Electrical characteristics Next, let us consider the resonant frequency of the
coil and the current-voltage conversion factor. From
Also shown in Table 1 are the target values of the section 2, the resonant frequency of the coil is given by
electrical characteristics. The current-voltage conversion Eq. (5). As the values of LQ and Q are increased, the
factor was chosen to be 1/100 in consideration that the resonant frequency/^ tends to be smaller. When Eqs. (3)
current to be measured is several amps to several kil- and (4) are substituted into Eq. (5), the relationship of
amps, and the measurement range of the digital memory the resonant frequency with the coil structure is given by
is several tens millivolts to several tens volts. For the
current over this value, the range of the measured volt-
1
age is adjusted by a resistive voltage divider. The fre- log-
fr = nr
quency range is up to 300 kHz in consideration of the 2nl (18)
fact that the rise time of the direct lightning strike surge
current is about 1 \is. The frequency is proportional to 3/4th power of the
cross section a and to 3/2th power of the number of
winding n. The resonant frequency decreases as a and n
3.2. Structural design are increased. The resonant frequency is inversely pro-
portional to the coil length /. As / is increased, the reso-
As described in section 2, it is necessary in the nant frequency is estimated to decrease. Further, the
design of a Rogowski coil to determine the optimum resonant frequency is related to the conductor radius r of
condition of the integration start frequency of the integra- the coil winding. The resonant frequency increases as the
tor and the upper limit of the coil (resonant frequency) in conductor r is decreased.
consideration of the current-voltage conversion factor.
On the other hand, the current-voltage conversion
Let us consider first the integration start frequency. factor is given by Eq. (10) and the sensitivity is im-
This is given by Eq. (12). It is desirable that the integra- proved as the cross-section a and the number of winding
tion is possible at the lowest possible frequency. Howev- n are increased. (Note that this sensitivity has little de-
er, as indicated by Eqs. (11) and (12), an extension of pendence on the coil length and on the conductor radius
the integration to a lower frequency and a setting of a of the winding.)
larger current-voltage conversion factor are contradicto-
ry. Therefore, the integration frequency is restricted to From the foregoing, the cross section a is made
a range over 10 kHz in which the RF frequency compo- constant since the external diameter of the coil of the
nents of the rising part of the lightning surge current are design target is fixed. The resonant frequency and the
contained. The frequencies below this value are coped current-voltage conversion factor are plotted in terms of
with by the Fourier-transform computation in section the number of winding n, the coil length /, and the wire
2.3. The resistance R^ and the capacitance Cj are selected diameter r. The results are shown in Figs. 4 and 5.
79
10'
Winding diameter : 34
Numberof the winding : 170 (Turn/m)
N
10
10=
10- 1 10'
Number of the winding (Turn/m)
Diameter of the wire (mm)
Fig. 4. Relations between the number of the winding,
Fig. 5. Relations between the diameter of the wire
resonance frequencies, and conversion factors.
and resonance frequencies.
80
Table 2. Structure of Rogowski coil fabricated for trial
^ 10'
Length of the coil : 3 m N \ , Calculated
o
V
a) ,Measured
I
o
Required area |_J \
8 300 kHz
81
Rogowski coil current was measured. Also studied is the effect of the
50cm current in the exterior of the coil on the current measure-
ment inside the coil.
5cm
Figure 8(a) shows the position of the current to be
measured while Fig. 8(b) shows the current-voltage
conversion factor for such a current. Figure 8(c) shows
the waveform observed when a lightning surge current of
1 X 40 us flows in the wire at the location of A in Fig.
(a) Measured position of the current 8(a). The output of the integrator is shown with a dotted
line and the waveform corrected by the procedure in Fig.
3 is shown with a solid line. To compare the position
dependence of the waveform, identical measurement was
(dB)
Length of the coil 3 m carried out at the positions 5 to F in Fig. 8(a). The
-20
CAJLB waveforms at B and C are identical to the one at A while
tor
82
(2) Based on the equivalent circuit described in the
foregoing, the winding diameter and the wire diameter of
the copper wire can be designed for the given design
target. A hollow coil with a vinyl-pipe core was fabricat-
ed. A coil was realized which has a length of 1 to 10 m,
an effective frequency of 1 to 300 kHz and a current-
voltage conversion factor of 1/100.
5. Conclusions
To measure the lightning surge current in columns,
REFERENCES
girders and walls of the center of a building, a Rogowski
1. 1. Hayashi and Y. Nakano. Rogowski coil and
coil was designed which has a length sufficient to sur-
magnetic probe. Jour. Inst. Electrical Engineers of
round a column with its side exceeding 1 m and which
Japan, 81, 874 (June 1961).
can be installed in a flexible manner in the measurement
2. T. Harada. Measurement of high voltage and large
location. As shown below, a sufficiently practical coil
current in nuclear fusion. Electric Power Central
has been develoj)ed.
Research Laboratory Report, No. 183003 (June
1983).
(1) The equivalent circuit of the coil can be ex- 3. H. Krompholz, J. Doggett, K. H. Schoenbach, J.
pressed in terms of lumped elements such as the induc- Gahl, C. Harjes, G. Schaefer, and M. Kristiansen.
tance L of the coil itself, the resistance R, and the static Nanosecond current probe for high-voltage experi-
capacitance C between the wirings. Its resonant frequen- ments. Rev. Sci. Instrum., 55, 1 (Jan. 1984).
cy is the usable upper limit frequency of the coil. The 4. Takeyama. Electromagnetic Phenomenology.
output voltage of a CR-type integrator connected to the Maruzen Publ. (1969).
coil can be estimated by the equivalent circuit. The num- 5. K. Funabashi. Exercises for Electromagnetic
ber of windings and the wire diameter of the coil can be Theory. Tokyo Denki Daigaku (May 1967).
designed from the integration start frequency of the 6. K. Kido. Fast Fourier transform and its applica-
integrator, the resonant frequency of the coil, and the tions. Jour. Institute of Electronics and Communi-
current-voltage conversion factor. cations of Japan, 9, 3 (March 1976).
83
AUTHORS (from left to right)
J^^ ^5^^
a
yi Sato graduated in 1972 from the Department of Electrical Engineering, Yamagata University, and joined
Nippon Telegraph and Telephone. Since then, he has been engaged in research on structural design of metal communication
cables, gas dam structural design of optical fiber cables, grounding configurations of telephone center buildings, insulation
test of communication equipment, and disaster protection. Presently, he is a senior Research Engineer at NTT Telecommu-
nication Networks Laboratories, Communication Quality Research Department.
Shoichi Kuramoto graduated in 1985 from the Department of Electronic Engineering, Ibaraki University, and joined
Nippon Telegraph and Telephone, Telecommunication Networks Laboratories. Since then, he has been engaged in research
on grounding configuration in a telephone station. Presently, he is a senior researcher of NTT Telecommunication
Networks Laboratories, Communication Quality Research Department.
Koichi Matsuoka graduated in 1986 from Special College of Kogakuin University and joined Nippon Telegraph
and Telephone. Since 1991, he has been engaged in research on grounding configuration in a telephone station.
Minoru Ohta graduated in 1970 from the Department of Electrical Engineering, Tottori Prefectural Yonago
Technical High School, and joined Nippon Telegraph and Telephone. Since 1989, he has been engaged in research on
grounding configuration in a telephone station. Presently, he is with NTT Chugoku Branch, Equipment Service Department.
Koji Takemoto graduated in 1976 from the Department of Electrical Engineering, Komatsu Technical High School,
and joined Nippon Telegraph and Telephone. Since 1989, he has been engaged in research on grounding configuration in
a telephone station. Presently, he is with NTT Facilities, Hokuriku Branch.
84