Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
_________________________
:
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY, : SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY
: APPELLATE DIVISION DOCKET
v. : NO. A-002811-16T6
:
EDWARD FORCHION, : CRIMINAL ACTION
aka NJ WEEDMAN, :
: MERCER COUNTY INDICTMENT
Defendant-Appellant. : NO. 17-02-0105I
_________________________:
ON APPEAL FROM AN ORDER OF THE
SUPERIOR COURT OF NEW JERSEY,
LAW DIVISION, MERCER COUNTY,
ORDERING THE PRE-TRIAL DETENTION
OF THE DEFENDANT-APPELLANT
SAT BELOW:
LEGAL ARGUMENT
POINT I
CONCLUSION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
INDEX TO APPENDIX
i
PROCEDURAL HISTORY AND STATEMENT OF FACTS
Mercer County Narcotics Task Force on April 27, 2016. The raid
1
February 28, 2016 fight. On March 9, 2016, Mr. Forchion filed a
2
did not, however, issue his ruling barring Mr. Forchion from
Mr. Forchion purportedly violated the Court Order (the CIs name
LEGAL ARGUMENT
POINT I
3
administration of justice. (T35-7 to 9). Jury nullification
straight up would you do 7 years or let this guy get shot in the
and children). (T27-4 to 20). Mr. Forchion served not only the
witness but the prosecutor and judge with a copy of the federal
any threat. Not one single thing was a threat, actually it was
4
looking forward to a Court hearing. (T18-1 to 3). Mr. Forchion
has not had physical contact with the witness since his arrest
that, that I wanted him to come and testify. I felt that his
5
Tampering with a witness just doesnt
involve trying to cause somebody to withhold
testimony or elude process or fail to appear
to give testimony, it also involves efforts
to get somebody to testify falsely. And
this Court is satisfied that the only way to
prevent further intimidation of witnesses or
tampering with witnesses is to detain this
defendant. (T49-9 to 16; emphasis
supplied).
concerned about the nature and risk of his obstruction and his
6
that Mr. Forchion, a pacifist, encourages violence is incorrect.
7
Process rights. Mr. Forchion was, through the Internet, only
Joint and Liberty Bell Temple III. He supports one child, age 9
medical treatment for his bone cancer and C-cell tumor in his
right knee (with a possible tumor in his left hip). This life-
CONCLUSION
Respectfully submitted,
V. TERM
DEFENDANT
COUNT!
WITNEssTAMPERING
(SECOND DEGREE)
The Grand Jurors of the State of New Jersey, for the County of Mercer, upon their oaths,
presentthat EDWARD FORCIITON between the dates of April 27, 2016 and February 10,
2017, in the City of Trenton, in the County aforesaid, and within the jurisdiction of this Court,
did, beli~ving that an official proceeding or investigation was pending or had been instituted,
knowingly engage in conduct that could cause a witness or informant to testify falsely ~dlor
witbhold testimony and/or elude legal process summoning him to testifY or supply evidence
and/or absent himself from any proceeding or investigation to which he has been lega]ly
summoned, by employing threat of force, contrary to the provisions ofN.J.S. 2C:28-5a; 2C:2-6,
and against the peace of this State, the Government and dignity of the same.
FILED
FEB 28 2017
SUPcHiOk .,;ouRT OF NJ
MERCER VICINAGE
CRIMfNAl DIVISION
Da1
.... .:.:.. -..
The Grand Jurors of the State of New Jersey, for the County of Mercer, upon their oaths,
present that EDWARD FORCHION between the dates of April 27, 2016 and February 10,
2017, in the City of Trenton, in the County aforesaid, and within the jurisdiction of this Court,
did, believing that an official ])!.'Oceeding or investigation was pending or had been instituted,
knowingly engage in conduct that could cause a witness or informant to testify falsely and/or
withhold testimony and/or elude legal process summoning him to testify or supply evidence
and/or absent himself from any proceeding or investigation to which he bas been legally
summoned, contrary to the provisions ofN.J.S. 2C:28-5a, and against the peace of this Stat~ the
/~~orepersoil
/ .
DATE: ~/OJ--r/r 2
I
FILED
FEB 28 2017
SUPtKIUK ~vurt 1 OF NJ
MERCER VICINAGE
CRIMINAL DIVISION
Da2
THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY
vs.
EDWARD R FORCHION
ADDRESS 322 EAST STATE STREET
NJ 08608-0000
NAME:
or on ant says that to the best his/her knowledge, mformation and belief the named
defendantonorabout03/03/2017 in TRENTON CITY , MERCER County,NJdid:
BELIEVING THAT AN OFFICIAL PROCEEDING OR INVESTIGATION WAS PENDING OR HAD BEEN
INSTITUTED, KNOWINGLY ENGAGE IN CONDUCT THAT COULD CAUSE A WITNESS OR INFORMANT
TO TESTIFY FALSELY AND/OR WITHHOLD TESTIMONY AND/OR ELUDE LEGAL PROCESS
SUMMONING HIM TO TESTIFY OR SUPPLY EVIDENCE AND/OR ABSENT HIMSELF FROM ANY
PROCEEDING OR INVESTIGATION TO WHICH HE HAS BEEN LEGALLY SUMMONED, BY EMPLOYING
THREAT OF FORCE, CONTRARY TO THE PROVISIONS OF N.J.S . 2C:28-5A; 2C :2-6 , ON
FEBRUARY 27, 2017 DEFENDANT WAS INDICTED ON THIS CHARGE 2ND DEGREE
CERTIFICATION: I certify that the foregoing statements made by me are t rue. I am aware that if any of the foregoing statements mado by mo are willfully false, I am subject
will be notified of your Central First Appearance/CJP date to be held at the Superior Court in the county of MERCER
at the following address: MERCER COUNTY SUPERIOR CT
00 SOU'rH WARREN STREET TRENTON NJ 08608-0000
Date of Arrest: 0 31 0 3 0 17 Appearance Date: Time: Phone: 6 0 9-5 71- 4 0 0 0
PROBABLE CAUSE DETERMINATION AND ISSUANCE OF WARRANT
0 Probable cause IS NOT found for the issuance of this complaint.
lfi Probable cause IS found for the issuance of this complaint. TASHESIA HICKMOND JUDICIAL OFFICER03/03/2017
Signature and TiUe of Judicial Officer Issuing Warrant Date
TO ANY PEACE OFFICER OR OTHER AUTHORIZED PERSON: PURSUANT TO THIS WARRANT YOU ARE HEREBY COMMANDED TO ARREST THE
NAMED DEFENDANT AND BRING THAT PERSON FORTHWITH BEFORE THE COURT TO ANSWER THE COMPLAINT.
Da3
EDWARD R FORCHION
ON THIS CHARGE 3RD DEGREE
Original Charge
Charge
Da4
EDWARD R
by:
Amended Charge
Waiver lndt!Jury
Jail Term
Probation Term
Cond. Discharge Term
Community Service
Restitution
BenefiCiary:
DATE
Da5
EDWARD R
by:
Amended Charge
Waiver lndt!Jury
Jail Term
Probation Term
Community Service
0 /L Suspension Term
Restitution
Beneficiary:
Notes: F inding
1 - Guilty
2- N ot Guilty
3 - Dismissed - Other
4 - Guilty but Merged
5- Dismissed-Rule
s - Dismissed Lacl< of Prosecution
7- Dismissed - Pros MotionNic Req
Related Traffic Tickets and Complaints: 8 - Conditional Discharge
D - Dismissed- Prosecutor Discretion
M - Dismissed- Mediation
P - Dismissed-Plea Agreement
S - Disposed at Superior
W- Dismissed-False ID
DAT E
Da6
.., .. - - _...,., ,_..,... , t...~VIVVIC..V 1 t v.vv.v&. 1 IYI 1 !:1 v VI IV 11011~ ILJ. IVIVV.U I I U JVV
NJ 08608-0000
By certification or on oath, the complainant says that to the best of his/her knowledge, and belief the named
defendant on or about 03/03/2017 in TRENTON CITY , MERCER County, NJ did:
BELIEVING THAT AN OFFICIAL PROCEEDING OR INVESTIGATION WAS PENDING OR HAD BEEN
INSTITUTED, KNOWINGLY ENGAGE IN CONDUCT THAT COULD CAUSE A WITNESS OR INFORMANT
TO TESTIFY FALSELY AND/OR WITHHOLD TESTIMONY AND/OR ELUDE LEGAL PROCESS
SUMMONING HIM TO TESTIFY OR SUPPLY EVIDENCE AND/OR ABSENT HIMSELF FROM ANY
PROCEEDING OR INVE~TIGATION TO WHICH HE HAS BEEN LEGALLY SUMMONED, BY EMPLOYING
THREAT OF FORCE, CONTRARY TO THE PROVISIONS OF N.J.S . 2C:28-SA; 2C :2 -6, ON
FEBRUARY 27, 2017 DEFENDANT WAS INDICTED ON THIS CHARGE 2ND DEGREE
CERTIFICATION: I c:ortify that tho foregoing statements made by me are true. I am aware that If any of the foregoing statements made by me are willf ully false, 1am subject
to punishment
Signed: YOLANDA M WARD Date: 03/03/2017
will be notified of your central. First Appearance/CJP date to be held at the Superior Court In the county of MERCER
at the following address: MERCER COUNTY SUPERIOR CT
TRENTON NJ 08608 - 0000
609-571-4000
~ Probable cause IS found.forthe issuance of this complaint. TASHESIA HICKMOND JUDICIAL OFFICER 03/03/2017
Signature and TiUe of Judicial Officer Issuing Warrant Date
TO ANY PEACE OFFICER OR OTHER AUTHORIZED PERSON: PURSUANT TO THIS WARRANT YOU ARE HEREBY COMMANDED TO ARREST THE
NAMED DEFENDANT AND BRING THAT PERSON FORTHWITH BEFORE THE COURT TO ANSWER THE COMPLAINT.
' 0
0 Domestic Violence -Confidential
Special conditions of release:
0 No phone, mail or other personal contact w/victim
0 No possession firearms/weapons
0 Other (specify):
Da7
vv-,v lr - vv I lv""t- I I I 1 U..:J/VvU. V 1/ O.VV.V"- r"IVI r-y 0 Ul IV lli:UI:S IU: IVIv>:>LU I fO'd 100
EDWARD R FORCHION
ON THIS CHARGE 3RD DEGREE
Original Charge
Amended Charge
Da8
vv-.c..v IJ-VV I h.l"i"-1 I I I VvfV.,Jf;C..V I f V.VV.VL r iVI rl:l I VI IV I ldll~ IL.I. IVI\J,;)LV I I OCO IOv
NJ 08607
To any Law Enforcement Official of New Jersey, You are commanded to transport
this defendant to the Warden of this county who is required to keep the defendant
in custody until a release or detention decision is made.
1. 2 C : 2 8- SA ( 1} 2 WITNESS TAMPER!
3.
4.
will be notified of your Central First Appearance/CJP date to be held at the Superior Court in the county of MERCER
at the following address: MERCER COUNTY SUPERIOR CT
400 SOUTH WARREN STREET TRENTON NJ 08608-0000
Da9
- - --- ---- - . . ... I ::I- V I IV t I Gill I~ ILl. IVI\JQLU J JO~ 100
NJ 08608-0000
NJ 08607
Purpose: This Affidavit/Certification is to more fully describe the facts of the alleged offense so that a judge or au thorized judicial officer may determine
probable cause.
Da10
-~. , vv, v- , , , , v-.~tv-.Jt &.v, 1 u . vv .v&.. r 1v1 r~ -o Ul IU II <::Ill~ 1u : IVIv;::)LV ' I/O~:noo
2. I am aware of the facts above because: (Included, but not limited to: your observations,statements
of eyewitnesses, defendant's admission, etc.)
(Continued from above) The defendant repeated this theme regularly on his
website and his social media postings. The repeated theme was he was
publishing all of this information to make "the State's Motion moot"
regardless of the Court's ruling on i t . Forchion regularly addresses his
desire to utilize jury nullification practices in his trial , addressed
potential jurors and indicated that he will continu e to affect the jury pool
as much as possible . He also published both t he J u dge's phone number and
that of the prosecutor asking people to reach out to both to affect his case .
Forchion also sent mailings to family members of the person he b e liev ed t o be
the witness/informant including his father and relativ es out of State calling
him a "rat" and/or "snitch" a n d discussing "seeing h im i n cour t " and how i t
wi ll be a bad time for this person .
Subsequent to the Court ruling in favor of the State on the protective order
on February 27 , 2017 , the defendant continu es to scoff at the
Cert i fi c ation:
I c ertify that the f o regoing s tat ements made by me are true. I am aware that i f
a ny of t he fore go i n g s t a tements ma de by me are willfully fa l se, I am s ubject to
puni s hment .
Da11
. . - -- .- - - - - ~ - ~~-~-. , ~ '" v rv a11;:, ILJ. tVIuOL:U 1 10::1100
Cortification:
I certify that t he foregoing statements made by me are true. I am aware that if any of the foregoing statemonts made by me are willfully false, 1am
subject to punishment.
Signod: ______________________________________________________________
Da12
State of New Jersey Superior Court ofNew Jersey
Law Div ision: Criminal Part
v. Mercer County
_E_D_W_A
_R__
D_R.;.;..._F..O.;.;..
.::. R....::.
C....::.H::.;_TO
-"--
N_ __ _ , Defendant Pretrial Detention Motion Order
SBI Number: ..:.1""'-9_,_,73=2=0=B"------ - Complaint/Jnd. #: W -2017-001 I 34-1 I I I
Date ofBirth: 07/23/1964 Complaint/Incl. #: _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
Complaint/Lnd. #: _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
Findings
The State having filed a motion for pretrial detention, and after conducting a hearing,
1. Probable Cause
0 The Court finds that the State has established probable cause that the eligible defendant
committed the charged offense(s) based on
0 The testimony of , AND/OR
0 The probable cause affidavit or preliminary Jaw enforcement incident report marked as
ExhibitS- , AND/OR
0 Other evidence--- -- - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - -' OR
~efendant has been indicted for the described offense(s) AND
.TPlJIC!.MG~ -r- )Jr.:) /7 o Z- OJotJ-
2. 0 The court finds by clear and convincing evidence that no amount of monetary bai I, non-
monetary conditions or combination of monetary bail and conditions would reasonably
assure:
0 defendant's appearance in court when required, AND/OR
~~tion ofthe safety of any other person or the community AND/OR
B'that the defendant will not obstruct or attempt to obstruct the criminal justice process
AND THEREFORE PRETRIAL DETENTION OF THE DEFENDANT IS HEREBY
ORDERED.
3. 0 THE MOTION FOR PRETRIAL DETENTION IS DENIED. Based upon the reasons set
f01th on the record, the cotut does not find by clear and convincing ev idence that no amount
of monetary bail, non-monetary conditions or combination of monetary bail and conditions
will reasonably assure: (a) defendant's appearance in court when required, (b) the protection
ofthe safety of any other person or the community and (c) that the defendant will not obstruct
or attempt to obstruct the crimina l justice process. THE DEFENDANT IS HEREBY
ORDERED RELEASED AS SET FORTH IN THE PRETRIAL RELEASE ORDER.
Effective 01/01/2017, Promulgated by A.l Memo (12/27/2016), CN 12081 (Pretrial Detention Motion Order) page I of3
Da13
State ofNew Jersey v.EDWARD R. FORCHION S.B.I. Number: 197320B
~e weight of the ev idence against the defendant, considering the admissibility of any evidence
sought to be excluded
~sonal observation of law enforcement officer(s) - - - - - - -- -- -- - -
0 Statements ofwitness(es) - - - -- -- -- - - - - - - 0 Recorded
0 Statements of defendant - -- - - - - -- - - - - - - 0 Recorded
0 Video
0 Aud io
0 Physical evidence (specify):
ErThe history and cha racteristics of the defendant, including the defendant's:
0 character, physical and mental condition, family ties, employment, financial resomces, length
of residence in the community, community ties, past conduct, history relating to drug or
alcohol abuse.
~nature and seriousness of the risk of obstructing or attempting to obstruct the criminal justice
process that would be posed by the defendant's release, if applicable.
~tial for witness intimidation - - - - - - - -- - -- - - -
0 Potential destruction of evidence - - - - - - - - - -- -- - -
0 Other: - - -- - -- - - -- - - - -- -- -- - - - -- -- -
W'The release recommendation of the pretrial serv ices program obtained using a risk assessment
instrument.
0 Release not recommended
ra-other: ftF-t.u>d!:<: /1- Jtit:
/7tr:J Cou-1--1" ;::ire c ~ ~J tf{JC-<-c-..
a
J}.t<::F
AJ ,A}C /f Jc,?c
}.:).//7 if .fl7
cr
Effecti ve 01 /01 /2017, Promulgated by AJ Memo ( 12/27/20 16), CN 12081 (Pretrial Detent ion Motion Order) page 2 of 3
Da14
State of New Jersey v. EDWARD R. FORCHION S.B.l. Number: 197320B
Attachments:
If Pre~ention Is Ordered,
~The Court has directed that defendant be afforded reasonable opportun ity for private
consultation with counsel.
~endant has been advised of his/her right to appea l this Order within 7 days pursuant to
R. 2:9-13.
Date:
l~lhc_h 7, 2<.J r ?
rt/f'' ....~.~'-------
--------- -_ -_ _ __ __ , J.S.C.
Effective 01/01/2017, Promu lgated by AJ Memo (12/27/20 16), CN I 208 I (Pretrial Detention Motion Order) page 3 of3
Da15
New Jersey Judiciary
...;:aw-orv Assessment
RECOMMENDATION TO COURT
RELEASE WITH CONDITIONS -WEEKLY REPORTING + HD/EM
2.
Violent Offense and 20 Years Old or Younger: No
3. Charge at the Time of Offense: Yes
4.
5.
6.
7. Failure to Appear Pretrial in Past 2 Years: 1
Da16
[I] New Jersey Judiciary
___ Criminal and Court History
- - - - - --------
Published: 0 1/2017, CN: 11972 {PSA) PSA Run Date: 03/0412017 09:39 AM Page 1 of 4
Da17
....
MANUAL,
CAM-00-005889-Q01 12/01/2000 0912112000 2C:20-3 THEFT BY UNLAW TAKING NJ
PIG
Published: 0112017, CN: 11972 (PSA) PSA Run Date: 03/04/201 7 09:39AM Page2 of4
Da18
2C:20-T RECEIVING STOLEN
CAM-00-005886-001 12/01/2000 004Y OOM 0000 PROPERTY-VAL 3 NJ P/G, CCH
$500-74999/MV/GUN ETC
2C:35-5B(10) CDS-
CAM-97-007983-001 12/01/2000 010Y OOM 0000 MANU/OIST/PWIO MARIJ- =/> 5LB, 2 NJ P/G, CCH
HASH =/>1LB
MANUAL,
CAM-00-005889-001 12/01/2000 004Y OOM OOOD 2C:20-3 THEFT BY UNLAW TAKING .I NJ
P/G
P-ublished: 01/2017, CN: 11972 (PSA) . . . .~------PsA Run Date: 03t04i2o1709:39 AM Page 3of4
Da19
Acts Committed:
ASSAULT
Relief Results:
F-PROH CONTACT VIC
F-PROH CONTACT OTH
F-PROH FUTURE DV
F-RESTR DEF FROM LOC
F..f>ROH HARAS COM V IC
F-PROH STALKING VIC
F-PROH HARAS COM OTH
FPROH STALKING OTH
FV-BUR-001656-97 ACTIVEFO 05/06/1997 05/06/1997 05/ 13/ 1997 05/13/ 1997
Acts Committed:
HARASSMENT
Relief Results:
E-PROH RET TO SCENE
F-PROH CONTACT VIC
F-COND VISIT DEF
F-PROH CONTACT OTH
FPROH FUTURE DV
F RESTR DEF FROM LOC
F..f>ROH HARAS COM VIC
F-PROH WEAPON POSS
F-PROH STALKING VIC .
. F-PROH HARAS COM OTH
F-PROH STAU<ING OTH
FV-CAM-001 95694 ACTIVE AMENDED FO 02/0411 994 NONE 02/14/1994 NONE
Acts Committed:
HARASSMENT
TERRORISTIC THREATS
ASSAULT
Relief Results:
FCOND VISIT DEF
F-MON CHILD EMER SUP
F-POSS PLNT/ALT HOUS
E- POSS PLNT/ALT HOUS
F-CHILD CUST
E-GHILO CUST
F PROH HARAS COMMUN
EPROH HARAS COMMUN
E-PROH RET TO SCENE
E-PROH FUTURE OV
F-PROH FUTURE DV
E-PROH CONT FAMILY
FPROH CONT FAMILY
E-PROH CONT VICTIM
F-PROH CONT VICTIM
Da20
FILED
MAR 06 2011
ANGELO J. ONOFRI
MERCER COUNTY PROSECUTOR SUPERIOR COURT OF NJ
MERCER VICINAGE
240 WEST STATE S1EET CRIMtNAL OMSION
TRENTON, NJ 08650
609-989-6351
EDWARD FORCHION
ORDER TO UNSEAL INDICTMENT
Assistant Prosecutor Stephanie A. Katz. to the Court for an Order Unsealing Indictment;
On February 27, 2017, an indictment was issued charging the defendant with
And the defendant having been arrested on March 3~ 2017 on the warrant of
And the Court having been satisfied that the State's application requires granting
this application, there being no further purpose for the indictment to remain sealed;
/~ ~'r-:..4:.
Hon. Robert Binghaiii U, J.S.C.
Judge of the Superior Court
51
Da21
.... ~- 4' vv I lV"""T - I I I I V'-'IV '"'ti..::..V II I V ..::..V.!JI f""'\tVI - ~ I V I l lldll~ ll...l . Vr\ IVILU I f ( lV I L
ANGELO J ONOFRI
TRENTON, NJ 086500068
EDWARD R FORCH10N
NOTICE OF MOTION
Defendant PRETRIAL DETENTION
TRENTON, NJ 086080000
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that on a date to be determined by the Court, the State shall move for
Pretrial Detention on the above matter pursuant to N .J.S.A. 2A:162-19.
Da22
- - - --- - . . ~~~T-v" ov.<..v.vr '""'ovo ,-8 t VI I lli:III~IU.vri.IVILUI// . 1..)/L
ANGELO J ONOFRI
EDWARD R FORCHION
CERTIFICATION IN SUPPORT OF
Defendant PRETRIAL DETENTION
I, STEPHANIE ANN KATZ, being of full age, upon my oath depose and state:
1. The defendant is charged with a crime and there is a serious risk that:
* the defendant will not appear in court as required;
* the defendant will pose a danger to any other person or the community; and/or
* the defendant will obstruct or attempt to obstruct justice, or threaten, injure, or intimidate, or
attempt to threaten, injure, or intimidate, a prospective witness or juror.
2. There is probable cause to believe that the defendant has committed a new crime while on
pretrial release.
The defendant is charged with second degree witness tampering and has repeatedly indicated that he will
not abide by Court Orders.
I hereby certify that to the best of my knowledge, the foregoing above statements made by me are true.
am aware that if any statements are willfully false, I am subject to punishment.
Da23