Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
27
Solutions
PSS 27.2 The Electric Field of a Continuous Distribution of Charge
Description: Knight Problem-Solving Strategy 27.2 The Electric Field of a Continuous Distribution of
Charge is illustrated. (vector applet)
Learning Goal: To practice Problem-Solving Strategy 27.2 for continuous charge distribution
problems.
A straight wire of length has a positive charge distributed along its length. Find the magnitude of
the electric field due to the wire at a point located a distance from one end of the wire along the line
extending from the wire.
3. Divide the total charge into small pieces of charge using shapes for which you
already know how to determine . This is often, but not always, a division into point
charges.
4. Draw the electric field vector at P for one or two small pieces of charge. This will help you
identify distances and angles that need to be calculated.
5. Look for symmetries in the charge distribution that simplify the field. You may conclude that
Use superposition to form an algebraic expression for each of the three components of at
point P. (Note that one or more components may be zero.)
Replace the small charge with an equivalent expression involving a charge density and a
coordinate, such as , that describes the shape of charge . This is the critical step in
making the transition from a sum to an integral because you need a coordinate to serve as the
integration variable.
Express all angles and distances in terms of the coordinates.
Let the sum become an integral. The integration will be over the coordinate variable that is
related to . The integration limits for this variable will depend on your choice of
coordinate system. Carry out the integration, and simplify the result as much as possible.
ASSESS: Check that your result is consistent with any limits for which you know what the field should
be.
Model
No information is given on the cross section of the wire. For simplicity, assume that its diameter is
much smaller than the wire's length, and model the wire as a line of charge. Also, assume that the total
charge is uniformly distributed along the wire. Note that the point at which you want to calculate the
electric field is close to one of the ends of the wire, so you cannot make use of any symmetry to
simplify the problem. Instead, you will need to divide the total charge distributed along the wire into
many small segments and model each segment as a point-like charge.
Visualize
Part A
The diagram below is an incomplete pictorial representation of the situation described in this
problem: It shows the positively charged wire, a suitable coordinate system with the origin at the left
end of the wire, and the point P at which you need to calculate the electric field. The total charge
distributed along the wire has been divided into small segments, each of length and charge
. For clarity, only the i-th segment at point is shown in the diagram.
Complete this pictorial representation by drawing the electric field at P due to segment i.
Draw the vector starting at P.
ANSWER:
View
Each small segment will contribute to the net electric field at P. By modeling each segment as a point
charge and using the principle of superposition, you can make a quick estimate of the direction of the
net field at P. To do that, it is helpful to draw the electric field due to one or two more charge
segments.
net field at P. To do that, it is helpful to draw the electric field due to one or two more charge
segments.
Part B
With reference to the coordinate system used in the previous part, which component, if any, of the
electric field due to the total charge is zero at P?
ANSWER:
both the x and y component
the x component
the y component
neither the x nor the y component
Since the point at which you want to calculate lies on a straight line extending from the wire,
must be directed along the same line. Therefore, by choosing the x axis to be parallel to the wire, as
we did in Part A, we simplified the problem: Now the y component of the field at P is zero and the
Part C
Find , the magnitude of the electric field at point P due to the total charge.
Hint
How to approach the problem
C.1
As explained in the strategy above, the mathematical expression for the net field is
did in Part A, construct a mathematical expression for , the electric field due to the i-th
segment. Treat , the x coordinate of the i-th segment, as a variable. Express the charge on the i-
th segment in terms of . Then, let become an integral and apply your knowledge of
calculus to evaluate the integral.
Hint
Find an expression for the electric field due to segment i
C.2
Find the magnitude of the electric field at point P due to a segment of charge located at
on the x axis.
Hint
C.2.1 Find the distance between point P and a segment of charge at
Assume the origin of the x axis is at the left end of the wire and point P is located at a distance
from the other end of the wire. is the length of the wire. What is the distance between
on the x axis.
Hint
C.2.1 Find the distance between point P and a segment of charge at
Assume the origin of the x axis is at the left end of the wire and point P is located at a distance
from the other end of the wire. is the length of the wire. What is the distance between
point P and a segment of charge located at on the x axis?
Express your answer in terms of some or all of the variables , , , and , and the
constants and .
ANSWER:
Hint
Find an expression for the charge of a small segment
C.3
Since you will integrate with respect to a coordinate, it is important to express the charge on a short
Find a mathematical expression for assuming the charge is uniformly distributed along the
wire. Recall that the total charge on the wire is and the length of the wire is .
Hint
Find the linear charge density
C.3.1
Assuming the wire, whose length is , has a total charge uniformly distributed along its
Now use the linear charge density to express the charge on a small segment of wire in terms of
its length as .
ANSWER:
Now use the linear charge density to express the charge on a small segment of wire in terms of
its length as .
Express your answer in terms of and some or all of the variables , , and .
ANSWER:
Hint
How to make the transition from a sum to an integral
C.4
At this point in the problem, you should have found an expression for the magnitude of the electric
field due to a small charge segment of length located at along the x axis. Make sure
that your expression for contains only the following quantities, besides the electrostatic
constant : , , , , and . If this is not the case, go back and make the
necessary substitutions (the previous hints may help you do that).
Assuming each charge segment has the same length , you can construct an algebraic
expression for the magnitude of the net field using the principle of superposition, that is,
, where the sum contains as many terms as the number of charge segments. If you
assume that there is an infinite number of segments in the wire, will become infinitesimally
small and can be replaced with . At this point, you can replace the sum with an integral and
drop the subscript i from the variable , which will then become the integration variable .
Note that the remaining quantities , , and are constants: They are known quantities given
in the problem statement.
Hint
Find the limits of integration
C.5
When you change the sum over charge segments into an integral, the variable of integration will be
the coordinate . What should the limits of integration be?
ANSWER:
0 to
0 to
to
to
0 to
Hint
How to simplify the integral
C.6
You can simplify the integral by changing the variable of integration from to
Express your answer in terms of some or all of the variables , , and , and the constants
and .
ANSWER:
Assess
Part D
Imagine that distance is much greater than the length of the wire. Intuitively, what should the
magnitude of the electric field at point P be in this case?
Hint
Envisioning the limiting case
D.1
In the limiting case , the length of the wire is not relevant and the wire appears to be a
point charge in the distance. What is the magnitude of the electric field due to a point charge?
Express your answer in terms of some or all of the variables and , and the constants and .
A short wire far away from point P creates a field very similar to the one created by a point charge.
ANSWER:
A short wire far away from point P creates a field very similar to the one created by a point charge.
Not surprisingly, in the limiting case , the mathematical expression you derived for
reduces to that of the electric field due to a point charge.
To see this, note that one way of writing the answer you obtained in the Solve step is:
reduces to , as we expected.
Recall that the field around an infinite charged sheet is always perpendicular to the sheet and that
the field strength does not change, regardless of distance from the sheet.
ANSWER:
A
B
C
D
Part B
Part C
This applet shows two charges. You can alter the charge on each independently or alter the distance
between them. You should try to get a feeling for how altering the charges or the distance affects the
field lines.
Part D
In even relatively
simple setups as in the figure, electric field lines are quite helpful for understanding the field
qualitatively (understanding the general direction in which a certain charge will move from a specific
position, identifying locations where the field is roughly zero or where the field points a specific
direction, etc.). A good figure with electric field lines can help you to organize your thoughts as well
as check your calculations to see whether they make sense.
Part E
electric field lines are shown for a system of two point charges, and . Which of the
,
Very far from the two charges, the system looks like a single charge with value
. At large enough distances, the field lines will be indistinguishable from the
Charged Ring
Description: Find the electric field from a uniformly charged ring (qualitative and quantitative parts) at
points along its axis. Then use this to find the frequency of small oscillations of a oppositely charged
object placed on the axis.
Consider a uniformly charged ring in the xy plane, centered at the origin. The ring has radius and
positive charge distributed evenly along its circumference.
Part A
What is the direction of the electric field at any point on the z axis?
Hint A.1 How to approach the problem
Approach 1
In what direction is the field due to a point on the ring? Add to this the field from a point on the
opposite side of the ring. In what direction is the net field? What if you did this for every pair of
points on opposite sides of the ring?
Approach 2
Consider a general electric field at a point on the z axis, i.e., one that has a z component as well as a
component in the xy plane. Now imagine that you make a copy of the ring and rotate this copy
about its axis. As a result of the rotation, the component of the electric field in the xy plane will
rotate also. Now you ask a friend to look at both rings. Your friend wouldn't be able to tell them
apart, because the ring that is rotated looks just like the one that isn't. However, they have the
component of the electric field in the xy plane pointing in different directions! This apparent
contradiction can be resolved if this component of the field has a particular value. What is this
value?
Does a similar argument hold for the z component of the field?
Part B
What is the magnitude of the electric field along the positive z axis?
Hint
Formula for the electric field
B.1
You can always use Coulomb's law, , to find the electric field (the Coulomb force per unit
charge) due to a point charge. Given the force, the electric field say at due to is
In the situation below, you should use Coulomb's law to find the contribution to the electric
field at the point from a piece of charge on the ring at a distance away. Then, you can
integrate over the ring to find the value of . Consider an infinitesimal piece of the ring with
charge . Use Coulomb's law to write the magnitude of the infinitesimal at a point on the
Use in your answer, where . You may also use some or all of the variables ,
, and .
ANSWER:
=
Use in your answer, where . You may also use some or all of the variables ,
, and .
ANSWER:
Hint
Simplifying with symmetry
B.2
By symmetry, the net field must point along the z axis, away from the ring, because the horizontal
component of a similar contribution of magnitude from the other side of the ring. Therefore,
all we care about is the z component of each such contribution. What is the component of the
electric field caused by the charge on an infinitesimally small portion of the ring in the z
direction?
Express your answer in terms of , the infinitesimally small contribution to the electric field;
, the coordinate of the point on the z axis; and , the radius of the ring.
ANSWER:
=
ANSWER:
Hint
Integrating around the ring
B.3
If you combine your results from the first two hints, you will have an expression for , the
vertical component of the field due to the infinitesimal charge . The total field is
If you are not comfortable integrating over the ring, change to a spatial variable. Since the total
charge is distributed evenly about the ring, convince yourself that
Notice that this expression is valid for both positive and negative charges as well as for points located
on the positive and negative z axis. If the charge is positive, the electric field should point outward.
For points on the positive z axis, the field points in the positive z direction, which is outward from the
origin. For points on the negative z axis, the field points in the negative z direction, which is also
outward from the origin. If the charge is negative, the electric field should point toward the origin.
For points on the positive z axis, the negative sign from the charge causes the electric field to point in
the negative z direction, which points toward the origin. For points on the negative z axis, the negative
sign from the z coordinate and the negative sign from the charge cancel, and the field points in the
positive z direction, which also points toward the origin. Therefore, even though we obtained the
above result for postive and , the algebraic expression is valid for any signs of the parameters.
approximately , independent of the size of the ring: The field due to the ring is almost the same
as that due to a point charge at the origin.
Part C
Imagine a small metal ball of mass and negative charge . The ball is released from rest at
the point and constrained to move along the z axis, with no damping. If ,
what will be the ball's subsequent trajectory?
ANSWER: repelled from the origin
Part D
The ball will oscillate along the z axis between and in simple harmonic motion.
What will be the angular frequency of these oscillations? Use the approximation to
Recall the nature of simple harmonic motion of an object attached to a spring. Newton's second law
for the system states that
Hint
Find the force on the charge
D.2
What is , the z component of the force on the ball on the ball at the point ? Use the
approximation .
Hint
A formula for the force on a charge in an electric field
D.2.1
.
Therfore, in particular,
You have already found in Part B. Use that expression in the equation above to find an
expression for the z component of the force on the ball at the point . Don't forget
to use the approximation given.
Compare this to the generic force equation for an oscillator to find the oscillation frequency.
Express your answer in terms of given charges, dimensions, and constants.
ANSWER:
Hint
Relationship between electric field and electric force
A.1
The relationship between the electric force that acts on a particle and the electric field at the
location of the particle is
.
This formula indicates that the force and the electric field point in the same direction for a
positively charged particle, and in opposite directions for a negatively charged particle.
Hint
Determining the direction of the electric field
A.2
location of the particle is
.
This formula indicates that the force and the electric field point in the same direction for a
positively charged particle, and in opposite directions for a negatively charged particle.
Hint
Determining the direction of the electric field
A.2
The acceleration of the particle can be determined from the change in its velocity. By Newtons
2nd law, the force acting on the particle is parallel to its acceleration. Finally, since this is a
positively charged particle, the electric field is parallel to the force. Putting this all together results
in an electric field that is parallel to the particles acceleration.
Draw a vector representing the direction of the electric field. The orientation of the vector will be
graded. The location and length of the vector will not be graded.
ANSWER:
View
The motion diagram shows that the particle's acceleration points to the right. Because the particle has
positive charge, the electric field should point to the right.
Part B
Hint
Relationship between electric field and electric force
B.1
The relationship between the electric force that acts on a particle and the electric field at the
location of the particle is
.
This formula indicates that the force and the electric field point in the same direction for a
positively charged particle, and in opposite directions for a negatively charged particle.
Hint
Determining the direction of the electric field
B.2
The acceleration of the particle can be determined from the change in its velocity. By Newtons
2nd law, the force acting on the particle is parallel to its acceleration. Finally, since this is a
negatively charged particle, the electric field is directed opposite to the force. Putting this all
together results in an electric field that is directed opposite to the particles acceleration.
Draw a vector representing the direction of the electric field. The orientation of the vector will be
graded. The location and length of the vector will not be graded.
ANSWER:
View
The motion diagram shows that the particle's acceleration points to the right. Because the particle has
negative charge, the electric field should point to the left.
ANSWER:
View
The motion diagram shows that the particle's acceleration points to the right. Because the particle has
negative charge, the electric field should point to the left.
Part C
Hint
Relationship between electric field and electric force
C.1
The relationship between the electric force that acts on a particle and the electric field at the
location of the particle is
.
This formula indicates that the force and the electric field point in the same direction for a
positively charged particle, and in opposite directions for a negatively charged particle.
Hint
Determining the direction of the electric field
C.2
The acceleration of the particle can be determined from the change in its velocity. By Newtons
2nd law, the force acting on the particle is parallel to its acceleration. Finally, since this is a
positively charged particle, the electric field is parallel to the force. Putting this all together results
in an electric field that is parallel to the particles acceleration.
Because the electric field is uniform, you can find the direction of the particle's acceleration by
subtracting any two consecutive velocity vectors graphically. If and are any two consecutive
represent and . Pick any two vectors and that would make your
subtraction easier; you can verify your result by subtracting any other pair of consecutive vectors.
Draw a vector representing the direction of the electric field. The orientation of the vector will be
graded. The location and length of the vector will not be graded.
ANSWER:
View
Part D
Hint
Relationship between electric field and electric force
D.1
The relationship between the electric force that acts on a particle and the electric field at the
location of the particle is
.
This formula indicates that the force and the electric field point in the same direction for a
positively charged particle, and in opposite directions for a negatively charged particle.
Hint
Determining the direction of the electric field
D.2
The acceleration of the particle can be determined from the change in the illustrated velocity
vectors. By Newtons 2nd law, the force acting on the particle is parallel to its acceleration. Finally,
since this is a negatively charged particle, the electric field is directed opposite to the electric force.
Putting this all together results in an electric field that is directed opposite to the particles
acceleration.
Because the electric field is uniform, you can find the direction of the particle's acceleration by
subtracting any two consecutive velocity vectors graphically. If and are any two consecutive
velocities, you can subtract from by placing at the tip of . is the vector
represent and . Pick any two vectors and that would make your
subtraction easier; you can verify your result by subtracting any other pair of consecutive vectors.
Draw a vector representing the direction of the electric field. The orientation of the vector will be
graded. The location and length of the vector will not be graded.
ANSWER:
View
Consider two thin disks, of negligible thickness, of radius oriented perpendicular to the x axis such
that the x axis runs through the center of each disk.
The disk centered at
has positive charge density , and the disk centered at has negative charge density
What is the magnitude of the electric field at the point on the x axis with x coordinate ?
Hint
How to approach the problem
A.1
When calculating the electric field from more than one charge or a continuous charge distribution,
one makes use of the superposition principle, which states that the electric field from multiple
charges equals the vector sum of the fields from each individual charge. To find the electric field at
a point, add the field due to each disk at that point. Be careful of whether the field magnitudes
should add or subtract. The easiest way to be sure is to draw a figure with the two disks and arrows
for the electric field direction on each side of each disk. If the arrows for the two disks point the
same way, then the magnitudes add. If they point in opposite directions, the magnitudes subtract.
The magnitude of the electric field along the x axis for a charged disk centered at
is
where is the radius of the disk, is the charge density on the disk, is the permittivity of free
space, and is the x coordinate. Be careful in determining the direction in which the electric field
due to each disk points.
Hint Determine the general form of the electric field between the disks
A.3
space, and is the x coordinate. Be careful in determining the direction in which the electric field
due to each disk points.
Hint Determine the general form of the electric field between the disks
A.3
Which of the following equations represents the magnitude of the electric field between the two
disks?
Hint A.3.1 Determine whether the magnitudes should add or subtract
Which of the following statements properly describes the directions of the electric fields due to
each disk in the region between the two disks?
ANSWER: The electric fields due to both disks point to the left.
The electric field due to the positive disk points to the left, while the
electric field due to the negative disk points to the right.
The electric field due to the positive disk points to the right, while the
electric field due to the negative disk points to the left.
Since the two fields point in the same direction, their magnitudes add.
ANSWER:
Express your answer in terms of , , , and the permittivity of free space .
ANSWER:
Notice that as approaches , this expression approaches , the result for two infinite
sheets. Also, note that the minimum value of the electric field, which corresponds in this case to the
greatest deviation from the result for two infinite sheets, occurs halfway between the disks (i.e., at
).
Part B
For what value of the ratio of plate radius to separation between the plates does the electric
field at the point on the x axis differ by 1 percent from the result for infinite
sheets?
Hint
Percent difference
B.1
Recall that the percent difference between two numbers, in this case the electric field from Part
.
Express your answer to two significant figures.
ANSWER:
As mentioned above, this is the point on the x axis where the deviation from the result for two infinite
sheets is greatest. A common component of electrical circuits called a capacitor is usually made from
two thin charged sheets that are separated by a small distance. In such a capacitor, the ratio is
far greater than 50. Based on your result, you can see that the infinite sheet approximation is quite
good for a capacitor.
This applet shows the electric field lines from a pair of finite plates (viewed edge-on). You can adjust
the surface charge density. You can also move the test charge around and increase or decrease its
charge to see what sort of force it would experience. Notice that the deviation from uniform electric
field only becomes noticeable near the edges of the capacitor plates.
The ink drops have a mass = 1.001011 each and leave the nozzle and travel horizontally
toward the paper at velocity = 25.0 . The drops pass through a charging unit that gives each
drop a positive charge by causing it to lose some electrons. The drops then pass between parallel
deflecting plates of length = 1.50 , where there is a uniform vertical electric field with
magnitude = 7.60104 .
Part A
If a drop is to be deflected a distance = 0.250 by the time it reaches the end of the
deflection plate, what magnitude of charge must be given to the drop? Assume that the density of
First, find the amount of time spent by the drop between the plates and use the result to find the
acceleration needed for the drop to have a vertical deflection of 0.250 . Next, using Newton's
2nd law, find the force needed for this vertical deflection. Finally, calculate the charge by setting
the electric force equal to this required force.
Hint
Calculate the time spent between the plates
A.2
How much time does it take for the ink drop to travel horizontally from the start to the end of the
deflection plates?
Hint
Relating horizontal distance and velocity
Hint
Calculate the time spent between the plates
A.2
How much time does it take for the ink drop to travel horizontally from the start to the end of the
deflection plates?
Hint
Relating horizontal distance and velocity
A.2.1
The ink drop has no acceleration in the horizontal direction. Therefore, the distance traveled by
the drop is equal to the product of the horizontal velocity and the time traveled. Use this relation
to calculate the time the ink drop spends between the plates.
Express your answer in seconds.
ANSWER:
Hint
Calculate the vertical acceleration
A.3
Calculate the acceleration needed for the ink drop to be deflected vertically by 0.250
during its trip between the deflection plates.
Hint
How to calculate the vertical acceleration
A.3.1
Since the ink drop initially has zero velocity in the vertical direction, the vertical deflection
Hint
Calculate the force that must be acting on the drop using Newton's law
A.4
Calculate the force needed to deflect the ink drop vertically by a distance of 0.250 .
Hint
How to approach the problem
A.4.1
Recall Newton's 2nd law: . Once you know the droplet's mass and its vertical
acceleration, you can compute the force needed to deflect the ink droplet vertically.
Express your answer in newtons.
ANSWER:
=
Recall Newton's 2nd law: . Once you know the droplet's mass and its vertical
acceleration, you can compute the force needed to deflect the ink droplet vertically.
Express your answer in newtons.
ANSWER:
Now find the charge the ink droplet must have so that it will experience an electric force of this
Hint
Relating the electric force and the electric field
A.5
By definition, the magnitude of the electric field is the absolute value of the ratio of the magnitude
of the force acting on a charged particle in the field to the magnitude of the charge of the particle:
.
Express your answer numerically in coulombs.
ANSWER:
Here is something to think about: Is it reasonable to ignore the effect of gravity on the droplet in our
calculations? For an average inkjet printer, the magnitude of the acceleration due to the electric field
will be over ten times larger than the magnitude of the acceleration due to gravity. However, gravity
will still cause a small deflection of the droplet and hence should not be ignored if the accuracy of the
placement of the ink droplet is particularly important.