iFfp

/1/C / / r
File No l e/
Urr3
Volume No. _

ITT-T d
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
Pur9
cmeileio
PRIME MINISTER'S OFFICE
....... __SECTION/DIVISION
Pu4Pr417/ 7-11-417
NOTES/CORRESPONDENCE

TO-f a 4
indexed on SUBJ ECT

atTaTeR ......................................
441-4y> I f. 441

Initials 04-4- -&0414)4;94

6
304731
Record A/B
&I,Gt-fry t f
aft -A-
- TgTr ...................... . A 'rTz
Record C Destroy in
T
3 iij z i1c54, 4 -Ile tl - zu

*U 9 WEIT jflif

To be noted CO
in Sectional Note Book
Not to be noted

ar5 3./3itfterv
Initials of S.0./Supdt.

P4D., 3trolecv
I n i t i a l s o f C l er k

Rru-A itT4 Ara*

P r e vio u s References Later References
 IRTfff TITIFTT
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
surrq. ; t3i1 irriztRzt
PRIME MINISTER'S OFFICE
4 fl tf 0- 11 0 01 1
NEW DELHI -110011

(.; C
Forwarded to

aNff Trim-re fR7

for oppropriate action ........
q r r Hi t i
The Communications has not been
acknowledged. (141931 ; trirt tR)
(B. K. DHALI
7;7
Ur rL .deret .ry
. I -1
Prime t.,Sler'S Office

Atfiff 414-1 'Fria-4 4 'fro yr; fis

fC41-f
Prime Minister's Office U.O.
lcieil9cipefJ
Dated.. ...................
7 2-'

V ' -4
 -7 7 5 714T
4 W -d i c
,
f2-10-10.
Lt-Ec-k - t & ; c - t *
) 482 002
re e 0761 32 45 56 324557 28252 -TrtsOzT cfnL.1.4 ( a j l .
fr. 32 45 05 c-c,ztel,C.LA Uft.At

krtich : 20 / 1 / 2 0 0 0
9t,
Trrffk
- tr
im i t-Rc b l t ,

swazr qr-4441
'TTqT 9"1111 ,

T -T r f mir5 t 4 4 7 1 7 -4 ITGCE *r h .q4I,-Fi14

N EP T st4 a i r t l t r i 1 9 3 9 # T1s'1 1 c-q1411-) tdrt 41<if c1 atiT atTT Urft..crq.7)

air-Arq 17 TT 7r3-ff ft-zrr 3TTEr 311-(. 5[21-9-r ct)< t N-Elt AGIcly 4

ER Rtt itz rrF:rd Glril T f tJ- rA- t 1711-q

31-# P si RT J 0 1 4 1-6rur T,t

3 17 \ k . cht 611q

N -4 t

Tt jaf-O t 4 -4--4r-c 9-e.t 1.4,71 Q-114 31N75-t-PT

T1- k i T e f f t-741 9T c j I 3iTti k riich 23 1 I 'e r a 1.)< ft 3117 \1111-11c1

31t 1 1 ciA4Ej 7iTt 3m# -ar-ITT w-a bR c-4 61. 3rr4

711t VOt 31F-41 T, 4 0 c-1-4 "W q t I

TIURT-q N ,

4
Aova-A Ywv'9'vs-) t qf rf f )
kc wi i T rI N .fl W

NAT IO NAL SECRET ARY E3J P MEMBER ; ST A T E EXEC UT IVL

(MINORIT Y CELL)
441\i>sCI)VAI )
 1; 0 4 1 4

(4145,m 44-19-a afpfi)

(m ftra- 19 4 5 )
82, qPqr TNT , q (411.'q ZiTrf 9 t ti51 : 32 7 35 3 2

$7.! z1K-4 No. -16

11614-41 12 Jan: 2000

To
Dr. S.K.Nelson,
Silver Oak Hospital,
Jubbalpur (MP), -PIN-482 002.

Dear Ece.Nelson

Jai Hind. Very many thanks for yours of

31st Dec: 99. Since 1958, the All India INA Committee
has been requesting the succeding Governments to bring
the Ashes of Netaji Subha.s Chandra Bose, who liberated
our Country from British Domination but from Suit. Indira
Gandhi,Rajiv Gandhi,V.P.Singh, I.K.Gujral all have been
putting off the burning issue of Netaji's Ashes with the
pretext there is controversy regarding Air (*rash on 18-8-1945.
A few persons, who claim that Netaji did not die in Air crash
have been keeping the Nation at ransom and deny MARTYRDOM
to Netaji. It is National shame that Netaji who gave his
all for the freedom of country, his ashes are lying in
Renkthji Temple,Tokyo since 18-8-1945. My Japanese friends
have been writing to me to get the Ashes from Japan to
India.

You are National Secretary (Minority re13)

of B.J.P. Will you kindly make an appeal to Honlble
Prime Minister to arrange to bring the Ashes from X. Japan
Prime Minister has agreed to grace the occasion of
Netaji birthday celebration in New Delhi on 23rd Jan: 2000
and we have decided to make an appeal to the Prime Minister
on 23-1-2000. Will you kindly support us. Thanking you.
With warmest regards.

Yours sincerely,

(S.S.Yadavarapt:INA
Gen: Secretary
 1117-41-4
7,[ta gTVW
eJvW FC.7.71.
317craTa-
ui BT.A. ) 482 002 ot.7,4. it ftE
12 0761 324556 324557 28252
fr. 324505 - t,t?

D A T E : 2 0 /1/ 20 0 0
General Secretary
All India INA Committee
82, DARYAGANJ MARG,
NEW DELHI

Dear Shri S.S.Yadav,

Ref:- Bringing Ashes of N etaji to Jabalpur INDIA.

I am sending my request to Japan Embe ssy t o b u i l d

a Temple and bring Ashes of Netaji to Tr i p u r i Jabalpur

from where he left Indian National Co n g re s s to start

I.N.A. and freedom struggle for INDIA.

I am sending my request to INDIAN GOVT. Also for

not interfering in bringing the desputed ashes to INDIA

as we are re qu es t in g t hi s to ho no u r ou r g re at le ad e r an d

atleast now after 55years give him proper respect and

reverance which he deserved from the people of INDIA.

My Fax to Prime Minister is enc los ed he r ew i th ,

however I will le ave no s tone unt urned to bring t he Ashes

to INDIA.

With love & regards,

You rs si nce rel y,

(D R .S U DH I R K UM A R N EL S ON )
MEM BE R NA TIO NA L EX ECU TI VE B JP
VI CE P RE SI D EN T BJ P MI N OR IT Y MO RC H

7\ 1.>)\k
1N)% -
Dr. NELSON SK NATIONAL SECRETARY BJP MEMBER: SW-rEXECUT IVE BJP
MA, MBBS, MS, MSc, PhD,
(MINORITY CELL
 artguT ITTTR TWT
1(7 few ! wzr pm 1
`kulm'
'
Iiffl It(1 eirwiv ftriw ?)wly
4117351 : 2.27ZT/ 411111T
1.417 -
witir
.1 * Ai 4

.-S/Pr WIT 7 5 r e j r -A . e r W l . AT4 t r C. arrei 4231 4 t;

)avir 'R--tvt.ct.
- 2 FEB ?CM
zrici e n t r cl r-> arTA- afr4,1 al ITC y f
ATV' -ftrOlikrehlft, a-1 etit4 1 alva I I
-Riwitrr , EGIS-kE ED
- firrza- -t r *fk 41:.
-- ? * - cft
<TATI qt &i5u ,ti srfileg-
- ext41" cIzar Aro TA-114153 al 211" -SreGreereTZIT
41 4 -12rF earPFFT ct 1/191Czrr 1r ,1 lei er GT &WA- 14-r -41-
--T r i t 7 .
vi tP4- A-ri1011 c-TrETF-r - r - orfea- 4 .41 1 4-e- f r n a r r e T
+ ff-Nr" c7 & 'rt et M anteerg iZATft: 41i,r11 .14-4 1.7Ttf Crag'
$C1* .
Ar4 Z.11.1T41141 zr,,a4 IFFT4TesFRIc41-"tai 91 ItztF i d 0
-3.Wr " fig 44 A-F r-4 1- arf*Tt'r der anzr - -cfseAT
4 eliaT krr3T4 -
`T rarg. -TTITZET ch-f4F r arrtr zgaTs-r gmle-r-A- i
2rft q e14 'AT- 1` 07-R 2<21FT- 7,E-W 1.set *TAW
-Rfrg 4-4A-q't eizrr oi-vrca-tft-c2
271
G . T r E r Z r , w r a- 74- 1-474. d r i z - 4 7 TrE aAzreh
' 4r Gr--A

aT4
ca i i ' w 1 r zr14- drz.4 -der
-- .t If k-rOt .gcarft-reft __ _ 7,Tr-
4 -wwwir
__ _
ut-t,441-4.a.t.,?r
s vlicr
tzrms.
I.! eh
r4T,
t,
-A. 4-tte r
A1-1-r 2,plci am-r aw ;7itr ; cosi ZIGTITTT dMi "cri-g ch'01717; Tkir
War:4Z -1-4 -44t iriTZ4) c*VIWZ:Frri ) . Zn*. " g r, 90 ;60 2.11.0.4 SII.S1 ran ter ...Zgr
ct r r i k " h 4 e 6 Ostrri- i k Tirsr-,IN. saw-cTTiT -fftwrv 2F
rrizr,F E W
'7'a7" $'4153" eh-ra ff .uA4 .21 wrw cmr eFEW
- ',wrty--A' . IV Z
'11;11571"3AtaiN
, Fa- .> f t sr* a -dwr Tzsrarr it -* .Erxr.zr zracr
RT. 2TE- av-R- (114) GrrE1Trr ofreg-d- "T fr e t v g-4,1K
"-\ 1/4 c a r T r -%-xtrsr "alek-t4 zftsekrir fAw &ipvir
ma's crrer { c4IL %4471Src i A r i i J ti 1.arrc4-r i p - aTirA WA:Mr
ei 14.1 Zell I (7 M i n ) Fatr" 2. 1i i " T fti l t c=h-F t l i T a T r 4t l e ccr
Trurit 4 ,0)).( (4,0 4(3,1 , toter-, e t r i k r e c t 1T1V 1:XTIPSeticAlIRT kro
t31FKZ tr GT01-1 zrx's wiim-Tfkag -EFr tur*P-ei. .fdohaU ;1* %Ptj, eFr ftwortrie41
fleals7r zEr rA-ir ci;t:Trigrq`h-TraPr aim , e1- ormtr-vsr,47*-04
I.}4ife,fas t;b44 1a
e- 4F ).4K-i r r y-14124164 Au.
- fl;WT dtFt- ,4917
GrArtr--16pEr f rzpiTET-4T41- 3TTh1 -Err,-4(i.<sirrtsrT dFra?4,W
- r 1r6
-r
31r4 trn srr F).fr srriAtra-4;regfAar r zPT
"*0 'zits7 /5
 AVM' i(t'M RITT
sm. f e l !
`kzriT 1 wzr p m I

mr4quil1 eirtm itizv 4 4 /9 WNWZ

7fga W P M : aprici = m um
trtit*. yl.o. NI (12) frdw

u t i -trE -)4c,f) - '>erfa. tir-4 - eziRi 1 9 0 - `4 -r rb. H

-EeKrz. cr u c ii 3-4* - )14 14141 Ve ra' T rw, 1559 tt e gT O T
wtfl 1. "sinieK *Zr' T 1 a1 -1A-O r mt r va - r i4-41 %erq.cr W r n : r I ".

t10 4-
5a T e b3:1 * Z i l- milt! i I . i e f t .F u r e i TrelaT -
if 4PerTF- esoftr NretT1T.W. i f t t a r 4 4 -1,rufkix

(.74-t -A r - 144 74cirr fT ) FUT. (* Cr e a r g -gr ororn

cgt,,Trc-
ciftmR741 GrrYix` farr(zrer RIA-cqz-trz 7rur ZrfAE-rkti- xrcrir e -mer,
3 R ar efr rXT.R a - 1.
4 1 r-r
11: air M T N. Y e c al4) i r g r r ta(4,4 ITar
24T1r (FRTrc %-t w r x z l m -KrEw -F r lb z 4-zegar 4. 0.)r(eretw r
/cr. I.Trcr (W2.4 Ati 4. 2-1 1 - : 3)-
1:-c -

I.
urtiikt e i " W ch9-41-cuT drra-ktrr e n.44- ?ffrrtg)- Anode
ccreretf7 cgr aF A- trz. T R" 4F -11.K G . 4Z% 6T r nekzrcF"cre s/ rrr
x e- 46r e a t . sTrcr- r (-krr ic) , ) - r nc4 T -m-I=4-tar 4- - e w 'Iry
-
tA csrr---arrc 614nd awa
, mc-w-TE-T 7A. -rr--T & zwz- 0,
* r * c?T rrrfk-i eTzi-e8g oft.Pr N-4-Trr C'(-4n.ex-xt
set Nrivy smc-AT TE-zittrrirr 1
-et * *I -Ter -/-TF ")19- 3
. -4 1-zar. 71.=,- n.hircer -m14-47.1r
VAT " Su DATITUTS Powee. T o Nuet eRR wEMPOKS brZJ Mar^.

13-4 ,.1-4r <*iffIt.cs,itc$1114 As) a-6 7r1R7r e a z-f t- :g rtk -517Ere r

" f 217
iSercxr- 4 - ei t o zIntew wcro- trz
- 0#4TR-ranir3rogrepo1i-41-4(ire-457' R.114, I "1,,te0 P -4 -4 viut
sEr -g y ci}1 star t zrrer &trr T ri sfr'IT P4'410. .1-3
tiz1 W 41,17 471 .2 014)(21d ;15TrerK trz -E 4 * -64xerA' -ar-
1( LicJqJt. exg- e;.1. l' 7
4 Tr k 1 6
z T " rer r ),
A-a f t wet ccr ( ft aTtrA- 6iic4f Zraname chi
& T T L- 2a-ct t t:(11 `R -r- zr5 z;rxrr ko'\ -1430 er eg i r a Wr r. 1.7 #
2fr %ft 711A4-47-1- -4c -4F tF-r , s;rtra-A- tr"0. 3Tr aFff
_ M t -er .:01-F r a r A i f t k -t r w m-
ir )43r 7.x- t . xarz .d;* rale' vgr eho4
- 4,1*
Trf-A --;Thyc GrEiltic)
sr t
brgirr wtr-/n r # w i rtT *T t
-1 0 0 0 w a i t _ m a $1.419-4--i<ii TR, 444 .3 0
- 44011 P04.-1,1-sS6
 Virff f fRIFIT
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
Ea ff *it Icitif-mt
PRIME MINISTER'S OFFICE
fC W-1 1 0 0 1 1
NEW DELHI -110011

Forwarded to. <

afaa. wrice fwq siftrff

for oppropriate action .......................
tvx srrfiRI lafft RO if-41 itt
The Communications has not been
acknowledged.

sra-rq IFTeRzt crir t .

fr4r-f ...........
Prime Minister's Office U.O. No... C )I " c-t(
Dated......... . . . . . .
t
Li
 NETAJI PROBE & RESEARCH FOUNDATION
28, Gurudwara Rakab Ganj Road
New Delhi - 110 001
Phone: 3352273, Telefax : 3714131

Dated 27thJanuary 2000

To
Shri. Atal Behari Vajpayee,
Hon'ble Prime Minister of India,
New Delhi.

Sub: Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose

Dear Prime Minister,

Jai Hind.

We are deeply shocked, appalled and disgusted to read in the press that your
goodself has expressed the willingness of your government to bring to India the so
called ashes of Netaji claimed to be lying at Renkoji temple. After the appointment
of a Commission of Enquiry by your government, and after our meetings with your
goodself on 24th March 1999 and 12th Jan.2000, it is extremely difficult to believe
that you could have made such a statement which has appeared in almost all the
papers all over the country. In the absence of any contradiction by PM0 or your
government, we have no option but to believe that you made this statement which is
most irresponsible and damaging, and amounts to contempt of the Enquiry
Commission. We condemn this statement in the strongest possible words and
demand the withdrawal of this statement. The nation has been confused about the
real motives of the government.

May we remind you that your government has appointed a Commission of Enquiry
under the Chairmanship of Mr. Justice M.K.Mukherjee, a retired judge of the
Supreme Court of India. One of the terms of reference of the Enquiry Commission is
"Whether the ashes in the Japanese temple are the ashes of Netaji". So long as the
Enquiry Commission has not submitted its report on the matter, to talk of bringing to
India the ashes of Netaji, that too by a person like your goodself, amounts to
scuttling the independent functioning of the Enquiry Commission. During your
meeting with us you had promised to extend complete cooperation, in the free and
fair functioning of the Enquiry Commission; but your actions speak quite opposite to
our words. Moreover if this is the beginning , where shall the whole thing end.

11k
 2-

The issue of Netaji's disappearance is a national issue and we should rise above all
political and partisan considerations, in settling this issue for ever.

The success of the Enquiry Commission depends on the cooperation it gets from
the govt. We look to you for light and guidance, and not confusion and chaos. We
appeal your goodself to clarify the position of your government on this issue.
Kindly recall our meeting on 12th Jan.2000, where I raised the issue of shifting the
office of the Commission from Calcutta to New Delhi, your goodself also agreed in
principle to look into the matter. I am taking this opportunity to request you to take
immediate steps to shift the office of the Commission from Calcutta to New Delhi. So
that, the activities of the Commission would be more smooth and useful.

Thanking you,

In anticipation,

Sincerely yours,

DEBABRATA BISWAS,
Member of Parliament (Rajya Sabha),
General Secretary, Netaji Probe & Research Foundation.
 vtrf ;RITT
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA

surrq ;t3ft
IFTZINzT
PRIME MINISTER'S OFFICE
4 ftf;ft-110011
NEW DELHI -110011

Forwarded to ......

7f4ff FriraTe * fff7 siffrff

for oppropriate action .............................
RX *-41 t
The Communications has not been
acknowledged.

* T O R-4 i o RN Re
ftr4t-f ...........
Prime Minister's Office U.O. No l t . q . ! . . . .. .
Dated..................... ...
rIcr-totx-e
f

-4-i/u1A-1,7
 ' JAN. 2E: 2 0 0 0 0 3 : 2 0 P M Pl .

NETA,i1 PROBE & RESEARCH FOUNDATION

2s, G u r u d w a m
Raitab Gilnj Fcloati
New "Deih, 1,1Cr fAl"i
Phone t -335227.7 Tett,f4g -- :37 4- 31

Jaituaiv 2000
Shn i4eltran Vaipayee,
P r i m e Ministe,' of ;hdia

74n,tif.ia
!,15:

, - ;1?).r ,!.-,a;

rias
...ashes of Ni-itta;', ::/airrier.:1 .9 i:.renkuti
r,crnrriissiort of F.:...-tquiry
goodseif on 24'71., 8 -
you couci have made such a
over the ..:,;.irt.t.ry Itti the absencE.
we have no ootion but to

*4:, irresponsible arid dart-iaatg

condemn this statement ;.1 the strongest Coss:i,k-i
of this statement The nation hos ,
qol,ernment

May we rerriinq you lir iTieht has actyointe(r

the Chairmanship of Mr .A..istice K kfiukher ,
Court of indra. One of the terms of reference ,
ashes in the Japanese temple are the ashes cf :
Commission has not submitted its report on the rhot r i ,
ashes of Netaji, that too by a person ke7,1/ o w -q(Y..-).c:;sF
independent functioning. of the Enq y C .
had promised to extariii
Enquiry Commission; but your irictiors soeaks
Moreover if this is the beginnii . where shai: -

.A00 The issue of Netaji's iDisappea 'am:a ;s nationai

political and partisan consIrreraiorts, settiine

The success of the Enquiry Corimission deoet. .

govt We look to you for right and guidahui.
a o o ea l your goodseif to clarify tie positich of ") +' 4
 NETAJI PROSE & RESEARCH FOUNDATION
28, Gurudwara Rakab Gani Road
New Delhi 110
Phone 3352273 Teiefex 3714131 '

Kindly recall our meeting on 121' Jan.2000, where we raised the issue of shifting the
office of the Commission from Calcutta to New DeIli, yov coodseit also agreed in
principle to look into he matter. We are takim3 oop,rtunity to request you to
take immediate steps shift the oftice oC the C rrir.-F.s:for, frorn cai0utta 10 New
Delhi. So that, the v.f,t0i.ies of he Com srs.i07, rror,!! srricoth and tisefW

ki B RATA HI

Net;.,tj, ;'rcbe
 TARPROBE&RESEARCH FOUNDATION
_
Delhi trice:
28 , G u r u d w a r a R ak a b G a n j R o a d Phone 237-3956
5 2 /7 , B.B.G ANGULY ST REET New Delhi 11 0 0 0 1
Fax. 237-2065
CAL CUT T A - 1 2

57:2/2.0 ,)
Ref:

To,
Sri Atal Behari Vajpayee,
Prime Minister of India,
New Delhi.

Sub: Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose.

Hon'ble Prime Minister,

Jai in

I gratefully acknowledge your letter dated 2nd February,

2000. We are highly relieved and feel extremely grateful to learn
that your Govt. has no proposal to bring to India the so-called
/ ashes of Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose allegedly lying at Tokyo. We
/ ) /feel satisfied by your response and hope that in the future also
r
the Government shall maintain the same approach. We are sure that
under your stewardship the Govt. of In d i a will no t ta k e any
decision which ma y go against the findings of the Justice
Mukherjee Commission of Inquiry, or which is not in concurrence
with the findings of the above said Commission of Inquiry.

We are pleased to learn that the Govt. has no intention

to politicise the matter, or use this matter for pa rt is an
consideration. Once again we express our heart -felt gratitude to
your goodself for giving the assurance that your Govt. will extend
full cooperation in this matter and do everything possible for the
smooth and effective functioning of the Commission. We shall feel
highly obliged if your Government takes a positive decision about
the shifting of the office of the Commission of Inq ui ry fr o m
ralrutta to Delhi.
May I again express gratitude on be ha lf of al l the
followers of Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose and the Members of Netaji
Probe & Research Foundation for the positive and su pp o rt in g
attitude which your Govt. has maintained towards our requests and
appeals, and hope that in future also your goodself shall maintain
the same approach.

Thanking you, Yours care

(DEBABHATA BISWAS
General Secretary
 rfrfff RTC"(
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA

SiEn q Ti3TI IETTINtr

PRIME MINISTER'S OFFICE
rt fkfci/-110011
NEW DELHI -110011

Forwarded to ......

afwr Trime fffq iftrff

for oppropriate action .......................
crit 10 seta' qaffr *-41 qt
The Communications has not been
acknowledged.

snrrq *it TtT Totr4

fraw ........... // e e? P.Y
V / N 4
Prime Minister's Office U.O. No.....
Dated
2
 J a i Hind

2;n
.c nzo4)z-ab nmaptea
mos (e)
111 GANDHIAN UNITY DEVELOPMENT &
PEACE ORGANISAT ION OF INDIA (R)
NO. 41, 4TH BLOCK, 6TH MAIN. RAJAJINAGAR. BANGALORE - 560 010. INDIA
Phone : 3303383 / 3303122

Founder President: at e: 30. 01.2000

Sri Rajayogindra Veerayya To,
Swamy Shastrimath Guruji,
(Ex Youth and Congress worker S r i. A t a l Be h a r i V a j p a ye e ,
1954-71) "Lokaleeva Hitachintaka", Hon ' bl e P r i m e M i ni s t er of I n d i a ,
Social worker since freedom New D e lh i.
movement - Kamataka Unification
Sub: B r i ngi ng of N e t a j i ' s a s h e s to In di a i s Un w ar r an t e d .
VicePresident:
Sri R.J. Desai D e a r S h r i P r ime M i n i s t e r ,
Sri B.G. Thimmapaiah
Sri B.S. Shivappa Setty We a r e de e p l y sho c ke d a n d r e g r e t e d t o r e a d i n t he p r e s s
Sri. A.P. Mulla that yo u r g o o d s e l f ha s e x p r e s s e d t he wi l l i ng n e s s of yo ur
Sri. G.R. Shivashankar G ove r n m e n t t o br i n g t o I n d i a t h e s o ca l l e d a s h e s of N e t a j i
S r i . K . M . S w a m y H i r e ma t h cl a i me d t o b e l yi ng a t Re n k o j i t e mp l e ( J a p a n ) .
S up r e me General Secretary:
Cour t Sri. K. Sajjan T h a t t h e f a c t , a b o u t t h e d e a t h of N e t a j i i n a p l a n e
Advocate a c c i de nt i s n ot a t al l p r o v e d s o fa r. So t h e q u e s t i o n of
Organising Secretary: br i n g i n g t h e a s h e s of N e t a j i i s r e d ic u lo u s a n d u n wa r r a nt ed .
Sri. D. Marappa T h e p r e v io u s G ov e r n m e n t ha d a p p o i n t e d a C om m i s s i on en q u i r y
t o s u b mi t it s r e p o r t r e g a r d i n g t h e a ir a c c i d e n t i n wh i c h N e t a j i
Treasurer/ Gen. Secretary:
Sri. Chandrashekar Meti wa s t r a v e ll in g i n t ha t p l a n e, bu t i t wa s f a i l e d t o s u b mi t i t s
r e p o r t s o fa r .
Joint Secretary:
Sri. M.S.Hiremath
*11.S .J . P u r a n i k
T he pr es ent G ove r n m e n t after t he expiry of ne a r l y 5
Smt. Vijayalakshmi Bhat
decades is un a b l e to com e to the rea l fa c t of demis e of
Members: Sri .Ne t aj i . F u r t he r , r e s e a r c h e s are goi n g on to th is e f fe c t .
Sri. Guru Shastrimath
Sri. Karumbaiah So it is to ou r humb l e s ub m i s s i on to yo u r g o od s e l f tha t,
Sri. Basavaraj Nandidwaj please, ca ll for t h e e n t i r e r e c o r d s fr om the con cer n ed For ei g n
Sri. N.P. Jagadish
Prof. C.M. Chikkodi C o u n t r i es , whe r e Net aji wa s r e s i d i ng to a c hi e v e h i s u l t i m a t e
aim to secur e In de p e nd en ce to India t h r ou g h I . N . A.
ac t i v i t i e s .

We ho p e t ha t yo ur goodself wi l l do t he n e e d f u l in the
in t e r e s t of t he t h ou s a nd s of we l l w is h er s of S r i. N e t a ji.
An e a rl y re p l y i s ex p e c t e d b y yo u r go o ds e l f .
T h a n k i n g you Si r , Y ou r s t u l ,
-
-7s- 1,1 ( S r i . R . S . V . S h a s t r i m a t h G ur uji ) -.
(K N .SWAMY) We are listed in the updated edition of the World Directory of Peace
Sup r e me Cour t Research and Training Institutions, UNESCO
A d vo c a t e http://www.unesco.org/general/eng/infoservidb/dare.html
 WTI-
PRIME MINISTE
New Delhi
February 2, 2000

Dear Shri Biswas,

I have received your letter of 27thJanuary 2000. At the outset, let
me clarify that there is no immediate proposal before the Government to
bring the ashes lying at Renkoji temple to India. The reference made to
the same was in the context of a volume of correspondence received from
different quarters requesting the Government to do the same. Any action
in this regard will be initiated by the Government only if there is a broad
agreement in this regard. The findings of the Enquiry Commission, of
course, will be a fundamental consideration in any such decision.
There is no question of the Government politicising the issue or
being guided by partisan considerations in the matter. Government will
await the report of the Enquiry Commission and extend cooperation in
every manner to ensure that the Commission is able to function smoothly
and effectively.

So far as the shifting the office of the Commission from Calcutta to

Delhi is concerned, this is being looked into.

With regards,

Yours sincerely,

(A.B. Vajpayee)

Shri Debabrata Biswas, MP

General Secretary
Netaji Probe & Research Foundation
28, Gurudwara RaJcab Ganj Road
New Delhi -110 001

No.915/11/C/9/99-Pol.Vol.11 Fe b r ua r y 1 1 , 2 0 0 0

V
Af
r Copy with a copy of the letter under reference
forwarded to Home Secretary for info rmation.

[ SN.Sahai ]
De p u ty S ec r e ta r y

Air
\Q\
 TaTtlar31*
AZ -T19 41
PRIME MINISTER
New Delhi
February 2, 2000

Dear Shri Biswas,

I have received your letter of 27th January 2000. At the outset, let
me clarify that there is no immediate proposal before the Government to
bring the ashes lying at Renkoji temple to India. The reference made to
the same was in the context of a volume of correspondence received from
different quarters requesting the Government to do the same. Any action
in this regard will be initiated by the Government only if there is a broad
agreement in this regard. The findings of the Enquiry Commission, of
course, will be a fundamental consideration in any such decision.
There is no question of the Government politicising the issue or
being guided by partisan considerations in the matter. Government will
await the report of the Enquiry Commission and extend cooperation in
every manner to ensure that the Commission is able to function smoothly
and effectively.

So far as the shifting the office of the Commission from Calcutta to

Delhi is concerned, this is being looked into.

With regards,

Yours sincerely,

(A.B. Vajpayee)

Shri Debabrata Biswas, MP

General Secretary
Netaji Probe & Research Foundation
28, Gurudwara Rakab Ganj Road
New Delhi -110 001

)(61
,k)
/
 b r_

New Delhi
January 31, 2000

Dear Shri Biswas,

I have received your letter of 27th January, 2000.

At the outset, let me clarify that there / rg no immediate proposatrbefore the

Government to bring the ashes lying at Renkoji temple to India. The reference made
01/4_ .., t.o..y.04...
to the same was in the context of -several correspondence received from
different quarters requesting the Government to do the same. Any action in this
regard will be initiated by the Government only if thew is a gengral consensus within
I
the country that the same should be done"./F- r;-fe re is no que stioni of the
Government politicising the issue or being guided by 94 tth partisan Lt.
roncitleratinnt. in the matter ( n v er n m e n t wi l l await the renn rt n f t h e F n n i i i r v .

c
Commission and extend cooperation in every manner to ensure that the Commission i.4.. $
is able to function smoothly and effectively. )
30 im-,- e.."3 )3 .4.1
As regar-d-c\ithe shifting the office of the Commission from Calcutta to Delhi, this
is El@ Tovernmen
-A3 L 4....Q. 40
With regards,

Yours sincerely,

(A.B. Vajpayee)

" 3 0111

S e A A N \ t t 41Wlek4 1 ta Biswas, MP
,tary
rivkt
& Research Foundation
To Rakab Ganj Road
kV _ x. A" 10 001
J

kie/ 1 5 1 Y' 131- _

;V
2 ! A
 DRAFT

Dear

I h a v e re c e i v e d y o u r fax o f J a n u a r y 27, 2000 regarding

shifting of the of f i c e o f t h e C o m m i s s i o n o f In qu ir y of Ne ta ji

S u b h a s C h a n d O r a B o s e fr o m Cal c utta to Delhi.

W ith re g a rd s ,

Yours sinc ere ly,

PM

Shri D e b a b r a ta B i s w a s , MP

\S" -

f
)4
077
c5'5
2 X 15 36,c,1
*2-xf) fl
) 1acf1?--
14,P(ki
" ce.0.,t
`))-'
Nn c5\/
.
 :

NETAJI PROBE & RESEARCH FOUNDATION

28, Gurudvvara Rakab Ganj Road
New Delhi- 110 001
Phone: 3352273, Telefax : 3714131

Dated 27' January 2000

To
Shri. Atal Behari Vajpayee,
H011'hle Prime Minister of India,
New Delhi.

Sub: Netaii Subhas Chandra Hose

Dear Prime Minister,

Jai Hind,

W e are deeply shocked, appalled and disgusted to read in the press that your
goodself has expressed the willingness of your government to bring to India the so
called ashes of Netaji claimed to be lying at Renkoji temple. After the appointment
of a Commission of Enquiry by your government, and after our meetings with your
goodself on 24th March 1999 and 12th Jan.2000, it is extremely difficult to believe
that you could have made such a statement which has appeared in almost all the
papers all over the country. In the absence of any contradiction by PM() or your X
government, we have no option but to believe that you made this statement which is
most irresponsible and damaging, and amounts to contempt of the Enquiry
Commission. We condemn this statement in the strongest possible words and
demand the withdrawal of this statement. The nation has been confused about the
real motives of the government.

May we remind you that your government has appointed a Commission of Enquiry
under the Chairmanship of Mr, Justice M,K.Mukherjee, a retired judge of the
Supreme Court of India. One of the terms of reference of the Enquiry Commission is
" Whether the ashes in the Japanese temple are the ashes of Netaj,". So long as the
Enquiry Commission has not submitted its report on the matter, to talk of bringing to
India the ashes of Netaji, that too by a person like your goodself, amounts to
scuttling the independent functioning of the Enquiry Commission. During your
meeting with us you had promised to extend complete cooperation in the free and
fair. functioning of the Enquiry Commission: but your actions speak quite opposite to
your words. Moreover if this is the beginning , where shall the whole thing end.
1/4/
i q tt i pr y)) v (W'S.Cte3
41 ' a f t *
Office of a. B. (7) F4411F/Dente
Dy. No. .......
Di n t s . J.L.7).446

/ 9 APP- F11/ to:WV !.5

-
7 9 0- )
 P: 02

-2-

The issue of Netaji's disappearance is a national issue and we should rise above all
political and partisan considerations, in settling this issue tor ever.

The success of the Enquiry Commission depends on the cooperation it gets from
the govt. We look to you for light and guidance, and not confusion and chaos W e
appeal your goodself to clarify the position of your government or this issue

Kindly recall our meeting on 12th Jan.2000, where I raised the issue of shifting the
office of the Commission from Calcutta to New Delhi, your goodself also agreed in
principle to look into the matter. 1 am taking this opportunity to reduest_you 10.15
3.'&q
immediate steps to shift the office of the Commission fromQalcut, I _So
that, the activities of the Commission would be more smooth and useful.

Thanking you,

In anticipation,

Sincerely yours,
ycj _t

DEBABRATA BISWAS,
Member of Parliament (Rajya Sabha),
General Secretary, Netaji Probe & Research Foundation,
 WE1T9 Tf t com1c-14
PRIME MINISTER'S OFFICE

1 c 1-110 011
New Delhi -110 011

Subject: Lok Sabha Provisional Notice Dy. No. 2554

fo r 1 .3 . 2 0 00 r e g ar d i n g N e t a ji ' s as h e s .

**********************

Reference is invited to MHA u.o. No.

I/13012/32/2000-1S(D.III) dated 23.2.2000 o n the
subject mentioned above.

2. PMO has no more information on the subject

then the MHA itself would have.

[ S . W. S a ha i I
De pu ty S e cr et ar y

MHA ( Sh ri M. S. Zu ha - D esk O ff ice r, I S ( D. II I) De s k )

PMO u.o. No. 915/11/C/9/99-Pol. da t ed : 2 5 .2 . 20 0 0

\\\
 MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS
IS(D.III) DESK
***

Subject: Lok Sabha provisional Starred Question Dy. No.2554 for

1.3.2000 regarding Netaji's ashes.

Lok Sabha's provisionally Starred Qu e s t i o n reads as

under:

a) whether attention of the Government has been drawn

to t he n ew s -i te m a bb ea re d in t he H in d us ta n Ti me s da te d
January 24, 20 00 under the c aption 'Govern ment: ready to
help bring back Netaji's ashes';

whether the Government have decided to in it ia te th e

pr oc es s of br in gi ng t h e as he s of Ne ta ji S ub h as h Ch an dr a
Bose from Japan provided there is a consensus on the
issue;

b) if so, wheter the Government have set up a Commission to

probe into Netaji death;

c) if so, the time by which the report is likely to be

received from the said Committee; and

d) the progress made by Government in this regard?

2. Parawise comments a longwith Note for S upplementaries may

please be sent to this Ministry immediately.

(M.S. Zuha)
DE S K O FF I C E R

PM0(Shri Jarnail Singh, Joint Secretary) South Block.

MHA U0 No.I/1 3
- O L7 -- /2000- IS(D. III), dated 23.2 .2000

Copy to:

Ms N ee ta B hu sh an , U nd er S ec re ta ry (J K) , S ou tn B lo ck , Ne w
Delhi

,e77-

c4;44).6f-y-ei.,4te1
3 b atiplervv.i,) 71v-tfr-
er
,rivy gc-ct,oL A rcire- ./ ge
. t-1.4
troL), .0 0 0 hit4 rto
011zfro-solLA,v C. 4itiVe.e.1--li
Atm- ii4-611,- .4i7w-a
ta)ty-
.8114,4.4,1AA. fr'
9
et/L-1-- .
re", ofilyv-va,
.e
)> I C)
't j 414
A \\1 ,U
J\
Vvt'
Vice, of 3,

Ty$ NO.......
1-11/72 ()
) 29
 mum 701 comflmo
PRIME MINISTER'S OFFICE

9-4 f -110 011

New Delhi -110 011

Subject: Ra j y a S a b ha P ro v i s io n a l N o t ic e Dy . N o. 0 02 4 9 1
fo r 2 . 3. 2 0 0 0 r e g a r d in g N e ta j i ' s a s h e s .

**********************

Reference is invited to MHA u.o. No.

I/13013/45MPA41.(Pa) d a t e d 22.2.2000 on the subject
mentioned above.

2. PM0 has no m ore information on the sub je ct

th a n t he M H A itself wo u l d h a v e .

S.N.Wahai )
De pu ty W e cr et ar y

MHA (Shri M.S. Zuha - Desk Officer IS (D.III) Desk)

PMO u.o. No. 915/11/C/9/99-Pol. da t ed : 2 5 .2 . 20 0 0

in

`-/>g,toviv
 MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS
IS(D.III) DESK
**

Sub je ct :R aj ya S ab ha p ro vi si on al Not ice Dy. No .

002491 for 2.3.2000 reg ard ing Ne t a ji ' s
ashes.

Rajya Sabha's provisionally St a r r e d

Qu e st i on Dy . No. 002491 for 2.3. 2000 re ad s a s
under:

a). Whether Govt propose to initiate steps to

br in g h om e a sn as of N a ta ji Su b h as C h an dr a
Bose from Japan and kept at Red Fort?

b) If so, the details thereof; and

c) If no, the reasons thereof?

2. Parawise comments along with Note for

Supplementaries may please be sent to this
Ministry immediately.

(M.S. ZUHA) ,
DE SK O FF IC ER

PM0(Shri Jarnid Singhn, Joint Se c r e ta r y ) Soutn

Block.

MHA (JO No. I/13013/, /20 00 dat ed 22. 2.2 000

6/1-,,
- - - - - - - - -Ai,bill
\ \, n e ji. no,i4. fre,,,, A A"
17 V 0, edewil 44014,7 X / :',4 .
\
im
c 2 / -v t r ' * d"Wz-evw1-1-e-c 4 Alz9411j( ,W44114441
-
444,1 7," 4ed-e . e94-4 % gte44-14 4 -ele-i-w-,
4 /71, -,
i -r l e ,114--ti ' r e
oT It, etalimeeze` e -r,
r i v k a t X A44.44 01 AC, 144 tee vt z-yet
k5 1
are 4.41141 q iti e l i ( W'
Al 01174'e it.A.-" , 04k 104 c - 9 l'
All 4 1 -ill. ovilmi /1t,
f7ii'q 41-e ifilvel..4-64-4-e.4 44-eI t m tipi , A/.c
4/1,M,A.4'" * 14111A thia pr t I r 11.11/1 AO 0124- 4

eivl ArLt 4k l e -t, A0,44 /k7

\eV 6/ity-rprIAA 1 4' 1 11114_,?') bat 4.- e.
01,1i,t4i nil el- litim--4- ge" clol-
/

\
N

Office of 4. B. (7)

14.

t
2/
 AF F frTTTK
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
S1ETM T t i t WIttiRti
PR I M E M I N I S T E R ' S OFFICE
fft iqc.c.i1-110011
NEW DELHI -110011

Forwarded to.. . . .

j .........

T-t ef fff r4 r 19-q si.

for oppropriate action ..............................
ff Ell' 0* seta- q a.T
. rYW4-fi Trt
The Communications has not been
acknowlectge_cl.

(B. K. HAL)
( fffitg
Seeretarit
r 1 irat44
Vinsste
f
WM T ilt WrzliM1 Fto s fi
RATW' ..................
Prime Minister's Office U.0 NO'S !S-.) 11-1(- ) 6111,-Ifc.
Dated .....................
I I
 MILAN SAMITI
(A Socio-Cultural Organisation)
ROYNAG AR (RLY.-SIDING), KARI MG ANJ, AS S A M .
ESTD. 1991 (1)
REGN. NO. 2290/94-95

- Z i kb G.11 OM) Ry Co Fit/ ISION ON N E I A O Y S M`l STE R.)Ous DI Ft'P'PEAR.ANC.E_

To, fkavti,ee. ,4\, JL *E-1_14

Shri Atal Behari Vajpayee --L

firg 4 I fiNeW r u
Hon. Prime Minister of India,
-8 APR 701
Through The Deputy Commissioner, Karimganj
Respected Sir,
'
We, in tune with millions of Indian people,express our heart felt gratitude and thanks to the-
Government led by hon. Sri Atal Behari Vajpayee for taking the strong and sensuous decision of forming the Third Enquiry
Commission to unfold the mystery of disappearance of Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose, the most revered personality
in the history of Indian freedom movement.
Shah Nawaz Commission and Khosla Commission set up for the same purpose
by Pandit Jawahar Lal Nehru and his daughter, Mrs. Indira Gandhi respectively had failed invariably to fulfil the desires and
aspirations of the people of India to the extent that it was reasonably felt that both the Commissions were premonitored
and meant only to justify and establish the 'popular aircrash story' as factual truth. In this context, we would take the
opportunity to quote Sri Suresh Chandra Bose, one of the three members of
"It appears that from all that has transpired during the pendency of this enquiry, that after getting
Netaji's death confirmed by the committee, the ultimate object of the Government is to bring those 'Ashes' from
Tokyo as 'Netaji's Ashes'." (Dissentient Report, Second Edition, Page 41
The same statement is applicable to Khosla Commission, too. For your kind information, it would not be out of
context to mention that The Amrita Bazar Patrika of Calcutta published a report on 15 April, 1962 that some American
Forensic Experts had proved that 'The Ashes' kept in Renkoji temple, Japan are not of any human being but are probably
of a dog or a similar animal.
To believe that Netaji was alive even after "The crash" in 1945 is not without sufficient reasons. His voice had
been heard on Radio several times after the "said crash" and it is on record that on December 19, 1945, one such Radio

"This is Radio Manchuria, Subhash Bose speaking. We are under the shelter of one of the great powers
of the World................... We are sure to be successful within two years. I will go to India on the crest of a third
World War and sit in judgement upon those who am trying rny officers and my rnen at Red Fort."
In Calcutta, Netaji's Radio speeches were heard on not less than three occasions in the months of December 1945
& January and February 1946. Not only in India but also in many other parts of the World, his Radio speeches were heard.
Further more, in 1994, a research team from The Asiatic Society of Calcutta while at research in Russia on Indo-
Soviet relationship during the period from 1917 to 1947, obtained sufficient conclusive clues to opine that Bose had been
in Russia even in the year, 1946. a researcher from the team sought permission and help from the then
Government of India to carry on the investigative activities in this matter but the request surprisingly was not only denied
but also any such attempt was ironically discouraged.
During the terrible phase of the Indian freedom movement, the British Imperialists resorted to 'Agency Politics' so
as to sabotage the nationalist movement from within and later on being compelled to leave the subcontinent, they transferred
the administrative power to those agents who and whose successors, obviously, were not interested in solving the "Mystery
of Netaji's Disappearance" and hence, no sincere effort was made, ever. On the contrary, ill attempts were made to close
the chapter by bringing 'The Ashes' from Japan and confirming it as 'Netaji's Ashes'. Hence, the reports had been stuffed
with contradictory statements and controversial witnesses so as to mask the ill intentions of the earlier commissions.

Continued ...
 MILAN SAMITI
( A So cio- Cu lt ur al Or ga n isat ion )
ROYNAGAR (RLY.-SIDING),
ESTD.
KARI MGANJ, ASSAM.
1991
(2)
REGN. NO. 2290/94-95

'70.11 stA6,titRy commi ss 1.1 I N NE -TAT%Is tlySTE_RIOlis DISAPPEARANCE_

n
/4.

Moreover, the wealth belonging to Azad Hind Bank still remains untraced. the professor and
researcher was told by Col. Hugh bye (A British Millitary Intelligence Officer during the second World War and the writer
of the book, "The Springing Tiger".) that the latter had himself handed over huge amount of wealth to Pandit Jawahar
Lal Nehru, the whereabouts of which is still not known. The world knows that, in response to Netaji's Call, thousands
of Indians and non-resident Indians had donated their whole lives' earnings for their motherland's freedom movement. Hence,
in addition to unfolding of the mystery of disappearance of Netaji, we also demand for an inquiry into the vanished
property of the Azad Hind Bank which invariably belongs to the nation, not to any particular person.
We nourish this hope in our heart that the Central Government under the leadership of Sri Atal Behari Vajpayee
would extend a helping hand by providing all the related documents to the Third Enquiry Commission formed by the
previous Government and at the same time, would also request the countries related to the matter to cooperate with The
Commission by allowing the Commission to see and use the various documents at their disposal so that the mystery could
be unfolded.
We have the strong belief that an honest exercise of power by the central Government will invariably unveil the
greatest mystery of the 20th century and establish the truth in its actual footings. And for this act of sincerity, we, alongwith
millions of Indian people, would be thankful to the Government, forever.
JAI HIND !
Cordially
on behalf of millions of
Netaji's Admirers
._PAAA,gr,./tyyt
(Shankar Baulk) (Praha! Kanti San)
President Secretary
'MILAN SAMITI' President, 'MILAN SAMITI'
Karimganj,MIL A N SA M I T I . Roynagar. (Rly-siding), Karimganj.
soy Nagar (My Si d i n g ) GENERAL SECRETARY.
KARIMGmN.J. MILAN SA T-r .
1. Shri KR. Narayanan, Hon. President of India. floynagar Rly. Sicrng
2. Shri. L.K. Advani, Hon. Home Minister of India. Karimganj, Assam.
3. Shrimati Mamata Banerjee, Hon. Minister, Railways.
4. Shri Jaswant Singh, Hon. Minister External Affairs
5. Shri Arun Jaitley, Hon. Minister, Information & Broadcasting.
6. Shri G.M.C. Balayogi, Hon. Speaker Lok Sabha.
7. Shri Nepal Ch. bias, Hon. Member of Parliament
8. Shri Manoj Kumar Mukhopadhyay, Hon. Chairman, Third Enquiry Commission.
9. Hon. President, Forward Block.
19 Hon. Secretary, Netaji Research Bureau.

(Shankar Banik) (Praha! Kanti Sen)

President Secretary
'MILAN SAMITI' 'MILAN SAMITI'
Karimganj. Roynagar. (Rly-siding), Karimganj.