Sunteți pe pagina 1din 9

Asian Affairs, Vol. 29, No.

3 :44-60, July-September, 2007 CDRB FREEDOM OF PRESS IN DEMOCRACY


publication

democracy from the 1991 has brought a considerable freedom for


the press with a democratic order. The successive democratic
regime generally respected the freedom of the press, although
FREEDOM OF PRESS IN DEMOCRACY: the tasks of upholding this freedom by the Journalists have not
BANGLADESH PERSPECTIVE been easy in Bangladesh. Numerous cases have been documented
where journalists are harassed, intimidated and killed by political
activists, police and often vested groups in the society.
MOHAMMAD TARIKUL ISLAM
The state and its functionaries are the most obvious source of
Abstract media censorship, reassessment and repression. However, as
The paper attempts to focus the freedom of press and democracy in many action also have a stake in suppressing, the activities of
analytical perspective. It is pointed out that, freedom of press is journalists. Steady criminalization of the political and economic
indeed, an essential force that plays critical role as one of the
landscape explaining much of the violence and brutality
main conscience keepers of the nation, and for the protection of
those who have no other redress in a democratic country like
experienced by members of the press.
Bangladesh. For the welfare of the society and the development of
democratic system, none can deny the importance of freedom of Pervasive corruption at all levels also becomes a fundamental
press. Specially, modern democracy is fully meaningless without barrier to press freedom. The problem is not so much of oppressive
the freedom of press. The press freedom acts as an essential safe lawsalthough existing laws are not exactly liberal but more
guard of democracy. But in our country, there are numerous that extralegal measures and illegal forms of intimidation,
constraints behind the freedom of press. The reasons why, coercion and violence are routinely used by the state and others
democracy is not functioning properly till today. Moreover, the to silence the press. The numerous newspapers and periodicals
democratic journey of the country at a stake. The paper also published in Bangladesh testify to that freedom press. Not
considers the state of freedom of press in Bangladesh and
withstanding, the press in Bangladesh suffers from some serious
contributions of it for the promotion of democracy.
limitations and barriers. As a result of the fact, freedom of press
Introduction is an essential for the consolidation of fledging democracy in
According to Alexis de Tocqueville, the emergence of the Bangladesh 2.
press claims it self as a powerful instrument for democracy1.
Freedom of the press, therefore, becomes more necessary in Freedom of Press: Its Conceptual Analysis
proportion as men become more equal and individual more to be The press has become even more central to democratic
feared. To suppose that they only serve to protect freedom would discourse worldwide. The existence of freedom of the press still
be to diminish their importance. Democratization and freedom marks a critical point that distinguishes a freely functioning
of press are hand in hand and reinforce one another. There is democracy from an authoritarian regime. The quintessentially
hardly any doubt that democracy to be meaningful must ensure modern idea of a free press has been evolving for more than two
freedom of information to the people. The free flow of information centuries. A truly noteworthy development of the latter half of
is therefore, an essential requirement for successful the twentieth century has become a gradually growing realization
democratization. In fact, freedom of press is a powerful change around the world that press freedom not only is an indispensable
agent in a democratic society. Bangladesh is a democratic pillar of democracy, but it is important for the long term
country of the 3rd world. The reintroduction of the parliamentary sustainability of social and economic development. For over a
CopyrightCDRB, ISSN 0254-4199 45
ASIAN AFFAIRS FREEDOM OF PRESS IN DEMOCRACY

century and a half following 1791, when the first amendment have a right to expression, if there is no search light on corruption
was written into the U.S. Constitution to guarantee freedom of and inequitable practices, you can not build the public consensus
the press, this idea did not gain global acceptance. Only a few needed to bring about change5.
industrializing societies in the west allowed the press to function
freely within their borders. 3 Today, how ever the number of According to the definition of William Blackstone, Every free
countries that respect freedom of the press has risen man has an undoubted right to lay what sentiment he pleases
dramatically, though there remain many others that still do not before the public; to for did this, is to destroy the freedom of the
have anything resembling a free press. In 1950, as the post world press.
war II. Wave of a desalinization swept across the world, India
became the first non-western, non-industrialized nation to create A.V. Dicey commented, the freedom of press means the right
a dramatic republic with the right of freedom of expression of a person to publish what he pleases in books or newspapers6.
written in to its constitution. Article 19 (1) of the Indian
constitution did not use the exact phrase freedom of the press, The first Indian press commission commented as the freedom
it simply stated that all citizens would have the right to freedom to hold opinions, to receive and to impart information, through
of speech and expression. the printed word, without any interference from any public
authority.
Many newly independent nations declared themselves to be
democracies of one kind or another, but their governments Realizing the importance of freedom of press, Ex U.S president
excluded press freedom from the definition of democracy. The Jefferson Stated, were it left to me to decide whether we should
situation began to change as the new third wave of have government without news paper or newspaper without
democratization initiated among the 3rd world countries in the government, I should not hesitate a moment to prefer the latter7.
2nd half of the twentieth century.
So, a free press means a press, which is free from the
compulsions from whatever source govt., social external or
The awarding of the 1998 Nobel Prize in economics to Amartya
internal. A free press is free for the expression of opinion in all
Sen was therefore a milestone for those who recognize the
its phases. Freedom of press includes the right to adopt and
crucial link between freedom and well being, between democracy
pursue a policy without governmental restriction.
and growth.4
Democracy: Its Meaning and Content
Significantly, that link has been noted by the worlds leading More than a form or system of government, democracy has
development organization, the World Bank. Until recently, the come to assume the status of a fashionable nomenclature. As
Bank rarely mentioned words like democracy or press freedom fashion is a fast changing concept, so are the meanings and
in its official statements. These days, the Bank openly states its contents of democracy in reality, if not always in theory. Though
support for freedom of the press as a key factor in economics often assumed to be simple form of government, democracy seems
and social advancement. In a recent speech to the world press to have assumed most of the complexities of the world; on the
freedom committee in Washington D.C, World Bank president other hand, an umpteen number of adjectives have been adopted
James D. Wolfensohn stated. A fresh press is not a luxury, a to divert the attention of the critics of democracy in several
free press is at the absolute core of equitable development, states. Basic, Guided, Panchayat, Party less, one party,
because if you can not enfranchise poor people, if they do not Peoples, and Islamic are some such adjectives.
46 47
ASIAN AFFAIRS FREEDOM OF PRESS IN DEMOCRACY

The term democracy has been defined by the concise Oxford variously known as parliament, congress, national assembly has
Dictionary of Current English as (state practicing) government the right to legislation, the right to vote taxes and control the
by the people, direct or representative; the politically unprivileged budget and the right publicly to question, discuss, criticize and
the concept as a form of government in which the supreme power oppose government measures without being subject to threats of
is vested in the people collectively and is administered by them interference or arrest 10".
or by officers appointed by them; the common people; a state of
society characterized by recognition of equality of rights and Allan Ball has identified the following features of liberal
privileges; political, social or legal equality; in the U.S. the democratic system:
democratic party8.
1. There is more than one political party competing for
Walter Laqueur has elaborated democracy in the following political power.
fashion: Derived from the Greek People and Power, originally 2. The competition for power is open, not secretive and is
referred to the right of the citizens of the Greek city states to based on established and accepted forms of procedure.
participate directly in the act of government, now a days, in the 3. Entry and recruitment to positions of political power are
west, the term is usually reserved for political systems that relatively open.
accept certain basic assumptions (often written into the 4. There are periodic elections based on universal franchise.
constitution) but which may also be the result of custom and 5. Pressure groups are able to operate to influence
tradition e.g., the British constitution. These are: the govt. should government decision. Associations such as trade unions
reflect the peoples will and the choice-hence, the constitutional and other voluntary organizations are not subject to close
provision of regular elections, by secret ballot, with governmental control.
representatives of at least two parties standing for election. 6. Civil liberties, such as freedom of speech, religion,
Citizens, there fore, have the right to combine to achieve common freedom from arbitrary arrest, are recognized and
aimsprovided these aims do not jeopardize the rights of protected within the political system. This assumes that
others 9". there is substantial amount of independence and freedom
from government control of the mass media, i.e., radio,
Commenting on Democracy, Allan Bullock observes that television, newspapers.
democracy is no longer direct but indirect i.e., through the 7. There is some form of separation of powers, i.e., a
election of representatives; hence the term representative representative assembly has some form of control over
democracy. The criteria of democracy are therefore (a) whether the executive and the judiciary is independent of both
such elections are free: i.e., whether they are held frequently executive and legislature 11.
and periodically, whether the every citizen has the right to vote,
whether candidates and parties are free to campaign in opposition So, democracy is a form of government, in which people is
to government of the day, and whether the voter is protected the supreme authority as a whole rather than any section, or
against intimidation by the secrecy of the ballot; (b) whether class or interest group within it. As a result of the fact, we can
such elections provide an effective choice i.e., whether the choice conclude our Conceptual discussion of recognized definition of
of the electors is not limited to a single party, and whether a Abraham Linkon regarding democracy, democracy is the
majority vote against the government in power leads to change government, of the people, by the people, and for the people.
of government; (c) whether the elected body of representatives
48 49
ASIAN AFFAIRS FREEDOM OF PRESS IN DEMOCRACY

Importance of Freedom of Press in Democracy: Every one has the right to freedom of opinion and freedom of
A Critical Analysis expression, this right includes freedom to hold opinions without
The exercise of freedom of opinion, expression and information, interference and to seek, receive and impart information and
recognized as an integral part of human rights and fundamental ideas through any media and regardless of frontiers.
freedoms, is a vital factor in the strengthening of peace and
democracy. In fact, press freedom is a major component that Declaration on mass communication media and human rights,
plays a critical role to promote democracy. council of Europe, 1970 prioritized the importance of press freedom
that works best as a safeguard to protect human rights and
According to John Stuart Mill, Greatest happiness for the democracy.
greatest number of people is democracy and freedom of thought.
It holds that the freedom to speak is intimately tied to the Press systems of SAARC, Jointly organized by Asian Mass
freedom of thought, and that a probition on what one can think Communication (AMIC) and Nepal press institute in 1991, placed
is an attack on ones identity, freedom of thought as a result of importance over the freedom of press for the exercise of
the fact, is indeed a vital force to strengthening democracy12". democracy. It also stressed the priority upon the free flow of
information through press freedom in South Asian countries for
Realizing the importance of press freedom for democracy, the institutionalization of democracy14.
David Flint pointed out three major points:
Tocqueville pointed out the importance of press freedom in
(1) People need to be informed on all matters of public strengthening democracy. He mentioned that press freedom
interest so that they may effectively exercise their roles, causes political life to circulate through all the parts of that vast
as citizens, for example in voting and so also that they majority. Its eye is constantly open to detect the secret springs
may form opinions and engage in debate. of political designs and to summon the leaders of all parties in
turn to the bar of the public opinion. It rallies the interest of the
(2) The exchange of free and full information is the oxygen community round certain principles and draws up the creed of
of a market economy. every party; for it affords a means of inter course between those
who hear and address each other without ever coming in to
(3) Democracy requires both good and erroneous ideas be immediate contact.
allowed and indeed, encouraged in the market place of
ideas. When ideas complete in the market place for As a result of the fact, no democratic system cannot exist
acceptance, full and free discussion exposes the false without freedom of press. Freedom of press is an important pre-
and they gain few adherents13. requisite for democratic system as:

Amartya Sen rightly commented that, Freedom of expression (a) For organizing peoples view, there is no alternative to
and freedom of the press are surely essential elements in the press freedom. Press freedom can provide people the real
developing process of democracy. and factual news and as a result, people can go through
right decision and organize themselves for real objects.
United Nations in its universal declaration of human rights (b) In a democratic system, the connection of every group is
(Article 19) rightly mentioned the following: important for a strong democracy, every group must be
50 51
ASIAN AFFAIRS FREEDOM OF PRESS IN DEMOCRACY

able to criticize the functions of govt. which is against Press can drive the state and society in a proper way and can
the interest of people. pave the way to be solidified nation. Every state has some
(c) In modern governing system public opinion is very objective end views for the articulation. Such sorts of nationall
significant issue. For the existence of any state, the goals are the ultimate product of the unification and consensus
articulation of public opinion is crying need. Press is the of the people. A free press can work to serve the national interest.
only way to articulate the public opinion and let the govt.
give a chance to run over the state through pro-people Importance of Freedom of Press in Bangladesh:
policies. An Evaluation
(d) Without peoples consciousness about their right and Bangladesh is a democratic country of the 3 rd world.
duties, the society will not drive in a proper way. Press is Parliamentary democracy had been practicing in Bangladesh
the ultimate product of public consciousness that plays a since her birth in 1971. Moreover, after few years of practicing
critical role to bring a sense of eagerness to take part in parliamentary democracy since its liberation, Bangladesh went
the state functioning. through a serious political instability with the staging of coups
(e) Human rights is essential to promote the development of and counter coups. Several political ups and downs like
the society. Press plays a critical role to secure the human introduction of one party system by sheikh Mujibur Rahman,
rights in all respect. When human rights is violated any military role by Ziaur Rahman and HM Ershad and irresponsible
where by anyone through the country, press comes competion of political parties to capture power have placed the
forward to speak in support of it. democratic journey of the countries at stake. However, the nation
(f) UN secretary General Kofi Annan says, Good Governance has restarted her journey to democracy with over through of
is perhaps the single most important factor in eradicating Ershad in 1990 but the path is not moisturized still now, though
poverty and promoting development. In fact, democracies as an independent nation, we have passed about thirty five years
are better guarantor or property rights than no but our achievements in the spheres of democracy and
democracies an that enforcing tracts is essential for development are not noteworthy. Even, the country today is
investment and growth for the development of the society, riddled with numerous problems threatening the very
freedom of press is important as it can ensure the real development of democracy. Lack effective and strong presence
situation regarding development. As a result, the of freedom of press is one of them. Through the constitution of
authority concern go through right measures on time to Peoples Republic of Bangladesh guarantees freedom of speech
boost development process15. and expression under article 39, but such freedom is subject to
(g) Press is the mirror of a society. It provides the real reasonable restrictions. Moreover, a number of acts along with
picture of a society. Specially, in modern world press is the rigid government control over the information and the misuse
very alert and conscious about corruption. So any sort of of power are responsible for the less effectives of press freedom.
mismanagements, power abuse, wastages of resources, In 2003, The committee to protect journalists (CPJ) declared
nepotism, press when it is free from the interference Bangladesh to be one of the most violent places in the world for
can uphold the real story, and let the govt. give a reporters. In deed, investigative journalism has become an
chance to combat terrorism, corruption, increasingly hazardous occupation in Bangladesh.
mismanag4ement as well.
(h) In a modern world, press is known as the fourth state The state and its functionaries are the most obvious source
for the democratic development of any state. of media censorship harassment and repression. However, as
52 53
ASIAN AFFAIRS FREEDOM OF PRESS IN DEMOCRACY

many of the incidents make clean, a variety of non state actors become prey when they report on the hooliganism and corruption
also have a stake in suppressing the activities of journalists, of the ruling party members.
steady criminalization of the political and economic landscape
explains much of the violence and brutality experienced by Journalists are often per secured with the help of law
members of the press in 2003. Pervasive corruption at all levels enforcement agencies and in some cases with assistance from
has also become a fundamental barrier to press freedom. The professional criminals.
problem is not so much of draconian on oppressive laws-although
existing laws are not exactly liberal but more that extralegal Libel and defamation cases against journalist are also used
measures and illegal forms of intimidation, coercion and violence as tools of harassment. Although turning to procedures laid out
routinely used by the state and others to silence the press. The in the law, rather than resorting to extra legal measures such
special power acts of 1997 introduced certain restrictions on the as rouging up and intimidating individuals on ransacking offices,
activities of journalists, among other things; they were bound by may appear democratic, the uses and interpretation of the law
that law to reveal their sources of information. Subsequently, leave much room for manipulation.
these provisions were removed by an interim caretaker Many laws in Bangladesh compel journalists to practice some
government 16. degree of self censorship, when even a case is filed under section
In our country, till today journalists are routinely harassed 501 of the penal code, which relates to printing or engraving
intimidated on physically assaulted in the course of their work. matter known to be defamatory. the courts response is to issue
There are almost daily causes of physical assaults and an arrest warrant rending investigation, it has become a practice
intimidation, particularly in rural areas. Not surprisingly, those in Bangladesh that on the day of the first hearing, the court
journalists who reports on political violence, official corruption issues a warrant and in most cases, irrespective of the charges
and organized crimes are prime targets for reprisal by the police, gravity, journalists are ordered to be arrested immediately. It
political cadres affiliated with the ruling party, and by under has been a long standing demand of the press that the practice
world criminal gangs who themselves often ties to parties in on issuing warrants be changed so that journalists are not
powers. inhibited by the fear of arrest even if their report is based on
facts.
On the contrary, many found that upon publishing stories
that in criminate powerful interest groups, false cases are lodged In addition to this provision, there are certain other provisions
against them in turn. of the penal code, viz., sedition (section 124 A), defamation (section
499-502), statements conducing to public mischief (section 505),
Law enforcement agencies although their mission is to protect offence relates to obscenity (sections 292 and 293), deliberate
citizens, members of law enforcement agencies, the police, The and malicious acts intended to outrage religious feelings of any
Bangladesh Rifles, and other intelligence agencies frequently class by insulting its religion on religious feelings (section 295A)
function as handmaidens of the govt. and the ruling party. The etc. manipulation of which allow the govt. to intrude on the free
police have an especially bad record in this respect. Fabricating and fair exercise of freedom of press, the official secrets act,
charges against journalists in retaliation for unearthing 1923 restricts the journalists to have access to official materials.
potentially damaging information is a common method of The administration is a vital source of news as it is the arena
harassment. Members of the ruling party routinely harass where corruption, mismanagement are most likely to take place
journalists through out the year. In most cases, journalists the bureaucracy in Bangladesh till looks at the press with
54 55
ASIAN AFFAIRS FREEDOM OF PRESS IN DEMOCRACY

suspicion and fear, and tries to avoid the journalists. This is a to exercise their rights as citizen and participate intelligently
stumbling block to the growth and impact of the press for an and effectively in the governance of the country19. The press is
accountable and efficient democratic system in Bangladesh17. by far the best-suited medium for the purpose. It can keep the
people informed of all the local, national and international
It is said that no paper or periodical can stand up to financial developments and provide widest possible scope for public
power in Bangladesh. It needs money to bring out papers. The discussion on issues and common concern. It is acknowledged
revenue earned from subscribers can not cover even a fraction on all hands that freedom of the press is not a one sided privilege
of the production cost even if the circulation is exceptionally of the journalists. It is a corollary to the readers right to know.
high. Advertisements are the lifeblood of the media, and since
the government is the biggest blood donors, as a result, it has a The press in Bangladesh plays a unique role and enjoys a
strong control over the press and that is a barrier to the freedom considerable freedom compatible with a democratic order; the
of press in Bangladesh18. successive democratic regimes generally respected the freedom
of the press, although the tasks of upholding this freedom by the
A developing country like Bangladesh is not well established journalists have not been easy. Numerous cases are documented
in democracy. Most of the time the ruling system of the country where journalists are harassed, intimidated and killed by political
is one man show, authoritarianism type of ruling system. As a activists, police and other vested groups in the society. There
result, freedom of press is very limited here, on the contrary. In are cases when the press in Bangladesh sometimes becomes a
case of irresponsible journalism on press freedom creates a willing propaganda machine for corporate on dominant political
critical problems in a democratic country like Bangladesh. For interests, but the change can be clearly noted as the profession
the cause of freedom, press can provide public news without of journalism is moving towards a high standard of accountability
real documents, this type of wrong and irresponsible information and increasing realization that media serves the needs of the
creates a unprecedented suffering at local and national level people. The profession of journalism is noble, enjoyable as well
and jeopardize the stability of the country. Moreover, political as risky. The practice of journalism is difficult in todays world
involvement and biasness of the editors, publishers and that is paradoxically witnessing enormous opportunities as well
journalists have become a major impediment to the freedom of as myriad challenges for peaceful social and political existence.
press in our country. The tasks of journalists, therefore, are adventurous, rewarding
and often dangerous, particularly in conflict areas and violence
Despite the fact, Bangladesh today is fortunate to enjoy a of prone societies. The trend is clear the journalists suffer
considerable freedom that is essential for the promotion of its increasingly for their reporting on crime, corruption, bad
democracy. governance, and violation of human rights 20. In Bangladesh,
journalists run the risk of arrests and violence as offenders
Concluding Remarks against public order and safety by the state. At the same time,
What becomes very clean from the above discussion is that in many new democracies like Bangladesh, the profession of
the press and for that matter free press is inseparable from journalism has not also developed to that highest standard where
democracy. It is at once an essential attribute of and in ethics of journalism is fully maintained. The journalist are often
dispensable pre-condition for democracy. The people must be tempted and induced to write sensational and motivate news
allowed the freedom to hold opinion without interference and to damaging for particular groups, political party or interest. The
seek, receive and impart information and ideas to enable them frontiers of information ethics are therefore, becoming very
56 57
ASIAN AFFAIRS FREEDOM OF PRESS IN DEMOCRACY

reluctant for the journalists in the globalizing era. It is imperative NOTES


that journalists follow the ethics of their profession without which
individuals, groups and nation states will suffer in image and 1. Adhikari, Gautam, (2000): From the press to the Media, Journal of
reputation. Democracy, Vol. 11, No.-01

2. Rahman, Gazi, Shamsur (2000): Sangbath pathrar Sadinata (Freedom


The new generation of journalist should therefore, be equipped of Press), Samaj Nirikkha, No. 72.
with skill as well professional integrity and greater realization
of the implications of their reports and stories. 3. Hadenius, Akel,. (1992): Democracy and Development, Cambridge
University Press, Cambridge, UK.
The official secrets act, 1923 restricts the journalists to have
access to official materials. The reason why, a transparent system 4. Sen, Amartya,. (1999): Democracy as a universal value, journal of
of administration should be able to ensure free flow of information democracy, July 10.
from the government so that inefficiencies, misuses and failures
of the govt. can be exposed to the wider public. 5. Wolfensohn, James D (1999): Voice of the poor, Washington Post,
November 10.
The free press is also constrained by the political parties who 6. Dicey, A. V. (1915): The Law of the Constitution.
always try to assess freedom of. the press and the objectivity of
journalism in terms of how much support or sympathy they obtain 7. Akindele, S. T. and Obiyan, A. Sat (1996): The thesis of liberal
from their reports and coverage. democracy: A revisitational review, IFE Social Sciences Review. Vol.
13, No. 02.
So, time has come to realize the importance of freedom of
press to promote democracy in Bangladesh. The govt. should be 8. The Concise Oxford Dictionary of Current English, London, Oxford
serious to apply the mechanism to protect human rights in all University Press, 1964.
aspects as per the constitutional obligation (article 39). Beside
9. Laquer, Walter (1969): A Dictionary of Politics, London, Pan Books.
the editors publishers, and journalists should keep their
neutrality to uphold the prestige of the profession. It is impossible 10. Bullock, Alan and Stally, Brass, Oliver, eds. (1983): Fontana Dictionary
for the govt. and the press media to shoulder the responsibilities of Modern Thought, London, Fontana/Collins.
of improving the state of press freedom. So, the political parties,
civil society, public intellectuals and conscious citizens should 11. Ball, Alan (1977): Modern Politics and Government, London, Macmillan
come forward to uphold the spirit of freedom of press to strengthen Press.
democracy in Bangladesh. In fact, freedom of press plays an
important role as one of the main conscience keepers of the 12. Sen, Sachin (1957): The Press and Democracy, India.
nation and is indeed act as an essential watchdog of democracy.
13. Flint, David (1998): Censorship Vs Free Flow: Regulation Vs
Deregulation in Converging Industries, Media Asia. Vol. 25, No. 3.
14. Press Systems of SAARC, Jointly Organized by Asian Mass
Communication Research and Information Centre (AMIC) and Nepal
Press Institution, Khathmandu, Nepal, 1999.

58 59
ASIAN AFFAIRS

15. Kofi Annans Speech on Governance, Development and Press Freedom,


Visit www.uno.com

16. Alam, Md. Khurshed (1992): Sangbad Pathrar Sadinata (Freedom of


Press), Mowla Brothers, Dhaka.

17. Kanti, Tapas Baul. (2003): Press Freedom in 2003: Ominous signs for
the future, published in Press Freedom, Dhaka.

18. Ranjana, Shahana Huda. (1990): Bostonista Sangbadikatha O Sangbad


Patrar Sadinata, Samaj Nirikkhan, No. 41, Dhaka.

19. Jahangir, Muhammad, eds (1995): Democracy (in Bangla), Mowla


Brothers, Dhaka.

20. Freederick, W. Schieck, Independent Medias Role in Building


Democracy, Visit http:/usinfo. State.gov/journals/itgie/0203/ijge/
gjol.htm.

60

S-ar putea să vă placă și