Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
through its undersigned counsel, for its objection (the “Cure Objection”) to the proposed
cure amount scheduled in the Debtor’s Notice of Proposed Assumption and Assignment of
Executory Contracts and Unexpired Lease, filed on May 28, 2008 (the “Cure Notice”)
1. Kanye is, among other things, a record producer whose services are
furnished by Konman.
2. On February 19, 2008 (the “Petition Date”), TeeVee Toons, Inc. d/b/a TVT
Records (the “Debtor”) filed a voluntary petition for relief in this Court under chapter 11 of
title 11 of the United States Code, 11 U.S.C. §§ 101, et seq. (the “Bankruptcy Code”).
3. Prior to the Petition Date, Kanye and the recording group known as “213”
respect to procuring Kanye’s services as a record producer in connection with the creation
of one master recording (the “Master”) embodying the Artist’s performance. It was
contemplated that the Master was to be delivered by the Artist to the Debtor pursuant to
with recording the Master, it was contemplated that the Artist was to pay, or to cause the
Debtor to pay, Kanye, a one-time, recoupable sum of $40,000 as an up-front advance from
any and all royalties payable to Kanye (excluding mechanical royalties) under the Producer
Producer Agreement as Exhibit A (the “Letter of Direction”) (together with the Producer
Agreement, the “Agreements”), the Artist would exercise its right to request the Debtor to
pay the Advance to Kanye on behalf of the Artist.1 Thus, it was anticipated that the
obligation to pay the Advance would be satisfied by the Debtor. Both the Producer
Agreement and the Letter of Direction acknowledged that Kanye could receive the entire
such agreements were exchanged, the Agreements were never executed due to a dispute
1
Pursuant to the Letter of Direction, it was anticipated that the Advance would be recoupable by the Debtor
from any and all royalties (excluding mechanical royalties) payable to Kanye pursuant to the Producer
Agreement. To the extent not so recouped, the Advance would be recoupable by the Debtor from any record
royalties payable to the Artist (excluding mechanical royalties) under the Producer Agreement.
2
over “swap” arrangements among the parties. Thus, it is likely that the Producer
Agreement was never an enforceable contract and therefore, is not capable, as a matter of
Agreement, on or about August 12, 2004, the Debtor delivered a check in the amount of
$20,000 to Kanye as a “front-end payment” for his services under the Producer Agreement
(the “Purported Advance Payment”). Upon information and belief, this payment was
Payment to the Debtor asserting that the terms of the Producer Agreement required the
payment in full of the Advance. Kanye also asserted that until such payment was made by
the Debtor, it, or its affiliates, would have no rights to exploit the Master and/or the
composition in connection with the Master. Upon information and belief, the Debtor did
not respond to the return of the Purported Advance Payment or the correspondence
accompanying it.
9. On May 28, 2008, the Debtor filed the Cure Notice listing the executory
contracts and unexpired leases which the Debtor may seek to assume and assign in
connection with the sale of substantially all of its assets, and, by its calculations, any
10. The Cure Notice lists the Producer Agreement as an executory contract
which the Debtor may seek to assume and assign in connection with the sale of
substantially all of its assets. In addition, the Cure Notice provides that no cure amount is
3
due and owing to Kanye under the Producer Agreement.
11. Kanye asserts that, as a matter of law, the unexecuted Producer Agreement
contract.
performance, if any, pursuant to the anticipated Agreements and the Debtor’s tender of
partial payment (albeit unsuccessful due to its failure to comport with the terms of the
subject to assumption as an executory contract, Kanye objects to the proposed cure amount
followed where the parties to the anticipated agreement do not consider the outstanding
issues to be material. In this instance, however, the dispute over the “swap” arrangement
was material and ultimately led to the breakdown in negotiations resulting in the
14. By its Cure Notice, however, the Debtor may be asserting that due to
industry standards the parties herein acted as if the Agreements had been executed, and
therefore, the Agreements are executory and capable of being assumed and assigned,
15. Upon information and belief, as of the date hereof, the Debtor has not
satisfied its obligations to pay the Advance to Kanye pursuant to the Agreements.
4
Additionally, the Debtor may have unsatisfied obligations in connection with the payment
pursuant to the Agreements, the total cure amount which the Debtor is obligated to pay
before it may assume the Agreements is, at a minimum, $40,000.00, plus royalties,
calculated according to the Agreements. However, without access to the Debtor’s books
and records, including records pertaining to its sales of recordings, manufacturing records,
inventory records and other pertinent information that would enable Kanye to ascertain
whether and to what extent the Debtor has properly accounted to Kanye (or accounted at
all), Kanye cannot fully determine the accurate cure amount corresponding to the
Agreements. The Debtor’s superficial and conclusory statement regarding an alleged cure
amount is woefully insufficient. The Agreements contain provisions setting forth the
formulas to be used to calculate the payments to be made to the parties and procedures to
be followed in order to reconcile amounts due and owing under the Agreements. These
formulas and procedures, are, in turn, based on sales data and other information within the
Debtor’s knowledge and control, which Kanye will have to review and reconcile before
determining a cure amount. Without more specific information and some level of shared
effort to reconcile the proposed cure amount with the Debtor, Kanye cannot reach a more
16. In its current state, the Cure Notice appears to represent only the Debtor’s
minimal efforts to satisfy the deadline for filing an assumption and assignment notice and
will then to simply wait and see whether contract counterparties object before making a
more substantive attempt to accurately determine what executory contracts it has and the
accurate cure amounts thereto. Pursuant to the Section 365(b)(1) of the Bankruptcy Code
5
(“Section 365(b)(1)”), a debtor can only allow an executory contract if no default exists.
In the event a default has occurred, the debtor is required to cure the default as a predicate
to assuming the contract. The Cure Notice filed by the Debtor is nothing more than a half-
hearted effort to simulate a real effort to satisfy the relevant legal standard, which should
17. Because the accuracy of the proposed cure amounts in connection with the
Agreements cannot be determined, the Debtor cannot claim to have satisfied the
requirements of Section 365(b)(1) which requires the cure, in full, of all outstanding
defaults or amounts due under an unexpired lease or executory contract to be assumed and
assigned. The Debtor cannot consummate any proposed assumption and assignment of the
Agreements unless and until it properly identifies the amounts of such cure obligations and
affords contract counterparties the opportunity to determine whether the alleged cure
amounts are accurate. Only then, once such amounts are agreed upon and such amounts
are paid in full, can the relevant agreements be assumed and assigned (assuming that a cure
can be effected or that agreements were not terminated prior to the commencement of the
Debtor’s chapter 11 case). As such, Kanye objects to the entirety of the Cure Notice.
18. Kanye reserves the right to (i) amend or supplement this Cure Objection,
(ii) object to potential assumption or assignment of the Producer Agreement on any other
basis and (iii) assert all of its other rights and remedies against the Debtor.
WHEREFORE, Kanye respectfully requests that the Court (a) determine that the
Producer Agreement is not a contract capable, as a matter of law, of being assumed by the
Debtor or (b) in the alternative, if the Court were to determine that the Producer Agreement
was an executory contract, condition any assumption and assignment of the Producer
6
Agreement on (i) the payment in full outstanding amount due to Kanye in compliance with
Section 365 of the Bankruptcy Code and (ii) compliance with any other applicable law and
(c) grant such other and further relief as the Court deems just and proper.