Impact of Dynamic Demand Response in The Load Frequency Control

Impact Of Dynamic Demand Response In The Load Frequency
Control
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 INTRODUCTION
The quantification of device reserve has a noticeably easy and
largely deterministic system. The demand for electric energy is
enormous, particularly in regions where business and business
activities have rapidly evolved. However, locating a appropriate website
online for a brand new substation or new transmission line is difficult

due to protests by the residents of doubtlessly affected neighborhoods.
Expanding the capacity of a substation or transmission line is likewise
tough in urban areas. The gadget safety of the substation is tough to
maintain when the substation suffers from capacity shortages or is in a
kingdom of emergency. A suitable load control scheme is, therefore,
needed to keep the reliability of the structures.
Frequency drifts, upwards or downwards, in a power device is the
principle indicator of the momentary imbalance among era and
demand. If, at any instant, electricity demand (taken on this paper to be
lively energy simplest) exceeds deliver, then the device frequency falls.
Conversely, if power deliver exceeds demand, frequency rises. The
device frequency fluctuates continuously in reaction to the changing
demand and because of the realistic impossibility of generation being
controlled to right now music all adjustments in call for.
In the ultimate three a long time, distinct soft computing strategies
have developed and effectively applied to specific complicated
optimization hassle. Power gadget optimization is not any exception to
this trend. Soft computing techniques that are efficiently used to
Dept. of EEE BITIT-Hindupur

Page 1
Control
remedy load frequency control trouble encompass Genetic Algorithm
(GA), Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO), Bacterial Foraging Algorithm
(BFA) and Differential Evolution (DE). In order to solve the optimization
trouble greater successfully special artificial intelligence techniques are
blended in hybrid manner. For example a Fuzzy logic manipulate
scheme in mixture with different optimization technique may be very
beneficial to make sure the robustness of the system.
The obvious challenge in inclusive of masses in frequency control
is the massive growth within the quantity of capability participants.
Even in the biggest manipulate regions, at most a few hundred big mills
contribute to frequency control. On the alternative hand, participation
from the demand facet might involve tens of thousands if no longer
millions of clients. Though this can appear technically daunting and
economically unrealistic, it has to remember that traditional primary
frequency control is a allotted control gadget that is based at the
availability of the frequency as a degree of imbalance among load and
era. Indeed, the reaction of each generating unit is decided by way of its
slump characteristic and a nearby frequency size, not through a signal
despatched from a manage middle. Communication to and from the
control center is used handiest inside the slower secondary and tertiary
control loops for higher financial optimization and network security. A
load or purchaser for this reason does not should be plugged into a
conversation network to take part in number one frequency manage.
1.2 LITERATURE SURVEY
Conventionally, frequency regulation in energy gadget is
completed by using balancing technology and demand via load
following, i.E., spinning and non-spinning reserves. The destiny
electricity grid, however, is foreseen to have excessive penetration of

Page 2
Control
renewable power (RE) electricity generation, which can be fantastically
variable. In such cases, power garage and responsive masses show
exquisite promise for balancing generation and call for, as they may
help to keep away from using the conventional generation following
schemes, which may be high priced and/or environmentally unfriendly.
Given the confined availability, low performance, and high cost of huge
garage devices, real-time clever responsive load participation, referred to
as call for response (DR), has been actively considered for power
balancing. It can be finished via energetic client participation in actual-
time to hold stability among technology and demand with two-manner
communique. It is well known that DR increases device reliability and
flexibility to manipulate the variability and uncertainty of a few RE
resources, decreases the fee of operation, and enhances system
efficiency.
Furthermore, DR may be used to provide ancillary services (AS) for
regulation reserve and to reply momentarily to the area manage
mistakes (ACE). Although AS are known as greater frequently than
conventional load dropping events, the once a year overall hours of
curtailment is a great deal much less, and man or woman events are a
lot shorter. Thus, AS applications might also enchantment to retail
customers, as they will find extra frequent and quick on/off switching
of some of their stop-use masses extra suitable than rare and lengthy
curtailments. Examples of consumer end-use masses which have on
the spot response and are ability candidates for DR are electric water
warmers (EWHs) and HVACs. For the above motives enormous attention
has been lately given to DR for extraordinary functions, e.G., economic
benefits of DR, offline making plans and day-beforehand scheduling,
availability assessment of the DR sources for reserve capability, and

Page 3
Control
analysis of the effectiveness of DR in imparting AS on the islanded
distribution-level micro grids. A variety of research have additionally
addressed the effectiveness of decentralized dynamic call for manage on
stabilization of grid frequency, especially at the transmission degree.
However, the above research gift the subsequent shortcomings:
They do not gift a popular framework for the evaluation of the
affects of DR on a popular energy machine version and load.
AGC model has not been considered inside the evaluation.
Only precise masses (which includes HVAC, EWHs and lighting
fixtures) had been considered in and specific energy structures without
generalization.
Communication postpone in critical DR, and size put off in
decentralized DR have not been considered.
Frequency regulation have no longer been studied. Only
underneath-frequency load shedding (UFLS) characterization has been
analyzed.
Unreal assumptions for the availability of DR always have been
made. Load-damping coefficient, which can enhance frequency
stabilization, has been disregarded.
Only sensitivity analysis of frequency-associated load damping
coefficient function without generalization and DR manage is offered.
In the closing 5 many years, traditional LFC models have been
revised and changed to consist of the special kinds of power flowers,
which include RE strength technology with real limitations, consisting
of ramp-up/down limits, in the conventional and de-regulated strength
market. These models are useful in small disturbance studies along

Page 4
Control
with small variations in load and technology, and in controller layout.
However, thus far inside the literature, the concept of manage in the
LFC model has simplest targeted on the technology side, and DR has
now not been covered in those research. In this thesis modifies the
general small-sign version of a energy gadget used in LFC research via
introducing a DR manipulate loop to the LFC version (referred to as
LFC-DR).
1.3 PROBLEM FORMULATION
In this thesis, to design the model as general as possible and to
include communication latency associated with DR between the load
aggregator companies (Lagcos) and the end-use customers devices. This
is an important parameter in the system dynamic performance of LFC-
DR. In this assumed the communication delay between the balancing
authority (BA) and the Lagcos to be the same as that between the BA
and generation companies (Gencos). In this thesis not considered these
delays in our study since the focus of this thesis is on the evaluation of
the DR loop in the LFC model. The proposed LFC-DR also gives an
opportunity to the system operator to choose the DR option or
spinning/non-spinning reserve, or a combination of the two, based on
the real-time market price. Furthermore, the LFC-DR model can be
used to estimate the actual value of the required responsive load
manipulation when the magnitude of the disturbance is unknown to
the system operator.
Another inspiration for this study is the importance of the
dynamic performance of a power system with DR to provide AS. Several
real cases of DR operation have revealed that extreme shedding of the
responsive loads in emergency DR could lead to unexpected power
oscillations, which complicate the sequential generation control]. The

Page 5
Control
LFC-DR model will help the operators to investigate the impact of DR on
the dynamic performance of the system prior to its usage and during
the automatic generation control (AGC) design process. The idea of DR
for AS used in this thesis, has been fully explored in and will not be
repeated here. In such a model, the Lagcos will work with the
customers and inform the utilities, e.g., independent system operators,
of the amount of DR available. An example of such a model is the PJM
electricity market.
1.4 OBJECTIVE OF THE THESIS
The objective of this thesis is to design the DR control loop in the
conventional LFC model (named as LFC-DR) for a single-area power
system. The model has the characteristics of best possible operation
through optimal power distribution among supplementary and DR
control. The consequence of DR communication delay in the controller
design is also measured. The simulations were performed in the
environment of MATLAB/SIMULINK.
1.5 ORGANIZATION OF THE THESIS
The report is organized as follows:

Chapter 1: In this Chapter, the concept of LFC, introduction and
importance are discussed.

Chapter 2: In this Chapter, concept of load frequency control,
different types of frequency control methods and its
significance are discussed.

Chapter 3: In this Chapter, the dynamics of the power system model
is analyzed and the model is explained.

Chapter 4: In this Chapter, the different types of load frequency
control are discussed.

Page 6
Control
Chapter 5: In this Chapter, the simulation results are analyzed by
simulating the proposed model in the environment of
MATLAB/SIMULINK.
Chapter 6: This Chapter gives conclusions and scope for further
work in the area of multi area concept.

Page 7
Control
CHAPTER 2
FREQUENCY CONTROL
2.1 INTRODUCTION
Due to the physics of the synchronous device, the electrical
frequency of the generator voltage and the mechanical rotational
velocity of the generator are in constant proportion to each other,
therefore, any version in frequency results in rotational velocity
deviation from the desired consistent state. Also, a synchronous
location in AC strength machine should have the identical frequency at
every node; i.e. All interconnected mills rotating at the same
(normalized) speed. A big frequency deviation may have unwanted
results on energy machine like unfavorable equipment, degrading load
overall performance, causing the transmission strains to be overloaded,
interfering with system safety schemes and finally, leading to an
unstable situation for the strength system. Thus, controlling frequency
is an essential venture for the electricity system operator. For keeping
the frequency of a electricity machine within a required range, the
generation and call for must be stored in stability. In spite of sizable
effort for forecasting electricity demand, making a completely correct
prediction is not possible. Second-to-2d and minute-to-minute
fluctuations are very hard to foresee, which can also result in a
distinction among load and dispatched era.
Any mismatch among intake and manufacturing, in reality, is a
trade inside the balance between carried out mechanical shaft power
and electrical power extracted at the synchronous generator terminals.

Page 8
Control
Based at the rotational Newtons law, traditional synchronous mills offer
counter response over a several seconds timeframe every time there's a
mismatch among mechanical supply and electrical demand. This form
of reaction of generators is referred to as inertial frequency reaction.
Therefore, any unexpected trade in load or generation is to start with
compensated via addition or extraction of kinetic energy from the
rotating inertia of all synchronous generators. Beyond this natural
reaction, three levels of controls are commonly used to attain the
preferred frequency manipulate, which are called primary, secondary
and tertiary frequency control. In the relaxation of this segment, those
3 control frequency mechanisms will be defined.
2.2 PRIMARY FREQUENCY CONTROL
A turbine top mover of a conventional generator is usually
prepared with an outside manage loop known as governor manage.
Governor manipulate machine regulates the rotation pace of the shaft
by using changing the deliver to the turbine and accordingly
manipulate frequency. This kind of manage is traditionally known as
primary frequency control. This type of control is designed to keep the
stableness of the energy system in contingency conditions like huge era
or load outages. The governor response is started out nearly right away,
although a governed generator typically desires a while to reap the
output level dictated through governor manipulate system. The gain of
the feedback loop within the number one frequency controller, that's
called speed stoop, is described as follows:
(2.1)

Page 9
Control
Where f0 is the nominal frequency and p0 is the generator ability.
In the alternative words, stoop is the percent exchange in frequency
which might motive the units output to alternate by a hundred% of its
ability. The governor lifeless-band, which is a region round everyday
frequency wherein the governor isn't always activated, is likewise a
completely important trouble in frequency manage. Dead-band changed
into really a herbal feature of the earliest governors because of their
bodily traits. Intentional lifeless-bands which might be commonly larger
than the bodily ones are used to lessen the governor interest in
everyday situations of electricity system.
2.3 SECONDARY FREQUENCY CONTROL
Inertial frequency reaction and number one frequency manage
are decentralized and best capable of restrict and forestall frequency
tours however now not properly desirable to carry the frequency lower
back to its goal price. Instead, secondary frequency control is a
centralized automated manipulate which is capable of restore the
frequency to its set point. Within the UCTE, secondary frequency
control is likewise called load-frequency manipulate (LFC), while the
term automatic generation manage (AGC) is desired in North America.
However, within the UCTE, the term AGC designates the mixture of
dispatching and secondary frequency manage. Maintaining frequency
and controlling the internet power interchanges with neighboring
manage areas at the scheduled values are important objectives of LFC.
For meeting those objectives, a manage error sign, called the area
control mistakes (ACE), is measured. ACE is a linear aggregate of

Page 10
Control
internet interchange and frequency deviations and includes a frequency
bias time period which requires every balancing region to increase era
when system frequency is low and decrease technology when frequency
is high. The bias is hooked up in MW/0.1 Hz and is based at the MW
length of the balancing area. After measuring and filtering the ACE, it's
far used as an enter for a controller which is mostly a proportional
necessary (PI) controller.
Based at the characteristics of manipulate location, the resulting
output signal is conditioned with the aid of limiters, delays and benefit
constants. Then based on the resulted manipulate sign and the
participation factors of all of the LFC player systems, the new set factors
are calculated and dispatched to the generators by using the automated
era manage (AGC) machine. This manage mechanism gives outstanding
frequency manipulate beneath normal situations however is just too
gradual to reply to primary contingencies when the device frequency
actions outdoor the governor dead-band, as proven in figure1. In the
context of energy markets, controlling the frequency by using the use of
the on-line generators, which can be prepared with AGC and take part
in LFC, is known as frequency law, that's a type of ancillary services.
2.4 TERTIARY FREQUENCY CONTROL
Tertiary frequency control refers to manual and automatic
modifications inside the dispatching and commitment of generating
devices. This manage is used to repair the number one and secondary
frequency control reserves, to manage congestions in the transmission
network, and to convey the frequency and the interchanges returned to
their goal cost when the secondary manage is unable to perform this
remaining assignment.

Page 11
Control
2.5 DEMAND RESPONSE
Historically, electricity has been generated from huge power
vegetation end transported to cease customers for call for. The
electricity device needs to be in balance 50 instances a 2d. To ensure
high carrier for the strength customer the primary attention has been
on a way to modify the era to an most suitable. For generation capacity
like hydro power or gasoline generators this regulation to stability the
energy waft is conceivable. Large thermal electricity plant life and
mainly nuclear plants are most excellent operated at complete energy.
The call for facet has been used for balancing the strength system with
exceptional forms of incentives in which Time-of-Use is the most
commonplace. For the strength system operators it's far more fee green
to pay the costumer for a modified demand than to adjust the thermal
strength vegetation. These varieties of Load Management, Demand side
Management or Time-of- Use tariffs are used on a every day basis all
around the global. In a few power systems there are problems with
adequacy. Either because of the electricity device does now not have
sufficient power supply capacity to stability the call for or due to the
fact the grid has restrained capability. To avoid Black Outs (now not
planned energy failure) or Brown Outs (planned load dropping) many
utilities have used different kind of demand discount to help balancing
the system.
The future tendencies are that electricity will be generated from a
number of 1-10 MW sized units rather than 500-1,000 MW massive
electricity flowers. Many small decentralized devices like non-public
solar (PV) units of 10 kW, small residential wind turbines of 25 kW or
micro-CHP of few kW capacities can be a developing a part of the
strength systems capability. These many small technology sources are

Page 12
Control
renewable inside the sense that they're capable of gain electricity from
wind, sun, ocean or geothermal. The predictability of a 1,000 MW
nuclear strength plant is being substituted with 500 wind turbines in
an offshore farm relying at the changing climate in the subsequent
hours.
The grid of the power machine can be instable because of the
truth that most of the brand new styles of generation are based totally
on inverter era (DC/AC) and no longer classic synchronous generators.
The energy system will need ancillary offerings like inertia, brief-circuit
power, voltage manipulate and frequency manage to ensure a strong
device with a high electricity nice.
Since the electricity machine historically has been designed
to transport electricity from huge strength plants related at the HV
degree all the way down to cease consumers at LV level, it's miles a
developing venture if the future power era comes from many thousand
distributed strength resources (DER) placed within the LV grid. There
may be multiple cases of congestion within the LV grid. Electricity is
being traded at a strength trade. Supply and demand need to meet at
the least each hour. Owners of thermal electricity flowers or wind
turbines have exclusive market strategies. Thermal energy plant life
need a market fee to cover the marginal charges of the operation. Wind
generators have a marginal cost close to zero and proprietors would like
to trade every MWh while the wind is predicted to blow the following 24
hours. Outside the market there are one of a kind and frequently
exceptionally complicated subsidy schemes for special kinds of strength
era that also have a secondary effect on the market. The marketplace
will become increasingly more unstable. Volatility isn't always a bad
factor. Many marketplaces reflect the ever converting deliver and

Page 13
Control
demand conditions in the fee. However, power is a rare commodity with
little potential for storing as a minimum without sizeable losses.
Demand Response must be seen inside the change of paradigm
for the power system. Demand Response is certainly one of many gear
to be included in the present and future improvement of the coherent
power system.
2.6 SUMMARY
In this Chapter, the concept of load frequency control, different
types of the control methods and the demand response are presented.
CHAPTER 3
Page 14
Control
INTERCONNECTED POWER SYSTEM
3.1 INTRODUCTION
A comprehensive advent to the dynamic fashions of general
electricity systems can be located in. In this chapter, the modeling of a
standard power generating system, together with the modeling of 3
kinds of generating devices, the tie-line modeling and the modeling of
parallel operation of interconnected regions will be delivered.
In the ultimate three a long time, one-of-a-kind tender computing
techniques have evolved and efficaciously applied to exceptional
complex optimization hassle. Power device optimization isn't any
exception to this trend. Soft computing strategies that are efficiently
used to clear up load frequency control problem include Genetic
Algorithm (GA), Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO), Bacterial Foraging
Algorithm (BFA) and Differential Evolution (DE). In order to remedy the
optimization trouble greater effectively unique synthetic intelligence
strategies are blended in hybrid manner. For example a Fuzzy logic

manipulate scheme in aggregate with other optimization method is very
useful to make sure the robustness of the machine.
3.2 POWER GENERATING UNITS
3.2.1 Turbines
A turbine unit in power structures is used to convert the natural
electricity, which include the electricity from steam or water, into
mechanical electricity (Pm) this is supplied to the generator. In LFC
model, there are three sorts of normally used mills: non-reheat, reheat
and hydraulic turbines, all of which may be modeled by using transfer

Page 15
Control
functions. Non-reheat turbines are first-order devices. A time put off
(denoted by Tch) happens among switching the valve and producing the
turbine torque. The switch feature may be of the non-reheat turbine is
represented as
(3.1)
Where PV is the valve/gate position change
Reheat turbines are modeled as 2nd-order units, when you consider
that they have distinctive tiers because of excessive and low steam
pressure. The switch characteristic can be represented as
(3.2)
Where Trh stands for the low pressure reheat time and Fhp
represents the high pressure stage rating [2].
Hydraulic generators are non-minimal section systems due to the
water inertia. In the hydraulic turbine, the water stress response is
contrary to the gate role exchange at the beginning and recovers after
the temporary reaction. Thus the switch function of the hydraulic
turbine is inside the shape of
(3.3)
Where Tw is the water starting time

Page 16
Control
For balance subject, a transient hunch reimbursement element
inside the governor is needed for the hydraulic turbine. The switch
feature of the transient hunch compensation part is given by means of
(3.4)
Where TR, RT and R represent the reset time, temporary droop and
permanent droop respectively:
3.2.2 Generators
A generator unit in strength systems converts the mechanical
strength acquired from the turbine into electric electricity. But for LFC,
we awareness at the rotor pace output (frequency of the power
structures) of the generator in place of the strength transformation.
Since electric strength is difficult to store in massive amounts, the
stability needs to be maintained among the generated energy and the
weight demand. Once a load alternate occurs, the mechanical energy
dispatched from the turbine will now not healthy the electric energy
generated through the generator. This blunders among the mechanical
(Pm) and electric powers (Pel) is integrated into the rotor velocity
deviation (r), which may be changed into the frequency bias (f) by
means of multiplying by using 2. The courting among Pm and f is
proven in Fig.3.1, wherein M is the inertia constant of the generator.

Page 17
Control
Fig.3.1: Block diagram of the generator
The electricity loads may be decomposed into resistive masses
(PL), which remain regular while the rotor speed is converting, and
motor hundreds that trade with load pace. If the mechanical power
stays unchanged, the motor loads will compensate the load exchange at
a rotor speed that is extraordinary from a scheduled price, that's shown
in Fig.3.2, wherein D is the load damping steady.

Page 18
Control
Fig.3.2: Block diagram of the generator with load damping effect
The reduced form of Fig.3.2 is shown in Fig.3.3, that is the
generator model that we plan to apply for the LFC layout. The Laplace-
remodel illustration of the block diagram in Fig.Three.3 is
(3.5)
Fig.3.3: Reduced block diagram of the generator with the load damping
effect
3.2.3 Governors
Governors are the devices which are used in energy structures to
sense the frequency bias resulting from the weight exchange and cancel
it via various the inputs of the turbines. The schematic diagram of a
velocity governing unit is proven in Fig.3.4, in which R is the speed law
characteristic and Tg is the time constant of the governor. If without

Page 19
Control
load reference, while the load change occurs, a part of the trade may be
compensated through the valve/gate adjustment at the same time as
the relaxation of the trade is represented in the shape of frequency
deviation. The aim of LFC is to modify frequency deviation in the
presence of varying lively power load. Thus, the load reference set point
can be used to modify the valve/gate positions so that all the weight
exchange is canceled by using the energy generation rather than
resulting in a frequency deviation.
Fig.3.4: Schematic diagram of a speed governing unit
The reduced form of Fig.3.4 is shown in Fig.3.5. The Laplace transform
representation of the block diagram in Fig.3.5 is given by

Page 20
Control
(3.6)
Fig.3.5: Reduced block diagram of the speed governing unit
3.3 THE INTERCONNECTED POWER SYSTEMS
3.3.1 Tie-lines
In an interconnected electricity system, one-of-a-kind regions are
related with each other via tie-lines. When the frequencies in regions
are different, a strength exchange happens via the tie-line that linked
the 2 regions. The tie-line connections can be modeled as proven in
Fig.3.6. The Laplace rework illustration of the block diagram in Fig.3.6
is given by way of
(3.7)
Where Ptieij is tie-line exchange electricity among regions i and
j, and Tij is the tie-line synchronizing torque coefficient between place i
and j. From Fig.3.6, we are able to see that the tie-line energy errors is
the crucial of the frequency difference among the two regions:

Page 21
Control
Fig.3.6: Block diagram of the tie-lines
3.3.2 Area control error
The dreams of LFC are not simplest to cancel frequency errors in
each region, but additionally to drive the tie-line power change
consistent with time table. Since the tie-line electricity mistakes is the
essential of the frequency distinction between each pair of regions, if we
control frequency errors lower back to zero, any regular state errors in
the frequency of the system might result in tie-line electricity mistakes.
In the ultimate 3 many years, one-of-a-kind tender computing
techniques have advanced and correctly applied to different complicated
optimization problem. Power system optimization is not any exception to
this trend. Soft computing strategies that are effectively used to remedy
load frequency manipulate trouble include Genetic Algorithm (GA),
Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO), Bacterial Foraging Algorithm (BFA)
and Differential Evolution (DE). In order to clear up the optimization
problem extra correctly special synthetic intelligence strategies are
mixed in hybrid way. For instance a Fuzzy good judgment manipulate

Page 22
Control
scheme in mixture with different optimization approach could be very
useful to make certain the robustness of the system.
Therefore we need to consist of the data of the tie-line power
deviation into our manipulate enter. As a result, an area control
mistakes (ACE) is described as
(3.8)
Where Bi is the frequency response characteristic for area i [1] and
(3.9)
This ACE signal is used as the plant output of each energy
producing region. Driving ACEs in all regions to zeros will result in
zeros for all frequency and tie-line power mistakes in the machine.
3.3.3 Parallel operation
If there is several power producing devices working in parallel inside
the same place, an equal generator will be developed for simplicity. The
equal generator inertia consistent (Meq), load damping consistent (Deq)
and frequency reaction characteristic (Beq) can be represented as follows.
(3.10)
(3.11)
(3.12)

Page 23
Control
3.4 DYNAMIC MODEL OF ONE-AREA POWER
GENERATING UNITS
With the power producing systems and the tie-line connections of
interconnected regions added in Sections 2 and 3, a entire form of 1-
region strength producing unit may be built as Fig.3.7.
Fig.3.7: Schematic of one-area power generating unit
In Fig.3.8, there are 3 inputs, which can be the controller input
U(s), load disturbance PL(s), and tie-line power error Ptie(s), one ACE

Page 24
Control
output Y(s) and one generator output f. The time period Pe is not in
Fig.3.4 as it does not have a bodily meaning. We notice the input of the
equal unit in the governor as Pe for simplicity when developing the
Laplace rework of the one-region power producing plant
In the past a long time, unique soft computing strategies have
evolved and successfully applied to distinct complex optimization
trouble. Power system optimization is no exception to this trend. Soft
computing strategies which might be successfully used to solve load
frequency manipulate problem consist of Genetic Algorithm (GA),
and Differential Evolution (DE). In order to clear up the optimization
problem greater successfully unique artificial intelligence strategies are
mixed in hybrid way. For instance a Fuzzy good judgment manage
scheme in mixture with other optimization method may be very
beneficial to ensure the robustness of the system.
3.5 SUMMARY
The modeling of each part in the power generating unit is
discussed in this Chapter, followed by the Laplace transform
development of the decentralized power generating area. This chapter
has laid the groundwork for both the controller design and the
constructions of the power test systems.

Page 25
Control
CHAPTER 4
LOAD FREQUENCY CONTROL TECHNIQUES
4.1 INTRODUCTION
Load frequency control is one of the most densely researched
topics in strength system engineering. In truth no longer simplest load
frequency manipulate however the whole idea of computerized
technology manage has drawn attention of strength system researchers.
The strategy to the problem of load frequency manage has superior over
the years. Various researchers have proposed diverse strategies to cope
with the problem of load frequency manipulate in electricity system. In

Page 26
Control
order to track the improvement in LFC till nowadays, on this
bankruptcy specific methods toward LFC are briefed. Due to numerous
nature of strategies LFC techniques may be labeled into exclusive
groups. In this Chapter LFC strategies are classified as follows:
Load frequency manipulate based totally on distinct strategies.
Load frequency manipulate with AC DC parallel tie line.
Consideration of conversation delay in LFC
Load frequency manipulate of conventional resources included
with dispensed electricity resources.
LFC of hybrid electricity system included with renewable energy
assets.
Application of different getting to know techniques in LFC.
Application of strength electronics devices in LFC.
4.2 LOAD FREQUENCY CONTROL BASED ON
DIFFERENT TECHNIQUES
In this class, specific techniques used for implementation of LFC
are discussed. The number one consciousness remains on the manage
techniques of parameters, which might be usually the profits of
controllers generally used in forward direction in which location
manage errors is the input to the controller. In some instances governor
velocity regulation (R) and frequency bias () are also needed to be
optimized. Depending at the one of a kind control scheme this
organization is in addition subdivided into following subgroups:

Page 27
Control
LFC with specific optimization Techniques
LFC With Different Feedback Theory
LFC with Application Of Observers
LFC Using Internal Model Control
4.2.1 Load Frequency Control with Different Optimization

Techniques
In the last 3 many years, different tender computing strategies
have developed and efficaciously implemented to one of a kind complex
optimization trouble. Power system optimization is not any exception to
this fashion. Soft computing strategies that are effectively used to solve
load frequency control problem consist of Genetic Algorithm (GA),
and Differential Evolution (DE). In order to remedy the optimization
problem extra successfully specific artificial intelligence techniques are
combined in hybrid manner. For instance a Fuzzy common sense
manage scheme in mixture with other optimization method may be very
useful to make certain the robustness of the system.
4.2.1.1 Implementation of Genetic Algorithm in LFC
Genetic algorithm has been used effectively as an optimization
tool in tuning the gain parameters in LFC hassle. It was found that GA
based optimization method gives better brief performance than
traditional Matrix Riccati based surest manage implemented on
energy frequency manipulate. Further improvement of the device
performance changed into completed the usage of hybrid genetic
algorithm simulated annealing (GA - SA) techniques to optimize PID
gains. The result found out that GA SA method is advanced to GA
method for both off nominal and foremost PID profits. Transient
Page 28
Control
reaction changed into determined through speedy acting Sugeno fuzzy
good judgment method. But these were now not sturdy techniques.
Two decentralized sturdy load frequency manage design methodologies
were proposed by means of [6]. The first control layout turned into
based totally on H manipulate strategy based totally on Linear Matrix
Inequalities (LMI) techniques even as the second changed into primarily
based on GA tuned PI controller. The 2nd method is called GALMI
method because it coordinates Gas with the LMI manage toolbox
optimization so one can reap gain parameters of a conventional
controller this is subjected to H constraints. Result revealed that
robustness of overall performance of GALMI is almost identical as that
of the robust H controllers. But those had been no longer hybrid
strategies and suffered purposeful hazards. Hybrid fuzzy proportional
essential (FPI) controller become also efficaciously implemented in top-
quality load frequency manage. To improve the performance of FPI
controller hybrid GA PSO optimization technique become used. PSO
provided the populace for GAs, which have been further used as
parents in crossover and mutation operation. For this pass bid
strategies ideal outcomes were found over traditional GA based totally
method. Combinations of conventional manage technique with GA have
been extensively utilized to look at the performances of various
Automatic Generation Control (AGC) schemes. A conventional AGC
system using recursive least square set of rules for acquiring the system
parameters in real time was also attempted. The proposed set of rules
correctly tracked parameters which have outcomes on LFC dynamics in
various operating circumstance. An optimum advantage scheduling of
LFC had been attempted the use of Genetic Algorithm (GA). To make
this device suitable for time various and non-linear device circumstance

Page 29
Control
the Fuzzy Inference System (FIS) changed into also carried out and time
discrete results have been obtained.
The progressed LMI based totally balance criterion and Lyapunov
theory were used to advise a stability criterion to acquire decreased
computational time and improved calculation accuracy. The interaction
among the postpone margins and manipulate gains have been also
investigated.
A continuous discrete mode AGC framework for interconnected
hydrothermal electricity system is proposed someplace else. The
controller profits are optimized using Fmin search a MATLAB feature.
With speedy increase in strength call for use of isolated strength
machine has grow to be obsolete. Instead electricity system designers
now an afternoon decide on interconnected power structures due to
their excessive reliability. Another vital phenomenon that has won
momentum in ultimate two a long time is the integration of renewable
power like solar and wind strength to the electrical grid. However, it's
far very hard to exactly quantify the energy available from non-
conventional sources as they rely upon unsure elements like solar
irradiation, wind velocity and so on. Hence, in a renewable electricity
incorporated electric grid, energy garage systems are used to offer
backup electricity. Such a place load frequency manage with battery
electricity storage system is studied the usage of GA tuned PI controller.
4.2.1.2 Use of Differential Evolution Technique in LFC
Differential evolution is one of the maximum powerful
evolutionary algorithms which have been used substantially in various
fields of engineering optimization. Various researches works wherein
differential evolution is efficaciously implemented in load frequency

Page 30
Control
controller furnished exciting consequences. A DE based parallel two
degree of freedom PID controller for LFC is proposed in. Along with the
traditional goal function ITAE and ISE, a changed objective function
primarily based on integral time multiply absolute errors was
formulated and minimized. The damping ratio, settling time and peak
overshoots with proper weight coefficients is derived to boom the
performance of the proposed controller.
In the ultimate 3 many years, specific tender computing
strategies have evolved and successfully applied to special complex
optimization trouble. Power device optimization is no exception to this
fashion. Soft computing strategies which can be efficaciously used to
resolve load frequency control trouble consist of Genetic Algorithm (GA),
and Differential Evolution (DE). In order to resolve the optimization
hassle greater successfully specific synthetic intelligence strategies are
blended in hybrid manner. For instance a Fuzzy good judgment
manipulate scheme in combination with different optimization
technique could be very useful to make certain the robustness of the
system.
A DE based AGC for interconnected strength machine is offered
in. The salient characteristic of that study changed into that, it used
three one-of-a-kind objective features, crucial time multiply absolute
error, damping ratio due to the Eigen values and the settling time. A
comparative examine became made between the proposed choicest
controller with bacterial foraging optimization and genetic set of rules
based optimized controller.
The version of parameter settings has enormous impact on
performance of most of the soft computing strategies. Such an attempt

Page 31
Control
turned into exercised to tune the parameters of DE based totally LFC.
Variation of mutation thing and crossover ratio of DE to set the
controller gains become tried on this trouble. Initially, in a single region
system the overall performance turned into investigated, accompanied
by its utility in a multi area machine. In the later case of research
HVDC hyperlink is connected in parallel with AC tie line. Lastly, the
overall performance of such optimized controller changed into as
compared with the performance of remarks controller, which exhibited
the superiority of DE based optimized controller over the traditional
controller.
4.2.1.3 Bacterial Foraging based Optimization in LFC
Bacterial foraging is another current meta-heuristic method that
is used to find international minimal of complicated optimization
problem. To obtain optimized values of controller gains of load
frequency manage problem BFO technique was followed in numerous
works. Optimization of the governor pace law parameter (Ri) and
frequency bias parameter (Bi) at the side of indispensable controller
profits turned into accomplished the usage of BFO, GA and classical
optimization strategies. A comparative study between these optimization
techniques discovered the prevalence of BFO technique over the
opposite techniques related to this paintings. Similar approach of using
bacterial foraging optimization algorithm to song controller benefit was
additionally provided. In this paintings additionally the superiority of
proposed controller over conventional region controller and GA
optimized controller changed into determined. Saikia et al. Offered a
comparative study of different styles of conventional controller
proportional (P), vital (I), integral spinoff (ID), proportional
indispensable derivative (PID), imperative double derivative (IDD)

Page 32
Control
in. Bacterial foraging optimization (BFO) was the optimization method
used to optimize the gains of various sorts of controller one at a time.
These controllers are used to observe the load frequency hassle having
conventional mechanical governor and electric governor of hydro
system. The outcomes received proved the prevalence of modern-day
electric governor over traditional one. Apart from the conventional
controllers, a non integer type fractional order controller become used
for multi place automated technology manipulate with generation fee
constraints. BFO approach was implemented to optimize the fee of order
of integrator and differentiator in that case. BFO based totally PID gains
and governor pace law parameter (R) have been used to make evaluation
between specific varieties of integer order controller.
4.2.1.4 Particle Swarm induced Optimization in LFC
Particle swarm optimization is every other broadly used
optimization approach that is based totally at the idea of swarm
intelligence. Studies on LFCapplying PSO isn't sparse. Stochastic
particle swarm optimization based totally LFC turned into provided in a
take a look at which evaluates Eigen cost primarily based performance
index. This index become then used to optimize the controller profits
but no Tie line strength dynamics were reported. HVDC tie line that's
related in parallel with an AC tie line to get an most appropriate LFC
has been studied in PSO based totally PID controller. The result found
out that the proposed PID gains gave higher dynamic reaction with
small frequency deviation and tie line electricity deviation. The
frequency and tie line powers have been settled down fast if so. Sliding
mode fuzzy logic controller changed into also used to optimize LFC [20]
hassle. To enhance the performance of fuzzy controller, PSO

Page 33
Control
optimization technique changed into used to alter the club feature of
fuzzy device as it should be. Such a combination showed interesting
effects. Another similar technique changed into exercised in LFC using
scaled fuzzy controller. PSO optimization turned into used to song the
fuzzy controller input and output gains. Hence it's miles observed that
the a hit application of PSO in LFC turned into recommended and it
installed its significance to clear up the load frequency troubles.
4.2.1.5 Implementation of Other Optimization Techniques in LFC
The non linear dynamics of chaos had drawn attentions as a
heuristic optimization approach. This is referred as chaotic
optimization. The lozi map based totally chaotic algorithm optimization
approach became used for PID controller benefit optimization. The
performance of the proposed controller turned into studied and
comparisons had been finished with GA PID, pattern search PID and
simulated annealing PID (SA - PID) primarily based controllers. Lenoir
proposed an AGC consisting of energetic electricity float issues. AGC
PF strategies turned into found to be very useful for keeping frequency
within limit. It become also appropriate to restriction the overflow of
energetic strength. Hence, the proposed method changed into used to
reschedule the real energy generation. A fuzzy rule based totally system
became shaped to select the best controllers, their actions and step
size. A decentralized radial foundation functional neural community
(RBFNN) changed into proposed for LFC of three location interconnected
electricity machine underneath deregulation. The H2/H manner
turned into used to tune the proposed controller. The connections many
of the manage areas in rest of the system and the effects of possible
gotten smaller scenarios had been dealt with as disturbance indicators
and fed to the input.

Page 34
Control
Another best load frequency manage trouble in restructured
environment become additionally attempted the usage of differential
algebraic equation systems (DAEs). A quasi- Newton set of rules
changed into used to optimize the formulated DAE system.
4.2.2 Load Frequency Control with Different Feedback Theory
Development is a by no means finishing method. Application of
different development on feedback principle on LFC is also suggested.
In fact specific feedback theories had been used as controlling tools in
those LFC research. A strong decentralized LFC in deregulated
environment is supplied in. The LFC trouble become solved as a multi
objective manipulate problem using H2/H manage method. A sturdy
controller was designed via lowering the LFC hassle in static output
feedback manipulate.
Rakhshani et al. Designed a linear quadratic regulator for load
frequency control in a deregulated environment in. The proposed
highest quality output remarks regulator overcame the need of
measuring all the country variables of the system. In the proposed
design most effective the measurable nation variables within every
manipulate vicinity were required to use for feedback. Comparison of
the performance of the proposed regulator with the performance of
complete country comments and state observer strategies had
additionally been finished.
The advanced LMI based totally balance criterion and Lyapunov
principle were used to advocate a balance criterion to gain decreased
computational time and extended calculation accuracy. The interplay
among the put off margins and manage profits were additionally
investigated.

Page 35
Control
Role of novel robust decentralized controller were proven to solve
the load frequency manage (LFC) problem in a restructured strength
system. Quantitative remarks theory (QFT) became used here to
assemble the proposed controller. The main feature of this changed
dynamic model of LFC turned into that during specific shrunk
eventualities, the results of the possible contracts behaved as a set of
new input sign. Comparative have a look at between the QFT based
proposed controllers and the traditional controller proved the
prevalence of the primary one. It were proved that for a huge version in
machine parameters proposed QFT based totally controller is superior.
Proportional vital (PI) country comments controller to solve the weight
frequency hassle. This examine become aimed to find the right governor
velocity regulation parameter (R) and participation factor in AGC for
each generator. The look at changed into achieved at the device which
includes hydro, thermal and gasoline producing systems.
The advanced LMI primarily based stability criterion and
Lyapunov idea have been used to advocate a stability criterion to
achieve reduced computational time and accelerated calculation
accuracy. The interplay among the put off margins and manage profits
had been additionally investigated.
4.2.3 Load Frequency Control Using Observer
Load frequency control video display units a whole lot of aspect of
electricity system which are immediately or circuitously associated with
LFC. Hence observer takes a essential location in LFC because it
observes minute to minute circumstance of every issue that guarantees
frequency deviation remains within the prescribed restriction. The
blessings of observer idea have been correctly used to remedy load
frequency control issues.

Page 36
Control
Rakhshani et al constructed a reduced order observer controller to get
rid of the trouble of measuring and monitoring all of the state variables
at all time. This proposed scheme changed into found effective when the
machine runs with lesser numbers of sensors than numbers of states.
With the help of reduced order observer multi location LFC hassle
became solved with improved dynamic responses in deregulated
environment. LFC of a two region strength machine the usage of a
international proportional necessary (PI) state remarks controller
based on quasi decentralized purposeful observers (QDFOs) concept
became presented in any other paintings. Unlike traditional observers
which had been used as a centralized one for all areas in LFC, a low
order observer become used for every location. Though they may be
completely decoupled from each different a few outputs have been
shared among them to get a international manage. The overall
complexity of the system changed into decreased by way of the use of
the proposed technique.
Moreover, a decentralized sliding mode manipulate scheme changed
into also used to resolve LFC hassle of three place interconnected
energy device. The strong controller changed into based totally on
attaining regulation technique to attain higher overall performance and
to make frequency deviation zero after any load variant or any device
version.
4.2.4 Use of Internal Model Control in Load Frequency Control

Page 37
Control
Internal model control is some other manage approach which
presents a brand new technique for solving load frequency control
problem. The primary concept of this control approach is just like that
of observers. This manipulate scheme is employed in LFC to lessen the
complexity of the hassle. Recent developments closer to restructuring of
electricity system and interconnected system makes the load frequency
control extra complicated. As the vicinity increases order of the system
also will increase which in flip will increase device complexity. Hence
inner model manage (IMC) scheme is applied in LFC to lessen the order
of the device. Internal version control (IMC) changed into efficiently
implemented in AGC. Successful utility of IMC based totally on
degree of freedom idea in load frequency hassle is presented in wherein
2nd order plus useless time (SOPDT) is used as opposed to complete
order system. In a version predictive manipulate scheme for LFC, focus
turned into on neural community model predictive controller. The
performance of the proposed controller turned into investigated over a
huge range of machine parameters. Another version predictive
manipulate (MPC) scheme for AGC changed into used for a massive
manipulate location. Each sub place consists of its personal MPC
controller.
4.2.5 Hierarchical Load Frequency Control
In a hierarchical tier shape of AGC, the primary manipulate
degree foremost manage of each region changed into obtained after
incorporating local statistics at the side of the others coming from the
alternative regions. In the second control stage a worldwide answer
based on coordination strategy and a strong controller became
obtained. A look at on hierarchy based totally Spanish AGC structure
studied the impact of the nonlinear filter at the frequency deviation
harmonics below 2 mHz. Another hierarchical AGC shape became

Page 38
Control
proposed by Marinovici et al. A decentralized robust controller become
proposed for primary frequency manage. It helped to damp out
oscillations in frequency and tie line strength fluctuations as a result
of disturbance in massive scale energy machine.
A one of a kind sort of take a look at on the facts integrity assault
on AGC and energy operation market became suggested. This control
set of rules changed into capable for the assault detection and
mitigation which in flip eliminates low fake ramp assaults. The
proposed mitigation based set of rules also efficaciously maintained
frequency in the limit at the time of assault. A work related to
pluralistic load frequency control scheme labored on extraordinary
control regions: real control location (RCA) and a digital manage
location (VCA). If AGC and LFC adjust a particular manage region to
maintain frequency and tie line energy at respective set values, then
the region is referred as RCA. According to control necessities, the
regulator continuously exploits its power regulating reserves in case of
RCA. But when the strength drift via the grid violates its restrict, the
regulator of a place is adjusted. In this example, the place is referred as
VCA. Simulations based on each pluralistic and hierarchical control
scheme for AGC became done for 3 region control in restructure
environment.
4.3 LOAD FREQUENCY CONTROL WITH AC DC
PARALLEL TIE LINE
Use of HVDC device makes it possible to transmit bulk amount if
strength via lengthy distance without big energy loss. The use of HVDC
device no longer best proved superior in transmission sector, the
software of dc hyperlink at the side of ac hyperlink in parallel is proved

Page 39
Control
to be a great choice to cope with load frequency hassle. Though the
HVDC link related in parallel with AC line treated in a different way, the
goal is identical this is to take part in frequency restoration within
prescribed time restriction.
HVDC link had been used to improve LFC scheme in and three location
system. The research discovered the effectiveness of the HVDC
transmission hyperlink to enhance frequency fluctuation in
interconnected power system. The HVDC link become used as a
comments system of machine nation variables. Here, the HVDC system
turned into dealt with as a lower back to returned (BTB) controller of
instantaneous power flow to restore the consistent kingdom frequency.
Since the energy is exchanged through AC tie HVDC hyperlink become
observed not to be plenty beneficial for interconnected device. But it
become located effective when remoted systems have been related thru
HVDC hyperlink. Another version together with wind turbine generator
delivered electricity via HVDC link which turned into managed thru line
commutated converter. Load frequency control was completed in this
paintings thru sensing of the grid frequency the usage of rectifier. When
the grid frequency changed then rectifier sensed it and lively electricity
transport thru HVDC hyperlink was changed. Wind electricity become
additionally changed the use of pitch controller. It modified the blade
angle of wind turbine and consequently the trade of HVDC shipping.
The dynamic performance evaluation of a multi place thermal system in
a deregulated environment
With the usage of HVDC hyperlink in parallel with AC link became also
completed efficiently. The overall performance of LFC with out HVDC
turned into determined higher than that of the AGC with HVDC.
Another technique for LFC with HVDC link used the centre of inertia

Page 40
Control
(COI) signals. In this proposed method COI frequency of each vicinity
had been tracked to attain a device COI frequency. That work turned
into finished to offer emergency energy assist to the reserve negative
areas from the reserve rich regions through COI sign based HVDC
modulations.
4.4 CONSIDERATION OF COMMUNICATION DELAY IN
LFC
In restructured power system, the competitive open get admission to strategy makes the
weight frequency problem greater complicated and its overall performance worse. To
triumph over this undesirable state of affairs open verbal exchange infrastructure is needed.
Unlike the traditional closed conversation community, time delays are not constant for the
brand new open communication network. Hence, computerized technology manipulate
achieves extra perfection with the attention of communication time put off. Automatic era
controls with delays also are supplied. Again some studies are done through thinking about a
restrict of postpone in which some are without any margin. Hence LFC look at on this
organization is further subdivided as follows:
Communication delay without a margin.
Communication delay with margin
4.4.1 Communication Delay with No Margin
The load frequency control hassle with communication put off
components changed into simulated using linear matrix inequalities
(LMI) technique. That version used a unmarried delay unit in place of
all current delays from the control centre. Open and disbursed
conversation networks had been used to switch records in LFC. The
manage offerings were supplied by the 0.33 birthday party individuals
and integrating machine operator (ISO).

Page 41
Control
The stepped forward LMI primarily based stability criterion and
Lyapunov concept have been used to recommend a stability criterion to
acquire decreased computational time and accelerated calculation
accuracy. The interaction among the delay margins and manage profits
had been additionally investigated.
Another work on PI based totally load frequency manage trouble with
communication put off used iterative linear matrix inequalities (ILMI)
set of rules based on H2/H manage approach [50]. In this paintings
proportional integral (PI) based load frequency manage changed into
decreased to a static output remarks primarily based control scheme.
Authors validated the efficiency of the proposed scheme with the aid of
doing a little actual time non linear laboratory exams on the analog
strength device modeled on the Research Laboratory of Kyushu Electric
strength agency.
4.4.2 Communication Delay with Margin
Due to the use of open communique get right of entry to research
on LFC with time various put off turns into necessary. The take a look
at on LFC with steady and time varying delays are presented. Delay
dependent stability of LFC scheme the usage of Lyaponuv principle
and linear matrix inequalities (LMIs) technique set the controller gains.
These profits were tuned to acquire a compromise between dynamic
overall performance and the postpone margin. Case research had been
completed both for unmarried and multi region manage thinking about
regular and time varying delays. Finally a change-off between the
dynamic performance of the LFC and postpone margin become done.
Zhang et al. Proposed a sturdy technique to reap a PID based LFC
scheme with conversation delays. The approach of indexing sturdy
performance index (RPI) by way of the use of the effect of the

Page 42
Control
disturbance on the controller output of the closed loop device made this
paper one-of-a-kind. RPI became used to find out the robustness of the
system below the presence of different delays and expected put off
margin. From the end result it become visible that received PID type
controller offers extra delay margin. The improved cone complementary
linearization (ICCL) algorithm along with LMI approach was
implemented. This work became extended for multi area load frequency
manage in deregulated surroundings considering postpone. It used
postpone margins as a new overall performance index to guide the
tuning of the controller.
The stepped forward LMI based totally stability criterion and Lyapunov
theory had been used to advise a stability criterion to gain reduced
computational time and improved calculation accuracy. The interplay
among the put off margins and control gains were additionally
investigated.
4.5 APPLICATION OF POWER ELECTRONICS
DEVICES IN LFC
TCPS and SMES are referred as thyristors managed segment
shifter and superconducting magnetic energy storage machine
respectively. The utility of SMES and TCPS in the area of LFC is
provided. Tripathy et al. First included the concept of superconducting
magnetic electricity storage with automatic era manipulate in power
machine. In this observe self tuning adaptive control strategy were
hired to show the progressed performance for load adjustments of
random significance and duration the usage of SMES. Again a take a
look at on discrete kingdom area model of two area interconnected
strength system with reheat steam turbine, governor lifeless band and

Page 43
Control
superconducting magnetic electricity garage changed into finished. The
advantage of the usage of an IGBT converter rather than thyristor
converter was determined here. LFC of interconnected power device
with the software of TCPS and SMES became also achieved in some
other work. A supplementary controller with fuzzy gain agenda changed
into used to enhance the performance of the proposed machine. A
comparative study among SMES SMES, TCPS SMES, SSSC TCPS
on LFC became offered with the aid of Bhattetal. A seriously disturbed
system become used to stabilize the device by way of using the dynamic
electricity drift manipulate capability of static synchronous collection
compensator (SSSC) or TCPS with SMES. Gains of controller
parameters and parameters of SMES, TCPS and SSSC had been
optimized using craziness primarily based PSO (CRPSO). The
comparative examine between the performances of CRPSO and actual
coded GA proved the superiority of first one.
Introduction of the concept to use of FACTS devices to improve
the load frequency traits in a deregulated electric powered energy
system changed into elaborated in so many articles. In these articles,
total examinations had been done by means of decomposing a multi
vicinity energy machine into two decoupled subsystems. This illustrates
an utility of overlapping decomposition approach.
4.6 SUMMARY
In this Chapter, it is observed that several researchers have
contributed in various manners in load frequency control. Also there
are several of works in LFC involving renewable sources. But few of
them consider restructuring of power system. Hence, the present work
focuses on LFC in single area power system. Cultural algorithm is one
of the new entries in soft computing techniques and is hardly utilized

Page 44
Control
for optimizing controller gains of LFC. Particle swarm optimization is
opted as first optimization technique, followed by cultural algorithm. At
the end a comparative study related to the chosen problem is made.
CHAPTER 5
SIMULATION RESULTS
5.1 INTRODUCTION
In order to show some important features of the proposed LFC-
DR model, the results of several different simulation studies are

reported in this Chapter for a single-area power system. In order to
make a fair comparison, similar LQR design procedure has been
employed for controller design for both systems, with and without DR.
In order to validate the proposed topology, simulation is carried out
using the Matlab/Simulink.
5.2 PROPOSED TOPOLOGY
The block diagram for single-area power system with a simplified
non-reheat steam turbine is shown in Fig. 5.1, where the feedback loop
for DR is also shown. Tg and Tt are the equivalent speed-governor and
turbine time constants, respectively, R is the equivalent droop value,
and is the equivalent DR delay. The parameters of the system can be
the equivalent of all generation assets and load damping of the same
area. This model is selected to convey the main idea of this thesis.
Unlike the usual spinning reserve-provider power plants, there is no
ramp up and down limitations on the DR resources. In other words, the
power consumption status of controllable loads can be changed
instantaneously by the command signal they receive. Therefore, the

Page 45
Control
only obstacle for DR (disregarding the aggregation of small loads) is
communication delay, known as latency, which could affect the system
dynamic performance. The parameters used in the simulation studies
are given in Table 5.1.
Fig.5.1: Block-diagram representation of a single-area power system
model
Table 5.1: Power System Parameters for the Simulation Study [33]
Tg Tt R 2H D Td P K
0.0 0. 3.0H 0.16 0.015p 0. 0.0 0
8se 4s z/p. 67p .u./Hz 1s 1p. .

u
c ec u ec u. 2
sec

Page 46
Control
5.3 SIMULATION RESULT ANALYSIS
In the first simulation study, a 0.01p.u load disturbance was
applied to the single-area power system with conventional LFC and the
proposed LFC-DR model. The system frequency deviation is shown in
Fig. 5.2.
0.005
-0.005
Frequency deviation, Hz
LFC with Dr, alpha = 0.1

LFC with Dr, alpha = 0.8
Conventional LFC
-0.01
-0.015
-0.02
-0.025
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Time (s)
Fig. 5.2: Frequency deviation for conventional LFC and LFC-DR models
It can be seen that when (i.e., 10% of the required regulation is
provided by the supplementary control and 90% from DR), the LFC-DR
model has a superior performance over the conventional LFC during

Page 47
Control
the transient period. Specifically, the overshoot in the system frequency
deviation is decreased by about 42.5%. The results show improvement
in the settling time as well. The same simulation was repeated for
=0.8. As expected, the lower DR control effort resulted in less
improvement in the system dynamic performance. It can be observed
that the dynamic performance of the system approaches that of
conventional LFC for higher values of .
The supplementary and DR control inputs are shown in Fig.5.3,
for the same simulation. The steady-state values of the control inputs
are based on the share between the DR and the supplementary control
loops, i.e., the value of , which is decided by the regional ISO/RTO
based on the real-time electricity market. The steady-state value
calculations are also shown in Fig. 5.3.
-3
x 10
9
6 DR loop, alpha=0.1
SS=0.9x0.01=0.009 p.u
Control inputs, p.u
Supplementary, alpha=0.8
5 SS=0.8x0.01=0.008 p.u
4 DR loop, alpha=0.8
Supplementary, alpha=0.1 SS=0.2x0.01=0.002 p.u
3 SS=0.1x0.01=0.001 p.u
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Time (s)
Fig.5.3: Steady-state values of the control inputs for the LFC-DR model
A simulation study was carried out to show the impact of the
order of Pad approximation on the performance of the system, the
results of which are shown in Fig.5.4. 2 nd- and 5th-order Pad
approximations are considered in the proposed LFC-DR model and

Page 48
Control
compared with the conventional LFC, for =0.1. It can be seen from
Fig.5.4 that the results from the 2 nd- and 5th-order Pad approximation
are almost identical. It is mainly because the simplified governor and
turbine models are low pass filters which restrict the system response
to lower frequency ranges, where Pad approximation is exactly the
same as pure time delay. Therefore, for simplicity, 2 nd-order Pad
approximation can be employed for more complicated power systems
without negative impacts on the final results.
0.005
0
F re q u e n c y d e v ia tio n , H z
-0.005 DR 2nd order pade approximation

DR 5th order pade approximation
Conventional LFC
-0.01
-0.015
-0.02
-0.025
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Time (s)
Fig. 5.4: Controller performance for different order of Pad
approximation
-3
x 10
2
u2 = F(u1)
-2 u1 = F (u2)
-4
-6
-8
-10
-12
-14
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20
Time (s)

Page 49
Control
Fig.5.5: Impact of different unified inputs on the performance of the
LFC-DR model
The two control inputs are unified as a single input for the
controller design as a function of . The control input unification can be
done in two ways: unifying u1(t) as a function of u2(t) or vice versa [
or ]. To show the
impact of unification, a simulation study was carried out to compare
the performance of the system for both unification cases, and the
results are shown in Fig.5.5. It can be observed that the difference
between the two unifying approaches is negligible. In other words, the
unifying control input can be chosen arbitrarily without any negative
impact on the performance of the LFC-DR model.
0.005
-0.005
Td = 0.02 sec
Td = 0.1 sec
Td = 0.2 sec
-0.01 Td = 0.3 sec
Td = 0.4 sec
Conventional LFC
-0.015
-0.02
-0.025
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20
Times (s)
Fig. 5.6: Impact of latency on the performance of the LFC-DR model
One significant feature of the proposed LFC-DR model is the
possibility for the ISO/RTO to evaluate the impact of communication

Page 50
Control
delay of the DR control loop on the system performance for frequency
stabilization. In order to show the impact of latency, a simulation study
was performed for different values of communication latency for =0.1.
Simulation results are shown in Fig.5.6. The lowest communication
delay (lowest) is for a small power system with fast two-way
communication link, such as wireless communication, between the
Lagcos and individual loads. It can be seen that the LFC-DR model
gives a better performance compared to the conventional LFC when
. When the time delay exceeds 0.2 sec, it
deteriorates the performance of the LFC-DR, and the response is even
worse than that of conventional LFC for . This is
not surprising since the single-area power system under study has a
very fast dynamic response. In larger power systems with generation
rate limiters and slow turbine-governor systems, a slower dynamic
behavior would be expected from the supplementary control. But, the
LFC-DR will keep its superior performance even for higher
communication latencies
-3
x 10
0.5
-0.5
-1
Td=0.1 sec
-1.5 Td=0.3 sec
Td=0.5 sec
-2 Conventional LFC
-2.5
-3
-3.5
-4
-4.5
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20
Time (s)

Page 51
Control
Fig. 5.7: Impact of DR latency on the performance of a slower single-
area power system
To show the impact of the DR latencies on a larger power system
with high inertia and slower response, another simulation study was
conducted with the parameters given in Table 5.2. It can be seen from
Fig.5.7 that for a larger and consequently slower power system, the
performance of the LFC-DR model is superior to that of conventional
LFC even for larger communication latencies. It has been shown in [6]
that even with the current Internet infrastructure; a latency of 500msec
can be achieved easily. Therefore, it can be concluded that the DR with
the largest available latency (500 msec) still can be effective for large
power systems.
Table 5.2: Power System Parameters for the Simulation Study
Tg Tt R 2 D PL
0.3se 0.8se 2.4Hz/p. 3. 0.0083p.u./ 0.01p.
c c u 0 Hz u.
pu
se
c
5.4 SUMMARY

Page 52
Control
In this chapter, the proposed method is explained and compared
with the conventional method using simulation results. The proposed
method validated through simulation results for the different cases.

Page 53
Control
CHAPTER 6
CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE SCOPE
6.1 CONCLUSIONS
The proposed LFC-DR model responds to all frequency deviations
as is the case in the traditional LFC model. However, if it is desired to
prevent the LFC-DR model to respond to small frequency deviations,
and also keep the linearity of the model, a dead band could be added to
the input. This is because of the fast dynamics of the common variable
generation (wind, solar PV) compared to those of traditional power
plants in the LFC model.
In this thesis, investigate the effectiveness of the LFC-DR model
for frequency regulation at the transmission level in a single-area power
system. However in general, large power systems are multi-area where
different Gencos and Lagcos are available in each area.
In this Project, a general framework is proposed to include DR
into the LFC problem (LFC-DR). The proposed formulation can be
expanded easily for any type of power system in size and
characteristics. The framework adapts real-time electricity market with
existing load aggregators. It balances the power between generation and
demand and stabilizes the system frequency by utilizing a percentage of
available controllable loads and/or conventional supplementary control,
based on the real-time market price. It also includes communication
latencies in DR for controller design, using Pad approximation. It is
shown through different analytical studies that the proposed LFC-DR
framework will improve the stability margins in the conventional LFC
model and is slightly less sensitive to the variation in the system

Page 54
Control
parameters, such as changes in the open-loop transfer function. Similar
results have also been obtained for the sensitivity of the closed-loop
system w.r.t. the parameter. Simulation results show the effectiveness
of the LFC-DR model in improving stabilization of the system frequency.
In this thesis, investigate the effectiveness of the LFC-DR model
for frequency regulation at the transmission level in a single-area power
system. However in general, large power systems are multi-area where
different Gencos and Lagcos are available in each area.
6.2 FUTURESCOPE
In future work, it will be report that the application of LFC-DR in
multi-area power systems.

Page 55
Control
REFERENCES
[1]. R. Doherty and M. OMalley, A new approach to quantify
reserve demand in systems with significant installed wind
capacity , IEEE Trans. Power Syst., vol. 20, no. 2, pp. 587595,
May 2005.
[2]. U.S. Department of Energy, Smart Grid, Sep. 28, 2011
[Online]. Available: http://energy.gov/oe/technology-
development/smart-grid.
[3]. C. Goldman, M. Reid, R. Levy, and A. Silverstein,
Coordination of Energy Efficiency and Demand Response a
Resource of the National Action Plan for Energy Efficiency, U.S.

Environmental Protection Agency, U.S. Department of Energy ,
2010, Tech. Rep.

[4]. R. Walawalkar, S. Blumsack, J. Apt, and S. Fernands, An
economic welfare analysis of demand response in the PJM
electricity market, Energy Policy, vol. 36, no. 10, pp. 36923702,
Oct. 2008.
[5]. M. Klobasa, Analysis of demand response and wind integration
in Germanys electricity market, IET Renew. Power Gener., vol. 4,

no.1, pp. 5563, Jan. 2010.
[6]. A. Brooks, E. Lu, D. Reicher, C. Spirakis, and B. Weihl,
Demand dispatch: Using real-time control of demand to help
balance generation and load , IEEE Power Energy Mag., vol. 8,
no. 3, pp. 2029, May/Jun. 2010.

Page 56
Control
[7]. J. Medina, N. Muller, and I. Roytelman, Demand response
and distribution grid operations: Opportunities and challenges,
IEEE Trans.Smart Grid, vol. 1, no. 2, pp. 193198, Sep. 2010.

[8]. H. Saele and O. S. Grande, Demand response from
household customers: Experiences from a pilot study in Norway,
IEEE Trans. Smart Grid, vol. 2, no. 1, pp. 102109, Mar. 2011.
[9]. N. Ruiz, I. Cobelo, and J. Oyarzaabal, A direct load control
model for virtual power plant management, IEEE Trans. Power
Syst., vol. 24, no. 2, pp. 959966, May 2009.

[10]. A. J. Conejo, J. M. Morales, and L. Baringo, Real-time
demand response model, IEEE Trans. Smart Grid, vol. 1, no. 3,
pp. 236242, Dec. 2010.

[11]. D. T. Nguyen, M. Negnevitsky, and M. de Groot, Pool-based
demand response exchange-concept and modeling, IEEE Trans.
Power Syst., vol. 26, no. 3, pp. 16771685, Aug. 2011.

[12]. P. Faria, Z. Vale, J. Soares, and J. Ferreira, Demand
response management in power systems using a particle swarm
optimization approach, IEEE Intell. Syst., to be published.

[13]. M. Parvania and M. Fotuhi-Firuzabad, Integrating load
reduction into wholesale energy market with application to wind
power integration, IEEE Syst. J., vol. 6, no. 1, pp. 3545, Mar.
2012.
[14]. K. Dietrich, J.M. Latorre, L. Olmos, and A. Ramos,
Demand response in an isolated system with high wind
integration, IEEE Trans. Power Syst., vol. 27, no. 1, pp. 2029,
Feb. 2012.
[15]. M. Rastegar, M. Fotuhi-Firuzabad, and F. Aminifar, Load
commitment in a smart home, J. Appl. Energy, vol. 96, pp. 45
54, Aug. 2012.

[16]. N. Navid-Azarbaijani and M. H. Banakar, Realizing load
reduction functions by a periodic switching of load groups, IEEE
Trans. Power Syst., vol. 11, no. 2, pp. 721727, May 1996.

Page 57
Control
[17]. K. Y. Huang, H. C. Chin, and Y. C. Huang, A model
reference adaptive control strategy for interruptible load
management, IEEE Trans. Power Syst., vol. 19, no. 1, pp. 683
689, Feb. 2004.

[18]. D. Westermann and A. John, Demand matching wind
power generation with wide-area measurement and demand-side
management, IEEE Trans. Energy Convers., vol. 22, no. 1, pp.
145149, Mar. 2007.

[19]. S. A. Pourmousavi and M. H. Nehrir, Demand response for
smart micro grid: Initial results, in Proc. 2nd IEEE PES Innov.
Smart Grid Technol. (ISGT), Anaheim, CA, USA, 2011, pp. 16.
[20]. S. A. Pourmousavi, M. H. Nehrir, and C. Sastry, Providing
ancillary services through demand response with minimum load
manipulation, in Proc. 43rd North Amer. Power Symp. (NAPS),
Boston, MA, USA, 2011, pp. 16.

[21]. S. A. Pourmousavi and M. H. Nehrir, Real-time central
demand response for primary frequency regulation in micro
grids, IEEE Trans. Smart Grid, vol. 3, no. 4, pp. 19881996,
Dec. 2012.
[22]. D. Trudnowski, M. Donnelly, and E. Lightner, Power-
system frequency and stability control using decentralized
intelligent loads, in Proc., IEEE PES Conf. Exhib. Transm.
Distrib., Dallas, TX, USA, 2005, pp. 14531459.

[23]. J. A. Short, D. G. Infield, and L. L. Freris, Stabilization of
grid frequency through dynamic demand control, IEEE Trans.
Power Syst., vol. 22, no. 3, pp. 12841293, Aug. 2007.

[24]. A. Molina-Garca, F. Bouffard, and D. S. Kirschen,
Decentralized demand-side contribution to primary frequency
control, IEEE Trans. Power Syst., vol. 26, no. 1, pp. 411419,
Feb. 2011.

Page 58
Control
[25]. D. Jay and K. S. Swarup, Dynamic demand response and
control in smart grid environment, in Proc. Annual IEEE India
Conf. (INDICON), Hyderabad, 2011, pp. 14.

[26]. D. Jay and K. S. Swarup, Frequency restoration using
dynamic demand control under smart grid environment, in Proc.
IEEE PES Innovative Smart Grid TechnologiesIndia (ISGT
India), Kerala, 2011, pp. 311315.

[27]. K. Samarakoon, J. Ekanayake, and N. Jenkins,
Investigation of domestic load control to provide primary
frequency response using smart meters, IEEE Trans. Smart
Grid, vol. 3, no. 1, pp. 282292, Mar.2012.

[28]. D. Angeli and P.-A. Kountouriotis, A stochastic approach to
dynamic demand refrigerator control, IEEE Trans. Control Syst.
Technol., vol. 20, no. 3, pp. 581592, May 2012.

[29]. Z. Changhong, U. Topcu, and S. H. Low, Frequency-based
load control in power systems, in Proc. American Control Conf.
(ACC), Canada, 2012, pp. 44234430.

[30]. L. R. Chang-Chien, L. N. An, T. W. Lin, and W. J. Lee,
Incorporating demand response with spinning reserve to realize
an adaptive frequency restoration plan for system contingencies,
IEEE Trans. Smart Grid, vol. 3, no. 3, pp. 11451153, Sep. 2012.
[31]. H. Huang and F. Li, Sensitivity analysis of load-damping
characteristic in power system frequency regulation , IEEE
Trans. Power Syst., vol. 28, no. 2, pp. 13241335, May 2013.
[32]. Ibraheem, P. Kumar, and D. P. Kothari, Recent
philosophies of automatic generation control strategies in power
systems, IEEE Trans. Power Syst., vol. 20, no. 1, pp. 346357,
Feb. 2005.
[33]. H. Bevrani, Robust Power System Frequency Control. New
York, NY, USA: Springer, 2009, ch. 13.

[34]. C.-C. Wu, W.-J. Lee, C.- L. Cheng, and H.-W. Lan, Role
and value of pumped storage units in an ancillary services

Page 59
Control
market for isolated power system-simulation in the Taiwan power
system, IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. 44, no. 6, pp. 19241929,
Nov./Dec. 2008.
[35]. J. Mickey, Using load resources to meet ancillary service
requirements in the ERCOT market: A case study, in Proc. IEEE
PES General Meeting, Minneapolis, MN, USA, 2010, pp. 12.

[36]. P. Kundur, Power system Stability and Control. New York,
NY, USA: McGraw-Hill, 1994, ch. 11.

[37]. R. C. Dorf and R. H. Bishop, Modern Control Systems, 7th
ed. New York, NY, USA: Addison-Wesley, 1995, p. 807.

[38]. G. H. Golub and C. F. Van Loan, Matrix Computations, 3rd
ed. Baltimore, MD, USA: Johns Hopkins Univ. Press, 1996, pp.
572574.
[39]. G. F. Franklin, J. D. Powell, and A. Emami- Naeini,
Feedback Control of Dynamic Systems, 3rd ed. New York, NY,
USA: Addison-Wesley, 1994, p. 778.

[40]. C. E. Fosha and O. I. Elgerd, The megawatt-frequency
control problem: A new approach via optimal control theory,
IEEE Trans. Power App. Syst., vol. PAS-98, no. 4, pp. 563577,
Apr. 1970.
[41]. E. C. Tacker, C. C. Lee, T. W Reddoch, T. O. Tan, and P. M.
Julich, Optimal control of interconnected electric energy
systems: A new formulation, IEEE Proc. Lett., vol. 60, no. 10, pp.
12391241, Oct. 1972.

[42]. G. Shirai, Load frequency control using Lyapunovs second
method: Bang-bang control of speed changer position, IEEE
Proc. Lett., vol. 67, no. 10, pp. 14581459, Oct. 1979.
[43]. S. C. Tripathy, T. S. Bhatti, C. S. Jha, O. P. Malik, and G. S.
Hope, Sampled data automatic generation control analysis with
reheat steam turbines and governor dead-band effects, IEEE
Trans. Power App. Syst., vol. PAS-103, no. 5, pp. 10451051, May
1984.

Page 60
Control
[44]. T. Hiyama, Design of decentralized load-frequency
regulators for interconnected power systems, Proc. IEE
Generation, Transmission, Distribution Conf., vol. 129, no. 1, pp.
1723, 1982.

Page 61

Impact of Dynamic Demand Response in The Load Frequency Control

Încărcat de

Informații document

Titlu original

Drepturi de autor

Formate disponibile

Partajați acest document

Partajați sau inserați document

Opțiuni de partajare

Vi se pare util acest document?

Este necorespunzător acest conținut?

Drepturi de autor:

Formate disponibile

Impact of Dynamic Demand Response in The Load Frequency Control

Încărcat de

Drepturi de autor:

Formate disponibile

Impact Of Dynamic Demand Response In The Load Frequency

The quantification of device reserve has a noticeably easy and

largely deterministic system. The demand for electric energy is

enormous, particularly in regions where business and business

activities have rapidly evolved. However, locating a appropriate website

online for a brand new substation or new transmission line is difficult

Expanding the capacity of a substation or transmission line is likewise

tough in urban areas. The gadget safety of the substation is tough to

maintain when the substation suffers from capacity shortages or is in a

kingdom of emergency. A suitable load control scheme is, therefore,

needed to keep the reliability of the structures.

Frequency drifts, upwards or downwards, in a power device is the

principle indicator of the momentary imbalance among era and

demand. If, at any instant, electricity demand (taken on this paper to be

Conversely, if power deliver exceeds demand, frequency rises. The

device frequency fluctuates continuously in reaction to the changing

demand and because of the realistic impossibility of generation being

controlled to right now music all adjustments in call for.

In the ultimate three a long time, distinct soft computing strategies

have developed and effectively applied to specific complicated

optimization hassle. Power gadget optimization is not any exception to

this trend. Soft computing techniques that are efficiently used to

Dept. of EEE BITIT-Hindupur

(GA), Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO), Bacterial Foraging Algorithm

(BFA) and Differential Evolution (DE). In order to solve the optimization

trouble greater successfully special artificial intelligence techniques are

blended in hybrid manner. For example a Fuzzy logic manipulate

scheme in mixture with different optimization technique may be very

beneficial to make sure the robustness of the system.

The obvious challenge in inclusive of masses in frequency control

is the massive growth within the quantity of capability participants.

contribute to frequency control. On the alternative hand, participation

from the demand facet might involve tens of thousands if no longer

millions of clients. Though this can appear technically daunting and

economically unrealistic, it has to remember that traditional primary

frequency control is a allotted control gadget that is based at the

availability of the frequency as a degree of imbalance among load and

slump characteristic and a nearby frequency size, not through a signal

despatched from a manage middle. Communication to and from the

control loops for higher financial optimization and network security. A

conversation network to take part in number one frequency manage.

1.2 LITERATURE SURVEY

Conventionally, frequency regulation in energy gadget is

completed by using balancing technology and demand via load

following, i.E., spinning and non-spinning reserves. The destiny

electricity grid, however, is foreseen to have excessive penetration of

Dept. of EEE BITIT-Hindupur

variable. In such cases, power garage and responsive masses show

help to keep away from using the conventional generation following

schemes, which may be high priced and/or environmentally unfriendly.

garage devices, real-time clever responsive load participation, referred to

balancing. It can be finished via energetic client participation in actual-

time to hold stability among technology and demand with two-manner

communique. It is well known that DR increases device reliability and

flexibility to manipulate the variability and uncertainty of a few RE

resources, decreases the fee of operation, and enhances system

Furthermore, DR may be used to provide ancillary services (AS) for

regulation reserve and to reply momentarily to the area manage

mistakes (ACE). Although AS are known as greater frequently than

conventional load dropping events, the once a year overall hours of

lot shorter. Thus, AS applications might also enchantment to retail

curtailments. Examples of consumer end-use masses which have on

has been lately given to DR for extraordinary functions, e.G., economic