Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Table of Contents
OCCUPANCY INTERVIEWS..........................................................................................44
Primary occupancy interviews ..........................................................................................44
Other occupancy interviews..............................................................................................44
Information management..................................................................................................44
CONSTRUCTION METHODS & HAZARDS.................................................................44
Common building construction types................................................................................44
Identifying structural collapse hazards ..............................................................................45
Timber frame................................................................................................................45
Reinforced Masonry .....................................................................................................45
Unreinforced Masonry..................................................................................................46
Concrete Tilt-up ...........................................................................................................46
Reinforced Concrete and Steel Frame ...........................................................................46
COLLAPSE PATTERNS ..................................................................................................47
Typical collapse patterns ..................................................................................................47
Curtain Fall Wall collapse.............................................................................................48
Inwards / Outward collapse...........................................................................................48
Lean Over collapse .......................................................................................................49
Lean to Floor collapse...................................................................................................49
900 Angle Wall collapse................................................................................................49
Pancake Floor collapse .................................................................................................50
" V " collapse................................................................................................................50
Inverted, "A" or Tent collapse.......................................................................................50
Cantilever collapse .......................................................................................................51
Progressive collapse .....................................................................................................51
SECONDARY COLLAPSE INDICATORS .....................................................................52
Identifying the three secondary collapse indicators ...........................................................52
Movement in the structure ............................................................................................52
Visual alertness.............................................................................................................52
Hearing alertness ..........................................................................................................53
During Practical Operations..........................................................................................53
STRUCTURAL IDENTIFICATION SYSTEMS .............................................................54
Importance of identifying structures .................................................................................54
Single structure – Side Label ............................................................................................55
Floor identification ...........................................................................................................56
Structure identification within a geographic area ..............................................................56
Identification of bridges, flyovers & trains........................................................................57
Zone/barrier marking system (INSARAG)........................................................................58
Operational Work Zone ................................................................................................58
Collapse/Hazard Zone ..................................................................................................58
Other markings.................................................................................................................58
Facility .........................................................................................................................58
Vehicle .........................................................................................................................58
Teams...........................................................................................................................58
FEMA STRUCTURE HAZARD EVALUATION ............................................................59
STRETCHER WALK........................................................................................................74
FURTHER READING.......................................................................................................75
NZ Colour Light Stick Codes ...........................................................................................75
Operational Briefings .......................................................................................................75
Situation (introduction, terrain & risk) ..........................................................................76
Mission.........................................................................................................................76
Execution .....................................................................................................................76
Administration and Logistics ........................................................................................76
Command and Communication.....................................................................................76
Questions......................................................................................................................76
Team effectiveness ...........................................................................................................77
Effective teamwork ......................................................................................................78
Different types of people within a team.........................................................................80
Phases of Teamwork ........................................................................................................82
Phases of Team Formation................................................................................................83
The appreciation process ..................................................................................................83
Continuing Action ........................................................................................................85
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ...............................................................................................86
www.fire.org.nz
USAR NZ History
Define USAR
An integrated multi agency response, which is beyond the capability of normal rescue
arrangements, to provide initial medical care and removal of entrapped persons from
damaged structures or other environments in a safe and expeditious manner.
USAR (Urban Search and Rescue) is the mobilisation of resources required to safely
and expeditiously locate and remove trapped and often injured victims from partially
or totally collapsed structures or environments and providing for emergency medical
care in doing so. USAR is not the same as Land SAR, which is search and rescue of
persons in wilderness environments.
USAR involves the integrated response of highly specialised equipment and trained
personnel from different disciplines, effective communications and an established
method of command and control and logistical support. In addition to the response of
personnel and equipment, effective USAR involves preparing prior to an incident
occurring, and assisting the affected community to recover from the incident. In many
instances, this will involve cross agency, national and possibly international
participation and co-operation.
The complexities of the search and rescue function after a structural collapse
requires a co-ordination and incident management system that is commonly
understood, constantly used and effective, and SOPs (Standard Operating
Procedures) developed for the strategic and tactical functions of the incident.
FEMA
FEMA (Federal Emergency Management Agency) launched its USAR Task Force
system in 1989. The program originally evolved in response to the need for trained
personnel to assist in coping with natural disasters, primary earthquake. Following
Oklahoma bombing in 1995 the government realised that the Task Forces had a
broader potential and began to deploy them to such events as 1996 Atlanta Summer
Olympics at which a catastrophic event could occur.
INSARAG
INSARAG (International Search and Rescue Advisory Group) was formed in 1991 as
a co-operative effort by the United Nations and many of the participating countries,
including New Zealand, in international SAR (Search and Rescue). With the
assistance of all participants, the conclusions and recommendations adopted at the
initial INSARAG meeting were based on their collective experiences in disaster
responses.
United Kingdom
Historically, the British Fire Service has been responding to disasters around the
world for a number of years. In the Mexico City (1985) and El Salvador (1986)
earthquakes, a team from the London Fire Brigade were sent with thermal imaging
cameras. In Armenia in December 1988, teams including London, Kent and
Hampshire responded on search & rescue missions. These efforts were not co-
ordinated and action depended upon individual brigades.
Following the UK response to assist the Kurdish population in northern Iraq (1991),
as a consequence of the Gulf War, the then Minister for Overseas Development,
announced a new initiative designed to improve the effectiveness of any future British
relief effort.
A steering group of Chief Fire Officers was set up, the steering group developed the
protocols & guidelines under which teams would be utilised or mobilised.
Australia
The USAR CAT2/Technician course was developed in September 1998. In the first
USAR course they held four back to back courses in three months training over 100
fire fighters, as well as a number of Police and Ambulance Officers in USAR.
NZ evolution of USAR
A National USAR Technician training pilot was run in Palmerston North in October
1995, pioneered by Bernie Rush, former Wanganui CFO, NZFS (New Zealand Fire
Service), with Ernesto Ojeda, Don Reyes and Frank Borden, specialist trainers from
Los Angeles City Fire Dept, USA.
During 2000, the New Zealand Fire Service & Ministry of Civil Defence proposed to
NZ Government the establishment of a national USAR capability with one Task Force
Teams in Palmerston North, Christchurch and Auckland.
USA
US NFPA 1670
• Awareness
• Operation
• Technician
There are 28 federally funded US&R Task Forces across the United States. FEMA
teams organise existing search and rescue capability into a national program that can
quickly deploy to an event. They have additional training, and must be able to deploy
within six hours and to sustain themselves for 72 hours. They must also have a roster
that fills 31 different positions with at least two people for each position. To receive
the FEMA certification, the team must be approved by a US&R oversight board that
includes leaders in the field and FEMA officials
A task force is really a partnership between local fire departments, law enforcement
agencies, federal and local governmental agencies and private companies.
Task Force members include structural engineers and specialists in the areas of
hazardous materials, heavy rigging, search (including highly trained search dogs),
logistics, rescue and medicine.
Europe
4CL:
• Awareness
• Medium
• Heavy
• Executive/Command
Australia
• Awareness (CAT1)
• Technician (CAT2)
• Manager (CAT3)
3 Task Forces
• TF1 – Palmerston North
• TF 2 – Christchurch
• TF 3 – Auckland (No resources)
Each Task Force has 32 Technicians plus support staff (max 40 persons). This
allows for 2 watches each doing 12hr shifts. It is made up from multiple agencies
including Fire, Ambulance, Defence Force and Civil Defence.
USAR NZ is administered by the New Zealand Fire Service & Ministry of Civil
Defence & Emergency Management.
Currently requests for Task Force activation is made through the New Zealand Fire
Service Communication Centre.
Responders provide first response and focuses on majority of victims that are
entrapped on the surface, once Task Forces arrive responders support operations
such as debris bucket lines.
USAR Response Teams (CAT1-R) are managed by Local CDEMG are not nationally
managed.
The USAR incident ground card (Orange Card) and industry certificate have been
developed by FRSITO (Fire & Rescue Services Industry Training Organisation) and
the USAR Training Standards Committee, on behalf of the National USAR Steering
Committee.
The Responder Orange Card has been designed to identify individuals who have the
necessary certification to function as a first responder to a structural collapse
incident. Specialist skill endorsements can also be identified on the rear of the card to
aid effective and safe logistical management at such incidents.
As well as the Orange Card, the same competencies will be recorded on an industry
certificate. The minimum competencies required also contribute to proposed national
qualifications in Urban Search and Rescue.
USAR Task Force Technicians and Managers are also eligible for Technician and
Manager USAR Orange Cards upon meeting specified criteria and such applications
can be made through the USAR Training Standards Committee.
The Orange Card provides identification for anyone holding the competencies
required to provide first response to a structural collapse. This may include personnel
both career and voluntary from Fire Service, Police, Ambulance, Civil Defence, Red
Cross, Search Dog Teams, SAR groups and other teams
At USAR incidents, standard command and control systems apply; the Orange Card
does not delegate any special authority or powers to the holder in such operations.
USAR Responders still work under the Incident Controller as per the New Zealand
CIMS model.
Under health and safety legislation, the employer must ensure staff are competent to
carry out a task or are supervised by someone who is. The Orange Card is an ideal
and easy way to do this.
The card also promotes a minimum industry standard of competency, meaning that
teams can ensure their members hold or are supervised by someone who is trained.
This is particularly helpful when interacting with other agencies where you may not
know their skill level, whether in training or operations.
Contact Fire Rescue Service Industry Training Organisation (FRSITO) or visit website
www.frsito.org.nz and send a completed form with payment, along with photo and
proof of unit standard achievements.
This was highlighted at the Oklahoma City Bombing, where it was quickly realised
that the resources of the Oklahoma City Fire Department were going to be insufficient
to cope with the incident.
In addition to the 26 Fire departments, eleven 56 member FEMA task forces and
countless other agencies that responded to assist, there was over 26 tons of
specialist equipment shipped in to assist in the operations. This was in addition to the
tons of equipment donated by the people of Oklahoma City and surrounding areas.
Pre-planning is required for any USAR operation, and much thought must be given to
the overall quantity and type of equipment that is required and may be available for a
large scale incident.
The type of equipment required can be broken down into the following areas:
Heavy
Heavy machinery that could be used in USAR operations or support, includes:
Aerial ladders, elevated platforms, bull dozers, bob cats, cranes, backhoes,
generators.
Medium
Portable equipment used, not specifically designed for rescue, but able to support
USAR operations, includes: Hydraulic jacks, lights towers, wire rubble baskets.
Rescue
Specialist rescue equipment - usually hand tools, includes: Acoustic devices, fibre
optic cameras, time lapse cameras, search cameras, thermal imaging cameras, infra
red cameras, chainsaws, bolt cutters, concrete cutters, air hammers, drills, lighting,
ropes, Tifor host, fulcrum lever
Support
Non-technical equipment used to support USAR operations, includes: Wheel
barrows, buckets, medical waste disposal, and morgue facilities.
Medical
Medical services and resources that aid USAR operators and victims, includes:
Triage, transport, specialist drug administration, health and safety, veterinary.
Communications
Communications equipment to support USAR operations and administration,
includes: Mobile data terminals, SATCOM, HF Comms, portable radios, repeaters,
mobile phones, computers, printers, copying machines, fax machines.
Shoring
Structural collapse stabilisation resources, includes: Large quantities of timber and
tubular steel, nails, carpentry tools, hydraulic shoring equipment
Animals
USAR Certified search dogs for victim location, includes: Live victim search dog and
cadaver search dogs.
Services
Non-Operational Support services and resources, includes: Portable toilets, tents,
catering heaters.
While this list is not complete or exhaustive, it provides an indication of the types of
equipment that will be required at an incident.
Some of this equipment may already be available to your agency, but the majority of
it will not, and close working relationships will be essential with other agencies and
private contractors in order to ensure that the equipment that is needed will be
available when it is required.
The following agencies have similar or specialised resources that change from time
to time. The following organisations may be able to provide resources at an incident:
• Fire Brigade
• Police Services
• Defence Force
• Ambulance service
• Commercial suppliers
• Local Government
• International agencies
Safety Officer
(Look Out)
Each team would have a maximum of 5-7 responders to ensure and manageable
span of control, although a further 5-7 responders could be available for the rotation
of crew members.
All of this debris leads to a situation where normal operations become difficult and
extra care and equipment is required to ensure the safety of rescue personnel, which
is the primary consideration at any incident.
In addition to the dangers associated with the damaged structure, there are the
problems associated with utilities in and around the building, e.g. gas, electricity,
water and other building services. One of the first tasks of personnel attending an
incident will be to isolate these utilities, but there will always be hidden dangers within
a building that can affect the safety of workers and rescuers.
At an incident that is entering its second, third or subsequent days, some of the major
problems that will confront rescuers will be the biological hazards due to the
decomposition of bodies, the presence of body fluids in the debris, food decomposing
and untreated sewage. These incidents begin to take on a special hazard in
themselves, and precautions must be taken to protect rescuers from any body fluids
and airborne pathogens (micro organism, germs, virus, bacterium etc) that may be
present.
Decontamination of not only equipment, but of personnel, will be required before any
person or equipment leaves the site of a protracted USAR incident. Crews must
ensure that all appropriate hazardous materials (HazMat) procedures for the incident
are adopted in line with your agencies SOPs for HazMat incidents.
Due to the nature of a USAR incident it is important to be familiar with the types of
protective clothing that give the maximum protection while still being suited to the
environment of a structural collapse.
Traditional fire service turnout gear and self contained breathing apparatus (S.C.B.A.)
are not suited to non fire incidents of long duration under rubble or in confined
spaces, due to their bulkiness, lack of mobility, and related heat stress factors.
USAR teams who are trained and endorsed in its use may use supplied airline
respiratory equipment. This equipment will give the teams more freedom of
movement especially in confined spaces if additional respiratory protection is required
due to irrespirable atmospheres.
Close fitting garments that are both durable and comfortable should be worn to
exclude dirt and rubble and protect the rescuer from cuts and abrasions. They should
have pockets to carry small items, minimal openings and no loose straps that may
catch on edges when crawling through debris. In addition to the pockets on the
clothing, a bum bag or tool bag can become a handy addition to carry spare personal
protective equipment and any small gear that may be required.
The following list describes the types of personal protective equipment that should be
considered as a minimum requirement for personnel entering any USAR incident.
Specific incidents may necessitate the use of additional protective equipment as
required.
• Full length clothing or uniform to protect from cuts and abrasions. Ensure
sleeves are rolled down to protect your skin
• Head lamp with spare bulb and batteries for night and confined space operations
• Goggles or safety glasses to protect the eyes from dust and dirt (fully
encapsulating, not glasses)
• Dust masks will prevent the inhalation of dust. Asbestos masks and suits may
have to be used if there is a chance of asbestos contamination.
• Gloves will protect the hands from a range of hazards that will be encountered at
an incident. They should give the palms good protection and extend a short way
up the arms to overlap the sleeves of the overalls/protective garment.
• First aid kit for personal use. Your team will also have comprehensive first aid kits
in its equipment cache.
• Boots should incorporate toe cap and sole protection and give good support.
• Knee and elbow protection is also advisable, as the rescuer may have to spend
many hours on hands and knees, crawling through or over rubble.
When considering purchase or use of equipment rescue teams should ensure the
equipment complies with AS/NZS Standards. Information on standards or purchase
of documentation is available from http://www.standards.co.nz
Where there is no AS/NZS standards for equipment, teams should ensure equipment
complies with one of the following standards
USAR responders are to wear orange helmets with their name & team ID visible. The
following stripes will also be used to indicate the individual’s position within the team.
Jerkins should also be worn denoting the wearers role in English, consistent to the
CIMS model
Jerkins should also be worn denoting wearers role in English, consistent to the CIMS
model
The USAR helmet colours differ from that of the New Zealand Fire Service and of
many rescue teams. The USAR Orange Card may also be used to verify the
competencies of any individual.
Dehydration
To avoid dehydration
• Drink fluids every hour
• Avoid caffeine and sweet drinks
• Drink at least 2 litres of water every day (more if it is hot)
Encourage your team members to drink water whenever you have a drink.
Fatigue
Causes of fatigue
To avoid fatigue
Wear latex or neoprene gloves beneath your leather gloves when handling victims
and/or bodies. Eye protection should also be considered to avoid splash infection.
It is important to thoroughly wash hands before eating at meal breaks. A wash area
will be set up by HazMat teams for this purpose.
Cover any cuts or abrasions. This is necessary to prevent the transfer of bacteria and
viruses.
Wear your Personal Protective Equipment; ensure that sleeves are rolled down to
protect bare skin. It is advised that front line emergency service workers undergo
periodical hepatitis status checks and immunisation (available from your doctor or
GP)
Stress
Stress is both an external and self-generated response to events that exceeds your
bodies’ ability to cope.
Stress is a personal reaction; each situation creates a different stress reaction for
each individual. Some examples of situations that may cause stress are
• Claustrophobia
• Anxiety
• Panic
The following brief explanation assists in understanding this terminology and has
been adapted from an article written by Deputy Firemaster Geoff Williams, Central
Scotland Fire Brigade, Scotland.
Phobia
This term is generally used as a suffix e.g. Acrophobia, Agoraphobia etc. These are
fears of some situation or object where the danger is magnified out of all proportion to
its actual seriousness. The word claustrophobia has limited value to Emergency
Service Workers but it is worth understanding the meaning of the term i.e.-abnormal
fear of a close or confined space. (Claustrum = closed, Phobia = abnormal fear)
Anxiety
Panic
Biological reactions
Biological reactions will influence how a person will react to the stresses of being in a
confined space. The control of claustrophobia focuses on the individual’s ability to
control their feelings. The operator with more experience can achieve this due to
having been exposed to this type of environment previously. In this instance what the
operator is doing is controlling their 'adrenaline rush', or more correctly their response
to the release of catecholamines, in particular nor adrenaline. This is one of the
hormones released when you are frightened, anxious or working extremely hard. For
the more inexperienced operator, prior psychological training in control techniques
can be of benefit.
As you can imagine many other substances are released as a result of the 'fight or
flight' response, (the normal physiological response to stress), however it is irrelevant
and impractical to try to measure these in the field. It is worth noting that there is no
chemical substance within the body that will reduce stress, except the removal of the
operator from the event or the environment which is producing stress. The above
mentioned hormones dissipate, and their production is significantly reduced once the
event causing the stress has ended.
Subconscious forces
Some psychoanalysts state that phobias may be passed from childhood experiences.
An example of this could be where as a child the individual was trapped within some
small room or object. The anxiety created at this time might be shifted into the
subconscious mind and remain as an unclarified source of anxiety into adulthood.
The anxiety could be known to the individual i.e. he/she knows consciously that they
have this feeling. However, it could be subconscious and the person may not be
aware of this particular fear. Therefore the person may be attempting to avoid the
threat e.g. missing the actual entry involvement during a confined drill period by
acting defensively. This defensive behaviour may work by temporarily relieving
anxiety and it tends to be repeated i.e. a habitual response.
Every person has a different biological make up and understanding these effects and
learning how to control them should be phased into training programmes when
preparing for confined space rescues.
Control Techniques
There are any number of control techniques that may be used to overcome the
psychological factors encountered at an USAR incident. Some of these are listed
below, but remember that you as an individual should use whatever works for you.
Behavioural training
One theory, which supports this type of psychological progression, is the graded
exposure method, or step by step approaches to the anxiety-creating situation.
When one considers the confined space scenario, these steps include:
1. Identify the anxiety creating mechanism, in this case entering the confined space.
2. Grade the fear as it relates to individuals, least fearful to most fearful. For
example:
Once the person can visualise a mildly fearful situation without feeling unduly anxious
then they move up the hierarchy to a more anxiety-provoking situation.
Contextual Therapy
A therapy developed by Doctors Zane and Milt suggest a 6-point program for phobia
related anxiety control called "Contextual therapy". The following example outlines
these steps when related to a confined space entry.
The primary comparison between both theories involves confronting and entering the
enclosure, preferably under a training environment, so that the reactions are not
unexpected and potentially dangerous.
Paradoxical Intervention
This control technique involves the individual exaggerating the symptoms and
feelings of anxiety, e.g. a person thinking they would faint if they went higher than two
floors. This sometimes humorous approach has a means of diminishing the
symptoms by taking control of them. Training in the area would allow persons to
become familiar with fear producing situations.
Practical considerations
• Total body bulk is reduced and this provides more freedom of movement and
assists by giving the person a greater feeling of confidence.
• This increase in confidence allows the rescuer to concentrate on the rescue and
not on feelings of confinement.
The tight working areas, electrical and mechanical devices, numerous obstructions,
extremes of temperature combined with poor lighting and long access time ensure
any rescuer will be pushed to their physical and mental limitations.
Compound all this into a hazardous atmosphere and a "cocktail" for a serious incident
is assured.
The confined space rescue demands tactical decisions such as ventilation, casualty
access, assessment and removal. These are entirely different from the more typical
rescue problems.
CIMS Overview
Background of ICS
The Incident Command System used in New Zealand is CIMS, Co-ordinated Incident
Management System. It incorporates modern management principles and has been
modified and adapted for New Zealand. The system has been used in the USA since
1970s and was introduced into Australia in the 1980s
An Incident Command System is designed for both planned and unplanned events
such as fires, earthquakes, floods, riots, HazMat, motor vehicle accidents, parades,
etc.
CIMS is a subject in its own and all rescue workers should complete an Introduction
in Co-ordinated Incident Management System. The Unit Standard for Introduction in
CIMS is required as part of the Orange Card.
The Incident Controller is responsible for the overall direction of response activities in
an emergency situation and is the person in charge at an incident. The Incident
Controller fulfils all management functions and responsibilities until the incident
requires additional appointments.
INCIDENT
SAFETY
CONTROLLER
LIAISON
PLANNING /
OPERATIONS LOGISTICS
INTELLIGENCE
Gather information of resource and situation status to allow for effective planning and
logistical management.
Use mobile phones and ES Liaison Simplex Channels for the Incident Management
Team. Learn how to use ES Liaison Simplex/Duplex channels on your radios.
Limit the number of people supervising the logistics area, and make sure they all use
the same system.
Have an inventory control system set up before an incident occurs, and update
resources on a readily available computer. These computer systems should have
facilities to update resources as they arrive, and allow for the operators to preplan
logistics requirements.
Centralise logistics
Have only one logistics area for the entire incident, and for all attending agencies.
This helps to prevent duplication of resource requests.
Plan accordingly, ensure future staff replacements are forecasted and arranged
including logistical support for new staff.
Hazards
The USAR incident often has many hazards. These are combined in an environment
that is unfamiliar and can overwhelm the large percentage of untrained rescuers.
There are six major hazards that can be grouped into two areas, Situational and
Environmental. Each of the six major hazards is a challenge in itself but as long as
the trained rescuer maintains awareness and addresses each hazard in the correct
method, a successful outcome can be achieved.
Situational
• below debris hazards
• surface hazards
• overhead hazards
• structural instability
Environmental
• hazardous materials
• utilities
Situational hazards
These can be defined as those below the finished ground or debris surface height
and may include
• flooding
• oxygen deficient atmosphere
• toxic environments
• flammable environments
• different levels of elevation
Before stepping onto surfaces first probe for false floors and differences in elevation.
Keep in mind that after a building collapse the orientation of floors may be altered.
Flooding
This is not only a hazard to those persons trapped in the vicinity of the flooding but
also the rescuers working above. The flooding may be a static level or dynamic
(raising, flowing or falling) all of which can effect the debris pile’s stability and
composition.
Toxic environment
The toxic environment may exist from stored hazards, which have been released due
to the collapse of the structure. Personal protective equipment must be worn at all
times to reduce the risk of injury.
Hazardous material
As with all HazMat incidents the correct level of protective clothing and equipment
must be used to ensure personnel safety. Set procedures must be adopted and
specialist advice will, in many cases, be required.
If unsure, questioning witnesses and survivors can give clues as to the type of
occupancy of the building.
Pre-planning and local knowledge are useful tools to determine the possibility of
hazardous material.
Hospital and research institutes usually contain radioactive material and compressed
gases; similarly chemicals are commonplace in many industries. For more
information on identifying hazardous materials, consult to your own agencies HazMat
documentation or see you local Dangerous Goods Inspector.
Flammable environment
These could occur from ruptured storage tanks or lines. Obviously ignition sources
must be eliminated and the atmosphere rendered safe.
The surfaces that were once ceiling and walls can now appear to be the floor. As
rescuers move into voids to search, the surface on which they are working cannot be
guaranteed as being stable. As the search proceeds debris will continue to settle and
further altered levels may be encountered throughout the structure.
Note; in the Oklahahoma bombing (1995) a Fire fighter fell four floors from
basement level 2 to basement level 6 as he stepped through a doorway.
Surface Hazards
Rubble found at a structural collapse could weigh from less than 1 kg to several
tonnes. The quantity and position of the debris can add to the complexity of the
rescue. Nails, reinforcing bars, steel, conduit, electrical cables and copper piping may
be exposed or found just below the surface.
Rain, snow and ice can also create slippery conditions as well as hiding sharp
surfaces and holes. The hazards on the surface can depend on the nature of the
collapse, and the cause of the collapse.
The surface hazards could be largely affected by the weather and time of incident
and could include:
Climate
Inclement weather and poor building construction may be the factors that lead to a
building collapse and it is these same weather conditions that the rescuer will be
working in. In sub zero temperatures ice and snow will cause surfaces to become
slippery, especially if working with hydraulic cutting equipment using water, snow will
hide voids and levels, conceal sharp objects, reduce visibility and possibly impose
additional weight on the structure.
Surfaces
In the debris pile the surfaces will be uneven and unsound, creating slippery and
dangerous conditions. These conditions will exist well into the incident and will
require the rescuer to move with caution at all times.
Note: the use of a lower body height and the debris crawl will assist in the safe
transition of the debris pile.
Care must be taken to avoid sharp and jagged objects in the debris pile in the USAR
environment. Personal protective equipment and vigilance while moving on the scene
can help to prevent unnecessary injuries.
Pooling of water
A pool of water can appear shallow although it could be deep enough to drown the
unwary. If the water must be traversed then probing for depth and soundness of
bottom should first be carried out. Buildings may have internal swimming pools or
open tanks and knowledge of these will assist rescuers to avoid these types of
hazards.
The pools of water may be from broken water mains, sewage lines or local flooding.
Considerations must be given to the origin of such pools and the subsequent removal
of the water.
After the collapse of the structure the dust can be suspended for extended periods,
further to this any cutting will also contribute to this problem. The use of dust masks is
essential to protect the rescuer.
The wind if present will contribute to the plan of attack as this will have an effect on
several aspects of the rescue. These include the stability of the structure, the amount
of dust produced and the carriage of sound.
The noise on a site must be kept to a minimum as this will facilitate effective
searching and afford the rescuers a warning of the locations of victims and some pre
warning of the structure under stress, which may lead to secondary collapse.
The vibrations that can be caused by the use of heavy cutting tools and machinery
must be closely monitored to keep vibration at a minimum. This will allow for early
detection of victims and aid in the stabilisation of the debris pile.
Overhead Hazards
The phrase look up and live is an appropriate catch cry in the USAR incident as the
dangers from above can kill the unwary. This can range from the falling debris in the
event of further collapse to the dropping of a load by a crane during debris clearance
Picture 6. The only rescuer killed after the Bombing at Oklahoma (April 1995)
was a civilian nurse who died after being struck by a computer whilst she was
attempting to remove surface casualties.
All overhead hazards must be stabilised or removed before lower level rescue
operations commence.
Large sections of floors, walls, ceilings and building contents can be left hanging
overhead after a structural collapse. These can suddenly fall, especially in
aftershocks and high wind conditions.
Low hanging power lines can cause a tripping or electrical shock hazard. A broken
conductor could energise any material capable of conducting electricity. Very high
voltage (11,000 volts) is fed into many larger buildings. The high voltage is reduced
to 415 volts within the building. Power must be isolated prior to commencing rescue
operations and expert advice is required to ensure site safety.
Ornamental plasterwork, loose windowpanes and broken panes of glass, neon signs
and any other structure that can fall must be secured or removed before work
commences. Rescuers must not work under cranes or machinery employed to
remove hazards and rubble.
Structural Instability
Areas where structural instability can occur are walls, columns, beams, floor
assemblies, overhangs, roofs and unconnected walls or parapets. Fallen trees, low
hanging power lines and building contents can place a load on structural elements.
Chain link fences can be “loaded” if unbroken and under stress and have the
potential energy to create further damage and collapse.
The method in which a building is tied together is critical to prevent further collapse.
Moving or removing any load-bearing element can cause other building elements to
collapse and load bearing elements may be under heavier loads and stresses than
they are designed to carry. Some pre-collapse non-load bearing elements may
become load bearing after the collapse. An elevator car or counterweight’s guide can
be separated from the rails and hoisting cables and could be in danger of falling.
Points to consider include:
The cause of the collapse will result in a type of structural failure. These causes can
range from natural events such as:
• earthquakes
• flooding
• wind
• landslide
Structural collapse and failure can also result from man made events such as;
• fires
• explosions (terrorist, accidental)
• inadequate construction methods
In each of these situations the size of the destructive forces, combined with the
physical aspects of the structure will all influence the degree of damage. The amount
of the structure left standing and its type add to the possibility of further collapse
(secondary collapse).
The design factors of the load bearing structural members (beams, columns and
floors) are all compromised in the emergency situation. The additional loads placed
on the remaining structure could place it at the verge of collapse. Load points on the
building will be altered so all possible care must be taken.
Rescuers as they penetrate into voids will place additional loads on the remaining
structure. These will have to be shored and braced to prevent further collapse. Before
attempting to brace any structural load, experts in engineering should be consulted.
Page 36 of 87 l Version 1.2 l 2002 © New Zealand Fire Service
New Zealand Urban Search & Rescue l Awareness Student Manual
Environmental
Hazardous Materials
• asbestos
• various types of cylinders, e.g. oxygen, acetylene.
• research materials ( biological, radioactive, or base chemicals)
• pesticides
• bleaches
• acids, oils
• contaminated waste products.
The type of use of the structure will give some information as to the likelihood of
these conditions. Additional information could be obtained from pre - planning,
survivors and any Fire Safety and Evacuation plans or Territorial Building Authority
The type of hazard that the rescuer will encounter will dictate the level of personal
protective equipment required. The physical and chemical properties of the material
will determine the type of threat, be it respiratory, direct contact or skin absorption to
the rescuer and the victims alike.
Utilities (services)
The disruption of gas, water and power services will further complicate a rescue at a
collapse incident. The escape of gas causes two areas of concern. The first is the
displacement of oxygen in a confined space and the second the potential for an
explosive mixture.
With the displacement of oxygen, the victims and rescuers could be overcome by the
lack of oxygen. Ventilation or the use of breathing apparatus will assist, but
atmospheric monitoring is essential to ensure a safe working environment.
If there is a risk of fire or explosion, cutting off the source of ignition and providing
safe and effective ventilation can reduce this threat.
Note: Constant monitoring of air quality throughout the rescue can reduce the
likelihood of explosion that would cause further casualties and greater injury.
Due to the additional weight and the possibility of trapped victims drowning, water
used for fire fighting purposes or from a ruptured pipe must be kept to a minimum and
not allowed to accumulate. Water soaked debris can also make manual removal
efforts more demanding for rescuers.
Gas and water meters operating can indicate if either hazard is leaking or flowing and
are usually situated at an isolation point.
State of Equilibrium
State of equilibrium is where a building (or part thereof) is stable in its current
situation in the absence of external influences (additional weight or movement due to
people working on the pile, earth tremors, wind, vibration, train passing nearby etc).
Importance of monitoring
Eliminate and minimise any factors that may affect the state of equilibrium. Cordon
the area and stop trains and masses of bystanders running over collapsed structure
Ensure a Safety Officer (Look Out) is appointed and watches for indicators of
secondary collapse
Locate machinery and appliances away from the hot zone where possible.
Check weather forecasts for possible wind changes and rain that may significantly
affect the state of equilibrium
The safe working practices that are used in an Urban Search and Rescue incident
are those that are derived from combating the hazards and effective management
practices.
• personal
• planning
• general
Personal
Personal protective equipment is covered earlier in this manual. Refer to the section
as required. In addition to wearing your full personal protective equipment, the
following guidelines should be followed:
Picture 8. Urban Search and Rescue operators monitoring the progress of one
of their colleagues.
Planning
The basic plan of the USAR incident is SURVEY / STABILISE and SEARCH. In order
for this approach to be effective, all persons involved in the incident must effectively
use information.
With this in mind, effective planning should include, but is not limited to the following:
• safe working distance from weakened walls is 1.5 times the height of wall
• atmospheric monitoring
• eliminate sources of ignition
• don’t use gas pressure to set pneumatic shores
• provide adequate ventilation and lighting
• use the services of experts (structural engineers, chemists)
• cut columns only as a last resort
• use a safety check list and crew timers
The confined space entry and rescue represents one of the most challenging and
dangerous rescue operations undertaken by rescue workers today. The increasing
use of confined areas for construction, industrial and Government Customs and
Excise purposes means rescuers must be aware they need to develop specialist
techniques for these dangerous environments.
The following description of a confined space has been adapted from an article
written by Deputy Firemaster Geoff Williams, Central Scotland Fire Brigade,
Scotland.
"Any space that has a limited means of egress, not intended for continual
occupancy, which may have the potential for an oxygen deficient or hazardous
atmosphere or where the potential for engulfment may occur"
A confined space is any area that is not intended for human occupancy and that also
has the potential for containing a dangerous atmosphere.
A confined space:
• contains a material, such as sawdust or grain, that could engulf anyone who
enters
Examples of confined spaces include wells, silos, pits, cellars, tanks and vessels,
manholes, utility tunnels, culverts, caves, collapsed structures and large-diameter
pipes and ducts.
If, as a responder, you are faced with a confined space incident you must advise the
incident controller the need for Task Force or specialist teams.
You may be able to ventilate the area from the exterior to assist in stabilising the
patients’ condition. This should only be done after seeking expert advice from a
HazMat or Confined Space Technician.
Picture 10. A void from which a survivor was removed following a structural
collapse is an example of a confined space.
Occupancy Interviews
Questioning witnesses and survivors can give clues as to the type of occupancy,
potential or known hazards and provides clear working zones of the building. It also
provides newly arriving teams with an organised operations area.
Information management
When considering the structural collapse potential of buildings, there are five principal
construction types to consider. The references to these types of construction are
common throughout New Zealand, and for that matter most of the world.
• Timber frame
• Reinforced masonry
• Unreinforced masonry
• Concrete tilt-up
• Reinforced concrete and steel frame
These construction types will all react differently when subjected to forces that lead to
a structural collapse. The following descriptions will give you some idea of what to
expect, but there may be large variations due to any combination of factors, but most
importantly, the cause of the structural collapse will have the largest bearing upon
how the building reacts.
Timber frame
There is an extreme risk from fire in these structures due to the abundance of fuel.
Due to their relatively lightweight nature and small size few people are seldom
comprehensively entrapped within timber residential collapsed structure.
Reinforced Masonry
Unreinforced Masonry
Concrete Tilt-up
E.g. Warehouses with large floor areas and some newer medium-rise residential
buildings.
• Walls separate from wood floors / roof causing at least local collapse of the
floor / roof, possible general collapse of walls and floor / roof.
• Suspended wall panels become dislodged and fall off the building.
• During fires and earthquakes, the steel connections that hold the wall panels
to the primary frames can break and cause a pack of cards style collapse
(sequential angle wall collapse).
E.g. Most major new commercial buildings in town centres and cities.
• Columns break at joints with other members
• Reinforcement ties and bars do not confine concrete when subjected to high
shear and compression stress
• Punching shear failure at intersection of slabs and columns
• Precast floor slab units dislodge due to overall structure movement or
inadequate seating
• Weak concrete and poor construction can worsen above hazards
Modern buildings therefore have the ability to deform significantly and still stay up,
whereas earlier buildings are much more vulnerable to sudden, brittle collapse.
Collapse Patterns
There are ten types of possible structural collapse patterns, the first five being the
most common. The remaining five require more specialised training in rescue
techniques, which is beyond the scope of this manual.
These patterns are the types that you are most likely to see as a result of structures
becoming fire damaged, but the patterns are equally recognisable due to any
collapse factor.
A further five collapse patterns may be seen, but rescue following these collapses
usually involves accessing void and confined spaces.
The majority of these structural collapse patterns are based on research and
experience following earthquakes.
It must be stressed that other collapse patterns and a combination of these collapse
patterns may occur. For example, building collapse following an explosion is
dependent on a large number of factors that may or may not be predictable.
Occurs when a wall made of bricks or blocks falls like a curtain, i.e. drops straight
downward.
Occurs when a floor above ground level becomes dislodged from one side of the
structure and falls to the level below.
Occurs when a floor or ceiling gives way in the centre and falls to the floor below.
Occurs when a floor or ceiling gives way in the centre resulting in the opposite of the
" V " type collapse pattern.
Cantilever collapse
Occurs when a piece of floor, ceiling or wall falls landing on a stationary structure and
leaves a large segment hanging over an open area.
Progressive collapse
Occurs when there is an initial failure of a single primary support member. A chain
reaction of failures continues in a downward movement.
• Visual alertness
• Hearing alertness
Visual alertness
Picture 11. Cracks in a wall showing smoke seepage and potential for collapse.
Hearing alertness
• creaking and groaning types of noises coming from the building / structural
elements
• interior explosions, rumbling noises, hissing sounds, electrical arcing
• strong winds
• safety warning signals
The way rescuers are deployed onto a structural collapse or for that matter, any
building on fire, can have an effect on the integrity of a building. The Team Leader
should always monitor the location of rescuers, as should the Safety Officer. Some
points to be particularly aware of are listed below.
Structural collapse can occur for a variety of reasons, which include earthquakes,
faulty construction methods, fires and explosions. The incident may involve single
structures or, as found in many natural disasters, multiple structure damage spread
across a large geographical zone.
Height, design and type of buildings and the magnitude and duration of the
destructive force responsible for the devastation are important factors. Combined,
they determine the severity of damage that can make identification of individual
structures difficult.
The system adopted by New Zealand USAR is the one used in the US and Europe
for identifying locations following both fires and structural collapses. This system
nominates the address, the street or address side of the structure as SIDE 1.
The structure’s interior should be divided into quadrants. The quadrants are identified
alphabetically and in a clockwise manner starting from the area where SIDE 1 and
SIDE 2 perimeters meet.
The central core where all four quadrants meet is designated, as QUADRANT E. It
must be remembered that quadrants do not have to be symmetrical, and can be
altered to suit the needs of the incident.
Floor identification
Structural collapse incidents involving multi-floor structures must have each floor
clearly identified. In the event of a partial or total collapse making this task not clearly
discernible, the floors should be numbered as viewed from the exterior.
The ground floor should be designated GROUND and moving upwards the second
floor designated FLOOR 1 and so on. Conversely, the first floor below ground level
should be B-1, the second B-2 and so on.
Where there are multi-floor access to the building, the ground floor will be designated
by the main entrance. Other entrances such as the rear entrance may be several
floors above or below the main entrance
Structural collapses involving bridges and flyovers can be sectored into manageable
sections along their length. Once again, the size of sectors will be based on the
incident and geography of the area.
COLLAPSED BRIDGE
General cordon markings (cordon banners, flagging, etc.) are to be used for small
defined area. They can be enlarged to include other non-buildings (i.e., bridge,
dangerous zones, security, etc.). Large areas may require barricades/fences/patrol/etc.
Collapse/Hazard Zone
PEL
IGR
O O
IGR
PEL
PE LIG
O RO
IGR
PEL
PEL
IGR
O O
IGR
PEL
Other markings
Facility
All team facilities (medical facility, ICP, etc.) must be identified by team name (Iconic
flags, banners, balloons, etc)
Vehicle
Vehicles must be marked with team name and function (flag, magnetic sign, etc.).
Teams
Response teams must be identified by country and team name (uniform, patch, etc.)
Task Force members will place the markings adjacent to the safe entry point of the
structure. This marking system where appropriate will also occur inside the structure
adjacent to rooms, hallways, stairwells, etc.
“HM” is placed on the outside of the box to indicate hazardous material and an arrow
is located next to the marking to indicate the direction of safe entrance into the
structure should the marking need to be made away from the indicated entrance.
The example below indicates a safe point of entry to the left of the marking. The
structure may require some shoring and/or bracing. The assessment was made on
19 November by New Zealand TF1. There is also a risk of LPG in the building
19 Nov 1730 Hr
HM - LPG
NZ TF1
Since the Second World War and the Blitz experiences' of numerous major cities a
standard plan was designed to ensure those involved in collapse rescue situations
were not prone to indecision and delay. This methodical approach was vital for teams
to perform in a professional manner. Over the passing years this basic plan of initial
action has been updated by numerous emergency agencies, however the basic
standard format still remains very similar to it's original concept. The following is a
developed version of the plan combined into a mnemonic for ease of learning and
remembering by the USAR team member.
When the rescue team arrives at the site the Team Leader should immediately set
his/her team to work attending to surface casualties which are not trapped and not
within the collapsed structure. It may be that surface casualties have already been
removed and in this case the rescuers will be instructed to go rapidly over the area,
working in from the perimeter of damage to check that all such casualties have in fact
been cleared. It is the Team Leader‘s responsibility to ensure that work undertaken
by others is properly completed. Therefore the Team Leader should consider specific
assignments for incoming teams to perform a thorough site survey.
Surface casualties are not generally trapped in any way and would suffer mostly from
injuries inflicted by flying fragments. The work of attending to them or having them
removed could generally be nearing completion when the Team Leader returns from
his/her reconnaissance provided the site is not too large an area.
It must be remembered that the Team Leader of the incident may change as the
incident escalates. For more information on escalating incidents, consult with your
instructor, or refer to your agencies Incident Management System manual.
The following headings summarise the information which the Team Leader should
seek from persons who know the area affected e.g. residents of nearby property
which is unaffected, local Police etc.
The extent of the area of damage that the team must cover needs to take into
account the hazards from damage to public services, e.g. gas, flooding, and
electricity. The nature of the damage and any particular hazards involved must also
be considered and includes leaning roofs and walls, explosives, flammable
substances or radioactive sources.
The Team Leader should consider the removal of casualties, position of ambulance
loading points; position of a temporary mortuary; the use of medical teams etc.
The Team Leader should ensure a rapid tour of damaged buildings where casualties
are trapped is undertaken. He/she should note the various forms of collapse and
attempt to establish the likely position of casualties in the debris. The survey should
form a preliminary plan for the extrication of casualties and develop a sequence of
priorities.
All this must be done rapidly. A reconnaissance at this phase is general in nature and
should not be carried down to minute details. It is important that the Team Leader
should get back to the team as soon as possible and get them operating to a logical
plan. During this initial reconnaissance phase, the Team Leader (if possible) should
be accompanied by a member of the team who can assist in hazard assessment.
Elimination of utilities
Phase II is one of the most important phases and can often be overlooked because
of the scene of carnage often presented to the initial responding teams. It is a vital
assignment of any team to ensure the elimination of all utilities is completed as soon
as possible.
A broken gas pipe leaking flammable gas throughout the area can cause a severe
explosion and possible secondary collapse. Leaking gas can also accumulate in
confined spaces where victims may be trapped thus causing them to become
asphyxiated and possibly die.
Damaged electrical wiring not isolated can cause fires to break out and possible
electrocution of rescuers.
Leaking water can form at lower levels and victims have been known to drown in
these situations. Broken water pipes can cause mortar to form into sludge and cause
possible secondary collapses throughout the debris.
Slightly damaged buildings may be defined as structures in which the floors or roofs
have not collapsed. These should be systematically searched and any injured or
trapped people attended to and removed. Care in approach and entry to this type of
building is important. Floors that are still in position may be precariously supported
and temporary shoring may be required.
If casualties are conscious a 'calling and listening period' may locate them (the Line
and Hail Technique is covered later in this manual). The Team Leader positions
teams along the fringe of the debris near the position where casualties are thought to
be trapped. They lie on the debris and if possible get their heads close to openings
that go down into the debris. The Team Leader calls for silence on the site and if
necessary asks the Police to ensure that silence is maintained while the calling lasts.
Each team member in turn is instructed to call, using terms such as "rescue team
above, can you hear me?" All listen intently for any answering sound from a trapped
casualty and if a reply or knocking sound is heard each rescuer indicates with an
outstretched arm in the direction from which they think the sound originated.
The Team Leader, observing the various bearings given by team members should be
able to estimate the position of the casualty with a good degree of accuracy.
If there is no reply to the rescuers a good tactic is to try knocking on objects such as
steel beams which go deep into the debris. This sound may reach the casualty even
though the calls have failed to do so, and they in turn may be able to knock in reply.
When contact has been established the rescuer must question the casualty (if they
are able to speak). The questions should be confined to ones aimed at receiving
information that will help the Team Leader in forming a strategic plan for the
extrication. The nature of the casualty's injuries, for instance, is often significant in
this regard. How are they trapped? Are there any openings in the walls in their
vicinity? This latter question is of great importance. A lane cleared through the debris
in a straight line towards the casualty, for instance, may bring the rescuers up against
a blank wall. Such a clearance should be aimed at doors or windows or other
openings formed in the walls by the collapse.
Once communication of this kind has been established with a person it should, as far
as it is possible, be maintained for the following reasons:
In this phase rescuers explore all places where trapped casualties might have
survived the collapse even when there is no evidence of the presence of such
casualties. Examples of survival points are:
The rescue teams should make themselves familiar with the different types of
collapse patterns and understand the locations where to start removing debris in an
orderly manner and with the best chances of finding people alive.
It must be noticed that in general the casualty's chance of survival decreases with
each succeeding phase. Many persons buried under debris in this phase will
unfortunately be dead but their positions nevertheless must be explored and all
casualties located before work starts on phase VI.
When rescue teams have gone systematically through the first five phases and there
are still some casualties to be accounted for (or even in cases where parts of bodies
are still missing), the whole area must be stripped of debris until they are recovered.
Unless special orders to the contrary are given, a rescue operation must be carried
on diligently without interruption until phase VI is completed. Every person known or
likely to have been in the building must be accounted for. In the absence of specific
instructions to the contrary there should be no relaxation of effort until this phase is
reached, no matter how long the work may take. It should never be assumed,
because persons have not been extricated after several days' work that they must be
dead and there is no further need for strenuous work. Persons have, in fact, been
recovered alive after being trapped under debris for many days, for example, in the
1976 Terngshan China Earthquake 459 people were rescued alive after 5 days.
It is impossible for even the most experienced USAR team members to tell from an
external inspection of a pile of debris whether casualties buried in the debris will be
alive or not. Even the most tightly packed debris may be quite loose underneath and,
in fact, experience has shown that this is often the case.
When rescue operations are prolonged, work can be carried on continuously only by
employing relays of rescuers working at high pressure for short periods. Only in this
way can the attack be maintained with undiminished effort. Rescuers must not be
allowed, in their own interest or in the interest of the rescue effort, to work until they
are exhausted. Few can carry on rescue work efficiently at really high pressure for a
continuous period of more than about four hours, and even though they may be keen
and willing to work longer, it is much better to bring another team into action to effect
relief.
The question of how many teams can be spared for relief will need to be considered
by the Team Leader. It is his/her duty however, to call for a relief team as soon as
they know the operation is likely to be prolonged and prior to the team starting to
show signs of fatigue.
In this regard the Team Leader must bear in mind that it may take a relief team some
time to arrive because of distance, even if one is immediately available.
As has already been indicated, the Team Leader’s principal duties is to decide on the
best method of tackling the incident and to see that teams and equipment are
employed to the best possible advantage with the minimum risk. The Team Leader of
methods is by no means an easy one largely because it is impossible to foresee
exactly whether or not certain strategies and tactics are going to be the most efficient
until they have been tried. For example, almost insurmountable difficulties may be
encountered in approaching a casualty from one direction whereas, later efforts may
reveal that an approach from another direction is much easier. Difficulties of this kind
cannot be avoided, no matter how good the judgement and experience of the Team
Leader may be.
If sufficient rescuers are available, considerable time can be saved by trying different
approaches simultaneously, although simultaneous action of this kind has the
disadvantage that unless the strictest command and control is maintained by the
Team Leader, the work of one team may endanger the lives of another. Two teams or
half teams working simultaneously in the same site must always be under the
direction of one Sector Team Leader and not be allowed to work independently
` The six phases sequence gives the Team Leader a meaningful checklist and a
helpful order of priorities.
It does not suit every collapse scenario nor is it applicable to widespread areas of
damage where a large number of casualties are involved e.g. mass area earthquake.
It also does not take account of First Aid or Medical priorities; however it is structured
in being used as a starting point for operations to commence and flexible enough in
application to be expanded into an overall large rescue strategy.
Warning Signals
INSARAG warning signals
At any Urban Search and Rescue operation, there needs to be a set of standard,
internationally accepted signals that can be conveyed over the entire area of
operations in case of an emergency. An example may be where another aftershock
occurs or a secondary explosive device is suspected or found.
There also needs to be a signal when search teams require quiet, for example if they
believe they have heard a survivor, and need to fix a bearing on where they are.
The most commonly used apparatus for warning signals is the air horn, either a fixed
model, or a portable rechargeable model.
Search crews will normally have a portable air horn with them in the structure, and
will sound it when required.
Other considerations
You can use whistles, portable air horns or vehicle horns. Ensure everyone is briefed
on the method you will be using
The evacuation signal should be relayed by members of the team to ensure that
everybody on the work site can hear the signal.
During briefing remind the team that only INSARAG signals are to be used, as
different whistle signal systems are used in other rescue disciplines. ASTM Rope
Rescue Standard F1768-97 for down rope = INSARAG evacuate signal for example
The basic symbol consists of a 1-metre X 1-metre square box at the primary access
point into any compromised structure. The marking will identify any known hazards,
whether it is safe to search (G or N), the team name and the start time and date of
the search.
Once a search has been completed a circle is put around the entire search marking
As the incident progresses, further information may indicate that the structure needs
searching again, if this were the case a new search marking would be made by the
new search team.
During the search function, it is necessary to identify the location of any known or
potential victim. The amount and type of debris in the area may completely cover or
obstruct the location of the known or potential victim. The victim location markings are
made by the Search Team or other individuals conducting search and rescue
operations whenever a known or potential victim is located and not immediately
removed.
The victim location markings should be made with florescent colour, preferably
‘International orange’
Draw a large "V" near the location of the known or potential victim. The letter “L” with a
number will denote the number of live victims. The letter “D” with a number will denote
the number of dead victims.
Draw an arrow beside the "V" when the location of a victim has been confirmed either
visually, vocally or hearing specific sounds, which would indicate a high probability of a
victim. This may be done when the victim is initially located or may need to be done
later after some debris removal or use of specialised search equipment. A canine alert
will initially receive the "V" without an arrow to indicate a potential victim.
Draw a horizontal line through the “V” to indicate only dead victim(s) remain.
A circle would be drawn around the "V" when all victims have been extricated from that
location.
Rubble Crawl
When a rescue team arrives at a structural collapse incident one of the first
considerations for the Team Leader is surface casualties who are not trapped and
not within the collapsed structure. Where it is safe to do so, rescue teams can
remove these victims to the casualty staging area. Surface casualties are not
generally trapped in any way and are usually suffering from injuries caused by flying
fragments.
Picture 12. Highlights three points of contact with rubble and correct safety
gear.
Under the direction of the Team Leader the line moves 2 -3 metres forward into the
rubble pile and all rescuers crouch with their heads as low as possible. Rescuer No 1
shouts the rescue call, “RESCUE TEAM ABOVE; CAN YOU HEAR ME?" The entire
rescue team listens for a response for 15 - 20 seconds. If nothing is heard rescuer No
1 will shout, “NOTHING HEARD”
This is the cue for No 2 to shout the rescue call and again, the rescue team listens for
a response, then rescuer No 3 shouts the rescue call, and so on. Once all rescue
team members have shouted the rescue call and nothing has been heard, the line
moves forward 1.5 - 2 metres and the evolution is repeated. A large area of collapse
can be covered using the audible search method.
Rescuers who hear a call or any other noise coming from the collapse site must raise
their arm until acknowledged by Team Leader. They must then point with their arm
fully extended in the direction they believe the noise is coming from and remain in
that position until otherwise directed by the Team Leader. The Team Leader can then
move individual team members to pinpoint the source of the noise.
During an audible search all unnecessary noise must be kept to a minimum. It must
also be remembered that metal is an excellent conductor of sound. A person trying to
attract attention below the rubble surface may tap steel RSJ with a piece of broken
concrete or other hard object. The tapping sound at surface level, depending on the
collapse may be several metres away from the victim. It is worthwhile during the
audible search for rescuers to tap any protruding steel structural members with a
hard object and listen for a response.
Casualties found buried or partly buried must be approached with extreme caution. It
can be difficult to determine if these casualties are in a vertical or horizontal position
below the rubble. Debris removal must start a few metres from, and around, the
casualty. This prevents rescuers standing on any unseen parts of the casualty just
below the debris if he/she is in a horizontal position and provides a reasonable step-
down distance if the casualty is in a vertical position.
Picture 13. Category 2 Urban Search and Rescue operators preparing for a line
and hail search.
Identify casualties as soon as possible and mark the victim's location with a ‘V’
painted in orange paint. The bottom of the ‘V’ should point towards the victim. It is
important to mark the victim's location, for you may at any stage be evacuated or
relieved from the area, and a different crew may be assigned to remove the victim.
Ask the victim if they know of any other victims and where they are or were located.
Always consider the possibility of Crush Syndrome for trapped casualties and
conduct basic First Aid requirements as required.
Stretcher Walk
Casualties should only be moved in a stokes litter, stretcher or other carrying device.
Rescuers, working in a team of seven can use one member to “scout” in front of the
carrying team when removing victims from a structure. This person selects the
easiest route, identifies any hazards and informs the team. Keep in mind that the
shortest route may not always be the easiest.
The carrying team, working three members each side, pass the stretcher forward,
hand-over-hand, allowing the rear two members to release their hold of the stretcher
and carefully move to the front of the team whilst the other four members bear the
weight of the victim.
Clear, loud orders such as “BREAKING”, “SAFE”, and “PASSING” must be given
during the operation. Team members need to rest at regular intervals and maintain
their fluid levels. Protect and reassure the casualty during the rescue, know where
the patient staging area is located before you commence return and relay relevant
information to the Team Leader via situation reports (SITREP).
When breaking from the stretcher and moving forward, never lean on crewmembers
holding the litter to support yourself. You may stumble and possibly cause the
member supporting you to fall as well and as a consequence the rescue crew may
drop the stretcher and victim.
Further Reading
Some specialist rescue teams in New Zealand use a Colour Light Stick coding
system for night operations, this however is not an internationally approved coding
system and some countries have their own system which differ from the system
below.
Colour Use
Operational Briefings
Often briefings are not given because the event seems so insignificant that the
briefing would seem ‘over the top’ and a source of ridicule. With the benefit of
hindsight it would have, in a number of situations been beneficial.
Give the team enough information on the current activity to enable them to complete
their tasks. If this is a continuation from a previous activity then it may only include an
update on that briefing.
When covering the terrain also mention the current location. Should you or a member
of your team suffer harm it is important that other team members know where to
direct other emergency crews to for assistance
Ensure your team is advised of risks that they may have to deal with, e.g. tide times,
gas, power, unstable or slippery surfaces, etc.
Mission
This is a concise statement of what is to be achieved by the team and is for the
particular briefing been given. You should state the mission and then restate it again;
your team must leave the briefing knowing what the mission is.
Execution
Give a brief overview of how the mission will be achieved. Describe each persons
role and what they are to do, but keep it simple. Cover details like sequencing of
events, priorities, key timings, etc.
This section covers essential administration and logistic information regarding the
mission. It may contain information on vehicles, equipment, stores, forms to be
completed and even when lunch is.
Give details on who is in charge and whom the team or members within the team are
to report to. You should cover how reporting to the person in charge should take
place, i.e. by whom, through what process and when.
When covering communication you may wish to remind the team of light stick
colours, radio call signs, phone and fax numbers, whistle and evacuation signals, etc.
Questions
It is important to ask the team if they have any questions to ensure they understand
their role. Once all the questions are answered it is important to check their
understanding of the briefing. This can be achieved by asking several team members
questions about what was covered in the briefing. If the person giving the briefing has
learned the Pose, Pause, Pounce, Praise method of questioning, it should be used.
The use of the SMEACQ format for briefings can be great time saver as well as a
checklist for the team leader. It should be used in any situation where a briefing is
required.
• Briefings should be brief but to the point , it is not a discussion on what should be
done or a detailed guide on how to perform each task
• Have the team take notes as they may have to relay the briefing to other
members of your team as they arrive
Team effectiveness
Each person at an USAR incident must realise that there are a number of roles that
combine to make an effective USAR team. In particular, the Incident Controller has a
number of roles that increase with the size of the incident.
An example of the need for USAR teamwork was the bombing of the Alfred P Murrah
building in Oklahoma City, 1995. The rescue operations at this incident involved 682
USAR Trained personnel, 20 search dogs, 460,000 pounds of rescue equipment,
1000 Oklahoma City Fire Department members, and 100's of Local and State Police
and Federal Agents. The co-ordination and control of an incident of this magnitude
requires effective teamwork at all levels of the operation.
Each individual who responds to a USAR incident will have a different role to play
that is dependent upon their agency’s role. These roles are primarily legislative, and
will be in accordance with each agency’s SOP's.
Effective teamwork
In order to achieve effective teamwork, there are three sets of needs that have to be
present. These are:
Task Needs
Team Needs
Individual Needs
Task needs are the successful concluding of the incident itself, and the task you will
be required to perform based on legislation, resources, training etc.
Team needs are how you fulfil your role as a team member, and what your team is
required to do.
Individual needs are how you perform at the incident, and how you cope with the
work and stress of the incident.
One of the problems that face any team is that each individual may have a different
perception of how these three needs fit together.
For example, at an incident, one person's perception may be like the diagram below,
with their task needs being the dominant factor.
Another's perception may have a greater emphasis on the team as shown in the
diagram below.
This is called personal paradigms and means that each individual has a different
perception of the incident based on how they feel, their experience, what they know
and what they have been told.
The role of the Team Leader is to ensure that each part balances, and when
combined with the personal traits of the individual, the team is working towards
reaching the objectives set by the Incident Controller.
This requires you to understand where you fit into the overall team, to understand
that your perception of an incident may not be the same as that of the Incident
Controller, and that you are a part of a team working towards an overall objective.
For example, when you arrive at an incident, the relationship may look like the
diagram below with the greatest emphasis being on the task at hand.
But after four or five days at an incident, as you become tired and stressed, the
relationship between the parts may begin to look like the diagram below as your
individual needs become greater.
In order to ensure that the overall incident objectives are always met, Team Leaders
will need to continually monitor their team and how their three sets of needs are
balanced.
It needs to be impressed upon all individuals who attend an incident, that not every
individual team member can be working at the 'coal face' conducting rescues. Your
agency will have a role, and through your agency, your role will be defined. All of this
In summary, each person has an individual role that helps ensure that the overall
incident objectives are met. Despite these different roles, you are still a part of a
team, achieving its task.
In theory, the ideal balance of task team and individual needs should appear like the
circles shown below.
In order to effectively manage an USAR incident, the Incident Controller and each
Team Leader, must be aware of the way individuals approach their work. Dr Susan
Segal has identified four different approaches that people have to work, these are:
Bullets
Give job progress
Not good managers
Task oriented
Make things happen
Risk takers
Willing to compromise
Motivated by results
Diggers
Like information in writing
Do not like quick decisions
Need proof of everything
Very thorough
Will not compromise
Needs lot of time to think
Motivated by recognition as an expert
Involvers
There to promote harmony
Think about people and likely reactions
Make people rather than task things happen
Will compromise
Motivated by acceptance and belonging
Dreamers
Innovative lateral thinkers
Creative
Their thought processes are conceptual
Can facilitate change
Not good at implementation
Usually generate enthusiasm
Dislike detail
Motivated by recognition or ego.
Each person will have an assigned job at an incident, whether that is medical
support, logistical support, or rescuer. In addition to how you approach your work as
an individual, the team that you form a part of will go through various phases before it
is able to function effectively.
Phases of Teamwork
Tucklan's model for teams defines four specific stages that a team will go through
when they are put together. The first four phases that any team goes through are:
This is the stage where the team comes together, establishes a structure and
identifies common goals.
This is the stage where conflict occurs normally due to the issues of autonomy within
the group, and dependence on the group.
This is the stage where group goals are re established and group norms appear and
are reinforced. Definite roles will appear for members that help the group to function
effectively. If roles are defined before an incident, this phase can be reached quicker.
This is the stage where group energy is now being channelled into the task. This is
when the designated leader begins to take a less active and more supporting role.
These four phases will always occur to varying degrees whenever a team is formed.
Sometimes teams never progress beyond the storming phase, and as a result,
incident objectives cannot be met.
The final phase that some teams will go through is called the mourning stage, when
the incident is over and the teamwork is no longer required. This is a topic beyond
the scope of this manual, and is an issue for Critical Incident Stress Debriefing
(CISD) teams.
In addition to these four phases, there are another four phases that the formed team
will go through. These phases relate directly to the four phases of teamwork and are:
The aim is a clear statement of what the team has to achieve in order to solve the
problem. The aim must be clear, concise, achievable, and expressed in positive
terms. The aim will form the mission statement in an operational briefing and should
be as simple as: “To rescue the casualty from the bottom of the lift shaft”.
Factors are points relevant to the problem that has to be solved. Some factors that
may have to be considered in an operational situation are:
• Number and location of casualties
• Time and space
• Topography
• Weather
• Available resources, both personnel and equipment
• Support requirements and availability
• Communications
• Logistics
• Priority of tasks.
Each factor will lead to one or more logical deductions, so that the leader should be
in a position to say: “If this is the case – then…”
Each factor should be thoroughly examined and care should be taken not to
introduce irrelevant facts into the examination.
All possible courses that will attain the aim and that are practical must be considered
in the ‘Courses Open’ segment. Only facts dealt with in the ‘Factors’ should be
considered and no new material should be introduced at this stage.
At this stage, a choice must be made from one of the possible solutions developed by
the appreciation process. If more than one workable solution is produced and the
best course is not obvious, the following criteria should be applied to each:
Risk — Which solution carries the least risk factor in its execution, or the
consequence of failure?
Simplicity — Which is the simplest course?
Time — If urgency is a factor, which course can be completed in the shortest time?
Economy — In the terms of resources, which solution imposes the least demand?
The plan will result from the choice of the best course open. That is, it will be the
best solution to the problem with the most advantages and the least disadvantages.
The plan must be simple, and it must relate directly to the aim. When completed, the
plan should be checked against the following test questions:
• Is the reasoning sound?
• Is it set out in a logical order?
• Is everything relevant to the problem?
• Has anything relevant been left out?
• Is it free of uncertainties or ambiguities?
• Is it accurate (positions, timings and so on)?
• Has the aim been kept in mind throughout?
• Can the plan achieve the aim?
Continuing Action
Having made decisions and deployed personnel, Team Leaders must ensure
reconnaissance is continued with a view to allocating priorities for the further
deployment of resources.
Attempt to locate and identify the parts of the building and especially those parts in
which casualties are reported to be. This will provide a rough idea where casualties
might be found in relation to the various parts of the damaged structure.
At times such as this, a leader will need to call upon all accumulated experience and
training and combine them with effective decision-making
Acknowledgements
Developed by
Manager
Steve Glassey
Project Manager – USAR CAT 1 Course Development
New Zealand Fire Service – Training Systems
National USAR Training Standards Committee
Author
Shane Briggs
Private Contractor to New Zealand Fire Service – Training Systems
On Behalf of
Technical Editors
Ian Craig
USAR Technician (NZ TF-2)
National USAR Standards Committee
Environment Canterbury Civil Defence
Bernie Rush
Dave Brunsden
Structural Engineer
National USAR Steering Committee
Editor
Daphne Sutton
Acknowledgements
The author and project manager wishes to thank the following individuals and
organisations that have contributed to the development of this manual.
Bernie Rush, Jim Dance, Ian Craig, David Brunsden, Des Bull, Trevor Brown, Leonce
Jones, David Guard, Graeme Mills, Charles Ollivier, Daphine Sutton, Geoff Williams
and the following organisations:
Photos