12 False Christian Assumptions

This series of home group lessons is derived from the

book 12 Christian Beliefs That Can Drive You Crazy
by Henry Cloud and John Townsend. There are
twelve lessons in the series, each exploring one of
these so-called Christian beliefs, which are actually
false assumptions. We highly recommend this book,
since we have observed that these beliefs are
strongly held by many apostolic people. We hope you
find this series to be helpful.

This series is provided for the edification of the church and is offered
without charge.
Theme: 12 False Christian Assumptions
Lesson 1. Its selfish to have my needs met.
To the teacher: After studying this outline and reading each of the Scriptures, summarize in one
or two sentences what you have determined to be the main point that you hope to communicate to
the group:
Read Job 30:25-27
Sarah was having a terrible day. Well actually a terrible life. Exhausted and
lonely one day, she flipped on the radio and tuned in to her favorite Christian
station. So youre down, troubled, lonely, youre under crushing pressure. You
wonder if things will ever change for you, the pastor was saying. Is he reading my
mind? She thought, turning up the volume. Theres an answer, he announced.
Stop thinking of yourself and start thinking of others! Get off the pity pot. Repent of
your self-absorption and find peace in sharing. Sarahs heart dropped. Peace in
sharing? Ive been sharing myself all weekend, and Im in pieces, not at peace. She
immediately felt guilty for her thoughts. I guess hes right, she thought bleakly. Im
just being selfish. As she flipped through her church bulletin to find another
committee to volunteer for, she despaired about herself and her life.
Every day, well-intentioned ministers teach this same crazy-making, false
Christian assumption: Its selfish to have my needs met. On the surface
this principle sounds Christian, but a deeper look reveals just the opposite.
Its like someone saying, I saw you at the gas station last night filling your
cars tank. You need to be filling other peoples tanks with that gas .
Jesus values our needs. In fact, He created us to be needy to help us
to grow and be closer to Him. He intended for us to be incomplete in and of
ourselves. He made us to be relationally dependent on Him and His body.
He made us in such a way that we must reach out to survive.
Read Matthew 5:3-6
Jesus is describing some needy people in these verses. But is he
criticizing them for having needs? No. Hes meeting their needs. Jesus
wants people with needs. These needs draw us closer to Him and to other
people. Our needs help us to be humble, since we cant do it on our own.
Our needs help us to grow because they force us to realize that we must
look to God for the answers to our needs. His answers lead us to maturity,
attaining to the whole measure of the fullness of Christ (Ephes ians 4:13).
Our needs help us to be real.
Read Matthew 7:17-18
If God built us to have needs, then letting those needs go unmet can
cause major problems in our lives. Just as neglecting regular oil changes
will destroy your cars engine, neglecting our God-given, legitimate needs
will cripple us. Bad fruits or symptoms are Gods way of letting us know that
something is wrong. Feelings of depression, anxiety, eating disorders,
compulsive behaviors, and the like are all symptoms of a deeper problem.
These symptoms let us know that we are not getting our needs met.
Read 2 Corinthians 1:3-4 and Luke 7:36-47
The most comforting people in the world are those who have been
comforted; the most loving people in the world are those who have been
loved. Its not surprising that John, the apostle who Jesus loved most, later
became known as the apostle of love. Jesus demonstrated this principle in
Luke 7. The woman, a sinner who found forgiveness, was able to love
much, while Simon the Pharisee, who was blind to his own neediness, was
unable to love. We mus t acknowledge our needs and bring them to the feet
of the Master in order to love Him and other people with genuine love.
Discussion Questions:
1. Have you ever heard this crazy-making, false Christian assumption
before? Did you believe it? How do you feel about it now?
2. How are needs pleasing to God? Name some positive results of
admitting needs to God and others and asking for help.
! Our needs draw us closer to Him, help us to be humble, connect us
to other people, help us grow to m aturity.
3. W hy would people feel uncomfortable about admitting their needs to
others and asking for help?
! Pride; thinking that asking for help is not pleasing to God; grew up
learning to be self reliant; fear that no one will care enough to help; fear
of being ridiculed for not being able to do it themselves.
4. Describe what you think would be appropriate and inappropriate ways
of asking God and others for what you need.
! Appropriate: asking with a right attitude, asking with the right motives
(not asking amiss, James 4:3), asking with an understanding of what
God and others can and should do.
! Inappropriate: demanding help from others through hostility or
pouting; expecting others to read your mind; asking for help when you
dont need it (knapsac k vs. boulder).
5. Are you experiencing any bad fruit or symptoms in your life that
indicate that your needs are not being met? Are you asking for help? If
you are not asking for help, what do you think is holding you back?
It is not selfish to have your needs met. Jesus created us to be needy
so that we would draw close to Him and other people.
Theme: 12 False Christian Assumptions
Lesson 2. If Im spiritual enough, Ill have no pain
or sin.
To the teacher: After studying this outline and reading each of the Scriptures, summarize in one
or two sentences what you have determined to be the main point that you hope to communicate to
the group:
Ted was discouraged. In fact, he felt so depressed that he wondered if he
really were a Christian. To fight against his feelings of depression, he
increased his Bible study and listened to all the spiritual life tapes he could
get his hands on. But he only felt more depressed. Because of some things
he had been taught in church, Ted believed that his feelings of depression
mus t be the result of a spiritual failure.
Like many Christians, Ted subs cribed to this false as sumption: If Im
spiritual enough, I will have no pain or imperfections. People who live
under the cloud of this assumption see only two options: 1) try harder at the
spiritual disciplines; or 2) give up on the spiritual life altogether. Perhaps
the best-known individual who learned this spiritual lesson was Job.
Read Job 7:15
W e see here that Bro. Job was not living the abundant life.
Read Job 8:3-6, 11:13-16
Jobs infamous friends came along with these words of comfort: you
suffer because you sin. If you are truly good, you wont hurt. If you depend
wholly on God and stay away from sin, your pain will go away. In other
words, get your act together, and then God will bless you.
Read Job 42:7
But God did not agree with the message Jobs friends preached. God
tells us that we encounter pain and imperfection within ourselves, others,
and the world every day. Being a Christian doesnt exempt us from
problems. W e will have tribulation in this world, but through Jesus we can
overcome.
Read Psalms 139:23-24
There are three common ways that we try to avoid pain and owning our
own imperfection. The first is denial: pretending the sin or pain is not
there. This leads to discouragement, anxiety, and criticizing others for
things w e deny in ourselves. W e dont need to fear our badness, God is big
enough to handle it. The second way is works: working harder to make up
for our faults, improve ourselves, and ease our guilt. Works tend to produce
a false image of spirituality, lead to legalism, and become empty rules. The
third way is law: condemning our badness, feeling guilty about it, and
getting angry at it. The Bible is very clear about the destructiveness of guilt.
God has set us free from the law of sin and death through grac e.
This false assumption leads to bad fruits such as feelings of failure,
wasted energy, hiding, unforgiveness, and lack of love.
Read 1 John 1:8 and Mark 7:20-23
Being an imperfect human being is normalit is reality. Failure is also
normal. When you find in yourself the things Jesus mentioned in Mark 7,
dont fear them, own them. God is gracious. W e need to accept the
presenc e of badness within us.
Read Psalms 62:8 and James 5:16
W e must confess and forsake our sins. W e must also take our pain
our sadness, grief, hurt, abandonment, woundedness, and rejectionto
God and to others where it can be loved and healed. After we have
received grace we must give it in the form of forgiving those who have
wronged us.
Discussion Questions:
1. Did you ever believe that once you became a Christian you should not
experience any more painthat you would somehow be perfect?
W hen you did experience these things, how did you feel? How do you
feel now, in light of this teaching?
2. W hy would people refuse to accept the badness inside themselves?
W hy do people think that God does not accept the badness inside
them? What is the difference between acceptance and approval?
3. How might uncovering sins such as those Jesus mentioned in Mark 7
actually show that a person is growing in God rather than backsliding?
4. Have you ever found yourself avoiding sinful tendencies and pain
within yourself by denying it, doing works, or condemning it with the
law? What kind of fruit did it produce in your life?
5. Do you feel comfortable pouring your heart out before God and other
people? W hy or why not?
Because Go d accepts our fallenness, w e can too. W e dont need to
hide from it anymore. We must take our pain and imperfection to God
and to each other where we will find healing that leads to love and
good deeds.
Theme: 12 False Christian Assumption
Lesson 3. If I change my behavior, I will grow
spiritually and emotionally
To the teacher: After studying this outline and reading each of the Scriptures, summarize in one
or two sentences what you have determined to be the main point that you hope to communicate to
the group:
Deeply discouraged, Debra approached her house knowing what awaited on the
inside: resentful children and a critical husband. No one in the family was getting
along, and she shouldered a lot of the blame. Reaching out for help, Debra confided
in the wife of an elder in the church. The older woman told her, Emotions follow
behaviors. If you act loving, youll feel loving. The Bible tells us to put on the new
self. That means to behave like a loving Christian. Then youll feel like a loving
Christian. Though it seemed dishonest to act differently than she felt, Debra took
the womans advice. While her husband and the kids enjoyed her bright attitude,
Debra still felt depressed.
Read Philippians 1:9-11
Over and over again, the Bible points out that our actions are the result
of spiritual change, not the cause of it. Good behavior is the cart, not the
horse. Changes in behavior indicate that God is doing an invisible, internal
work within us. Destructive behaviors are not the causes of bad attitudes;
they are the result of the hearts sinful condition. Positive behavior comes
from Gods work in our hearts. This is why changing only our behaviors
confuses fruits with roots.
Read Matthew 23:25-26
In essence, Debras older friend told her to pretend to love others.
Covering up the resentment with spiritual behavior sounds frighteningly
sim ilar to what Jesus rebuked the P harisees for. God is more interested in
searching our hearts to get to the root of our sin than He is in meticulous
correctness on the outside. And He knows the outcome of pretending.
Years and years of trying to behave right with little or no connectedness to
God and others leads to despair. The very fact that we are Christians
signifies that we have problems or else Jesus w ouldnt have needed to die
for us.
Read Romans 11:33-36
The good behavior approach to living for God also places the power
of change squarely on our shoulders. This behavior denies the power of
the Cross. Changing ones behavior in order to change ones heart also
fosters a proud, omnipotent, self-dependency that leaves God out of the
picture.
Read Philippian s 2:12-13 and Psalms 1:1-3
How should we behave then? In the Bible, God continually compares
our spiritual maturity to how plants thrive. Herein is the answer: instead of
attempting to fix our symptoms, we must actively take ourselves to good
nutrients. Just as a tree planted in rich soil can flourish, so can we expose
ourselves to Gods healing resources. This is how we take personal
responsibility for our spiritual growth. W e dont make ourselves grow, we
connect to the One W ho can make us grow.
Read Psalms 139:23-24
Actions can be confusing and are not accurate guideposts of spiritual
growth unless they are correctly interpreted. What seems like good behavior
on the surface may be motivated by fear or pride rather than love. And what
seems like bad behavior on the surface may indicate that God is bringing the
hidden things of the heart out of hiding and into relationship with Him. W hat
appear to be dangerous and even bad periods in some lives c an actually
bring them closer to the Lord becaus e these individuals are being honest with
God from the heart rather than fearfully complying on the outside.
Discussion Questions:
1. W hy isnt good behavior a valid cause of spiritual growth? How would
believing this false assumption affect a believers life?
2. W hy do you think God is more concerned with our heart motives than
our outward behaviors?
! Because we can do everything right on the outside, but inside have
wrong motives (ex. The Pharisees); right actions that dont come from
the heart inhibit our relationship with God and others; doing right
fosters pride, and God cant draw close to the proud.
3. How could bad behavior indicate a good change in a persons heart?
! Hidden things are finally being exposed to the light of God and being
brought into relationship with Him.
4. How can wrongly judging outward behavior (your own or someone
elses) interfere with the work God is doing in a persons heart?
! W e can either praise someone who behaves good when it may be
a pretense OR w e can condem n someone behaving badly and thwart
Gods effort to bring sin into safe relationship.
5. How does your behavior reflect the work of God in your life? Are your
good behaviors motivated by love? Are your bad behaviors motivated
by God cleansing your heart?
Behavior change is the result of spiritual grow th, no t the cause of it!
Even in the times wh en your beh avior feels out of control, God is still
doing a deep w ork in your character and changing you on the inside.
Theme: 12 False Christian Assumptions
Lesson 4. I just need to give it to the Lord.
To the teacher: After studying this outline and reading each of the Scriptures, summarize in one
or two sentences what you have determined to be the main point that you hope to communicate to
the group:
Alcoholism had cost Dennis two large businesses and two families. After
each loss he built his life anew but was unable to sustain it. His life was
bleak and no one believed he could ever change. But Dennis is a different
man today. He is a successful businessman, a faithful husband, a loving
father, and a good friend. And he has maintained this lifestyle for two
decades. When ask ed how he made his amazing turnaround, Dennis
answ ers dryly, It wasnt hard. I w ent to seven AA meetings a day.
Read Philippians 2:12-13
Dennis restoration from alcoholism didnt just drop out of the sky. He
worked very hard for it. Although AA is not the place to turn for spiritual
answers, the principle is that God requires us to be partners in the
business of our spiritual growth. According to Paul, we are co-laborers with
God in working out our salvation. Many times, however, we adopt a passive
attitude toward spiritual growth, assuming incorrectly that all we need to do
is give it to the Lord. When we adopt this passive attitude and do not
perceive that we are partners with God in cultivating our spiritual growth,
we will eventually find ourselves in a spiritual rut.
Read Ephesians 1:3
There are a couple false assumptions that a Christian can adopt that
will keep him from growing. One stems from this verse. Some believe that if
we really knew what God has secured for us in the heavenly realms, we
would be transformed into a state of wholeness. W e wouldnt have to deal
with the past, with pain, or with brokenheartedness. They teach that you
just have to focus on your position in Christ.
Read Numbers 33:51-53,55
God has secured for us every spiritual blessing. But if we are to
possess these blessings, we must fight the good fight of faith with Him.
W hen we refuse or neglect to be partners w ith Him in our spiritual growth,
we deny our responsibility for the processthe responsibility to face our
pain and the issues that caused the pain.
Read Matthew 7:5 and 1 Corinthians 11:28
Another false teaching is one that says, Introspection is self-worship.
Just focus on the Lord, or Stop thinking of yourself. There is a vast
difference between self-worship and a godly examination of ourselves.
W henever a person encounters God he is forced to look inside himself and
see his sin and brokenness. W hen Isaiah saw the Lord, the very next thing
he saw was his own sinfulness. Those who teach us to get our minds off
ourselves are actually teaching us to avoid the process of our own
cleansing and healing.
Read 1 Timothy 4:15
God has given us an arsenal of at least a dozen things we can do to be
active partners with Him in our spiritual growth process. We are able to: 1)
Own our own problems; 2) Confess our failures to God and others; 3) Ask
for help from God and others; 4) Ask God to reveal what is in our souls; 5)
Turn from the evil we discover inside ourselves; 6) Discover what needs
were not met in our biological families and then take those needs to the
family of God where they can be met; 7) Seek out those whom we have
injured and, when it is helpful, apologize, admit our wrong, and ask
forgiveness; 8) Forgive others who have hurt us; 9) Develop the gifts and
talents that God has given to us; 10) Continue seeking God; 11) Seek for
truth and wisdom; 12) Follow Gods example of love. This is working out
salvation with fear and trembling. This is pressing toward the mark.
Discussion Questions
1. Have you ever heard the false assumption, I just need to give it to the
Lord? Did you believe it and act on it? What do you think about it now?
2. W hy would it be tempting to live according to this false assumption?
3. Des cribe some natural examples of the spiritual principle that w e are
co-laborers with God in cultivating our spiritual growth. (ex. God
supplies the rain, sunshine, and soil, but a farmer has to go out and
plant seeds, care for his crop, and eventually harvest the crop).
4. Of the list of 12 actions with which we can work out our salvation,
which action do you find the easiest? W hich do you find most difficult to
take? W hy?
5. In which situation in your life do you need to be a more active partner
with God? W hat have you just given to the Lord that needs to be
worked on by both you and God?
In order to grow spiritually, we must be active co-laborers with Jesus
in the process.
Theme: 12 False Christian Assumptions
Lesson 5. One day, Ill be done growing
spiritually
To the teacher: After studying this outline and reading each of the Scriptures, summarize in one
or two sentences what you have determined to be the main point that you hope to communicate to
the group:
Read 2 Timothy 4:7-8
Spiritual growth is not like changing a burned-out light bulb. Take the
bad one out, pop the new one in. Fix an irrational fear. Cure a compulsive
spending problem. Repair an anxiety attack. Spiritual growth takes time
and continues throughout life. Although God Himself is a finisher It is
finished! (John 19:30)w e must be patient with ourselves and others
while spiritual problems are being worked on. We must be patient in the
face of our continuing sinfulness and immaturity. W e will finish our course
in life just as Paul did, but we will never finish growing in the grace and
knowledge of Jesus Chris while we are here on earth.
Read 2 Corinthians 3:18
W e are made in the image of God. But when man sinned in the Garden
of Eden, the image was tarnished severely. Once we are born again and
living for God, we are in the process of growing the image of God in
ourselves so that we can be like Him. All of this growing is spiritual growth if
it involves the biblical process of love, responsibility, and forgiveness. If the
process produces a cheerful heart, concern for others, a deeper sense of
respons ibility, and an ability to set limits on evil, then it is a spiritual growth
process.
Read 1 Timothy 1:5
The goal of the spiritual growth process is love, not finishing a task.
This one day I will be finished false assumption forces a person to
focus on the lawfinishing the journeyrather than the spirithow you
are going about the journey. It drives a person toward the taskmaster of
perfection, and arriving at perfection becomes the demand that breaks the
persons back. In fact, love is not only the goal, it is the process of
achieving the goal. Learning to trust, to extend our heart, to take ownership
over our resistance to lovethese are all part of the spiritual growth
process. W hen we focus on finishing, we lose sight of the goal.
Read Romans 8:1
Spiritual growth is full of bumps and bruises. W e take a step, make a
mistake, learn from it, and make a more educ ated s tep. W e blunder,
confess, repent, and learn from our painful consequenc es. A nd since there
is no condemnation in Christ Jesus we are never alienated from love in all
of our errors and outright sins. If there were no grace to catch us when we
fall, we wouldnt risk making a mistake. The cost of failure would be too
high. People who are told to just get their lives together and get well are
robbed of Gods forgiveness. They are given no room for trial and error, for
risk and learning. There is no room for growth built on love. When we focus
only on finishing, we lose forgiveness.
Read Luke 18:9-14 and Matthew 5:48
If we believe that one day we will be finished with our spiritual growth,
our tendency will be to become proud and self-sufficient. We deny our
unfinished bus iness; we deny that we are beggars w ho need to daily cry
out to God for the grace to help us with our problems. W hen Jesus
commanded us to be perfect, he commanded us to be mature or complete,
not to never make a mistake. God wants a grown-up, not a perfectionist.
Read Proverbs 13:12
If we believe that one day we will be done growing spiritually, we will
eventually despair. Failure and regression are normal parts of spiritual
growth. If you were to chart the spiritual growth process, it wouldnt look
like a straight, ascending line. It would look like a zigzagging line full of hills
and valleys. If Paul was the chief of sinners, if Peter denied the Lord, if the
murderer and adulterer David is remembered as a man after Gods own
heart, then we must give up the idealized picture of ourselves and allow our
imperfect selves to be forgiven, loved, and m atured.
Discussion Questions:
1. In your own words, describe the goal of spiritual growth.
2. W hat are some results of focusing on the end of spiritual growth rather
than the process itself?
3. Do you focus more on finishing your spiritual growth or on growing? If
so, what results of focusing on finishing have you experienced?
4. Do you feel driven to perfection? W here do you think that motivation
comes from?
5. How can the Church become a place where people feel safe to
spiritually grow at their own pace?
Instead of asking, A m I finish ed grow ing spiritually yet? L earn to
ask, Whats next on my journey, as I am known by God and others?
The endpoint and the journey is loving and being loved.
Theme: 12 False Christian Assumptions
Lesson 6. Leave the past behind.
To the teacher: After studying this outline and reading each of the Scriptures, summarize in one
or two sentences what you have determined to be the main point that you hope to communicate to
the group:
Read Philippians 3:13-14
Many have used this passage to prove the false assumption that we
should leave the past behind, or leave the past in the past. But what
Paul has left behind is not the hurts or situations that require him to forgive
someone, neither is it his old sins. The past that Paul is forgetting is his old
way of trying to achieve righteousness. Hes leaving the old system behind.
Paul is not saying in this passage, let bygones by bygones. On the
contrary, this man models the act of bringing ones past to the Light and
confes sing it.
Read Ephesians 5:13
Instead of covering up the past, we are to expose the deeds of
darkness in our past so that they do not affect us now and in the future. W e
are to uncover feelings and hurts from the past and we are to uncover
hidden motives generated by past relationships. For example, a man who
is highly ambitious may be trying to gain the approv al of other people.
Read Ephesians 4:32
Unless we look at the past, we cannot truly forgive because
forgiveness deals with the past. The hurt and abuse people faced as
children surface later in relationships and behaviors that often result from
unforgiveness. For example, Tom constantly argued with his superiors over
trivial matters. He made an issue of everything and always had to have the
last word. As he explored this problem, he realized that he was trying to
settle an old score with his father who had put young Tom down whenever
they talked and always had to have the upper hand in conversations.
Read 2 Corinthians 6:11-13
Grieving is the process of letting go of things we were once attached to,
which opens the door to life. W hen we deliberately release our attachment to
persons, goals, wishes, or religious systems, we open the door to new and
better things that God has for us. We are no longer restricted by our affections
for things we can no longer have. Too many people experience loss but never
grieve. This obstructs the healing process because there is no outlet for
emotions such as sorrow or anger. The result is depression. Though grieving
is painful for the moment, it is necessary to avoid the long-lasting pain of
depression. Grieving is letting go of the past, cleansing, and. healing.
Read 2 Chronicles 30:7-8 and 1 John 1:9
To repent we must understand the past. The Old Testament records
several times when God confronted the people for walking in the wicked
ways of their fathers. They were repeating generational sins, and He called
them to repentance. People who deny the sins of their fathers are destined
to repeat them. They hurt their own children as they themselves were hurt.
Insight and confession break the chain of generational sin and give
hope. If we confes s the wicked ways we learned in our early years and turn
from them, God will honor our repentance. Then we will enjoy the freedom
that comes from walking in the light of God and not repeating inherited
patterns of darkness.
Similarly, if we find personal sin in our past that we alone are responsible
for, then we must confess it to God and others. W e then need to make
amends with anyone that we have wronged by apologizing and seeking
reconciliation. God is serious about the way we treat each other. In making
amends there is healing for us as well as healing for those we have hurt.
Read Colossians 1:19-20
Though none of these processes can change the past, they
nevertheless redeem the past. God is in the process of reconciling
everything that has gone wrong, including our personal past: he deals with
the past, reconciling people to himself, repairing damage, rebuilding what
sin has destroyed. But in order for Him to do this, we must bring all of our
broken parts to Him. This is the ultimate way of dealing with the past. Bring
your past to God, whether it happened two days ago or 20 years ago. Bring
it to Him and to His people, allow His light and grace to transform it, bring
His truth to bear on it, and experience the reconciliation of your whole life.
Discussion Questions:
1. W hat is the difference between changing the past and redeeming the past?
2. According to this lesson, what vital elements of spiritual growth are lost
when we leave the past in the past?
3. W hy is it difficult to examine the past for losses and grieve them? What
are the even more difficult consequences of not grieving our losses?
4. W hat generational sins have you discovered from your past? W hat are
some behaviors that you do not want to repeat in your own life?
5. How can you effectively deal with these generational sins (as well as
personal sins)? W hat will be the fruit of overcoming these past sins?
Dont believe the false assumption that you should leave it in the
past. Humbly and ho nestly bring your past to G od and allow Him to
redeem your past as well as your present and your future.
Theme: 12 False Christian Assumptions
Lesson 7. If I have God, I dont need people.
To the teacher: After studying this outline and reading each of the Scriptures, summarize in one
or two sentences what you have determined to be the main point that you hope to communicate to
the group:
Roy was a successful Christian businessman w ith a wife and children. One
day he w as fine, the next day he had m oved out of his house and virtually
disappeared for more than a year. When Roy returned to his home, he
confided in a Christian friend about the year he spent aw ay. He told his
friend that he had been under extreme pressure and in deep depression.
Other friends had given him loads of advice and he had spent hours in
pray er and Bible study trying to conquer his emotional pain. He had seriously
contemplated suicide. But one day his neighbor, a non-Christian, visited Roy
to borrow a screw driver, and Roy ended up pouring his heart out to this
man. He told of his business pressures and marriage struggles, his abusive
mother and absent father, his acting-out school years and his brother who
had let him down. His neighbor had just listened and asked questions
without offering advice. After their conversation and spending time with some
of his neighbors friends who were struggling just like him, Roy began to feel
better. Much better. He had the courage to reenter life again. But he was
confused. Why did hanging out with a bunch of ordinary people help me?
he asked his friend. Why w asnt God enough for my needs?
Read 2 Corinthians 3:5
Some interpret this verse to mean that we are sufficient in Jesus and
Jesus alone, leading believers to the me and God syndrome: its me and
God against the world. If Hes beside me, I need no one else. This distorted
teaching says that going to people for spiritual and emotional needs is
wrong. This c razy-making ass umption tells people who turn to other people
for help that they lack faith, that their view of God is small or limited, that
they are proud, and even that they are sinning. But this teaching is not
upheld by the Bible or life experiences.
Read Galatians 6:2
People need people. People are Gods resources, and He us es us to
meet peoples needs with love. This is the essence of ministry. Jesus uses
other people to help us to grow , to comfort us, to give us wisdom, and to
repair us. What if Philip, when asked by the eunuch, how can I understand
the Scriptures unless someone explains them to me, had said, Well, you
need to lean on God to understand these words. See ya. Or if the Philippian
Church hadnt supplied Pauls material needs, or the women didnt follow
Jesus and minister to Him? What if a mother stood over the crib of a crying
infant, told her baby to be comforted by God, and walked away? Or a
husband never showed affection to his wife because Christ loved her and
thats enough? Obviously, Jesus relies on us to be His physical body in the
world and minister to one another in love.
Read 1 Timothy 2:5
The worst aspect of this false assumption is that it distances us from the
humanity of Jesus. It was not sufficient for God to remain in heaven and deal
with mankind on a spiritual level. He cam e down to earth in physical form to
minister healing, deliverance, and salvation to a condemned world. God
chose to minster through humanity, though direct, hands-on compassion and
love. At the root of this false assumption is false doctrine, specifically the
ancient philosophy of Gnosticis m that deemed the physical world to be evil.
Gnostics believed that Jesus was purely spiritual with no humanity. John,
however, exposed this false teaching when he wrote that they had seen
Jesus with their eyes and that their hands had touched Him. Jesus humanity
was essential in order to bring salvation to the world. Jesus humanity was
the mediator between God and mankind.
Read Ephesians 4:15-16
Jesus is still using humanity as a mediator between Himself and mankind,
but today that humanity is us. W e are to build up one another in love. W e are to
provoke one another to good works. We are to rejoice with those who rejoice
and weep with those who weep. We are to act as Gods finger in the world by
ministering with compassion, not point the finger at people and minister with
criticism and condemnation. And we are to turn to other people when we are in
need so that Jesus, through them, can minister to us.
Discussion Questions
1. W hy did Roy get help from these ordinary folks and not from God?
2. W hy would it be difficult for a person to seek ministry from other people
rather than directly from God?
3. W hat are the benefits of turning to other people in times of loneliness ,
pressure, depression, and the like?
4. Tell about a time when you turned to another person for ministry and
found spiritual healing and renewal.
5. W hat issues in your life right now are you only bringing to God but not to
other people? Tonight may be a good night to allow others to help you
bear your burdens.
God made us so that we wo uld need Him and other people. Allow Him
to touch you through whatever or whomever He desires.
Theme: 12 False Christian Assumptions
Lesson 8. Shoulds are good.
To the teacher: After studying this outline and reading each of the Scriptures, summarize in one
or two sentences what you have determined to be the main point that you hope to communicate to
the group:
Henry grew up reading the Bible every day becaus e He loved it. From fourth
grade on, he would read his Bible every night. When Henry got to college,
He joined a discipleship group that enforced a daily quiet time. Every week
the group would ask, Are you having your quiet time? He began to dread
the question, and suddenly when he didnt read his Bible or pray every day
he felt guilty. Reading his Bible, which he had always loved doing, had
become a requirement with negative consequences. Henry had moved out
of a w orld of w ant tos and into the world of shoulds.
Read Matthew 22:37-40
Our goal as Christians is to love the Lord our God with everything weve
got. But we cannot really love Him until we are free to not love Him. Serving
God from a sense of obligation rather than from genuine love is a problem.
W e must perceive our freedom to choose, and freedom comes through
grace. Though we are saved by grace through faith, we can still be very
much under law in our life experience. Living under law produces the feeling
that if we do not do as we should, we are bad or condemned and deserved
to be punished. To the degree that we experience guilt, anger, and loss of
love when we do not do as we should, we are still under the law.
Read Romans 4:15
There are at least five major consequences of being under the law. First
the law brings wrath. W e expect God to be angry at us when we transgress
His law. We, in turn, get angry at Him. We resent Him and His rules, and we
want to move away from Him. Then we get angry at ourselves. Wrath is a
natural fruit of the law. Second, we are in a state of guilt and condemnation
when we are under the law, something we should never feel when we are in
Christ Jesus (Romans 8:1).
Read Ezekiel 18:4 and Romans 7:5
A third consequence of being under the law is being separated from
love. Law implies that if we do not do what we should, then God will not love
us. Unless we are as we should be, He will not relate to us. Fourth, when we
are under the law, sin increases. The law arouses w ithin us the desire to sin
more, not less. This is a confusing and destructive principle.
Read 2 Corinthians 9:7 and 1 Corinthians 13:1-3
The fifth consequence of the law is that we gain no benefit from following
it because our motive is not love. Our motives are everything to God. W e
may sacrifice in all sorts of ways, but if we dont have love it is meaningless.
Only when we are free can we freely love. If we are slaves to the shoulds
we are not ready to love. Slaves do not love; sons and daughters do.
Read Joshua 24:15
W hat does a life outside of the shoulds look like? In relationships, it
means that we are free to love. We dont have to love God or anybody else.
W e are free to love whomever we please. It also means that we do not put
others under the law by condemning them, getting angry at them, or
withdrawing love from them when they fail to love us the way we want. When
we evaluate our performance, we look at what we should be doing without
condemning ours elves. W e are not defensive about our failures, for we are
not condemned. Instead, we take responsibility for our failures..
Read Hebrews 12:2
Coming out from under the law means changing the have to to want
to. B ut we may not always feel like doing what is right; Jesus certainly didnt
feel like to go to the cross. But He did it because He wanted what it would
produce: a redeemed body of people who have freely chosen to love Him.
Likewise, we may not want to do individual deeds of obedience, but we do
want the end result of our deeds. Many time we must do what we dont want
to do in the immediate moment in order to get what we want in the future.
Maturity expects delayed gratification. That is the true want to.
Discussion Questions:
1. How do the shoulds keep us from fulfilling our purpos e as Christians, to
love God with all our heart, mind, soul, and strength?
2. W hat are some consequences of emotionally living under the law?
3. W hy do we have a tendency to put other people under the law by
criticizing them and being angry with them when they fail our
expectations?
4. W hat have you been doing because you should be doing it and not
because you want to be doing it?
5. How can you change your should to a want to?
! Read Romans 8:1-2. Relying on the power of Jesus and building a
relationship with Him and His body of believers fees us from the law of
sin and deaththe law of the shoulds.
Once you break free from the shoulds, you will start to live, finding
true freedom to desire God and His life.
Theme: 12 False Christian Assumptions
Lesson 9. Guilt and shame are good for me.
To the teacher: After studying this outline and reading each of the Scriptures, summarize in one
or two sentences what you have determined to be the main point that you hope to communicate to
the group:
Whatever Became of Guilt? The sermon title jumped out at Randy and
Vicki as they sat in the pew. Shrugging, they listened to the pastor as he
began his mess age. This Sunday, Pas tor Glenn came right to the point.
Beware of the humanistic approach to guilt, he preached. If you feel
guilty, you are guilty! Guilt solves the problem of loving ourselves too
much, he said. Rather than concentrating on how wonderful w e are, guilt
refocuses us to the darker side. It puts w ho w e are in perspec tive. T he Holy
Spirit speaks to us through guilt.... His message continued to the
discomfort of the couple. Driving home, Randy said, Honey, I feel worse
after the sermon than I did before. Vicki nodded. Same here.
Read John 16:8
Pastor Glenn was confusing guilt with the goading of Gods Spirit in the
heart. W hen Jesus said that the Holy Spirit would convict the world of sin,
He was describing His S pirits role in convicting sinners. Gods Spirit
exposes our sinfulness , but it doesnt dictate our response. Guilt, worldly
sorrow, rebellion, and indifference come from us, not God. Once we have
been born again, the work of guilt is done because we have been
pronounced not guilty by the blood of Jesus.
Read Romans3:19 and Genesis 2:25
Guilt has two common meanings: the legal state of having done wrong,
and the feeling of self-reproach resulting from the belief that we have done
wrong. The Bible only describes the first meaning of guilt, the legal
condition of having broken the law. Feelings of guilt are often our
consciences condemning us and telling us we are bad.
A persons conscience acts as a kind of internal parent monitoring our
goodness and badness. But this can hinder spiritual growth because of the
inaccuracy of our conscience. For example, Ken was in group therapy for
depression. One day he w as late to the group. The other mem bers said
hello and then sat quietly. After a m om ent, Ken blurted out, Im sorry, Im
sorry! The group looked startled. I know why youre all so quiet, he said.
I disrupted you all by being late, and now no one wants to talk. Ive ruined
the group. His consc ience punished him for being late. He assumed his
consciences judgm ent was accurate, but it was nt.
Read 1 Corinthians 8:7, 1 Timothy 4:1-2 and Hebrews 13:18
The Bible describes three types of consciences: the weak, the seared, and the
clear or mature conscience. The weak conscience prohibits, criticizes, and accuses
unjustly; the seared conscience has little sense of remorse, cant empathize with
others, and is controlling and manipulative; the clear conscience isnt perfect, but it
can help a person make better, more biblical decisions.
Read 2 Corinthians 7:9-11
Godly sorrow is a better response to our failures than guilt. Paul teaches here
that godly sorrow (remorse) is empathetic, centering on the hurt we have caused
others, often those we love. We feel bad because weve injured another person.
Worldly sorrow (guilt) focuses on how bad we are and is more concerned with the
misdeed than with restoring the relationship. Guilt-ridden people are afraid to love.
They are also afraid of being themselves because they feel so condemned.
Emotionally they are under the law. Guilty people are more concerned about being
good and living a sin-free life than they are about getting well and living for God.
Read 1 John 3:19-20
What can we do if were controlled by guilt? We need to: 1) Own the guilt; 2)
Become more concerned with building relationships than sin-busting; 3)
Investigate where you learned your messages of guilt; 4) Take ownership of your
anger; 5) Forgive those who controlled you by withholding love when you were
bad; 6) Reeducate your conscience through spiritual disciplines such as prayer
and fasting; 7) Learn to yield to the voice of Jesus; 8) Dont resist grief; it is
necessary for healing and restoration; 9) Let caring brothers and sisters comfort you
and love you through this process.
Discussion Questions:
1. What are some examples of guilt and shame messages.
! How can you be so selfish? Shame on you for saying that! After all Ive done
for you. You should have recovered from (whatever) by now.
2. What is the motive behind guilt and shame messages?
! The speaker usually wants something from you and is angry that you are not
providing it. Guilt and shame are simply ways to coerce you into changing your
mind.
3. Who in your life has given you messages of guilt and shame? What were they?
How have these messages affected your life and your relationship with these
people?
4. How do you generally react to having done wrong? With guilt or with godly
sorrow? How can you tell?
! Guilt focuses on the wrong-doing, while godly sorrow focuses on the hurt of
the other person.
5. What can a believer do to overcome guilt feelings in his life? What can he do to
reeducate his conscience? (See list above for answers)
Guilt is not good for us because it prevents us from being motivated by love.
Gods Spirit and His loving people can move us away from guilt and toward
love.
Theme: 12 False Christian Assumptions
Lesson 10. If I make right choices, I will grow
spiritually.
To the teacher: After studying this outline and reading each of the Scriptures, summarize in one
or two sentences what you have determined to be the main point that you hope to communicate to
the group:
As Laura listened to the sermon on Sunday morning she grew more and
more discouraged. She had come to church yearning for help. At 31, she
was back in another hurtful romantic relationship and still didnt own her life.
She couldnt stand up to her mother, w ho manipulated her life, and couldnt
follow through on diets. She was weak-willed in most areas of her life. As the
pas tor ended his sermon he said, It all comes dow n to c hoices. People
choos e to do what they want to do. If you really w ant to live for God, you will.
By an act of will, you will stop sinning, choose Gods ways over your own,
and m ake right choices. Go from here today and make right choices!
Lauras heart sank. She had tried to m ake right choices for years, but didnt
have the willpower to do it. If this was Gods offer, then she had no hope.
Slipping out of church, she glumly drove to her boyfriends house. At least
she wouldnt be alone.
Read Romans 7:15
Just say no! was a popular drug campaign of the 1980's . Some people
have held this philosophy about other things as well, such as anger, lust,
depression, addictions. This false assumption makes life pretty simple: you
just need to find our what is right and do it. Knowledge and willpower
become the keys to spiritual growth. But willpower is human power, which is
why it usually falls short. Instead of experiencing victory, we experience what
Paul experienced: utter failure. W e are hopeless if we believe that simply
making the right choices will cause us to grow spiritually.
Read Matthew 22:37
In this verse, Jesus paints a picture of an integrated person who takes all of
himselfnot just his willto God. We do things with our entire person, not just
our will or our intellect. Jesus wants us to serve Him and relate to Him with our
whole person. W illpower alone is insufficient. W e must have His power.
Read Romans 7:22-24 and Galatians 5:17
Often we are faced with internal conflict within ourselves, and w e dont like
to face that conflict. We may know what is right, but deep in our hearts we may
love things and people that are contrary to what is right. For this reason the
Bible calls for a change from the inside out, not just making right choices.
Read Romans 8:1-4 and Galatians 5:16,18
The transforming power we have within us is not our human willpower
but the power of the Holy Spirit. God triumphs over the power of sin with the
power of His Spirit It is then up to us to tap into this life-changing power by
connecting to G od through prayer and connecting to the members of His
body. This is how we receive the grace and truth necessary to be
transformed into His image.
Read Philippians 2:12-13
The word translated to will literally means to desire. Any act of the will
that does not come from a desire initiated by God is bad fruit. And we cannot
have Gods desires apart from the indwelling presence of His Spirit. As we
openly confess our evil desires to God and to others, those desires can be
transformed through grace and repentance. Only then can we desire what God
desires.
Read Galatians 3:3
Right choices dont cause spiritual growth: they are the result of spiritual
growth. The ability to make right choices is a fruit of the Spirit. When we
believe we can make right choices apart from God, we are being prideful.
Jesus told us to own our spiritual poverty and allow Him to transform us.
Discussion Questions:
1. How does leaving this false assumption behind affect your perception of
living for God?
! It takes the press ure off! W e dont have to do it on our own, we have to
connect to Jesus and allow His power to transform us.
2. W hat is an example of a right choice that we dont have the power to
make on our own?
! Examples are: to choose to stop being angry, fearful, addicted to a
substance or activity, habitually sinning, etc.
3. Though we cant make right choices such as these, what choices can we
make that will draw us closer to Jesus and enable Him to transform us?
! examples are: confess our sins, give up thinking we can save ourselves,
submit our inabilities to God, repent, make amends with others, forgive,
ask for help in searching for our faults, let others meet our needs.
4. W hat things in your life have you been trying to make right choices about
but are not submitting to the power of God? W hat has the result been?
5. W hat choices can you make instead to bring healing to the situation?
Instead of trying to make right choices, surrender your inability to God, be
humble , be unable, and allow Him to begin the process of spiritual gro wth
in you. As you cooperate with Him , in du e season you will produce fruit!
Theme: 12 False Christian Assumptions
Lesson 11. Doing right is more important than
why I do it.
To the teacher: After studying this outline and reading each of the Scriptures, summarize in one
or two sentences what you have determined to be the main point that you hope to communicate to
the group:
The Andrews fam ily sat in the pastors office mom, dad, and their 16-year-
old son Dave. They were there to discuss Daves recent behavior problems
at sc hool and hom e. As Dave sat in stony silence, his parents blam ed their
sons behavior on his choice of friends. When the pastor suggested that
family life can directly influence a teens behavior, Daves mother got
defensive, but Dave perked up. Ask them about the schedule, Dave
instructed the pastor. The schedule Dave was referring to was jammed full of
good, Christian activities. When Daves father defended the wholesome
family schedule, Dave glared at him and said, I think you keep so busy so
you and Mom dont have to talk to each other. You dont like to talk to each
other. The room was silent.
Read Romans 2:13
This encounter illus trates the false assumption, Doing the right thing is
more important than why I do it. O r, more spiritually phrased: Obedience is
the key to Christian life. People who believe this false assumption use
Scriptures to support their belief. But this suggests that God looks at our
actions more than our motives and will bless our efforts regardless of our
reason for doing them. In other words, it doesnt matter if you are obeying
because you are avoiding someone; it doesnt matter if youre obeying
because you dont want to look bad to others; it doesnt matter that youre
feeling resentment or guilt as you obey; it jus t matters that you obey.
Read Deuteronomy 5:33, 6:24, and 10:13
The word obey in both the Old and New Testaments means , to hear,
to attend to. The word obedience describes our relationship with God: we
hear what He wants and then we respond, much like a child responds to the
voice of his parents. Obedience is a structure that enables us to grow up to
maturity; it is not an end in itself. And obedience always has a purpos e. W e
dont obey just for the sake of obeying; this would suggest that God is a
control freak (which He is not). His directives help us to learn His ways so
that we can grow into His image. They help us to become like Him.
Read Isaiah 29:13
This false assumption has six main problems. First, it teaches us to
substitute seemingly sacrificial acts of servic e for true obedience. Second, it
splits a person apart on the inside. W e des ire one thing and then do another,
like this verse suggests. Third, it discourages a sense of responsibility for our
actions and attitudes. A person becomes so focused on pleasing a feared
authority figure that he cannot deal with differences betw een the authority
figure and himself. The result is a person not taking responsibility for his true
feelings about situations.
Read Matthew 21:28-31
Fourth, this false ass umption promotes lying. It forces a person to lie
about the no on the inside and say yes on the outside, which, according
to this parable, is not pleasing to God. Fifth, it denies our fallenness or our
inability to perfectly obey every command in the Scripture. And sixth, it
devalues the power of the cross in our lives. Jesus gives us the grace
necessary to try, fail, learn from the consequences, and try again without
heaping anxiety, condemnation, or guilt on us because we didnt obey
perfectly. When we know we wont be condemned when we fail, we grow
faster. W e take more risks.
W hen we allow ourselves to work through our inner motives and conflicts
about situations, we are more free to be autonomous, to take responsibility
for our behavior, and to be truly free in Christ.
Discussion Questions:
1. W hy does this false assumption seems so spiritual on the surface?
! Because obedience to God is a biblical principle.
! Because our actions are important to God.
2. W hy is it so easy for people to live this false assumption? (think back to
the Andrew s family)
! Because obedience allows people to avoid confronting deeper issues
while maintaining outward spirituality.
3. W hy would living this false ass umption be destructive to a persons
relationship with God and others?
! Review six problems mentioned above.
4. Have you ever believed this false ass umption? Do you now? How has it
affected your relationship with God and others?
5. W hat can people do to stop acting upon this false assumption?
! Value honesty and take responsibility for how they really feel about
situations; Be willing and able to say no, or in other words, have good
boundaries established; appreciate how much Jesus values their heart
motives and act on that.
Why we do something is just as important as what we are doing.
Motives matter!
Theme: 12 False Christian Assumptions
Lesson 12. If I know the truth, I will grow.
To the teacher: After studying this outline and reading each of the Scriptures, summarize in one
or two sentences what you have determined to be the main point that you hope to communicate to
the group:
When Joyce began attending a home group meeting, she had believed all 12
false Christian assumptions. She had been 130 lbs overweight when she
began, but was now m aintaining a healthy weight. When asked how she
explained her weight loss, she answered, First, I had to come out of
isolation and connect to other people. Second, I had to set boundaries that
would enable me to get my life under my c ontrol. Third, I had to deal with
and express my pain and hurt instead of covering it up with eating. I learned
that Bible study couldnt cure me; I had to do w hat the Bible talks about.
Know ing the Bible did not change me, doing it did.
Read John 8:32
People who believe the false assumption If I know the truth, I will grow
misinterpret Scriptures such as this one. They assert that Bible study alone
is the remedy for spiritual and emotional healing. Although the W ord is
necessary for spiritual growth, the Bible itself teac hes that study of Scripture
is insufficient in and of itself for bringing us into a healthy Christian life.
Read John 5:39
Jesus Himself rebuked the Pharisees for subscribing to this false
assumption. While they were busy scrutinizing the fine points of the
Scriptures, they missed the O ne who could give them eternal life. They were
cut off from God and from each other.
Read 2 Corinthians 5:18-19
The essence of spiritual life is to be reconciled to God, having a vibrant
relationship with Him. It is then being reconciled to others in the same way.
God knew that for us to understand this concept, He would have to become
one of us. Even today, He still comes to us in bodily form through His
Church, which is the BOD Y of Christ. The Church is the Spirit of Jesus with
skin on. We feel Gods grace not only by studying the Bible, but by
experiencing it through our relationships with Him and His body.
Read 1 John 4:20 and 1 Peter 4:8-10
Humans are G ods agents for administering His grace. Gods grace is
not something we learn only by reading the Bible. W e also receive it through
our human relationships.
Read Luke 6:46-49
Besides cutting us off from an avenue of Gods grace, this false
assumption teaches people to become hearers of the Word but not doers.
They are taught to get over their emotional and spiritual problems by just
reading their Bibles and praying. But there will be no genuine healing until a
person becomes a doer of the W ord.
Read Psalms 119:9
W e dont keep our ways pure by reading the W ord. W e keep our ways
pure by doing the Word. In keeping Jesus Word there is life and health.
Doing the Word leads a person to being humble and loving, responsible and
forgiving, cleansed and transformed, and actively involved in bringing others
into the same kind of healing relationships with Jesus and His body.
Discussion Questions:
1. W hy does this false assumption seem so true on the surface?
! Because we are to esteem the Bible and the integrity of the W ord.
! Because reading the Bible is a spiritual activity.
2. But why is this false assumption not true after all?
! Because reading and knowing the Bible alone does not bring healing;
only responding to the teaching of the Scriptures brings healing.
3. Tell about a time when you turned to reading Scripture in an effort to
solve emotional problems that you were having. What was the outcome?
4. W hy is it so spiritually dangerous for people to believe this false
assumption?
! If a person turns to the Scripture believing that Bible knowledge will
heal him of his problems and it doesnt work, he may become
disillusioned with the W ord of God and eventually with God Himself.
5. Tell about a time when you began to do the W ord after it became known
to you and you were healed of an emotional, physical, or spiritual
problem. W hat situations in your life now do you need to apply this
principle to?
Learn the truth, study your Bible diligently, but dont stop there. Put
the Bible into action in your life. It is doing the teachings of Jesus
rather than just kn ow ing them that sets us free!