0 Voturi pozitive0 Voturi negative

6 (de) vizualizări2 paginiTradução do mestre da matemática alemã, Agraham Kastner

May 31, 2017

© © All Rights Reserved

PDF, TXT sau citiți online pe Scribd

Tradução do mestre da matemática alemã, Agraham Kastner

© All Rights Reserved

6 (de) vizualizări

Tradução do mestre da matemática alemã, Agraham Kastner

© All Rights Reserved

- Neuromancer
- The E-Myth Revisited: Why Most Small Businesses Don't Work and
- How Not to Be Wrong: The Power of Mathematical Thinking
- Drive: The Surprising Truth About What Motivates Us
- Chaos: Making a New Science
- The Joy of x: A Guided Tour of Math, from One to Infinity
- How to Read a Person Like a Book
- Moonwalking with Einstein: The Art and Science of Remembering Everything
- The Wright Brothers
- The Other Einstein: A Novel
- The 6th Extinction
- The Housekeeper and the Professor: A Novel
- The Power of Discipline: 7 Ways it Can Change Your Life
- The 10X Rule: The Only Difference Between Success and Failure
- A Short History of Nearly Everything
- The Kiss Quotient: A Novel
- The End of Average: How We Succeed in a World That Values Sameness
- Made to Stick: Why Some Ideas Survive and Others Die
- Algorithms to Live By: The Computer Science of Human Decisions
- The Universe in a Nutshell

Sunteți pe pagina 1din 2

T R A N S L AT I O N

Excerpts from

On the Conceptions that

Underlie Space

(1790)

Abraham Gotthelf Kstner

ABRAHAM GOTTHELF KSTNER was one of the most important figures in the history of science. Born in

1719 in Leipzig, Kstner spent his entire life as a passionate defender of Kepler and Leibniz. In 1756, he

was appointed professor of mathematics at Gttingen University, where his students included Carl F. Gauss.

In 1766, he hosted Dr. Benjamin Franklins visit to the University, as part of his continuing support for the

efforts of Leibnizs networks to create a republic in North America.

Kstners contributions to science are numerous, but perhaps his most important was his seminal work on

developing what his student Gauss would later call anti-Euclidean geometry. As the following excerpts

demonstrate, Kstner, like Leibniz and Kepler, rejected Aristotles insistence that all knowledge must rest on

a set of a priori axioms, postulates, and definitions, as is the case in Euclidean geometry. As Kstner indi-

cates, all Euclidean geometry depends on the truthfulness of the so-called parallel postulate, which must

be accepted without proof. Gauss, and his student Bernhard Riemann, adopted Kstners view, demanding

that all such axiomatic systems be discarded, and that physical science be based on demonstrable universal

physical principles alone.

25. [The article in] Phil. Mag. II, Vol. 1, p. 88, gives the they intersect. The visual concept of a such pair of lines is

arguments, why the well-known eleventh axiom* of thus as follows: When the sum of the two angles comes

Euclid does not possess the evidence, that an axiom closer and closer to two right angles, then the lines will

should have: because it contains the concept of an infini- stay apart for a longer distance, before they intersect; and

ty: a space that, in regard to its bounding, would be indef- the axiom only says: The lines can always be extended far

initely extended, and which the senses and imagination enough [i.e., to the point where they intersectJT].

could not represent. 27. In the magazine mentioned above, we read, they

26. Speaking precisely, it does not seem to me that this intersect, when they are extended to infinity.

concept is contained in Euclids axiom. . . . [When Euclid This is a correct translation of the [Greek] words, but

speaks of] extension of lines into the infinite, this means the Greeks did not attach the same thought to the word,

nothing other than: extending as far as necessary. Euclid which we call the infinite, as what we thinkor believe

says only, that [if two lines intersect a third one in such a we thinkin connection with the German expression.

way, that the inner angles formed add up to less than two For, if it were necessary to extend the two lines to infinity

right angles, then] one can extend the lines so far, that (in the newer sense of that word), in order for them to

__________ intersect, then they do not intersect at all, but are parallel. . . .

* I.e., the parallel postulate. Modern editions number this as the 28. One says: Parallels intersect at infinity; in what

Fifth postulate.Ed. sense this is said, I have show in my Foundations of Geom-

100

2004 Schiller Institute, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission strictly prohibited.

etry 12, p. 12. If this manner of speak- 34. Thus, the difficulty concerns

ing is to be defended, then it must the distinction between curved and

certainly signify as much, as to say: straight lines. A curved line means, a

the lines never intersect. line in which no part is straight. This

29. If the two lines (as in 26) inter- concept of a curved line is distinct,

sect each other, then they form because the concept of straight line is

together with the third line, where clear; but it is also incomplete, because

the two angles mentioned above are the concept of straight line is merely

formed, a triangle, and thereby a fig- clear.

ure which constitutes a bounded 35. So we see, that the difficulty of

space. In Euclids expression, they the axiom does not concern infinite

intersect, when they are continued to space, but rather the indistinctness

infinity, the word infinity signifies and incompleteness of the concepts.

nothing other, than what we 36. A curved line never intersects

explained in point 26 above. its asymptote; the strange thing

30. The reason why one does not about this is, that it always

find the same degree of evidence in approaches toward the asymptote. A

this axiom, as in the others, does not Abraham Kstner bit of thought shows: never intersect-

lie in the concept of infinite space in ing, but always approaching, could

the newer meaning of the word, but rather: that we have only occur at the same time, if the amount of approach

merely a clear concept of straight line, and not a definite becomes smaller and smaller. So, the oblique line (31)

concept, as I pointed out in my article: what it means in surely must approach [the other line] at a constant rate,

Euclids geometry to be possible. although not an increasing one. Since this proposition is

If two straight lines, in the same plane, are perpendic- sufficient, one need only prove it, in order to establish

ular to a third line, then they never intersect. This con- that an intersection occurs. This has also been attempt-

clusion flows from the clear concept of straight line: for, ed, but without success, because the required result can-

on one side of the third line everything is identical to the not be derived from concepts that are no more than

other side, and so the two lines would have to intersect on clear.

the other side also, if they intersect on this side. But they 37. Besides, in geometry, asymptote means noth-

cannot intersect twice . . . . ing more than a straight line that comes ever closer to a

31. However, when only one of the two lines is per- curved line, without ever touching it. The more mod-

pendicular to the third, and the other does not form a ern authors say: the curved line is intersected by the

right angle, then do they intersect? And on which side of asymptote at infinity; and even regard the pair of such

the third line? touching-points, located far across each other on the

This is a part of the non-evident eleventh axiom; and infinite line, as constituting a single point; and other

if one could establish the correctness of this part, then the such paradoxes, which all arise from a poetic interpre-

whole would follow. tation of the simple, clear prose of the ancients. Even

32. The lack of evidence does not flow from the fact, the concept of asymptotes requires nothing more, than

that we have no visual concept of an infinite space. . . . a space, in which extension can be continued further

33. The question is this: Let one extend the oblique and further.

straight line (31) as far as one wants: do we ever get to the 38. In Joseph Raphson, Analysis aequationum univer-

perpendicular line? salis, 2nd edition (London: 1694), one can find his article

The difficulty to give an affirmative answer to this on Spatio reali, seu ente infinito, conamen mathematico

question, comes from the following: metaphysicum. In Chapter 3, he calls the infinity of the

One could imagine, instead of the oblique straight line, mathematicians, as this occurs with series, asymptotes,

a curved line, whose asymptote would be the perpendicu- etc., the potential infinite. . . .

lar straight linefor example, a branch of a hyperbola. Raphson says exactly what I have said. Since I have

With such a curved line, one could go out as far as one restricted myself to space, as the geometers conceive it,

wanted, without ever touching the perpendicular line. the rest of his propositions dont belong to my present

Why should something necessarily occur with an intentions; besides which, I still think the way Leibniz

oblique straight line, which does not have to occur, when and Wolf taught me to think.

one replaces it with a curved line? translated from the German by Jonathan Tennenbaum

101

- 3D & VectÎncărcat deRobertBellarmine
- Mathematics 3D Geometry MCQÎncărcat derasheedshaikh2003
- Hyperbolas Articles 1Încărcat deMarcia Patterson
- entropy-19-00291Încărcat desleepanon4362
- DEI & TC Syallabus (Final)Încărcat denandini
- Computer Graphics_Chapter 2Încărcat deZeeshan Bhatti
- C 3 2014Încărcat devic70r9
- final al-mahdi10thg 16-17Încărcat deapi-253679034
- Graphing Rationals 3Încărcat deJason Miller
- On Algebraic Multi-Vector Spaces, by Linfan MaoÎncărcat deAnonymous 0U9j6BLllB
- Electric Field Plotting Lab manualÎncărcat deHeba
- dancingthroughmathÎncărcat deapi-282153836
- An Introduction to Godels TheoremsÎncărcat desuwailem
- edee-332-w18 geometry definition protocolÎncărcat deapi-368183330
- 12 - Three Dimensional GeometryÎncărcat decpverma2811
- PuzzlesÎncărcat deArpit Agarwal
- ModuleÎncărcat deJen E Veb
- 0704-001Încărcat deorfeu_niko
- ASPECTS OF THEORY DEVELOPMENT-DR.RNP.pptÎncărcat dedanmero11
- Y3 - Module 1 - Interpreting Drawings and Symbols EditedÎncărcat deIP G
- Math TrialÎncărcat deAmirul Adily
- EN(1351)Încărcat dereacharunk
- Burkard Polster - Q.E.D. (Beauty in Mathematical Proof) - WalkerPublishing Company, 2004-68pÎncărcat deNara Roberta Andrade
- geometry prouject - real world examplesÎncărcat deapi-283655149
- webassignmentÎncărcat deapi-301047801
- 60 Odd Years of Mathematical Moscow OlympiadsÎncărcat deAnup Saravan
- Final Ppt of Tracing of Polar CurvesÎncărcat deNidhi Rai
- myaimpptÎncărcat deRatna Kommoji
- Linear Equation in Thrre VariablesÎncărcat dehugonunes89
- RegressionÎncărcat deMeghan Woods

- Eir - RussiangateÎncărcat demattoro
- Eir - How Abraham Lincoln Organized Victory for the UnionÎncărcat demattoro
- Syrian Reconstruction Ready for Takeoff.pdfÎncărcat demattoro
- Aula 14 - Social Studies of Science-2011-PettyÎncărcat demattoro
- Identifying With ChinaÎncărcat demattoro
- EIR - O Destino Manifesto Da China e Da AméricaÎncărcat demattoro
- 1991 Roth_Interpretation_as_explanation.pdfÎncărcat demattoro
- fulltext_020Încărcat dejoluq
- o Modelo ChinêsÎncărcat demattoro
- Eir - Europa 2Încărcat demattoro
- Pierret-2003-Sociology of Health & IllnessÎncărcat deLau Palermo
- _VILLAÇACORPOJRAÎncărcat deEsmael Oliveira
- 1982 Anthropologies Ilness&SicknessÎncărcat demattoro
- Marie-Louise Von Franz - Antichrist or Merlin.pdfÎncărcat demattoro
- Larouche - Glass-steagall & BeyondÎncărcat demattoro
- Larouche - Kennedy EconomicsÎncărcat demattoro
- David Shavin - Eir - Poe's Poet-Mathematician: Evariste GaloisÎncărcat demattoro
- Eir - Abraham Lincoln & John Quincy AdamsÎncărcat demattoro
- Eir - The End of the Imperial Money SystemÎncărcat demattoro
- Eir - Alexander Hamilton's Challenge to Us TodayÎncărcat demattoro
- eir - Leibniz, Sun Yat Sen, the LaRouches, And Xi Jinping.pdfÎncărcat demattoro
- Larouche - Leibniz From Riemann's StandpointÎncărcat demattoro
- Eir - Leibniz, Sun Yat Sen, The LaRouches, And Xi JinpingÎncărcat demattoro
- Eir - Poe e a Bela Cidade - Nova IorqueÎncărcat demattoro
- Andromidas - Bela Cidade - Parte 3Încărcat demattoro
- Larouche - The Lost Art of the Capital BudgetÎncărcat demattoro
- Eir - The Promise of Fusion RocketryÎncărcat demattoro
- Eir - Glass Steagall e a Formação Da União EuropeiaÎncărcat demattoro

- 15419Încărcat detushar11singh
- Innovative ProjectsÎncărcat deJohn_Grylls
- File Manager for IMSÎncărcat deRavi Venkatesh K P
- Universe in Nutshell Hawking ReviewÎncărcat deVladica Barjaktarovic
- 15 16Sem1 Mid Term CommentsÎncărcat deXet Fat
- Analog Tape RestorationÎncărcat deBrandy Thomas
- Circuit Stepper Motor DriverÎncărcat dekalpico
- WinCC Flexible 2008 Micro Www.otomasyonegitimi.comÎncărcat dewww.otomasyonegitimi.com
- circulute_3000.pdfÎncărcat deShaique Siddique
- 40401977 Monthly Safety ReportÎncărcat deAbdul-Kailani Sulley Wa'Zailani-Barbuga
- Lotto Logic 2000 Pro User ManualÎncărcat deJoe Abeb
- Herbert MarcuseÎncărcat deJorge O El George
- Mina Bissell - Biology's New DimensionÎncărcat deLynn4flybell
- BAT Taiwan UGM SIT Case.docxÎncărcat deDwitya Aribawa
- Top Secret Programs Hidden in Plain SightÎncărcat deTee R Taylor
- UntitledÎncărcat dekouls
- Assignment No 1Încărcat deKrishna Patel
- OSÎncărcat deAyub Arshad
- The 12 Common ArchetypesÎncărcat deperfectknight
- Chennai tkt (1)Încărcat deHarishKumar
- Priasma ChecklistÎncărcat depiangporn
- Time Table 20 August 2019Încărcat dev123t456
- Stress and Strain PptÎncărcat deKUNAL1221
- LDI TemplateÎncărcat deSDN Helpline
- Homework 1Încărcat de楊旻錡
- Horizon Scanning to Improve Social ImpactÎncărcat deGeorge Bekatoros
- Settlement of Circular Footing on SandÎncărcat deninoronald
- 3.FundamentalsÎncărcat deTwinkle Ratna
- Stirling 3Încărcat deermias
- Hướng dẫn thực hànhÎncărcat deNguyễn Cường

## Mult mai mult decât documente.

Descoperiți tot ce are Scribd de oferit, inclusiv cărți și cărți audio de la editori majori.

Anulați oricând.