TATA CONSULTING ENGINEERS LIMITED

PROJECT : Project Mangament Services for PVC Resin Plant, Ethiopia.

COMMENT SHEET
Consolidated
Received TCE Comment
Sl. No. Document Number Title Rev No. Comment Issue
Date Issue Date
Date
 TATA CONSULTING ENGINEERS LIMITED
PROJECT : Project Mangament Services for PVC Resin Plant, Ethiopia.
COMMENT SHEET
Calculation Report forAcetelyne Holder Foundation
Doc Title :
Acetylene Holder Foundation

8299-D-6104C-19-001
Doc No :
8299-D-6104C-23-001
Revision: B
Date of
16-Jun-17
issue:
PPD BY: Amol R Khismatrao

Comments By Consultant (TCE) / Comments- Comments By Consultant (TCE) / Employer

Sl. No. Reference Response By EPC contractor (CEC) Response Date Response Date Status (Open/Resolved)
Employer (DCEP) Date (DCEP)

In the report it is mentioned as follows:-

"This tank will be put on foundation top and
without bolt. The overturning and sliding check The calculation for equipment stability has
1 Output parameters will be shown in equipment design report". 5/5/2017 been added in revised report. See section 6/2/2017
Contractor to submit the equipment design report 6.
without which calculation report can not be
approved.

Contractor to provide following checks:-

Please note that as per point 1 , SBC value considered
a) Soil Pressure below ring wall for allowable is 350kpa. Contractor to note that the
2 Output parameters b) Soil Pressure below tank area 5/5/2017 Added in revised report. 6/2/2017 6/16/2017 Open
founding level of the tank is not at the same level as
which 350kPa is available.
Contractor to incorporate in the report.

Contractor to provide overturning and slidding

check for foundation. This tank will be placed on civil foundation
and no bolt connection to foundation. Tank
3 Output parameters 5/5/2017 will not have overturning and slidding force 6/2/2017
to foundation. The tank's overturning and
slidding check is done in report.

Follwing statement mentioned in the report"In

normal status, media inside tank is gas, the load is
less than water. So this stage dont need
Output parameters to be checked." Normal status(service phase) checking of
4 5/5/2017
foundation see section 3
6/2/2017
Contractor to check the foundation for hydrotest
load conditions.

Contractor to submit the Design calculations for 1) Contractor shall ensure all necessary checks, internal
ring wall . software checks, codal compliances to GB codes as
a)Provide check for min % of reinforcement criteria appropriate.
for walls as per code.Provide calculation with a)b)c)d) Added in revised report.
code references in report e) Added in revised report. 2) Contractor shall ensure thorough checking to retain
b)Circumferencial Reinforcement g)h)i) The weight of tank is average complete Structural integrity required for worst load case
c)Vertical Reinforcement distruibuted on foundation so no shear scenarios.
5 Output parameters d)Check for tensile stress in concrete due to hoop 5/5/2017 6/2/2017 6/16/2017 Open
stress need to be checked. And in Code
tension for design of steel tank foundation (GB
e)Thickness of Wall 50473-2008), it is not required to check
g)CHECK FOR SHEAR STRESS the shear stress.
h)CHECK FOR ONE WAY SHEAR
i)CHECK FOR TWO WAY SHEAR