Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
INTRODUCTION
We a ll k n o w t h at em o t io n s a re u seless a n d b ad fo r o u r p ea ce o f m in d a n d o u r
bloo d p r essu re.
Sk in n er, 1948, p. 92
DEFINING EMOTION
We d e n e em o t io n s a s ep iso d ic, rela tively sh o r t -t er m , b io lo gica lly b a sed
p at t ern s o f p ercep t io n , exp er ien ce, p hy sio logy, a ct io n , a n d co m m u n ica t io n
t h a t o ccu r in resp o n se t o sp eci c p hysica l a n d so cia l ch a llen ges a n d
o p p o rt u n ities. E m o t io n s invo lve m o re exib le in t er p ret a t io n s a n d
resp o n ses t h a n re exes, wh ich t yp ica lly invo lve xed resp o n ses t o im m ed i-
a t e st im u li (Sch erer, 19 84). E m o t io n s h ave m o re sp eci c in t en t io n a l o b ject s
t h a n m o o d s (F r ijd a , 19 86) a n d t yp ica lly a re sh o rt er in d u ra t io n a s well
(E k m a n , 198 4). W h erea s t h e p rim a ry go a l o f d rives, su ch a s h u n ger a n d
t h irst , seem s t o b e t o regu la t e t h e in t er n a l o p er a tin g co n d itio n s o f t h e
o rga n ism , em o t io n s regu la te t h e in d ivid u a ls rela t io n t o t h e ext ern a l envir-
o n m en t (see Bu ck , 1985 a n d To m k in s, 19 84, fo r o t h er d ist in ctio n s b et ween
em o t io n s a n d d rives).
FUNCTIONAL ACCOUNTS 469
DEFINING FUNCTION
O f t h e m a ny m ea n in gs o f fu n ct io n (C u m m in s, 197 5; Jo h n so n -L a ird &
O a t ley, 199 2; W r igh t , 1973), o u r p resen t co n cer n is with t h e ro le o f
fu n ct io n with in scien t i c exp la n at io n . To d e n e t h is sen se o f fu n ctio n , it
is h elp fu l t o b egin with wh a t fu n ct io n s a re n o t . F u n ct io n s a re n o t so lely
u ses o f so m et h in g o r wh a t it is go o d fo r, b eca u se b eh avio u r, t r a its, o r
syst em s h ave m a ny u ses a n d a re go o d fo r m a ny t h in gs t h a t a re n o t
syn o nym o u s with t h eir fu n ct io n s (e.g. t h e so u n d o f t h e h ea r t b ea t in g
ca n b e u sed t o d ia gn o se p hy sical co n d itio n s, k n ives ca n b e u sed t o
p a in t ). N o r a re fu n ct io n s u n d er lyin g m ech a n ism s (M a st er s, 1995) ,
wh ich refer t o p ro cesses, t yp ica lly p hysio logica l o r cogn itive, t h a t p ro -
d u ce b eh avio u r with cer t a in fu n ct io n s. N o r a re fu n ctio n s go a ls, wh ich
refer t o p ro p ert ies o f a ct io n (W r igh t , 19 73). R a t h er, fu n ct io n s a re a
cert a in so rt o f co n seq u en ce o f go a l-d irect ed a ct io n . F u n ct io n s a re
id en t i ed in a et io lo gica l exp la n a t io n s o f t h e o rigin s a n d d evelo p m en t
o f t h e b eh avio u r, t r a it , o r syst em (W righ t , 1973) . F u n ct io n a l a scrip t io n s,
t h erefo re, refer t o t h e h ist o ry o f a b eh avio u r, t r a it, o r system , a s well a s
it s regu la r co n seq u en ces t h a t b en e t t h e o rga n ism , o r m o re sp eci ca lly,
t h e syst em in wh ich t h e t r a it, b eh avio u r, o r syst em is co n t a in ed (C u m m in s,
1975 ).
t yp ica lly less regu la r (see W r igh t , 1973 fo r d ist in ct io n s b et ween a ccid en t s
1
a n d fu n ctio n s). F o r exa m p le, a n ger m igh t p la u sib ly h ave severa l co n se-
q u en ces, in clu d in g in crea sed p h o n e b ills, p a rk in g t icket s, ea t in g b in ges,
a n d ir ra t io n a l b o u t s o f h o u se-clea n in g, t h a t d o n o t relat e t o t h e a ssu m ed
fu n ct io n o f a n ger, t h e resto ra t ion o f ju st rela t io n s. E m o t io n -rela ted co n -
seq u en ces m ay b e d istin gu ish ed fro m fu n ct io n -rela ted co n seq u en ces b y
t h eir rela t ive in d ep en d en ce fro m t h e ca u ses o f em o t io n a n d em o t io n -
relat ed resp o n ses a n d t h eir irregu la r it y o f co -o ccu rren ce b o t h with in t h e
sa m e in d ivid u a l over t im e a n d a cro ss d ifferen t in d ivid u a ls.
1
W illiam s (1966) o ffers a n elegan t exa m p le illu st r at ing th e d istin ction b etween fu n ctio n
a n d a cciden t. T h e fu nctio n of th e app le is to d isp erse a n d r epro du ce t he sp ecies. A cciden ta l
co nseq uen ces o f th e ap ple in clu d e its ro le in t he Wa sh ingt o n st ate econ o m y a n d ingr at iat in g
r itu als in t h e gr a m m a r sch o ol cla ssro o m . F or exa m ple, a fu n ct ion a l a ccou nt m igh t d e n e
sym pa thy a s th e inclin at ion t o com fo r t a n d help o th ers in n eed, in p a r ticu la r th ose wh o h ave
a ttr ibutes o f d efen celessness, u nt il th e d ist r ess is a m elio ra ted .
FUNCTIONAL ACCOUNTS 475
POINTS OF DIVERGENCE AMONG
FUNCTIONAL ACCOUNTS
We h ave p ro p o sed t h at fu n ctio n a l a cco u n t s o f em o t io n s fo cu s o n t h e
rea so n s h u m a n s h ave em o t io n s, t h e p ro b lem s em o t io n s so lve, t h e syst em ic
n a t u re o f em o t io n -rela t ed resp o n ses, a n d t h e syst em at ic, b en e cia l co n se-
q u en ces o f em o t io n . D ifferen t fu n ctio n a l a cco u n t s o f em o t io n sh a re t h ese
gen era l a ssu m p t io n s t o va r yin g d egr ees b u t d iverge in sever a l im p o rt a n t
ways.
Levels of Analysis
F u n ct io n a l a cco u n t s o f em o t io n m ay b e o ffered at a ny o n e o f a nu m b er o f
levels o f a n a lysis (Aver ill, 19 94; Ba rret t & C a m p o s, 1987 ). E m o t io n s ca n
serve im p o rt a n t fu n ctio n s a t t h e level o f in t ra -o rga n ism ic resp o n se, co -
o rd in at in g p hysio lo gica l, p ercep t u a l, a n d co gn itive p ro cesses t h a t en ab le
t h e o rga n ism t o resp o n d a d a p t ively t o sign i ca n t enviro n m en t a l ch a llen ges
o r o p p o r t u n ities (L even so n , T h is Issu e). A seco n d , co m p lem en t a ry level o f
a n a lysis, co n sid er s t h e so cia l o r in t er-o rga n ism ic fu n ct io n s o f em o t io n s
with in t h e co n t ext o f o n go in g in t era ctio n s (Ba r ret t & C a m p o s, 1987 ;
K elt n er & H a id t , T h is Issu e). A t h ird level o f a n a lysis fo cu ses o n t h e
so ciet a l level fu n ct io n s o f em o t io n s, a d d ressin g t h e m a n n er in wh ich
em o t io n s b en e t la rge gro u p s a n d so cia l o rga n isa t io n s (e.g. L u t z &
W h ite, 198 6). T h u s, em o t io n s su ch a s a n ger o r love m ay o rga n ise in t ern a l
p ro cesses, so cia l in t era ct io n s, a n d even gro u p ritu a ls a n d so cieta l in st it u -
t io n s in fu n ct io n a lly co m p lem en t a ry wa ys (K eltn er & H a id t , T h is I ssu e;
L even so n , 1994) .
Manner of Organisation
A t a ny given level o f a n a lysis, fu n ct io n a l a cco u n t s m ay d iffer in t er m s o f h ow
t h ey a re str u ct u red . C ert a in fu n ct io n a l a cco u n t s t a ke a s t h eir u n it o f a n a lysis
a sin gle em o t io n , a s in a n a lyses o f a n ger (L u t z, 198 8), d isgu st (R o zin , 1996 ),
em b a r ra ssm en t (K eltn er & Bu swell, 1997) , o r jea lo u sy (St ea r n s, 1989) , a n d
exp lica te t h e ra n ge o f fu n ct io n s ser ved b y t h a t em o t io n . O t h er fu n ct io n a l
a cco u n t s t a ke a s t h eir u n it o f a n a lysis a sp eci c co n t ext , fo r exa m p le,
gr eet in g u n k n o wn o t h ers (E ib l-E ib esfeld t , 1989) , p lay (B owlb y, 19 69), o r
t ea sin g (K eltn er, Yo u n g, H eerey, O em ig, & M o n a rch , 199 8), a n d t h en
exa m in e t h e fu n ct io n s p layed b y m u ltip le em o t io n s with in t h a t co n t ext .
St ill o t h er s m ay t a k e a s t h eir u n it o f a n a lysis a given fu n ct io n (e.g. a t t a ch -
m en t ), a n d t h en ca refu lly exa m in e a va r iet y o f em o t io n s t o see wh et h er t h ese
a p p ea r t o serve t h is fu n ct io n in a sp eci c co n t ext (e.g. Bow lby, 19 69).
Range of Focus
F in a lly, fu n ct io n a l a cco u n t s o f em o t io n a lso m ay d iffer with resp ect t o
t h eir ra n ge o f fo cu s. So m e a cco u n t s m ay str ive fo r a n a n a lysis o f em o t io n s
a cro ss a w id e r a n ge o f sp ecies, in clu d in g h u m a n s. O t h er a cco u n t s m ay
rest rict t h em selves t o h u m a n s. A cco u n t s a lso m ay d iffer with resp ect t o
t h eir co n sid er a tio n o f d evelo p m en t a l issu es, w it h so m e a cco u n t s en ga gin g
t h e co m p lexities o f h o w fu n ct io n s o f em o t io n s m ay va ry over t h e lifesp a n ,
with o t h ers co n t en t t o elu cid a t e t h e fu n ct io n s o f em o t io n w ith in a m o re
lim ited ra n ge (e.g t h e a d u lt yea rs).
REFERENCES
Aver ill, J.R . (1980). A con st r u ctivist view of em ot io n . I n R . P lu tchik & H . K ellerm an (E ds.),
Emotion: Theory, research, and experience (p p. 305339). O r la n do, F L : A ca d em ic P r ess.
Aver ill, J.R . (1990). E m o tio n s r elated t o syst em s o f b eh avio r. In N .L . St ein , B. L even tha l, &
T. Trab a sso (E d s.), Psycholo gical and biological ap proa ches to emotion (p p. 385404).
H illsd ale, N J: E r lb au m .
Aver ill, J.R . (1992). T h e st r u ctu r a l b ases of em o tio n a l beh avior. In M .S. C la rk (E d .), Emotion
(p p. 124). N ewb u r y P ar k , C A : Sa ge.
Aver ill, J.R . (1994). E m o tio n s a re m a n y sp len d o red th in gs. I n P. E km a n & R .J. D avid so n
(E d s.), The nature of emotion (p p. 99102). N ew Yo r k: O xfo r d U n iversity P r ess.
Ba r r ett , K .C ., & C a m p o s, J.J. (1987). P ersp ectives on em o tio n a l develo p m en t: I I : A fu n ctio n -
alist a p pr oa ch t o em o tion s. I n J.D . O so fsk y (E d .), H andbo ok of infant development (2n d
ed., pp. 555578 ). N ew Yo r k : W iley.
Bo wlb y, J. (196 9). Attachment. N ew Yo r k: Ba sic Boo k s.
Bu ck , R . (198 5). P r im e th eor y: A n in tegrat ed view o f m o tiva tio n a nd em o tion . Psychological
Review, 92, 389413.
Bu ss, D .M . (199 2). M a le p r eferen ce m ech a n ism s: C o n seq u en ces fo r p a r t n er ch o ice a n d
in tr a sexu a l co m petit io n . I n J.H . Ba rko w, L . C o sm id es, & J. To o by (E d s.), The adapted
mind (p p. 267288). N ew Yo r k: O xfo r d U n iversit y P r ess.
B u s s , D . M . , H a s e l t o n , M . G . , S h a c k e l f o r d , T . K . , B l e s k e, A . L . , & W a k e e l d ,
J.C . (1998). A d a p t atio n s, exap tation s, an d sp a n dr els. Am erican Psychologist, 53 , 533548.
C a lh ou n , C ., & So lo m o n, R .C . (19 84). I nt ro d u ct io n. I n C . C a lh o u n & R .C . So lom o n (E ds.),
W hat is an emotion: Readings in philosophical psychology (p p.3 40). N ew Yo rk : O xfo rd
U n iversity P r ess.
C la r k , L .A ., & Watso n , D . (1994). D istin gu ish in g fu n ct io n al fr om dysfu n ct io na l affect ive
478 KELTNER AND GROSS
r esp o n ses. I n P. E k m a n & R .J. D avid so n (E d s.), The nature of emotion: Fundamental
questions (p p. 13113 6). N ew Yo r k : O xfo r d U n iversit y P r ess.
C lor e, G . (1994 ). W hy em ot io ns a r e felt . In P. E km a n & R .J. D avidso n (E ds.), The nature of
emotion (p p. 103111). N ew Yo r k : C a m b r id ge U niver sity P ress.
C u m m in s, R . (1975). F u n ct io n a l a na lysis. Journa l of Ph ilosophy, 72, 741764.
D ar win , C . (1872). The expressio n of emotions in man and animals. N ew Yo r k: P h iloso ph ica l
L ib r a r y.
D avid so n, R .J. (1992 ). A nt erior cerebr a l a sym m etr y a n d th e n a tur e o f em o tio n . Brain and
Cognition, 20, 125151.
D avid so n, R .J. (1993). P a r sin g affective sp a ce: P ersp ectives fro m n eu ro p sych o logy a nd psy-
cho p hysio logy. Neuropsychology, 7, 464475.
D avid so n, R .J., & C a cio p p o, J.T. (1992). N ew d evelop m en ts in th e scien ti c st u d y o f em o -
tio n : A n in tro du ctio n to th e sp ecial se ct io n. Psychological Science, 3, 21 22.
D ewey, J. (1895). T h e t h eo r y of em o tio ns: I I . T h e sign i can ce of em ot io ns. Psychological
Review, 2, 1332 .
E ibl-E ib esfeld t, I . (1989). H uman ethology. N ew Yo r k : A ld ine d e G r u yter.
E km a n, P. (1984). E xp r essio n a n d t h e n atu r e o f em ot io n. In K . Sch erer & P. E km a n (E d s.),
Approaches to emotion (p p. 319344). H illsd a le N J: E r lba u m .
E km a n, P. (19 92). F a cia l exp r essio n s o f em o tion : N ew n d in gs, new qu estion s. Psychological
Science, 3, 3438.
E km a n, P., & D avidso n , R .J. (1994). A ft erwo r d. I n P. E k m a n & R .J. D avid so n (E d s.), The
nature of emotion (p p. 176178 ). N ew Yo rk : O xfo r d U niversit y P r ess.
E llis, B. (1992). T h e evolu tion o f sexu a l attr a ctio n: E va lu a tive m echa n ism s in wo m en . In J.H .
Bar ko w, L . C o sm id es, & J. To ob y (E d s.), The adapted mind (p p. 267288). N ew Yo r k:
O xfo rd U n iversit y P r ess.
F er na ld , A . (1992). H u m a n m atern a l vo ca lizatio ns to infan ts a s b io logica lly r elevant sign a ls:
A n evolu tio n a r y per sp ective. I n J.H . Ba r ko w, L . C osm id es, & J. To ob y (E ds.), The adap ted
mind (p p. 391428). N ew Yo r k : O xfo r d U niver sity P ress.
F o gel, A ., N wo k ah , E ., Yo u ng D edo, J., M essin ger, D ., D ick so n , K .L ., M atu so v, E ., & H o lt,
S.A . (1 992 ). S o cia l p r o cess t h eo r y o f em o t ion : A dyn a m ic syst em s a p p ro a ch. Social
Development, 1, 122 150.
F r eu d , S., & St r a ch ey, J.T. (1 96 1). C ivilization and its disc ontents. N ew Yo r k : N o r t o n .
(O r igina l wo r k p u b lished 19 30).
F r ijd a , N .H . (19 86). The emotions. C a m br idge, U K : C a m b r id ge U n iversit y P r ess.
F r ijd a , N .H . (19 88). T h e laws o f em o t io n. Am eric an Psychologist, 43, 349358 .
F r ijd a , N .H . (1994 ). E m o t io ns a r e fu n ct io na l, m ost o f t he tim e. I n P. E k m a n & R .J. D avid so n
(E d s.), Th e nature of emotion: Fundamental questions (p p. 112122). N ew Yo r k: O xfo r d
U niversity P r ess.
G o rd on , S.L . (1989). T h e so cia lizat io n o f ch ild r ens em o t io ns: E m ot io na l cu ltu r e, com pe-
ten ce, a n d expo su re. I n C . Sa a r n i & P. H a r r is (E d s.), Child ren s understanding of emotion
(p p. 319349). C a m b r id ge, U K : C a m br id ge U n iversit y P r ess.
H ebb, D .O. (1949). The organization of behavior: A neuropsychological theory. N ew Yo rk :
W iley.
I za r d, C .E . (19 93). O r gan iza tio na l a n d m ot ivat io na l fu n ct io ns o f discrete em o tio n s. I n M .
L ewis & J.M . H avilan d (E d s.), The ha ndb ook of emotions (p p. 63 164 1). N ew Yo r k :
G uilfor d P r ess.
Ja m es, W. (188 4). W h at is an em o t io n? M ind, 9, 188205 .
Jo h n so n -L a ir d , P.N ., & O a tley, K . (199 2). Ba sic em o t io n s, r a tio n a lit y, a n d fo lk t h eo r y.
Cognition and Emotion, 6, 201223.
K elt n er, D ., & Bu swell, B.N . (1997). E m ba r r a ssm en t : I ts d istin ct fo r m a n d a p pea sem en t
fu n ct io n s. Psychological Bulletin, 122, 250270.
FUNCTIONAL ACCOUNTS 479
K elt ner, D ., & K r in g, A . (1998 ). E m o t io n, so cia l fu n ctio n , an d p sych o p a th olo gy. Review of
General Psychology, 2, 32034 2.
K eltn er, D ., Yo u n g, R .C ., O em ig, C ., H eerey, E ., & M o n a r ch , N .D . (1 998). Tea sin g in
h ier a r ch ica l a n d in t im at e r elat io n s. Jo urn al of Person ality an d Social Psycho logy, 75,
12311247.
K r eb s, J.R ., & D avies, N .B. (1993). A n introduction to behavioural ecology. O xfo rd , U K :
Bla ck well.
L a n g, P.J. (1995). T he em o t io n p r o b e. Am eric an Psychologist, 5, 372385 .
L a n g, P.J., R ice, D .G ., & St ern ba ch , R .A . (1972). T h e p sych op hysio logy o f em o tio n. I n N .J.
G r een eld & R .A . St ern b ach (E d s.), Handbook of psychophysiology (p p. 62 3643). N ew
Yo rk : H o lt, R in eh a r t, & W in st o n .
L a za r u s, R .S. (1991). Emotion an d adaptation. O xfo r d , U K : O xfo rd U niversity P r ess.
L eD o u x, J.E . (1993). E m o tio n al n etwo r ks in t he br a in . I n M . L ewis & J.M . H avilan d (E ds.),
Handboo k of emotions (p p. 109118). N ew Yo r k : G u ilfo r d P r ess.
L eeper, R .W. (1948). A m o tivatio n a l t heo r y o f em o tion to r epla ce ``em o tion a s d iso r ga nised
resp o n se . Psychological Review, 55, 521.
L even so n , R .W. (1 988 ). E m o t io n a n d t h e a u t o n o m ic n er vo u s syst em : A p r o sp ect u s fo r
resea rch on a u to n om ic sp eci cit y. I n H .L . Wa gn er (E d .), Social psychophysiology and
emotion: Theory an d clinical applications (p p. 1741 ). L on d o n : W iley.
L even so n , R .W. (1992). Au t on om ic nervo u s syst em d ifferences a m o n g em ot io ns. Psycholo-
gical Science, 3, 2327.
L even so n , R .W. (1994). H um a n em o tio n s: A fu n ct io n a l view. I n P. E km a n & R .J. D avid so n
(E d s.), The na ture of emotion: Fundamental questions (p p. 1231 26). N ew Yo rk : O xfo rd
U n iversity P r ess.
L u tz, C .A . (1988). Unna tural emotions. C h icago, I L : U n iversity o f C h icago P r ess.
L u tz, C .A ., & A b u-L ugh o d, L . (1990 ). I n tro d u ctio n : E m ot io n, discou r se, an d th e p o lit ics o f
ever yd ay life. I n C .A . L ut z & L . A bu -L u gh o d (E d s.), Language and the politics of emotion
(p p. 123). N ew Yo r k: C a m b r id ge U n iversity P ress.
L u tz, C ., & W h it e, G .M . (1986). T h e a n thr op o logy of em o tio n s. Annuel Review of Anthro-
pology, 15, 405 436.
M a nd ler, G . (1984). M ind and body : Psychology of emotion and stress. N ew Yo r k: N o r to n .
M a r k u s, H .R ., & K it aya m a , S. (1 991). C u lt u r e a n d th e self: I m p licatio n s fo r co gn it io n ,
em o tio n , a n d m ot iva tio n. Psychological Review, 98, 22 4253.
M a st ers, R .E . (19 95). M ech a nism a n d fu n ctio n in evo lut io n a r y p sych olo gy: E m o tio n , cog-
nit ive n euro scien ce, a n d perso n a lity. Psychological Inqu iry, 6, 6568.
M iller, R .S., & L ea r y, M .R . (1992). So cial so u r ces a nd in tera ctive fu n ct ion s o f em b a rr ass-
m en t. In M . C la r k (E d .), Emotion and social behavior (p p. 32233 9). N ew Yo r k : Sa ge.
N a gel, E . (19 79). The structure of science (2n d ed .) I n d ia na polis, I N : H a ckett .
N esse, R . (1990). E vo lut io na r y expla n atio n s o f em o tion s. H uman Nature, 1, 26128 9.
O atley, K ., & Jen kins, J.M . (1992). H um a n em ot io n s: F u nct io n a n d dysfu n ctio n . Annual
Review of Psychology, 43, 5585.
O h m a n, A . (19 86). F a ce th e b east a n d fea r th e fa ce: A n im a l a n d so cia l fea r s a s p ro t ot yp es fo r
evolu tio n ar y a n alysis of em o tio n . Psychop hysiology, 23, 123145.
P a nk sep p, J. (1986). T h e a na to m y of em o tio n s. I n R . P lut ch ik & H . K ellerm a n (E ds.), Emo-
tion: theory, resea rch, and experience (Vo l. 3, pp. 9112 4). O r la n do , F L : A ca d em ic P r ess.
P in ker, S., & Blo o m , P. (1992). N a tu ra l selectio n a n d n atu r a l la nguage. I n J.H . Ba r ko w, L .
C osm id es, & J. To o by (E ds.), The ada pted mind (p p. 451494). N ew Yo r k : O xfo r d U n i-
versit y P r ess.
P lu tch ik , R . (1980). Emotion: A psychobioevolutionary synthesis. N ew Yo r k : H a r p er & Row.
R edican , W.K . (19 82). A n evolu tio n a r y p ersp ect ive on hu m an fa cia l d isp lays. I n P. E k m an
(E d .), Emotion in the human face (2n d ed .), N ew Yo r k: C a m br id ge U n iversity P r ess.
480 KELTNER AND GROSS