Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
INTRODUCTION
the world. Most people use English to communicate with other people from other
separated to the role of this language. For those reasons English has been taught at
1992:3).
elementary schools as a local content up to third grade of senior high schools. But
unfortunately even though various methods and approaches have been tried out to
reach the purpose, the result has not been satisfactory yet.
listening, speaking, writing, and reading through the mastery of the language
factors, they are: learners, the teacher, time allotment, material, the use of visual
aid, methodology, teaching material and interaction between the teacher and
students in the classroom.
includes all of the classroom events, both verbal interaction and non-verbal
1interaction. The verbal interaction takes place because of the teacher and learners
teacher and learners when they communicate without using words. These two
kinds of talk are important; they dominate the classroom events and influence
comprehensible input but also their own output. But a good lesson is not one in
which students do all or even most of the talking. Some lesson may be good if
they are carefully structured in such away that students do a good deal of talking
and at the same time get a lot of feedback from the teacher, both formally and
that teaching will be effective depending to a large degree on how directly and
Based on the FIAC, there are three categories in the classroom interaction,
they are: teacher talk, students talk, and no/all talk. Teacher talk includes accept
feeling, praises, accept/ uses ideas of students, ask question, lecturing, giving
direction and criticizing. Student talk includes student talk response and student
It is clear that the active role of both the teacher and learners is absolutely
needed to create a good interaction because everyone will learn something better
English from the teacher, be active in responding the teachers questions, and
introducing their own ideas. Besides, the teacher must be creative in using
learned by the learners. Those are not easy tasks for many teachers, because as
Goodman said that language appears sometimes to be so easy to learn and at other
times so hard (Goodman, 1986:39). If the teacher fails, he cannot achieve the
teaching-learning objectives.
With all of these backgrounds, I want to study the teacher and learners talk
high school has to be developed by improving the quality of the teacher and
learners talk because they will govern the classroom behavior. Now formal
Competence that demands both the teacher and learners to be active. Its emphasis
is on process of gaining knowledge and applying the skill of the students, here the
I chose the teacher and learners talk in the classroom interaction based on
the FIAC as the topic of this final project with the following considerations:
a. The teacher and learners talk is very important in teaching and they affect the
students acquisition.
b. Through the learners talk, students can apply and practice the language
c. Through the teacher talk, the teacher can realize his role and what he is going
to do, because in fact there are still many teachers teach their learners without
e. I wish to know and observe the language used by the teacher and learners
a. How is the interaction between the teacher and learners conducted in the
classroom?
3b. What language do the teacher and students use in the classroom interaction
and why?
a. To describe the interaction between the teacher and learners while they are in
the classroom.
teaching, especially the teaching of English to junior high school students. I also
hope that the result would contribute to the development of English teaching in
that way the interaction can be more effective. Teacher should reduce the use of
knowledge.
the study.
High School, Learner Talk and Teacher Talk, and The Interaction
Categories (FIAC).
was: The approach, the Research Site, and the Activity Center. The
point is the Subject of the Study, the Type of Data, the Techniques
2. 1 Theory of Language
(Ramelan, 1980:9)
Based on the statement, it can be said that the major function of language toward
human life is for communication. When people communicate, they use language
Another definition which supports the idea above is the definition from
From the definition above, it is clear that there is a close relationship between
language human being and society. Language distinguishes human from other
creatures in the world. Human can create language so that there is a culture in
their life.
People need to communicate with other but they cannot do that smoothly,
6by them. All normal people in a community understand and speak well enough
their language to carry out every activity. However some people in that
community cannot read or write, but by using the language they are still able to
of arbitrary, vocal symbols which permits all people in a given culture, or other
people who have learned the system of that culture to communicate or to interact.
In fact, we use languages to transmit every single message in our minds through
usually involves at least two problems, the speaker and the hearer. It is true that
the interaction between speaker and hearer makes the meanings become clear. The
hearer gives the speaker a feedback as to whether or not he understands what the
speaker has said. In this way, the speaker can revise what he has said and tried to
successful when the hearer understands what speaker says, and in turns the
step. Since he does not go to school at his age, he does not learn his first language
definition, knowledge or skill about language use can be gained by the learners
through the study in the classroom or through experience in his life. During the
process of learning, there are changes of learners behavior. They will get the
knowledge or skill that they have not had before as the result of learning. Kimbley
The changing of learners behavior and knowledge will depend on the effort as of
both the teacher and the learners. If the teacher uses appropriate methods in
teaching, it will be easier for the learners to study the materials. In this case of
learning, the learners study the material consciously and practice it in order to get
good results.
f. is a change in behavior.
what the speaker wants to say. By speaking, one can express his minds, ideas, and
written languages. Spoken languages have already been used far before the
In the process of learning in the classroom, both the teacher and the
learners use the language to interact with one another. The language used is
mostly spoken. In this case speech has the priority in language teaching. One of
the principles of the language teaching is that spoken language is primary, and this
Brook, who as quoted by Richard, et. al. (1986:49), argues that the primarily
medium of language is oral. Speech is language, and since many languages do not
have a written form, and since we learn to speak before we learn to read or write,
it is argued that language is primarily what is spoken and only secondary what is
written.
language, the students must learn the spoken form first and written form later.
There are many kinds of methods in language teaching, but there is no best
method of teaching or any method that will suit all occasions. In almost every
purpose to get good teaching result. Methods cannot be separated from one
with other people from different parts of the world. In Indonesia, English is taught
as a compulsory subject in the junior and senior high school, including the
vocational school. And now English is also taught in many elementary schools as
a local content.
difficult to learn. The other reason is that they have spoken their native language
previously which will interfere with their acquisition of the new language. It can
be shown by the fact that the students tend to transfer their native language rule to
the new language they are learning. Considering the differences between the two
Between the ages 10 and 18 the range of the middle and secondary-school
that the lives of teenagers are full of complexities and enigmas. The business of
growing up is a complicated one. Adolescents are torn by many conflicts and
where someone is searching for individual identity and that this search provides
the key challenge for this age group. Identity has to be forged among classmates
heterogeneous. Harmer also states that adolescents sometimes can cause discipline
problems and be disruptive in class. It because of the boredom they feel and the
Penny Ur in Harmer suggests, teenage students are in fact overall the best
great creativity, passionate commitment to things which interest them, and a great
solidarity among classmates. Thus, they have unique characteristics. Teacher has
to be able to use these characteristics and dig their potency through a supportive
11and constructive way, so that besides achieving the goal of teaching learning
Based on the reality above, there must be variety in the classroom, such as
the teaching-learning process, the teacher should sometimes let the learners work
enabling the learner to learn, setting the condition for learning. The teacher as
facilitator should give the facility to the learners the learning process. He must
select the teaching material related to the learners need, and arrange them from
the simple to the complex item. Richards et, al. (1992:7) suggest that the
expose every particular material, since all methods have their advantages and
disadvantages. This is in line with Harmers (2001:57) opinion that the teacher
tutor, observer and model. Here, the teacher has acquired knowledge about
curriculum, teaching methods, subject matter, and child behavior, together with a
In the teaching learning process the teacher has to pay attention to the
foreign language can be enjoyable subject and mastered by the learners well with
pleasure.
Hornby has written that talk has some meanings, they are: a conversation
teachers make adjustments to both language form and language function in order
known that teacher talk is a major way used by the teacher to convey information,
have discussion and negotiations and motivate his students, so he can give the
It has been said before that teacher and learner talks are the factors that
teacher talk will make the students passive and static; they cannot improve their
English acquisition. It will be also bad if the teacher has too little talk, the students
will not get enough knowledge from him. But it is wrong to judge or assess
13teacher talk only by reference to its quantity. It is just as important to assess its
quality.
a. Physiological aspect
This aspect related to the voice produced by the teacher. The teacher has to be
b. Interpersonal aspect
This aspect related to how the teacher speaks with utterances which is
c. Pedagogical aspect
This aspect related to how teacher organize the lesson, so it can create a good
interaction.
(Johnson, et. al., 1986: 70-72)
From the statement above, it can be known that the teacher have to be able
to make his talk balance with students talk, situation and context because it can
affect students language acquisition. As William Ayers says that the focus of
teaching, so that the teachers ability to combine and apply the three aspects in his
learn language (Halliday, 1986:16). It is same with when they learn foreign
language in the classroom. Firstly they imitate the teacher talk and they need more
time to record every teachers talk that its called silent period, then start to
express their own idea, having discussion, and finally can get their communicative
competence.
Student talk can be said as students speech when he imitates his teachers
examples, expresses his idea or gives comments and criticism about something in
the classroom, because Prabhu said that learners have effort in the language
classroom (Prabhu,1991: 49), but teachers role cannot be separated from their
number of different reason and on a continued basis throughout the school day.
process.
not exist. A good interaction will make messages transmission success and create
possibilities
There are seven categories used when the teacher is talking and two
categories when the learner is talking. In his pioneering work, Flanders used the
term Interaction Analysis for his ten-category observation schedule that he had
rather than for any subject in particular. In his work, he combined a politically
powerful idea with a very practical simplicity. The powerful idea was that the
teaching was more or less effective depending on how directly or indirectly
high school classroom. The research method I used will be described in the
subsequent sections of this chapter, which include discussion of the approach, the
location, the subject of the study, the type of the data, and the techniques of data
gathering. The procedures collecting data activity and procedures of data analysis
The goal of the study was to get a clear description of speech strategies
an English classroom. Since the speech strategies was a process which involved
human behavior in its natural setting the writer decided to make use of the
methods, concern with the understanding of human behavior from the actors own
The research was centered at the Arts and Languages Faculty, the state
Semarang.
The data collection activities were made at SMP N 2 Cepiring Kendal,
which was located on Jalan Kyai Ibrahim, about 5 minutes from my house on
foot. My house is near from the data collection centre (the school).
The subjects of the study were the second year students of SMP N 2
Cepiring Kendal in the academic year 2006/2007. They had studied English as a
foreign language for about two years. The writer used one class; they are VIII.A
The data of the study were collected in the form of recorded classroom
interaction and the observers field notes. The two types of database were
examined in order to identify what kinds of activity were involved in the teacher-
and also discussion. It was found that the interaction contained teacher talk and
learners talk as well as teacher activity and learners activity. In other words, the
data of the study were in the form of speech and actions. They were collected as
through the five senses; sight, smelling, hearing, touching and taste. (Arikunto,
2002:133). The observation was conducted twice (in the classroom and
interview). Each observation lasted ninety minutes. It was done on June 5, 2007;
the observation was from 10.15 a.m until 11.45 a.m. The observer directly
observed the classroom, and took notes on the relevant events while the teaching-
learning process was going on. In the meantime, audio recording of the whole
proceeding was also made to acquire more complete data about the classroom
process.
3.5.2 Interview
gave some questions to collect the data about the important features of the
language, and the data about the school social environment. The interview
The data collection activity was conducted through several steps. First, I
classrooms. As soon as the permission was given, I met the English teacher to
I went into classroom to conduct the observation. Steps of this research procedure
were as followed;
The data in this research were in the form of words, phrases, sentences
taken from the data resources (field notes & transcript). The data resources were
taken by using observation and in-depth interviews. The observation was done by
observing, recording & noting down the events happening in the classroom
interaction. The instrument for collecting the data was the researcher herself.
After the class was over I interviewed the teacher using the interview
guide which had been prepared beforehand. I also asked five students who
20supposedly represented the class for a similar interview. Interviewing the students
was done in group in order for the students to be able to express their opinions
The data to be analyzed in this study were the data of the teacher-learners
interaction in the classroom. In this study, I analyzed the observed data by using
Flanders Interaction Analysis System suggested by Allwright and Bailey
2. Determining the early data by reading and underlining the words, phrases, or
lecturing, example:
Minute 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
components as follows:
1. Teacher talk, which was sub-categorized into direct and indirect influence.
is expected to comply;
change student, bawling someone out starting why the teacher is doing
a. Accepts feeling, i.e. accepts and clarifies the feeling tone of the students
c. Accepts or uses students idea, i.e. clarifies, builds and develops ideas
suggested by students;
22b. Students-talk initiation, i.e. talk by the students which they initiate,
by the observer.
Based on FIAC, there are speaking strategies that I used for study. In this
table below, on number 1 up to 7 are teacher talk which are categorized into
Table 1
Observation %
No Speaking Strategies
TEACHER TALK
1 Accepts feeling
2 Praises or encourages
4 Asks questions
5 Lecturing
6 Giving directions
7 Criticizing
LEARNER TALK
3 Silence or confusion
Total
To identify the language used during the interaction, the writer examined
the recording and field notes and compared the language by counting sentences
used. Based on the recording the activity would be taken into the table below:
Observation
Language
Speaker Numbers %
Teacher
Students
English
Total
Teacher
Students
Indonesian
Total
Total Overall