Philippine Women’s University

High School
Taft Avenue, Manila

“Ian McEwan’s ‘Atonement’”

(A Book Review in English 4)

Analyzed by: Stacey Kate M. Posion

Section: IV-Integrity

Presented to: Mrs. Editha G. Celis

Date:
 I. Title: “Atonement”

I think the title suited the story because Briony really recon
ciliated on her fault. Her consciences were bugging her that she did
personal suffering. “I gave them happiness, but I was not so self-
serving as to let them forgive me," Briony says at the end of the
novel. Briony recognizes her sin and attempts to atone for it through
writing her novel. She does not grant herself forgiveness; rather, she
attempts to earn atonement through giving Robbie and Cecilia a life
together in her writing.

II. Author’s Profile

Ian McEwan was born on 21 June in

1948 in Aldershot, Hampshire, England. He
spent much of his childhood in the Far East,
Germany and North Africa where his
father, an officer in the army, was posted.
He studied at the University of Sussex,
where he received a BA degree in English
Literature in 1970. He received his MA
degree in English Literature at the
University of East Anglia.

He returned to England and read English at Sussex University.

After graduating, he became the first student on the MA Creative
Writing course established at the University of East Anglia by
Malcolm Bradbury and Angus Wilson. He is a Fellow of both the
Royal Society of Literature and the Royal Society of Arts, a Fellow of
the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, and was awarded the
Shakespeare Prize by the Alfred Toepfer Foundation, Hamburg, in
1999. He was awarded a CBE in 2000.

McEwan reiterates the comparison between himself, a writer in

reality, and Briony, a writer of fiction in his story. Throughout the
novel, McEwan compares himself, an author of literary fiction, to
Briony and both her literary fiction and real-life fiction. This
comparison draws a relationship between the life of the author and
the life of Briony in the story.

When he came to write Atonement, his father's stories, with

automatic ease, dictated the structure; after he finished the opening
section, set in 1935, Dunkirk would have to be followed by the
reconstruction of a 1940 London hospital. It is an eerie, intrusive
matter, inserting imaginary characters into actual historical events.
A certain freedom is suddenly compromised; as one crosses and re-
crosses the lines between fantasy and the historical record, one feels a
weighty obligation to strict accuracy. In writing about wartime
especially, it seems like a form of respect for the suffering of a
generation wrenched from their ordinary lives to be conscripted into
a nightmare.

Many ex-servicemen have found it difficult or impossible to talk

about their experiences of war says, Ian . His father never had any
such problems. He never tired of telling me, a bored adolescent, and
later, an attentive middle-aged son, how his legs were shot up by a
machine gun mounted on a German tank; how he teamed up with a
fellow who had been wounded in both arms, and how between them
they had managed the controls of a motorbike to drive to the beaches
of Dunkirk and eventual evacuation.

III. Setting

The story opens in an almost fairy-tale setting on the luscious

grounds of the Tallis family estate in Surrey, a county in southeast
England. It is a balmy, hot summer day and there seems no urgency
in the air. There is an atmosphere of celebration.

However, there are signs of distraction. An heirloom vase has been

cracked and the dinner meal is too hot for the steamy weather.
Briony, the Tallis's daughter, is hoping to put on a play but her
cousins are not following directions and are disappointing as actors.
Lola has usurped Briony's good will and has stolen the leading role.

In 1935 follows through the chaos and carnage of World War II

and into the close of 20th century.
IV. Characters
Major Characters

Briony Tallis – The Protagonist of the story. The

younger sister of Leon and Cecilia, Briony is an
aspiring writer. She is a thirteen year old at the
beginning of the novel and takes part in sending Robbie
Turner to jail after she finds Robbie and Cecilia
making love in the library.

Briony is part narrator, part character, and I see her transformation

from child to woman as the novel progresses. At the beginning of the
novel, there is a tendency to portray Briony as an innocent child,
unaware of what she is doing. But as the novel closes, Robbie reveals
that Briony might have betrayed Robbie. She had seen that Robbie
was more attracted to Cecilia than to her. She was jealous. At the
end of the novel, Briony has realized her wrongdoing as a “child”
and decides to write the novel to find her atonement. A lot emphasis
is put on Briony's imagination and her confusion. Frequently, Briony
is unable to discern between her real and her fictional worlds. She
died because of vascular dementia at age 77.

Cecilia Tallis – The middle child in the Tallis family,

Cecilia has fallen in love with her childhood companion,
Robbie Turner. After a tense encounter by the
fountain, Robbie and she don't speak until they meet
again before a formal dinner. Upset over the loss of her
love, to jail and war, she has almost no contact with her
family again. She is the total opposite of her younger
sister unorganized, messy, and clumsy. Cecilia was
killed by a bomb that destroyed the gas and water
mains above Balham Underground station.

Robbie Turner – Robbie is the son of Mrs. Turner,

who lives on the grounds of the Tallis home. Having
grown up with Briony and Cecilia, he knows the family
well. He attended Cambridge University with Cecilia
 and when they come home on break, they fall in love.
He himself made a mistake because of the love letter he
wrote for Cecilia that turned into evidence that he is the
rapist. He wrote in the letter, “You’d be forgiven for
thinking me mad—wandering into your house barefoot
or snapping your antique vase. The truth is, I feel rather
lightheaded and foolish in your presence, Cee, and I
don’t think I can blame the heat! Will you forgive me?-
Robbie” typing his love for Cecilia and thought of
something perverted “In my dreams I kiss your cunt,
your sweet wet cunt. In my thoughts I make love with you
all day long.” Robbie died before he could be evacuated
from Dunkirk and that Cecilia was killed by a bomb
three months later. He died of septicemia caused by his
injury on the beaches of Dunkirk

Minor Characters

Leon Tallis – The eldest child in the Tallis family,

Leon returns home to visit. He brings his friend Paul
Marshall along with him on his trip home.

Emily Tallis – Emily is the mother of Briony, Cecilia,

and Leon. Emily is ill in bed for most of the novel,
suffering from severe migraines.

Jack Tallis – Jack is the father of Briony, Cecilia, and Leon. Jack
often works late nights and it is alluded to in the novel that he is
having an affair.

Grace. Turner – The mother of Robbie Turner, she

was given permission from Jack Tallis to live on the
grounds. She has become the family’s maid and does
 laundry for the Tallis’. After the conviction of her son
for a crime she doesn’t believe he committed, she leaves
the Tallis family.

Lola Quincey – Lola is a 15-year-old girl who is

Briony, Cecilia, and Leon’s cousin. She comes, along
with her brothers, to stay with the Tallis' after her
parents’ divorce. She is red-headed and fair-skinned
with freckles.

Jackson Quincey – Jackson is a young boy (Pierrot's twin) who is

Briony, Cecilia, and Leon’s cousin. He comes, along with his sister
and his twin, to stay with the Tallis's after his parents divorce.

Pierrot Quincey – Pierrot is a young boy (Jackson's twin) who is

Briony, Cecilia, and Leon’s cousin. He comes, along with his sister
and his twin, to stay with the Tallis's after his parents divorce.

Danny Hardman – Hardman is the handy man for the

Tallis family

Paul Marshall – A friend of Leon's, who rapes Lola

and, some years later, marries her.

Tommy Nettle – Nettle is Robbie's companion during

the Dunkirk evacuation.
 Frank.Mace – Mace is Robbie's companion during the
Dunkirk evacuation.

Betty – The Tallis family's servant, described as

"wretched" in personality.

V. Plot/Synopsis/Gist/Summary
In the hot summer of 1935, 13-year-old Briony Tallis is already an
ambitious writer. She has written a play for her older brother, Leon,
who is supposed to arrive later in the day. The characters are to be
played by her cousins, 15-year-old Lola and the nine-year-old twins
Jackson and Pierrot. Briony's sister, Cecilia, has returned home from
Girton College, Cambridge, and is trying to sort out her confused
feelings towards the charlady’s son and her childhood friend, Robbie
Turner, who is home from Cambridge University for the summer.
His studies were financed by her father, Jack Tallis.

Cecilia wants to fill a vase with water at the fountain in front of

the Tallis’ house. She meets Robbie and they start talking, but the
conversation quickly becomes awkward. When Robbie wants to help
Cecilia with the vase, she remains stubborn, the vase breaks and two
pieces fall into the fountain. Cecilia strips to her underwear, jumps
into the fountain and retrieves the fragments while Robbie only
stares at her. Briony witnesses the ensuing moment of sexual tension
from an upstairs bedroom and is confused as to its meaning.

Leon Tallis arrives with his friend, Paul Marshall. They meet
Robbie on their way to the house, and Leon invites him to dinner.
Cecilia is irritated at Robbie’s coming, but does not know why he
bothers her so much.

Meanwhile, Robbie wants to write a letter to Cecilia to apologise

for his behaviour at the fountain. He indicates that he also feels
awkward around her, and, like her, does not know why. After
finishing it, he unthinkingly adds an obscene suggestion on to the
bottom of his letter, using the word “cunt”. Although he then writes
another version of it, it is the first that is accidentally delivered to
Cecilia via Briony, who reads it. Briony consults with her cousin
Lola; Briony is then convinced that Robbie is a “maniac" and that
she must protect her sister from him.

Upon reading Robbie’s letter, Cecilia realises her love for Robbie,
and they end up making love in the library. Briony interrupts them,
and interprets their lovemaking as a sexual assault upon her sister.

During dinner, the twin cousins run away, leaving a letter. The
dinner party divides into groups to go out searching for them. Robbie
and Briony are the only ones who leave alone — as Robbie has to
acknowledge later, the biggest mistake of his life. In the dark, Briony
comes across Lola being raped by an unknown attacker. Briony
convinces herself that Robbie is the attacker, as it fits perfectly in her
picture of him as a maniac. Lola, afraid of even more humiliation,
lets Briony do the talking.

The police arrive to investigate, and when Robbie arrives with the
rescued twins, he is arrested solely on the basis of Briony's testimony.
Apart from Robbie's mother, only Cecilia believes in his innocence.

By the time World War II has started, Robbie has spent three
years in prison. He is released on the condition of enlistment in the
army. Cecilia has become a nurse. She cuts off all contact with her
family because of the part they took in sending Robbie to jail. Robbie
and Cecilia have only been in contact by letter, since she was not
allowed to visit him in prison. Before Robbie has to go to war in
France, they meet once for half an hour during Cecilia’s lunch break.
Their reunion starts awkwardly, but they share a kiss before leaving
each other.

In France, the war is going badly and the army is retreating to

Dunkirk. As the injured Robbie goes to the safe haven, he thinks
about Cecilia and past events like teaching Briony how to swim and
reflecting on Briony’s possible reasons for accusing him. His single
meeting with Cecilia — the one kiss — is the memory that keeps him
walking, his only aim seeing her again. At the end, Robbie falls asleep
in Dunkirk, one day before the evacuation.
 Briony has refused her place at Cambridge, and instead is a
trainee nurse in London. She has realized the full extent of her crime,
and now remembers it was Paul Marshall, Leon’s friend, whom she
saw raping Lola. Briony still writes, although she does not pursue it
with the same recklessness as she did as a child.

Briony is called to the bedside of Luc, a young, fatally wounded

French soldier. She consoles him in his last moments by speaking
with him in her school French, and he mistakes her for an English
girl whom his mother wanted him to marry. Just before his death,
Luc asks "Do you love me?", to which Briony answers "Yes" — not
only because "no other answer was possible" but also because "for
the moment, she did. He was a lovely boy far away from his family
and about to die." Afterwards, Briony daydreams about the life she
might have had if she had married Luc and gone to live with him and
his family. (Later, it is briefly mentioned that after the war Briony
married a Frenchman named Thierry in Marseille).

Briony attends the wedding of her cousin Lola and Paul Marshall
before finally visiting Cecilia. Robbie is on leave from the army and
Briony meets him unexpectedly at her sister’s place, as well. They
both refuse to forgive Briony, who nonetheless tells them she will try
and put things right. She promises to begin the legal procedures
needed to exonerate Robbie, even though Paul Marshall will never be
held responsible for his crime because of his marriage to Lola, his
victim.

The fourth section, titled "London 1999", is written from Briony's

perspective. She is a successful novelist at the age of 77 and dying of
vascular dementia.

It is revealed that Briony is the author of the preceding sections of

the novel. Although Cecilia and Robbie are reunited in Briony’s
novel, they were never reunited in reality: Robbie Turner died of
septicemia caused by his injury on the beaches of Dunkirk, and
Cecilia was killed by the bomb that destroyed the gas and water
mains above Balham Underground station. The truth is that Cecilia
and Robbie never saw each other again after their half-hour meeting.
Though the detail concerning Lola’s marriage to Paul Marshall is
true, Briony never visited Cecilia to make amends.

Briony explains why she decided to change real events and unite
Cecilia and Robbie in her novel, although it was not her intention in
her many previous drafts. She did not see what purpose it would
serve if she told the readers the pitiless truth; she reasons that they
could not draw any sense of hope or satisfaction from it. But above
all, she wanted to give Robbie and Cecilia their happiness by being
together. Since they could not have the time together they so much
longed for in reality, Briony wanted to give it to them at least in her
novel.

The novel ends with a meditation on the nature of atonement and

authorship. The conclusion that Briony reaches is that an author
cannot achieve atonement through a novel; the author plays the role
of God in her novel, determining the characters' fates and altering
them at will.

A.THEME: The novel bears the name of its primary theme.

Briony atoned for her sin and never forgive herself even if
Cecilia and Robbie might forgive her. First there is the deceit
of Lola and Paul Marshall. Although it is not totally explored,
Lola must have known the identity of her assailant. Paul had
attacked her in the children's room in the Tallis family manor
before dinner. Later, he rapes her (or that is what Lola claims).
But Paul keeps silent while Robbie is taken to prison. Later
Lola and Paul are married, and they never confess their lie.
Briony too is deceitful. One could argue that she is shaken by
what she witnessed.

B.MOOD/TONE: The mood of the story is sad. The tone of

the story is tragic, sorrowful, and deceitful. Self suffering but
still unable to forgive herself.

C.CONFLICT: Briony made a big mistake in her life that

made Cecilia and Robbie apart when they finally realize their
love for each other. She accused Robbie even though she knew
who really the rapist was.

The Internal Conflict is in Briony as a child it is understandable

there are many things that she needs to learn even though she’s
already smart and a good writer. Briony is lost in her reality
world and her fictional world that made her confused on
deciding and the fact that she also loves Robbie but he can not
return her feelings because Robbie loves her sister, Cecilia. She
is jealous of her sister that she lied and made them part.
The External Conflict in the story is that Lola and Paul
Marshall did not confess their lie even though it passed for so
many years and until they got married. This is when Briony
felt so guilty about what she did because she really knew and
saw that Paul Marshall was the one who raped Lola and in the
end, they got married. She realized that she betrayed Robbie
and made him suffer for her selfish jealousy even though his
innocent.

D.CLIMAX

The Climax point in the novel arises when; an unknown

rapist raped Lola. The police investigate them all. As what
Briony saw in the library before the dinner, she marked in her
that Robbie is a maniac that attacked her sister earlier. She
pointed out and promised in front of the police that she really
saw in her own two eyes that Robbie is the rapist. The deciding
point is hard on her because she is confused and even though
she knows, the right thing to do her jealousy is the one that
urged her to lie and made them apart.

E.DENOUMENT/ENDING

The story ended tragically in truth but happily in

Briony’s novel. She did not intended the story to end happily
but she made it end with a happy ending at least in her novel
even though the truth is opposite. That is all at least she can do
for them for making them apart until the end.

F.STYLE

The author created an impact by using stream of

consciousness. Briony is the one who wrote the novel she is the
narrator too.

The narration of Briony is in the 1st person point of view,

she wrote it detailed and organized. The flow of the story was
that she wrote the after happenings before the beginning of
situation. It is narrated backwardly.
 The dominant element of the novel is the Theme as a
teenager myself it is hard to have a sinful memories and a
nagging conscience in your heart.

I find it most interesting is when Lola married the man

who raped her. Maybe she already loves him when she was still
a child.

VI. Standard Values

Factual Value:
The factual value in the story is that you will know some extra
knowledge about history and the happenings and sufferings of the
people in World War II. The places and hospitals where the soldiers
were sent to when injured and dying.

Psychological Value:
Briony grew up getting everything she wants. She’s a spoiled
brat because she’s the youngest child. Even in love she wants to
pursue it but she already know that her sister Cecilia already have
what she wants. Jealous, and rage in her heart unable to get what she
wants. Instead of still wanting to get it she made them tear apart.

Symbolical Value:
The symbolism in the story is the vase that got broken in to two
pieces. It symbolizes that the trust between Briony and Cecilia got
broken and can not be mend in to one piece again.

Ethical Value:
It has always been like this until now it is now like a tradition
that rich belongs to rich people only and poor people belongs to poor
people.

The Tallis family is rich they have big house and many
servants. One of the servants is the mother of Robbie Turner. Robbie
is also a servant of the Tallis family.
VII. Reaction and Suggestion

Actually, this novel was made into a movie. I saw the trailer and it
caught my interest. The movie won so many awards and it’s really
interesting. I watched the movie and I love it and when the story is
backwardly shown and narrated. I like the setting because it’s back
in the old times and it’s in the middle of World War II.

It’s like Briony became the God and she manipulate the life of her
sister and her love Robbie. Well she’s the author of the story.

I don’t want to change the ending I’ll leave as it is because it’s

appropriate for this amazing tragic novel. The two lover’s story
ended tragically but their love story in Briony’s novel ended happily.

I really recommend this to all the people especially to the people

who love to read books. It’s really knowledgeable, fun, interesting,
heart wrenching, eyes watering. And to all the aspiring writers in the
world you will learn so many things. Ian McEwan’s writing skills are
really outstanding. I love this twisted complicated story.