Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Diagnosis and
Address correspondence to
Dr Elan D. Louis, Yale School
of Medicine, Department of
Neurology, LCI 710, 15 York St,
KEY POINT
h Tremors are rhythmic a neurologic examination followed by focused neurologic examination. First,
oscillations of a diagnosis and, ultimately, treatment. the examiner should try to elicit postural
body part. tremor in the arms (ie, tremor observed
APPROACH TO THE PATIENT during sustained arm extension). The
WITH TREMOR examiner should assess the following
The approach to the patient with tremor, features about the postural tremor:
as with any neurologic patient, begins & Are the movements regularly
with a history and then includes a neu- recurrent and oscillatory?
rologic examination. & Across which joints are the
movements occurring and in
Medical History what directions?
The first step is to elicit a medical his- & Are the tremors in each arm
tory. This history should include an occurring synchronously (ie,
initial set of questions used to determine in phase)?
whether the patient has an action or a & Does the postural tremor have a
resting tremor. Open-ended questions reemergent quality (ie, is it
such as, What type of tremor do you initially absent)?
have? may be followed by a series of & Is the tremor accompanied by
more specific questions about tremor abnormal postures in the same
such as, Do you have your tremor when limb (eg, flexed posturing or
you are holding a cup? This is then dystonic postures)?
followed by additional questions that & Is the tremor characterized by
elicit information on the following: distractibility (ie, a decrease or
& The body regions that are involved cessation of tremor when
& The limb and body positions or volitionally performing a task [eg,
the specific maneuvers that elicit finger tapping with opposite
or suppress the tremor hand]), entrainment (ie, the tremor
& The age and time course of onset may be brought into a specific
and evolution of symptoms over time rhythm), or suggestibility (ie, the
& Whether the patient is aware or tremor may be induced with
unaware of the tremor certain stimuli)?
& The presence of any accompanying Next, the examiner should try to eli-
pulling sensations or pain cit kinetic tremor (ie, tremor that oc-
& The presence of associated curs during movement) by asking the
movements or additional patient to perform the finger-nose-
neurologic symptoms finger maneuver, draw spirals or write
& The current use of potential a sentence, pour water between cups,
tremor-inducing medications
or drink from a cup. The examiner
& The current use of tremor- should assess the following features:
exacerbating substances
(eg, caffeine) & Does the tremor have an
& Experiences of diarrhea, weight intentional component (ie, does it
loss, or heat intolerance worsen as the limb approaches
& Family history of tremor in first- or a target)?
second-degree relatives & Are dystonic postures present (eg,
during the finger-nose-finger
Neurologic Examination maneuver)?
After obtaining a patients medical his- & What is the relative severity of
tory, the next step is a detailed and kinetic tremor versus postural
KEY POINTS
h Given its progressive which is in excess of that seen in into a more complex, multidirectional
nature and propensity similarly aged controls. In most pa- tremor. Unless it is severe, the neck
to result in functional tients, this is mild, although in some tremor, which is a postural tremor,
disabilities, the term it may be of moderate severity. Some should subside and then resolve when
benign essential tremor evidence indicates that this gait ataxia the patient is lying on his or her back
is no longer favored. is more pronounced in patients who with the head fully at rest. Isolated
h The jaw tremor of have midline cranial tremors (eg, tremors neck tremor, with minimal or no ac-
essential tremor typically of the neck, jaw, and voice).5 companying arm tremor, is extremely
occurs when the Initially in essential tremor, the rare and should raise suspicion that
mouth is open rather tremor may be mild and asymptomatic the diagnosis is dystonia rather than
than closed. and may not worsen for many years. essential tremor. A curious feature of
However, in most individuals, the the neck tremor of essential tremor is
tremor worsens with time. Several pat- that patients are often unaware of its
terns of progression have been de- presence, particularly when it is mild
scribed. The two most common are: (Case 6-1). The presence of dystonic
(1) late-life onset (after the age of 60) posturing in essential tremor cases is
with progression and (2) early-life controversial, although it is likely that
onset (before the age of 40) with mild, the presence of a mild dystonic posture
stable tremor for many years that in the tremulous arm in some cases
then has a late-life progression. The does not preclude a diagnosis of essen-
least common pattern is that of early- tial tremor, especially when the dys-
life onset with marked worsening over tonic posture is a late finding in a
the ensuing years to decade.6 Few case with long-standing and severe
prospective, longitudinal natural his- essential tremor.
tory studies exist, but the best esti- Thirty percent to 50% of essential
mates of rate of change indicate that tremor cases are misdiagnosed, with
arm tremor worsens by 2% to 5% per many of these patients having PD or
year.7 With the progression of time, dystonia rather than essential tremor.
the tremor tends to spread beyond Differentiation from PD may be made
the hands and arms so that patients readily, however, by the absence of ri-
develop cranial tremors (neck, voice, gidity, the absence of other signs of
jaw). These are particularly prevalent parkinsonism (eg, hypomimia), the ab-
in women with essential tremor, sence of bradykinesia that is in excess
among whom the risk of neck tremor of age (ie, absence of slowness that is
is several times higher than that of men above and beyond that seen in normal
with essential tremor (Supplemental aging), and the absence of bradykinesia
Digital Content 6-1, links.lww.com/ accompanied by decrement (ie, absence
CONT/A180). The prevalence of neck of a sequential decrement in amplitude
tremor is the highest of these cranial during finger taps).8 The characteristics
tremors, with voice tremor being less of the tremor are also important in dis-
so, and jaw tremor being even less tinguishing a patient with essential
common. The jaw tremor is more often tremor from one with PD. The presence
one that is seen when the mouth is of isolated postural tremor (ie, postural
held open or during speech rather tremor with minimal kinetic tremor),
than at rest; the latter is more a feature a postural tremor predominantly in-
of PD-related jaw tremor. Neck tremor volving the metacarpophalangeal
often begins as a unidirectional tremorV joints rather than the wrist, or a postural
no no (ie, horizontal) or yes yes tremor characterized by greater wrist ro-
(ie, vertical)Vbut with time can evolve tation than wrist flexion and extension,
1146 www.ContinuumJournal.com August 2016
are all indicators that the likely diagno- essential tremor from the spinocere-
sis is emerging PD rather than essential bellar ataxias. Hyperthyroidism can be
tremor. Reemergent tremor is a pos- assessed by clinical history (eg, diar-
tural tremor that commences after a rhea, weight loss, or heat intoler-
brief latency of several seconds, rather ance) as can the use of medications
than immediately, and is a feature of PD. (eg, lithium, valproate) or other sub-
Flexed posturing of the hand during stances (eg, caffeine, tobacco) that
arm extension is an additional marker produce or exacerbate tremor. A dif-
of parkinsonism. Dystonia in the arm is ficult differential is between a mild
characterized by dystonic posturing case of essential tremor and an indi-
(eg, spooning of the fingers, referring vidual with enhanced physiologic
to the tendency during arm extension tremor, although the presence of neck
to flex the wrist and hyperextend the tremor should exclude the latter.
metacarpophalangeal and phalangeal Computerized tremor analysis, with
joints) (Supplemental Digital Content inertial loading (ie, placing a weight
6-1, links.lww.com/CONT/A180) or the on the hand), can assist with this
presence of a tremor that is neither differential. In patients with a tremor
rhythmic nor oscillatory. The possibility of central origin (eg, essential tremor),
of neck dystonia should be assessed and the primary tremor frequency should
is characterized by head tilt or rotation not change with inertial loading. Other
with head tremor, hypertrophy of the features that support the essential
sternocleidomastoid muscle, the pres- tremor diagnosis are the presence of
ence of a tremor null point, or a sensory essential tremor in one or more first-
trick by history (ie, a maneuver such as degree relatives. Reduction in tremor
touching the chin that lessens the with ethanol use is often used as a
tremor). Absence of cerebellar speech diagnostic marker; however, this is not
(ie, either scanning or dysarthric) and very specific and of limited utility.
absence of nystagmus distinguishes Patients with most tremor disorders
Continuum (Minneap Minn) 2016;22(4):11431158 www.ContinuumJournal.com 1147
KEY POINT
h With enhanced often experience a reduction in tremor agents that have been used include
physiologic tremor, no following ethanol consumption. topiramate, gabapentin, and benzodi-
intentional component The tremor of essential tremor may azepines (alprazolam or clonazepam)
occurs on the be severe enough to result in embar- (Table 6-1). High-frequency thalamic
finger-nose- rassment and functional disability, and stimulation (ie, deep brain stimulation
finger maneuver. these are the main motivations for [DBS]) markedly reduces the severity
treatment.9 Beta-blockers (especially of the tremor, as does thalamotomy, in
propranolol) and primidone, alone or patients with severe pharmacologically
in combination, are the most effective refractory tremor.
pharmacologic therapies, although many
patients choose to discontinue these Enhanced Physiologic Tremor
medications due to their limited effi- Enhanced physiologic tremor is an ac-
cacy (Table 6-1). Propranolol has been tion tremor of the hands that occurs
used in doses up to 320 mg/d, although to some extent in all people.10 The pos-
doses in excess of 100 mg/d are rarely tural and kinetic components are gen-
tolerated in the elderly, with the main erally several Hz faster and generally
issue being slowed heart rate. Asthma have a lower amplitude than those seen
is a relative contraindication to the use in essential tremor,10 with the caveat
of propranolol but is not an absolute that at disease onset, patients with es-
contraindication and must be assessed sential tremor have a low-amplitude
on a case-by-case basis. Primidone is tremor that may be difficult to dis-
given in doses up to 750 mg/d, although tinguish from enhanced physiologic
lower doses are often effective. An tremor.11 Unlike essential tremor, no
acute nausea and ataxia is observed in intentional component occurs on the
approximately 25% of patients who are finger-nose-finger maneuver. Voice and
prescribed this medication, and pre- limb tremor may be present but not
loading the patient with phenobarbital head (ie, neck) tremor. Cogwheeling
(eg, 30 mg 2 times a day for 3 days) is may be present, but it is not accom-
one method that is used to avoid this panied by rigidity. On quantitative
unwanted side effect. These drugs re- computerized tremor analysis, inertial
sult in a mild to moderate reduction in loading reveals a pattern that is con-
the amplitude of tremor in 30% to 70% sistent with a peripherally generated
of patients, but they do not abolish rather than a centrally generated tremor
it unless the tremor is mild. Other (ie, a reduction in the primary tremor
frequency occurs with inertial loading).
Medications and Treatment should begin with reas-
TABLE 6-1
Dosage Ranges for surance that the patient does not have
Essential Tremor essential tremor or PD. Many of the
individuals who present to a clinician
Medication Dosage Range do so because they are also anxious.
Propranolol 10Y320 mg/d Beta-blockers, at low dose (eg, pro-
Primidone 25Y750 mg/d
pranolol up to 60 mg/d or used in
a 10 mg to 60 mg dose on an as-
Topiramate 25Y300 mg/d needed basis), and benzodiazepines
Gabapentin 100Y1800 mg/d may be effective.
Alprazolam 0.125Y3 mg/d
Drug-Induced Action Tremor
Clonazepam 0.5Y4 mg/d
A variety of medications may produce
or exacerbate action tremor, and the
1148 www.ContinuumJournal.com August 2016
KEY POINT
h Voice tremor in patients furthermore, they should be of mild to 60 mg/d), benzodiazepines, or
with dystonia is often severity relative to the tremor itself. beta-blockers. For dystonic neck
associated with Tremor in the neck or voice is tremor, other options include IM botu-
voice breaks. another issue worth discussing. Patients linum toxin injections, selective dener-
with neck dystonia (ie, torticollis) may vation, or DBS.
also have neck tremor (Case 6-2).17
This tremor is generally neither strictly Primary Writing Tremor
rhythmic nor oscillatory and may be Primary writing tremor is a task-specific,
accompanied by twisting or tilting of kinetic hand tremor that occurs pri-
the neck, jerklike or sustained neck marily or only during writing and does
deviation, hypertrophy of neck mus- not occur or is milder during other
cles, or a symptom of pulling sensations tasks that involve the use of the
or pain in the neck. These features do hands.10,19 The current definition of
not occur in essential tremor. Also, in primary writing tremor excludes pa-
contrast to the head tremor of essential tients who have dystonic postures with
tremor, which generally resolves when hand tremor while writing (ie, dystonic
the patient lies down, dystonic head writing tremor).10 Primary writing tremor
tremor often persists while the patient has a similar frequency to that seen in
is recumbent.18 Voice tremor may also patients with essential tremor (ie, 4 Hz
be present in patients with vocal cord to 8 Hz) and is relieved by ethanol con-
dystonia (ie, spasmodic dysphonia), but sumption in 30% to 50% of cases.19 The
in contrast to the voice tremor of es- mechanisms that underlie primary writ-
sential tremor, is often associated with ing tremor are unclear, and it is debated
voice breaks or strangulated speech. whether the condition represents a
The treatment of dystonic tremor variant of essential tremor or a variant
includes the use of medications used of dystonia, and in some families all
to treat dystonia (ie, trihexyphenidyl three conditions may be present.20
up to 10 mg/d in adults, baclofen up Tremor in patients with essential tremor
Case 6-2
A 43-year-old woman presented for a neurologic consultation because of
neck pain with tremor. She stated that her neck pain had begun about
5 years previously, mainly on the left side. For the past 3 years, she had felt
a pulling sensation and increased pain in the neck region. She also
described that her head had been turning to one side and sometimes it
even felt shaky. She had not noticed any hand tremor. On examination,
there was a mild postural tremor of the left arm with a little bit of spooning
of the hand on that side. No tremor occured during the finger-nose-finger
maneuver. Her left sternocleidomastoid muscle was slightly hypertrophic,
and her head tended to preferentially turn to the right and shake
intermittently. The shakiness was irregular. This head tremor persisted even
when she lay down on the examining table. She was treated with IM
botulinum toxin injections to several neck muscles, which helped diminish all
of her symptoms, although they did not resolve completely.
Comment. This case illustrates a number of key features of dystonic
head (neck) tremor, including the fact that the tremor is often irregular
and that it often persists in the recumbent position. Furthermore, it may
be accompanied by pain or pulling sensations.
KEY POINTS
Psychogenic Tremor The treatment of psychogenic trem-
h The presence of
entrainment, distractibility, This type of tremor occurs in patients or usually begins with a discussion of
and suggestibility all with specific psychiatric conditions, the diagnosis, recognition of the pa-
point to a diagnosis of especially conversion disorder, and tients suffering, and a referral to a
psychogenic tremor. malingering.28 By history, the tremor psychiatrist in order to explore the
h Wing-beat tremor is often has a sudden (ie, abrupt) start underlying psychiatric issues.
considered a classic with maximal tremor at onset rather
tremor in Wilson than an insidious onset followed by a Wilson Disease With
disease, but it is not the slowly progressive course. On examina- Associated Tremor
most common type of tion, the tremor often has nonphysiologic Patients with Wilson disease may pres-
tremor in that disease. or unusual features (eg, may exhibit ent with a wide range of involuntary
variable frequency or change direction, movements, including tremor.31,32 In-
and an unusual combination of rest, deed, tremor ranks among the eight
postural, and kinetic tremors may major symptoms reported by patients
be seen) (Case 6-3). On examination, with Wilson disease who have neuro-
the clinician may see signs that are logic features.33 Tremor is usually ac-
suggestive of psychogenic tremor, companied by other neurologic signs,
including entrainment (ability of the although there are rare reports of iso-
examiner to alter the rhythm of the lated tremor and even rarer reports of
patients tremor by having it match isolated action tremor.34 Although the
the rhythm of a tremor the examiner classic tremor associated with Wilson
produces), distractibility (ability of disease is the wing-beat tremor (pres-
the examiner to stop the tremor by ent on abduction of the shoulder and
asking the patient to perform certain flexion of the elbow), it is not the most
mental or physical tasks), and sug- commonly observed type of tremor.32,35
gestibility (ability of the examiner to Overall, the tremor phenomenology
bring on the tremor with the power of is quite varied. Indeed, across patients,
suggestion).29 Interestingly, on quan- a wide range of tremors may occur, in-
titative computerized tremor analysis, cluding kinetic tremor as well as resting
inertial loading can result in a para- tremor, postural and intention tremors,
doxical increase in tremor amplitude tremors that can be symmetric or
rather than the expected decrease in asymmetric, those that are low ampli-
amplitude that should be seen with tude and others that are high ampli-
organic tremors.30 tude, and those that are intermittent,
Case 6-3
A 27-year-old woman presented for a neurologic evaluation with a reported
tremor that had begun suddenly 2 years previously after she had fallen down
the stairs. The tremor affected her entire body and was not relieved by
anything. She had been unable to work as a waitress since the onset of the
tremor and stated that her life was falling apart. On examination, she had
a head tremor, which sometimes involved a horizontal movement and, at
other times, involved a vertical movement. At other times it was complex
and rotatory. The tremor was virtually continuous. The examination was
otherwise normal. The examiner was able to stop the tremor for a few
seconds while distracting the patient.
Comment. A number of important features of psychogenic tremor are
illustrated in this case, including its sudden onset, its often variable quality,
and the fact that it may cease when the patient is distracted.
KEY POINT
h Midbrain (rubral) tremor characterized by sensory deficits, weak- the pontine-midbrain region, affecting
is generally a unilateral ness, wasting (Supplemental Digital Con- cerebellar outflow tracts and dopaminer-
tremor accompanied tent 6-3, links.lww.com/CONT/A182), gic nigrostriatal fibers.53 There are also
by rest, postural, and diminished/absent deep tendon re- reports of lesions occurring elsewhere
and kinetic/intentional flexes is readily apparent in the tremu- (eg, the thalamus),54 which is one of
components. lous limb or limbs,48,49 although the the motivations for referring to the
severity of the weakness does not ne- tremor as Holmes tremor rather than
cessarily correlate with the severity of rubral tremor. As the dopaminergic
the tremor.50 The tremor disappears if system is involved in most cases,
neuropathic weakness progresses to treatment with levodopa (100 mg/d to
the point of paralysis. The underlying 1000 mg/d) may be beneficial.55 In
mechanisms are likely to be diverse and addition, medications that are used
may involve central as well as peripheral for the treatment of essential tremor
components.44 If the tremor occurs may be effective. DBS has proven
in the setting of an immunoglobulin- beneficial in some cases as well.55
mediated disease, then immunosuppres-
sive therapies, such as corticosteroids, RESTING TREMOR
IV immunoglobulin, cyclophosphamide, The differential for resting tremor is
or plasma exchange may be used. There less extensive than that of kinetic
are several reports of the use of pre- tremor. The main items are PD and
gabalin (up to 450 mg/d) for the treat- drug-induced tremor.
ment of neuropathic tremor.46 The
tremor may respond to DBS.51 Parkinson Disease
The tremor in patients with PD is clas-
Midbrain (Rubral) Tremor sically a tremor at rest. The tremor may
Midbrain tremor has also been re- affect any limb but is generally asym-
ferred to as Holmes tremor or rubral metric, affecting one limb or one side
tremor.10,52 The tremor is generally of the body (ie, arm and leg) preferen-
unilateral and has three components: tially. In patients with arm tremor, the
tremor at rest, postural tremor, and tremor often involves distal joints
kinetic/intentional tremor, with the rel- (eg, fingers and wrist) rather than the
ative severity generally being such that elbow or shoulder. In addition, wrist
kinetic tremor is greater than postural pronation-supination rather than
tremor, which is greater than resting flexion-extension is more common
tremor (Supplemental Digital Con- (Supplemental Digital Content 6-5,
tent 6-4, links.lww.com/CONT/A183). links.lww.com/CONT/A184). In addi-
The tremor is often severe and dis- tion, limb postures (flexed posture of
abling and can render the affected the hand while walking or during arm
limb functionally useless. Patients may extension) is quite common, as are other
have other neurologic signs as well, cardinal signs of parkinsonism. A con-
including mild dystonia or ataxia. The fusing feature of the examination can
tremor may occur in a variety of clinical be the presence of reemergent tremor
settings (eg, in the setting of a brain during arm extension or during activi-
tumor, multiple sclerosis, or slowly ties (eg, pouring water). Tremor may
expanding vascular lesion) and, when affect the jaw, although in contrast to
occurring in the setting of a stroke, the essential tremor, is more often there
tremor may arise after a latency of when the mouth is closed and relaxed
months to years. On brain imaging, a rather than while speaking or holding
lesion is often but not always present in the mouth open.
1154 www.ContinuumJournal.com August 2016
16. Defazio G, Conte A, Gigante AF, et al. 30. Schwingenschuh P, Katschnig P, Seiler S, et al.
Is tremor in dystonia a phenotypic feature of Moving toward laboratory-supported
dystonia? Neurology 2015;84(10):1053Y1059. criteria for psychogenic tremor. Mov Disord
doi:10.1212/WNL.0000000000001341. 2011;26(14):2509Y2515. doi:10.1002/
mds.23922.
17. Jankovic J, Leder S, Warner D, Schwartz K.
Cervical dystonia: clinical findings and 31. Soltanzadeh A, Soltanzadeh P, Nafissi S, et al.
associated movement disorders. Neurology Wilsons disease: a great masquerader. Eur
1991;41(7):1088Y1091. Neurol 2007;57(2):80Y85.
18. Agnew A, Frucht SJ, Louis ED. Supine head 32. Lorincz MT. Neurologic Wilsons disease.
tremor: a clinical comparison of essential Ann N Y Acad Sci 2010;1184:173Y187.
tremor and spasmodic torticollis patients. doi:10.1111/j.1749-6632.2009.05109.x.
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2012;83(2):
33. Walshe JM, Yealland M. Wilsons disease:
179Y181. doi:10.1136/jnnp-2011-300823.
the problem of delayed diagnosis. J Neurol
19. Bain PG, Findley LJ, Britton TC, et al. Primary Neurosurg Psychiatry 1992;55(8):692Y696.
writing tremor. Brain 1995;118(pt 6):1461Y1472.
34. Frucht S, Sun D, Schiff N, et al. Arm tremor
20. Cohen LG, Hallett M, Sudarsky L. A single secondary to Wilsons disease. Mov Disord
family with writers cramp, essential tremor, 1998;13(2):351Y353.
and primary writing tremor. Mov Disord
1987;2(2):109Y116. 35. Starosta-Rubinstein S, Young AB, Kluin K,
et al. Clinical assessment of 31 patients
21. Louis ED, Ford B, Wendt KJ, et al. A comparison with Wilsons disease. Correlations with
of different bedside tests for essential tremor. structural changes on magnetic resonance
Mov Disord 1999;14(3):462Y467. imaging. Arch Neurol 1987;44(4):
22. Rana AQ, Vaid HM. A review of primary 365Y370.
writing tremor. Int J Neurosci 2012;122(3): 36. Machado A, Chien HF, Deguti MM, et al.
114Y118. doi:10.3109/00207454. Neurological manifestations in Wilsons
2011.635827. disease: report of 119 cases. Mov Disord
2006;21(12):2192Y2196.
23. Yaltho TC, Ondo WG. Orthostatic tremor: a
review of 45 cases. Parkinsonism Relat Disord 37. Saito T. Presenting symptoms and natural
2014;20(7):723Y725. doi:10.1016/j.parkreldis. history of Wilson disease. Eur J Pediatr
2014.03.013. 1987;146(3):261Y265.