Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Abstract
Background and Purpose The aim of this study was to conduct a population-
based epidemiological survey among young adults aged 18 to 44 years in
Northern Sweden and furthermore to gain further insight into the etiology of
ischemic stroke in this age group.
Methods Two studies were done. In the first part, epidemiological data were
collected to calculate incidence and mortality from 1991 through 1994. This was
based on the World Health Organization Northern Sweden MONICA register of
acute stroke events. Eighty-eight first-ever ischemic stroke patients were
identified during that period. In the second part, 107 consecutive patients aged
18 to 44 years with ischemic stroke referred to a university hospital were
studied prospectively during a 5-year period and were extensively evaluated
according to a standardized protocol. On the basis of modified Trial of ORG
10172 in Acute Stroke Treatment (TOAST) criteria, the patients were classified
into eight subtypes of ischemic stroke.
Results The average population-based annual incidence rate for ischemic stroke
(cases per 100 000 per year) was 11.3 (95% confidence interval, 6.7 to 16.1).
The case-fatality rate was 5.7%. According to the modified TOAST criteria, a
probable cause of ischemic stroke was identified in 36% and remained
unexplained in 21% of cases. Spontaneous cervical arterial dissection was the
leading probable etiology (13%). Patent foramen ovale or atrial septal aneurysm
was a possible cause of stroke in 28% of cases. The percentages of ischemic
stroke attributed to IgG anticardiolipin antibodies (4.7%), atherothrombotic
vasculopathy (3.7%), oral contraceptive use (7%), and migraine (1%) were lower
than reported in recent clinical series.
Conclusions The incidence rate for ischemic stroke was higher than previously
reported from most countries in Western Europe. The higher incidence was not
explained by a higher prevalence of premature atherosclerotic vasculopathy.
Without the additional diagnostic information derived from advanced cardiac
imaging, the proportion of indeterminate cases would have constituted 37% of
the patients.
Introduction
Ischemic stroke in young adults has been considered a relatively rare event,
with fewer than 5%1 of all cerebral ischemic infarctions occurring below the age
of 45 years, although more than 10% has been reported.2 The age-specific
incidence of stroke among individuals in this young age group has been
reported by community and hospital surveys from various geographic areas.
However, hardly any population-based data have been reported.3
The causes of stroke among young adults are more diverse than in the elderly
and require a thorough diagnostic workup. A major problem has thus been that
previous studies addressing the etiology of ischemic cerebral infarction in the
young have often been retrospective and nonstandardized, with highly variable
investigational techniques and sets of diagnostic criteria being applied.4 In
addition, advances in technology, including transesophageal investigation and
new biochemical assays, have introduced new potential causes of ischemic
stroke that still need to be substantiated. Finally, without the acknowledgment of
cases not referred for investigation, a biased pattern of the causes of the
disease may be present in hospital-based studies from third-level facility
hospitals.
Acute stroke events in the two northernmost counties of our catchment area
(Fig 1) have been monitored since 1985 by the WHO Northern Sweden MONICA
project.6 The case finding and validation of data quality have been described in
detail earlier.7
View larger version:
Map of Sweden displaying the MONICA surveillance area for Northern Sweden
(dark gray color) and the catchment area of Ume University Hospital. Eighty-
eight patients were included during 1991 to 1994 from the MONICA register for
the epidemiological part of the study. One hundred seven patients were
recruited and evaluated from the catchment area of Ume University Hospital
during 1991 to 1996 for the etiological part of the study. This includes the 71
patients from the MONICA surveillance area evaluated between 1991 and 1994.
The total population in the MONICA surveillance area was 518 669 on January 1,
1991, and 527 423 on December 31, 1994. The target population considered to
be at risk included all residents aged 18 to 44 years in this area. They
represented 37% (194 194 and 193 113, respectively) of the total population at
the beginning and at the end of the epidemiological survey period.
Clinical information from discharge records on all subjects in the age range 25
to 45 years with ICD-9 codes 430 to 438 was screened and validated for acute
stroke events that met the definition of ischemic stroke. Data from the group
aged 18 to 25 years not originally computed in the MONICA register were
obtained, adhering to the same guidelines. This part of the study thus contains
patients referred to our university hospital (included in the etiological study; see
below) as well as patients investigated only at local acute-care hospitals in
Northern Sweden. The same inclusion and exclusion criteria as in the etiological
study were used.
Etiological Study
A detailed laboratory study was performed, including complete blood cell count;
electrolytes; serum creatinine; amino-transferases; creatine kinase; urinary
analysis; erythrocyte sedimentation rate; serum protein electrophoresis;
concentrations of blood glucose and glycosylated hemoglobin; antinuclear
antibodies and IgG aCLs; rheumatoid factor; complement factors (C3/C4);
serological testing for syphilis, borreliosis, and viral infections, including HIV;
serum cholesterol and triglyceride levels; LDL and HDL levels; lipoprotein(a);
and prothrombin and activated partial thromboplastin times. Activated partial
thromboplastin time was also used as a screening test for the presence of lupus
anticoagulants. Levels of protein C, protein S, and antithrombin III were
analyzed both in the acute phase and at least 4 months after first admission.
Classification of Subtypes
Statistical Analyses
Incidence rate was derived from the number of first episodes of ischemic stroke
among the residents in the two counties during the study period. The average of
the populations living in the area between January 1, 1991, and December 31,
1994, was the denominator of the equations for the incidence rates. Case-
fatality rate was defined as the number of subjects who died within 28 days from
the onset of stroke during the same period. Ninety-five percent confidence
intervals were computed according to the Poisson variation for the number of
events within the age groups. Fishers exact and 2 tests were used when
appropriate for statistical analysis. Probability was two tailed, and P<.05 was
considered significant.
The study was approved by the Research Ethics Committee of Ume University;
data handling procedures were approved by the National Computer Data
Inspection Board.
Results
A total of 88 first-ever ischemic strokes in the age range 18 through 44 years
from the MONICA surveillance area were recognized during the time period of
January 1, 1991, to December 31, 1994. Seventy-one cases (81%) were primarily
evaluated or referred from secondary-level care settings for further
investigations at the university hospital. These patients are thus included in the
etiologic study part. The additional 17 cases, all admitted to local acute-care
hospitals, were identified from the MONICA project register. These additional
cases had all undergone CT scan or necropsy. No further cases were
recognized from death certificates only or from medical discharge records in
the group aged 18 to 24 years.
The average annual incidence rate of first-ever ischemic stroke in the group
aged 18 to 44 years was 11.3/100 000. The age- and sex-specific incidence rates
and the 95% confidence intervals are shown in Table 1. In both sexes the risk of
stroke increased with age, but there was no statistically significant difference
between men and women (2=3.03, P=.08).
Five patients died within 28 days, resulting in a case-fatality rate of 5.7%. Deaths
resulted from ischemic cerebral edema and herniation in 3 patients and from the
effects of severe brain stem cerebellar infarction in 1 patient. One patient died
as a result of a myocardial infarction and subsequent congestive heart failure.
Data pertaining to the yearly average of ischemic stroke events in men and
women in the group aged 25 to 74 years during the time period 1991 to 1993
were available from the MONICA register.7 On average, 562 first-ever ischemic
stroke events occurred yearly during 1991 to 1993. Ischemic stroke in young
adults thus represented 3.9% of all ischemic strokes in the group aged 18 to 74
years.
The distribution of the main diagnostic categories for the 71 patients evaluated
at the university hospital during the epidemiological survey period is shown in
Fig 2. The mean age of the 17 patients (10 men, 7 women) not evaluated at our
university hospital was 40.22.3 years (range, 27 to 44 years). Based on
information from local hospital records on admission and on discharge, an
apparent probable diagnosis could be assigned to 3 patients. Because of
incomplete evaluation at the local- level hospitals, it was not possible to allocate
the remaining 14 patients to a particular etiologic subtype.
Etiology
In this part of the study, 63 men and 44 women referred to our hospital from
January 1, 1991, through May 31, 1996, fulfilled the inclusion criteria. The mean
age of the patients was 36.56.2 years (range, 19 to 44 years); age and sex
distribution is shown in Table 2. Unwillingness to participate in certain
procedures, technical problems, pregnancy, and early death explained why
scheduled investigations were not accomplished in all cases. Selective
angiography of both carotids and at least one vertebral artery was performed in
95 patients (89%), and abnormalities related to clinical symptoms were found in
58 patients (61%). In addition, 3 patients underwent MRI angiography. All
patients were investigated by CT, and 80 patients (75%) were investigated by
MRI of the brain. The carotid territory was involved in 56%, the posterior
circulation was affected in 41%, and multiple territories were involved in 3%. Six
patients did not display any visible ischemic lesions on neuroimaging. One
hundred five patients (98%) underwent either a TTE or TEE investigation.
Lower-Priority Diagnoses
Thirteen patients met the criteria for lacunar infarct, ie, a lacunar syndrome and
small deep infarction compatible with small-artery disease. In 8 patients a
coexistent higher-order diagnosis was present (possible cardiac embolism
[n=2], possible atherothrombotic vasculopathy [n=5], and IgG aCL low-positive
reading [n=1]).
Eighteen percent of men and 35% of women had a history of migraine, but only 1
woman fulfilled the criteria of the International Headache Society for a probable
migraine-induced stroke.9 Migraine-induced stroke was possible in an additional
3 patients with higher-priority diagnosis (possible cardiac embolism [n=2] and
probable arterial dissection [n=1]).
Oral contraceptive use was the likely cause of stroke in 3 female patients with
additional risk factors (smoking and migraine [n=1], smoking [n=1], and
hypertension [n=1]). Five women qualified for another diagnosis (possible
cardiac embolism [n=2], probable arterial dissection [n=2], and possible
atherothrombotic vasculopathy [n=1]).
Discussion
The present study is one of the largest reported series of young adults with
ischemic stroke investigated by a group of physicians at a single medical center
and the first study of stroke in young individuals in which a clear population-
based strategy for case finding has been combined with a very extensive
diagnostic workup.
By international standards, the crude incidence rates for ischemic stroke in the
present study are higher than those reported earlier from most countries in
Western Europe3 10 11 12 (Table 5) and similar to those among whites in
Baltimore, Md.13 One study from Israel has provided information from this
decade with an estimated incidence for ischemic stroke of 5/100 000 in the
group aged 17 to 44 years.14 Our rates are only lower than the unusually high
rates of stroke among males and females aged 15 to 40 years of age in
Benghazi, Libya,15 and among blacks in Baltimore, Md.13 The reported 50%
higher incidence rates for ischemic stroke in the elderly population of the
Northern Sweden MONICA study compared with available data from the
MONICA study of Gothenburg, Sweden,10 together with older limited data from
the Stockholm region11 may suggest a south to north stroke gradient in
Sweden. The explanation for such a possible geographic variation is currently
unclear.
Similar to reports from other countries, incidence rates for both men and women
were found to rise steeply after the age of 35 years.16 In our study this increase
was mainly explained by an increase in the number of arterial dissections and
cardioembolic cases, but it was influenced to only a minor degree by an
increase in premature atherosclerosis (Table 3).
The topography of cerebral infarctions in young adults with ischemic stroke has
rarely been detailed in previous studies. The proportion of patients with
involvement of the vertebrobasilar territory has varied from 25% to 34%.2 19 The
relatively high proportion of involvement of the vertebrobasilar territory in our
study (41%) may at least partially be due to the extensive use of MRI
investigations. Thus, quite a few cases with ischemic lesions in this territory,
including cerebellar strokes, may have gone undetected in studies mainly
relying on CT scanning.
The prevalence of PFO and ASA is increased in younger adults with stroke, 28 29
particularly in patients with otherwise unexplained stroke.21 30 In those younger
than 45 years, a prevalence of PFO within the same range as in our study (24%
to 50%) has been reported from three previous studies.26 30 31 The mechanism
underlying thromboembolic events in patients with interatrial septum
abnormalities is not well known.21 32 Angiographic evidence of embolic
intracranial arterial occlusions was present in 53% of our patients and gave
some evidence of a nidus for thrombus formation. It is of interest to note that
50% of our patients with vertebral dissection had a PFO, an ASA, or both. It is
thus important to emphasize that significant vascular pathology must be
excluded before these cardiac abnormalities are accepted as the cause of
stroke in each individual case.
The risk increment for cardiovascular disease, including stroke, among users of
oral contraceptives is currently a matter of controversy.44 45 46 By ruling out
coexistent and more convincing etiologies such as cardioembolism and arterial
dissection, we could attribute a probable pathogenetic role to oral
contraceptive use in 7% of women.
Conclusions