Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
ISSUE247
This paper describes the differences between granular fluxes and powder fluxes in
terms of efficiency, environmental emissions and cost savings. The application of
fluxes in aluminium foundries uses both cleaning and drossing, and the difference
between these two groups of fluxes is shown in terms of melt cleanliness.
INSURAL ATL, a highly insulating, simple lining system, has been designed for optimum
performance. INSURAL ATL liners are precast to shape, highly insulating, fully fired and
delivered ready for rapid installation. The INSURAL ATL liner is fitted into a conventional
steel shell and surrounded by a highly insulating backing material for secure fitting
called INSURAL 10. The complete system is quickly installed and instantly ready for use
with no further firing necessary.
Bronzes and Gunmetals are an important group of copper base alloys that are used
extensively for applications where good pressure tightness and wear resistance
properties are critical. This paper focuses on the different stages of the process of
producing a casting, particularly metal treatment, feeding and filtration, giving
recommendations on the steps necessary to achieve high quality castings. In
addition, the role of simulation in ensuring optimum filling and solidification of the
casting is described.
For many years metal treatment using chemical additives has been conducted
manually. Subsequently, flux dispensing machines - single operated or in
combination with degassing units have been introduced to improve this key step in
foundries. Sometimes, however these machines do not function satisfactorily, as
blockages can occur during the metal treatment process. To overcome such problems
and to ensure that metal treatment can be completed in a single operation and
without any blockage, the MTS 1500 system has been developed. Nearly all
treatment steps, such as grain refining, modification, cleaning and element removal,
can be carried out using a wide range of newly developed additives. In addition, the
MTS 1500 has been designed to provide foundries with metallurgical, environmental,
health and safety and economical benefits.
Granular and powder fluxes for aluminium alloys. Cleaning efficiency, cost and environmental aspects
Cleaning fluxes are designed to remove aluminium oxides and other
Introduction impurities from the melt. The action of a cleaning flux takes place within
the melt, beneath the melt surface, by trapping the oxide particles and
For many years powder fluxes have encouraging them to float out. The flux has to be in intimate contact with
traditionally been used for the metal the melt, therefore it should be plunged and stirred intensively within the
treatment of aluminium and aluminium molten metal.
alloys, however these fluxes possess
certain disadvantages such as dust Drossing fluxes are designed to agglomerate the oxides in the dross and
generation during application, high toxic to separate them from the liquid metal leaving dry and powdery dross.
emissions, and problems of inconsistent Skimming is thus facilitated and metal loss due to aluminium
efficiency due to their morphology. entrapment in the dross is reduced. The flux should only be mixed with
the dross on the melt surface to avoid the re-introduction of oxides and
In order to overcome these disadvantages, other impurities into the melt.
fluxes in dust free granular form have
been developed. This paper describes the In order to have a better understanding of the cleaning efficiency in
differences between granular fluxes and aluminium melts, a test programme has been devised to compare the
powder fluxes in terms of efficiency, melt quality with the use of different flux recipes, morphologies and
environmental emissions and cost applications: i.e
savings. The application of fluxes in
aluminium foundries uses both cleaning cleaning vs. drossing flux
and drossing, and the difference between
these two groups of fluxes is shown in granular vs. powder flux
terms of melt cleanliness.
standard vs. Na-Ca free flux
The Prefil (Pressure filtration) test was
used to verify the molten metal Flux overview
cleanliness and results from tests on six
products are presented.
The following products were examined in the practical study (Table 1):
01
Figure 1 Operation of the Prefil test, which outputs a weight, filtered vs. time curve and a filter residue for metallographic analysis
1400
1000
800
Weight (g)
400
200
0
0 30 60 90 120 150
Time (s)
Oxide films affect the initial slope of the curve (20 - 30 seconds), with a
slope that decreases as the number of oxide films increases.
Fine particulate inclusions such as TiB2, fine Al2O3 or carbides cause the
curve in the Prefil test to deviate from a straight line. The loading of fine
particles can be inferred from the point at which the curve begins to
deviate from the initial slope.
02
Granular and powder fluxes for aluminium alloys. Cleaning efficiency, cost and environmental aspects
The build-up of inclusions on the filter, which is known as an inclusion Melting was carried out in a 230 kg
band, can often be seen with the naked eye in metallographic samples. capacity electric tilting furnace. Initially
The width of this band gives a quick indication of the level of inclusions 50 kg of ingot was charged and melted
within the metal. and held at 750C. Turnings were then
charged into the furnace, and the lubricant
Prefil curves are usually defined by comparison to industrial data. Each on them allowed to burn off while they sat
Footprint is compiled from an upper boundary that relates to super clean on the surface of the melt. Once this was
material and a lower boundary that relates to the industrial range of completed, the turnings were then
data. Figure 3 shows an example Prefil plot illustrating the window for plunged into the melt and vigorously
alloys that are not grain refined. stirred in.
1400
The furnace was then allowed to stand for
approximately 30 minutes and then
1200 skimmed before a Prefil test was taken.
Upper boundary
Clean metal
Increasing amounts of turnings were then
Lower boundary added in a similar manner until the metal
1000
Dirty metal
was considered dirty enough to replicate
industrial practices, as measured by the
800
Weight (g)
Prefil technique.
0
Manual stirring of the flux was carried out
0 30 60 90 120 150
Time (s) for 1 minute with the induction power off.
The melt was then heated to 740C and
Figure 3 The Prefil World Class Production Window
held for 10 minutes. After holding the
induction power was switched off and the
Experimental procedure metal drossed off (figure 5).
Tests were carried out on AlSi9Cu3 alloy type made up from in-house The metal temperature was again raised to
ingot and turnings (figure 4). 740C before a Prefil test was taken.
03
Results
The Prefil graph (figure 6), shows the cleaning characteristics of each
flux. These characteristics are the result of a curve subtraction technique,
as outlined below.
Flux Curve - Control
Efficiency = x 100%
Clean Reference - Control
200
180
160
140
Cleaning efficiency (%)
120
100
80
60
40
20
04
Granular and powder fluxes for aluminium alloys. Cleaning efficiency, cost and environmental aspects
Cleaning vs. drossing flux
The COVERAL GR 2410 cleaning granular flux gives the best melt quality
in the test. Compared to COVERAL GR 2510 drossing granular flux, the
cleaning granular flux performed about 20% better in terms of inclusion
removal. The same result was shown by the comparison between
COVERAL 105 cleaning powder and COVERAL 90 drossing powder
(figure 7).
200
180
160
140
Cleaning efficiency (%)
120
100
80
60
40
20
Granular Powder
Granular
Application vs.
powder
Product Efficiency Product Efficiency
05
Standard vs. Na-Ca free flux
All of the sodium and calcium free fluxes used in the tests can be used
for both drossing and cleaning. As they contain no sodium or calcium
salts the range of available raw materials and recipes is limited. The
cleaning efficiency of the melts were, however, found to be close to
standard granular fluxes (figure 8). If specified to use Na or Ca free
fluxes, dependent on the alloy, the result showed a measurable quality
improvement with a dry low metal content dross.
200
180
160
140
Cleaning efficiency (%)
120
100
80
60
40
20
Figure 8 Cleaning efficiency comparison between standard and Na-Ca free fluxes
Environmental aspects
Flux A Flux B
Powder Granular Powder Granular
Concentrations in mg/m
Total particulate 1.5 0.46 1.35 0.52
Total Cl 0.73 0.72 0.83 0.82
F 11 3.4 7.5 3.6
Nox - - - -
SOX 8.5 1.6 4.9 2.5
Table 3 Overall comparison of emissions for several furnace types in several conditions
06
Granular and powder fluxes for aluminium alloys. Cleaning efficiency, cost and environmental aspects
The overall indications from the work are that the amount of emission is
significantly reduced using the granular fluxes. This work highlights that
References
the most significant advantages are to be had by going from powder to
granular flux, rather than changing the formulation of the powder flux. 1. R. Gallo; Development, Evaluation and
This really supports the theory that the morphology of the flux is a very Application of Granular and Powder
significant contributor to the type and quality of pollutants that may Fluxes in Transfer Ladles, Crucible and
emanate. The move from powder to granular fluxes will improve the Reverberatory Furnaces;
working environment by the reduction of pollutants in the atmosphere. Foundry Practice 237 (2002)
The price of a granulated flux compared to a powder flux is higher due 3. S.R. Sibley; Granular fluxes for
to its manufacturing process, however as shown in the trials, the aluminium alloys, environmental and
addition rate of granular fluxes is significantly lower. Besides the technological advances;
stronger cleaning impact and the environmental benefits of granular Foundry Practice 227 (1996)
fluxes, there can also be an economical benefit which is illustrated in the
following example (ME = money equivalent, it does not relate to a
certain currency)
Powder A Granulate A
Selling price: 1 ME / kg 2 ME / kg
Addition rate: 0.35% 0.10%
Price per treatment of 100 kg: 0.35 ME 0.20 ME
Conclusions / summary
Fluxes in both powder and granular form have been compared in terms
of melt cleaning efficiency using the Prefil Test and have shown the
granular fluxes to be superior in all cases.
07
INSURAL ATL ladle lining at
NEMAK CZ
For example, if a conventional lining with
Introduction an expected temperature loss of 8C per
minute is used then a super heat of 80C
Energy costs and environmental considerations continue to put financial may be necessary leading to increased
pressures on the foundry industry. Concerns with global warming is oxide formation and higher dissolved
resulting in governments taxing both companies and individuals into hydrogen levels. Whereas an INSURAL ATL
becoming more fuel efficient. To remain competitive foundries will have lining system will only have a temperature
to look closely at all working practices to see where cost savings can be loss of around 3C per minute and so for
made and more efficient forms of metal melting and holding will have to the same treatment time will only require
be considered along with good recycling practices. 30C of superheat. This reduces the holding
temperature of the melting furnace, leading
The foundry industry, where energy consumption is a major factor, must to cost savings.
consider improving insulation along with sophisticated temperature
control and monitoring in order to reduce costs. Figures 1 and 2 show the relative
insulation of traditional linings against
One particular area of the foundry which is often overlooked is that of INSURAL ATL liners, an Infra red camera
transfer ladles, where costs are often not considered to the extent that is used to compare the energy emitted
they ought to be. Although these ladles are of fairly simple design they from both systems and the reduction in
can play a key part in controlling quality as well as cost of production. heat loss is clearly evident.
When looking for the ideal transfer ladle lining material a number of
factors have to be considered. Many foundries use traditional refractory
concrete linings which are poor insulators and difficult to dry completely.
These linings can be a source of hydrogen pick up as they can take many
days or casts to fully stabilise.
Other foundries use crucibles to line ladles but these are inherently
conductive and therefore lose heat rapidly.
When looking for the ideal lining material a number of factors need to be
considered mainly good insulation properties, metal cleanlinesses and
speed of replacement.
Figure 1 Refractory concrete ladle seen through an
INSURAL ATL, a highly insulating, simple lining system, has been designed Infra red camera showing the level of energy emitted
for optimum performance in all these key areas. INSURAL ATL liners are
precast to shape, highly insulating, fully fired and delivered ready for rapid
installation. The INSURAL ATL liner is fitted into a conventional steel shell
and surrounded by a highly insulating backing material for secure fitting
called INSURAL 10. The complete system is quickly installed and instantly
ready for use with no further firing necessary.
Insulation
08
INSURAL ATL ladle lining at NEMAK CZ
Metal cleanliness Thermal shock
To maintain casting quality the avoidance of oxide skins Many ceramic and refractory materials suffer from
and non metallic inclusions is very important. Oxide films thermal shock and thus have to be carefully preheated
and inclusions will reduce mechanical properties, act as before use for a considerable period of time, this being a
nucleating sites for porosity and unwanted intermetallic costly process. INSURAL does not have this problem and
compounds, as well as increasing the chances of lack of metal can be safely poured into the ladle even when it is
pressure tightness. A ladle lining which avoids the below 150C with no adverse effects.
formation of an oxide skin or, which makes any skin very
easy to remove, will ensure there is no cross Preheating
contamination between metal transfers and there will not
be a build up of oxide which can grow before breaking
Many refractory concretes have high thermal capacities
away to give hard inclusions in the melt. Using a lining
and will chill the molten metal on filling if not preheated
material which is non wetting will therefore be
close to the metal temperature. It is not unusual to see
advantageous. INSURAL ATL is such a system where the
these refractory concrete ladles being continuously
skull of remaining metal can be easily removed once
preheated with strong gas burners when not in use.
cooled, leaving a clean dry lining for subsequent
INSURAL does not suffer from this problem and minimal
transfers, compared to a conventional lining as seen in
preheating is required. To prevent hydrogen pick up,
figure 3 where a thick skull can be seen.
INSURAL should only be preheated after standing for
many hours, such as weekends, but in normal working
conditions little or no preheating is required. The
avoidance of preheating offers the foundry a significant
reduction in energy usage.
Wear resistance
09
This ladle has now been replaced by an INSURAL ATL
1000 ladle lining giving a safe transfer weight of 900 kg
molten metal. The ladle lining was installed in 4 hours,
painted with CERAMOL 258G and put into service
following careful heating. In order to use a tapping
temperature of 750C and a delivered temperature of
710 C the ladle liner is mildly heated and a temperature
of 380C is maintained on the INSURAL surface. The gas
consumption over the full period of the project was
measured and a reduction in gas usage of 90% was
found. The gas usage was reduced from 3.117 cu m per
hour to 0.29 cu m per hour.
No drying required
Fast relining.
Figure 6 INSURAL ATL1000 IB-Ladle with a capacity of 900kg
10
Sand cast bronzes and
gunmetals
11
however, or if the oxide skin is affected by other factors
(such as the presence or absence of deoxidants,
Filtration
impurities, etc.) protection is not provided and further
reaction can take place. Metal/mould reaction will The widespread use of ceramic foam filters has
therefore be most likely to occur in alloys that are introduced a new dimension into the running and gating
inadequately or excessively deoxidised particularly where of castings. Filters have several important effects:
phosphorus or magnesium are the deoxidants used.
They effectively trap dross and oxide films
The water vapour formed when the molten metal enters
the mould, having given up its oxygen to form an oxide They control metal flow
skin, releases a quantity of hydrogen. Such hydrogen is
very active and can enter into solution in the molten They reduce turbulence
metal unless the oxide skin formed on it is very strong
and protective. The use of ceramic filters allows the traditional gating
rules to be modified while still achieving quality castings.
With leaded or lead free gunmetal containing zinc, a Ceramic foam filters have a distinct advantage over the
phosphorus content of 0.03% or above is enough to extruded type in that there is no separation of the initial
cause the reaction. A residual phosphorus content 0.06% metal stream, hence the possibility of reoxidation at the
to 0.08% is usually sufficient to produce an appreciable filter face is reduced. The provision of a ceramic foam filter
effect. For gunmetal alloys and bronzes a severe reaction immediately after the base of the sprue changes the flow
can be prevented by coating the moulds and cores with patterns markedly.
MOLDCOTE*, MOLCO* or TENO* coatings.
The filter requires a certain amount of pressure and time
to prime, so the flow of metal is temporarily arrested on
Running and feeding encountering the filter, this allows the sprue to backfill
excluding air from the incoming metal. Metal exits the
Methods best suited to long freezing-range alloys should filter in a single turbulence-free stream at low velocity,
be used, with unpressurised or slightly pressurised hence the runner fills gently and the gates operate as
systems based on ratios such as 1:4:6 or 1:4:4. This type of designed. The casting then fills without the entrainment of
sprue/runner/ingate system can provide a useful source of air and oxide films. The beneficial effect of filters is their
feed metal to the casting as long as the gate remains ability to eliminate turbulence, although they also filter
unfrozen. Where additional feed is required, generous any gross dross inclusions which may be carried over
feeders must be placed on the heavier sections, as is from the melting unit. Bronze and gunmetal alloys
usual for long freezing-range alloys. KALMIN* S feeder especially benefit greatly from filtration in the mould.
sleeves are particularly suitable for bronzes and Because of the higher temperature compared to
gunmetals. Due to the usage of a high proportion of light aluminium-based alloys, SEDEX* ceramic foam filters are
refractory raw materials, a density of 0.45g/cc is achieved, recommended for copper-based alloys instead of SIVEX*
ensuring highly insulating properties. KALMIN S feeder FC filters, which are usually used for Aluminium alloys.
sleeves extend the solidification times by a factor of 2.0-
2.2 compared to natural sand feeders of the same size.
From these results, Modulus Extension Factors
Simulation
(MEF) of 1.4-1.5 have been calculated. Though KALMIN S
feeder sleeves can give more than 33% of their feeder A number of software packages are now available which
volume to the solidifying casting, it is recommended that model the flow of metals into dies or moulds and allow
a maximum of one-third of the feed metal volume should the filling and the solidification of the casting to be
be fed into the casting so that the residual feeder modulus simulated. Computer modelling is being increasingly
is adequate in relation to the casting modulus at the end used for the design of dies and moulds in order to reduce
of solidification. For this reason, it is recommended to the lead time required for making new castings.
consider modulus as well as solidification shrinkage in
order to determine the correct feeder. FOSECO provides Predictive fluid flow software, MAGMASOFT being one
tables allowing KALMIN S feeders to be selected with the of the best known, uses physics-based modelling to allow
desired modulus, volume (capacity) and dimensions. mould filling to be studied and its effects on casting
soundness to be assessed. Ideally such modelling should
enable the onset of turbulence during mould filling to be
predicted and the effect of gating systems on the
temperature distribution within the casting to be studied.
12
Sand cast bronzes and gunmetals
The first step in any flow modelling
investigation is to obtain a 3D CAD model
of the mould cavity and all of the
boundary conditions such as alloy type,
mould and core materials, coating used
etc. The filling simulation indicates the
direction of flow, the velocity and the
temperature of metal at any point and any
given time during the filling sequence.
13
Figure 3 shows the smooth filling of the
mould. The scale on the right hand side
gives the velocity by colour, any figure
below the critical velocity of 50 cm/s is
shown in blue. Figure 3 shows the mould
filling after 5.3 seconds.
14
MTS 1500 automated Metal
Treatment Station
15
The control panel contains a Programmable Logic Controller (PLC) to
enable the optimum treatment cycle, to establish, maintain and
Benefits
ensure consistent treatment. The PLC regulates the principle
functions of the MTS 1500 machine: lifting and submersion of shaft The MTS 1500 offers the foundry several
and rotor into the melt, the shaft and rotor speed, the dispensing of benefits that can be divided into four main
the desired quantity of flux/fluxes, the positioning of the baffle plate categories: metallurgical, environmental,
to initiate and terminate the vortex as well as the flow rate of inert gas. health and safety as well as economical
benefits.
Consumable products
The XSR rotor and COVERAL* MTS fluxes are products, which are key to Metallurgical benefits
the satisfactory performance of the MTS 1500. The use of COVERAL MTS fluxes in
combination with the MTS 1500 machine
The novel design of the patented XSR rotor enables foundries to get metallurgical
(figure 2) helps to create the optimum vortex benefits such as consistent mechanical
during the addition of the treatment and physical properties, homogeneous
products. In addition, it is highly efficient in microstructure and composition,
removing oxides and dissolved hydrogen acceptable levels of metal cleanliness and
from the melt. controlled gas porosity.
16
MTS 1500 automated Metal Treatment Station
Economic benefits
MTS 1500 enables foundries to make substantial cost savings by reducing
treatment costs and improving performance.
A set of case studies for different melt treatment steps such as cleaning,
grain refining, sodium modification, and/or element removal gives an
overview of the process and attendant benefits.
Grain refining
The grain size of cast alloys is dependent on the number of nuclei
present in the melt as it begins to solidify and on the rate of
undercooling. Grain refining improves hot tear resistance, reduces the
harmful effects of porosity and redistributes shrinkage porosity in
aluminium alloys. Titanium, particularly in association with boron, has a
powerful nucleating effect and is the most commonly used grain refiner.
Case study 1
A test in a die casting foundry for brake components for automotive
industry was carried out to compare AlTi5B1 rod with the newly
developed COVERAL MTS 1584 grain refiner. The treatment was carried
out in electrical heated crucible furnaces (Table 2).
17
AlTi5B1 rod (0.10%)
The material costs per treatment for AlTi5B1 master alloy (at 0.10%
addition rate) and COVERAL MTS 1584 (at 0.04% addition rate) are
generally similar, although this depends on specific master alloy prices.
Grain refining with COVERAL MTS 1584 in combination with MTS 1500
technology is a new and effective option for titanium boron nuclei
addition into aluminium alloys.
Sodium modification
Case study 2
The problem faced by a gravity die casting foundry producing safety
critical componets was variability in flux additions due to operator error.
This variation could be significant resulting in unacceptable scrap levels.
A MTS 1500 treatment was introduced as seen in Table 3.
18
MTS 1500 automated Metal Treatment Station
Gravity die casting FDU plus manual MTS 1500
foundry (automotive) treatment
Flux used Powder flux COVERAL MTS 1572
Melt capacity 500 kg
Treatment temperature 740 760C
Amount of flux used/ 4.5 kg 1.8 kg
treatment
Sodium pick up 150 ppm 150 ppm
Variation in sodium 13% 5%
content
Once the MTS 1500 treatment cycle had been optimised there was less
than 5% variation in the sodium content of the treated metal as the cycle
is constant. The foundry saved 60% of the amount of modification flux,
but the biggest benefit for the foundry has been achieved through
producing sounder castings with reduced scrap rates.
Case study 3
A sand foundry intended to change its melt treatment practice to
MTS 1500 to achieve a better consistency. Due to its particular location
near a housing estate, the use of a non-toxic material was not allowed.
FOSECO developed an environmentally acceptable product which is non-
toxic i.e COVERAL MTS 1576. The parameters for the process are outlined
in Table 4.
The intensive mixing of product with the melt given by MTS 1500
enabled the use of a non-toxic sodium modifier. The use of COVERAL
MTS 1576 with MTS technology reduced significantly the operator
involvement, and minimised the number of injuries caused by burns.
Also it improved the working environment, which is benefical to the
employees and to the local community.
Cleaning/drossing
19
A successful drossing agglomerates the oxides in the dross and The major economic benefit for the
separates them from the liquid metal leaving dry and powdery dross. foundry has been achieved by the
Skimming is thus facilitated and metal loss due to aluminium reduced quantity of dross and aluminum
entrapment in the dross is reduced. loss. The MTS 1500 provides a more
intensive mixing of metal with the melt
Case study 4 treatment product, which gives a better
This is a wheel foundry, part of a European foundry group, operating a segregation of melt and oxides. The total
considerable number of melting furnaces. The molten metal is transfered amount of aluminium lost has been
by forklift to the low-pressure machines in an 800 kg transfer ladle. reduced by about 50%.
Degassing and melt treatment are carried out in this ladle. Table 5
outlines procedure and result using MTS.
Element removal
European wheel foundry FDU plus manual MTS 1500
For special types of alloys (pistons or Al-Mg
flux addition
alloys), the removing of sodium, strontium,
Production capacity 20,000 tons per year
and calcium is essential. COVERAL MTS
Number of ladles treated 65 - 70 ladles per day
per day (INSURAL ATL 800 ) 1591 is a granulated flux, which provides a
Treatment temperature 730 760C strong cleaning action while removing
Type of fluxes used COVERAL GR 2410 COVERAL MTS 1524 these elements. This product is fluoride free
(0.05%) (0.03%) and emits low fume.
Amount of flux used per cycle 400 g 20g 240 10 g
Flux amount used per year 6,000 kg 3,600 kg The first results achieved with COVERAL
Dross weight per treatment 7.2 kg 4.4 kg MTS 1591 showed very low levels of
Dross amount produced calcium, strontium and sodium in the
per year 108 tons 66 tons melt. Further trials on a longer period of
Metal dross content 44% 36% time have to be conducted to confirm
Amount of aluminium lost these results. The main goal is the
per year 47.5 tons 23.8 tons replacement of chlorine use in foundries
as chlorine is a hazardous material for
Table 5 Trial parameters and results for melt cleaning
people and the environment. It is likely
Figure 6 compares the amount of dross and aluminium currently lost that the chlorine use will be restricted in
per year. the future.
Conclusion
20
All rights reserved. No part of this
publication may be reproduced, stored
in a retrieval system of any nature or
transmitted in any form or by any
means, including photocopying and
recording, without the written
permission of the copyright holder.
COMMENT
Editorial policy is to highlight the latest Foseco products and technical developments.
However, because of their newness, some developments may not be immediately available in your area.
Your local Foseco company or agent will be pleased to advise.
Foseco International Limited
P.O. Box 5516
Tamworth
Design & Production: Warwicks UK Limited, Coventry, England.
Staffordshire
England B78 3XQ
Registered in England No. 468147