Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
2
Contents
3 Data Collection
4 Cost Calculation
6 Improvement Opportunities
2
STEP ONE
MFCA Team Planning
A) Involvement of Management
B) Determination of Necessary Expertise
C) Establish MFCA Working Committee
geme
ana nt
M
mittee
Expert
Com
ng
ise
k i
r
Wo
MFCA TEAM PLANNING
|
Management Expertise Working Comittee M
A) Involvement of Management B) D
iii
Review
iv
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
Results
Q
iv
Imp
|
4
STEP ONE
Management Expertise Working Comittee
i
ii R&D
Material
iii
QC vi
Kaizen
MFCA TEAM PLANNING
iv v
Impact Cost
|
5
Management Expertise Working Comittee
i
Management
ii
Expertise
iii
Supplier
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
Secretary
STEP TWO
A) Determine The Applicable Product
and Boundary
B) Determine The Time Period
C) Create The Material Flow Model
duct a
Pro unda nd
Bo ry
low
Time Pe
ate del
rial F
M Mo
rio
d
MATERIAL FLOW PLANNING
|
Product Boundary Time Period Material Flow Model P
Product B
High Material
Volume Used
Market
Tendency
Product
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
|
8
Model Product Boundary Time Period Material Flow Model
STEP TWO
and Boundary - 2
Boundary
Single process
Multiple process
Whole facility
Boundary
Single
Process
Multiple Supply
Process Chain
MATERIAL FLOW PLANNING
Whole
Facility
|
9
Product Boundary Time Period Material Flow Model P
A week
A month
3 months
Half year
A year
Determine
The Time
Period
A Month A Week
3 Months
Half Year
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
A Year
|
10
Model Product Boundary Time Period Material Flow Model
STEP TWO
t Visualise the material flow by listing
down all the input and output for all
processes within the set boundary.
Input materials:
> Part of product:
Raw materials, auxiliary, materials,
intermediate products.
> Not part of products:
Cleaning solvents, chemical catalysts.
Material
Flow Model
1
Visualise
MATERIAL FLOW PLANNING
Input Output
Materials Waste / Loss
|
11
Product Boundary Time Period Material Flow Model P
Process flow
Quantity plan
Material
Flow Model
2
Documents
Process
Flow
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
Quantity
Plan
Monitoring &
Measurement
|
12
Model Product Boundary Time Period Material Flow Model
STEP TWO
Materials needed
l > Colour post-it notes
> Marker pens
> Paper (Large flip chart paper)
> Large work surface (Wall, table or floor)
Material
Flow Model
3
Colour
Post-It
Notes
Marker
Pens
Paper
Work
Surface
|MATERIAL FLOW PLANNING
13
Product Boundary Time Period Material Flow Model P
Material
Flow Model Process Process Process
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
4 A B C
14
Model Product Boundary Time Period Material Flow Model
STEP TWO
en When all items has been identified,
written on the post-it notes and pasted
on the large paper.
t
ial Material
Flow Model
5
ss Paste
On Paper
Perform
MATERIAL FLOW PLANNING
ut, On-Site
or
es On-Site
Verification
|
15
Product Boundary Time Period Material Flow Model
On-Site Verification
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
STEP THREE
D) Data Collection
tre Un
en U
i
ts ed
C
ity
To
s
Quant
Be
tion
Methectio
Coll
lec
od
ol
C s
n
Data
DATA COLLECTION
|
Quantity Physical Collection Data Q
Centre Units Methods Collection C
ance Sheet
Bal
rial Da
t
te
aC
a
M
oll
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
ect
ion Activities
igate
est
Inv
Sig
ni
fic
ant
Data
Gaps
|
18
t
ts
Centre
Quantity
Input Output
Units
Process Material Mass (a) Product / WIP (b) Waste / Loss (c) Gap
(d)
Physical
Unit
Item Previous New Inventory Item Volume Unit Item Volume Unit b+c a-d
1 2 3 4
Methods
Collection
Data
Quantity Centre
Collection
DATA COLLECTION
19
|
STEP THREE
Quantity Physical Collection Data Q
Centre Units Methods Collection C
or
ificant
Sign
tify aps Co
en ata G n
D
Id
sis
ten
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
t/S
tandardised
terial
f Ma
eo
Co
yp
T m
pa
rat
ive C
onversion
|
20
be
es,
pe
of
Centre
Quantity
Input Output
Units
Process Material Mass (a) Product / WIP (b) Waste / Loss (c) Gap
(d)
Physical
Unit
Item Previous New Inventory Item Volume Unit Item Volume Unit b+c a-d
5 6 7
Methods
Collection
Data
DATA COLLECTION
21
|
STEP THREE
Quantity Physical Collection Data Q
Centre Units Methods Collection C
s Accuracy
r v
ou
-H
an
Co
M
llec
ted D
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
ata
Data
tain
Ob
In
tia
i
lD
ata
Collected
|
22
Quantity Physical Collection Data
Centre Units Methods Collection
data
ur).
STEP THREE
High
Degree
Accuracy Data
Cost
(man-hours)
and Degree
of the
Accuracy
of Data Cost
Reasonable
Level
Low
Small Number of the established Quantity Centre Large
23
Quantity Physical Collection Data Q
Centre Units Methods Collection C
Ma
a
te
at
eD
ria
l Ba
Summarised th
lance
Sheet fo
r Ea
sy
D
at
aC
olle
ction
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
Part (code)
|
24
y
ed
data
Part (code)
Day Date RMS Material Weight Cavity Shot Product Product Sample
Centre
Quantity
DATA COLLECTION
25
|
STEP THREE
26
| 7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
Part Centre
Period Product
Quantity
(Kg)
Example of Data Summary Sheet
Collection
A) Material Cost
B) Energy Cost
C) System Cost
D) Waste Management Cost
STEP FOUR
l E
a
ne
eri
rgy
Mat
as ent
Syst
W gem
te
em
a
Man
COST CALCULATION
|
27
Material Energy System Waste Management M
Cost Cost Cost Cost C
Monetary Units
Production Data
Existing Data
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
|
28
Material Energy System Waste Management
Cost Cost Cost Cost
Step 1:
Allocation of process-wide or
facility-wide costs to different quantity
centre.
STEP FOUR
Step 2:
Allocation of quantity-centre costs to
products and material losses.
STEP 1: Process-wide
or Facility-wide Costs
29
Material Energy System Waste Management M
Cost Cost Cost Cost C
Material Distribution
Percentage
Positive Products and
Negative Products
Distribute to Processing
Historical, Standard
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
$
|
30
Material Energy System Waste Management
Cost Cost Cost Cost
STEP FOUR
Output from One Quantity
Centre Becomes Input for
Another Quantity Centre
nd
sing
$ $ $ $ $
| COST CALCULATION
31
32
| 7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
Example of MFCA Cost Calculation Cost
Material
NG 5 5 7 70 34 110
Waste Management
p
b
C
C
M
A) M
Material Energy System Waste Management
Cost Cost Cost Cost
A) Material Cost
STEP FOUR
Cost for A Substance
33
34
| 7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
Cost
Material
Product: 20 27 Product: 25 40
Plastic part 3 20 4 20% 27 Plastic part 20 80% 7 27
Carton 7 5 20% 13
Cost
c
c
C
S
S
B) E
n
b
C
C
C
M
Material Energy System Waste Management
Cost Cost Cost Cost
B) Energy Cost
Step 1:
Cost allocation to different quantity
centre from whole facility cost.
Step 2:
Cost assigned to positive products and
negative products (materials losses)
based on material distribution percentage.
STEP FOUR
Cost for Electricity, Fuel, Steam,
Heat, Compressed Air
35
Material Energy System Waste Management M
Cost Cost Cost Cost C
Step 1
Example of Energy Costs Allocation
36
M)
000)
1.50
000)
4.00
000
0 / 4)
500
/ 10)
000
/ 10)
000
000
000
000
Total material weight x energy cost New material weight x material
Step 2 allocation at step 1 (100kg x RM14.00) unit cost (25kg x RM1.50)
Cost
3
Energy
Carton 5 20% 64
System
COST CALCULATION
37
|
STEP FOUR
Material Energy System Waste Management M
Cost Cost Cost Cost C
Syst
Co
Alternative Allocation Criteria For Energy Use Cost
m
10% Losses
100% - 61.2%
20%
= 38.8% St
15% Co
ce
Total Energy Use
Product St
90% x 80% x Co
85%
= 61.2% ne
ba
a) b) c)
Setup Material Machinery
shut down Inefficiency Inefficiency
Source: ISO 14051 Standard (2011)
| 7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
38
Material Energy System Waste Management
Cost Cost Cost Cost
System Cost
61.2%
% Step 1:
Cost allocation to different quantity
centre from system cost estimation.
t Step 2:
80% x Cost assigned to positive products and
% negative products (materials losses)
based on material distribution percentage.
39
40
| 7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
Cost
Material
Step 1
Cost
Energy
kg - 5,000 (h)
Process Number Unit Number of Month Labour Labour
of Labour Machine Cost Cost per
Cost
Month Process
axbxd
Carton 5 20% 30
System
COST CALCULATION
41
|
STEP FOUR
Material Energy System Waste Management M
Cost Cost Cost Cost C
42
ts
tre
ial
Total disposal cost for each
Example of Waste Management material (if any)
Cost
Cost Calculation 1
Material
Carton 5 20%
Losses: 80 0 Losses: 0 0
Purging 15 15%
Cost
COST CALCULATION
43
|
STEP FOUR
Material Energy System Waste Management
Cost Cost Cost Cost
Hidden Profit
A
MFC
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
|
44
Material Flow Cost Matrix
45
|
STEP FIVE
MFCA Data & Cost Calculation Material Flow Cost Matrix
Total
Input
Positive
Product
(Product)
Negative
Product
(Waste/
Loss)
Total
Output
STEP FIVE
POSITIVE
PRODUCT
AND
NEGATIVE
MATERIAL FLOW COST MATRIX
PRODUCT
|
MFCA Data & Cost Calculation Material Flow Cost Matrix
Positive & Negative Product
Material (RM), Energy (RM),
System (RM), Waste (RM)
| IMPROVEMENT OPPORTUNITIES
STEP SIX
Loss Analysis At Counter Implementation L
Negative Product by Measure Plan N
Cost Factor C
Types of losses
i. Theoretical loss: off-cut, solvent
medium etc.
ii. Normal loss: set-up, trial run,
cleaning, sample etc.
iii. Avoidable / Abnormal loss:
defective unit etc.
tre
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
en
yC
ct
du
tit
ro
an
eP
Qu
v
al
ati
du
g
s
Ne
ivi
se
Ind
os
of
fL
s
pe
so
Ty
pe
Ty
|
50
ion Loss Analysis At Counter Implementation
Negative Product by Measure Plan
Cost Factor
Cost of
Manufacturing Positive
Cost Product
(Material,
Energy System,
Cost of
Waste Disposal)
m Negative
Product
1
Types of Negative
Product
Q3
75% 70%
50% Q2
26%
25% Q1
4% Q4
0%
0%
NG Purging Runner Sample
IMPROVEMENT OPPORTUNITIES
Q4 Q1 2
0% 4% Individual
Quantity Centre
STEP SIX
Q2,
26%
Q3,
70%
|
51
52
| 7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
Cost Factor
3
Negative Product by
Con
Imp
re
L
idea
C
N
To
To
ion Loss Analysis At Counter Implementation
Negative Product by Measure Plan
Cost Factor
Improvement Opportunities - 1
IMPROVEMENT OPPORTUNITIES
ibi
ns
ss
po
/Lo
es
STEP SIX
ste
t-R
Wa
en
em
ify
nt
ov
Ide
pr
Im
53
Loss Analysis At Counter Implementation
Negative Product by Measure Plan
Cost Factor
Improvement Opportunities - 2
FCA
e of M
ycl
Fir st C
to 6
/3
p2
Ste
Conduct
Loss
Analysis
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
Implement
|
MFCA Improvement Impacts
A) Visualisation of Material Losses Within
Organisation / Supply Chain
B) Improving Coordination and
Communication On Material and
Energy Use Within Organisation
C) Improve Material & Energy Efficiency
D) Reduce Environmental Impact
Coo
ses Com rd
os m
ina unica
L
and Mate
tal
on act
men
ri
ci
p
en
Im cy
ir d
Env
MFCA IMPROVEMENT IMPACTS
STEP SEVEN
|
56
| 7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
(B)
Visualisation of material (A) Material Visualised improvement
losses within organisation Material Flow Cost achievements
Flow Cost Matrix
and supply chain Model Identify new opportunities
(Visualised &
MFCA Improvement Impacts
Material Material
Loss: Loss:
62% 59%
FY2006 FY2007
Purchase Quantity Purchase Quantity
Before Improvement After Improvement
57
|
STEP SEVEN
Feedback Form
7 Steps in MFCA Implementation
Please ( ) your answer according to this scale
1 2 3 4 5
Very Weak Weak Moderate Good Excellent
ANSWER
No. STATEMENT 1 2 3 4 5
1. Ease of Understanding
4. Content
5. Design
6. Graphics
7. Overall
58