Sunteți pe pagina 1din 60

Overview of Material Flow Cost Accounting

What is Material Flow Cost Accounting (MFCA)?

Material Flow Cost Accounting (MFCA) is one of


the major tools of Environmental Management
Accounting (EMA). EMA is a set of procedures
used within corporations and other organisations
for linking environmental considerations with
economic pursuits. EMA covers not only the
monetary calculation regularly handled by
accounting, but also extends to the calculation of
materials on a physical basis.

Organisations seek management tools to link


the environment with the economy. MFCA is a
management tool, which promotes the efficient
use of materials more effectively, contributing to
reduction of emission (waste). MFCA provides a
clear picture of the problems, including invisible
ones. By solving the problems, we can reduce
waste generation, improve material productivity,
and reduce the cost at the same time.

MFCA is applicable to any organisations,


regardless of type, size, activities and location,
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION

and not only in developed countries but in


developing countries as well. Furthermore, the
application of MFCA does not always require
advanced computer-based information systems
as an information base. Especially in organisations
such as SMEs (Small and Medium-sized
Enterprises), simple spreadsheet calculations are
quite enough, or even just a calculator.
|

2
Contents

MFCA Team Planning 3


Material Flow Planning 7
Data Collection 17
Cost Calculation 27
Material Flow Cost Matrix 45
Improvement Opportunities 49
MFCA Improvement Impacts 55
1 MFCA Team Planning

2 Material Flow Planning

3 Data Collection

4 Cost Calculation

5 Material Flow Cost Matrix

6 Improvement Opportunities

7 MFCA Improvement Impacts


7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
|

2
STEP ONE
MFCA Team Planning

A) Involvement of Management
B) Determination of Necessary Expertise
C) Establish MFCA Working Committee

geme
ana nt
M
mittee

Expert
Com
ng

ise
k i

r
Wo
MFCA TEAM PLANNING
|
Management Expertise Working Comittee M

A) Involvement of Management B) D

i. Assigning roles & responsibilities. i. F


(e.g. Establish MFCA working committee) O
p
ii. Providing resources.
ii. M
iii. Monitor progress and reviewing results. t

iv. Decide on improvement based on MFCA iii. P


results.
iv. W
a
e
i
Roles v. C
ii
Resources
vi. K

iii
Review

iv
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION

Results
Q

iv
Imp
|

4
STEP ONE
Management Expertise Working Comittee

B) Determination of Necessary Expertise

i. Flow of material & energy use:


tee) Operational expertise from R&D,
purchasing and production.

ii. Material balance: Engineering,


ts. technical & relevant expertise.

FCA iii. Product reject: QC expertise.

iv. Waste management and environmental


aspects and impacts: Environmental
expertise.

v. Cost allocation: Accounting expertise.

vi. Kaizen: Related process owners.

i
ii R&D
Material

iii
QC vi
Kaizen
MFCA TEAM PLANNING

iv v
Impact Cost
|

5
Management Expertise Working Comittee

C) Establish MFCA Working Committee

i. Led by top management.

ii. Consists of various relevant expertise.

iii. May consists of relevant supplier


representative from production supply
chain.

i
Management

ii
Expertise

iii
Supplier
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION

MFCA Project Leader

Secretary

Relevant Expertise KAIZEN Teams


|
Material Flow Planning

STEP TWO
A) Determine The Applicable Product
and Boundary
B) Determine The Time Period
C) Create The Material Flow Model

duct a
Pro unda nd
Bo ry
low

Time Pe
ate del
rial F
M Mo

rio

d
MATERIAL FLOW PLANNING
|
Product Boundary Time Period Material Flow Model P

A) Determine The Applicable Product D


and Boundary - 1 a

Product B

High material volume used

High disposal cost

Market tendency product

Product High Disposal


Cost

High Material
Volume Used
Market
Tendency
Product
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
|

8
Model Product Boundary Time Period Material Flow Model

Determine The Applicable Product

STEP TWO
and Boundary - 2

Boundary

Single process

Multiple process

Whole facility

Supply chain at the discretion of the


organisation

Boundary

Single
Process

Multiple Supply
Process Chain
MATERIAL FLOW PLANNING

Whole
Facility
|

9
Product Boundary Time Period Material Flow Model P

B) Determine The Time Period C) C

Full operation period or production lot

A week

A month

3 months

Half year

A year

Determine
The Time
Period

A Month A Week

3 Months

Half Year
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION

A Year
|

10
Model Product Boundary Time Period Material Flow Model

C) Create The Material Flow Model - 1

STEP TWO
t Visualise the material flow by listing
down all the input and output for all
processes within the set boundary.

Input materials:
> Part of product:
Raw materials, auxiliary, materials,
intermediate products.
> Not part of products:
Cleaning solvents, chemical catalysts.

Output waste / loss:


Air emission, wastewater, solid waste,
rejected product, recycled and so on.

Material
Flow Model
1

Visualise
MATERIAL FLOW PLANNING

Input Output
Materials Waste / Loss
|

11
Product Boundary Time Period Material Flow Model P

Create The Material Flow Model - 2 C

Documents to consider as reference


during preparation for input material
and output waste or losses

Process flow

Quantity plan

Environmental monitoring &


measurement list

Material
Flow Model
2
Documents

Process
Flow
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION

Quantity
Plan

Monitoring &
Measurement
|

12
Model Product Boundary Time Period Material Flow Model

Create The Material Flow Model - 3

STEP TWO
Materials needed
l > Colour post-it notes
> Marker pens
> Paper (Large flip chart paper)
> Large work surface (Wall, table or floor)

Material
Flow Model
3
Colour
Post-It
Notes
Marker
Pens

Paper

Work
Surface
|MATERIAL FLOW PLANNING

13
Product Boundary Time Period Material Flow Model P

Create The Material Flow Model - 4 C

Record each process with a marker pen


on a separate post-it note (Yellow).

Record each input material with a


marker pen on a separate post-it note
(Blue) for each process.

Record each output, waste or losses


with a marker pen on a separate post-it
note (Green or Pink) for each process.

Paste on paper according to process


flow.

Input Input Input


Material Material Material

Material
Flow Model Process Process Process
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION

4 A B C

Output, Output, Output,


Waste or Waste or Waste or
Losses Losses Losses
|

14
Model Product Boundary Time Period Material Flow Model

Create The Material Flow Model - 5

STEP TWO
en When all items has been identified,
written on the post-it notes and pasted
on the large paper.

e Perform on-site verification to ensure all


the processes, input materials and
output waste or losses have been
accurately captured.
t-it
s. The post-it notes can be changed or
added accordingly as per findings from
on-site verification, if needed to
reflect the actual situation.

t
ial Material
Flow Model
5

ss Paste
On Paper

Perform
MATERIAL FLOW PLANNING

ut, On-Site
or
es On-Site
Verification
|

15
Product Boundary Time Period Material Flow Model

Initial Identification of Input,


Process, Output

On-Site Verification
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION

Discussion and Verification


|
Data Collection

A) Establish Quantity Centre


B) Decide Physical Units To Be Used
C) Data Collection Methods

STEP THREE
D) Data Collection

tre Un
en U
i
ts ed
C
ity

To
s
Quant

Be
tion

Methectio
Coll
lec

od
ol

C s
n
Data
DATA COLLECTION
|
Quantity Physical Collection Data Q
Centre Units Methods Collection C

A) Establish Quantity Centre Exa

Transfer the material flow model


information into Material Balance
sheet.

Each process will be the quantity


centre which serves as the basis for
data collection activities.

Purpose of quantity centre is to


compare quantities of material inputs
to outputs to identify any significant
data gaps.

Any significant imbalance found,


investigate further.

ance Sheet
Bal
rial Da
t
te
aC
a
M

oll
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION

ect
ion Activities
igate
est
Inv

Sig

ni
fic
ant
Data
Gaps
|

18
t
ts
Centre
Quantity

Input Output


Units

Process Material Mass (a) Product / WIP (b) Waste / Loss (c) Gap
(d)
Physical

Unit
Item Previous New Inventory Item Volume Unit Item Volume Unit b+c a-d

1 2 3 4
Methods
Collection


Data

Example of Material Balance Sheet - 1

Quantity Centre
Collection

DATA COLLECTION

19
|

STEP THREE
Quantity Physical Collection Data Q
Centre Units Methods Collection C

B) Decide Physical Units To Be Used Exa

To facilitate in measuring quantities of


material inputs to outputs so as to
identify any significant data gaps.

> Measurement units used should be


consistent / standardised unit

or

> Comparative conversion factors

Physical unit is selected based on type


of material.

> e.g. mass, length, number of pieces,


volume

ificant
Sign
tify aps Co
en ata G n
D
Id

sis
ten
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION

t/S
tandardised
terial
f Ma
eo

Co
yp

T m
pa
rat
ive C
onversion
|

20
be

es,
pe
of
Centre
Quantity

Input Output


Units

Process Material Mass (a) Product / WIP (b) Waste / Loss (c) Gap
(d)
Physical

Unit
Item Previous New Inventory Item Volume Unit Item Volume Unit b+c a-d

5 6 7
Methods
Collection


Data

Example of Material Balance Sheet - 2


Collection

DATA COLLECTION

21
|

STEP THREE
Quantity Physical Collection Data Q
Centre Units Methods Collection C

C) Data Collection Methods Ma


Acc
Consider the man-hour vs accuracy
balance for data accuracy.

> Higher accuracy of the collected data


will result in higher cost (man-hour).

> Initial data collected based on


existing information.
(man-h
> If insufficient data, obtain data by and D

additional measurement or Acc


o
estimation based on material
balance figure.

s Accuracy
r v
ou
-H
an

Co
M

llec
ted D
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION

ata
Data
tain
Ob

In

tia
i

lD
ata
Collected
|

22
Quantity Physical Collection Data
Centre Units Methods Collection

Man-Hour vs Accuracy Balance For Data


Accuracy
y

data
ur).

STEP THREE
High
Degree
Accuracy Data

Cost
(man-hours)
and Degree
of the
Accuracy
of Data Cost

Reasonable
Level
Low
Small Number of the established Quantity Centre Large

Source: Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry, Japan (METI) (2005)


DATA COLLECTION
|

23
Quantity Physical Collection Data Q
Centre Units Methods Collection C

D) Data Collection Exa

Create a data compilation sheet based


on Material Balance Sheet for easy data
collection in production floor.

> Summarised the data compiled by


specified time period, category or
product and waste / losses.

Ma
a
te
at
eD

ria
l Ba
Summarised th

lance
Sheet fo
r Ea
sy
D

at
aC
olle
ction
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION

Part (code)
|

24
y
ed
data
Part (code)

Day Date RMS Material Weight Cavity Shot Product Product Sample
Centre
Quantity

Mixing Mixing Material: Counter WIP Ng QA


Lot No. (Kg) (Pieces) (Pieces) (Pieces)
Units
Physical
Methods

Lot No. Start End Lot No. Weight Weight


Collection

Start Running. Material. End Material Runner


Time Time Purging (Kg)
(Kg)
Example of Data Compilation Sheet
Data
Collection

[ Injection Molding Process ]

DATA COLLECTION

25
|

STEP THREE
26
| 7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
Part Centre
Period Product
Quantity

Month Qth Start End Pcs Kg


(Kg) Running Running
Date Date
Units
Physical
Methods
Collection

Runner % Ng Kg % QA Kg % Purging % Total Total


(Kg) (Pcs) (Pcs) (Kg) Loss
Data

(Kg)
Example of Data Summary Sheet
Collection

[ Injection Molding Process ]


Cost Calculation

A) Material Cost
B) Energy Cost
C) System Cost
D) Waste Management Cost

STEP FOUR

l E
a

ne
eri

rgy
Mat
as ent

Syst
W gem
te

em

a
Man
COST CALCULATION
|

27
Material Energy System Waste Management M
Cost Cost Cost Cost C

Cost Calculation Cos

Important: Translate physical units into En


monetary units to support co
decision-making. pr

Calculate directly from production data Tw


for each quantity centre.

If not possible, estimate from existing


data. f

Monetary Units

Production Data

Existing Data
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
|

28
Material Energy System Waste Management
Cost Cost Cost Cost

Cost Allocation Methods

o Energy costs, system costs and disposal


costs are commonly available for an entire
process or facility.

a Two steps procedure:

Step 1:
Allocation of process-wide or
facility-wide costs to different quantity
centre.

STEP FOUR
Step 2:
Allocation of quantity-centre costs to
products and material losses.

Energy Costs, System Costs


and Disposal Costs

STEP 1: Process-wide
or Facility-wide Costs

STEP 2: Products and


Material Losses
| COST CALCULATION

29
Material Energy System Waste Management M
Cost Cost Cost Cost C

Cost Allocation Criteria Cos

Cost allocation criteria is based on material An


distribution percentage. be
ce
Cost assigned to positive products and
negative products (materials losses). Th
ou
If management decision is not consistent sy
distribute cost to processing. w
qu
Most appropriate allocation is based on
organisation decision: Historical cost,
standard cost, existing cost accounting
etc.

Material Distribution
Percentage
Positive Products and
Negative Products

Distribute to Processing

Historical, Standard
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION

and Existing Cost

$
|

30
Material Energy System Waste Management
Cost Cost Cost Cost

Cost Carryover Between Quantity Centres

erial An output from one quantity centre


becomes the input for another quantity
centre.

The cost associated with the product


output (material costs, energy costs,
nt system costs) used to make the product
will be carried over as the input for next
quantity centre.
n

STEP FOUR
Output from One Quantity
Centre Becomes Input for
Another Quantity Centre

Material Costs, Energy Costs,


System Costs
n

nd

sing

$ $ $ $ $
| COST CALCULATION

31
32
| 7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
Example of MFCA Cost Calculation Cost
Material

Quantity Centre - 1 (Molding)


Weight, kg % Materials (RM) Energy (RM) System (RM) Disposal (RM) Total
Cost

New inputs in QC 100 135 1,400 672 2,207


Energy

Inputs from previous QC 0 0 0 0 0

Product: 20 27 280 134 441


Cost

Plastic part 20 20% 27 280 134 441


System
Cost

Losses: 80 108 1,120 538 0 1,766

Purging (For recycling) 15 15 20 210 101 331

Runner 60 60 81 840 403 1,324

NG 5 5 7 70 34 110
Waste Management

Total 100 100% 135 1,400 672 0 2,207

[ Injection Molding Process ]




l
C

p
b
C
C
M

A) M
Material Energy System Waste Management
Cost Cost Cost Cost

A) Material Cost

Cost for a substance that enters and / or


leaves a quantity centre.

Cost assigned to positive products and


negative products (materials losses)
based on each material distribution
percentage.
[ Injection Molding Process ]

STEP FOUR
Cost for A Substance

Positive & Negative Products


| COST CALCULATION

33
34
| 7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
Cost
Material

New material weight x material New material weight x material


unit cost (RM1.35 x 100kg) unit cost (RM2.50 x 5kg)
Example of Material Cost Calculation 2 7
Quantity Centre - 1 (Molding) Quantity Centre - 2 (Packing)
Cost
Energy

Weight, kg % Materials(RM) Weight, kg % Materials (RM)


New inputs in QC 100 135 New inputs in QC 5 6 13
1
Inputs from previous QC 20 27
Cost

Inputs from previous QC 0 0


System

Product: 20 27 Product: 25 40
Plastic part 3 20 4 20% 27 Plastic part 20 80% 7 27
Carton 7 5 20% 13
Cost

Losses: 80 108 Losses: 0 0


Purging (For recycling) 15 15% 20
Runner 60 60% 81
NG 5 5% 7
5
Waste Management

Total 100 100% 135 Total material cost x material 25 100% 40


proportion, % (RM135 x 20%)
[ Injection Molding Process ]


c
c
C

S
S
B) E

n
b
C
C
C
M
Material Energy System Waste Management
Cost Cost Cost Cost

B) Energy Cost

Cost for electricity, fuel, steam, heat,


compressed air.

Step 1:
Cost allocation to different quantity
centre from whole facility cost.

Step 2:
Cost assigned to positive products and
negative products (materials losses)
based on material distribution percentage.

STEP FOUR
Cost for Electricity, Fuel, Steam,
Heat, Compressed Air

STEP 1: Cost Allocation


[ Injection Molding Process ]

STEP 2: Cost Assigned


| COST CALCULATION

35
Material Energy System Waste Management M
Cost Cost Cost Cost C

Step 1
Example of Energy Costs Allocation

Historical Data Cost (RM)

Annual energy cost 1,000,000


a) Molding machine 70% 700,000
b) Others processes 30% 300,000
(receiving, crushing, mixing, packing)

a) Molding machine x 10 units 10 70,000


(700,000 / 10)

bi) Other processes 10 30,000


(to support 10 molding machines) (300,000 / 10)

bii) Consist of 4 quantity centres 4 7,500


(receiving, crushing, mixing, packing) (30,000 / 4)

Annual Total wieght for target product, kg 5,000

a) Molding machine energy cost per kg = 14.00


(70,000 / 5,000)
b) Other Quantity Centre energy cost per kg = 1.50
(7,500 / 5,000)
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
|

36
M)

000)
1.50
000)
4.00
000
0 / 4)
500
/ 10)
000
/ 10)
000
000
000
000
Total material weight x energy cost New material weight x material
Step 2 allocation at step 1 (100kg x RM14.00) unit cost (25kg x RM1.50)
Cost

Example of Energy Cost Calculation 1 4


Material

Quantity Centre - 1 (Molding) Quantity Centre - 2 (Packing)


Weight, kg % Energy (RM) Weight, kg % Energy (RM)
New inputs in QC 100 1,400 New inputs in QC 5 38
Cost

3
Energy

Inputs from previous QC 0 0 Inputs from previous QC 20 280


Product: 20 280 Product: 25 318
Plastic part 20 20% 280 Plastic part 20 80% 254
Cost

Carton 5 20% 64
System

Losses: 80 1,120 Losses: 0 0


Purging 15 15% 210
Cost

Runner (For recycling) 60 60% 840


NG 5 5% 70
2
Total 100 100% 1,400 Total energy cost x material 25 100% 318
proportion, % (1,400 x 20%)
[ Injection Molding Process ]
Waste Management

COST CALCULATION

37
|

STEP FOUR
Material Energy System Waste Management M
Cost Cost Cost Cost C

Syst

Co
Alternative Allocation Criteria For Energy Use Cost
m
10% Losses
100% - 61.2%
20%
= 38.8% St
15% Co
ce
Total Energy Use

Product St
90% x 80% x Co
85%
= 61.2% ne
ba

a) b) c)
Setup Material Machinery
shut down Inefficiency Inefficiency
Source: ISO 14051 Standard (2011)
| 7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION

38
Material Energy System Waste Management
Cost Cost Cost Cost

System Cost

Cost of labour, cost of depreciation and


maintenance, and cost of transportation.

61.2%
% Step 1:
Cost allocation to different quantity
centre from system cost estimation.

t Step 2:
80% x Cost assigned to positive products and
% negative products (materials losses)
based on material distribution percentage.

Cost of Labour, Depreciation and


Maintainance, and Transportation
STEP FOUR

STEP 1: Cost Allocation

STEP 2: Cost Assigned


| COST CALCULATION

39
40
| 7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
Cost
Material

Step 1
Cost
Energy

kg - 5,000 (h)
Process Number Unit Number of Month Labour Labour
of Labour Machine Cost Cost per
Cost

Worker Cost / for kg


System

Month Process

Molding 2 RM1,400 1 12 RM33,600 RM6.72


(a) (b) (d) (e) (f) = (f) / (h)
Cost

axbxd

[ Injection Molding Process ]


Example of System Costs Allocation

Annual Total Weight for Target Product,


Waste Management

Total material weight x system cost


C
M
Total material weight x system cost Total material weight x system cost
Step 2 allocation at step 1 (100kg x RM6.72) allocation at step 1 (25kg x RM0.58)
Cost

Example of System Cost Calculation 1 4


Material

Quantity Centre - 1 (Molding) Quantity Centre - 2 (Packing)


Weight, kg % System (RM) Weight, kg % System (RM)
Cost

New inputs in QC 100 672 New inputs in QC 5 15


3
Energy

Inputs from previous QC 0 0 Inputs from previous QC 20 134


Product: 20 134 Product: 25 149
Plastic part 20 20% 134 Plastic part 20 80% 119
Cost

Carton 5 20% 30
System

Losses: 80 538 Losses: 0 0


Purging 15 15% 101
Cost

Runner (For recycling) 60 60% 403


NG 5 5% 34
2
Total 100 100% 672 Total system cost x material 25 100% 149
proportion, % (672 x 20%)
[ Injection Molding Process ]
Waste Management

COST CALCULATION

41
|

STEP FOUR
Material Energy System Waste Management M
Cost Cost Cost Cost C

Waste Management Cost

Cost of handling material losses in


quantity centre.

Cost only assigned to negative products


(materials losses).

Cost of Handling Material


Losses in Quantity Centre

Cost Only Assigned to


Negative Products
(Materials Losses)
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
|

42
ts

tre
ial
Total disposal cost for each
Example of Waste Management material (if any)
Cost

Cost Calculation 1
Material

Quantity Centre - 1 (Molding) Quantity Centre - 2 (Packing)


Weight, kg % Disposal (RM) Weight, kg % Disposal (RM)
Cost

New inputs in QC 100 New inputs in QC 5


Energy

Inputs from previous QC 0 Inputs from previous QC 20


Product: 20 Product: 25
Cost

Plastic part 20 20% Plastic part 20 80%


System

Carton 5 20%
Losses: 80 0 Losses: 0 0
Purging 15 15%
Cost

Runner (For recycling) 60 60%


NG 5 5%
2
Total 100 100% 0 Direct distribute disposal for 25 100% 0
each material if any
[ Injection Molding Process ]
Waste Management

COST CALCULATION

43
|

STEP FOUR
Material Energy System Waste Management
Cost Cost Cost Cost

Significance of Material Flow Cost


Accounting

MFCA focuses on emission (waste)


Profits is hidden in emission (waste)
MFCA finds out the hidden profit

Hidden Profit

A
MFC
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
|

44
Material Flow Cost Matrix

MATERIAL FLOW COST MATRIX

45
|

STEP FIVE
MFCA Data & Cost Calculation Material Flow Cost Matrix

MFCA data & cost calculation should be


summarised for easy interpretation and
further analysis.
Example of Material Flow Cost Matrix Sheet

Mass Costs (RM)

Kg Material Energy System Waste Total


Management

Total
Input

Positive
Product
(Product)

Negative
Product
(Waste/
Loss)

Total
Output

(Injection Molding Process)


SUMMARISED
DATA & COST
CALCULATION
|7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
MFCA Data & Cost Calculation Material Flow Cost Matrix
Positive & Negative Product
Material (RM), Energy (RM),
System (RM), Waste (RM)

The material flow cost matrix provide the


cost proportion for positive product and
negative product at one glance.

It is used as a communication tools for

Management to support decision making.

Employees on the changes to be made to


reduce the negative product percentage.

STEP FIVE

POSITIVE
PRODUCT
AND
NEGATIVE
MATERIAL FLOW COST MATRIX

PRODUCT
|
MFCA Data & Cost Calculation Material Flow Cost Matrix
Positive & Negative Product
Material (RM), Energy (RM),
System (RM), Waste (RM)

Example of Material Flow Cost Matrix

Mass Costs (RM)

Kg Material Energy System Waste Total


Management

Total 105 148 638 687 0 1473


Input

Positive 25 40 158 149 347


Product
(Product) 24% 27% 25% 22% 24%

Negative 80 108 480 538 0 1,126


Product
(Waste/
Loss) 76% 73% 75% 78% 0% 76%

Total 105 148 638 687 0 1,473


Output

(Injection Molding Process)


7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION
|
Improvement Opportunities

| IMPROVEMENT OPPORTUNITIES

STEP SIX
Loss Analysis At Counter Implementation L
Negative Product by Measure Plan N
Cost Factor C

Conduct loss analysis to identify negative Exam


product cost by breakdown

Types of negative product

At each individual quantity centre


- Some quantity centre with higher
material losses maybe due to upstream
process, supply-chain

Types of losses
i. Theoretical loss: off-cut, solvent
medium etc.
ii. Normal loss: set-up, trial run,
cleaning, sample etc.
iii. Avoidable / Abnormal loss:
defective unit etc.
tre
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION

en
yC
ct
du

tit
ro

an
eP

Qu
v

al
ati

du
g

s
Ne

ivi

se
Ind

os
of

fL
s
pe

so
Ty

pe
Ty
|

50
ion Loss Analysis At Counter Implementation
Negative Product by Measure Plan
Cost Factor

e Example of Loss Analysis - 1

Cost of
Manufacturing Positive
Cost Product
(Material,
Energy System,
Cost of
Waste Disposal)
m Negative
Product

1
Types of Negative
Product
Q3
75% 70%

50% Q2
26%
25% Q1
4% Q4
0%
0%
NG Purging Runner Sample
IMPROVEMENT OPPORTUNITIES

Q4 Q1 2
0% 4% Individual
Quantity Centre
STEP SIX

Q2,
26%
Q3,
70%
|

51
52
| 7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION

Cost Factor

Example of Loss Analysis - 2


Loss Analysis At

3
Negative Product by

No Quantity Waste / Waste / Type of Loss


Centre Loss Loss
Waste
Source
Counter

Volume Cost Theoretical Normal Avoidable


Loss Loss Loss
Measure Plan
Implementation

Con
Imp

re
L

idea
C
N

To
To
ion Loss Analysis At Counter Implementation
Negative Product by Measure Plan
Cost Factor

Improvement Opportunities - 1

Conduct brainstorming session to gather


ideas.

To identify waste / loss sources.

To plan improvement activities, assign


responsibility and action time frame.
lity

IMPROVEMENT OPPORTUNITIES
ibi
ns
ss

po
/Lo

es

STEP SIX
ste

t-R
Wa

en
em
ify
nt

ov
Ide

pr
Im

53
Loss Analysis At Counter Implementation
Negative Product by Measure Plan
Cost Factor

Improvement Opportunities - 2

Implement first cycle of MFCA


1. Resource Planning
2. Material Flow Planning
3. Data Collection
4. Cost Calculation
5. Material Flow Cost Matrix
6. Improvement Opportunities

Repeat step 2 or 3 to 6 after completing each


planned improvement actions for KAIZEN.

FCA
e of M
ycl
Fir st C
to 6
/3
p2
Ste

Conduct
Loss
Analysis
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION

MFCA Data KAIZEN Plan


Collection Improvement
& Cost Matrix Action

Implement
|
MFCA Improvement Impacts
A) Visualisation of Material Losses Within
Organisation / Supply Chain
B) Improving Coordination and
Communication On Material and
Energy Use Within Organisation
C) Improve Material & Energy Efficiency
D) Reduce Environmental Impact

Coo
ses Com rd
os m
ina unica
L

tion tion Energy Effi al an


ial
Mater

and Mate
tal
on act
men

ri
ci
p

en
Im cy
ir d
Env
MFCA IMPROVEMENT IMPACTS

STEP SEVEN
|
56
| 7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION

MFCA Improvement Impacts

(B)
Visualisation of material (A) Material Visualised improvement
losses within organisation Material Flow Cost achievements
Flow Cost Matrix
and supply chain Model Identify new opportunities
(Visualised &
MFCA Improvement Impacts

Identity) for improvement

Improve material &


(C)
energy efficiency Material
Reduce environmental (D) Flow Cost Communication of
KAIZEN Matrix material & energy use
impact
(Communication)
Enhance profit

MFCA Improvement Impacts


MFCA Improvement Impacts
(Case Sample)

Material Material
Loss: Loss:
62% 59%

Weight of material loss in FY2007


OMRON KURAYOSHI decreased
MFCA Improvement Impacts

Product: Product: by 11% compared to FY2006


38% 41%

FY2006 FY2007
Purchase Quantity Purchase Quantity
Before Improvement After Improvement

MFCA IMPROVEMENT IMPACTS

57
|

STEP SEVEN
Feedback Form
7 Steps in MFCA Implementation
Please ( ) your answer according to this scale

1 2 3 4 5
Very Weak Weak Moderate Good Excellent

ANSWER
No. STATEMENT 1 2 3 4 5
1. Ease of Understanding

2. Presentation of the publication


3. Language

4. Content

5. Design
6. Graphics

7. Overall

If you find any criteria that does not meet your


need, please advise us why?
7 STEPS IN MFCA IMPLEMENTATION

Kindly forward your completed form


through fax or e-mail to:

MPC Publication House-Your Knowledge Partner


MALAYSIA PRODUCTIVITY CORPORATION (MPC)
Lorong Produktiviti, Off Jalan Sultan
46200 Petaling Jaya, selangor Darul Ehsan
Tel: +603-7960 0173, 603-7955 7266
Fax: +603-7960 0206, 603-7955 1824
E-mail: lokleelee@mpc.gov.my
|

58

S-ar putea să vă placă și