Sunteți pe pagina 1din 40

;

~epuhlic of tbe ~bilippines


Jjrestbenttal Qflectoral ~rtbunal
;1J!lanila

NOTICE

Sirs/Mesdames:

Please take notice that the Tribunal issued a Resolution


dated AUGUST 29, 2017, which reads as follows:

"PET Case No. 005 - FERDINAND "BONGBONG" R. MARCOS, JR.,


protestant, versus MARIA LEONOR "LENI DAANG MATUWID" G.
ROBREDO, protestee.
x--------------------------------------------------x
RESOLUTION

During the Preliminary Conference held on July 11, 2017 at 2:30


p.m., the Tribunal, for clarity, and with protestant's agreement, categorized
protestant's causes of action into the following:

First Cause ofAction - Annulment ofProclamation

The proclamation of protestee Robredo as the duly elected Vice


President is null and void because the Certificates of Canvass
(COCs) generated by the Consolidation and Canvass System
(CCS) are not authentic, and may not be used as basis to
determine the number of votes that the candidates for Vice
President received.

Second Cause ofAction - Revision and Recount

Revision and recount of the paper ballots and/or the ballot


images as well as an examination, verification, and analysis of
the voter's receipts, election returns, audit logs, transmission
logs, the lists of voters, particularly the Election Day
Computerized Voter's List (EDCVL), and voters registration
records (VRRs), the books of voters and other pertinent election
documents and/or paraphernalia used in the elections, as well as
the automated election equipment and records such as the Vote
Counting Machines (VCMs), CCS units, Secure Digital (SD)
cards (main and backup), and the other data storage devices

l..,...-'~
1\r-~w t>
Notice of Resolution -3- P.E.T. Case No. 005
August 29, 2017

the relief prayed for is meaningless and pointless. Even as protestant avers in
the First Cause of Action that the automated election system used in the
2016 National and Local Elections was unreliable rendering the COCs null
and void, he, however, does not seek the manual recount of all the votes in
all the precincts - which is necessary in order to determine who won the
post of Vice President.

Stated otherwise, even if protestant succeeds in proving his First


Cause of Action, this will not mean that he has already won the position of
Vice President as this can only be .determined by a manual recount of all
votes in all precincts. And if this is a relief protestant has clearly stated he is
not praying for, then, allowing the First Cause of Action to continue would
be an exercise in futility and would have no practical effect. To be sure, the
Tribunal cannot allow this exercise to even begin especially if it were to
consider the amount of resources and time it will demand from the Tribunal.

Thus, the First Cause of Action may be dispensed with for judicial
economy and for the prompt disposition of this case. Judicial economy
refers to "efficiency in the operation of the courts and the judicial system;
especially the efficient management of litigation so as to minimize
duplication of effort and to avoid wasting the judiciary's time and
resources." 3 This would also do away with the question of whether or not
the Commission on Elections (COMELEC) should be impleaded as a party,
being the government body mandated with the conduct of clean, fair, and
honest elections. As well, this dispenses with the need to determine if the
other nationally and locally elected officials who won in the 2016 elections
would need to be impleaded as indispensable parties.

As admitted by Atty. Garcia during the preliminary conference, the


First Cause of Action is merely "complementary" to the Second and Third
Causes of Action. 4 How this is so has not been adequately explained by
Atty. Garcia. More importantly, however, it should be noted that the Second
Cause of Action requires the revision or manual recount of the actual ballots
to determine the votes cast; whereas the Third Cause of Action primarily
requires the presentation of evidence aliunde. In other words, both these
causes of action remain intact independent of the First Cause of Action.
Thus, the Tribunal is left with no option but to already dismiss the First
Cause of Action as indeed, this will not prevent the Protest from continuing
because protestant can still prove his case through the Second and Third
Causes of Action.

The causes of action for the Protest are now limited to the Second
and Third Causes of Action as mentioned above.

Ren Transport Corp. v. National Labor Relations Commission (2nd Division), G.R. Nos. 188020 &
188252, June 27, 2016, 794 SCRA 498, 509, citing Black's Law Dictionary, Eighth edition, p. 863. /
4
TSN,p.10. V
..,-"'
~\~
Notice of Resolution -5- P.E.T. Case No. 005
August 29, 2017

Committee) canvassed a total of one hundred sixty-seven (167)


COCs wherein:

(a) One hundred twenty-three (123) were


electronically transmitted;

(b) Forty-two (42) were physically delivered to


the Senate of the Philippines;

(c) The COC for Taiwan was included in the


special electoral diplomatic pouch from the People's
Republic of China; and

(d) The COC for Russia was delivered to the


House of Representatives after the Joint Committee has
already convened. 9

3. On the first day of canvassing, canvass of three (3)


COCs from Laguna, Ilocos Sur and Davao del Norte was
deferred due to multiple transmissions of results, including Pre-
Logic and Accuracy Test (Pre-LAT) results. 10

4. The COCs from the Province of Davao del Sur,


Kingdom of Bahrain and Malaysia were canvassed, despite the
multiple electronic transmissions of COCs from Davao del Sur
and the lack of physically delivered COCs from Bahrain and
Malaysia. 11

5. The canvass of the four (4) COCs from the


Province of Antique, State of Kuwait, Iloilo City, and Canada
was deferred for the following reasons:

a) Antique - The Provincial Board of


Canvassers (PBOC) was ordered to appear and explain
the discrepancy between the electronically transmitted
COCs vis-a-vis the manually counted/physically
delivered COCs;

b) State of Kuwait - COMELEC was required


to submit a written explanation for the absence of the
special diplomatic electoral pouch containing the COC;

r~
9
Id. at 23414-23415, 23564.
10
Id. at 23415, 23564.
II Id.

1'\""~ .
Notice of Resolution -7- P.E.T. Case No. 005
August 29, 2017

Protestee adopted the following admissions as expressed


in her Brief and reflected in PC Guide 3:

1. The Joint Committee convened on May 25, 2016. 19

2. The Joint Committee held three (3) meetings


where the COMELEC was required to be present to assist the
former in its mandate to determine the authenticity and due
execution of the COCs. 20

3. During the canvassing, candidates were


represented by their counsels. 21

4. The counsels of the candidates were afforded the


opportunity to examine the COCs. 22

5. The counsels of the candidates were afforded the


opportunity to register their objections/manifestations.23

6. On the first day, forty-eight (48) COCs were


considered for canvass, but only forty-five (45) COCs were
actually canvassed. 24

7. On the second day, a total of seventy-three (73)


COCs were considered for canvass but only sixty-nine (69)
were canvassed, which included the COCs for the Provinces of
Laguna, Ilocos Sur and Davao del Norte after the concerned
PBOC Chairpersons appeared and explained the discrepancies
between the electronically transmitted COCs vis-a-vis those
physically delivered. 25

8. For the Kingdom of Bahrain and Canada, Director


Maria Juana Valeza, Office for the Overseas Absentee Voting,
COMELEC submitted the written explanation for the absence
of the physically delivered COCs. 26

9. The special electronic diplomatic pouch from the


People's Republic of China also contained the manually
counted COC for Taiwan but both COCs were nonetheless
19
Id. at 23414.
20 Id.
21 Id.
22
23
24
Id.
Id.
Id. at 23415.
Id.
.,.,V"
~\v'(""
2s
26 Id.
Notice of Resolution -9- P.E.T. Case No. 005
August 29, 2017

PROVINCE TOTAL CLUSTERED


PRECINCTS
Lanao del Sur 1,251
Maguindanao 1,083
Basilan 422
Cebu Province 2,968
Leyte 2,305
Negros Occidental 2,164
Negros Oriental 1,284
Masbate 867
Zamboanga del Sur 1,053
Zamboanga del Norte 1,099
Bukidnon 1,244
Iloilo Province 2,318
Bohol 1,546
Quezon 2,095
Batangas 2,499
Western Samar 1,165
Misamis Oriental 934
Camarines Sur 1,816
Second District, Northern 384
Samar
Palawan 1,007
Al bay 1,312
Zamboanga Sibugay 641
Misamis Occidental 707
Pangasinan 2,842
Isabela 1,678
Iloilo City 430
Bacolod City 392
Cebu City 837
Lapu-Lapu City 261
Zamboanga City 617 33

16. Based on the Provincial Certificates of Canvass,


the parties received the following votes:

PROVINCE ROB REDO MARCOS


Lanao del Sur 180,539 56,243
Maguindanao 220,125 80,591
Basilan 77,321 32,326
Cebu Province 590,777 196,943
Leyte 241,960 406,815
Negros Occidental 614,440 119,149

33 Id. at 23418-23420.
_/V'
~'fr
Notice of Resolution - 11 - P.E.T. Case No. 005
August 29, 2017

Municipality of Bontoc 29
Municipality ofNantonin 16
Municipality of Paracelis 43
Municipality of Sabangan 19
Municipality of Sadanga 10
Municipality of Sagada 23
Municipality of Tadian 25
TOTAL 237
ABRA
Municipality of Bangued 47
Municipality of Boliney 9
Municipality of Bucay 24
Municipality of Bucloc 4
Municipality of Daguioman 4
Municipality of Danglas 7
Municipality of Dolores 17
Municipality of La Paz 17
Municipality of Lacub 9
Municipality of Lagayan 6
Municipality of Lagangilang 21
Municipality ofLangiden 6
Municipality of Licuan-Baay 11
(Licuan)
Municipality of Luba 12
Municipality of Malibcong 12
Municipality of Manabo 14
Municipality of Penarrubia 9
Municipality of Pidigan 16
Municipality of Pilar 20
Municipality of Sallapadan 10
Municipality of San Isidro 9
Municipality of San Juan 19
Municipality of San Quintin 7
Municipality ofTayum 16
Municipality of Tineg 13
Municipality of tubo 12
Municipality of Villaciosa 9
TOTAL 360
KALIN GA
Municipality of Balbalan 28
Municipality ofLubuagan 17
Municipality of Pasil 16
Municipality of Pinukpuk 36
Municipality of Rizal (Liwan) 22
City of Tabuk 106
Municipality of Tanudan 22
'.<'-.!
~~r'
Notice of Resolution - 13 - P.E.T. Case No. 005
August 29, 2017

Municipality ofMadalag 27
Municipality of Makato 30
Municipality of Malay 53
Municipality of Malinao 29
Municipality of Nahas 33
Municipality of New 41
Washington
Municipality of Numancia 34
Municipality ofTangalan 25
TOTAL 606
ANTIQUE
Municipality of Anini-y 24
Municipality of Barbaza 43
Municipality of Belison 16
Municipality of Bugasong 37
Municipality of Caluya 34
Municipality of Culasi 55
Municipality of Hamtic 58
Municipality of Laua-an 46
Municipality of Libertad 21
Municipality of Pandan 45
Municipality of Patnongon 47
Municipality of San Jose 54
Municipality of San Remigio 48
Municipality of Sebaste 20
Municipality of Sibalom 84
Municipality of Tibiao 31
Municipality of Tobias 52
F omier (Dao)
Municipality of Valderrama 27
TOTAL 742
SARANGGANI
Municipality of Alabel 71
Municipality of Glan 102
Municipality of Kiamba 56
Municipality of Maasim 53
Municipality of Maitum 55
Municipality of Malapatan 55
Municipality of Malungon 103
TOTAL 495
SULU
Municipality ofHadji 8
Panglima Tahil (Marunggas)
Municipality of Indanan 55

~~v'
Municipality of Jolo 64
Municipality of Kalingan 22

'f\~
Notice of Resolution - 15 - P.E.T. Case No. 005
August 29, 2017

Municipality ofTantangan 37
Municipality of T'boli 78
Municipality of Tupi 64
TOTAL 1127
NORTH COTABATO
Municipality of Alamada 53
Municipality of Aleosan 33
Municipality of Antipas 25
Municipality of Arakan 47
Municipality of Banisilan 39
Municipality of Carmen 58
Municipality of Kabakan 71
City of Kidapawan 119
Municipality of Libungan 46
Municipality of Magpet 53
Municipality of Makilala 76
Municipality of Matalam 77
Municipality of Midsayap 123
Municipality ofM'lang 84
Municipality of Pigkawayan 57
Municipality of Pikit 87
Municipality of President 50
Roxas
Municipality of Tulunan 54
TOTAL 115236

18. Based on the Provincial COCs, the parties received


the following votes: 37

PROVINCE MARCOS ROBREDO


Apayao 40846 2762
Abra 11273438 5457
Mountain 34286 17653
Province
Kalinga 64023 11636
Bataan 18476039 84241
Capiz 43684 25311040
Aklan 51395 148280
Antique 44640 41 11896042

36
Id. at 23421-23432.
37
Id. at 23432-23433.
38
The figure should be 112,694, per Protestant's Comment to the PC Guides, p. 2; rollo (Vol. XXXII), p.
24325.
39
The figure should be 184,670, id; id.
40
The figure should be 253,290, id; id.

,~r'~
41
The figure should be 44,663, id; id.
42
The figure should be 119,055, id.; id.

~~"'
Notice of Resolution - 17 - P.E.T. Case No. 005
August 29, 2017

4. The Province of Lanao del Sur is composed of


thirty-nine (39) municipalities and one (1) city; 54
5. Based on the Project of Precincts for the May 9,
2016 National and Local Elections, the Province of Lanao del
Sur had a total of four hundred eighty-four thousand four
hundred thirty-five (484,435) registered voters; 55
6. A total of four hundred twenty-one thousand fifty-
seven (421,057) registered voters actually voted based on the
Provincial Certificate of Canvass; 56
7. The Province of Maguindanao is composed of
thirty-six (36) municipalities; 57

8. Based on the Project of Precincts for the May 9,


2016 National and Local Elections, the Province of
Maguindanao had a total of six hundred thirty-four thousand
three hundred twenty-three (634,323) registered voters and not
five hundred thirty thousand seven hundred ninety-three
(530,793) registered voters as reflected in protestee's
Preliminary Conference Brief dated June 16, 2017 and PC
Guide No. 5; 58
9. A total of four hundred ninety-six thousand three
hundred nineteen (496,319) registered voters actually voted
based on the Provincial COC of Maguindanao and not five
hundred thirty thousand seven hundred ninety-three (530,793)
actual voters as reflected in protestee's Preliminary Conference
Brief dated June 16, 2017 and PC Guide No. 5; 59
10. The Province of Basilan is composed of eleven
(11) municipalities and two (2) cities and not one (1) city as
reflected in protestee's Brief and PC Guide No. 5; 60
11. Based on the Project of Precincts for the May 9,
2016 National and Local Elections, the Province ofBasilan had
a total of two hundred thirty-six thousand fifty (236,050)
registered voters and four hundred twenty-two (422) clustered
precincts which functioned; 61

54 .Id.
55 Id.
56 Id.
51 Id.
Id.

,~
58
59
Id. at 24326-24327.
60
Id. at 24327.
6t Id.

~\r~
Notice of Resolution - 19 - P.E.T. Case No. 005
August 29, 2017

B. For Protestee

Second Cause ofAction (Judicial Recount ofBallots)

1. Whether the "protest all the clustered precincts" type of


election protest, contesting ALL the clustered precincts
of the Provinces of Cebu Province, Leyte, Negros
Occidental, Negros Oriental, Masbate, Zamboanga del
Sur, Zamboanga del Norte, Bukidnon, Iloilo Province,
Bohol, Quezon Province, Batangas, Western Samar,
Misamis Oriental, Camarines Sur, 2nd District of
Northern Samar, Palawan, Albay, Zamboanga Sibugay,
Misamis Occidental, Pangasinan, Isabela, Lanao del Sur,
Maguindanao and Basilan and the highly urbanized cities
of Iloilo City, Bacolod City, Cebu City, Lapu-Lapu City
and Zamboanga City, is a petition to declare a failure of
election and hence beyond the jurisdiction of the
Tribunal; or in alternative:
a. Whether the recount, revision and re-
appreciation of the ballots will confirm the
victory of protestee as the winning candidate
for Vice President;
b. Whether the alleged electoral frauds, anomalies
and irregularities affected the results of the
elections for Vice President during the May 9,
2016 National and Local Elections;
c. Whether undervotes or overvotes are valid
votes that could be a ground to contest the
results of the elections; or, whether the presence
of undervotes or overvotes are badges or signs
of electoral frauds, anomalies and irregularities;
d. Whether the alleged unaccounted votes contain
valid votes for protestant;

e. Whether there is a discrepancy in the voter's


receipt vis-a-vis the votes contained in the
official ballots; and
f. Whether there is a discrepancy in the voter's
receipt vis-a-vis the votes received by the
parties. 66

66
Id. at 23465-23466. ./~
'Kl\t-Y'
Notice of Resolution - 21 - P.E.T. Case No. 005
August 29, 2017

precincts of Lanao del Sur, Maguindanao and Basilan that functioned


during the May 9, 2016 National and Local Elections.69

Protestant also reserved the presentation of three (3) registered


voters and/or members of the Board of Election Inspectors to identify
paper ballots and/or ballot images, voter's receipts, and signatures on
the lists of voters, particularly the EDCVL, VRRs, and the books of
voters used during the May 9, 2016 National and Local Elections in
each of the two thousand seven hundred fifty-six (2,756) protested
clustered precincts ofLanao del Sur, Maguindanao and Basilan during
said elections. 70

Protestant further stated that he intends to file a formal request


for the issuance of subpoenas ad testificandum (and subpoenas duces
tecum, if necessary) to secure the appearance of the above-mentioned
witnesses for the purpose of executing their respective judicial
affidavits and their attendance during the trial of this Protest. 71

For the Second Cause of Action, protestant maintains his


position that he will no longer present any testimonial evidence to
prove the material allegations in so far as the thirty-six thousand four
hundred sixty-five (36,465) protested clustered precincts which
functioned in the following protested areas of Cebu Province, Leyte,
Negros Occidental, Negros Oriental, Masbate, Zamboanga del Sur,
Zamboanga del Norte,. Bukidnon, lloilo Province, Bohol, Quezon
Province, Batangas, Western Samar, Misamis Oriental, Camarines
Sur, 2nd District of Northern Samar, Palawan, Albay, Zamboanga
Sibugay, Misamis Occidental, Pangasinan, Isabela, Iloilo City,
Bacolod City, Cebu City, Lapu-Lapu City, and Zamboanga City are
concerned. 72

In view ofprotestant's clear and unequivocal declaration that he


will no longer present any testimonial evidence on his Second Cause
of Action, 73 the Tribunal reiterates its directive to protestant to submit
a new list of witnesses for the Third Cause of Action by limiting the
number of witnesses to three (3) per clustered precinct, and already
identifying the concerned clustered precinct, within a non-extendible
period of five (5) days from receipt hereof. Protestant's failure to do
so will be deemed a waiver of his right to name and identify his
witnesses, and to present them during the reception of evidence.

B. For protestee

69
Id. at 24328.

r~
10 Id. at 24328-24329.
71
Id. at 24329.
72
Id.
73 Id.

"Z'\>"y(
Notice of Resolution - 23 - P.E.T. Case No. 005
August 29, 2017

In compliance with the directive of the Tribunal, counter-


protestant submitted the new list of witnesses attached hereto as
AnnexB.

C. Pilot Provinces

The pilot provinces for the Counter-Protest are: Capiz,


Sulu, and North Cotabato. 76

D. Counter-protestee's comment to Counter-Protest

Counter-protestee atlirms that there are no admissions


pertaining to the Counter-Protest. 77
Counter-protestee denies counter-protestant' s proposed
stipulations for the Counter-Protest. 78
Counter-protestee acknowledges the proposed issues and
proposed witnesses of the counter-protestant in connection with
the Counter-Protest. 79

IL
PENDING INCIDENTS

The Tribunal now resolves the following pending incidents:

A. Motion for Reconsideration

In the Resolution dated January 24, 2017, the Tribunal denied


protestee's motion to set a preliminary hearing on her special and affirmative
defenses. 80

On February 27, 2017, protestee filed her Motion for


Reconsideration, 81 claiming that the Tribunal erred in finding the Protest
sufficient in form and substance.

On March 27, 2017, protestant filed his "Comment/Opposition [To


the Motion for Reconsideration, Pro Tanto with Prayer to Set for Hearing
dated 24 February 2017]," in compliance with the Resolution dated March 7,
2017 requiring the same.

76 Id. at 23556.
77 Rollo (Vol. XXXII), p. 24335.
78 Id.
79 Id.
80
Rollo (Vol. XXIX), pp. 22459-D-22459-F.
81
Id. at 22674-22698.
~
~y-y\"
Notice of Resolution - 25 - P.E.T. Case No. 005
August 29, 2017

Roxas, the protestee moved to dismiss the election protest because it


purportedly failed to specifically state the precincts protested and contested
and provide a detailed specification of the acts or omissions complained of
showing the alleged electoral fraud~ anomaly, or irregularity. In denying the
motion to dismiss, the Tribunal ruled as follows:
Moreover, contrary to the complaint of Binay that the protest failed to
provide a detailed specification of the acts or omissions complained of
showing the alleged electoral fraud, anomaly or irregularity, the protest
contained narrations of irregularities and ultimate facts that need to be
proved in due time.

Considering the foregoing, the Tribunal finds the protest sufficient


in form and substance, that is, the protest can sufficiently apprise Binay of
the issues which he has to meet, and the Tribunal of the ballot boxes that
have to be collected.

But even if the instant protest is fow1d to be sufficient in form and


substance, it must be emphasized that nothing as yet has been proved as to
the veracity of the allegations. The protest is only sufficient for the
initial determination by the Tribunal of the grounds for the protest
and give Roxas the opportunity to prove his case, both pursuant to
Rule 65 of the P.E.T. Rules. 87 (Emphasis supplied)

Following Roxas, in determining the sufficiency of the allegations of


an election protest, what is merely required is a statement of the ultimate
facts forming the basis of the Protest. At this stage, the consideration of
evidentiary matters would be premature. Moreover, as applied to this case,
the Tribunal finds that the allegations in the Protest are sufficient to apprise
protestee of the issues that she has to meet and this Tribunal of the ballot
boxes that have to be collected.

Finally, it is well to stress that the Motion for Reconsideration


essentially restates the arguments contained in protestee's Verified Answer
and Counter-Protest, and these have all already been duly considered and
passed upon by the Tribunal in the Resolution dated January 24, 2017. The
Tribunal finds no cogent reason to discuss these matters any further.

B. Protestee's Manifestation with Omnibus Motion (1) for Clarification;


and (2) to be Furnished Copy of the Annexes Attached to the
Manifestation/Compliance dated May 25, 2017 dated June 20, 2017
(Motion for Clarification)

On April 7, 2017, protestee filed a Manifestation88 . of even date,


seeking clarification on several matters relating to stripping and backing-up
activities of the CO:rvfELEC, including the cost of the lease of the warehouse
in Sta. Rosa, Laguna where the said activities were being held.

87
88
Id. at 2.
Rollo (Vol. XXX), pp. 22979-22984.
;,/
"(\\'"~
Notice of Resolution - 27 - P.E.T. Case No. 005
August 29, 2017

Here, the payment of PS,609,244.00 is pursuant to a "Contract for the


Provision of Warehousing Facility and Equipment through Lease, and Allied
Services" between COMELEC and JAM Liner, Inc. As clarified by the
COMELEC, the expense of PS,609,244.00 is to be applied to the lease of the
warehouse being used in its closure activities. The said amount is further
broken down as follows: (i) P2,737,200.00 for the lease of the covered area
and open area; (ii) P2, 149,600.00 for the lease of equipment; (iii)
P461,164.00 for compensation of personnel; and (iv) an estimated
P261,280.00 for electricity, drinking water, and gasoline expenses. 90

In this regard, it is clear that such expenses are not incidental to the
retrieval and transportation of ballot boxes to the Tribunal in connection
with the instant Protest and Counter-Protest. Hence, there would be no
occasion for the Tribunal to charge the same against either of the cash
deposits of protestant or protestee.

On another matter, protestee is similarly seeking clarification on


whether protestant would be held liable for the amount of Two Billion
Seventy-Eight Million Three Hundred Four Thousand Two Hundred
Twenty-Five Pesos and Seventy-Six Centavos (P2,078,304,225.76)
representing the costs to be incurred by COMELEC in case of its failure to
tum over possession of 97 ,366 leased units of Optical Mark Recognition
(OMR) Machines to Smartmatic-TIM, Inc., pursuant to the AES Contracts
executed between the said parties. Parenthetically, Section 6.9 of the AES
Contracts provides for an option to purchase scheduled to take effect on
December 1, 2016. 91

Given the collateral nature of protestee's inquiry, the Tribunal finds


such matter to be outside the issues posed in the instant Protest and Counter-
Protest. Such matter is more properly within the competence of COMELEC
to address. Besides, there is no showing at this time that COMELEC is
already demanding such amount from protestee pursuant to the AES
Contracts.

C. Protestant's Motion for the Collection and Retrieval of Ballot Boxes


and other election documents and paraphernalia dated July 10, 2017
(Motion for Retrieval); Motion for Technical Examination dated July
10, 2017 (Motion for Technical Examination); Protestant's Motion for
Decryption and Printing of Ballot Images dated June 1, 2017 (Motion
for Decryption); and COMELEC's Letter dated April 22, 2017
requesting for temporary custody of ballot boxes and election
documents in connection with EPC No. 2016-3 7 (Abdusakur M Tan
v. Mujiv S. Hataman).

90
Rollo (Vol. XXXI), pp. 23814, 23866-23867. /~
t'~
91
Id. at 23815, 23867-23873.
Notice of Resolution - 29 - P.E.T. Case No. 005
August 29, 2017

the election protest pending before it; but recognized that the Tribunal has
preferential right over the custody and recount of ballots involved in
simultaneous protest and submitted the matter to the wise discretion of the
Tribunal.

Protestee, in her Comment and Opposition to the Motion for


Retrieval 96 dated July 20, 2017, on the other hand, argued for the denial of
the Motion for Retrieval because of the pendency of protestee's Motion for
Reconsideration and for logistical and practical reasons as the Tribunal had
mentioned during the preliminary conference, that the retrieval should only
be limited to the three pilot provinces.

On the other hand, in protestant's Motion for Technical


Examination, 97 protestant prays that the Tribunal direct the conduct of
technical examination to be done by handwriting experts of the COMELEC
of the voters' signatures appearing on the EDCVL as against the voters'
signatures appearing on the VRRs in each of the 2,756 clustered precincts of
Lanao del Sur, Maguindanao, and Basilan.

Similar to her Comment and Opposition to the Motion for Retrieval,


protestee argued in her Comment and Opposition to the Motion for
Technical Examination, that protestant is not entitled to the technical
examination of the signatures of voters in Lanao del Sur, Maguindanao, and
Basilan as these provinces are not among those protestant designated as his
pilot provinces. 98 Protestee also argued that the pending incidents and
logistical and practical considerations as discussed during the Preliminary
Conference warrant the denial of the Motion for Technical Examination. 99

The Tribunal has already resolved protestee's Motion for


Reconsideration above; thus, the Motions for Decryption, Retrieval, and
Technical Examination can already be resolved.

Rule 65 of the 2010 PET Rules, as its caption states, is for the initial
determination of the grounds for the protests. Foil owing this, the revision
and reception of evidence, upon designation of the provinces best
exemplifying the frauds or irregularities, will begin with those provinces,
thus:

INITIAL DETEnMINATION
OF THE GROUNDS FOR PROTEST

RULE 65. Dismissal; when proper. - The Tribunal may require


the protestant or counter-protestant to indicate, within a fixed period, the

96

97
98
Id. at 24220-24237.
Rollo (Vol. XXXI), pp. 23966-23972.
Rollo (Vol. XXXII), pp. 24239-24245. //
~'<:"~
99
See id. at 24245-24250.
Notice of Resolution - 31 - P.E.T. Case No. 005
August 29, 2017

involved in simultaneous protests, it will not be exercising such right now


considering that the Tribunal, pursuant to Rule 65, needs to make an initial
determination of the grounds of the Protest based on protestant's pilot
provmces.

With respect to the protestant' s Motion for Decryption, the Tribunal


finds it premature to decrypt and print the ballot images from the relevant
SD cards and/or other data storage devices in each of the 36,465 protested
clustered precincts. As stated ear] ier, protestant himself has not prayed that
the revision process use the printed ballot images in lieu of the actual ballots.
Indeed, considering the protestant' s Motion for Retrieval - where he
likewise prayed for the immediate retrieval of all ballot boxes in the
protested provinces 101 - it appears to the Tribunal that protestant himself
desires that the revision would use the actual ballots themselves. This is
consistent with his counsel's declaration during the preliminary
conference 102 and in his Comment to the Preliminary Conference Guides 103
that the "ballots are the best repository of the sovereign will. Hence, in the
hierarchy of evidence in election contests, ballots constitute the highest and
best evidence of the voters' will." 104

That said, the Tribunal deems it proper to allow the decryption and
printing of the ballot images from the relevant SD cards and/or data storage
devices in the three (3) pilot provinces chosen by protestant. Again, this is
aligned to Rule 65 of the 20 l 0 PET Rules as regards the initial determination
of the grounds for the Protest.

IN VIEW OF THE FOREGOING, the Tribunal resolves to:

a. DISMISS protestant's First Cause of Action;

b. DENY protestee's Motion for Reconsideration, Pro Tanto, with


Prayer to Set for Hearing dated February 24, 2017;
c. PARTIALLY GRANT protestant's Motion for Retrieval only
insofar as all the precincts in the provinces of Camarines Sur,
Iloilo, and Negros Oriental are concerned;

d. NOTE COMELEC Letter dated April 22, 2017 and GRANT


the request for temporary custody of the ballots, other election
paraphernalia, including list of voters such as EDCVL, VRR
and Book of Voters as well as data storage devices used in May
9, 2016 elections for the position of Regional Governor,
Autonomous Region of Muslim Mindanao involving the 200
clustered precincts listed in said letter;

101

102
See rollo (Vol. XXXI), pp. 23980-23981.
TSN, p. 24. .,.-~
1''(~
103
Rollo (Vol. XXXII), pp. 24324-24341.
104
Id. at 24329. Emphasis omitted.
Notice of Resolution - 33 - P.E.T. Case No. 005
August 29, 2017

k. DIRECT Hon. Corpus B. Alzate to furnish COMELEC local


officers of Bucay, Abra and COMELEC Central Office the
Manifestation dated August 17, 2017 within a non-extendible
period of five (5) days from notice, and to SHOW CAUSE
why he failed to seek prior approval from the Tribunal before
the conduct of the activity in accordance with the Precautionary
Protection Order within a period of ten ( 10) days from notice;

I. DIRECT COMELEC local officers of Bucay, Abra and


COMELEC Central Office to SHOW CAUSE why they failed
to seek prior approval from the Tribunal before the conduct of
the activity in accordance with the Precautionary Protection
Order within a period of ten (10) days from receipt of the
Manifestation dated August 17, 2017 in (k);

m. NOTE Letters dated August 17, 2017 and August 21, 2017 of
Atty. Jose M. Tolentino, Jr., Executive Director, COMELEC;
Letter dated August 1, 2017 of Elma A. Mellomida, Election
Officer lII, Sta. Josefa, Agusan del Sur; and Letter dated
August 14, 2017 of Helen I. Priela, Municipal Treasurer, Bato,
Camarines Sur; and GRANT requests, subject to the following:

1. COMELEC shall give the Tribunal and the parties prior


notice of the date of the activities; and

11. The parties sha11 be allowed to observe and participate


therein.

n. NOTE Manifestation dated August 22, 2017; and

o. DIRECT parties to file comment on the Motion for


Reconsideration (of the resolution dated July 11, 2017) dated
August 22, 2017 within a non-extendible period of ten (10)
days from notice." Sereno, C.J., on leave. Leonardo-De
Castro, J., on official time. Tijam, J., on official leave.
Gesmundo, J ., on leave. ( 1)

Very truly yours,

\~~~-~
FELIPA-Jl ANAMA th.
Clerk of the Tribunal,,,. t.
ANNEX.''~~~J
NAME POSITION ADDRESS PRECINCT
NUMBER

PROVINCE OF 1.;ANAO DEL SUR

Cairoden B. Election Officer Municipality of


Usman ~umbaca-Unayan,
Lanao del Sur .By way of
Macapantao I. Election Officer Munjcipality of subpoena
Ca rim Tamparan, Lanao duces tecum
del Sur and ad
Asima Election Officer Muncipality of . testificandum
Macalaba Masiu, Lanao del
Sur
Jasliah P. Poll Clerk Barangay .QQ02A, 00028
Dimakuta Lombayao,
Municipality of
Balindong, Lanao
.. Del Sur
Adauya Poll Clerk Barangay Raya 0017A, 00178
Radiamoda Cadayonan,
Gomampong Municipality of
Bayang, Lanao del
Sur
Norharifa R. BEI Chairman Barangay Raya 0014A
Monadi Bubong,Lanao Del
Sur
Johaira R. BEI Chairman Barangay Ilian, 0023A
Monaoli Municipality of
Bayang, Lanao del
Sur
Sitti Aisah BEI Chairman Marantao, Lanae
Moonie del Sur
...
Okila H. Poll Clerk Barangay Ilian, 0023A
Marmaya Bayang, Lanao del
Sur
Khalid B. Baran gay Barangay Barua, 0006A, 00068
Biston f( Chairman Bacolod-Kalawi,
'---
Lanae del Sur

/v
~~}"'(
del Sur
Noroden M. H. Registered Municipality of
Abdullah Voter Bayang, Lanae del
Sur
Nor-Hoymah Registered Municipality of
B. Hadji Nor Voter Tugaya, Lanae del
Sur ~
Rohainie B. Registered Barangay Bangon, 0019A, 00198,
Maute Voter Marawi City, 0020A, 0021A
Lanao del Sur
Norhanie A. Registered Balindong, Marawi
Am-erol Voter City
Monoray S. Registered Municipality of
Decampong Voter Bayang, Lanae del
Sur
Manal M. Registered Baran gay 0017A
Bayabao Voter Kormatan,
Municipality of
Madalum, Lanao
delSur
Kurtubi Mukoi Registered Barangay 0008A, 00088,
Solaiman Voter .. Pagalongan, OOOBC 0008D,
Dumalondong, DOOSE
Lanae del Sur
Musa Registered Barangay OOOBA, 00086,
Panonggo Voter Pagalongan, 0008C 000$0 I
Solaiman
,. Municipality of OOOSE
Dumalondong,
Lanae del Sur
Aba Aisa Registered Barangay Ilian, 0023A
Fa had Voter Municipality of
Bayang, Lanae del
Sur
Hairiya R. Registered Barangay Nusa, 0039A, 00398
Tamrac Voter Municipality of
Balindong, Lanao
delSur
Rahata S. Registered Municipality of
Hadji Rasul Voter Tugaya, Lanao del
Sur
Hasana P. Registered Municipality of
Gomanpong Voter Bayang, Lanae del
. Sur
Amida M. Registered Municipality of
Tantao Voter Madalum, Lanao
- del Sur
3

/
~~r
PROVINCE OF MAGUINDANAO
Samad T. Registered Voter Barangay Nuyo, 00548
Mamorubid Municipality of
Bu Id on,
Maquindanao
Yolanda F. Registered Voter Barangay . 0127A .
Besanez Salimbao,
Municipality of
Sultan Kudarat,
Maguindanao
Marietta D. Registered Voter Barangay 0114A
Bonghanoy . Landasan,
Municipality of
Parang,
Maouindanao
Marivel A. Registered Voter Barangay 0126A
Amir . Tagudtungan,
Municipality of
Bonggo Island,
Pa rang,
. Maquindanao
Taib P.
0
Registered Voter Baran gay 0017C
Abdu lazis Macabiso,
Municipality of
Sultan Mastura,
Maguindanao
Kabiladas B. Registered Voter Barangay 00228
Masakal Bugasan Norte,
Municipality of
Matanog,
Maquindanao
Sainodin P. Registered Voter Barangay 0021A
Bau lo augasan Norte,
Municipality of
I
Matanog, .
I
Maquindanao
Ramil Sanday Registered Voter Barangay 0022A
. Poblacion 2,
Municipality of
Pa rang,
Maouindanao

v</v
1''t~- v
PROVINCE OF CEBU

Felino Y. Election Officer , Municipality of


Ma mafias Alcantara, Cebu
Arthur J. Election Officer Municipality of
Patiaa Barili, Cebu
Sandra L. Election Officer . Municipality of
Cocon Moalboal, Cebu
Delilah K. Election Officer Municipality of
Fuentes Dalaguete,
Cebu
Myler M. Election Officer Municipality of
Kiamco Balamban. Cebu
Anna Nelia T. Election Officer Municipality of
Jubav Asturias, Cebu
Maria Lina L. Election Officer Municipality of
Pineda Bolioon, Cebu By way of
Cresente Election Officer Municipality of subpoena duces
Hedralin S. Ronda, Cebu tecum and ad
Flores testificandum
Chauncey T. Election Officer Municipality 9f
Bo hoist Booo, Cebu
Carla O. Election Officer Municipality of
Esojna Tuburan, Cebu
Honorato K. Election Officer Municipality of
Flores Santander,
Cebu
Desierto B. . Election Officer Municipality of
Hortelano, Jr. Daanbantayan,
Cebu
Patricia A. Election Officer Municipality of
Si toy Consolacion,
Cebu
Mario Election Officer Municipality of
Alexander B. Tabogon, Cebu
Lao
Emmanuel D. Election Officer Municipality of
J. Uy Borbon, Cebu
Ferdinand Election Officer Municipality of
Hortelano San Fernando,
Cebu
Arvin R. Election .officer Municipality of
Maghanoy Compostela,
~-
Cebu

/~
~'ty;
Benedicto M. Election Officer Municipality of
Santiago San Francisco;
Cebu
Maria Neriza Election Officer Municipality of
S. Gigante III Bantavanl Cebu
Almaw. Election Officer II Municipality of
Canada Samboan, Cebu
Ma. Rena B. Election Officer Muni.cipality of
Martos III Sta. Fe, Cebu
Jose H. Election Officer Municipality of
Barria a III Soood. Cebu
Cordelia Election Officer Municipality of
Llanos III Argao, Cebu
Panaaanan
Jose A. Municipality of
Election Officer
Menouez III Catmon1 Cebu
Lito B. Election Officer Municipality of
Arquillano III Pilar, Cebu
Vivian S. Election Officer Municipality of
Canillo III Oslob, Cebu
Rudy P. Gilos Election Officer II Municipality of
Sibonoa. Cebu
Leo M~ Election Officer Municipality of
Monterola Tabuelan, Cebu
Gilbert L. Election Officer Municipality of
Pepito III Aloguinsan,
Cebu
Gallardo A. Election Officer Toledo City,
Escobar, Jr. III Cebu
Elsa C. Dabon Election Officer Municipality of
Ill Carmen, Cebu
Charita N. Election Officer Municipality of
Pasaol Poro, Cebu
Ferdinand S. Election Officer , Mandaue City,
Gujilde IV Cebu

PROVINCE OF LEYTE

Loreden F. Barangay 0006B


Rabuya Buntay,
Municipality of
~--
AbUVOQ, Levte
Nida G. Cena BEI Municipality of 009B.
Abuvoq, Levte
Miraflor N. BEI Municioalitv of 0098

.,,~
~'<',y\
-
Municipality of
Mac Arthur,
.. Levte
Evelina C. Barangay Palale 0044A,
Maceda 1, Municipallty 0045A,
of Mac Arthur, 0046A,
Leyte 0047A
Arceli G. Poblacion 0012A
Tabfgue District III,
Municipality of
Mac Arthur,
Levte
Minerva Baran gay Gen. 0030A,
Cajustin Luna, 00308,
Municipality of 0031A,
Mac Arthur, 00318
Levte
Archimedes Tacloban City
Retverto .
Nadia T. Baran gay 0059A
Duquilla Cabunan,
. Municipality of
Tanauan, Levte
Rosemarie P. Canmogsay, 0008A,
Royeras Municipality of 00088,
Tolosa, Leyte 0009A
Everette Telegrafo,
Suyom Municipafity of
Tolosa, Leyte
Eduardo Barangay
Olemberio Quilao,
Municipality of
Tolosa. Levte
Efren Palacio
. Barangay 0093A
Crossing Rubas,
Jara, Levte.
Evelyn Abuda Barangay 03
Upper Nula
. Tula, Tacloban
Cltv, Levte
Christy Ibojo Barangay 0051.A,
Binibihan, 0052A,
Municipality of 0053A,
-
Carigara, Leyte 0054A

11

,~
"<'\r',}<1
Apostol III Isabel, Leyte
Ramone Election Officer . Municipality of
Rizalee DP. III Jaro, Leyte
Baliton
Emma R. Election Officer II Municipality of
Marzol Julita. Levte
Darwin R. Election Officer Municipality of
Molabola III Kananqa, leyte
Roger Election Officer II Municipality of
Durante La Paz, Levte
Corona dos Election Officer Municipality of
Asensi III Leyte, Levte
Don Joshua Election Officer II Municipality of
Margate MacArthur,
Le~te
Reuel M. Election Officer II Municipality of
Junia Mataq-ob, Levte
Edgardo E. ~lection Officer II Municipality of
Aoostol Mavorga. Levte
Corazon Election Officer Municipality of
Pepito III Merida, Levte
Ramon City Election Ormoc City,
Dadulla Officer Leyte
Susan . Election Officer Municipality of
Colla mar IHI Palol Leyte
Leandro Election Officer Municipality of
Serino III Palompon,
Leyte
Dexter M. Municipality of
Dacillo Pastrana, Levte
Edgardo M. Election Officer Municipality of
To rill as III San Isidro,
Levte
Venditto D. Election Officer II Municipality of
Galban Santa Fe, Levte
Mary Dinah Acting Election Municipality of
N. Mendoza- Officer II . San Miguel,
All era Levte
Socorro D. Election Officer Municipality of
Altareios III Tabanao. Levte
Chester N. Election Officer II Municipality of
Canas Tabontabon,
Levte
Ma. Goretti V. Election Officer Tacloban City,
Casenas- IV Levte

13

/
?f'l't~
Edwin B. . Baran gay 00278,
Insierto Bagawines, 0028A,
Municipality of 0029A,
Vallehermoso, 0030A
Negros Oriental
Ricardo De La Barangay 00278,
Cruz Bagawines, 0028A,
Municipality of 0029A,
Vallehermoso, 0030A
Neqros Oriental
Ramon Tanjay City,
Antonio A. Negros Oriental
Ruperto
Gildu R. Dumaguete
Agoncillo City, Negros
Oriental
Ferlina B. " Barangay
Yocor Banilad,
Dumaouete City
Eufemia Tanja y City,
Ramirez 'Negros Oriental
Du Fan
Imelda Tanjay City,
Villaflores Negros Oriental
Santa

PROVINCE OF MASBATE

Magdie A. Election Officer Municipality of


Moran III Aroroy, Masbate
Judith M. Election Officer Municipality of
Lumberio III Baleno, Masbate
Mitchie Election Officer Municipality of
Tambal Balud, Mas bate
Letad a
Vicente Election Officer . Municipality of
Can~te Batu an,
Masbate
Lowell A. Election Officer Municipality of By way of
Barrun Cataingan, subpoena duces
Mas bate tecum and ad
Arnulfo B. Election Officer Municipality of testificandum
Valdemoro Cawayan,
Mas bate

15

~,~
if\~~
Amalia S. Baran gay
Mitra Bagumbayan,
Masbate City
Maribeth N. Barangay
Garganta Matungo,
' Municipality of
Tuqbo

PROVINCE OF ZAMBOANGA DEL SUR

Ellis L. Mig.uel Acting Provincial Pagadian City, By way of


Election Zamboanga del s.ubpoena duces
Supervisor Sur tecum and ad
testificandum

PROVINCE OF ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE

Cynthia D. Election Officer Dapitan City,


Cabrera Zamboanga del
Norte
Eric G. Election Officer Municipality of
Centi no Manukan,
Zamboanga del By way of
Norte subpoena duces
Delfo R. Election Officer Municipality of tecum and ad
Gall emit Pres. M.A. testificandum
Roxas,
Zamboanga del
Norte
Jossil R. Acting Election Dipolog City,
Ma cute Officer Zamboanga del
" Norte
Rhoderick P. Acting Election Municipality of
Sorronda Officer III Polanco, .
Zamboanga del
Norte
Josephine T. Acting Election Municipality of
La wagon Officer Rizal,
Zamboanga del
Norte
Delia M. Election Officer II Municipality of
Lag ata Pi nan,
Zamboanga de!
Norte ~
~ '

17 , 1''(~
Rosita Election Officer Municipality of
Alonzaqa Alimodian, Iloilo
Eden Election Officer . Municipality of
Dimafiles Anifao, Iloilo
Theodore Election Officer Municipality of By way of
Carmelo Badiangan, subpoena duces
Villaflor Iloilo tecum and ad
Rizalina P. Election Officer Municipality of testificandum
Sausa Balasan, Iloilo
Marion Election Officer Municipality of
Beau in Banate, Iloilo
Mary Grace Election Officer Municipality of
Labagnao Batad, Iloilo
Calbryan Election Officer Municipality of
Nobleza "Bingawan, Iloilo
Carlos Election Officer Municipality of
Serviqon Cabatuan, Iloilo
Cecilia Election Officer Municipality of
Caso no Calinog, Iloilo
Cirilo Z-errudo Election Officer Municipality of
Carles, Iloilo
Diana Jane Acting Election Municipality of
Lausple Officer Concepcion,
Iloilo
Evelyn Election Officer Municipality of
Abagatnan Dfngle, Iloilo
Romulo Election Officer Municipality of
Mataouel Duenas, Iloilo
Fralyn Marfori Election Office.r Municipality of
. Dumangas,
Iloilo
Jose Domingo Election Officer Municipality of
Seloterio Estancia, Iloifo
Remie Election Officer . Municipality of
Fernandez Guimbal, Iloilo
Cecile Ann Election Officer Municipality of
Fortuna do Iqbaras, Iloilo
Ma. Elisa Election. Officer Municipality of
Bernal Janiuayi Iloilo
Ma. Felisa Election Officer Municipality of
Labrador . Lambunao,
Iloilo
Renalisa Election Officer Municipality of
Jacaba Leoanes, Iloilo

,/~
Leonardo E. Election Officer Municipality of
~
"

~\t~
19
Nadderwin . Registered Voter Barangay
Nad Cagbang,
. Municipality of
Oton, Iloilo

PROVINCE OF BOHOL

Christopher Acting Election Municipality of


S. Peralta Officer Alburquerque,
Bohol
Maria Flor D. Election Officer Municipality of
Perin Alicia, Bohol
Steve C. Election Officer Municipality of
"
Lucero Anda, Bohol
Ester F. Election Officer Municipality of
Escobilla Baclavon, Bohol
Hamili M. Election Officer . Municipality of
Aki at Balilihan, Bohol
Ma. Divina P. Election Officer Municipality of
Gamutin Bilar, Bohol
Ranulfo C. Election Officer Municipality of
Valmoria Buenavista,
Bohol
Sherwin Rey Election Officer Municipality of
C. Iria Calaoe, Bohol By way of
Cecelia Election Officer Municipality of subpoena duces
Araceli C. Carmen, Bohol tecum and ad
Bali Ii testificandum
Ducelyn A. Election Officer "Municipal_ity of
Borba no Catigbiant Bohol
Ian De Castro Election Officer Municipality qf
Clarin, Bohol
Genevieve 0. Acting Election Municipality of
Sam ante Officer Corella, Bohol
Maria Shirley Election Officer Municipality of
A. Roloma Cortes, Bohol
Teodula B. De Election Officer Municipality of
Los Reyes- Dagohoy, Bohol
Reves
Joseph M. Election Officer Municipality of
Torrefiel Danao, Bohol
Maribella T. Election Officer Municipality of
Decasa Dimiao, Bohol

~
Magdalena E. Election Officer . Duero, Boholof
Municipality
Gamutin

21
*'V'y(
Enriquez Election Quezon
. Suoervisor
Florencio E. Election Officer Municipality of
Pineda Panukulan, . By way of
Quezon subpoena c(uces
Roly R. Election Officer Municipality of tecum and ad
Villegas Gumaca, testificandum
Ouezon
Erwin N. Acting Election Municipality of
Mantes Officer Plaridel, Quezon
Maricor P. Election Officer Municipality of
Saldua . Macalelon,
Ouezon
Honesto U. Acting Election Municipality of
Jorvina Jr. Officer Tagkawayari,
Quezon

Mesa
.
Connie De Registered Voter Lucena City 0016A, 0016B,
0018A, 00188,
0019A,0020A
Maria Jazmin Registered Voter Lucena City 0079A, OOBOA,
Jaca 0081A, 00818,
0082A,0082B
Joselyn R. Registered Voter Municipality of 0115A
Caubang Calauag,
Quezon
Jessica Registered Voter Sabang Uno, 0114A, 01148,
Barrera I
,, Calauag, 011SA, 01158,
Quezon 0116A, 0117A,
0118A, 01188

PROVINCE OF BATANGAS

Socoro 'M. Aro Election Officer Municipality of


Alitagtag,
Batanqas
Eric S. Ebite Election Officer Municipality of
Balite, Batanaas
Gene B. Barte Election Officer Municipality of
Bauan,
Batanoas
Agapita C. Election Officer Municipality of By way of
Bugaoisan Calaca, subpoena duces
"
BatanCJas tecum and ad
Nicanora A. Municipality of testificandum

./~
Election Officer
Bau~on Calataqan, -

'tl~y'li
23 .
.
Belinda F. De Election Officer Municipality of
Villa Sta. Teresita,
Batanqas
May De Villa- Election Officer Municipality of
Ga}'.'. Ian Taali Batangas
Arner M. Acting Election Municipality of
Samson Officer Taysan,
Batangas
Susana M. Election Officer Municipality of
Luna-Alvarez Talisay,
Batanqas
Marilyn S. .Election Officer Municipality of
Be lino Tingley,
Batanqas .
Erlinda Candy Election Officer Lipa City,
T. Orense Batangas
Evelyn s. Election Officer Municipality of
Nuestro Tuy, Batangas
Mitzelle Veron Election Officer Tanuan City,
L. Morales- Batangas
Castro
Joseph C. Election Officer Municipality of
Cuevas AgonciHo,
Batanoas
Nonnato M. Election Officer Bgy Poblacion
Mabutas 4', Municipality
.. of Balayan,
Batangas
Vilma B. Election Officer Municipality of
Ramos Lian. Batanqas
Grollen Mar City Election Poblacion 17,
M. Liyvag Officer Batangas City,
Batanaas
Luzel Marly Election Officer San Juan,
M. Dapula Batangas

PROVINCE OF WESTERN SAMAR

Maria Provincial Catbalogan


Corazon S. Election City, Samar
Manta Ilana Supervisor
Vesa M. Election Officer Municipality of
Ygbuhav Almagro, Samar

~-~
Gray O. Election Officer Municipality of By way of
~-

25
"'\'~ .
i: Antonio D. Election Officer I Municipality of
t Tonelete I Sto. Nino,
Sa mar
Election Officer I Municipality of
Talalora, Samar
Election Officer Municipality of
n: fjanez Tarangnan,
f Sa mar
l:1 G.
ma .
B
\.' Cabangunav
Election Officer .; Municipality of
Villareal, Samar
Nicolas A. Election Officer Municipality of
Mend ova Zumarraga,
Sa mar
Gloria D.
Hermosura
Housewife Barangay
Guintarcan,
l 0029A, 0029B,
0029C
Municipality of
Villareal Samar
~ Juliesa Mae Registered Voter Barangay 04 I OOOSA, 00058,
l~
G. Enerez Poblacion, ooosc
Municipality of
San Jose de
Buan Samar
Joanna Marie Registered Voter Baran gay I 0073B
Gabionza Canlapwas,
Catbalogan
Cit Sa mar
Rogie L. Registered Voter Baran gay I OOOSA
Betana Poblacion 3,
Municipality of
Dara ml Samar
Marites S.
Cale
J Registered Voter I Barangay
Iguid,
I 0137A,0137B
Catbalogan
. Cit Sa mar
Maria Ryza R. Registered Voter Barangay P-5 I 0067A, .0067B,
Jaboyan Canlapwas, 0068A
Catbalogan
Ci Sa mar
Corazon S. Registered Voter Barangay I 0001A, 0002A,
Macopia Poblacion 1 0003A
(Brgy. 1),
Catbalogan
Cit Sa mar
Crimar'S. IRegistered Voter I Barangay Pob. 7 0023A, 0024A

I~
Bernal es (Bgy 07),
Catbalogan
27
"{1~,
I I Oriental I --

Arlyn V. BEI I Municipality of


Bequiso Manticao,
Misamis
Oriental
f Maria Fe T. BEI Municipality of
r Jabagat Manticao,
j Misamis
l Oriental

CAMARINES SUR

,j Noriel A. Provincial Municipality of


./ Badiola Election Pili, Camarines
Su ervisor Sur
. JRam1rez,
/1

Rod?lfo M. Election Officer Municipality of


., 1 Jr. III Baao,
I Camarines Sur
Raquel R. Election Officer Municipality of By way of
Lagrimas- III Ba Iatan, subpoena duces
Lanuza Camarines Sur tecum and ad
Emilia R. Election Officer Municipality of testificandum
Queng-Bueza Bato,
Camarines Sur
..".:1 lHaide I. Tigue Election Officer Municipality of
;I
.. I
Bombon,
,; : Ca marines Sur
Jaime L. Election Officer Municipality of
Pantorgo Buhi, Camarines
i Sur
~-/ Oliva Delos Election Officer Municipality of
Santos-Base Cabusao,
Camarines Sur
']'' Alexander B. Election Officer Municipality of
, Marpuri Calabanga,
f Camarines Sur
I'! Salvacion B. Election Officer Municipality of
Fornoles Camaligan,
"' 1 1 1 Camarines Sur 1
Nenette A. Election Officer Municipality of
Efondo Canaman,
Camarines Sur
L..e ...
~/r!t'-- t>
Y
29
--
Jocelyn P. Election Officer Municipality of
Garchitorena Sag nay,
A I1 Ca marines Sur
Sonia A. Election Officer Municipality of
.I Idian San Fernando,
~ 1- Camarines Sur
, \ Imelda C. Election Officer Municipality of
:: . Anonuevo San Jose,
: I - Camarines Sur
I Freda Election Officer Municipality of
"' Guzman- Sipocot,
Andalis Camarines Sur
lI Ronald B. Election Officer Municipality of
J1 Beltran1
Siruma,
Camarines Sur
:'JI Adonis B. Election Officer Municipality of
Amador Tigaon,
t 1 Ca marines Sur
~lI Kirk Thomas 'Election Officer Municipality of
C. Tate Tinambac,
Camarines Sur
,. Cielito Moral- Election Officer Municipality of
)1 Ramos Gainza,
JI Camarines Sur
Perfecto V. Election Officer Municipality of
JJ.i Llanza, Jr. Garchitorena,
Camarines Sur
1
Dionisio O.
Election Officer Municipality of
.,. I Miguel Goa, Cama.rines
.... i Sur
, I P03 Alex M. Municipality of
Blazado Camaligan,
Camarines Sur
J Nup Mary Municipality of
:j Ann Francis Camaligan,
I B. Piloneo Camarines Sur
IP/SINP Rpmel Police Senior Concepcion
;
1
T. Santos Inspector Pequena, Naga
. City
Maico T. Election Officer Naga City,
Julia. Jr. Camarines Sur
Aldrin P. Registered Voter Barangay San NOTE:
I Broqueza Rafael, Previously
Municipality of executed an J
T
~
Lagonoy, Affidavit,
;.l.;..L
':
Camarines Sur attached to the
'
i... 31 ----- , '

"(l'f-~
''
''
Shandy M. Election Officer II Municipality of
:,,
Morecho Las Navas,
. Northern Samar
.: j Frumencio
Yu Acting Election Municipality of
. , Lagrimas Officer II Lapinig,
Northern Samar By way of
Nonita A. Election Officer Municipality of subpoena duces
.:
'
.I
'
Arzadon Laoang, tecum and ad
;I
_; i
Northern Samar testificandum
:\ Gerald A. Election Officer Municipality of
: Ape lo Mapanas,
' Northern Samar
'
Teresita Election Officer Municipality of
'i<
Sheila G. Pambujan,
'
Valencia no Northern Samar
Renato L. Election Officer Municipality of ...
:i I Madronio Silvino Lobos,
: i
,:
I! Northern Samar
Rolando C.
, j Election Officer Municipality of
. Arellano San Roque,
'1
"' Northern Samar
f] James 0. Election Officer Municipality of
1 1 Bernadas Gamay,
J Northern Samar
0.1:.l
'" i
PALAWAN
''

Urbano C. Provincial
;, I Arlando Election
Suoervisor
. :1 Elizabeth Election Officer Municipality of
,. Columna Aborlan,
I
' i Palawan
.:! Ferdinan? T. Election Officer Municipality of
: : Berme)o Quezon,
Palawan
''
Lilibeth D. Election Officer Municipality of
Ustare Duma ran,
Palawan
''
Alpha 0. Election Officer Municipality of
Sobrepena Balabac,
Palawan
. j Mangombaya Election Officer Puerto Princesa
'
l S. Madale City
)'1... -~
;.-,

'
.......
.
.
l.,:
33
~'f
Riah Ulson Registered Voter . Municipality of
Roxas, Palawan
Arne! Remote Registered Voter Municipality of
Roxas, Palawan
Marites B. Registered Voter Municipality of
Pislaan Narra, Palawan
Ailene E. Lim Registered Voter Municipality of
El Nido,
Palawan

ALBAY

Elias B. Election Officer Municipality of


Verqara Bacacav, Al bay
Sarah Jean S. Election Officer Municipality of
Escoto Camalig, Albay
Patricia B. Acting Election Municipality of
Barr.eda Officer Daraqa, Albav
Arlene Q. Election Officer Municipality of By way of
Chavez Guinobatan, subpoena duces
Albav tecum and ad
Roel I. Azurin Election Officer Municipality of testificandum
Jovellar, Albay
Wilhelmina Election Officer Municipality of
Render Libon, Albav
Grace B. Officer-in-Charge Municipality of
.Ranosa Ugao City,
" Albav
Jeanette B. Election Officer Municipality of
Batas Manlilioot, Albav_
Alan B. Officer-in-Charge Municipality of
Quinalavo . Malinao, Albey_
Jerry Eection Officer Municipality of
Benedicto M. Manito, Albay
Calaq
Alfredo B. Election officer Municipality of
Bas, Jr. Oas, Albav
Mario V. Election Officer Municipality of
Hernandez Ploduran, Albav
Anddy A. Election Officer Municipality of
Toledo Polangui, Albay
--
Ma. Sonia A. Election Officer Municipality of
Fernandez-
Mabelin
. Rapu-Rapu,
Albav /
~;t'
!(\~ .
35
-
Mangcasing Titay,
Zamboanga
Sibuaav
Pablito L. Registered Voter Municipality of
Camingao Titay,
Zamboanga
Sibuqay
Angie M. Registered Voter Municipality of NOTE:
Abao Titay, Previously
.. Zamboanga executed
Sibuqay Affidavits of
Luciana R. Registered Voter Municipality 9f Denial, attached
Turne Titay, to the Answer
Zamboanga
. Sibuoay
Lita M. Cabe! Registered Voter Municipality of
Titay,
Zamboanga
Sibuaa:y:
Saturnina C. Registered Voter Municipality of
Gallo Titay,
Zamboanga
Sibuoav
Angelie M. Registered Voter Municipality of
Asuncion Titay,
Zamboanga
Sibugay
Marites Orica Registered Voter Municipality of
Titay,
Zamboanga
' Sibugay

MISAMIS OCCIDENTAL

Roselyn Election Officer Ozamiz City,


Jagonia- Misamis
"
Smith Occidental . By way of
Mary Jane E. Election Officer Municipality of subpoena duces
Jumawan Clarin, Misamis tecum and ad
Occidental testificandum
Jovy 0. Election Officer . Ozamiz City,
Bonita Misamis
Occidental
Anacleta D. BEI Ozamiz City; 0320A

~~
Sebullen Misamis
--- Occidental
37

'!'~
Diosdado C. Election Officer Municipality of
Cas Anda,
Pangasinan
Renato C. Election Officer Municipality of
Poserio Balungao,
Panaasinan
Nazario 8. .Election Officer Municipality of
Radoc II Bani,
Panoasinan.
Norie N. Election Officer Municipality of
Nanteza Basista,
. Panaasinan
Michael Election Officer Municipality of
Estrellas Bautista,
Pangasinan
Zenaida E. Election Officer Municipality of
Diaz Bayambang,
Pangasinan
Anacleta E. Election Officer Municipality of
Casimero Binalonan,
Panaasinan
Estrella C. Election Officer Municipality of
Cave Binmaley,
Panoasinan
Renante C. Election Officer Municipality of
Albino Bolinao,
Panciasinan
Rizalina A. Election Officer Municipality of
Estrellas Bugallon,
Pangasinan ,.

Edna C. Del Election Officer Municipality of


Fierro Burgos,
- Panqasinan
Jeremias Election Officer Municipality of
Mancias Calasiao,
Panoasinan
Myrna A. Election Officer Municipality of
Sajonas . Daso I,
Pangasinan
Ulysses M. Election Officer Municipality ~f
Montano Infanta,

l Belarmjno S. Election Officer


. Panoasinan
Municipality of

\_r'~
Robina Labrador,
Panoasinan

39 +-.'ft"' -
Q
Mila L. Election Officer Municipality of
Dalutag San Nicolas,
Panaasinan
Gene N. Election Officer Municipality of
Balolong San Quintin,
Panaasinan.
Judith F. Election Officer Municipality of
Juguillon Sison,
. Panaasinan
Lorna S. Lepo Election Officer Municipality of
Santa Barbara, ,.
Panaasinan
Marivic G. Election Officer Municipality of
Luna Santa Maria,
Panaasinan
Generoso C. Election Officer Municipality of
Zarza, Jr. Santo Tomas,
Panoasinan
Eva V. Quinto Election Officer . Municipality of
Sual,
Panaasinan
Lalaine P. Election Officer Municipality of
Cancino Tayug,
Panqasinan
Jinky F. Election Officer Municipality of
Tabag Umingan,
Panqasinan
Windsor P. Election Officer Municipality of
Calugay Urbiztondo,
Panoasinan
Miguel G. Election Officer Urdaneta City,
Bautista, Jr. Panoasinan
Filomina M. Election Officer Municipality of
Matias-Cafe Villasis,
" Panaasinan

PROVINCE OF ISABELA

Candida 0. Registered Voter . Cauayan City, NOTE:


Cuaodan Isabel a Previously
Rosalia D. Registered Voter Cauayan City, executed an
Paranoan lsabela affidavit,
attached to the

\/'~
Mary Grace E. Registered Voter Cauayan City,
Ortaliza Isabel a Answer.

~\w~tr '
41
,.-------------~---------- -"----

ANNEX''B''
NAMES POSITION ADDRESS PRECINCT
NUMBER
~ -- 4

PROVINCE OF SARANGGANI

Solaiman
Dela Pena
R.-:--T

Registered
Voter
Biirangay Pobladon, l 0018A
Municipality of
Malapatan,
Saranaqani
Jonemene Del Registered Barangay Bafuntay, I 0079A
Rosario Voter Municipality of
Alabel, Saranaoani

PROVINCE OF SULTAN KUDARAT

I Marcos s. 1 --Registered Barangay man,-- I 0041A _,


Sabang Voter Municipality of
Eperanza, Sultan
Kudarat
Alfredo Agatep Registered Barangay Poblacion, I 0023A
Voter Tacurong City,
Sultan Kudarat
Zaida Abpet Registered Barangay Poblacion, I 00098
Voter Municipality of
President Quirino,
. Sultan Kudarat
Naila Balaymanl-- Registered 1Barangay Pedtubo;t-oo6ss -
Voter Municipality of
President Quirino,
__ Sultan Kudarat
Farida G. Registered Purok Namnama, 0026A
Amino Voter Barangay Poblacion,
Municipality of
Lambayong, Sultan
Kudarat
Noraida Registered . Barangay San 0182C

I
Macatiguil Voter Pablo, Tacurong
! I I City, Sultan ~ud?,_@_t ___
Nhor A. Alim Registered Purok Namanama, O~lSB ~
Vo::>ter Barangay Poblacion,
. _ __ _ _ _ _ _---.1 _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _...l-___:.M..:..:u::::..:n...:.:lc;!pali!'i_c>f __ ~ .

1 ~~
NAMES POSITION ADDRESS PRECINCT
. NUMBER
...i------ ...
Guinandang L. Registered Barangay Poblacion, 0022A
Bansilan Voter Municipality of
- Kapacan, C9tabato ---
Yusoph N. Registered Municipality of 0103A
Masabpi - Voter - M'lang( Cotabato
Omar P. Registered Barangay Aringay, 0058A
Sansduna Voter Municipality of
-.. ~--
Kabacan, Cotabato
Datu Alih s. Registered Barangay Kayaga, 0133A
Mamawda Voter Municipality of
Kabacanl Cotabato
Catalina U. Registered Municipality of 0109A
.___ Estancia Voter Tulunan, Cotabato., --
--
Jorge L. Mandia Registered Municipality of 0081A
Voter Tulunan, Co~_~bq~o ...- ..
Nonito S. Registered Barangay Labu-o, 0067A
Toraneo, Jr. Voter Municipality of
President Roxas,
Cotabato
Datu Sammy A. Registered Municipality of 0031A
Ca mad Voter Arakan, Cotabato
Datu Gabriel Registered Barangay 0032A
--
Eno yo Voter Doroluman,
Municipality of
Ara k~tlJ.t Cota bato
Emma D. Registered Barangay Poblacion 0048A
Pacete Voter 1, Municipality of
- Magpet, C919g_~t9___ ------4--.. . . -
~-

Dionisio G. Registered Municipality of 0013A


Alburo Voter Maqpet, Cotabato I

Edison Romero Registered Barangay Inac, 0036A


Voter Municipality of
tvlaqpet, Cotabato
Isidro T. Registered Municipality of 0139A
Soledad Voter M'langL Cotabato
Marilou A. Registered Municipality of OOllA
Berangel Voter MakilalaU----------.
Cotabato . ------
.
PROVINCE OF BATAAN

Ernesto Bendo
-Registered Barangay Mabiga, 0126A
..._ Voter
3
Municioalitv of
.,..V'
ti'r y-:.

S-ar putea să vă placă și