Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
VIDEO LARYNGOSCOPES
An examination of the equipment used
to visualise a patient's larynx P26
MAN VS MACHINE
Land speed records are being broken at
record pace and the FIA is ensuring that
medical provisions for drivers keep up
AUTO+MEDICAL
LETTERS/
P4 The best letters and emails received from readers around the world
GLOBAL NEWS/
P6 ICMS set to host 26th Annual Congress
P8 Grand Prix Trust renamed to broaden motor sport reach
P9 Injured IndyCar star praised after victory
P9 MDD named FIA's official medical products supplier
P10 Vienna set to host FIA medical summit
P11 Williams brings F1 skills to neonatal care
FEATURES/
P12 MAN VS MACHINE
The FIAs Land Speed Records Commission sets out to ensure
minimum medical provisions are in place for speed challenges
P20 CMO PROFILE: DR KELVIN CHEW
Dr Kelvin Chew on organising the Singapore Grand Prix, challenges
he has faced and how he would improve motor sport medicine
P26 VIDEO LARYNGOSCOPES
An in-depth examination of the equipment used to visualise a
patient's larynx that is used by medical motor sport personnel
P30 INSIDE THE WEC MEDICAL CAR
The World Endurance Championship has introduced a new medical
car that carries the kit to help drivers from multiple racing classes
P34 THE ROAD BACK: NICK HEIDFELD
The Formula E racer shares his thoughts and memories on the wrist
injury he sustained at the 2015 Putrajaya ePrix
STUDY/
P40 MOTOR SPORT RESUSCITATION REVIEW
Dr Matthew Mac Partlin discusses the latest resuscitation techniques
and explains how these can be applied to motor sport
2
AUTO+MEDICAL
In this section, we print the best letters and emails received from readers around the
world. We welcome comments on articles as well as suggestions for future content. If
you wish to send in a letter or email, please direct it to: medical@fiainstitute.com
4
AUTO+MEDICAL LETTERS
5
AUTO+MEDICAL GLOBAL NEWS
GLOBAL
NEWS
The 26th ICMS
annual congress
takes place on
7-8 December
6
AUTO+MEDICAL GLOBAL NEWS
7
AUTO+MEDICAL GLOBAL NEWS
DRIVERS TOLD TO
COVER UP BY NEW
FIA REGULATION
A new FIA regulation will
require all competitors
in circuit events, hill-
climbs, special stages
of rallies and selected
sections of cross-country
competitions to make
sure their neck, wrists
and ankles are doubly
protected against fire.
The latest rule
was included in the
governing bodys 2016
update of Appendix L
of the International
Drivers Licences,
Medical Examinations,
Drivers Equipment and
Conduct requirements.
The regulation states:
The Grand Prix The neck, wrists and
Trust was established
ankles shall always be
in 1987
covered by at least two
articles of protective
clothing. The balaclava
8
AUTO+MEDICAL GLOBAL NEWS
9
AUTO+MEDICAL GLOBAL NEWS
10
AUTO+MEDICAL GLOBAL NEWS
11
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
FEATURES
MAN VS MACHINE
Land speed records continue to be rapidly broken and Formula Ones Dr Ian Roberts
has been appointed to the FIAs Land Speed Records Commission to ensure that the
medical provisions for drivers keep up
12
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
13
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
LOW FINANCES ARE PUSHING THE
BARRIERS SIGNIFICANTLY
in place before a high-speed run takes place. One of the most commonly referenced
This is all to codify what is put into place, land speed record attempts is the upcoming
says Roberts. There are obviously medical Bloodhound SSC project, which will try to break
resources put into place for any attempt but outright record and the 1,000mph barrier
they have not necessarily been to an official in October 2017. But there are many more
or regulation level. Certainly some would have automotive speed records that the Land Speed
been above what was necessary and some Records Commission is required to adjudicate.
necessarily below. But its really just to ensure The Thrust SSC car, which travelled 763.035
that there is a minimum standard. over one mile in 1997, holds the current
14
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
outright record but there have been other Bloodhound is very high profile there are also
records set by diesel and even steam powered records being attempted by individuals who
cars over the years. In August 2015, the Venturi have very low finances and they are actually
electric vehicle company broke a land speed pushing the barriers quite significantly.
record for EV machines with its Buckeye Bullet The Appendix D regulations state that during
car, which was built in conjunction with the event racing operations two radio equipped
Ohio State University. ambulances are required, one that is located
The Commission is looking across the at the pit entrance and one at the venues
board, explains Roberts. Although the control tower, but it is up to the event safety
15
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
officer to determine if there are more suitable cockpit, which will transmit a lot of acoustic
locations. These ambulances must be crewed energy into the vehicle.
by staff trained to a level that meets the local To counter this, Bloodhounds cockpit
laws and rules for public first responders. There has some very high quality soundproofing
must be a minimum of two Emergency Medical that utilises Basotect foam, a material that
Technicians in each ambulance and these is used on space rockets to protect their
vehicles must be at their stations before any satellites during launch. Underneath the
racing operations can get underway. full-face FIA-spec helmet, Green will be
A doctor proficient in resuscitation and wearing moulded earplugs complete with
experienced in the management of trauma microphones built inside to enable two-way
victims is required for absolute and outright voice communications.
land speed record attempts, although this is Dr Andy Timperley, Chair of the Aerospace
strongly recommended for all other challenges. Medicine Group at the Royal Aeronautical
Society, explains that the potential danger for
PREPARING TO LAUNCH
But there are further overall medical
considerations for any land speed record FROM A MEDICAL POINT OF
mission. In a project such as Bloodhound, VIEW, ITS ABOUT ENDURANCE
with its ambitious targets, the driver will face PHYSIOLOGY. THE DRIVER HAS
problems from the heat and noise generated TO BE PREPARED FOR ADVERSE
by running a car at such high speeds across the
CONDITIONS
ground. Often he will be subjected to speeds
and forces more commonly associated with
aerospace missions. a land speed driver is not the high-speed itself
So its a good thing that Bloodhounds but the acceleration required to get there, as
designated driver, Andy Green, is already an there will be high G-forces acting on the body.
experienced RAF pilot, as well as the current There are also other factors to consider, such
land speed world record holder with Thrust. as vision problems caused by the acceleration:
The body is quite good at detecting During rapid acceleration and to a lesser extent,
acceleration, which is significant for when travelling at constant high speed, it may
Bloodhound, he explains. And the noise is be difficult for the driver to see in detail their
another matter. The airflow into the jet intake surrounds, which may become a blur; this may
is shaped and compressed by the pre-entry be aggravated by vibration of the car and driver.
ramp, which is the top of the cockpit. This It is also important for a driver to be fully fit
shape is designed to slow the relative airflow to deal with the unique acceleration of a record
from 1000 mph to about 600 mph, as jet attempt. Roberts adds: Getting up to speed,
engines dont like supersonic airflow. Thats a its the G-Forces that will be acting upon the
speed reduction of 400 mph over a distance of body, which have various consequences for
less than two metres, or in time terms about his cardiovascular physiology in terms of blood
two milliseconds. This will generate some very pressure, conscious levels, and those sorts
powerful standing shockwaves on top of the of things.
16
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
Heat is another factor. Theres an enormous It is our aim to deliver the Golden Hour on-
amount of heat not just in the car but also in site: stabilisation and promotion of recovery,
the area that they run the attempt [usually a before transporting to an appropriate
desert]," he continues. "So from a medical point secondary care facility, he says.
of view, its actually an endurance physiology In the 14 months leading up the record
point of view really. The driver has to be attempt, the development of Bloodhounds
prepared for those adverse conditions. safety plan will need to take into account
Bloodhounds operations and medical crews the remoteness of Hakskeenpan, the South
have been working closely to prepare for any African desert site where the run will take
safety scenario from a problem with the car, place, from the established primary and
to crush injuries to physical extremities, or secondary care facilities. The projects
puncture wounds from mishandled tools in main safety precautions have already been
its on-site workshop. If something were to go considered and applied to the design of the
wrong, critical care would be administered car, support equipment, team training and
immediately by engaging both its ground and operational processes. It is our aspiration
air paramedic capabilities to help the team to train all team members to typical airline
doctor, Charan Naidoo, who is registered with cabin crew standards, says Martyn Davidson,
the South African Health Professionals Council. Bloodhounds's Operations Director. All
17
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
vehicles and workshops will be equipped with Inside the car, driver Roger Schroer wears
medical response equipment appropriate to a helmet fitted with a bladder that can be
their role. inflated to aid its removal after a crash, as
well as a HANS device and a nine-pointed
COCKPIT PROTECTION harness to keep him secure in the cockpit. I
A record-breaking machine also requires also have to force my head back into a tight
additional protection for the driver. The Venturi cockpit surround area, he says. I literally
Buckeye Bullet, which last year set the record cant move my head from side-to-side or up
of 212.615mph in the sub-class for electric or down in the event of a situation where
vehicles over 3.5 tonnes, uses an adapted the forces would be such that it would really
IndyCar survival tub to add strength to the shake your head. The idea is to restrain your
chassis and features master switches that head as much as possible.
safety crews can use to shut off the electricity in Schroer explains that mandatory arm
the event of a crash. Given the electrical nature restraints work better if sewn into the sleeves
of the car, which Venturi will again use to try of a fireproof suit than those that are just
and break the outright EV record later this fitted around the outside. You cant be
month, the team briefs the safety personnel too careful out there, he says but paying
that work during its record attempts on how to attention to all of the little details could save
react to an incident, such as an electrical fire. your life.
18
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
SAFETY STANDARDS FOR ALL attempted, they vary enormously from single
Land speed record attempts such as the driver operated small teams, right the way up
Bloodhound project will attract headlines to the outright record attempt, he says. So
and interest given the incredible speeds youve got a huge range of people and teams
they are attempting to reach. By putting in all the way down to teams where they are
place the minimum medical requirements not running on a great deal of financial input.
for all teams, including those producing So we also have to be very conscious that we
vehicles to try and break other categories of cant be too prohibitive in terms of saying: you
speed records, the FIA Land Speed Records need major trauma teams on alert and if thats
Commission is aiming to make the sport safer no good the record attempt simply will not
for everyone involved. But it does not want happen.
to be prohibitive and that is a fine balance, All sorts of vehicles from lorries to production
according to Roberts. cars are undertaking these record-breaking
The land speed records that are being missions, so it is essential to be flexible and
supportive of all attempts not just the most
high profile, according to Roberts.
THEY ARE THE UNSUNG
I think they are the unsung heroes of land
HEROES OF LAND SPEED speed records really, upon which everything
RECORD ATTEMPTS, UPON else is built. The FIA Land Speed Records
WHICH EVERYTHING Commission is well placed to make sure that
ELSE IS BUILT their attempts are recorded and done under
the best possible safety rules.
IMAGE: A4GPA (FLICKR)
19
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
DR KELVIN CHEW
Chief Medical Officer, Singapore Grand Prix
Dr Kelvin Chew became the Chief Medical Officer of the Singapore Grand Prix in
2009, one year after helping to organise the medical aspects of the inaugural event.
He tells AUTO+ Medical about the challenges of running the medical team at Formula
Ones only full night race and how he would improve motor sport medicine.
20
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
the temporary track medical centre. An of the team. The briefings include reminders on
agreement with the events primary receiving personal safety and overall safety of the team,
hospital is subsequently worked out, ensuring as well as team responsibilities.
all of the required specialist services will be on The teams are subsequently deployed
standby during race days. throughout the circuit and this is followed by a
We then get confirmation of the ambulance medical inspection. This will ensure that
service and medical vehicles, as well as an placements of the various medical teams are
update of medical equipment and supplies. optimal and safe. Other track service teams or
Meetings with the national security and structures could hamper an emergency
emergency agencies then take place to plan response and such situations will need to be
both track and spectator emergency sorted out before the start of the race.
teams. At the end of the days events, a debrief
LEARNING CURVE WAS INDEED
is conducted. Through this, we get feedback
STEEP from the ground as well as ensure that all
personnel are accounted for. It is close to
contingencies. Training sessions occur months midnight at this point.
before with a series of lectures and hands-on
sessions, with medical simulations and A+M: Can you describe the biggest challenge
extrication practice leading up to the you have faced as a motor sport doctor?
event week. KC: To me the biggest challenge was to take on
The track medical centre only gets completed the leadership role and responsibility for the
one month before the event, when we will start Singapore Grand Prix during its inception.
furnishing and equipping the place. The full Given that motor racing at such a scale before
circuit gets locked down only on the 2008 had taken a 35-year hiatus in the city, we
Wednesday of race week. had to work from scratch.
One of my responsibilities was to recruit and
A+M: What is your role during an actual train up a medical team with no motor sport
race weekend? experience. My apprehension was that of
KC: A typical day during race weekend would fielding a team that was unfamiliar with
involve arriving early at the circuit with a operating in a motor sport environment. The
meeting for senior race officials in race team needed to be familiar with extrication,
organisation. We are updated on potential communications, race operations and
situations and any changes to the event terminology. And most important of all was the
schedule, as well as track and weather issue of safety. Maximum efforts were placed
conditions, manpower and logistical issues. on track craft and how to manoeuver safely in
Such information is disseminated to the this high-speed environment.
medical team in the daily brief for the members The event also needed the involvement of
21
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
various ministries and national emergency
agencies to plan and possibly execute various THE AMOUNT OF
contingencies for both track and spectator PLANNING AND TABLE
incidents at various scales. The amount of
TOP EXERCISES THAT WENT
planning and table top exercises that went
into the event was unfathomable. But INTO THE 2008 EVENT WAS
fortunately, we made it through that UNFATHOMABLE
inaugural event.
A+M: What has been your greatest A+M: Can you give any examples of
achievement in motor sport medicine? incidents you have responded to during
KC: I dont believe I have achieved anything your time as a motor sport doctor?
great in motorsport medicine yet. But pulling KC: What comes to mind was a pit lane
through that first event with a brand new incident, where [Felipe Massa in 2008] was
medical team was probably my greatest released too early before the fuel hose was
achievement. disconnected injuring a mechanic. We had just
22
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
talked through various scenarios that could Other static medical elements include track
happen at the pit lane in the weeks before and posts at strategic turns and the pit lane medical
were devising strategies to swiftly and safely teams. The dynamic medical elements include
manage such situations and then it really medical intervention cars, extrication vehicles
happened. Within minutes, together with the and ambulances.
pit lane medical team, we stabilised and On average, the Marina Bay Street Circuit also
evacuated him to the medical centre via a pre- has approximately 86,000 spectators within the
arranged route through the paddock. This Circuit Park daily, so there are also multiple first
incident impressed on me the importance of aid posts to service the spectators throughout
contingency planning and simulation training. that area.
This was how we were able to react and
execute plans effectively in that scenario. A+M: Have there been many changes to the
medical facilities and services since the
A+M: What medical and safety facilities do Singapore Grand Prix began in 2008?
you use during the Singapore Grand Prix? KC: Yes. We started out having the medical
KC: The Singapore Grand Prix is held in the centre at the pit entry in 2008, but due to the
heart of the city. The street circuit setting space constraints of the street circuit, the
means we are limited for space. The compact medical centre is now situated in a compound
track medical centre is constructed on a plot of close to the pit exit. This meant making changes
parkland and is completed one month before to ambulance movement protocols to and from
the event. the medical centre and there were some pros
23
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
at all times, ready to respond to any incidents.
The street circuit layout means deployment
IT IS REWARDING TO SEE
of medical elements and vehicles is tricky.
Access is mainly from the track. Once a medical OUR MEDICAL VOLUNTEERS
vehicle is being deployed for an incident, it COME BACK TO THE
would be an intricate exercise to reset or cover SINGAPORE GRAND PRIX YEAR-
that sector with another medical element AFTER-YEAR.
without disrupting the race. So it is like a
balancing act of juggling static and vehicular
medical elements. keep a small team at the medical centre past
opening hours, so the medical centre is running
A+M: Are there any extra considerations for for 24 hours every day. I remember in one year
safety and medical protocols due to the I had to stay up with a driver who needed
Singapore race taking place at night? specialist medical attention in the wee hours of
KC: We were apprehensive for the inaugural the morning because he kept European timing.
race in 2008 and made several contingencies.
But once we saw the track lit, our fears were A+M: Do you have to train your medical and
allayed, as the lighting was four times brighter safety team differently due to the Singapore
than a fully lit stadium. Grand Prix taking place at night?
The downside was that each day would end KC: As the circuit is so brightly lit, protocols in
really late at night, which meant the medical terms of track craft and safety are similar to any
team would only get to leave the circuit past other race during the day. It is only in areas
midnight and get home in the wee hours of the beyond the run-offs that we had to cater for
morning. Fatigue is a potential problem we are extra lighting.
keeping an eye on.
A+M: What is the most rewarding part of
A+M: Does the unique timing approach of F1 your work in motor sport medicine?
teams to the Singapore race create any KC: Having seen through a successful event
additional health and safety concerns? and having provided the volunteers with a
KC: Maybe its more for the standby team. We meaningful and engaging time. It is rewarding
24
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
to see our volunteers come back year-after- training and education for medical
year. I find that it is important to provide them professionals involved in motor sport. Secondly,
with a positive volunteer experience. This improvements in volunteer management.
includes providing effective training, It is difficult to standardise a training
engagement all year round, and listening to programme as culture and motor sport
their feedback. Volunteering for motor sport is disciplines vary widely. One approach is with
not an easy task. The hours are long and the customised programmes that ensure that
conditions are not always the most teams perform at a suitable standard. These
comfortable. Sometimes little things like programmes should include not only
lollipops or ice cream in between sessions can theoretical knowledge, but also practical skills
be comforting. Most important of all is to keep and team-based simulation exercises focused
our volunteers engaged throughout the event. on challenges in motor sport environments.
We keep our medical volunteer retention rate In many aspects of motor sport, volunteers
at around 75 per cent and aim to improve that. make up the majority of race officials and are
essential for a successful event. Efforts must be
A+M: In what ways would you improve taken to ensure adequate training, safety and
motor sport medicine? welfare of volunteers. Regular volunteer
KC: There are two things I would like to see engagement, team-building efforts and seeking
being more done. Firstly, improvements in feedback are important.
Sebastian Vettel
leads the start of
the 2015 Singapore race
IMAGES: SINGAPORE GP PTE LTD
25
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
IN FOCUS: VIDEO
LARYNGOSCOPES
AUTO+ Medical responds to a request for information about video
laryngoscopes, equipment carried by anaesthetists working in motor
sport series around the world
Contributors: Dr Paul Trafford, Dr Rob Seal and Dr Ian Roberts
Maintaining an airway is something that any are best left to the anaesthetic specialists
doctor or paramedic may be required to do. and are not something to be added to the
Motor Sport provides some unique challenges, routine emergency medical bag, says Dr Paul
but basic airway manoeuvres should always be Trafford. We also hope to consider basic
deployed first, with often a simple jaw thrust airway management in a future edition of this
or clearing of the airway being adequate along publication as this is something very important
with the use of an oxygen mask. Where further to all of us whatever our specialty.
intervention is necessary, simple devices such The classic Macintosh laryngoscope has a
as the oropharyngeal or nasopharyngeal handle containing a battery, to which various
airways should be used and if appropriate the designs of blades can be attached depending
i-gel or laryngeal mask. on the circumstances that it is required for. A
Visualisation of the larynx, also known as light source is usually situated at the end of the
laryngoscopy, facilitates the insertion of an blade to illuminate the pharynx, epiglottis, vocal
endotracheal tube into the airway a practice cords and tracheal opening, although in some
that is routinely carried out by anaesthetic cases the light source is actually located in the
specialists in hospitals, but this is something handle with fibre optics being used to deliver
all doctors attending motor sport events in an the light to the end of the blade. In recent
emergency capacity should be familiar with. times many countries have made the blades,
Yet even in the hands of a skilled anaesthetist and in some cases the entire laryngoscope,
this is not always an easy procedure. Rarely disposable and they are thrown away after a
necessary on-track or in a stage of a rally, single use because of concerns over infection
intubation is best performed under controlled control, explains Trafford.
conditions in a medical centre and where The laryngoscope is held in the left hand,
possible by a skilled anaesthetist with inserted into the mouth and used to push the
appropriate assistance. tongue to the left side and lift the epiglottis,
We were asked for information on video which obstructs the view of the vocal cords.
laryngoscopes following publication of a recent To achieve this, the correct positioning of the
paper in the British Journal of Anaesthesiology patients head and neck is essential the neck
and whilst we are pleased to discuss the needs to be flexed forward with the head
subject we want to point out that such devices extended backwards in a position often called
26
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
Medical cars in
Formula One and
other series carry
a large bag for
equipment
27
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
sniffing the morning air. The field of view with not suitable. A small electronic screen similar
a laryngoscope is very limited even in ideal to those fitted on smart phones is used to
conditions and this makes it difficult to show show the view at the tip of the laryngoscope
others what you are looking at, adds Trafford. blade, which may not be visible via direct sight.
Where the anatomy is distorted, or in In skilled hands these devices can assist with
cases where mouth opening, head and neck correct placement of an endotracheal tube
mobility or prominent teeth cause issues through the vocal cords and into the trachea,
with the visualisation of the pharynx and explains Trafford.
tracheal opening, it may become difficult and Video laryngoscopes are now available
in some cases impossible to see what is going in disposable form and are produced by a
on. For this reason, when a difficult airway is number of suppliers at reasonable cost, he
encountered, anaesthetists have a series of continues. They can be a useful tool for
alternative methods available to them, most of those familiar with its use. The devices are
which are confined to the specialist in a hospital available in hospitals as part of the difficult
setting. Some, such as the use of the laryngeal airway protocol, and can be used for teaching
mask (for example the i-gel), are commonly the anatomy and learning intubation skills.
used in emergency pre-hospital care. Where the intubating conditions are difficult
The video laryngoscope is a device that allows and the user is familiar with its use, a video
the user to demonstrate the anatomy to others laryngoscope in the pre-hospital setting can
as well as allowing visualisation of the pharynx be really helpful in securing the airway, says
and vocal cords where direct laryngoscopy is Trafford. To my knowledge they are carried
28
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
in the medical cars for Formula One and the results of the study, those without a channel
BTCC as well as other series where there are guide proved more effective.
medical professionals familiar with their use, The paper also included a note that explained
however evidence of their use in the difficult how previous studies using in-line stabilisation
airway pre-hospital setting is limited, and we of the cervical spine had a success rate for
certainly arent recommending them as an intubation that was far higher than when
essential addition to the medical bag. intubation was attempted in the presence of a
The image shown on the screen of a video hard cervical collar.
laryngoscope can be difficult to see in bright We feel that if faced with the situation of
light and it may be necessary to use a shield having to intubate a competitor in a hard
that is held over the person performing the collar, the accepted procedure would be to
intubation. Some models have a channel for loosen or remove the collar during intubation
guiding the endotracheal tube placement, to allow mouth opening and have a colleague
but in those that do not it is necessary to use stabilise the neck and hold the head in line,
a stylet, or insert, to stiffen the ET tube and replacing the collar after the procedure was
allow it to be bent into position, something complete, says Trafford. This of course
many users may not be familiar with. would not allow flexing of the neck or any
A paper recently published in the British extending of the head, but by allowing the
Journal of Anaesthesia has reviewed the use mouth to open fully, the procedure would be
of a video laryngoscope in a simulated difficult made easier.
airway setting. Patients were fitted with a hard
cervical collar that limited mouth opening
REFERENCES
from an average of 46mm without the collar,
to 23mm with the collar. Attempts were made British Journal of Anaesthesia, 116 (5): 6709
using a range of six different laryngoscopes (2016)
(three with a channel to guide the ET tube Evaluation of six videolaryngoscopes in 720
into position and three without) in a total of patients with a simulated difficult airway: a
720 patients. The success rate during the multicentre randomised controlled trial
first attempt was 85-90 percent, although the M. Kleine-Brueggeney, R. Greif, P. Schoettker,
success differed markedly with the type of G. L. Savoldelli, S. Nabecker and L. G. Theiler
video laryngoscope used. According to the
29
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
30
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
31
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
32
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
6 5 INTERVENTION BAG:
The WEC medical crews
will carry a small bag
for intervention that
holds a lamp, catheter,
oximeter and fluid, as
5 well as a cervical collar
and resuscitator for
the doctor to use when
attending to a patient
outside of the car.
33
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
NICK HEIDFELD
The former Formula One driver and current Mahindra Formula E racer looks
back on the injury he sustained at last seasons Putrajaya ePrix and offers his
thoughts on when it is right to return to the cockpit
During the close stages of last seasons a proper scan it was impossible to know. We
Putrajaya ePrix, Nick Heidfelds Mahindra were all sure there was nothing really too
steering wheel jerked unexpectedly out of bad. But the next morning it got worse and
his hand. Although he was able to finish the then as soon as I was home in Switzerland I
race and was not aware of any serious injury, had it checked by a scan with some injections
he had snapped a ligament in his wrist and to see where all the fluid goes and then they
was forced to miss the following race in could see that there was a scapholunate
Punta del Este. He spoke to AUTO+Medical ligament that was cut through. This meant
about the incident and his recovery process. that we needed to organise an operation
quickly because if we waited too long it goes
AUTO+Medical: What happened during the back by itself and then its too late to fix, so I
Putrajaya ePrix that caused the damage to got an operation date a week later in Zurich
your wrist? and it was operated on.
Nick Heidfeld: I had a big oversteer moment
and I also brushed the wall, but it had nothing A+M: And how did that operation go?
to do with the small impact. I think it was just NH: The operation was longer than initially
the fact that I put a lot of opposite lock on planned and as my scar shows, they wanted
and as the oversteer was quite huge and with to do it a bit smaller but they had to open it a
this steering compared to other racing cars, bit more as its quite complicated to get to
you can actually turn the steering wheel quite the damaged part. I think the operation time
far. You can nearly turn the car on the spot was about 50 minutes long or something
and the radius is very small. like that.
So I was turning as much as I could and
then the arms locked out. I assume that I had A+M: Did you know then that you would
lot of force on all the muscles, but then as I miss some Formula E races?
couldnt turn my hand further it just dropped NH: Yes. Initially, from my understanding, it
out of the steering wheel and I think this is was like maybe I will miss one race but then
when it snapped. the more I spoke to the doctor and the
Afterwards it didnt hurt much, just a little physiotherapist and it was more like you will
bit, so I went to the doctors at the circuit. definitely miss one and very likely two, or
They put some ice on it and I thought it would even more races. So this was quite tough
be ok. They obviously looked at it but without to hear.
34
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
Heidfeld finished
tenth in the second
Formula E season
35
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
36
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
DURING THE COURSE OF THE
2016 SEASON
asked if it was feasible for them to let me the adrenaline comes and it will be ok.
drive the shakedown in Buenos Aires and So we decided together that I would do the
have another driver on hand to take over if I race on the Saturday in Buenos Aires, but I
couldnt do the race. Again, luckily, they still told them I was not 100 per cent sure I
agreed to do that because they definitely would not have any pain and I might not
wanted to have me back in the car, which was have enough strength, and the end of the
a nice feeling to have the team pushing very race would be poor because of that. But
hard and giving me every opportunity to together we decided to try it and then the
maybe make it. Then, after the shakedown, it race went relatively ok, just in the last couple
was still not an easy decision to start the race. of laps I missed a bit of strength and in the
high-speed chicane I couldnt push flat out
A+M: What did the wrist feel like when you there, but I didnt lose much time.
got back in the car? For me this was probably the biggest
NH: On certain movements it would still hurt, achievement I had in my racing career this
not on all the movements but if I had any year because getting my hand working again
sudden oversteer to react to, it would hurt. was by far the most difficult part.
37
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
Heidfeld
managed to finish
ninth in the 2015
Putrajaya race
A+M: Was this the first injury you have about the doctor getting the correct
suffered in your career? findings and I was very sure with the
NH: Yes, it was the first big one. I had some doctors I had that they were right. Ive had
small concussions but not something that put it before and there is a saying in Germany,
me on the sidelines for too long, so this was three doctors, three different points of view,
the biggest I ever had. Not only in racing, but so you have to make sure that you know
also in general. exactly what is going on and that youre fully
behind what action you are going to take
A+M: Did the nature of the Formula E cars whether you ultimately need to have an
steering play a part in your injury? operation or not.
NH: Im not sure. What probably made it Just try to get the best people possible and
more difficult is that we dont have power then I think, as in anything, it is important to
steering and in most other cars we do. So its believe in yourself. For me, if I hadnt pushed
quite hard to turn and it puts quite a lot of flat out on my recovery I would have missed
stress on your arms, shoulders and wrists. more races. It is a hard job and a lot of work
but it was kind of easy because I love racing
A+M: What advice would you give to other like all other racing drivers do so it comes
drivers who are recovering from an injury? easy to you to try everything you possibly can
NH: First of all you have to be absolutely sure to recover as quickly as possible.
38
AUTO+MEDICAL FEATURES
Heidfeld has
raced in Formula
E since the
series began
39
AUTO+MEDICAL SCIENCE
SCIENCE
MOTOR SPORT
RESUSCITATION
REVIEW
Dr Matthew Mac Partlin discusses
the latest theories and practices
in resuscitation techniques and
explains how these ideas can be
applied to motor sport
INTRODUCTION
All healthcare professionals have an ethical
and statutory responsibility to be familiar
with developments that occur within their
own speciality. There are a host of
resources available which allow us to
achieve this; through attendance at
meetings organised by colleges and
associations, peer reviewed journals, face-
to-face courses and internet articles. These
resources allow professional development
using an evidenced-based approach to
ensure that we provide the most up-to-date
40
AUTO+MEDICAL SCIENCE
41
AUTO+MEDICAL SCIENCE
care. For those of us involved with motor immediate, following unsurvivable injuries
sport medicine, the same responsibilities e.g. thoracic aortic disruption,
apply. The vast majority of available within the first hour from airway, breathing
information, however, is based upon public or circulatory problems,
practice. There are some instances of after days or weeks from sepsis or
military practice, but very few which multiorgan failure.
address the specifics of event medicine and
more specifically motor sport medicine. ATLS was based upon recognising and
Consequently, most healthcare treating the problems that caused deaths in
professionals and indeed others who the first hour, many of which were regarded
provide care at motor sport events e.g. fire as avoidable, hence the term Golden Hour.
and rescue, extrapolate from our day-to- This resulted in a misplaced assumption that
day professional abilities and experience to a practitioner had up to 60 minutes to
try and identify what is likely to be intervene in a major trauma victim, which is
applicable, what might need some now recognised as an oversimplification. It
adaptation and how this may be achieved. also resulted in inaccurate measures of
However, it is important to keep in mind quality of care.
many of the differences between motor Clearly, some victims need intervention
sport and general public incidents, the key much sooner (e.g. tension pneumothorax,
ones of which are the high speeds involved, impact brain apnoea) while others might
ultra-rapid medical and rescue attendance progress over a much longer time (e.g.
at the scene and the variety of safety subdural haematoma, pelvic venous plexus
devices employed. bleeding) (1). What is more important than
The aim of this article is to review a assuming a window of one hour in which to
selection of recent changes in hospital and provide care is the appreciation that a major
pre-hospital based acute care and explore trauma patient is at high risk immediately
how these may be utilised within motor and requires a systematic approach at each
sport rescue and medicine. stage of care in order not to miss life-
threatening injuries. This is particularly true
PRACTICE (R)EVOLUTIONS for circuit motor sport where the medical
response team will be rapidly on scene after
THE GOLDEN HOUR FALLACY an incident and signs and symptoms of the
The concept of the Golden Hourwas injuries may be only beginning to develop,
developed by the American Trauma which may lead to an underestimation of
surgeon, Dr. R. Adams Cowley and was the severity of injury unless those in attendance
basis for the Advanced Trauma Life understand the dynamics of the incident.
Support (ATLS) course. You can read more The concept of a fixed period in which to
about his story here: About Advanced deliver care also led to the presumed
Trauma Life Support. He described a dichotomy of stay and play, providing
trimodal distribution of deaths after advanced life support (ALS) skills at scene or
major trauma: scoop and run providing basic life support
42
AUTO+MEDICAL SCIENCE
The medical
helicopter at the
Circuit of the
Americas
(BLS) interventions, followed by a dash for the tried to repair all injuries, leading to
nearest major trauma centre (2). Once again, prolonged surgery and disappointing
many experts consider this apparent mutual outcomes, due in part to the triad of
exclusivity to be an oversimplification. hypothermia, acidosis and coagulopathy (3).
Factors such as the injuries sustained, skills Initial trauma surgery has evolved to:
of those responding, and transport time/ Treating rapidly any immediately life-
distance all have an effect on the outcome of threatening injuries e.g. haemorrhage from
the individual. This is reflected in motor sport a hepatic laceration, pelvic fractures
whereby it may be perfectly reasonable to Transfer to the ICU to manage any
provide basic life support interventions physiological derangement and prevent
followed by a two minute journey to the subsequent complications
nearby trauma centre to a circuit competitor, Definitive surgery then takes place when
a similarly injured Dakar competitor may the patient is stable, which may be several
require roadside decompression of the days later.
haemothorax or placement of an advanced
airway to ensure their survival of the much This process is referred to as Damage
longer transfer to definitive care. Control Surgery and has resulted in
improved outcomes and reduced
DAMAGE CONTROL RESUSCITATION complications. Further evolution of practice,
In early trauma practice, the surgical team influenced by military practice in recent
43
AUTO+MEDICAL SCIENCE
conflicts, has led to the concept of Damage necessary to ensure that the person
Control Resuscitation, of which damage survives to reach the Emergency
control surgery is a part alongside targeted Department or operating theatre of the
permissive hypotension and haemostatic receiving hospital; e.g. decompressing a
resuscitation. For a full review of the history tension pneumothorax, application of a
and components of damage control pelvic splint, insertion of an advanced
resuscitation read Damage control airway. Performing a pre-hospital
resuscitation: history, theory and technique resuscitative thoracotomy is controversial
in the Canadian Journal of Surgery (4) and and is dealt with below.
Damage control surgery in the era of damage Where there is evidence of or a high index
control resuscitation in the British Journal of of suspicion of ongoing, uncontrollable
Anaesthesia (5). haemorrhage i.e. intrathoracic or
How do these changes integrate into the abdominal, consider permissive
management of trauma at motorsport hypotension. For penetrating major trauma,
events? which is relatively uncommon in motor
Clearly in nearly all cases surgery is not sport, there is (moderate quality) evidence
performed within the motor sport environment, (6) to support accepting a systolic blood
but some key principles can be applied: pressure of 90mmHg. Blunt trauma to
Perform the minimum interventions either or both the thorax and abdomen is
The medical
team at the
Silverstone
circuit
44
AUTO+MEDICAL SCIENCE
THORACOTOMY IS the use of such products is rare within motor
sport practice as the need for cross-matching,
CONTROVERSIAL
appropriate storage and reconstitution of
these products and limited shelf-life makes it
the best approach to this situation. For an impractical for most venues. The search for a
overview of the controversies read Permissive reliable synthetic haemoglobin is ongoing.
Hypotension on the Critical Care FFP and clotting factor preparations are an
Compendium of the Life In The Fast Lane blog. interesting area, with work being done on
What is clear is that estimating the BP based lyophilised, freeze-dried FFP and clotting
on presence or absence of the radial pulse factor fractions, which have long shelf lives,
or which pulse is palpable, is not valid. In can be quickly reconstituted and have no
motor sports, blood pressure and perfusion compatibility issues (9,10,11).
should be measured using clinical estimates
of perfusion and a non-invasive device,
which is quicker and requires less
equipment than invasive monitoring.
Recognising the device limitations is
important.
Ensure that patient hypothermia is
prevented, or even treated if the
prehospital phase is prolonged. Minimise
prolonged body surface exposure and the
use of cold intravenous fluids.
Blood and blood product strategies will be
dealt with in the next section.
45
AUTO+MEDICAL SCIENCE
Managing ACT has also led to the penetrating wound resulting in a tension
reconfigured role for Tranexamic Acid (TXA), pneumo- or haemothorax which
an antifibrinolytic. There is increasing subsequently causes a PEA (EMD) arrest can
evidence for the use of TXA for major be addressed rapidly with restoration of the
haemorrhage in trauma (CRASH-II trial (12) circulation. Blunt trauma, a mechanism much
and the MATTERS trial (13)), and the fact that more likely in motor sport, was considered to
it is cheap, easily stored, transported and have a much worse prognosis, due to there
reconstituted makes it attractive for use being less likelihood of a readily correctible
either trackside or in the medical centre. The lesion. However, recent evidence questions
dosing is simple and giving the initial dose of this premise (18).
1g of TXA once the trackside basics have been There are two main controversies in the
attended to is well within the remit of the management of traumatic cardiac arrest; the
motor sport medical team. Some motor sport role of CPR and the role of the resuscitative
medical response teams now carry TXA as thoracotomy.
part of their pharmaceutical stock.
There is a good overview of the TXA
controversies in this article in the Medical THERE IS INCREASING
Journal of Australia - Trauma and tranexamic
EVIDENCE FOR THE USE OF TXA
acid (14). The CRASH-III trial (15) plans to
evaluate the use of TXA in the subset of FOR MAJOR HAEMORRHAGE
trauma patients with head injury while the IN TRAUMA
PATCH Trauma trial is being conducted to
evaluate the role of TXA in mature trauma
systems (16). CARDIOPULMONARY RESUSCITATION
(CPR)
CARDIAC ARREST IN THE TRAUMA VICTIM The cardiac arrest may be the result or
Cardiac arrest in the setting of trauma the precipitant of the trauma. Where it is
(traumatic cardiac arrest, TCA) (17) has the precipitant it is likely to have an
traditionally prompted a bleak response from underlying medical cause and
medics with a tendency to cease resuscitation management should be based upon
efforts on the presumed basis of futility. This standard basic and advanced life
in turn has led to some conflict, including support interventions. Clues that the
criticism for commencing resuscitative event may have a cardiac cause include:
efforts. In the pre-hospital setting, there may older age of the victim,
be pressure to be seen to provide treatment, a relative lack of other significant
especially in the highly visibile circumstances injuries
of a major motor sport event when there are evidence of loss of consciousness prior
large crowds or the event is televised. to impact; e.g. absence of crash
When cardiac arrest is caused by trauma, avoidance indicators such as witness
the mechanism, whether it is penetrating or accounts or lack of braking tyre marks
blunt has until recently been a key crash in an unusual location such as a
determinant of resuscitative action. A straight or an easy turn.
46
AUTO+MEDICAL SCIENCE
47
AUTO+MEDICAL SCIENCE
Guidelines.
At the same time, control any external
haemorrhage, check for and treat a
tension pneumothorax and apply a pelvic
binder device.
If commotio cordis is suspected, treat as
per ALS. Early defibrillation is critical. Use
trauma interventions as needed.
5. If a traumatic cause of cardiac arrest is
suspected:
Perform bilateral thoracostomies for
tension pneumo/haemothoraces. Use of
attendance at a critical care workshop (23). a scalpel-finger technique is preferred to
At the end of last year the International needle decompression(33).
Liaison Committee on Resuscitation (ILCOR) Compress any obvious external
published its five year update on the haemorrhage. Use a tourniquet on
International Concensus on Cardiopulmonary limbs. Topical haemostatic agents or
Resuscitation and Emergency Cardiovascular dressings are an option for some
Care with Treatment Recommendations (29). haemorrhaging wounds.
Having previously focussed mainly on medical Apply a pelvic splint.
causes of cardiac arrest, this latest document 6. Gain secure IV or IO access. Once a
included an algorithm for the management of spontaneous circulation is established,
traumatic cardiac arrest. The recommended give judicious fluid volumes aiming for a
algorithm has been adopted with some local systolic BP of 90mmHg unless a significant
inflections by the European, American, head injury is suspected (see above).
Australian and United Kingdom Resuscitation Blood products are preferable but again
Councils (the Resuscitation Council of Asia is there are often logistical barriers to their
yet to publish their full set of updated availability at motor sport events.
guidelines). 7. Secure the airway.
Below is a suggested version for how this 8. If there is no response to the above
algorithm might be applied to a motor sport interventions in the setting of penetrating
competitor: or blunt chest injury, perform a
1. Arrive at scene and assess. Victim resuscitative thoracotomy, if there is the
unconscious and showing no signs of life. skill set and equipment available. A
2. Open the airway and commence assisted bilateral clamshell incision is preferred
ventilation with supplementary high flow over an initial unilateral incision.
oxygen. 9. When the cause of the TCA is major trauma
3. In out of hospital TCA, only life-saving and a medical cause is unlikely, most
interventions are performed, so as not agencies and associations suggest that
delay transfer. after any reversible causes have been dealt
4. If a medical cause is suspected: with, it is reasonable to consider ceasing
Start treatment according to ALS resuscitation efforts after 10 minutes.
48
AUTO+MEDICAL SCIENCE
MANAGING A TRAUMATIC should be included in the events Medical
CARDIAC ARREST Response Plan and be addressed at the
medical briefing as this offers clarity and a
degree or protection for members of the
in the vehicle. In such cases, the steps should medical team should they be faced with a
be applied according to the circumstances. traumatic cardiac arrest situation. It is also clear
The majority of competitors in this scenario that a successful outcome will be enhanced by
who are going to survive will respond to steps clear communication, streamlined transport
1 to 7. Step 8, the decision to perform a processes and regular education and training.
49
AUTO+MEDICAL SCIENCE
50
AUTO+MEDICAL SCIENCE
Editors Note
The subject of the use of cervical collars and immobilisation is on the agenda to be discussed at the Biannual CMO
conference in Vienna. We hope to report on the discussions in a future issue.
51 51
AUTO+MEDICAL SCIENCE
52
AUTO+MEDICAL SCIENCE
slideshare.net/canicaveronica/ european-resuscitation-council-
advancedtraumalifesupportatls9thedition guidelines-resuscitation-2015-
27. ATLS 9th Edition review by Dr Kenji Inaba section-4-cardiac-arrest-
- https://youtu.be/nB8mNNmjCZg special#ASPECIALCAUSES
28. ATLS Evolving on ScanCrit (May 24, 2016) 32. Australian and New Zealand
- http://www.scancrit.com/2016/05/24/atls- Resuscitation Council Guidelines on
evolving/ Traumatic Cardiac Arrest 2016
29. ILCOR 2015 Updated Guidelines: ILCOR (Guideline 11.10.1) - http://resus.org.
CoSTR 2015 - http://www.ilcor.org/ au/guidelines/
consensus-2015/costr-2015-documents/ 33. S
imple Thoracostomy: Moving
30. ILCOR 2015: Does it matter for motorsports? Beyond Needle Decompression in
- http://rollcagemedic.com/news-and- Traumatic Cardiac Arrest. MEA
reviews/ilcor-2015-does-it-matter-for- Escott. JEMS 2014, Vol 39 (4) - http://
motorsports- www.jems.com/articles/print/
31. European Resuscitation Council Guidelines volume-39/issue-4/features/simple-
on Traumatic Cardiac Arrest 2015 http:// thoracostomy-moving-beyond-
ercguidelines.elsevierresource.com/ needle.html
53
AUTO+MEDICAL SCIENCE
CALL FOR
SUBMISSIONS
Every issue of AUTO+Medical contains a scientific research paper
that looks at the various medical issues that surround motor sport.
All submissions are welcome For each submission please AUTO+ MEDICAL
so if you have a study that include a summary of the EDITORIAL BOARD
you feel would be suitable research and all necessary
for publication in the future contact information. Dr Paul Trafford
issues of AUTO+Medical, (Chairman)
please send it to: The editorial board will
medical@fiainstitute evaluate each submission Dr Robert Seal
before it is accepted for use (Medical Director,
in the magazine. Canadian Motorsports
Response Team)
Dr Matthew
Mac Partlin
(Assistant Chief Medical
Officer, Australian GP)
Dr Pedro Esteban
(FIA Medical Delegate,
World Rallycross
Championship)
Dr Jean Duby
(FIA Medical Delegate,
World Rally
Championship)
Dr Kelvin Chew
(Chief Medical Officer,
Singapore GP)
Dr Jean-Charles Piette
(FIA Medical Delegate,
Formula One)
54