Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
place.
In
order
to
understand
these
limitations,
it
must
first
be
outlined
how
the
enzyme
works
to
metabolise
acetylcholine.
The
structure
of
the
AChE
enzyme
allows
for
cholinergic
drugs
including
acetylcholine
to
bind
to
a
sequence
of
amino
acids
in
the
protein
structure
of
the
enzyme,
as
long
as
the
drug
is
not
sterically
or
electronically
hindered.
The
ligand
binds
to
an
anionic
site,
which
has
partial
negative
charge
and
so
binds
to
the
electropositive
quaternary
amine
of
the
choline
moiety.
It
also
binds
to
an
esteratic
site
where
the
sequence
of
amino
acids
resides
and
where
the
significant
chemical
reactions
takes
place
(ATSDR,
2007;
olovi
et
al.,
2013).
A
schematic
Page
1
of
7
diagram
of
AChE
is
shown
below
in
Figure
2.1,
with
relevant
binding
sites
depicted
in
Figure
2.2.
Figure
2.1:
D iagram
of
3
dimensional
structure
o f
AChE
determined
by
Figure
2.2:
Schematic
of
AChE
binding
sites
(from
olovi
et
a l.,
2013)
X-ray
crystallography
(from
Field
a nd
Wymore,
2014).
The
active
site
of
the
enzyme
is
depicted
in
Figure
2.2,
which
resides
4
from
the
bottom
of
the
molecule.
The
anionic
site
is
represented
in
the
diagram
collectively
by
the
acyl
pocket
and
choline
binding
site.
It
is
uncharged
and
lipophilic.
The
cationic
substrate
is
not
bound
by
ionic
means
to
an
amino-acid
in
the
anionic
site,
but
by
Van
der
Waal
interactions
with
14
aromatic
amino-acid
functional
groups
that
line
the
site.
Key
amino-acids
in
this
site
are
the
aromatic
phenyl
group-containing
amino-acids
phenylalanine
and
tryptophan,
with
tryptophan
84
being
critical
to
the
activity
of
the
enzyme
(olovi
et
al.,
2013).
The
esteratic
site
comprises
of
the
catalytic
triad
that
is
common
among
serine
hydrolases
the
amino-
acids
serine
200,
histidine
440
and
glutamate
327
(olovi
et
al.,
2013).
The
hydrolysis
reaction
of
acetylcholine
by
AChE
has
been
studied
extensively
experimentally,
and
with
the
aid
of
quantum
mechanics/molecular
mechanics
(QM/MM)
simulations
of
chemical
reactions
of
the
enzyme
with
acetylcholine
and
other
ligands,
mechanistic
information
of
AChE
has
been
obtained
(Zhou
et
al.,
2010;
Field
and
Wymore,
2014).
It
has
been
discovered
that
human
AChE
metabolises
acetylcholine
in
a
two-step
process:
acylation,
followed
by
deacylation
(Field
and
Wymore,
2014).
The
chemical
reaction
is
shown
diagrammatically
in
Figure
3.
Page
2
of
7
Figure
3:
C hemical
mechanism
by
which
acetylcholinesterase
metabolises
acetylcholine
(from
olovi
et
al.,
2013).
In
the
acylation
step,
hydrolysis
of
the
carboxyl
ester
of
acetylcholine
leads
to
the
formation
of
an
acylated
enzyme
and
a
free
choline
metabolite
(in
the
diagram
above
this
is
depicted
by
the
reaction
in
the
first
two
steps).
This
is
followed
immediately
by
the
nucleophilic
attack
of
a
water
molecule
on
the
carbonyl
carbon
of
the
acyl-enzyme
product
of
the
previous
step,
which
is
assisted
by
the
histidine
440
group.
This
removes
the
acetate
from
the
enzyme
complex,
resulting
in
liberation
of
acetic
acid
and
reactivation
of
AChE
(olovi
et
al.,
2013).
With
the
knowledge
of
the
structure
of
this
enzyme
and
how
it
works
to
metabolise
cholinergic
ligands,
it
can
be
understood
how
inhibitors
of
AChE
work.
In
the
scenario
of
the
Curry
Crisis,
the
children
experienced
symptoms
of
stomach
ache,
watery
eyes,
sweating,
vomiting,
diarrhoea,
muscle
twitching,
convulsions,
loss
of
consciousness
and
death.
These
Page
3
of
7
symptoms
fit
closely
to
those
of
acute
organophosphate
(OP)
poisoning,
which
elicits
its
effects
via
acetylcholinesterase
inhibition.
These
symptoms
are
listed
in
Table
1
below.
Receptor
Symptoms
Diarrhoea,
urinary
incontinence,
miosis,
bradycardia,
bronchoconstriction,
bronchorrhoea,
hypotension,
increased
Muscarinic
receptors
(mAChR)
gastrointestinal
motility,
abdominal
cramps,
hypersalivation,
lacrimation
Table
1:
Acute
symptoms
of
OP
poisoning
a t
their
respective
receptor
a s
a
result
of
AChE
inhibition
a nd
subsequent
overstimulation
of
postsynaptic
c holinergic
receptors
(taken
from
Mangas
e t
al.,
2016).
The
children
reported
the
difference
in
taste
of
the
new
curry,
and
this
was
most
likely
due
to
the
change
in
cooking
oil
used,
suggesting
cross-contamination
of
the
new
ingredient
with
foreign
substances
including
insecticides
could
be
the
cause
of
the
symptoms.
The
poisoning
could
have
also
perhaps
been
caused
by
the
contamination
of
cooking
utensils
such
as
the
pots
and
containers
used
to
dish
out
food,
if
these
were
exposed
to
insecticides
prior
to
the
cooking
and
distribution
of
the
curry.
For
this
reason,
it
shall
be
assumed
that
the
children
in
this
scenario
suffered
from
insecticide
poisoning.
Insecticides
come
in
mainly
two
forms:
carbamates
and
organophosphates,
which
are
popular
mainly
due
to
their
effectiveness
and
relatively
low
price
(Mangas
et
al.,
2016).
The
general
chemical
structures
of
carbamates
and
organophosphates
are
depicted
respectively
in
Figure
4.1
and
Figure
4.2.
Both
figures
are
taken
from
olovi
et
al.,
2013.
Figure
4.1:
General
structural
formula
for
carbamates
Figure
4.2:
General
structural
formula
for
organophosphates
The
letters
for
both
structural
formulae
above
denote
different
atoms
that
may
make
up
the
molecule.
X
may
be
oxygen
or
sulfur
(in
which
case
the
carbamate
is
a
thiocarbamate)
and
R1,
Page
4
of
7
R2
and
R3
are
different
structural
groups
which
may
be
hydrogen,
metal
atoms,
or
(usually)
organic
substituents.
In
a
carbamate,
insecticide
activity
is
induced
if
R1
is
a
methyl
group
and
R2
is
a
hydrogen
(olovi
et
al.,
2013).
Since
both
classes
of
molecule
inhibit
AChE,
they
both
elicit
similar
toxic
acute
responses
with
the
difference
being
that
carbamate
insecticides
do
not
form
permanent
covalent
bonds
with
the
enzyme,
as
OP
insecticides
do.
Carbamate
molecules
are
able
to
spontaneously
hydrolyse
from
the
enzyme-carbamate
complex
in
much
the
same
way
that
acetate
can,
however
the
process
takes
a
much
longer
time
(approximately
30
40
minutes,
whereas
with
acetylcholine
deacylation
is
immediate)
(olovi
et
al.,
2013).
In
the
Curry
Crisis,
however,
the
childrens
symptoms
lasted
longer
than
30
40
minutes
and
were
more
severe,
indicating
organophosphate
poisoning
was
the
cause.
The
mechanism
by
which
AChE
metabolises
OPs
is
as
such.
In
much
the
same
way
as
acylation,
the
enzyme
reacts
with
the
drug
in
a
substitution
SN2
reaction,
but
in
this
case
it
becomes
phosphorylated.
This
is
because
the
structure
of
OPs
closely
resemble
the
structure
of
acetylcholine
(olovi
et
al.,
2013).
The
next
step
differs
in
that
deacylation
occurs
quickly,
whereas
dephosphorylation
occurs
much
more
slowly
(on
the
order
of
days)
and
that
is
if
the
OP
does
not
undergo
aging,
which
increases
their
toxicity
further.
This
is
an
enzyme-
mediated
process,
in
which
a
covalent
bond
is
formed
irreversibly
between
the
phosphorus
atom
and
the
enzyme
due
to
the
removal
of
an
alkyl
side
group
of
the
OP
caused
by
nucleophilic
attack
of
a
hydroxyl
anion,
resulting
in
a
negative
charge
on
the
oxygen
atom
that
was
linked
to
the
alkyl
group
(Field
and
Wymore,
2014).
This
makes
the
enzyme
much
more
resistant
to
reactivation,
as
the
formation
of
a
salt
bridge
is
promoted
between
the
protonated
histidine
and
the
negatively
charged
oxygen
atom
bound
to
the
phosphorus
atom.
Conformational
and
stability
changes
of
the
enzyme
also
occur
during
(and
as
a
result
of)
this
reaction
(Curtil
and
Masson,
1993).
The
result
is
irreversible
and
the
enzyme
is
permanently
inactivated.
In
a
way,
the
enzyme
catalyses
its
own
demise.
This
process
is
illustrated
on
the
following
page
in
Figure
5
with
the
example
of
the
OP
soman,
which
is
a
nerve
agent
but
acts
in
a
similar
way
to
insecticide
agents.
Page
5
of
7
Figure
5:
Process
by
which
the
OP
soman
inhibits
and
ages
AChE.
It
works
in
the
same
way
as
insecticide
OPs,
but
the
aging
mechanism
occurs
much
more
rapidly.
In
the
case
for
soman,
AChE
causes
dealkylation
to
occur,
eliminating
the
alkyl
moiety
leaving
the
enzyme
irreversibly
phosphorylated
and
the
alkyl
side
chain
as
a
carbenium
cation,
ready
to
react
with
other
molecules
in
solution
(Source:
Field
and
Wymore,
2014).
The
irreversible
formation
of
the
phosphorylated
enzyme
causes
AChE
inactivation.
As
a
result,
acetylcholine
levels
build
up
in
the
synaptic
cleft
as
it
can
no
longer
metabolise
the
neurotransmitter,
causing
overstimulation
of
cholinergic
receptors
and
leading
to
the
symptoms
listed
in
Table
1
and
the
ones
experienced
by
the
children
in
the
Curry
Crisis
(olovi
et
al.,
2013).
Depicted
in
Figure
6.1
and
Figure
6.2
are
chemical
structures
of
various
OPs.
The
chemicals
in
Figure
6.1
are
all
insecticides
and
in
Figure
6.2
paraoxon
and
diisopropyl
fluorophosphates
(DFP)
are
OPs
used
in
medicine
and
as
insecticides
and
sarin,
soman,
VX
and
tabun
are
all
examples
of
lethal
nerve
agents.
Figure
6.1
(above):
Chemical
structures
of
various
OP
insecticides.
(Taken
from
olovi
et
a l.,
2013).
Figure
6.2
(left):
Chemical
structures
of
various
OPs.
The
structures
shown
in
red
are
the
leaving
groups
once
the
drug
undergoes
hydrolysis
(Field
and
Wymore,
2014).
(Taken
from
Field
a nd
Wymore,
2014)
Page
6
of
7
In
conclusion,
acetylcholinesterase
is
a
very
important
enzyme
in
the
body,
as
it
is
responsible
for
the
metabolism
of
acetylcholine
in
synaptic
clefts
so
that
overstimulation
of
receptors
does
not
occur.
Through
analysis
of
the
Curry
Crisis
scenario,
the
symptoms
of
the
children
affected
closely
matched
the
symptoms
induced
by
overstimulation
of
cholinergic
receptors
as
a
result
of
acetylcholinesterase
inhibition.
It
was
hypothesised
that
insecticide
poisoning
was
the
cause,
with
two
main
culprits
identified
due
to
their
availability
in
the
context
of
the
Curry
Crisis:
carbamates
and
organophosphates.
The
childrens
symptoms
lasted
longer
and
were
more
severe
than
would
be
expected
of
a
carbamate
pesticide,
leaving
organophosphate
poisoning
as
the
remaining
logical
cause.
Investigation
of
the
pharmacology
and
organic
chemistry
involved
in
the
metabolism
of
acetylcholine
and
organophosphates
revealed
that
AChE
is
easily
phosphorylated
by
OPs
as
they
share
a
similar
structure
to
endogenous
cholinergic
neurotransmitters
though
it
is
much
more
difficult
for
the
phosphorylated
enzyme
to
then
be
hydrolysed
in
order
to
reactivate
it.
Due
to
these
reasons,
the
conclusion
was
made
that
the
children
were
most
likely
experiencing
organophosphate
poisoning.
References
(2007). Cholinesterase Inhibitors - Management of the Cholinergic Toxidrome - Medications:
2-PAM (2-Pyridine Aldoxime Methylchloride) (Pralidoxime) | ATSDR - Environmental
Medicine & Environmental Health Education - CSEM. Available at:
https://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/csem/csem.asp?csem=11&po=23
Colovic, M., Krstic, D., Lazarevic-Pasti, T., Bondzic, A., and Vasic, V. (2013).
Acetylcholinesterase Inhibitors: Pharmacology and Toxicology. Current Neuropharmacology
11: 315-335.
Field, M., and Wymore, T. (2014). Multiscale modeling of nerve agent hydrolysis
mechanisms: a tale of two Nobel Prizes. Physica Scripta 89: 108004.
Mangas, I., Vilanova, E., Estvez, J., and Frana, T. (2017). Neurotoxic Effects Associated
with Current Uses of Organophosphorus Compounds.
Zhou, Y., Wang, S., and Zhang, Y. (2010). Catalytic Reaction Mechanism of
Acetylcholinesterase Determined by BornOppenheimer Ab Initio QM/MM Molecular
Dynamics Simulations. The Journal Of Physical Chemistry B 114: 8817-8825.
Page 7 of 7