Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Old-Greek
Extending a few insights around vowel coding in divine names end
ego-pronouns in the common theory of masking language by Grassi,
Pindarus and Georgiades.
jwr47
Joannes Richter
Contents
The denial of artwork.............................................................................................................3
The art of painting..................................................................................................................3
The iconoclasm ......................................................................................................................3
The color codes as archetypes (as an intermezzo).................................................................4
Linguistic aspects - All things are numbers............................................................................4
The masking old-Greek language (according Georgiades' theory)........................................5
A masking language...............................................................................................................5
The masking music (?)...........................................................................................................5
The masking dance.................................................................................................................5
The masks...............................................................................................................................6
The loss of unity in modern language ...................................................................................6
In modern languages the rhythm looses the fettering rules....................................................6
The time-stamp of the transition from a rigged art to independent arts.............................6
The impact of the rigidity of Old-Greek art in our vocabulary ............................................7
Eternity as a concept of vowels..............................................................................................8
The common core in Diaus, *aiwi (forever) and *aiw (law) .......................................8
The time-stamp for the transition from rigged to free arts.....................................................9
The Greek and Roman alphabets before and after the fifth century......................................9
The vowels A, I, U in the old-Persian alphabet....................................................................10
The ego-pronoun in old-Persian cuneiform .........................................................................10
The Claudian letters .............................................................................................................10
The center of IAU, IEU and IOU-cores around Chur (Switerland).....................................11
Jauer dialect..........................................................................................................................11
Provencal..............................................................................................................................11
The dialect of the city of Nmes...........................................................................................12
The pivotal era......................................................................................................................12
Homer's Ulysses as a grammar.............................................................................................13
Conclusion............................................................................................................................13
The Masking Language old-Greek
Recently I studied some of the last remains of my father's huge library and arrived at the German
Rowohlts German Encyclopedia. These books had been published between 1950 and 1960. My
father's collection never had not been complete and is composed from selected works numbered
1,2,3,4,5,6,7,9,10,11,14,15,16,17,23,24,25,26,27,31,36,39 and 43.
Printed on post-war paper these volumes are not really valuable and I didn't try to avoid making my
notes in these books. I probably would be the last readers of these items and I even thought to throw
the books away if I could not find anything interesting in these works.
In fact I had been reading some of these works like La rebelin de las masas (The Revolt of the
Masses, 1930) by Jos Ortega y Gasset (#10) and Sigmund Freud (#14) by Ludwig Marcuse,
who had advised me (and the other readers) how to become a successful within three days by
simply write down whatever came to my mind about a topic. I also found a quite interesting book
The Americans (1948) (#9) by Geoffrey Gorer.
My notes at the empty pages of these books helped me to keep my notes within reach and copied
these to computer files for easy searching.
In the end I wound up at a book #36 titled Art and Myth 1 by Ernesto Grassi (1902-1991), who
as an author and publisher he also was responsible for the complete series of the Rowohlts German
Encyclopedia. His name was found at the front page for the Encyclopedia's series. I also noticed he
referenced to other authors of the Encyclopedia, which seemed to be composed as an integral
overview of selected philosophic topics.
The iconoclasm
In the third stage the iconoclasm deprived all objects of their religious symbolism and even
destroyed most of the graspable items. In the great Church of Our Lady at Breda only a few fresco's
have been rescued from the iconoclasm. The rest of the artwork vanished in the Reformation.
1 Kunst und Mythos. Rowohlt, Hamburg 1957. 2. Auflage: Suhrkamp, Frankfurt am Main 1990. Bearbeitete
Neuausgabe, herausgegeben von Richard Blank und Emilio Hildalgo-Serna: Alexander Verlag, Berlin 2014, ISBN
978-3-89581-312-2.
These three stages seem to have been hitting all forms of artwork (poetry, painting, music):
1. iconic structures with fixed color codes and other archetypes of sacred symbolism,
2. liberation of the prescribed color codes and archetypes for sacred symbolism,
3. destruction of symbolic codes in iconoclasm and reformation.
InPoetics Aristotle does not refer to sacred movements, tones or colors but simply
refers to Art.
A masking language
For this reason Georgiades named old-Greek language a masking language, in which the words
seemed to be as rigid as a sphinx. The words seemed to be uttered from a masked speaker, whose
facial expression is hidden behind a mask. This way the language speaks for itself and cannot be
varied by the speaker. According to Grassi and Georgiades the masking cannot be considered as a
loss, but fortifies the word. The pathetic enforcement of the context and rhetoric guidance cannot be
applied as long as the word is strictly pronounced according to the rules. Additional pathetic
expressions applied by the actors will merely disturb and diminish the expression. This way the old-
Greek verses are expressing the fate or the divine Being, whose representation cannot be altered and
adapted by human interference.
4 Euryale rewards persons she does not really observe. In studying paradoxes Niklas Luhmann refers to Euryale.
[Source: Euryale (Gorgone)]
Phrynis of Mytilene and Timotheus of Miletus invented new revolutionary ways in creating music.
Up to that phase the old-Greek language had managed to preserve the rigidity of rhythm. Now the
words lost their strict rhythm, which had characterized the masked Sphinx-expression of old-Greek.
The new ways of performance allowed the actors to express subjective feelings.
Ernesto Grassi even compares this revolutionary step with Eve's eating the apple in the
Biblical scenery of paradise, in which the insight destroyed the magnificent coherence
between divinity and human life. The loss of course resulted in disorientation, confusion and
absurdity, which did lead us to chaos...
The artwork is an intermediate step between the divine, perfect and the human, imperfect phases.
The myth still could be understood by religious people. Some interpreters managed to individually
hear the Socratic dmon as an inner voice that guided them in managing life in a troubled
environment.
According to Grassi Nietzsche was the first philosopher who expressed this idea in his Origin of
Tragedy, in which at the dawn of rationalism the old-Greek world explodes in thousands of
fragments...
These words seemed to have been designed based on strict vowel combinations, which followed the
rigid rules as had been applied in the old-Greek rhythms.
The vowel combinations of the ego-pronouns ieu, iau, iou, io, iu may be identified in the divine
names Dieu, Diau(s), Diou, Dio(s), Diu6.
5 The ego-pronouns are a shorted expression for the personal pronoun of the first person singular (I in English).
6 The Derivation of European Ego-Pronouns From the PIE-Sky-God Dyaus
Eternity as a concept of vowels
Those days of rigidity also seemed to have expressed eternity by a sequence of long vowels
a'onios, which in Dutch resulted in IE (the proceeding time) and still may be found in
the words eeuwig (eternal), ieder (everybody), iets (something), iemand
(somebody), niemand (nobody), nieuws (news)... etc..7
Dutch German English
IE JE Ever
eeuwig ewig eternal
ieder jeder everybody
iets etwas something
iemand jemand somebody
niemand niemand nobody
nieuws neues news
1: IE-root for elapsed time
Of course in plain English other words carry these same rigid cores, but the efficiency of modern
language introduced deterioration and reduced most of the vowels to one simple letter, but at least
the vowel managed to carry the information in a double vowel character: , a ligature of vowels a
and e, called ash. The alternative is w. In old Norse the word is translated ever, at any time, (in
English: aye) and derived from Proto-Germanic *aiwi (forever). Cognate with Old English ,
wa, , Old Saxon eo, io, ia, Old High German eo, io.
The Greek and Roman alphabets before and after the fifth century
Greek, like Phoenician, made a distinction for vowel length. Originally - as in
Phoenician - the difference in length was not made in writing. Long [e] and [o] were
written with the digraphs and , respectively, whereas long and short [a], [i], [u]
were never distinguished in writing. 14
However, by the 6th century BC the letter eta (not needed for a consonant in eastern
dialects of Greek, which lacked [h]) came to stand for the long vowel [], and a new
letter, omega, was developed for long []15.
There were initially numerous local variants of the Greek alphabet. Athens used a local form of the
alphabet until the 5th century BC; it lacked the letters and as well as the vowel symbols and
. The classical 24-letter alphabet that became the norm later was originally the local alphabet of
Ionia; this was adopted by Athens in 403 BC under archon Eucleides and in most other parts of the
Greek-speaking world during the 4th century BC16.
Obviously the transition from a unified rigged art to free and individual arts took place around the
same time of the introduction of the long vowels H and . Before this introduction the rhythms in
language had been fixed by the rigged interval relations between syllables, which did not require
special indicators for the vowel lengths. The loss of the masking sphinx character of old-Greek
however required the introduction of special characters H and . The Greek alphabet grew from 5
(A,E,I,O,U) to 7 vowels A,E,H,I,O,U,.
1: (I)
in old-Persian
he published a book on their theory when he was still in private life, and when he
became emperor had no difficulty in bringing about their general use. These characters
may still be seen in numerous books, in the [state] registers, and in inscriptions on
public buildings.[4]19
17 Vowel
18 Oud Perzisch
19 Suetonius pass, Loeb Classical Library edition, 1913-1914, English translation is by J. C. Rolfe. Page 77, paragraph
41. (From LacusCurtius) from Wikipedia's Claudian letters
The center of IAU, IEU and IOU-cores around Chur (Switerland)
The shortest words seemed to be most ancient and most important cores in the Danish and English
vocabulary. The ego-pronouns tended to be vowels Y and I in English and in Danish and Norse
dialects. At my recent visit in Norway I discussed this theme with a number of the Norse population
and they confirmed was a quite common ego-pronoun. The short words however seem to prevail
in the harbors and along the shorelines of the seas.
In contrast the longest ego-pronouns may be found in mountainous Alpine territory, in which the
original words may survive rough conditions by hiding behind the mountains.
In Chur (reputedly the oldest town of Switzerland and located in the Grisonian Rhine Valley) at the
center of the Alpes and in the French Provence a great abundant variety of the ego-pronouns is
found.20 The variety covers jau, iu, iu, eu - sometimes accompanied by a divine name Diu or
Diu respectively Deu.
Jauer dialect
The language in the valley using jau as an ego-pronoun is named Jauer dialect and the people are
named Jauers. Jauer is usually not written; the written standard in Val Mstair is traditionally
Vallader. Jauer is occasionally written regardless, and in 2007, a collection of short stories written in
Jauer (Dschon Uein id atras istorias grischunas) was published[5]
As with other Romansh speakers, virtually all speakers of Jauer with the exception of
children below school-age are also proficient in both Swiss German and Swiss Standard
German. Additionally, many people in Val Mstair also speak Bavarian German as a second
language due to contacts with neighboring South Tyrol[7]
Of course I studied the possibility of iau as a core of Dyaus, the PIE-sky-god.
Provencal
In March 2017 I concentrated on the conjugation of the verbs for which I had discovered a fine
database full of circa 90 verbs. It turned out to an archaeological treasury of iu-suffices in the
conditional and imperfect conjugations. Some of the iu-suffices even spread into the present
conjugations. The lists clearly revealed the immense power of the ego-pronoun, which may
eventually dominate all other words including the divine names.
Morris Swadesh intuitively seemed to have been right in placing the ego-pronoun on the first
position of the most important words in all languages, although he may have suppressed the sky-
god's Name Dyaus, who also provides us with a genuine iu-core21.
Indeed Provencal does contain some strong correlations between the ego-pronoun (iu), the divine
name (Diu), the iu-conjugations of verbs:
diu (I say),
siu (I am),
viu (I see)
and some fundamental words such as
fiu (son),
viu (alive),
siucle (century).
Conclusion
As a summary this paper concentrates on the vowel triad I,A,U and the extended versions I,A,E,O,
U respectively A,E,H,I,O,U,, which originally up to the Greek Axial Age (the pivotal age around
500 BCE) as I,A,U may have been a common core for divine names, ego-pronouns, various
important words (for eternity, law, contracts, vows and matrimony) and conjugations.
From Greece some of these vowel cores jau, iu and iu may have emigrated by sailing to Massalia
and surviving linguistic deterioration in the Alpine regions of the Chur region in Switzerland and
the French Provence.