Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
os
Rodosto Primary Sources: March through Anatolia
ari
Al
ng
Sa
Western
Nicomedia
Albert 3.1-30
Civetot William 3.16-18
Caffaro
Canso lys
Bu Ha
Ekkehard 14
Nicaea
s
Cyzicus Fulcher 1.13
nicu Bartolf 9
G ra
Prusa Sank Malmesbury 4.358
Abydos arya
Ankyra William 3.16-18
Danishmendids
s
acu
Elkhan Gesta 2/10b-c =22-24
nd
(Danishmend
Baldric 2.4b=34-35 Ghazi)
y
Rh
Bozuyuk
Qi Orderic{1085?-1104}
9.8h-m=65-71
Dorylaeum Guibert 3.13a=69
Peter 4.2=38-39
Robert 3.18-19, 24-29
Gilo 4.346-398
Nacolia
Letters 2 (EH6), 3 (EH7), 4 (EH9), 5 (HE 10),
8 (HE 16), 9 (HE 18)
Pergamum Ralph 33
os Amorium
Mytilene kira
y
Kaik
Rum Seljuqs Raymond 5c=28-29 Caesarea
Ba William 3.16-18 Kizil
(Qilich Arslan) irma
k
Chaka II Ge
d iz
{1092-1107} Eastern Christian
Anna 10.3b-c
Hermus
Mathew 2.113=166-167
Philomelium Michael 15.7c=618
Chios Smyrna Bar Hebraeus
Antioch Syriac
Philadelphia
t ros
s
Ka
y Muslim
nd eres AHC
Me
s
Studies
ru
k
K Apamea Iconium Ibn al-Athir
Sa
Asbridge 138-139 Ephesus Buyuk Ibn al-Qalanisi {a490}
France 185-189 Meander Kamal al-Din
Frankopan 149-150 Laodicea Maqrizi {a490} 3:20 Cilician Gates
Tangipernes Armenian
han
Rubenstein 133-135 Sibt {a490} 7:300
Sey
Runciman 187-190 Principalities
Heraclea
Smail
Philippopolis
Varna
Central Anatolian Steppe = Turkish Nomadic Zone 1097
Ardas a
Preslav Sinope Kur
Adrianople
Constantinople
Rodosto Trebizond
is
Nicomedia ps
ios
am
gar
Civetot Iris Ac
Neocaesarea
San
Yesil h Aras
us Amasya irma Coru
ni
c Cyzicus Nicaea k
Sebenkarahisar
a Theodosopolis
Abydos Gr Tokat Teleboas
Sank
dacus
arya
u)
Erzincan
S
Sebastea Centrala Su Anatolian Steppe
at
)
ur
Rhyn
Ankyra (K ar
Divrigi
(M
-Highland plateau
Dorylaeum -semi-arid grassland
ak
-unsuited for medieval agriculture
Pergamum Amorium rm technology nias Akhlat
Ha li s a
iz lys K izi Ar
d -perfect pasture for horse nomads
He Ge
rm
us Philomelium Melitene
-land settled by Turkish nomads
Smyrna
Comana
Antioch Caesarea
k
yu
Meander Iconium
Bu
han
Coxon Diyarbakir
n
Sey
Laodicea y ha
Ti
Cilician Gates Ce
g
ris
Heraclea Marash
s
Saru
Adana mus
ra Edessa
Py
Attalia
Goksu Cal Tarsis Belen Pass
Mosul
Rhodes yca
dnu
s Antioch
Seleucia Euphr
St Simeon Aleppo ates
Zab
ater
Raqqa
Gre
Latakia Rahba
Nicosia
Hama
Paphos Homs
Tripoli
Philippopolis
Varna
Turkish nomadic states and the steppe 1097
Ardas a
Preslav Sinope Kur
Adrianople
Constantinople
Rodosto Trebizond
is
Nicomedia ps
ios
am
gar
Civetot Iris Ac
Neocaesarea
San
Yesil h Aras
us Rum Seljuqs Amasya irma Coru
ni
c Cyzicus Nicaea k
Sebenkarahisar
a Theodosopolis
Abydos Gr Teleboas
Sank (Qilich Arslan) Tokat
Danishmendids
dacus
arya
u)
Erzincan
{1092-1107}
S
(Danishmend Ghazi) Sebastea Centrala Su Anatolian Steppe
at
)
ur
Rhyn
Ankyra (K ar
Divrigi
(M
-steppe divided between the two
Dorylaeum {1085?-1104} Turkish nomadic states, Rum Seljuqs
ak
and Danishmendids
Pergamum Amorium rm -With nomadic as
nimilitary power base, Akhlat
Ha li s a
iz lys K izi Ar
d Turkic warlords can dominate the
He Ge
rm
us Philomelium Melitenesurrounding cities.
Smyrna -some are sacked and devastated
Comana
Antioch Caesarea -some pay tribute
-some have garrisons occupying the
k
yu
han
Coxon Diyarbakir
n
Sey
Laodicea y ha
Ti
Cilician Gates Ce
g
ris
Heraclea Marash
s
Saru
Adana mus
ra Edessa
Py
Attalia
Goksu Cal Tarsis Belen Pass
Mosul
Rhodes yca
dnu
s Antioch
Seleucia Euphr
St Simeon Aleppo ates
Zab
ater
Raqqa
Gre
Latakia Rahba
Nicosia
Hama
Paphos Homs
Tripoli
Philippopolis
Varna
Central Anatolian
Anatolian Steppe
Population
= Turkish
Distribution
Nomadic Zone 1097
Ardas a
Preslav Sinope Kur
Adrianople
Constantinople
Rodosto Trebizond
is
Nicomedia ps
ios
am
gar
Civetot Iris Ac
Neocaesarea
San
Yesil h Aras
us Amasya irma Coru
ni
c Cyzicus Nicaea k
Sebenkarahisar
a Theodosopolis
Abydos Gr Tokat Teleboas
Sank
dacus
arya
u)
Erzincan
S
Sebastea Population distribution
at
)
a Su
ur
Rhyn
Ankyra K ar
Divrigi(
(M
-Byzantine agrarian population
Dorylaeum centered in the west and southern
ak
coasts and river valleys
Pergamum Amorium rm -Turks change ias military balance of
nthe Akhlat
Ha li s a
iz lys K izi Ar
d power by using the steppe as
He Ge
rm
us Philomelium Melitenefoundation for military power rather
Smyrna than the agrarian lands
Comana
Antioch Caesarea
k
yu
Meander Iconium
Bu
han
Coxon Diyarbakir
n
Sey
Laodicea y ha
Ti
Cilician Gates Ce
g
ris
Heraclea Marash
s
Saru
Adana mus
ra Edessa
Py
Attalia
Goksu Cal Tarsis Belen Pass
Mosul
Rhodes yca
dnu
s Antioch
Seleucia Euphr
St Simeon Aleppo ates
Zab
ater
Raqqa
Gre
Latakia Rahba
Nicosia
Hama
Paphos Homs
Tripoli
Philippopolis
Varna
Central Anatolian
Byzantine
SteppeReconquests
= Turkish Nomadic Zone 1097-1105
1097
Ardas a
Preslav Sinope Kur
Adrianople
Constantinople
Rodosto Trebizond
is
Nicomedia ps
ios
am
gar
Civetot Iris Ac
Neocaesarea
San
Yesil h Aras
us Amasya irma Coru
ni
c Cyzicus Nicaea k
Sebenkarahisar
a Theodosopolis
Abydos Gr Tokat Teleboas
Sank
dacus
arya
u)
Erzincan
S
Sebastea Byzantine Reconquests
at
)
a Su
ur
Rhyn
Ankyra K ar
Divrigi(
(M
-From the Byzantine perspective,
Dorylaeum reconquest of the highly populated
ak
agrarian lands was the primary
Pergamum Amorium rm strategic goal nias Akhlat
Ha li s a
lys izi Ar
diz K
-the Byzantines never reconquered
He Ge
rm
us Philomelium Melitenecentral Anatolia or the steppe
Smyrna -steppe based military states continued
Comana
Antioch Caesarea to exist in Anatolia for the next 500
years (Seljuqs, Mongols, Beyliks,
k
yu
han
Coxon Diyarbakir
n
Sey
Laodicea y ha
Ti
Cilician Gates Ce
g
ris
Heraclea Marash
s
Saru
Adana mus
ra Edessa
Py
Attalia
Goksu Cal Tarsis Belen Pass
Mosul
Rhodes yca
dnu
s Antioch
Seleucia Euphr
St Simeon Aleppo ates
Zab
ater
Raqqa
Gre
Latakia Rahba
Nicosia
Hama
Paphos Homs
Tripoli
Philippopolis
Varna
Central Anatolian SteppeCrusader March 1097
Ardas a
Preslav Sinope Kur
Adrianople
Constantinople
Rodosto Trebizond
1a- March to Heraclaea is
Nicomedia ps
ios
Narrative is brief, vague and am
gar
Civetot Iris Ac
anecdotal. Neocaesarea
San
Yesil h Aras
us Amasya irma Coru
ni
c Cyzicus Nicaea k
Sebenkarahisar
a Theodosopolis
Abydos Gr Tokat Teleboas
Sank 1
dacus
arya
u)
Erzincan
S
Sebastea
at
)
a Su
ur
Rhyn
Ankyra Divrigi(Kar
(M
Dorylaeum
Amorium ak
Pergamum Ha li rm
s anias Akhlat
iz lys K izi Ar
d
He Ge
rm
us Philomelium Melitene
Smyrna
Comana
Antioch Caesarea
k
yu
Meander Iconium
Bu
han
Coxon Diyarbakir
1 n
Sey
Laodicea y ha
Ti
Cilician Gates Ce
g
ris
Heraclea Marash
1b- Crusader March
s
Saru
1- Route chosen by Byzantine Adana mus
ra Edessa
Py
strategic advisor Tatikios
2- BypassesAttalia
the steppe
3- Avoids core zone of Turkish Goksu Cal Tarsis Belen Pass
Mosul
Rhodes yca
nomadic military power dnu
s Antioch
4- marches through land better for
supplying crusader army Seleucia St Simeon
Euphr
ates
Aleppo
Zab
5- Nomads can still harass the crusader
ater
Raqqa
from the steppe homeland
Gre
Latakia Rahba
Nicosia
Hama
Paphos Homs
Tripoli
0 25 50 k
Summary of the Crusader March to Heraclaea 1097/07-08
Constantinople
os
Rodosto {06/26 - /08/05}
ari
Al March of the crusaders through
ng
Sa
Anatolia, July through August
Nicomedia
Civetot
lys
Bu Ha
Nicaea 1- {07/02-04}
Cyzicus
ic us Crusaders camp in the
n
ra
G plains of Dorylaeum
Prusa S anka
Abydos rya
Ankyra Danishmendids
s
Numbers in the Crusader Army 1
acu
Elkhan 2- {07/04} Crusaders
nd
700,000 [Malmesbury 4.357d]
(Danishmend Ghazi)
y
leave Dorylaeum
Rh
500,000 [Mathew 2.113b=166] Bozuyuk
2
100,000 knights (=500,000-600,000 {1085?-1104}
Dorylaeum
total) [Letter 2 (Symeon) (HE 6)]
exaggerated x10
Nacolia
Pergamum
os Amorium
Mytilene
Ethnic
ir
ay
KaikDiversity of the Crusaders
Rum Seljuqs Caesarea
Ba [Fulcher 1.13.4]
k
Kizil
And whoever heard of such a mixture of (Qilich Arslan) irma
k
languages in one army? There were present
Franks, Chaka II Frisians, Gauls, G
Flemings, e d iz {1092-1107}
Hermus
Allobroges, Lotharingians, Alemanni,
Bavarians, Normans, English, Scots, Philomelium
Chios Smyrna Aquitanians, Italians, Dacians, Apulians,
Iberians, Bretons, Greeks, and Armenians.
Antioch
If any Briton or Teutons wished to question
Philadelphia
t ro 3
me I could neither areply ys nor understand.But
es
K 3- {07/31} Crusaders arrive
though ewe nderwere of different tongues we
at Antioch-in-Pisidia
s
M
ru
k
seemed,
K
however, to be brothers in the love Apamea Iconium
Sa
of God and to be of nearly oneBumind.
yuk 5- {09/01} Crusaders
Ephesus 4
Meander at Heraclaea
Laodicea Cilician Gates
4- {08/15} Crusaders
Tangipernes Armenian
han
at Iconium 5
Sey
Principalities
Heraclea
0 25 50 k
3a- Desolation of Anatolia Desolation of Anatolia 1097/07
1- Natural semi-arid steppe country in
Constantinople
highland Anatolia
os
Rodosto
ari
2- Negative impact of past Byzantine landAl
ng
Sa
policy, undermining free landholders
3- Turkish invasions = death and Nicomedia
enslavement of farmers Civetot
4- Refugees flee their farms from Turkish
conquest = safer in cities, or outside Danishmendids Ha
lys
Turkish domain Bu
5- Turks turn farm land into pasture
Cyzicus Nicaea (Danishmend Ghazi)
s
6-nicHigh
a
u summer = hot, dry, limited water 2a- Qilich Arslans army {1085?-1104}
2b- [Fulcher 1.12.6]
r
G7- comparing fertility levels and
Prusa Sank withdraws into the Anatolian The Turks, fleeing before
Abydos agricultural conditions of Europe to arya
steppe. Some Turks shadow and Ankyra us in confusion, sought
s
acu
Middle East harass the crusader army; others
Elkhan hiding places for
nd
precede it, practicing scorched
y
themselves throughout
Rh
Bozuyuk
3b- [Fulcher 1.13.1] We found Qi earth policy. Romania.
Romania, a land which is excellent and Dorylaeum
very fertile in products of all kinds, 2
terribly wasted and depopulated by the
Turks. [= Scorched earth policy]
Nacolia
[Fulcher 1.13.2] Often, however, you
could see many people much revived from 1- {07/04-/07/late} 1
Pergamum 3
the products
os of the scattered farms Crusaders march towards Amorium
Mytilene kirwhich
ay
Kaik
we found from time to time Antioch in Pisidia Rum Seljuqs Caesarea
Ba throughout the country. Kizil
(Qilich Arslan) irma
k
s
so that they would cease to pursue k Mthem in the possibility that the Christians, exhausted
ru
Apamea
Iconium
Sa
K
for want of provisions. It was a clever by lack of food,Bumight
yuk hurry across their
Ephesus
tactic, because it helped them greatly country. This hope did not deceive them, for the
Meander
and damaged our whole army. For our pilgrims fled from the sterileLaodicea
country which Cilician Gates
men found this land to be empty of afforded them no food and marched forward
Tangipernes Armenian
han
water and provisions alike. with all possible haste.
Sey
Principalities
Heraclea
1- {07/mid} Crusaders Army Splits for Logistics 1097/07/15-31
advance from Dorylaeum
1
Iconium
Two Antiochs
Antioch on the Orantes 3- [Albert 3.1b]
Antioch in Psidia [The crusaders passed through]
+16 cities in the USA valleys called the Malabrunzas
where because of difficulties of
the terrain and of narrow
passes between the rocks, they
shortened their journey during
the day for the sake of the
countless multitude narrow
chasms [Albert 3.3a]
3
March to Iconium 1097/08/01-15
1a- Anatolian Steppe = region
3a- Crusader Attrition of pasture for Turkmens herds. Qi
[Gesta 4/10e=23; + Albert 3.1]
1b- Qilich Arslans Strategy
We therefore pursued them through a land
1- Dont fight the crusaders in pitched battle
which was deserted, waterless and
2- Scorched earth
uninhabitable, from which we barely
3- harassment
emerged or escaped alive, for we suffered
4- Let the crusaders take cities = steppe is strategically
greatly from hunger and thirst, and found
3 crucial to Turkish armies
nothing at all to eat except prickly plants Philomelium
5- Realization that the crusaders are passing through
which we gathered and rubbed between our
Anatolia, not attempting permanent conquest.
hands. On such food we survived wretchedly 1 6- Retake the cities when the crusader army has moved on.
enough, but we lost most of our horses, so Ta 7- Iconium and Heraclaea are both in Turkish hands during
that many of our knights had to go on as
the Crusade of 1101.
foot-soldiers, and for lack of horses we had
to use oxen as mounts, and our great need 1
compelled us to use goats, sheep and dogs Antioch
as beasts of burden. [+Robert 18b]
4
2
Iconium Coxon
Tigris
Armenian
Amid
Principalites
han
1 Cilician Gates Samosata s
ate
Sey
n h r
Rum Seljuqs Sis Ce
y ha
Marash
E up
s
Heraclea
(Qilich Arslan)
ru
2
Sa
{1092-1107}
C aly
ca
Edessa
d Adana Aintab
2- Turkish harassmentnus m
us
[Letter 3d (Anselm) (HE7)] yra
P
We crossed through Romania and Mamistra
Tarsus Harran
Armenia without hindrance except for a
Gr
few Turks we who were preceding the eat
er
Alexandretta Zab
army met after Iconium.
Belen Pass Manbij l
Mosu a)
Gok
su
Antioch rb o g h
(Ke 1102}
h
lik
Seleucia (Yaghi-Siyan) -
Ba
Antioch
{1086-1098}
Aleppo {1095
St Simeon
Aleppo (Ridwan)
an
t es {1095-1113}
r
O Euphr
ates
Raqqa
Latakia
t ine
y zan
B
0 25 50 k
Battle of Heraclaea Te
le
bo
1097/09/01
H as
aly
s Danishmendids Mengujekids Saltuqids
(Saltuq)
(Danishmend Ghazi) (Mengujek)
{1090?-1102}
{1090?-1118} Su )
{1085?-1104} Arsa
nias
(M
urat
ak
Danishmend
i lirm
Turkish Tactics Kiz
At thisCaesarea
point, according to Anna, the Turkish warlord
The Turks attempt an ambush at Heraclaea. When it Danishmend (whom she calls Tanisman), realizing
fails they break off the battle and returned to scorched that the crusaders are nearing his own territory, sends a
earth and harassment tactics. Again no attempt is Da contingent to join with Qilich Arslans Turks to ambush Melitene
made to hold cities, which are are of secondary
Philomelium the crusaders at Heraclaea.
importance to a Turkish steppe nomad army.
1 Plastenzia
Elbistan
Qi
Iconium Coxon
Tigris
Amid
Armenian
Principalites
han
Cilician Gates Samosata s
ate
Sey
Note on Anna n h r
Rum Seljuqs
3 Annas account
Sis
y ha
here is garbledCe in timeMarash
and place. The E up
s
Heraclea
(Qilich Arslan)
ru
Sa
battle at Heraclaea. (Anna calls it Hebraica an
{1092-1107}
3a- {09/01} Battle of Heraclaea
C
3b- {09/01} Battle of Heraclaea (?) otherwise unknown location.)
[Gesta 4/10f=24 +Robert 3.19c]
aly
ca [Anna 11.3d] Edessa
Heraclea, in which a large Turkish dn Adana Aintab
us As they travelled onwards, drawn up in troops, the SultanmuTanisman
s [Danishmend] and
garrison was waiting in ambush to Asan [Qilich Arslan], who alone commanded eighty thousand yra armed men, met them near
P
attack the Christian knights. Our Hebraica [= Heraclaea?]. A fierce contest ensued asMamistra
there were such numbers of troops, Harran
knights, trusting in Almighty God, Tarsus
and neither side would yield to the other; when Bohemund who commanded the right
Gr
found these Turks and attacked them wing saw with what courage the Turks were fighting their opponents he withdrew from the eat
er
Alexandretta Zab
boldly, so on that day our enemies rest of the army and made a headlong descent upon Clitziasthlan [Qilich Arslan],
were defeated and fled the Turks that it made them turn their backs.Belen Pass Manbij l
Mosu a)
This soGoterrified
ksu Remembering the
Emperor's advice, they did not pursue them far, but reached the Antioch
Turks' lines and, after
rb o g h
(Ke 1102}
h
lik
resting there a little, After that the barbarian power collapsed;
Seleucia the survivors dispersed,
(Yaghi-Siyan) -
Ba
one here, one there, leaving their wives and children behind them, as forAntioch
{1086-1098} the future they Aleppo {1095
did not dare meet the Latins face to face, but tried to find safety for themselves in flight. Aleppo (Ridwan)
St Simeon
an
t es {1095-1113}
r
O Euphr
ates
Raqqa
Latakia
t ine
y zan
B
0 25 50 k
Rest at Heraclaea; Comet Te
le
bo
1097/09/02-05
H as
aly
s Danishmendids Mengujekids Saltuqids
(Saltuq)
(Danishmend Ghazi) (Mengujek)
{1090?-1102}
{1090?-1118} Su )
{1085?-1104} Arsa
nias
(M
urat
ak
i lirm
Kiz
Caesarea
Melitene
Philomelium
Plastenzia
Elbistan
1a- {09/01} At Heraclaea
Iconium [Gesta 4/10f=24 +Robert 3.19c]
Coxon
Our men entered [Heraclaea] at once, Tigris
Amid
and we stayed there for four days Armenian
{/09/02-05}
Principalites
han
Cilician Gates Samosata s
ate
Sey
n h r
Rum Seljuqs Sis Ce
y ha
Marash
E up
s
Heraclea
(Qilich Arslan)
ru
Sa
1
{1092-1107}
C aly
ca 1b- Sign of the Comet Edessa
dn Adana Aintab
us [Fulcher 1.14.1] us
m
ra
When we reached the city of Herac1ea, Py
we beheld a certain sign inTarsus
the sky which Mamistra
Harran
appeared in brilliant whiteness in the Gr
eat
shape of a sword with the point toward er
Zab
Alexandretta
the East. What it portended for the
Belen Pass Manbij l
Mosu a)
Gok
future
su we did not know, but we left the
present and the future to God. Antioch rb o g h
(Ke 1102}
h
lik
Seleucia (Yaghi-Siyan) -
Ba
Antioch
{1086-1098}
Aleppo {1095
St Simeon
Aleppo (Ridwan)
an
t es {1095-1113}
r
O Euphr
ates
Raqqa
Latakia
t ine
y zan
B
Crusading Warfare
https://www.crusadingwarfare.net/
https://www.facebook.com/groups/459168451092888/
YouTube channel = Crusading Warfare