Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
PII: S0378-5122(16)30270-5
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/doi:10.1016/j.maturitas.2017.02.011
Reference: MAT 6776
Please cite this article as: Cagnacci Angelo, Palma Federica, Napolitano
Antonella, Xholli Anjeza.Association between Pelvic Organ Prolapse
and Climacteric Symptoms in Postmenopausal Women.Maturitas
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.maturitas.2017.02.011
This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication.
As a service to our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript.
The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof
before it is published in its final form. Please note that during the production process
errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that
apply to the journal pertain.
Highlights
The association between climacteric symptoms and pelvic organ prolapse was
investigated in a single-center cross-sectional study of 1382 postmenopausal
women.
The Greene Climacteric Scale was used to investigate symptoms.
A higher score on the Greene Climacteric Scale was associated with a higher
prevalence of pelvic organ prolapse.
Angelo Cagnacci MD PhD, Federica Palma MD, Antonella Napolitano MD, Anjeza Xholli
MD.
1.2 Objectives
In this study it was investigated whether in post-menopausal women a higher degree of
climacteric symptoms is associated with an increased risk of POP.
2. Methods
2.1 Study design and setting
Cross - sectional investigation of the data retrospectively extracted from an electronic
database of the menopause outpatient service of our University Hospital. The local ethics
committee and the Institutional Review Board previously approved the anonymous
extraction of the data.
All postmenopausal women who entered into the analysis had previously signed an
informed consent, allowing the anonymous use of their data for scientific purposes. Data of
each single woman were collected and entered into a computer database at the time of
their examination. Subsequently, they were anonymously retrieved for statistical analysis.
Our database included specific information on pelvic floor defects since January 2010.
Accordingly, only first consultancies, performed between January 2010 and December
2015, were considered.
2.2 Participants
Of the 2574 extracted records, 702 were discarded, because the women were in pre-or
peri-menopause (defined as irregular menstrual cycles, up to amenorrhea for less than 12
months, experience of climacteric symptoms, and FSH serum level>30 IU/ml). The other
490 records were discarded due to incomplete data. Hysterectomised women were
excluded whether their FSH values were below 40 IU/L. Accordingly final analysis was
performed on 1382 postmenopausal women (Figure 1). No significant difference was
observed between the group of included women and that of women excluded for
incomplete data.
3. Results
3.1 Participants and descriptive data
The participating women were all white. 1072 (77.5%) were in physiological menopause
(amenorrhea for at least 12 months, and FSH level >40 IU/ml), 76 (5.5.0%) in surgical
menopause (ovariectomy plus hysterectomy), and 234 (17.0%) were hysterectomized,
with ovary conservation. 465 women (33.7%) had been on MHT for at least 3 months;
either a combination of estrogen plus progestogen therapy (n=322), or estrogen alone
therapy (n=143), whether in physiological or surgical menopause respectively. 844
(61.1%) postmenopausal women did not suffer from POP, while 538 (39.9%) did (Table 1).
A descent of the bladder was present in 503 (36.4%), of the uterus in 155 (11.2%) and of
the rectum in 93 (6.7%) of the women. A combined defect was present in 121 (8.7%) of
the women.
4. Discussion
4.1 Key results
Women suffering from pelvic floor defect scored higher in the Greenes climacteric scale
score. In multiple logistic regression analysis the Greenes climacteric scale score was an
independent determinant of POP. No association was found with the degree of POP. POP
severity may change over time and its subjective quantification can increase inter-observer
variance, thus reducing the power of our analysis. Among the different POPs a higher
degree of climacteric symptoms was mainly associated with a higher risk of bladder
prolapse. The risk of uterus or rectum prolapse tended to be increased but not significantly
so. Likely, the lack of significance was due an to insufficient statistical power of our
analysis due to the smaller number of subjects suffering from rectum or uterus than
bladder prolapse.
Pregnancy or number of deliveries represented risk factors for POP, as previously
reported [3,4], particularly of bladder prolapse. Probably, this association also explains the
differences observed between women with and without POP, such as a higher prevalence
of being married, of being a housewife, of having received a lower education, of being non-
smoker and of not being on anti-hypertensives. Indeed, in the multiple logistic regression
models that contained pregnancy and number of deliveries, as independent variables, all
these other factors lost their independent association with POP. Vice-versa, and in
accordance with previous studies, POP remained associated with an advancing age,
adiposity [6], as measured by BMI, and with having performed a hysterectomy [1,2]. The
use of coffee was independently associated with a lower prevalence of POP, and in
particular of bladder prolapse. A statistical association does not mean a cause-effect
relation. However, the reported dose- and gender- related effect of caffeine on collagen
turnover [21,22] and the stimulating properties of caffeine on rat collagen [23,24] indicate
that the role played by caffeine on POP should be further explored.
4.2 Interpretation
The association between climacteric symptoms and POP can be the consequence of
common modifications induced by gonadal steroid withdrawal. Women suffering from
climacteric symptoms might be more sensible to steroid deprivation. This may explain the
reason why women having suffered from intense vasomotor or climacteric symptoms are
at higher risk of cardiovascular disease, osteoporosis and urinary incontinence. Indeed a
higher rate of collagen loss [17] is associated with climacteric symptoms, and this may
have an influence on the risk of osteoporosis [18] and pelvic floor support [12,13]. Some
evidence indicates that climacteric symptoms per se, may contribute to the determination
of postmenopausal diseases. Intense climacteric symptoms are associated with an
increased secretion of cortisol [25]. Elevated cortisol may play a role both in inducing
metabolic modifications implicated in the pathogenesis of cardiovascular diseases [26,27],
and in collagen degradation [28,29], with an implication in the pathogenesis of
osteoporosis and POP. This analysis adds to our previous report on the functional
association between climacteric symptoms and urinary incontinence [19], the clinical
evidence that climacteric symptoms are associated with POP, one of the risk factors for
urinary incontinence.
4.3 Limitations
The present investigation has several limitations. Data were retrospectively retrieved by an
electronic database. The Greenes scale offers a subjective evaluation of the bother
induced by climacteric symptoms without any objective evaluation. There was a lack of
information about family history of POP, personal history of constipation, emphysema and
of instrumental delivery, which may have implications for pelvic floor function. The strength
of the study is in the composite evaluation of climacteric symptoms, and the inclusion of a
physicians evaluation of pelvic floor defects. In order to reduce variability among
observers we limited the analysis only to the presence or absence of a defect, without
evaluating its degree. Besides the limitations, overall, the data seems to indicate that
women with POP have a higher degree of climacteric symptoms.
4.4 Generalizability
The study was made on Caucasian women of a single outpatient centre. Women were not
from general population but they were part of a selected group of women asking for a
medical consultation. Thus, prevalence of POP may be different from that obtained in the
general population, and the results cannot be generalized. In addition women were
relatively young, less than 10 years since their menopause, as a mean, and hence findings
may not be applicable to an older cohort of women.
5. Conclusions
A higher degree of climacteric symptoms is present in women with POP, as previously
reported for preclinical cardiovascular disease [30] and osteoporosis [17,18]. Whether the
endocrine and metabolic modifications associated with climacteric symptoms play any
causative role in favouring POP remains to be determined.
Contributors
All the authors significantly contributed to the study design, data collection and analysis,
discussion of the results and manuscript writing.
Conflict of interest
The authors report no conflict of interest.
Funding
This research did not receive any specific grant from funding agencies in the public,
commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.
Ethical approval
The local ethics committee and the Institutional Review Board approved the anonymous
extraction of the data.
Provenance and peer review
This article has undergone peer review.
Acknowledgments
We thank Manuela Bellafronte MD, Marianna Cannoletta MD, and Cecilia Romani MD for
patient management.
References
Peri-Menopause
N=702
Incomplete Data
N=490
ANALYSES
N=1382