Sunteți pe pagina 1din 10

Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol 2000; 16: 918.

Fetal biometry at 4300 m compared to sea level in Peru


E. KRAMPL*, C. LEES*, J. M. BLAND, J. ESPINOZA DORADO*, G. MOSCOSO and
S. CAMPBELL
*Harris Birthright Research Center for Fetal Medicine, King's College Hospital, Denmark Hill, London SE5 9RS, UK, Department of Obstetrics
and Gynaecology and Department of Public Health Sciences, St. George's Hospital Cranmer Terrace, London SW17 0RE, UK and Instituto
Materno Perinatal, Jiron Antonio Miroquesada 149, Lima, Peru

KEY WOR DS : Fetal biometry, High altitude, Hypoxia, Ultrasound

ABSTRACT INTRODUCTION
Objectives The aim of this study was to compare Babies born at high altitude are known to be smaller than
ultrasound fetal size at high altitude and sea level. those born at sea level. This was initially thought to be due
to a higher incidence of preterm delivery1, but the length of
Methods Three hundred and thirty-four women in Cerro gestation has subsequently been reported to be similar at
de Pasco at 4300 m (14 100 ft) altitude and 278 women in both high and low altitude26. Ascribing the difference in
Lima (sea level) were recruited to the study. Ultrasound birth weight simply to socio-economic differences7 has
fetal biometry was carried out between 14 and 42 weeks of been disproved by a large epidemiological study from
gestation. Biparietal diameter, occipitofrontal diameter, Colorado; altitude acts as an independent factor in
abdominal circumference and femur length were measured determining birth weight with a reduction in birth weight
and head circumference and estimated fetal weight were of 100 g per 1000 m elevation gain6.
derived from these data. Two hundred and seventy-seven The smallness of babies born at high altitude is
women (82.9%) in Cerro de Pasco and 216 (77.7%) in generally attributed to lack of oxygen. It is known that
Lima had normal singleton pregnancies and certain maternal diseases that reduce oxygen availability are also
menstrual dates. These women were selected for statistical associated with fetal growth restriction. For example,
analysis. Fractional polynomial regression analysis on mothers with cyanotic heart disease produce small
gestational age was performed, controlling for maternal children8 and respiratory disorders adversely affect fetal
height and parity. growth if maternal arterial hypoxemia is present9,10.
Results Fetal biometry measurements were significantly Animal studies have demonstrated that maternal anemia
smaller in Cerro de Pasco compared with Lima. When decreases fetal growth independently from nutritional
gestation bands were compared this effect was present factors11. It has been postulated that the lower birth
from 25 to 29 weeks onwards, and was greater in the weight in mothers who smoke is due to the lower oxygen
abdominal circumference than in the head circumference availability caused by increased levels of maternal carbon
and femur length (ratios Cerro de Pasco : Lima, 0.96, 0.97 monoxide12.
and 0.98, respectively). Estimated fetal weight was also At sea level, the mean barometric pressure (PB) is
significantly lower in Cerro de Pasco (ratio 0.88), as were 760 mmHg (101.3 kPa). Oxygen comprises 21% of the air
birthweights (ratio 0.88). If the centiles derived from the and has a partial pressure (pO2) at sea level of 160 mmHg
Lima population were applied for Cerro de Pasco, 11.2% (31.33 kPa); the partial oxygen pressure in alveoli (pO2alv)
of all estimated fetal weights would be below the fifth is roughly 100 mmHg (13.33 kPa), arterial pO2 95 mmHg
centile, and 1.08% above the ninety-fifth. (12.64 kPa) and hemoglobin oxygen saturation ranges
between 95 and 100%. At increasing altitude, PB falls,
Conclusions These data suggest that at high altitude, all pO2alv falls and the oxygen pressure difference between
fetal biometry measurements follow a lower trajectory alveoli and lung capillaries, which constitutes the driving
than at sea level. Specific biometry charts should therefore force for diffusion of gas across the alveolar membrane,
be used for obstetric ultrasound at high altitude. decreases. As a consequence, arterial pO2 decreases from

Correspondence: Elisabeth Krampl, King's College Hospital, Harris Birthright Research Center for Fetal Medicine, 9th Floor Ruskin Wing,
Denmark Hill, London SE5 9RS, UK

Received 24-11-99, Revised 23-03-00, Accepted 15-6-00

ORIGINAL ARTICLE 9
Fetal biometry at high altitude Krampl et al.

Pasco from hospital antenatal and health clinics, when they


attended for routine visits. Local physicians, midwives and
nursing students carried out the recruitment. They had
been given detailed information about the study by the
examiners and had attended the examinations. All women
were ethnic Mestizo, a mixture between native Quechua
and Spanish. Only women who were resident at the
altitude at which they were born were included in the
study.
One operator (E.K.) performed ultrasound fetal biome-
try using Aloka SSD-1700 (Aloka Co., Ltd, Tokyo, Japan)
and Toshiba Eccocee (Toshiba, Japan) Ultrasound Appa-
ratus using 3.5 and 5 MHz probes. Biometry measure-
ments were stored as thermal printed images with
individual patient records. Measurements of biparietal
diameter (BPD), occipitofrontal diameter (OFD) and
abdominal circumference (AC) were all made in the planes
described previously25, where BPD and OFD were measured
from outer to outer border of the skull in a plane
demonstrating the anterior and posterior horns of the lateral
ventricles and AC was measured using an ellipse. For the
femur length (FL) a straight measurement was taken from
Figure 1 Patient selection numbers in Cerro de Pasco and Lima. the greater trochanter to the lateral condyle in a plane at
approximately 458 to the ultrasound beam21. Head circum-
95 mmHg (12.64 kPa) at sea level to about 50 mmHg ference (HC) was calculated from 3.14  (BPD 1 OFD)/2.
(6.67 kPa) at 4000 m and hemoglobin oxygen saturation Fetal weight was estimated (EFW) according to Hadlock
from 95 to 100% to about 80%. (HC 2 BPD 2 AC 2 FL)26. The following ratios were
Although an estimated 140 million people world-wide calculated: HC/AC, HC/FL and AC/FL.
are permanent residents at altitudes greater than Healthy women referred with normal singleton preg-
2500m13, there are no data available for ultrasound nancies with a gestational age of 14 weeks or more were
fetal biometry at altitude. Ultrasound charts for fetal examined once. Patients referred with a known clinical
biometry exist for Caucasians living at sea level1421, and problem which was likely to influence fetal growth, such as
other ethnic groups22,23 and can be customized to take hypertension, diabetes or clinical suspicion of intra-uterine
factors such as fetal sex, maternal weight and height, growth restriction were not included in the study. A total
ethnic group and parity into account24. Whether low number of 612 scans was performed, 334 in Cerro de
ambient oxygen has an effect on human fetal size and the Pasco and in 278 in Lima (Figure 1). Women who were not
possible magnitude of this effect has not been investigated sure of their last menstrual period (LMP), did not
to date. remember it, who had irregular periods or stopped taking
The aim of this study was to compare ultrasound fetal the contraceptive pill less than three cycles before
size at high altitude and sea level in the second and third becoming pregnant, or where there were multiple preg-
trimesters of pregnancy in a single ethnic group. Cross- nancies and fetal malformations were excluded. When the
sectional fetal biometry scans were undertaken in two biometry measurements (282 from Cerro de Pasco and 218
populations: in Cerro de Pasco, a mining town in the from Lima) were plotted against the gestational age it was
Peruvian Andes at 4300 m (14 100 ft), and in Lima (sea evident that five cases (1.5%) from Cerro de Pasco and two
level). cases (0.7%) from Lima were extreme outliers. Their
biometry measurements (BPD, OFD, AC, FL) prior to
25 weeks differed by more than 4 weeks from the mean of
gestation. It was assumed that this was due to error in
SUBJECTS AND METHODS
maternal recall of the menstrual history and as the
The study was carried out as a collaboration between intention was to establish normal ranges for fetal biometry
academic obstetric departments in London, UK and Lima, at a given gestation these measurements were excluded
Peru. The ethics committee of the Peruvian Ministry of from the analysis (Figure 2). Statistical analysis was
Health, and the IPSS (Instituto Peruano de Seguro Social) performed on the measurements of the remaining 493
hospital manager of the Pasco district gave ethical women (277 from Cerro de Pasco and 216 from Lima)
approval. All subjects gave informed written consent for (Figure 1).
ultrasound examination having read an information sheet In the first 2 weeks of the study, pO2 and pCO2 were
in Spanish. In addition, a local research nurse verbally measured in all patients with a portable blood gas analyzer
explained the purpose of the study. (OPTI 1, AVL, Graz, Austria) using solid-state single use
Subjects were recruited both in Lima and in Cerro de optical fluorescence cassettes. Full 1point gas calibration

10 Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology


Fetal biometry at high altitude Krampl et al.

each town our estimates are rather more precise than this.
Gestational age was adjusted by using the fractional
polynomial method of Royston and Altman30. This allows
a complex curve to be fitted using a small number of
parameters, enabling the effect of gestational age to be
removed more efficiently than could be done using a simple
polynomial. The variability of each biometric measure-
ment clearly increased as the gestation advanced. The
standard deviation appeared to increase with increasing
mean measurement. To make the variability independent
of the magnitude and hence suitable for regression
analysis, the data were log-transformed. Biometric vari-
ables were regressed on gestational age, altitude (Lima 0,
Cerro de Pasco 1), parity and maternal height. These
Figure 2 Head circumference measurements in Cerro de Pasco and variables were specified in advance, no stepwise procedure
Lima. A total of 502 measurements, 218 from Lima and 284 from
was used. The coefficient of altitude estimated the
Cerro de Pasco and from women with normal singleton pregnancies
with reliable menstrual history are plotted by gestational age derived difference between Cerro de Pasco and Lima. Anti-log
from the date of last menstrual period (LMP). Triangles denote five transformation of this coefficient yielded the Cerro de
patients from Cerro de Pasco and two patients from Lima who were Pasco/Lima ratio. This adjusted ratio is the estimate of the
excluded from analysis because of maternal error in recall of the size of a fetus in Cerro de Pasco divided by the size of the
LMP.
fetus in Lima as if they were of the same gestational age
and maternal height. The regression method provided a
confidence interval for this ratio and a test of the null
for pO2 and pCO2 was carried out automatically after
hypothesis that the population ratio equaled 1.
insertion of each cassette. Stable standard reference
The residuals (the difference between the observed
cassettes were used for verification of low, medium and
biometric measurement and that predicted by the regres-
high levels. Arterialized capillary samples were taken from
sion equation) were calculated. The mean of the absolute
the earlobe. Samples obtained by this method have been
value of the residual, irrespective of sign, can be used to
shown to have blood gas contents similar to arterial
estimate the standard deviation provided the underlying
samples27. Maternal hematocrit was determined by the
distribution is normal31. The absolute residuals were then
microcapillary method28.
regressed on gestational age, again using the fractional
polynomial method. The mean of the half-normal dis-
p
tribution is 2 over p. Multiplying the predicted absolute
Statistical analysis p
residual by p over 2 thus gives the standard deviation at
Statistical analysis was performed on the measurements of this gestation. The mean and standard deviation were used
the remaining 493 women (277 from Cerro de Pasco and to calculate centiles using the normal distribution.
216 from Lima). The planned sample size was 200 in each Interaction between the population and gestational age
town. The standard error of the sample size can be was calculated by adding a gestational age  group term
established using the method of Altman and Chitty29. For a to the regression model. Interaction would occur if the
sample size of 200 the width of the 95% confidence relative difference between the Cerro de Pasco and Lima
interval for the tenth and ninetieth centiles would populations were not the same at each gestational age. An
be ^ 0.19 standard deviations. As we exceeded 200 in altitude effect threshold model was also developed. A series

Figure 3 Normal distribution of the abdominal circumference (AC) measurements corrected for altitude: (a), frequency distribution of the resi-
duals; (b), residuals plotted against gestational age (weeks).

Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology 11


Fetal biometry at high altitude Krampl et al.

Figure 4 Fiftieth, fifth and ninety-fifth centile for biparietal diameter Figure 5 Fiftieth, fifth and ninety-fifth centile for head circumfer-
(BPD), derived from 493 measured fetuses, 216 from Lima and 277 ence (HC), derived from 493 measured fetuses, 216 from Lima and
from Cerro de Pasco. 277 from Cerro de Pasco.

of variables was defined, each of which was always zero repeated measurements taken in Cerro de Pasco using the
for fetuses from Cerro de Pasco. For fetuses from Lima, the intra-class correlation coefficient32. This is the correlation
variable was zero unless the gestational age was within a between repeated measurements ignoring the ordering of the
certain range, usually of 5 weeks (1519, 2024, 2529. pair. All intra-class correlations were between 0.982 and
3034, 3540). Regression analysis with these variables as 0.997.
predictors was then performed. This allowed different The t-test was used to compare maternal characteristics
slopes to be estimated for each interval of gestational age. between Cerro de Pasco and Lima, except for parity (Mann
If there were a threshold effect, these variables would only Whitney U-test) and the level of education (x2 test).
affect biometry at later gestational ages. Analyses were performed using Stata 5.0 (Stata Cor-
Figure 3 shows the distribution of the residual abdom- poration, TX, USA) and SPSS 8.0 (SPSS Science, Chicago,
inal circumference after log transformation and fitting IL, USA).
gestational age and town effects. The variability appears
uniform throughout the range of gestational age and the
R ES U LT S
shape of the distribution is symmetrical, fitting the normal
quite closely. Similar results were found for all the Table 1 shows that maternal age and pre pregnancy weight
biometry measurements. Normal regression methods can were similar in Cerro de Pasco and Lima. Height was
therefore be used on the log-transformed data. The however, significantly less in Cerro de Pasco compared
abdominal circumference was chosen for graphical illus- with Lima (149.9 ^ 5.3 cm versus 152.8 ^ 6.0 cm,
tration because pathological growth restriction affects the P , 0.001) and parity significantly higher (1.21 ^ 1.6
abdominal circumference more than other biometry and versus 0.64 ^ 1.1). Maternal levels of pO2 and pCO2 were
would therefore skew the distribution the most. significantly lower in Cerro de Pasco than in Lima
The reliability of measurements was assessed on 62 sets of (52.8 ^ 3.5 mmHg versus 101.6 ^ 14 mmHg, P , 0.001

Figure 6 Fiftieth, fifth and ninety-fifth centile for abdominal circum- Figure 7 Fiftieth, fifth and ninety-fifth centile for femur length (FL),
ference (AC), derived from 493 measured fetuses, 216 from Lima derived from 493 measured fetuses, 216 from Lima and 277 from
and 277 from Cerro de Pasco. Cerro de Pasco.

12 Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology


Fetal biometry at high altitude Krampl et al.

Figure 8 Fiftieth, fifth and ninety-fifth centile for estimated fetal Figure 9 Fiftieth, fifth and ninety-fifth centile for ratio of head cir-
weight (EFW), derived from 493 measured fetuses, 216 from Lima cumference to abdominal circumference (HC/AC), derived from 493
and 277 from Cerro de Pasco. measured fetuses, 216 from Lima and 277 from Cerro de Pasco.

and 25.5 ^ 2.4 mmHg versus 38.0 ^ 12.3 mmHg,


DISCUSSION
P , 0.001, respectively). Maternal hematocrit was sig-
nificantly higher (43.9 ^ 8.1% versus 36.5 ^ 3.5% We present the first comparative ultrasound biometry data
P , 0.001) (Table 1). The socio-economic status as for high altitude and sea level. All fetal measurements
assessed by the level of school education was similar in proved to be smaller in Cerro de Pasco than in Lima. When
both populations. In Cerro de Pasco 211 women (76.2%) gestation bands were compared this effect was present
had completed secondary school, in Lima the number was from 25 to 29 weeks onwards. These charts are likely to
170 (78.7%). reflect fetal growth in utero accurately as the ratio Cerro de
Fetal biometric measurements (BPD, OFD, HC, AC and Pasco/Lima between the EFW and the actual birth weights
FL) from Cerro de Pasco were compared with Lima by was very similar. Furthermore, all ultrasound measure-
regression analysis controlling for gestational age, mater- ments showed a very high degree of reliability as measured
nal height and parity (Tables 29), (Figures 47). There by intraclass correlation. The reference ranges are reliable
was a statistically significant difference between Cerro de because the sample size was adequate, the measurements
Pasco and Lima. The ratios Cerro de Pasco/Lima for the were performed in ethnically similar groups with similar
five variables were 0.98, 0.97, 0.97, 0.96, 0.98, respec- socio-economic status and appropriate adjustments were
tively (Table 10). The EFW was also significantly lower in made for important predictors of birth weight such as
Cerro de Pasco [ratio 0.88, 95% confidence interval (CI) maternal height and parity. We therefore interpret the
0.840.91)] (Figure 8). Birth weights were available from difference in fetal size between Cerro de Pasco and Lima as
360 live births at term, 213 (76.9%) from Cerro de Pasco being due to altitude.
and 147 (68.1%) from Lima. The mean uncorrected A major difference between the studied population and
birthweights were 2944 g and 3351 g, respectively, the Europeans33 was that it is highly unusual for pregnant
ratio Cerro de Pasco/Lima being 0.88 (95% CI 0.850.90). women in Peru to smoke; there were no smokers among
The ratio HC/AC was significantly larger in Cerro de the women examined. Another interesting difference was
Pasco than in Lima (ratio 1.01, P 0.003) (Figure 9), the the high recall of LMP in this population both in Lima and
ratio AC/FL was significantly smaller (ratio 0.98, in Cerro de Pasco. Around 80% were sure of their LMP,
P 0.01), but the ratio HC/FL was similar. These effects compared with 55% of the population scanned routinely at
did not change with gestation (Table 10). a London teaching hospital34. This may partly reflect the
There was significant interaction between group and lower incidence of oral contraceptive use, but may also be
gestational age with respect to the BPD, OFD, HC, AC and related to the higher motivation of women volunteering to
FL measurements (P-values 0.002, 0.006, 0.02, , 0.001 take part in a research study. The level of education was
and 0.005, respectively). The threshold model showed that high in both populations, even higher in Cerro de Pasco;
the difference becomes apparent from the gestational age the charts shown may arguably be biased against those at
interval 2529 weeks onwards (Table 11). the lowest end of the socio-economic spectrum.
If the centiles derived from Lima are applied to the Cerro It has also become evident that the AC is disproportio-
de Pasco population, 11.2% of EFWs over all gestation nately smaller than HC and FL. This phenomenon has
ranges are below the fifth centile, and 1.08% above the been shown previously in animal studies: pregnant rabbits
ninety-fifth. The effect is more pronounced from 35 weeks placed in a hypobaric chamber to simulate an altitude of
of gestation onwards with 21% of the EFWs at Cerro de 12 000 ft (3650 m) have smaller offspring and the size of
Pasco being below the Lima fifth centile and none above their organs is consistent with asymmetrical growth
the ninety-fifth (Table 12). restriction; the brain weight was similar, whereas the
The regression equations are summarized in Table 13. weight of the liver was significantly smaller in those

Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology 13


Fetal biometry at high altitude Krampl et al.

Table 1 Maternal clinical data; *n 67 in Cerro de Pasco, n 40 Table 3 Reference table for biparietal diameter in Cerro de Pasco
in Lima
GA (weeks) 5th centile Mean 95th centile
Cerro de Pasco Lima
Mean (SD) Mean (SD) P-value 14 22.9 26.4 29.8
15 25.9 29.9 33.9
n (analyzed) 277 216 16 29.0 33.5 38.0
Age 27.4 (5.9) 26.3 (6.9) NS 17 32.2 37.0 41.9
Parity 1.2 (1.5) 0.6 (1.1) , 0.001 18 35.4 40.6 45.7
Weight (kg) 54.2 (6.9) 55.8 (8.7) NS 19 38.6 44.0 49.5
Height (cm) 149.9 (5.3) 152.8 (6.0) , 0.001 20 41.8 47.5 53.1
pO2 (mmHg)* 52.8 (3.5) 101.6 (14.0) , 0.001 21 45.0 50.8 56.7
pCO2 (mmHg)* 25.5 (2.4) 38.0 (12.3) , 0.001 22 48.1 54.1 60.1
Hematocrit * 43.9 (8.1) 36.5 (3.5) , 0.001 23 51.1 57.3 63.5
24 54.1 60.4 66.7
25 56.9 63.4 69.8
26 59.6 66.2 72.8
rabbit offspring that developed under hypobaric condi- 27 62.3 69.0 75.6
tions35. 28 64.8 71.6 78.3
29 67.1 74.0 80.9
We assessed maternal blood gas levels in a subgroup of
30 69.3 76.3 83.3
women participating in this study. Maternal pO2 in Cerro 31 71.4 78.4 85.5
de Pasco was only 51% of that in Lima. The levels of 32 73.2 80.4 87.5
maternal pCO2 in Cerro de Pasco are 66% of those in 33 74.9 82.2 89.4
Lima suggesting that this relative hypocapnia can be 34 76.5 83.8 91.0
35 77.8 85.2 92.5
explained by a compensatory increase in maternal
36 78.9 86.4 93.8
ventilation. This is known to occur in non-pregnant 37 79.8 87.4 94.9
humans36. Furthermore, hypoxia is known to induce the 38 80.6 88.1 95.7
erythropoietin gene37 and increase hematocrit38; our data 39 81.0 88.7 96.4
for maternal hematocrit confirm this effect. These 40 81.3 89.0 96.8
compensatory mechanisms in the mother do not seem to GA, gestational age.
be sufficient to maintain oxygen availability for the feto-
placental unit. At altitude the placenta is larger and there

Table 2 Reference table for biparietal diameter in Lima Table 4 Reference table for head circumference in Lima

GA (weeks) 5th centile Mean 95th centile GA (weeks) 5th centile Mean 95th centile

14 22.4 24.9 27.3 14 75.0 87.6 100.2


15 25.3 28.7 32.0 15 87.5 101.7 115.8
16 28.4 32.5 36.6 16 100.2 115.7 131.2
17 31.6 36.3 41.1 17 112.9 129.7 146.5
18 34.8 40.1 45.4 18 125.6 143.5 161.4
19 38.1 43.8 49.6 19 138.3 157.2 176.1
20 41.4 47.5 53.6 20 150.9 170.6 190.4
21 44.7 51.1 57.5 21 163.3 183.8 204.3
22 48.0 54.6 61.3 22 175.5 196.6 217.7
23 51.2 58.1 64.9 23 187.4 209.0 230.7
24 54.4 61.4 68.4 24 199.0 221.1 243.2
25 57.5 64.6 71.6 25 210.2 232.6 255.1
26 60.5 67.6 74.7 26 221.0 243.7 266.4
27 63.4 70.5 77.7 27 231.4 254.2 277.1
28 66.2 73.3 80.4 28 241.3 264.2 287.1
29 68.9 75.9 82.9 29 250.7 273.6 296.5
30 71.5 78.4 85.3 30 259.5 282.3 305.1
31 73.9 80.6 87.4 31 267.8 290.4 313.0
32 76.1 82.7 89.3 32 275.4 297.8 320.1
33 78.2 84.6 91.0 33 282.3 304.4 326.4
34 80.1 86.3 92.4 34 288.6 310.3 331.9
35 81.8 87.7 93.7 35 294.2 315.4 336.6
36 83.4 89.0 94.7 36 299.0 319.6 340.3
37 84.7 90.0 95.4 37 303.0 323.1 343.2
38 85.8 90.9 95.9 38 306.2 325.6 345.1
39 86.7 91.4 96.1 39 308.6 327.3 346.0
40 87.4 91.7 96.1 40 310.1 328.1 346.0

GA, gestational age. GA, gestational age.

14 Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology


Fetal biometry at high altitude Krampl et al.

Table 5 Reference table for head circumference in Cerro de Pasco Table 7 Reference table for abdominal circumference in Cerro de
Pasco
GA (weeks) 5th centile Mean 95th centile
GA (weeks) 5th centile Mean 95th centile
14 80.0 91.0 102.1
15 90.4 104.4 118.3 14 68.4 82.7 96.9
16 101.5 117.7 133.9 15 78.6 93.6 108.7
17 113.1 130.9 148.8 16 88.9 104.7 120.6
18 124.8 144.1 163.3 17 99.3 115.9 132.5
19 136.7 157.0 177.3 18 109.8 127.1 144.4
20 148.5 169.7 190.9 19 120.3 138.3 156.3
21 160.3 182.1 204.0 20 130.7 149.4 168.2
22 171.8 194.2 216.6 21 141.0 160.5 180.1
23 183.1 206.0 228.8 22 151.2 171.5 191.9
24 194.1 217.3 240.6 23 161.2 182.4 203.6
25 204.7 228.2 251.8 24 171.0 193.1 215.2
26 214.8 238.6 262.4 25 180.5 203.6 226.7
27 224.5 248.5 272.5 26 189.8 213.9 238.0
28 233.7 257.9 282.1 27 198.8 224.0 249.2
29 242.3 266.6 291.0 28 207.5 233.8 260.2
30 250.4 274.8 299.2 29 215.8 243.4 270.9
31 257.8 282.3 306.8 30 223.7 252.6 281.5
32 264.5 289.1 313.8 31 231.2 261.5 291.8
33 270.6 295.3 319.9 32 238.3 270.1 301.8
34 276.0 300.7 325.4 33 245.0 278.3 311.6
35 280.6 305.3 330.1 34 251.2 286.1 321.1
36 284.4 309.2 334.0 35 256.9 293.6 330.2
37 287.4 312.2 337.1 36 262.0 300.6 339.1
38 289.6 314.4 339.3 37 266.7 307.1 347.6
39 290.9 315.8 340.7 38 270.7 313.2 355.8
40 291.4 316.3 341.1 39 274.2 318.9 363.6
40 277.1 324.1 371.0
GA, gestational age.
GA, gestational age.

Table 6 Reference table for abdominal circumference in Lima Table 8 Reference table for femur length in Lima

GA (weeks) 5th centile Mean 95th centile GA (weeks) 5th centile Mean 95th centile

14 60.3 71.6 82.9 14 6.4 10.2 14.0


15 72.7 85.2 97.7 15 10.2 14.1 18.0
16 84.8 98.7 112.5 16 13.8 17.8 21.8
17 96.7 112.0 127.2 17 17.3 21.4 25.5
18 108.4 125.1 141.7 18 20.6 24.8 29.0
19 119.9 138.0 156.1 19 23.8 28.1 32.3
20 131.1 150.7 170.3 20 26.9 31.2 35.6
21 142.0 163.2 184.4 21 29.9 34.3 38.7
22 152.7 175.5 198.2 22 32.7 37.2 41.7
23 163.2 187.5 211.8 23 35.4 40.0 44.5
24 173.4 199.3 225.1 24 38.0 42.7 47.3
25 183.4 210.8 238.2 25 40.5 45.2 49.9
26 193.2 222.0 250.9 26 42.9 47.7 52.5
27 202.7 233.0 263.3 27 45.2 50.1 54.9
28 212.0 243.7 275.4 28 47.3 52.3 57.3
29 221.1 254.1 287.1 29 49.4 54.5 59.5
30 230.0 264.1 298.3 30 51.3 56.5 61.7
31 238.6 273.9 309.1 31 53.2 58.4 63.7
32 247.1 283.3 319.5 32 54.9 60.3 65.7
33 255.3 292.3 329.3 33 56.5 62.0 67.5
34 263.4 301.0 338.7 34 58.0 63.6 69.3
35 271.3 309.4 347.5 35 59.4 65.2 70.9
36 279.0 317.3 355.7 36 60.7 66.6 72.5
37 286.5 324.9 363.3 37 61.8 67.9 74.0
38 293.9 332.1 370.2 38 62.9 69.1 75.4
39 301.1 338.8 376.5 39 63.9 70.3 76.7
40 308.2 345.2 382.1 40 64.7 71.3 77.8

GA, gestational age. GA, gestational age.

Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology 15


Fetal biometry at high altitude Krampl et al.

Table 9 Reference table for femur length in Cerro de Pasco Table 11 Threshold model. The threshold model was applied to all
fetal biometric measurements with significant interaction. The ratio
GA (weeks) 5th centile Mean 95th centile Cerro de Pasco/Lima is consistently smaller at later gestations than at
earlier. The differences become statistically significant from 25 to
14 8.8 12.7 16.5 29 weeks onwards
15 11.7 15.8 19.9
16 14.6 18.9 23.2 Interaction Gestational age interval (weeks)
17 17.5 21.9 26.4
18 20.3 24.9 29.5 Variable P-value , 20 2024 2529 3034 $ 35
19 23.1 27.8 32.6
20 25.9 30.7 35.5 BPD 0.002 1.00 1.01 0.97 0.97 0.97
21 28.5 33.5 38.4 OFD 0.006 1.00 1.00 0.98 0.96 0.96
22 31.2 36.2 41.2 HC 0.02 0.99 1.00 0.97 0.96 0.96
23 33.7 38.8 43.9 AC , 0.001 1.02 0.99 0.96 0.94 0.94
24 36.2 41.4 46.6 FL 0.005 1.03 0.99 0.98 0.95 0.97
25 38.6 43.9 49.1
26 40.9 46.2 51.6 BPD, biparietal diameter, OFD, occipitofrontal diameter; HC, head
27 43.1 48.5 54.0 circumference; AC, abdominal circumference; FL, femur length.
28 45.2 50.7 56.3
29 47.2 52.8 58.5
30 49.1 54.8 60.6 at high altitude are normally distributed and not skewed
31 50.9 56.7 62.5 towards smaller measurements. Furthermore, the neonatal
32 52.7 58.5 64.4 and infant mortality rates in low birthweight infants in
33 54.2 60.2 66.2
34 55.7 61.8 67.9
high-altitude populations have been shown to be lower
35 57.1 63.2 69.4 compared to low altitudes in Mexico42, Peru43 and
36 58.3 64.6 70.9 Colorado44.
37 59.4 65.8 72.2 The mechanisms which constrain fetal growth to
38 60.4 66.9 73.4 enable adaptation to altitude are poorly understood.
39 61.2 67.8 74.4
40 61.9 68.6 75.4
There is no doubt that maternal hypoxia predisposes to
small fetal size. In humans at high altitude, maternal
arterial oxygenation during pregnancy45 and the mater-
nal ventilatory response to hypoxic stress is directly
is increased branching of the capillaries with a decreased correlated with birth weight46. Further work might
diffusion distance at high altitude39,40. The fetus shows address non-invasive means of assessing fetal oxygena-
increased erythropoiesis: babies born at a similar high tion such as Doppler investigation of the arterial and
altitude in Bolivia (3800 m, 12 500 ft) have been shown venous circulations, and maternal physiologic and endo-
to have a higher hematocrit, higher levels of hemoglobin crine changes that occur throughout pregnancy at high
and fetal hemoglobin in cord blood compared with sea altitude.
level41. Importantly our results suggest that before 25 weeks,
Lower average birthweight at high altitude is likely to be fetal size at high altitude is not significantly different from
due to physiological adaptation rather than a higher sea level. Therefore second trimester dating charts from sea
number of pathologically growth-restricted babies for the
following reasons. Our data show that the measurements
Table 12 The percentage of measurements from Cerro de Pasco that
are below the fifth centile and above the ninety-fifth centile derived
from the Lima population
Table 10 Regression analysis of biometric variables controlled for
maternal height and parity Gestational age interval (weeks)

Ratio 95% confidence Variable , 25 2529 3034 35 1 Total


Variable Cerro de Pasco/Lima P-value interval Interaction
BPD , 5th 6.06 9.09 15.62 23.46 14.08
BPD 0.98 0.002 0.960.99 0.002 . 95th 9.09 3.03 3.12 2.47 4.33
OFD 0.97 0.001 0.960.99 0.006 OFD , 5th 6.06 10.61 14.06 19.75 13.00
HC 0.97 , 0.001 0.960.98 0.02 . 95th 3.03 4.55 7.81 1.23 3.97
AC 0.96 , 0.001 0.940.97 , 0.001 HC , 5th 7.58 10.61 14.06 23.46 14.44
FL 0.98 0.02 0.960.99 0.005 . 95th 6.06 4.55 4.69 0.00 3.61
EFW 0.88 , 0.001 0.840.91 0.2 AC , 5th 4.55 10.61 6.25 22.22 11.55
HC/AC 1.01 0.003 1.001.02 0.2 . 95th 7.58 3.03 1.56 0.00 2.89
HC/FL 1.00 0.9 0.981.01 0.004 FL , 5th 10.61 10.61 9.38 13.58 11.19
AC/FL 0.98 0.01 0.970.99 0.01 . 95th 7.58 7.58 0.00 1.23 3.97
EFW , 5th 3.03 7.58 10.94 20.99 11.19
BPD, biparietal diameter, OFD, occipitofrontal diameter; HC, head . 95th 0.00 3.03 1.56 0.00 1.08
circumference; AC, abdominal circumference; FL, femur length; EFW,
estimated fetal weight; HC/AC, head circumference/abdominal BPD, biparietal diameter; OFD, occipitofrontal diameter; HC, head
circumference ratio; HC/FL, head circumference/femur length ratio; circumference; AC, abdominal circumference; FL, femur length; EFW,
AC/FL, abdominal circumference/femur length ratio. estimated fetal weight.

16 Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology


Fetal biometry at high altitude Krampl et al.

Table 13 Regression equations


Cerro de Pasco
BPD 2 10.11463 1 22.59607  gest2 2 11.8292  gest2  log(gest)
OFD 2 18.32153 1 31.38366  gest2 2 16.73594  gest2  log(gest)
HC 2 46.63544 1 85.48547  gest2 2 45.3033  gest2  log(gest)
AC 2 24.37415 1 65.13188  gest2 2 31.27398  gest2  log(gest)
FL 2 34.88533 1 35.09442  gest 2 05760241  gest3
EFW 6933.429 1 13628.24  gest22 2 57328.36  gest22  log(gest)
Lima
BPD 2 14.43395 1 24.34002  gest2 2 12.77063  gest2  log(gest)
OFD 2 22.17255 1 32.92824  gest2 2 17.49558  gest2  log(gest)
HC 2 57.20661 1 89.83847  gest2 2 47.4349  gest2  log(gest)
AC 2 130.2058 1 147.6567  gest 2 1.800975  gest3
FL 2 104.8855 1 98.01394  sqrt(gest) 2 0.3105365  gest3
EFW 12842.6 1 52806.21  gest22 2 51276.29  gest21

BPD, biparietal diameter; OFD, occipitofrontal diameter; HC, head circumference; AC,
abdominal circumference; FL, femur length; EFW, estimated fetal weight; gest, gestational age;
sqrt, square root.

level may be valid at high altitude. On the contrary, from PT, Little MA, eds. Man in the Andes, 1st edn. Stroudsburg, PA:
35 weeks onwards, 21% of the fetuses in Cerro de Pasco Dowdon, Hutchinson & Ross, 1976: 16179
6 Jensen GM, Moore LG. The effect of high altitude and other risk
have an estimated fetal weight below the fifth centile of the
factors on birthweight: independent or interactive effects? Am J
Lima population, and none are above the ninety-fifth Public Health 1997; 87: 10037
centile. The use of inappropriate charts of fetal biometry in 7 Cotton EK, Hiestand M, Philbin GE, Simmons M. Re-evaluation
high altitude settings would lead to an over-diagnosis of of birth weights at high altitude. Study of babies born to mothers
small-for-gestational age babies, and the under-diagnosis of living at an altitude of 3,100 meters. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1980;
potential macrosomic conditions. Specific biometry charts 138: 2202.
8 Cannell DE, Vernon CP. Congenital heart disease and pregnancy.
should therefore be used for obstetric ultrasound at high Am J Obstet Gynecol 1963; 85: 744
altitude. 9 De Swiet M. Respiratory disease in pregnancy. Postgrad Med J
1979; 55: 3258
10 Schatz M, Zeiger RS, Hoffman CP. Intrauterine growth is related
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS to gestational pulmonary function in pregnant asthmatic women.
Kaiser-Permanente Asthma and Pregnancy Study Group. Chest
We would like to thank Dr Pedro Mascaro Sanchez, 1990; 98: 38992
Director, and Dr Gloria Larrabure, Research Director, 11 Crowe C, Dandekar P, Fox M, Dhingra K, Bennet L, Hanson MA.
from the Instituto Materno-Perinatal in Lima and Dr The effects of anemia on heart, placenta and body weight, and
blood pressure in fetal and neonatal rats. J Physiol (Lond) 1995;
Mario Soto, Hospital Manager and Gloria Castro, Head
488: 5159
of Midwifery, from Cerro de Pasco. Nilda Janampa, the 12 Bureau MA, Shapcott D, Berthiaume Y, Monette J, Blouin D,
Research Nurse, was extremely committed and her work Blanchard P, Begin R, Bureau MA, Shapcott D, Berthiaume Y,
was essential for running the clinics. Monette J, Blouin D, Blanchard P, Begin R. Maternal cigarette
We are grateful to Toshiba UK, Aloka Peru and AVL smoking and fetal oxygen transport: a study of P50, 2,3-
diphosphoglycerate, total hemoglobin, hematocrit, and type F
Austria for providing the equipment and the Peruvian
hemoglobin in fetal blood. Pediatrics 1983; 72: 226
Ambassador in London, HE J. Eduardo Ponce Vivanco and 13 Moore LG, Niermeyer S, Zamudio S. Human adaptation to high
his staff for their invaluable support. altitude: regional and life-cycle perspectives. Am J Phys Anthropol
This project was supported by the Fetal Medicine Suppl 1998; 27: 2564
Foundation, London (Registered Charity 1037116), and 14 Campbell S, Newman GB. Growth of the fetal biparietal diameter
E.K. was supported by the Austrian Science Foundation, during normal pregnancy. J Obstet Gynaecol Br Commonwealth
1971; 78: 5139
FWF (Erwin Schrodinger Fellowship, registered project
15 Hadlock FP, Harrist RB, Russsell LD, Park SK. Fetal head
number J01625). circumference. Am J Radiol 1982; 138: 64953
16 Hadlock FP, Harrist RB, Russsell LD, Park SK. Fetal abdominal
circumference. Am J Radiol 1982; 139: 36770
REFERENCES 17 Hadlock FP, Harrist RB, Russsell LD, Park SK. Fetal femur length
as a predictor of menstrual age. Am J Radiol 1982; 138: 8758
1 Lichty JA, Ting RY, Bruns PD, Dyar E, Incidence of prematurity 18 Chitty LS, Altman DG, Henderson A, Campbell S. Charts of fetal
higher at high altitude. Public Health Rep 1955; 70: 230. size: 2. Head measurements. Br J Obstet Gynaecol 1994; 101: 35
2 Lichty JA, Ting RY, Bruns PD. Studies of babies born at high 43
altitude I. Relation of altitude to birth weight. Am J Dis Child 19 Chitty LS, Altman DG, Henderson A, Campbell S. Charts of fetal
1957; 93: 6669 size: 3. Abdominal measurements. Br J Obstet Gynaecol 1994;
3 McClung J. Effect of High Altitude on Human Birth. Harvard, 101: 12531
MA: Harvard University Press, 1969 20 Chitty LS, Altman DG, Henderson A, Campbell S. Charts of fetal
4 Kruger H, Arias-Stella J. The placenta and the newborn infant at size: 4. Femur length. Br J Obstet Gynaecol 1994; 101: 1325
high altitudes. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1970; 106: 58691 21 Snijders RJM, Nicolaides KH. Fetal biometry at 1440 weeks'
5 Haas JD. Prenatal and infant growth and development. In: Baker gestation. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol 1994; 4: 3848

Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology 17


Fetal biometry at high altitude Krampl et al.

22 Browne PC, Hamner LH, Clark WS. Sonographic fetal growth 35 Chang JH, Rutledge JC, Stoops D, Abbe R. Hypobaric hypoxia-
curves from an indigent population in Atlanta, Georgia. I. induced intrauterine growth retardation. Biol Neonate 1984; 46:
Singleton pregnancies. Am J Perinatol 1992; 9: 46776 103
23 Davis RO, Cutter GR, Goldenberg RL, Hoffman HJ, Cliver SP, 36 Heath D, Williams DR. Physical and climatic factors at high
Brumfield CG. Fetal biparietal diameter, head circumference, altitude. In: Heath D, Williams DR, eds. High-Altitude Medicine
abdominal circumference and femur length. A comparison by race and Pathology, 3rd edn. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1995:
and sex. J Reprod Med 1993; 38: 2016 719
24 Gardosi J, Chang A, Kalyan B, Sahota D, Symonds EM. 37 Imagawa S, Goldberg MA, Doweiko J, Bunn HF. Regulatory
Customized antenatal growth charts. Lancet 1992; 339: 2837 elements of the erythropoietin gene. Blood 1991; 77: 27885
25 Campbell S, Thoms A. Ultrasound measurement of the fetal head 38 Ward MP, Milledge JS, West JB. Haematology. In: Ward MP,
to abdomen circumference ratio in the assessment of growth Milledge JS, West JB, eds. High Altitude Medicine and Physiology.
retardation. Br J Obstet Gynaecol 1977; 84: 16574 2nd edn. London: Chapman & Hall Medical, 1995: 15572
26 Hadlock FP, Harrist RB, Sharman RS, Deter RL, Park SK. 39 Ali KZ, Burton GJ, Morad N, Ali ME. Does hypercapillarization
Estimation of fetal weight with the use of head, body, and femur influence the branching pattern of terminal villi in the human
measurements a prospective study. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1985; placenta at high altitude? Placenta 1996; 17: 67782
151: 3337
40 Mayhew TM, Jackson MR, Haas JD. Oxygen diffusive con-
27 White RD, Hoopes KH, Allen SD. Comparison of capillary ear
ductances of human placentae from term pregnancies at low and
blood and -arterial blood to validate capillary sampling as an
high altitudes. Placenta 1990; 11: 493503
accurate assay of blood gas in swine. Am J Vet Res 1979; 40:
41 Ballew C, Haas JD. Hematologic evidence of fetal hypoxia among
10224
newborn infants at high altitude in Bolivia. Am J Obstet Gynecol
28 Platt WR, ed. Color Atlas and Textbook of Hematology
1986; 155: 1669
Philadelphia: JB Lippincott, 1969: 325.
29 Altman DG, Chitty LS. Charts of fetal size: methodology. Br J 42 Beall CM. Optimal birthweights in Peruvian populations at high
Obstet Gynaecol 1994; 101: 2934 and low altitudes. Am J Phys Anthropol 1981; 56: 20916
30 Royston P, Altman DG. Regression using fractional polynomials 43 Haas JD, Balcazar H, Caulfield L. Variation in early neonatal
or continuous covariates parsimonious parametric modeling. mortality for different types of fetal growth retardation. Am J
Appl Stat J Royal Stat Soc Series C 1994; 43: 1214. Phys Anthropol 1987; 73: 46773
31 Royston P, Altman DG. Construction of age-related reference 44 Unger C, Weiser JK, McCullough RE, Keefer S, Moore LG.
centiles using absolute residuals. Stat Med 1993; 12: 91724 Altitude, low birth weight, and infant mortality in Colorado.
32 Bland JM, Altman DG. Measurement error and correlation JAMA 1988; 259: 342732
coefficients. BMJ 1996; 313: 412 45 Moore LG, Rounds SS, Jahnigen D, Grover RF, Reeves JT. Infant
33 Graham H. Smoking prevalence among women in the European birth weight is related to maternal arterial oxygenation at high
Community 195090 Soc Sci Med 1996; 43: 24354 altitude. J Appl Physiol 1982; 52: 6959
34 Campbell S, Warsof SL, Little D, Cooper DJ. Routine ultrasound 46 Moore LG, Brodeur P, Chumbe OJDB, Hofmeister S, Monge C.
screening for the prediction of gestational age. Obstet Gynecol Maternal hypoxic ventilatory response, ventilation, and infant
1985; 65: 61320 birth weight at 4300 m. J Appl Physiol 1986; 60: 14016

18 Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology

S-ar putea să vă placă și