Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Naeem Khalid Lodhi(Lt Gen Retd) is entirely wrong about US trying to give a lead role to India.
Out of more than 3000 international solicitations (bids) in Afghanistan Pakistani companies could take part in not more than 50 because they did not have 2 % bid
security money .The US could not give a lead role to India in open international biddings . On the other hand it was good Indian policy in giving indian companies support
in arranging bid security which helped India .Turkish and Chinese governments also arranged bid security for private companies.
More than 60 % of contracts in Afghanistan were bagged by US ,Turkish ,Lebanese and Chinese companies and Indians certainly did not have a lead role in contracts.
I was consultant with two of Pakistans largest construction companies in Afghanistan and got one of them registered in Afghanistan.Both could not take part in any of
bids ( and we prepared 11 bids) because they did not have cash flow to arrange 2 % bid security.
In an Asian Bank project Gereshk Power project in heart of Taliban territory only one company took part and will get the project most likely .This was an Indian
company. What was stopping a Pakistani company from taking part in this bid ?
Pakistan is regarded as the most serious existential threat by Afghanistans 45 % non Pashtuns so the premise of the general about Pashtuns being anti US may be true
but not the non Pashtuns who view the US as a saviour.
At least half of Afghanistans population regards the USA as a saviour from the primitive Taliban who were overwhelmingly supported by Pakistan
The right solution is to partition Afghanistan and retain Bagram and Shindand as permanent bases.
As far as the US logistics contracts are being announced this appears to be the most likely US policy.The Obama pull out plan is an election strategy and the US intends
to stay in Afghanistan , at least North Afghanistan which is entirely feasible.
Iran despite being anti US successfully linked Mashhad with Herat.Uzbekistan kicked out the US from Khanabad base but successfully prevailed with Asian Development
Bank to link Termez with Mazar by rail.
About Balochistan there is no doubt that the insurgency is indigenous and it appears that the US wants an independent Balochistan .One cannot rule this out . Countries
are always created with asssistance of state actors.
The Billion dollar question is that Pakistani government is secretly supporting Taliban fighting the US Army in Afghanistan and also getting aid from the USA to fight
terrorism , why the hell should not the US follow a strategy of playing a similar double game with Pakistan ?
Agha H Amin
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
LINK:http://pakpotpourri2.wordpress.com/2011/07/06/why-americans-will-be-defeated-in-afghanistan/