Human Rights Alert (NGO)

Joseph Zernik, PhD "

PO Box 33407, Tel Aviv, Israel 6133301 ",33407 "
Fax: 077-3179186 Email: joseph.zernik@hra-ngo.org

[]

October20,2017

NadavArgaman,HeadofShinBet
PrimeMinister'sOffice,BenGurionCity,BuildingC
Jerusalem91950
Byfax:025605000,andbyemail:sigalM@pmo.gov.il

RE:ComputerizationoftheCentralElectionCommitteeFOIAresponses
5/0815/17and6/0829/17

DearMrArgaman:
Thankyouverymuchforyourresponsesonmypreviousinquiry,pertainingtolackof
integrityand/ordeceitandbreachoftrustintheCentralElectionCommittees
responseonFOIArequest.
AttachedhereinaretwoadditionalFOIArequestsinthesamematter,andthe
Committeesresponse:
1)FOIArequest5/0815/17
a)PertainingtothepositionandappointmentofMrLazarDudovich,whowas
representedinapreviousresponseasacentralfigure,relativetoITsystemsofthe
Committeetherequestedinformationisnotinourpossession.
b)Relativetoanyrecords,relatedtoChairpersonsoftheCommitteeSupremeCourt
JusticesrelatedtoITsystemsoftheCommitteetherequestedinformationis
notinourpossession.
2)FOIArequest6/0829/17
a)PertainingtocompliancewithIsraeliStandard27001Information
Technologies/SecurityTechniquesandinformationsecuritymanagementsystems
therequestedinformationisnotinourpossession.
BoththeStateOmbudsmansreports,pertainingtocomputerizationofthe
Committee,andconductoftheCommittee,relativetotheFOIArequests,raise
concernsofDeceitandBreachofTrustincomputerizationoftheCentralElection
Committeeamatterwhichisvital/criticalfortheessenceofthedemocraticregime.
Thecentralfigures,whicharesuspectedinthismatterare:
a)AttorneyOrlyAdastheCentralElectionCommitteesCEO,and
b)MrLazarDudovichrepresentedinapreviousresponsebytheCommitteeasakey
figureincomputerizationoftheCommittee.
TheShinBetAct(2002),Article7(a)says:
TheShinBetischargedwiththesafeguardofStatesecurity,procedures
andinstitutionsofthedemocraticregimeagainstthreatsofterror,
sabotage,andsubversion

1/3
Iwouldbegratefulforyourattentiontothisimportantmatterandconfirmationof
receiptbyreturnemail.
Truly,

JosephZernik,PhD
)HumanRightsAlert(NGO

CC:Computingexperts,legalscholars,activists,widedistribution
_________________________________________________________________________
202017,

"

,
91950
"sigalM@pmo.gov.il

:5/0815/17
6/0829/17

,
"/
.
,:
(15/0815/17
(,
"".
(
"".
(26/0829/17
(.27001./
"".

,
/.
:
("",
(
.
,(2002))7(,:
,
,,...
,".
,

2/3
 '
HumanRightsAlertNGO
:,,,

3/3
Human Rights Alert (NGO)
Joseph Zernik, PhD "
PO Box 33407, Tel Aviv, Israel 6133301 ",33407 "
Fax: 077-3179186 Email: joseph.zernik@hra-ngo.org

[]
August15,2017

AttorneyAleadNaveh
CentralElectionCommitteeFOIAOffice
Jerusalem
Email: hofeshmeida@knesset.gov.il , eladn@knesset.gov.il
Fax: 02-5669855

RE:FreedomofInformationRequestAdditionalinformationregardingITsystemsof
theCentralElectionCommittee

DearAttorneyNaveh:
PleaseacceptinstantFreedomofInformationRequest.Pleaseconfirmreceiptbyreturn
email,includingadulydesignatedFOIArequestnumber.
I.RequesterInformation
Name:JosephZernik
ID:
Address:POBox33407,TelAviv,Israel
Fax:0773179186
II.RequestedInformation
Instantrequestpertainstowrittendocumentationoftherequestedinformationinrecords,
whichareheldbytheCentralElectionCommittee,orspecificreferencestoofficial
publications(e.g.StateRegister)oftherequestedinformation.
A.MrLazarDudovitchspositionandlawfulappointment
Anysigned,lawfullymaderecord,whichdocumentsMrLazarDudovitchspositionand
lawfulappointment,pursuanttotheRegulationsofStateService,foranyposition,whichhe
holdstodayand/orheldwithinthepast10yearsintheCentralElectionCommittee.
Note:UnsignedprintoutsfromITsystemofHumanResourcesdepartment,whichindicate
rankandpay,donotconstitutedocumentationoflawfulappointmentforthispurpose.
B.ConductofChairpersonsoftheCommittee,pertainingtovalidity,reliability,
security,integrityandoperationoftheCentralElectionCommitteesITsystems
Anysigned,lawfullymaderecord,whichdocumentsanyconductofanyoftheSupreme
CourtJustices,whohaveservedoverthepast10yearsasChairpersonoftheCentral
ElectionCommittee,pertainingtodiscussion,examination,validation,reviewand/or
reporting,pertainingtovalidity,reliability,security,integrityand/oroperationofITsystems
oftheCentralElectionCommittee,includingcorrespondence,meetingsprotocols,etc,as
requesters,asrecipientsofsuchinformation,and/orasparticipantsinitsgeneration.
III,Payment:
a.RequestfeeinthesumofNIS20.00waspaid,ReferenceNo41274237.

Truly,

1/2
JosephZernik,PhD
)HumanRightsAlert(NGO
_________________________________________________________________________
152017 ,

"


"hofeshmeida@knesset.gov.il , eladn@knesset.gov.il :
02-5669855 :

: -

" ,
. " ,
.
I
:
"053625596 :
" ,33407" 6133301 :
"joseph.zernik@hra-ngo.org :
077-3179186 :
:
II

, ) ( .
.
, "
/ 10 .
: - ,
.
. , , ,

, ,
10 , ,,
, ,/ , , , /
, , , , ,
,/ .
III:
20" , .41274237
,

'
Human Rights Alert - NGO

2/2
 iri rn1'rT- rrn
17T'?r1 Inin jiri
fl"))V.)fl 'lV)fl fl"D : 1'Th1
2017 pTh 15
03698617

jr)-is 1,011 -1-t

33407 .1.3
6133301

5/0815/17 1103 )1'3fl V.J1fl 17in ' flV)1 :11111

15.08.17 O1' J1W' 'I'D13'V

)-1-rmD ''rn-T i5 5v rr'jrn rnrnn"'w ''v.w inv.'i n5prn 15.08.17

)5fl5) fl'D1fl )1'I1'flfl )11)fl 5V) fli1 D1))) fl1))Ilfl W1 2W rn511)flil 1D )Tfl'rufl
("xn1'nn xrt'v'

5v -iv in n-nn vn uvwN vtnr rnn nwn5 rivi'nn n-rn '-iw rm' 5 'D
I)fl3fl )YThT) 5' n)rnn 1'i'5 rnnn ,p5 .p 5' 'i 'nn nwp 5't'n ,u nvmn
pnn rncr -i5 nn -rnp 5'5

nwi5 'onn"nfl )5fl5

fl1WV) 14.12.16 D1'3 D 1' 5)) Vpflfl P1 nwina W12Ji1 ,nv'j'N c'5 .1
DI' l*,5Ninnwjrnyunrnnnn 12.1.17 D)' T12'lWflS DNT1fl 1/1214/16
5"n WflW.'flD rn5 ptnn5 i- 5 wpn rr'n i-is '-i' 1'N ,15.2.17
c2cT inw15 'wi'w

))1')fl r )'I' 1'N ,7nWp2 ' C1)))5 .2

fl:D:

fl v_,n

flD13fl 1V1'flfl 5YDfl ,T1'SSDfl fl5i1)fl - VI)) '5iTh 1'i))

Yfl1'flfl fl1)fl ,''Vfl ')fl'fl - fl)D' '1 1"l))

1 linn 1 fl:D)
Human Rights Alert (NGO)
Joseph Zernik, PhD "
PO Box 33407, Tel Aviv, Israel 6133301 ",33407 "
Fax: 077-3179186 Email: joseph.zernik@hra-ngo.org

[]
August29,2017

AttorneyAleadNaveh
CentralElectionCommitteeFOIAOffice
Jerusalem
Email: hofeshmeida@knesset.gov.il , eladn@knesset.gov.il
Fax: 02-5669855

RE:FreedomofInformationRequestregardingITsystemsoftheCentralElection
CommitteecompliancewithIsraeliStandardIS27001InformationTechnologies
securitytechniques
DearAttorneyNaveh:
PleaseacceptinstantFreedomofInformationRequest.Pleaseconfirmreceiptbyreturn
email,includingadulydesignatedFOIArequestnumber.
I.Requester
Name:JosephZernik
ID:
Address:POBox33407,TelAviv,Israel
Fax:0773179186
II.RequestedInformation
Instantrequestpertainstowrittendocumentationoftherequestedinformationinrecords,
whichareheldbytheCentralElectionCommittee,orspecificreferencestoofficial
publications(e.g.StateRegistry)oftherequestedinformation.
A.CompliancewithIsraeliStandardIS27001InformationTechnologies
Anysigned,lawfullymaderecord,whichdocumentscertificationofcompliancewithIsraeli
StandardIS27001InformationTechnologies:SecurityTechniquessystemsfor
administrationofinformationsecurity.
ThelatestversionoftheStandardwaspublishedonMarch06,2014intheStateRegistry
(YalkutHaPirsumim)6766:InstantStandarddetailstherequirementsforestablishing,
implementation,maintenanceandongoingupgradeofsystemforadministrationof
informationsecurityinthecontextofanorganization...
III,Payment:
a.RequestfeeinthesumofNIS20.00waspaid,ReferenceNo91898602.

Truly,

JosephZernik,PhD
HumanRightsAlert(NGO)

1/2
 292017,

"



hofeshmeida@knesset.gov.il
",eladn@knesset.gov.il:
025669855:

:
.27001.

",
.",
.
.I
:
"053625596 :
:",33407"6133301
"joseph.zernik@hrango.org :
0773179186 :
:
.II
)(
,)(
.
..27001.
,.27001.
:.
676606:2014,
"",,
)"(...
III:
20",.91898602
,

'
HumanRightsAlertNGO

2/2