Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
DOI 10.4335/13.2.265-284(2015)
ISSN 1581-5374 Print/1855-363X Online 2015 Lex localis (Maribor, Graz, Trieste, Split)
Available online at http://journal.lex-localis.info.
266 LEX LOCALIS - JOURNAL OF LOCAL SELF-GOVERNMENT
B. Veljkovi, L. Djeri & J.J. Markovi: Tourism perspectives and Local communities
development within two different countries
1 Introduction
It is generally accepted fact, that environmental and social impacts, indicators and
responses are applied for the mainstream sector of tourism on the world basis and
in that matter positioned in five categories: pollution and protection, prosperity,
peace and population. According to the European Commission the tourist industry
represents one of the key sectors of the EU economy, directly or indirectly
generating over 10% of EU gross domestic product in which 9.7 million
inhabitants found their employment in 1.8 million enterprises of all forms.
Tourism plays important role at the shaping of the European identity, awareness of
the enhanced natural and cultural heritage, employment, sustainable and regional
development (Veljkovi and Ambro, 2010). European Commission is promoting
tourism to keep EU as a leading destination and thus maximizing its contribution
to economic growth and employment. Formal definitions and acknowledges about
the importance of tourism in the EU are stated in in Article 195 of The Lisbon
Treaty. European Union (EU), and in that matter European Commission, defined
Tourism as an important economic activity in the EU (European Commission,
1999 and 2001). Tourism involves vast number of products; destinations with a lot
of different, private and public, stakeholders with decentralised areas of
competence at regional and local levels. In the eyes of EU economic policy
Tourism represents huge potential in the sense of contribution to the major EU
objectives i.e. economic growth, employment, economic and social cohesion and
sustainable development. In the EU, most Community policies have a significant
effect on the activities in the tourism sector and thus EU political institutions in
the new millennium strengthened for new political attention.
There are several important milestones in the political and judicial statements
process regarding Tourism policy of the EU. In 1997 the Luxembourg European
Council on Employment and the Council of Tourism Ministers was held.
Mentioned EU Council recognised the benefits of sustainable and balanced
development of EU tourism and demanded for reaching action as a response to the
Luxembourg Conference. In 1998 a Group on Tourism and Employment was set
up by the Commission. As a result of widely approved directions proposed by a
High-level Group, the Enhancing tourism's potential for employment
Communication was submitted Commission. If one comes out of the end of the
millennium there is EU document Tourism and Employment for sure to be
LEX LOCALIS - JOURNAL OF LOCAL SELF-GOVERNMENT 267
B. Veljkovi, L. Djeri & J.J. Markovi: Tourism perspectives and Local communities
development within two different countries
mentioned (Conclusions of the EU Council, 1999). With a strong support from the
EU Parliament, Committee of the Regions and the Economic and Social
Committee mentioned communication resulted as the conclusions of the EU
Council in June 1999. Council called upon the Member States and the
Commission for closer cooperation to escalate the contribution of tourism to the
employment and growth, with a respect to sustainability, training, information and
quality.
Council results were also important for the creation of active working groups
recommending directions for EU tourism strategies i.e.: the fundamental role of
information, knowledge and its dissemination; the need for competent human
resources motivated by medium and long-term prospects; the integration of
environmental policy and the promotion of sustainable tourism; recognition of the
need for European harmonisation of the concept of quality of tourism services and
infrastructures, and its assessment and monitoring; the need to speed up the
integration of information society tools and services in all tourism activities and
businesses, in particular SMEs; the need for a network of the stakeholders
involved and a generalised partnership, particularly between those in the field to
ensure implementation of all the recommendations (EU Commission, 2001). In the
year 2003 the EU Commission launched a document Basic orientations for the
sustainability of European tourism (EU Commission, 2003) what can be
considered as the next milestone. In this document EU Commission stressed the
need about consistency regarding various EU measures and policies to affect the
competitiveness and sustainability of the EU tourist industry. Sustainability is in
that matter becoming the main focus of EU tourism policies in the way of
increasing economic, environmental and social component of the European
tourism. EU sees important challenges for sustainable tourism linked in the
consumption and production patterns and in that matter in seasonal spread and
also the travel of the tourism purpose. In particular we can see importance of the
value chain and the tourist destinations which means to rely on Community
tourism measures and policies.
strength in the year 2007. Significant potential of the Tourism to generate future
employment and economic growth was also presented at that time structural
interpretations of the European economy i.e. contribution with approximately 4%
to EU GDP (from about 2% in some new EU members and up to 12% in Malta).
EU Commission even claimed that the indirect contribution of the tourism to the
GDP creation reaches more than 10% of EU GDP and secures approximately 12%
of all working places. Agenda for a sustainable and competitive European tourism
was launched in February 2007 (EU Commission, 2007). After recognizing a
significant role of tourism in the EU economy, the Commission adopted a
renewed Tourism Policy in March 2006 with the purpose of improving the
competitiveness of the European tourism industry and creating more and better
jobs through the sustainable growth of tourism in Europe and globally" (EU
Commission, 2006). At that time EU policy also recognised that "making growth
and jobs target goes hand in hand with promoting social or environmental
objectives" and launched the preparation of a European Agenda 21.
After the first section, presenting EU regulation, some basic documents regarding
the EU tourism industry and some leading research experiences, second section
presents tourism as the comparative advantage of the Serbian and Slovenian
Economy. It is followed by section 3 presenting analysed municipalities and data
series used. Section 4 presents our empirical findings and concludes the paper.
Empirical research on tourism has witnessed an enormous interest during the last
30 years. Empirical analyses on tourism began to appear in the economic literature
from the beginning of the 1970s. One of these earlier studies was by Robert W.
McIntosh analysing Job market for tourism graduates: A case of Michigan State
University (McIntosh, 1976). At that time author discussed the four-year tourism
program of Michigan State University and describes the job market for the tourism
graduates. Further, he cites the types of employment opportunities presently
available and predicts their increased in the future. In the eighties Lickorish, with
his paper European tourism action group analysed The Industry Conference,
convened by the European Travel Commission (ETC) in Luxembourg in
November 1980 to consider the major ETC study European Tourism Prospects to
1990, was attended by almost every sector of the tourist trades, both public and
LEX LOCALIS - JOURNAL OF LOCAL SELF-GOVERNMENT 269
B. Veljkovi, L. Djeri & J.J. Markovi: Tourism perspectives and Local communities
development within two different countries
private (Lickorish, 1983). Author claims, that it was also strongly supported by
international organizations. One of the major findings of the Lickorish (Lickorish,
1983) study was weakness in technical liaison between the different sectors of the
industry, e.g., road, rail, air, and sea transport; accommodation and catering trades:
and municipal and resort facilities. Just as, at the national level, the state tourist
organizations and at the regional and local level, the appropriate tourist bodies or
confederations provide a co-operative basis for joint action the author claimed at
that time.
Blaine, Golam and Var (1993) in their explanatory study analysed demand for
rural tourism. From Koth, Kreag and Sem they recognized that an increasing
number of rural communities throughout the United States are seeking to
capitalize on tourism as a means of sustainable economic growth and development
(Koth, Kreag and Sem 1991). Blaine et.al. discovered that many rural community
leaders have successfully identified the advantages of tourism in enhancing their
economic conditions and that a system to provide information on the demand for
rural tourism and to monitor changes in tourist expenditure patterns in the rural
community was at that time lacking. Blaine et.al. also claim in their paper that
most of the previous work on the estimation of tourism demand has focused on
geographically aggregated areas, at the state or national level (Quayson and Var
1982; Var, Mohammad and Icoz 1990).
Perales (2002) determinates the features that characterize a new tourist class,
called modern rural tourism, and figures out the proportion of this market in one
specific Spanish region. The geographical territory under study was El Alto
Palancia, one of the best known rural resorts, within the Valencian region. In order
to fulfil these goals, Perales conducted an empirical study and afterward applied
an econometric model. A wide set of variables has been selected for the Logit
Binomial Model, which was shown to be useful in discriminating the modern from
traditional tourists.
Beerli and Martn (2004) developed and empirically validated a model which
explains the different factors which form the post-visit image of a destination.
Based on a literature review Beerli and Martin involved analyzing the relationship
between the different components of the perceived image and the factors which
influenced its formation (sources of information, primary and secondary) and
stimuli influencing the forming of perceptions and evaluations of destinations pre-
and post-visit, respectively, and motivation, accumulated touristic experiences and
sociodemographic characteristics.
Buckley analysed social and environmental impacts, responses and indicators for
the mainstream tourism sector worldwide, in five categories: population, peace,
prosperity, pollution and protection (Buckley, 2012). Author went through huge
literature review, relevant publications and claims that in the literature exists very
270 LEX LOCALIS - JOURNAL OF LOCAL SELF-GOVERNMENT
B. Veljkovi, L. Djeri & J.J. Markovi: Tourism perspectives and Local communities
development within two different countries
few attempts to evaluate the entire global tourism sector in terms which reflect
global research in sustainable development. Buckley also concluded that the
industry is not yet close to sustainability and that the main driver for improvement
is regulation rather than market measures.
Walkera and Moscardob (2014) did research on the relationship between tourism
and sustainability with considerable attention paid to ecotourism's potential to
positively contribute to sustainability. They used tourist experiences, especially
those focusing on interpretation, to activate or change sustainability relevant
values, beliefs, attitudes and actions both at places visited and elsewhere. Their
paper reports on research conducted with passengers on expedition cruises that
explored links between aspects of the overall experience including the
interpretation provided tourist perceptions of the benefits of these experiences and
their awareness of sustainability values linked. The use an adapted mean-ends
analysis technique and found a consistent pattern of relationships between features
of interpretive experience, activation of values and intentions to adopt responsible
behaviours beyond the cruise. Responses highlighted the importance of staff
expertise and dedication, the ability of interpretive staff to provide security, to
assist people to make personal connections and to elicit participant trust. Walkera
and Moscardob (2014) developed a Value Model of Interpretation (VMI),
integrating theories of effective interpretive practice and connecting interpretation
to the activation of sustainability values. The VMI offers new areas for guides to
consider, shifting the focus from the transmission of information and towards the
facilitation of mindfulness and reflective engagement.
Analysing two countries future intentions we first went through both countries
development strategies regarding countries intentions in general and in the
subsection reviewed tourism strategies for both countries. On the one hand,
discussing about Slovenia's development strategy 2014-2020 as core strategic
document of the Slovenian government defining directions and intentions of
development till 2020, we went through main points of the strategy (Institute of
LEX LOCALIS - JOURNAL OF LOCAL SELF-GOVERNMENT 271
B. Veljkovi, L. Djeri & J.J. Markovi: Tourism perspectives and Local communities
development within two different countries
There are some crucial areas of economic development defined in the Slovenia's
development strategy 2014-2020 and those are; Economic development as
research, development and innovation, start-up growth and development of
small and medium-sized enterprises (Svetilii et.al., 2007), employment,
education, training and competence (Ovin and Maek, 2010). Government also
defined that by 2020, halve of the development funds, is going to be used for the
next areas: Competitive economy (highly educated labour force, geo-strategic
position of Slovenia, internationalized economy, tradition of investing in research
and development, recognizable tourist attractions and electrical energy supply);
knowledge and employment (work as a value, knowledge as a potential,
creativity); green living environment (water resources, renewable energy, forest
and wood, biodiversity) and inclusive society high quality of healthcare,
intergenerational support (Institute of Macroeconomic Analysis and Development,
2005).
On the other hand Serbia defined her vision as anticipation that by 2017 Serbia
will have become an institutionally and economically developed country with
adequate infrastructure, compliant with EU standards, with an economy based on
knowledge, the efficient use of natural and man-made resources, greater efficiency
and productivity. Further on, Serbia will become rich in educated people, a
country with a well-preserved environment, and a historically and culturally rich
272 LEX LOCALIS - JOURNAL OF LOCAL SELF-GOVERNMENT
B. Veljkovi, L. Djeri & J.J. Markovi: Tourism perspectives and Local communities
development within two different countries
nation. Serbia strives for a partnership of public, private and civil sectors, and for
an environment that would provide equal opportunities for all citizens.
According to the same Draft the projection for the year 2020 anticipates an
average of 5-6% annual growth rate (2011-2020) of GDP, so by the end of 2020 it
will reach about 55 billion EUR or around 8,000 EUR per capita. Two-thirds of
that GDP growth is a result of productivity growth, while one-third of its growth is
a consequence of increasing employment. The plan is also to double the
participation of export of goods and services in GDP during this period with a rise
from 33% to 65% (Serbia 2020, 2010). However, the current situation shows that
the growth rate of GDP is very low and with negative values in years 2009 and
2012. GDP per capita has, with slight oscillations, increased slightly since the year
2005, amounting to 4,464 EUR or $ 5,930 in 2013. Serbia has had a drop in the
unemployment rate in the years from 2005 to 2008. However, with the beginning
of the economic crisis in 2009, comes a rise of the unemployment rate, and it is
important to note a slight decline in unemployment over the last two years
(Statistical Office of the Republic of Serbia). The unemployment rate is based on
the National Employment Service records of the unemployed persons.
Belgrade, a city on two major rivers, which is a still undiscovered tourist capital of
South Eastern Europe. Ground and underground waters, from the wealth of
thermal springs and traditional spas, to the Danube, the Sava, the Tisa and the
Morava rivers and other streams, which form a special tourist offer in this part of
Europe, all represent a large unused potential. Still intact expanses of mountains,
forests, agricultural fields, vineyards and hunting-fishing zones, images of which
create a unique and recognizable image contrasts of rich landscapes are also listed
as a strategic potential, as well as the rich archaeological and architectural heritage
that testifies to the historical significance and the development of civilization in
the territory of the Republic of Serbia, and, especially, the highly valued historical
and artistic heritage of Serbian medieval monasteries and archaeological sites as a
source of inspiration and Serbian statehood.
Nine tourist products of the Republic of Serbia which are rated and ranked in the
context of the key success factors and priorities for development were identified
on this occasion. In this regard, a set of promising tourist products of the Republic
of Serbia are: city vacation, MICE (Meetings, Incentives, Conventions and
Exhibitions) and business tourism, touring, special interests, nautical tourism,
events, health tourism (spa & wellness), mountains and lakes, and rural tourism.
Based on the concentrations of different types of resources in some parts of the
country four tourist clusters were identified: Vojvodina, Belgrade, Western Serbia
with Kosovo and Metohija and Eastern Serbia.
Within the hotel industry growth projection is in relation to the completed process
of privatization of all hotel companies, restructured, modernized hotel and tourist
offer (in accordance with international standards and categorization) that has been
repositioned on the market, with the presence of several global hotel chains as
well as a large number of hotel chains of regional importance and the use of
modern standard operating procedures and serving standards in all significant
(categorized) accommodation and catering facilities. According to the current state
in the year 2014, the goals of the Strategy are partly realized, and the growth
projection from Table 2 (taken from the Strategy) is set too ambitiously,
particularly in terms of arrivals and overnight stays by foreign tourists.
In this paper, with selected time series data span from 2008 to 2013, we study
whether the three selected Slovenian and three Serbian municipalities are
achieving each countrys national touristic goals. Defined goals (or national
targets) come out of national Development Strategy for Slovenian Tourism and
Serbian strategy of tourism development from 20052015 and are so formally
recognized as national targets. In some way, we are also testing, if selected
municipalities in both countries are converging (Vojinovi et.al, 2013) towards
their national targets and criteria developing their tourism industry. For the
comparable sample of municipalities we took in account the criteria that the
municipalities population is under 50,000 inhabitants. In accordance to the
statistical criteria used we classified municipalities into the following categories:
health resorts (i.e., the municipalities in which the health and tourist centres,
which meet the conditions required to obtain the countrys status of thermal spa
health complex-resort and engage in the public health care network are present);
mountain communities (municipalities located predominantly in the range of
mountains); the seaside resorts (i.e., the municipalities along coast region); the
town municipalities; other municipalities (i.e. the remaining municipalities that
cannot be classified into any of the above groups).
tourists by 4% p.a. (growth rate) and to increase export revenues from by 68%
p.a. (growth rate). For Slovenia we selected municipalities from Spodnje Posavje
region i.e. Krko, Breice and Sevnica. Regarding Slovenian municipalities and
countries national goals we managed to collect the data for overnight stays and the
number of tourists and so tested time series for these two categories.
One has to notice that there were wast tourist industry investments (Oplotnik
et.al., 2012) in the past decades (thermal spa health complex-resort Terme ate)
in the municipality of Breice thus brings us to statisticaly significantely better
results regarding the domestic and foreign tourist arrivals and overnights in
comparison with other two selected Slovenian municipalities i.e. Krko and
Sevnica.
foreign tourist arrivals. Next national target is to increase the number of overnight
stays by 2% p.a. (growth rate). From data analysed in Table 5 one can easily
notice that, in the segment of overnights, neither domestic nor foreign tourists
overnights figures are not achieving selected national target, more the less,
domestic tourists are achieving more than 14% negative growth rate and foreign
more than 13% of negative growth rate.
Vrnjaka Banja (population: 27,332 according to the census of 2011) is one of the
largest and most famous health spas in Serbia. It is located in central Serbia,
surrounded by high mountain peaks as well as by famous Serbian medieval
monasteries. Tourism industry is undoubtedly the backbone of economic life of
Vrnjaka Banja, and thanks to it some other branches of economy have
successfully developed. The number of arrivals and overnight stays of foreign
tourists is growing year after year (see Table 6). The growth rates of foreigners
arrivals were highest in years 2011 (24.2%) and 2013 (19.0%). As for domestic
tourists, the situation is slightly different. After reaching a growth rate of 3.0% in
the number of arrivals and 2.8% in the number of overnight stays in the year
2011, it seems that the year 2012 had a most drastic fall regarding the growth rate.
(a decline of 10.7% in the number of arrivals and 14.1% in the number of
overnight stays. In the year 2013 Vrnjaka Banja reached the maximum number of
domestic arrivals and overnight stays.
280 LEX LOCALIS - JOURNAL OF LOCAL SELF-GOVERNMENT
B. Veljkovi, L. Djeri & J.J. Markovi: Tourism perspectives and Local communities
development within two different countries
Unlike Kladovo on the issue of foreign tourists the least favorable was the year
2011, when there was a decline of 52.9% in the number of arrivals, and a decline
of 49.1% in overnight stays. The situation in the year 2013 has dramatically
improved, when recorded the maximum number of foreigners with growth rates of
67.1%.
LEX LOCALIS - JOURNAL OF LOCAL SELF-GOVERNMENT 281
B. Veljkovi, L. Djeri & J.J. Markovi: Tourism perspectives and Local communities
development within two different countries
4 Conclusion
This paper estimates and analyses achieving two countries National tourism
development strategies at the local level in six selected municipalities, three from
each of the states. Comparing the projected growth in Serbia (with regards to
Tourism Development Strategy of the Republic of Serbia) for arrivals of domestic
and foreign tourists and their overnight stays for the period from 2005 to 2015
with the actual growth rates in observed municipalities by 2013, we found out that
two municipalities, i.e. Vrnjaka Banja and Kladovo, reach the goals set in the
Strategy when it comes to domestic tourism, and the third municipality, Velika
Plana, pursues the objectives set out in the Strategy for foreign tourism, while in
terms of domestic tourism it is at a great disadvantage and adversely affects the
overall tourism statistics of the Republic of Serbia. We also found out some
directions for analysed municipalities for the future. To intensify the increasing
number of foreign tourists, municipality of Vrnjaka Banja needs to look up to
other competing destinations (for example like Karlovy Vary in the Czech
Republic) and conducts external benchmarking. In order to increase the number of
foreign tourists Kladovo should attract investors to build a marina on the Danube
in order to "stop" and attract cruise ships that sail along the Danube. Velika Plana
is using its geographical position and without a lot of investment, mainly due to
the opening of Serbia and transit tourism, achieves a high positive growth rate of
foreign tourists from 2005 to the present.
References
Oplotnik, . J., Brezovnik B. & Vojinovi B. (2012) Local self-government financing and
costs of municipality in Slovenia, Transylvanian review of administrative sciences, 37
E, pp,128-142.
Oplotnik, . J., Vojinovi B. & Acharya S. (2011) Cross Border Economic Convergence
and EU Integration Process, Lex Localis - Journal of local Self-Government, 9(2), pp,
179-203, doi: 10,4335/9.2.181-205(2011).
Ovin, R. & Maek, A. (2010) How beneficial are inward C-B M & A for European
countries?, European Journal of International Management, 4(5), pp, 488-505, doi:
10,1504/EJIM,2010,034963.
Quayson, J. & Var, T. (1982) A Tourism Demand Function For Okanagan, BC. Tourism
Management 3(2), pp, 108-115, doi: 10.1016/0261-5177(82)90006-1.
Republiki zavod za statistiku (2005) Statistiki godinjaci Republike Srbije (Beograd:
Republiki zavod za statistiku).
Statistical Office of the Republic of Serbia (2012) 2011 Census of Population, Households
and Dwellings in the Republic of Serbia (Belgarde: Statistical Office of the Republic of
Serbia).
Svetlii, M. & Jakli, A. & Burger, A. (2007) Internationalization of small and medium-
size enterprises from selected Central European economies, Eastern European
Economics, 45(4), pp, 36-65, doi: 10,2753/EEE0012-8775450402.
Var, G. & Mohammad, O. I. (1990) Factors Affecting International Tourism Demand for
Turkey, Annals of Tourism Research, 17(4), pp, 606610, doi: 10.1016/0160-
7383(90)90031-L.
Veljkovi, B. & Ambro, M. (2010) Towards the sustainable concept of tourism
development in Posavje region in Slovenia, Innovative issues and approaches in social
sciences, 3(1), pp. 36-59, doi: 10.12959/issn.1855-0541.IIASS-2010-no1-art02.
Vlada Republike Srbije (2008) Nacionalna strategija odrivog razvoja (Beograd: Slubeni
glasnik RS, br, 57/08).
Vlada Republike Srbije (2010) Srbija 2020: Koncept razvoja Republike Srbije do 2020,
godine Nacrt za javnu raspravu (Beograd: Vlada R. Srbije).
Vojinovi, B. & Mikac, M. & Oplotnik, . (2013) The microeconomics of regional
development: measuring convergences of local and regional business cycles, Lex
localis - Journal of Local Self-Government, 11(3), pp. 777-797, doi: 10.4335/11.3.777-
797(2013).
Walkera, K. & Moscardob, G. (2014) Encouraging sustainability beyond the tourist
experience: ecotourism, interpretation and values, Journal of Sustainable Tourism,
22(8), pp, 1175-1196, doi: 10.1080/09669582.2014.918134.
World travel & tourism council (2012) Serbia travel & tourism development potential
2011-23 (London, UK: World travel & tourism council).
Yage Perales, R. M. (2002) Rural tourism in Spain, Annals of Tourism Research, 29(4),
pp, 1101-1110, doi: 10.1016/S0160-7383(02)00025-7.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without
permission.