Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Adrienne M. P. Wright, 1 Alan R. P. Paterson, 1,2 Bernard Sowa, 1 John J. Akabutu, 2,3
Paul E. Grundy 2,3 and Wendy P. Gati 1,2 1Department of Pharmacology, 2Department of Oncology and
3
Department of Pediatrics, University of Alberta and Cross Cancer Institute, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
Summary. 2-chlorodeoxyadenosine (2-CdA) and arabino- (r 078, P 0032, n 7). Cellular es nucleoside trans-
sylcytosine (araC) are nucleoside drugs that are used to porter content varied more than 35-fold among samples
treat various leukaemias, although 2-CdA has not been from 10 patients. The correlation between es nucleoside
tested extensively in children with acute lymphoblastic transporter content and drug sensitivity was statistically
leukaemia (ALL). Nucleoside cytotoxicity depends on the significant for araC (r )093, P 0023, n 5), but not
conversion of these agents to 5-phosphate derivatives, fol- for 2-CdA (r )057, P 023, n 6). Exposure of CCRF-
lowing drug entry into cells via nucleoside transport (NT) CEM cells to araC resulted in a substantial araC concen-
processes. This study compared es nucleoside transporter tration-dependent increase in the relative survival of es
content, determined using a flow cytometric assay with transporter-deficient cells, whereas the increase was slight
SAENTA [5-S-(2-aminoethyl)-N6-(4-nitrobenzyl)-5-thio- following exposure to 2-CdA. We conclude that, in ALL
adenosine] fluorescein, and cytotoxicities of 2-CdA and araC lymphoblasts, es nucleoside transporter content is a deter-
in fresh lymphoblasts from previously untreated paediatric minant of araC sensitivity and that a deficiency in NT may
ALL patients and the human T-lymphoblast cell line, CCRF- impart resistance to araC.
CEM. Lymphoblast samples from individual patients ranged
widely in sensitivity to both 2-CdA (IC50, 6 nmol/l to Keywords: acute lymphoblastic leukaemia, nucleoside
> 5 lmol/l; mean 418 nmol/l; n 8) and araC (IC50, transport, SAENTA fluorescein, 2-chlorodeoxyadenosine
59 nmol/l to > 5 lmol/l; mean 1050 nmol/l; n 7), (2-CdA), arabinosylcytosine (araC).
although IC50 values for the two drugs were correlated
In the current treatment of acute lymphoblastic leukaemia untreated paediatric acute myeloid leukaemia (AML)
(ALL), the most common form of childhood cancer, patients (Santana et al, 1991, 1992; Kearns et al, 1994).
approximately 25% of patients fail to achieve long-term, The success of 2-CdA in treating these malignancies, along
disease-free survival despite intensive combination chemo- with its low clinical toxicity (Carson et al, 1984; Santana
therapy (Rivera et al, 1991), an outcome attributed to the et al, 1991, 1992; Kearns et al, 1994), has made 2-CdA a
emergence of drug-resistant disease. 2-chlorodeoxyadeno- candidate for cytotoxic evaluation in the treatment of
sine (2-CdA), a purine nucleoside analogue with important paediatric ALL.
antileukaemic activity in both resting and proliferating Phase I and Phase II studies by Santana et al (1991,
lymphocytes (Piro, 1992), is currently used in the treatment 1992) reported some antileukaemic activity of 2-CdA
of a number of indolent lymphoid malignancies (Piro et al, treatment in a small number of paediatric ALL patients,
1988; Kay et al, 1989; Kurzrock et al, 1991). 2-CdA has although those studies included patients in their second or
also shown notable antileukaemic activity in previously third relapse, poor candidates for reinduction with any
single agent. In vitro studies of freshly isolated ALL cells by
Kumagai et al (1994) showed that sensitivity to 2-CdA
Correspondence: Dr Wendy P. Gati, Department of Pharmacology, appeared to be independent of either a high-risk karyotype
University of Alberta, 970 Medical Sciences Building, Edmonton, (Philadelphia chromosome or 11q23 abnormalities) or a
Alberta, T6G 2H7 Canada. E-mail: wendy.gati@ualberta.ca previous relapse history, factors that are usually predictive
RESULTS
Cytotoxicity of 2-CdA and araC in fresh leukaemic
lymphoblasts
The MTT dye reduction assay was used to determine the
sensitivity of freshly isolated ALL cells to 2-CdA and araC.
A linear relationship was demonstrated between cell
number per well and the reduced dye product (formazan)
formed, measured colorimetrically as A540 (data not shown).
That linearity occurred over a range of cell concentrations
(104)106 cells per well) in four patient samples.
Figure 1 and Table I illustrate the variability in response
to both agents among patient samples. The IC50 values for
araC toxicity towards the preB-cell ALL lymphoblasts from
Patients 4 and 8 were 372 nmol/l and 374 nmol/l, Fig 1. Sensitivity of leukaemic lymphoblasts from acute lym-
respectively, and, although several-fold greater than those phoblastic leukaemia (ALL) Patient 5 (T-cell, top) and Patient 6
for 2-CdA in the same experiment, these values are within a (pre-B-cell, bottom) to 2-chlorodeoxyadenosine (2-CdA) (,) and
arabinosylcytosine (araC) (d). Cells were exposed to graded con-
concentration range (60800 nmol/l) that is achievable in
centrations of each drug for 72 h. Cell viability was measured using
plasma with conventional araC chemotherapy (Rustum &
the 3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5-diphenyltetrazolium bromide
Raymakers, 1992). However, cells from preB-cell ALL (MTT) assay at the end of the incubation period. Logistic curves
Patient 6 were less sensitive to both 2-CdA and araC (IC50 were fitted to the data to obtain IC50 values from the concentration-
values of 1660 nmol/l and 2650 nmol/l respectively, Fig 1). effect relationships, as described in Materials and methods. Each data
Similarly, resistance to both 2-CdA and araC (Patient 9) was point represents the mean SD of six replicate measurements in a
shown in lymphoblasts from T-cell ALL (Table I). single experiment.
Table I shows that interpatient variation in sensitivity to
the nucleoside analogues was considerable, with IC50 values determined using flow cytometry. The RFI value obtained
for 2-CdA ranging from 6 nmol/l to > 5 lmol/l, and for from each fluorescence histogram (RFI versus frequency of
araC from 59 nmol/l to > 5 lmol/l. The leukaemic cells events) was a quantitative measure of bound SAENTA
showed significantly (P < 005) greater sensitivity to 2-CdA fluorescein. Specific binding was calculated as the difference
(n 8) than to araC (n 7). In the present study, IC50 between SAENTA fluorescein binding in the absence (total
values for 2-CdA were < 100 nmol/l in one-third of the binding) and presence (non-specific binding) of an excess of
patient samples tested; concentrations of 2-CdA achievable NBMPR. These experiments showed that SAENTA fluores-
in the plasma were in the 2385 nmol/l range (Kearns et al, cein binding was saturable and es transporter-selective in
1994). that bound SAENTA fluorescein was reduced by prior
Figure 2 tested the correlation between IC50 values for treatment of cells with NBMPR. Non-specific binding of
2-CdA and araC cytotoxicity in leukaemic lymphoblasts 20 nmol/l SAENTA fluorescein was 81% and 22% of the
samples from seven paediatric patients with ALL in which total binding in cells from Patients 8 and 9, respectively,
both parameters were determined (Table I), yielding a after correction for autofluorescence. Mass law analysis
statistically significant relationship (r 078, P 0032). of the binding data for lymphoblasts from Patient 8 yielded
the constants Bmax 578 16 RFI units/cell and
Cellular content of es nucleoside transporters in fresh KD 206 024 nmol/l. The binding constants for
leukaemic lymphoblasts Patient 9 were Bmax 114 04 RFI units/cell and
The data of Fig 3 illustrate the equilibrium binding of KD 285 036 nmol/l. Conversion of RFI values to es
graded concentrations of SAENTA fluorescein to cells from nucleoside transporter sites (NBMPR binding sites) using a
preB-cell ALL Patient 8 and T-cell ALL Patient 9, as factor (200) determined in human cell lines (Gati et al,
Patient number Immunophenotype Bone marrow blasts (%) IC50, 2-CdA (nmol/l) IC50, araC (nmol/l)
*IC50 values were determined from concentration-effect plots following 72-h exposure of lymphoblasts to the nucleoside
analogues. The MTT dye reduction assay was used to measure cell viability in the drug-treated cultures.
Not determined. All samples used in the present study are listed in the table. Although some samples were not tested for drug
sensitivity, SAENTA fluorescein binding data for those samples are shown in Fig 4.
Peripheral blood sample.
DISCUSSION
The present study examined the role of nucleoside transport
in the cytotoxicity of 2-CdA and araC in leukaemic
lymphoblasts from previously untreated paediatric patients
with ALL, by comparing the cellular es nucleoside trans-
porter content and nucleoside drug sensitivity of freshly ALL, an immunophenotype often associated with an unfa-
isolated lymphoblasts. vourable outcome (Mahony, 1994), two T-cell ALL samples
A wide interpatient variation in sensitivity of the leukae- in this study were also among those that were most sensitive
mic blast samples to 2-CdA and araC was reflected in IC50 to the nucleosides. Pieters et al (1994) have shown a wide
values that ranged more than 800-fold and 80-fold respec- variation in sensitivity to a number of antitumour agents in
tively. Although the leukaemic cell sample that was most leukaemic blasts from patients with ALL. Campana et al
resistant to 2-CdA and araC was from a patient with T-cell (1993) also observed considerable interpatient variation in
Fig 7. The proportion of es transporter-deficient cells in CEM cell populations after exposure to 2-chlorodeoxyadenosine (2-CdA) (h)
or arabinosylcytosine (araC) (d). CEM cells were exposed to graded concentrations of the nucleoside drugs for 96 h, stained with SAENTA
[5-S-(2-aminoethyl)-N6-(4-nitrobenzyl)-5-thioadenosine] fluorescein, phycoerythrin-labelled annexin V (annexin V-PE) and 7-aminoactino-
mycin D (7-AAD), and analysed by flow cytometry as described in Materials and methods. The proportions of es transporter-deficient cells were
determined as described in the examples of Fig 6. (A) Nucleoside concentration-dependence of changes in the proportion of es transporter-
deficient cells. (B) Changes in the proportion of es transporter-deficient cells as a function of nucleoside cytotoxicity. The data are means SEM
(n 4).