Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Panahon
Petitioner: Evic Human Resource Management Inc., Free Bulkers S.A. and/or Ma. Victoria C. Nicolas
Respondent: Rogelio O. Panahon
Date: July 31, 2017
G.R. No.: 206890
Ponente: Caguiao, J.
FACTS:
EVIC in behalf of its principal Free Bulkers hired Panahon as Chief Mate on board the vessel of M/V Free
Lady for a period of sic months with basic monthly salary of US$1,088.00.
Panahon was later repatriated to the Phils. without completing the contract of employment.
Panahon filed a complaint for illegal dismissal with claims for moral and exemplary damages, and attortneys
fees agains EVIC, Free Bulkers and Ma. Victoria Nicolas, the Owner and President of EVIC.
Panahon alleges that he has been a professional seafarer for 31 years and Chief Mate for 21 years.
He alleges that the Captain developed a Hostile Attitude towards him.
One time, the Captain asked Panahon to make a report about the damages on the ship. During their interaction,
the Captain smelled a whisky on Panahon. Panahon admitted that the drank a little whisky.
The captain made an entry in the logbook recommending his replacement.
The Petitioners on the other hand allege that the dismissal of Panahon was for a just cause because he did not
observe safety precautions, caught intoxicated in violation of company riles and the POEA contract and
arrogant.
LAs Ruling
The LA dismissed the complaint for lack of merit
NLRCs Ruling
The NLRC affirmed the ruling of LA, but awarded nominal damages since the requisite notice and hearing was
not given to Panahon.
CAs Ruling
The CA reversed the NLRC decision and held that the unnotarized behavioural report which was the basis of
the LA and NLRC cannot be given credence because it was not corroborated. Only the captain witnessed such
acts.
ISSUE/S:
1. W/N the CA erred in ruling that there was no just cause in respondents dismissal.
2. W/N Respondent is entitled to attorneys fees.