Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Financial Risk
Management for
Management
Accountants
By Margaret Woods
and Kevin Dowd
The material contained in the Management Accounting Guideline Financial Risk Management for Management
Accountants is designed to provide illustrative information with respect to the subject matter covered. It does not
establish standards or preferred practices. This material has not been considered or acted upon by any senior
or technical committees or the board of directors of either the AICPA, CIMA or CMA Canada and does not
represent an official opinion or position of either the AICPA, CIMA or CMA Canada.
Copyright 2008 by The Society of Management Accountants of Canada (CMA Canada), the American
Institute of Certified Public Accountants, Inc. (AICPA) and The Chartered Institute of Management
Accountants (CIMA). All Rights Reserved.
No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted, in any form or by any means,
without the prior written consent of the publisher or a licence from The Canadian Copyright Licensing Agency (Access
Copyright). For an Access Copyright Licence, visit www.accesscopyright.ca or call toll free to 1 800 893 5777.
ISBN: 1-55302-228-9
Page
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY.........................................................................................................................................4
INTRODUCTION.......................................................................................................................................................4
Risk Response............................................................................................................................................9
Regression Analysis.................................................................................................................................10
Value-at-Risk.............................................................................................................................................11
Scenario Analyses....................................................................................................................................12
The Need for Clear Hedging Policies and Understanding of Derivatives Trading..........................21
CONCLUSIONS......................................................................................................................................................22
CASE STUDY..........................................................................................................................................................22
GLOSSARY..............................................................................................................................................................25
ENDNOTES.............................................................................................................................................................26
BIBLIOGRAPHY......................................................................................................................................................27
3
Financial Risk Management
for Management Accountants
Executive Summary financial risks relate to the financial operation of a business
in essence, the risk of financial loss (and in some cases,
This Management Accounting Guideline (MAG) summarizes the
financial gain) and take many different forms. These
basic principles of financial risk management. The MAG first
include currency risks, interest rate risks, credit risks,
briefly outlines (a) the different types of financial risk that firms
liquidity risks, cash flow risk, and financing risks. The
may face, (b) the basic elements of a risk management
importance of these risks will vary from one organization to
framework, and (c) the benefits of managing financial risks. The
another. A firm that operates internationally will be more
MAGs core sections then focus on the interlinked issues of risk
exposed to currency risks than a firm that operates only
assessment (or quantification) and possible control tools. Risk
domestically; a bank will typically be more exposed to credit
assessment and control tools are suggested for each type of
risks than most other firms, and so forth.
financial risk, and real-world examples are used to illustrate the
discussion. A case study of the financial risks and the financial It is frequently suggested that the key driver of change has
risk manage-ment choices available to Pietrolunga, a fictitious been a series of economically significant and large-scale
specialist Italian lumber merchant, shows how the suggested financial disasters. To give just a few examples: in 1993,
methods may be applied in practice. A glossary of key terms Germanys Metallgesellschaft AG lost $1.3 billion in oil
provides a quick source of reference. futures trading, and in the following year the US munici-
pality, Orange County, was forced to file for Chapter 9
bankruptcy following massive losses from speculating on
Underlying all of the material in this MAG is the premise derivatives. In 1995, Barings Bank in the UK failed due to
that the key aim of financial risk management is to assist unauthorized derivatives trading by an offshore subsidiary.
management in controlling risks that may affect the And in 1998 the hedge fund Long Term Capital Manage-
achievement of organizational objectives. There is no ment (LTCM) collapsed demonstrating that having two
single ideal risk management package, but risks will be Nobel Prize-winning finance experts on its board of directors
managed most effectively if sound judgment and offered only limited protection from financial risks. Then
common sense are combined with the use of a judicious there was the fall of Enron in 2001 and the accompanying
mix of qualitative and quantitative controls. collapse of Arthur Andersen, the major accounting firm that
Financial risk management has ranked very high on acted as Enrons external auditors. The last couple of years
the corporate agenda since the early 1990s, but the have witnessed a considerable number of huge losses
large losses experienced in the last couple of years involving many of the worlds leading financial institutions.
indicate that many firms are still a long way from Indeed, recent events suggest that many firms including
managing their financial risks effectively. many financial institutions that should really have known
better still have a lot to learn about effective financial risk
management.
Introduction The financial risk management disasters of the last fifteen
While some of the tools and practices described in years or so have (a) made it clear that risk management is
this MAG have been developed by risk managers for fundamental to good corporate governance, and
use in and by financial institutions, the primary target (b) prompted a number of responses relating to
audience for this MAG is the financial manager in governance and internal control. Among these, the
non-financial organizations that face an array of Combined Code in the UK and the King Report in
financial risks and challenges inherent in doing South Africa. All see risk management as part of the
business in todays global economy. internal control process for which the board of
directors is responsible. Similarly, in the USA the
Risk management is concerned with understanding and
Sarbanes Oxley Act (SOX) of 2002 requires
managing the risks that an organization faces in its
companies to establish and maintain an adequate
attempt to achieve its objectives. These risks will often
internal control structure for financial reporting.
represent threats to the organization such as the risk
of heavy losses or even bankruptcy. Risk management Over this same period, company managers have also
has traditionally associated itself with managing the risks increasingly recognized the potential for effective risk
of events that would damage the organization. management to add value to an organization, and the
language of risk management has started to permeate the
Organizations face many different types of risk. These
day-to-day language of business. As a result, it is now
include risks associated with (a) the business environment,
commonplace to consider the risk implications of many
(b) laws and regulations, (c) operational efficiency, (d) the
business decision-making problems, such as (a) making
organizations reputation, and (e) financial risks. These
budgetary choices, (b) choosing between alternative
FINANCIAL RISKS
5
Market risks: These are the financial risks that arise
because of possible losses due to changes in future the borrower or counterparty, repayment sources, the
market prices or rates. The price changes will often nature of underlying collateral, and other support given
relate to interest or foreign exchange rate movements, current events, conditions and expectations. Additionally,
but also include the price of basic commodities that are the bank splits its loan portfolios into consumer or
vital to the business. commercial categories, and by geographic and business
groupings, to minimize the risk of excessive concentration
of exposure in any single area of business.
EXAMPLE 1: CADBURYS
SCHWEPPES EXPOSURE TO
FOREIGN EXCHANGE RATE RISK Financing, liquidity and cash flow risks: Financing risks
affect an organizations ability to obtain ongoing financing.
The confectionery giant, Cadbury Schweppes, An obvious example is the dependence of a firm on its
recognized in its 2007 annual report that it has an access to credit from its bank. Liquidity risk refers to
exposure to market risks arising from changes in uncertainty regarding the ability of a firm to unwind a
foreign exchange rates, particularly the US dollar. More position at little or no cost, and also relates to the availa-
than 80% of the groups revenue is generated in bility of sufficient funds to meet financial commitments
currencies other than the reporting one of sterling. This when they fall due. Cashflow risks relate to the volatility of
risk is managed by the use of asset and liability the firms day-to-day operating cash flow.
matching (revenue and borrowings), together with
currency forwards and swaps.
EXAMPLE 4: A CREDIT TRIGGER
Credit risks: Financial risks associated with the possibility of Banks often impose covenants within their lending
default by a counter-party. Credit risks typically arise agreements (e.g., a commitment to maintain a credit
because customers fail to pay for goods supplied on credit. rating), and access to credit depends on compliance
Credit risk exposure increases substantially when a firm with these covenants. Failure to comply creates the
depends heavily upon a small number of large customers risk of denial of access to credit, and/or the need to
who have been granted access to a significant amount take action (and costs involved) to restore that rating.
of credit. The significance of credit risk varies between
For example, the 2005 annual report of Swisscom AG
sectors, and is high in the area of financial services,
shows that the company entered into a series of cross-
where short- and long-term lending are fundamental to
border tax lease arrangements with US Trusts, in which
the business.
sections of its mobile networks were sold or leased for
A firm can also be exposed to the credit risks of other firms up to 30 years, and then leased back. The leasing terms
with which it is heavily connected. For example, a firm may included a commitment by Swisscom AG to meet
suffer losses if a key supplier or partner in a joint venture minimum credit ratings. In late 2004, however, a
has difficulty accessing credit to continue trading. downgrading by the rating agencies took the companys
credit rating to below the minimum specified level.
As a result, Swisscom AG incurred costs of
EXAMPLE 2: AMAZONS CREDIT RISKS Swiss Francs 24 million to restore that rating.
for
decision making
Implementation and Develop risk
monitoring of controls response strategy
7
CIMAs risk management cycle, illustrated in Figure Risk Identification and Assessment
2, shows that risk management forms a control loop
that starts with defining risks by reference to The first stage is to identify the risks to which the
organizational goals, then progressing through a organization is exposed. Risk identification needs to be
series of stages to a reassessment of risk exposures methodical, and to address the organizations main
following the implementation of controls. activities and their associated risks. Risk identification
may be carried out via questionnaires, surveys,
At the organizational level, the stages of the risk cycle are brainstorming sessions, or a range of other techniques
set against the background of a clearly articulated risk such as incident investigation, auditing, root cause
policy. Drafted by senior management, the policy indicates analysis, or interviews. The aim is to use staff expertise
the types of risks senior management wants the organi- to identify and describe all the potential financial risks to
zation to take or avoid, and establishes the organizations which the organization may be exposed.
overall appetite for risk taking. The starting point is there-
The scale of each identified risk is then estimated, using a
fore a general understanding of (a) the range and type of
mix of qualitative and quantitative techniques. (We will have
risks that an organization may face in pursuing its specific
more to say on these techniques below. For the time being,
strategic objectives, and (b) the scale and nature of any
however, we focus not on the techniques them-selves, but
interdependencies between these risks. This overview can
on how estimates of these risk exposures are put to use.)
then be used as the basis for constructing a more detailed
After this, risks are prioritized. The resulting risk ranking
risk management strategy for each risk category in this
should relate directly back to overall corporate objectives. A
case, financial risks.
commonly used approach is to map the estimated risks
Based on the cycle illustrated in Figure 2, the core against a likelihood/impact matrix, such as that illustrated
elements of a financial risk management system are: below. Often, both likelihood and impact would be classified
into high, medium, or low. The more likely the outcome, and
Risk identification and assessment
the bigger the impact, the more significant the risk would
Development of a risk response become. And it is especially important to identify and
Implementation of a risk control strategy and assess those risks that have the potential to severely
the associated control mechanisms jeopardize the organizations ability to achieve its
Review of risk exposures (via internal reports) objectives, or even to threaten its very survival.
and repetition of the cycle The estimated risks can then be prioritized using a
likelihood/impact matrix, such as that illustrated in Figure 3.
High
9
5
Medium 7 6
L 1
I
K 2
E
L Low 10
I 3
8
H
O 4
O
D
Low Medium High
IMPACT
Forwards
Risk Sharing Strategies: Futures
Risk sharing arrangements involving outside parties Joint Ventures
Swaps
Options
Risk Transfer Strategies:
Insurance
Risk transfer while maintaining upside benefits
Securitization
9
Risk transfer involves paying a third party to take over This basic framework for risk management can now be
the downside risk, while retaining the possibility of taking applied to each of the different categories of financial
advantage of the upside risk. An option, for example, risk, namely: market, credit, financing, liquidity, and
creates the opportunity to exchange currency at a pre- cash flow risks.
agreed rate, known as the strike price. If the subsequent
exchange rate turns out to be favorable, the holder will
exercise the option, but if the subsequent exchange rate Quantifying Financial Risks
is unfavourable, the holder will let it lapse. Thus, the Figure 3 shows that an organization must decide how to
option protects the holder from downside risk while respond to a financial risk, and choose between
retaining the possible benefits of upside risk. Note, by accepting and managing the risk as part of its normal
the way, that the greater flexibility of risk transfer tools is business operations by mitigating it, avoiding it, or
usually accompanied by greater cost. transferring it. From the CIMA risk cycle, we know that
The pros and cons of the different responses are the choice will reflect both
discussed in more depth within the context of each The priority attached to the risk, for example as
different type of financial risk, but it is helpful at this
shown on the likelihood and consequences
stage to recognize that various choices do exist.
matrix; and
The organizations risk appetite.
Risk Control Implementation In other words, managers need to know the scale of the
Having selected a risk response, the next stage is to risk they face before they can decide upon the response.
implement it and monitor its effectiveness in relation to
Three commonly used approaches to quantifying
the specified objectives. Implementation includes
financial risks are regression analysis, Value-at-Risk
allocating responsibility for managing specific risks and,
analysis, and scenario analysis. It is helpful to look at
underlying that, creating a risk-aware culture in which
each method in more depth to understand their
risk management becomes embedded within the
respective strengths and weaknesses.
organizational language and methods of working.
Regression Analysis
Review of Risk Exposures
Regression analysis involves trying to understand how one
The control loop is closed when the effectiveness of variable such as cash flow is affected by changes in a
the risk controls is evaluated through a reporting and number of other factors (or variables) that are believed to
review process. This then leads to a new risk influence it. For example, the cash flow for a UK-based
identification and evaluation process. This process engineering business may be affected by changes in
itself has three main components: interest rates (INT), the euro/sterling exchange rate
Review process: This should include a regular (EXCH), and the price of gas (GAS). The relationship
review of risk forecasts, a review of the manage- between the variables can be expressed as follows:
ment responses to significant risks, and a review Change in cash flow = + 1 INT + 2 EXCH + 3 GAS +
of the organizations risk strategy. It should also
include the establishment of an early warning where INT represents the change in interest rates, EXCH
system to indicate material changes to the risks represents changes in the euro/sterling exchange rate,
faced by the organization. GAS represents changes in the commodity price, and
represents the random error in the equation. The random
Internal reporting to the board or senior
error reflects the extent to which cash flows may change
management group: This might include a
as a result of factors not included in the equation.
(a) review of the organizations overall risk manage-
ment strategy, and (b) reviews of the processes The coefficients 1, 2, and 3 reflect the sensitivity of
used to identify and respond to risks, and of the the firms cash flows to each of the three factors. The
methods used to manage them. It should also equation is easily estimated using standard packages
include an assessment of the costs and benefits of (including Excel), and the estimated coefficients can be
the organizations risk responses, and an assess used to determine the firms hedging strategy.
ment of the impact of the organizations risk
management strategy on the risks it faces. To continue the example, suppose 2 is negative, implying
that the firms cash flow would fall if the exchange rate
External reporting: External stakeholders
went up. If the firm wished to hedge its cash flow against
should be informed of the organizations risk
such an event, then it might do so by taking out a forward
management strategy, and be given some contract. If the exchange rate rose, the resulting drop in
indication of how well it is performing. cash flow would be countered by an equivalent rise in the
11
Besides this application of VaR methods to Sudden decreases in liquidity: Markets can suddenly
estimate Earnings-at-Risk and Pension-Fund-at- lose liquidity in crisis situation, and risk management
Risk, other applications include: strategies can easily become unhinged, leading to
much bigger losses than anticipated.
Liquidity-at-Risk: VaR taking account of
changes in market liquidity. Concentration risks: Scenario analyses can
some-times reveal that we might have a much
Cashflow-at-Risk: VaR analysis applied to a
larger exposure to a single counterparty or risk
firms cash flows rather than P&L. factor than we had realized, taking into account
Credit-at-Risk: VaR analysis applied to a firms the unusual conditions of a crisis. Probability-
credit exposure. based measures such as VaR can overlook such
Default-Value-at-Risk: VaR analysis applied to concentration, because they tend not to pay
estimate a firms losses in the event of default. much attention to crisis conditions.
Macroeconomic risks: Scenario analyses are well
Thus, VaR-type analysis is very flexible and can be
suited for gauging a firms exposure to
applied to any type of quantifiable risk.
macroeconomic factors such as the state of the
business cycle, sudden exchange rate changes, and
Scenario Analyses the economic condition of a particular country.
strategies
VaR Potentially complex, Enhances understanding Easy to understand No idea of the potential
requiring good statistical of a wide range of risks scale of losses in excess
understanding covering liquidity, cash Gives a sense of the of VaR.
flows, portfolio values, likelihood of a given
credit, etc. scale of losses May give a false sense of
security because it does
Can be used as a risk not capture extreme
control tool scenarios
Scenario Analysis Simple What if analyses Highly flexible Likelihood of alternative
scenarios may not be
Crisis planning Easy to understand easily assessed.
Specification of scenarios
is subjective
13
summarizes the choices, using the risk management
The table also shows how rising salary costs can be framework developed earlier in this MAG.
compensated for by an increase in the discount rate,
so that liabilities remain close to stable. This Choosing the most appropriate tool depends upon the risk
information is useful for understanding the financial appetite, level of expertise in the business, and the cost
reporting implications of pensions risks, because the effectiveness of the particular tool. The board of directors
stock market now views pension liabilities as a form of sets the organizations risk appetite, so it is important for
corporate debt. As a result, high liabilities can serve to board members to understand the methods being used to
reduce the market value of the firm. manage risk in their company. If the methods are not well
understood, then it is advisable not to use them.
The rest of this section explains, according to risk
In this section, we have suggested three alternative type, each of the control tools listed in table 2.
methods for measuring risk, and it is helpful to end
by summarizing the respective uses, advantages,
and disadvantages of each approach. Market Risk Tools
Internal Strategies
Tools and Techniques to Mitigate Risk
Natural hedging is internal to a business and takes
Knowing the potential scale and likelihood of any given
advantage of the fact that different risk exposures
financial risk, management needs to decide how to deal with
may offset each other.
it. This means deciding whether it wishes to accept, partially
mitigate, or fully avoid the risk. Different tools exist for each Uses: primarily used in managing foreign exchange
of these choices and for each risk type. Table 2 and interest rate risks.
15
Futures: Futures contracts are a form of standardized The counterparty to any futures contract is the exchange
forward contract that are traded exclusively on itself. This means that firms taking futures positions face
organized exchanges. negligible default risk. The exchange protects itself against
default risk by obliging firms involved to maintain margin
Uses: In principle, futures may be used to protect
accounts. Every day, the value of the position is marked to
against changes in any asset or commodity price,
market, and gains or losses are settled immediately. So, for
interest rate, exchange rate, or any measurable
example, if a firm has a purchased a futures position (i.e.,
random variable such as temperature, rainfall, etc.
one that increases in value if the futures price should rise),
Contract sizes for futures are standardized, meaning that and if the futures price does in fact rise, then the firm can
they lack the flexibility of forward contracts. Additionally, it take its profit. But if the futures price should fall, the firm will
is not possible to use straightforward futures contracts to realize a loss and may face margin calls. Futures contracts
protect against price changes for all commodities. For are more liquid than forward contracts, but the firm also has
example, jet fuel is not traded on an organized futures to take account of the possibility of margin calls that may
exchange, so airline companies have to find alternative strain liquidity.
tools, such as the commodity swap market, to manage
Swaps: A swap is a contract to exchange the
their exposure to the risk of rising fuel costs.
difference between two cash flows at one or more
Nonetheless, the protection that futures (and also agreed future dates.
forwards) provide can be vital for all commodities that
Uses: management of interest rate and exchange rate
are significant components of production.
risks. More recently, markets in commodity and credit
risk swaps have developed. Swaps can be used to (a)
EXAMPLE 15: CADBURY SCHWEPPES reduce funding costs, arbitrage tax, or funding
differentials, (b) gain access to new financial markets,
AND COMMODITY FUTURES
and (c) circumvent regulatory restrictions.
Cadbury Schweppes uses commodity futures contracts
to hedge against adverse cash flow or profit and loss
movements arising from changes in the prices of sugar, EXAMPLE 17: AN INTEREST-RATE SWAP
cocoa, aluminium, and other commodities. It is easy to A fixed-for-floating interest rate swap enables a firm to
understand why Cadbury Schweppes use commodity arrange with a swap dealer to swap the difference
futures, because between the end of 2000 and June between a fixed and a floating rate of interest. Such an
2002, for example, the price per metric tonne of cocoa arrangement effectively allows an organization to
increased from $800 to $2200. Such a huge increase convert a position in a floating rate loan into a position
within a relatively short time implies that a failure to in a fixed rate one, and vice versa.
hedge such an exposure would potentially have
dramatically affected their profits. Similarly, the oil price LXNs Treasurer has negotiated a fixed rate of 6% or Euro
rises of 2008 have seriously affected the profits of small Libor +1.5% variable rate for a loan of 1.8 million. The
haulage firms that chose to accept the price risk rather counterparty is a swap dealer, MGV, who has agreed to
than to hedge their exposure. convert the fixed rate debt into synthetic floating rate debt
via a swap arrangement in which the two companies will
share the quality spread differential (QSD) equally.
Joint ventures imply that an organization is willing to
accept a given level of risk, but it may wish to share The counterparty can borrow at 7.2% fixed or Euro
that risk with another party. Libor + 2.5% variable. Euro Libor is currently 5%.
Uses: expansion into new markets where shared Comparing the cost of fixed rate borrowing between LXN
knowledge, as well as shared costs, helps to reduce risks. and MGV, we see that LXN has a comparative advantage
equal to 1.2% (7.2% - 6.0%). In the floating rate market,
LXN also has a comparative advantage of 1% ( LIBOR
EXAMPLE 16: JOINT VENTURES TO +2.5% - LIBOR + 1.5%). The gap between the relative
SHARE RISKS benefit in the fixed versus floating markets is termed the
QSD, and in most swaps this is shared equally between
The CW television network in the USA, which was the two parties. In this case the QSD equals 0.2%.
launched in the September 2006 season, is a joint venture
owned in equal parts by CBS Corporation and Warner The result is a net saving to both parties of 0.1% interest
Brothers. The network is specifically targeted at a narrowly on the terms that they could otherwise have obtained, i.e.,
defined market group 18-34 year old females. Launch LXN pays 6.4% instead of 6.5% variable, and MGV pays
risks are reduced by sharing the investment costs, but this 7.1% fixed instead of 7.2%. This saving has to be offset
also reduces the upside gains from risk-taking because the against the additional risk arising from the swap because
resulting profits are also shared. of the counterparty risk. LXN faces the risk that
17
The purchase of insurance is often obligatory, either Credit Risk Tools
for legal reasons or as precondition for credit as is
the case with mortgages. Internal Strategies
Self-insurance: The firm may decide to bear certain The majority of tools for controlling credit risk fall into
types of risk itself, and possibly set up its own insurance
this category. They include:
company (known as a captive insurance company) to
provide the cover. The global accountancy firms of Vetting: prospective counterparties to assess
PricewaterhouseCoopers, Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu, their credit risk. This is the oldest and most basic
Ernst and Young, and KPMG are good examples of means of managing credit risk exposure.
businesses that own captive insurance companies that
provide the firms with professional liability protection for
their audit staff. Self-insurance is also often used to cover EXAMPLE 21: EXTERNAL CREDIT VETTING
employee benefits such as health benefits, in addition to Internal vetting may be supplemented by the purchase of
covering certain types of litigation risks, and may be credit quality information from external providers. For
combined with purchased insurance. Captive insurance small and medium sized firms this may take the form of
companies may retain all of the insured risk or choose to purchase of facilities such as Creditwatch which, in
reinsure a portion of it in the open market. return for a fee, allows the nomination of specific
Securitization: The conversion of financial assets (such businesses on which it provides an alert service to notify
as credit cards, bank loans, and mortgages) or physical creditors of critical events such as the filing of new
assets into financial instruments that can be traded, accounts, court judgements, director resignations etc.
often through the use of special-purpose vehicles. Credit information on large companies or organizations
commonly takes the form of a formal credit rating
Uses: creating the potential to increase the scale of assigned by one of the agencies such as Standard and
business operations through converting relatively Poors or Fitch. Such ratings are based on detailed
illiquid assets into liquid ones. analysis of the companys financial position and
performance, in addition to more general information
Examples of businesses that have been securitized include
about economic and market conditions.
airports, motorway service stations, office accommodation,
and utilities. More recently, firms have begun to securitize
the risks associated with their pension funds. Position limits: imposing limits on the credit to
be granted to any individual counterparty. These
position limits can be both soft and hard; the
EXAMPLE 19: SECURITIZATION OF former would be similar to targets that might
PENSION LIABILITIES occasionally be breached; the latter would be
Companies can now opt to onward sell the liabilities and hard and fast limits that should not be exceeded
the associated risks relating to their final salary/defined under any circumstances.
benefit pension schemes to the UK insurance company Monitoring: Firms should always monitor their
Paternoster via an OTC deal that represents a specialized ongoing credit risk exposures, especially to
form of securitization. Paternoster purchases the counterparties to whom they are heavily exposed.
liabilities. In so doing, it assumes the responsibility Monitoring systems should send warning signals
for paying future pensions. This type of securitization as a counterparty approaches or breaches a
protects firms against the risk of uncertain escalation position limit.
of their pension liabilities, thereby allowing them to Netting arrangements: to ensure that if one
focus on their core business. party defaults, the amounts owed are the net
rather than gross amounts.
Credit enhancement: techniques include periodic
EXAMPLE 20: SECURITIZATION OF settlement of outstanding debts; imposing margin
PHYSICAL ASSETS and collateral requirements, and arranging to make
or receive further collateral payments if one party
The Canary Wharf Group plc has been securitizing
suffers a credit downgrade; purchasing credit
some of its major office block developments since
guarantees from third parties; and credit triggers
1997. Developments that are leased to blue chip
(arrangements to terminate contracts if one partys
clients offer predictable, low risk cashflows, and the
credit rating hits a critical level).
securitization of such high-quality assets gives the
group access to borrowings at prime rates, thus
lowering the overall cost of capital as well as
increasing its potential overall debt capacity.
19
Debt/Equity mix: Finance theory suggests that when
EXAMPLE 24: THOMAS COOK CREDIT LINE levels of long-term debt exceed certain levels, the cost
of capital for a business will increase. So, maintaining
In May 2008 the European based travel company
Thomas Cook announced that it had replaced its an optimal debt/equity mix is vital to maximizing
shareholder wealth. Excessively high ratios also create
existing credit lines with a new 1.8 billion facility
risks because it may lead to breaches of borrowing
intended for use to fund both acquisitions and a share
covenants, which result in additional costs. This risk
buy-back programme. Up to 320 million of the facility
must, however, be weighed against the benefit that
will, however, be dependent upon the successful sale
such debt has a lower cost than equity.
of the companys German airline Condor, to Air Berlin.
Working capital management: Too much capital tied up in EXAMPLE 27: YELL
inventory or accounts receivable puts liquidity pressures on In 2008 there were many examples of companies whose
a company, making it more difficult to take advantage of share price were negatively affected because they were
opportunistic investments. Additionally, debtors and too highly leveraged. One such example is Yell, which
inventory offer no return on capital. On the other hand, publishes print and on-line directories in the UK, US and
cash invested elsewhere in a business could be used to Spain. By July 2008 its share price had fallen to less than
increase earnings. The use of Key Performance Indicators one tenth of its February 2007 value of 645 pence. The fall
for core working capital ratios, and investment in MRP reflected not just the general credit crisis, but specific
systems and other software can also help to maintain concerns about levels of debt within Yell. Analysts noted
maximum access to short-term finance. that with levels of debt ran at 4.9 times the value of equity,
the stock was too highly leveraged for its sector, and there
EXAMPLE 25: EXTENDED PAYMENT TERMS was also some concern the company would soon be in
breach of covenants as a result. In order to avoid such
For smaller companies supplying to large businesses, risks, debt/equity ratios should be selected bearing in
there is sometimes limited control over the payment mind the need for a degree of sensitivity to a collapse in
terms, and this can put severe pressure on working share prices.
capital requirements. For example, in October 2008 the
global retailer Tesco wrote to all of its non-food suppliers
saying that it had changed its payment terms from 30 to
Risk Sharing Strategies
60 days effective December 1st, 2008. The policy change
generates millions of pounds in additional working capital There are no derivatives-based tools available to
for Tesco, but simultaneously deprives its suppliers of manage financing and liquidity risks.
access to that funding. Suppliers therefore needed to
respond by tightening their own working capital controls. Risk Transfer Strategies
Liquidity insurance: insurance against a sudden
Keeping liquid assets: Firms can also protect their ability loss of liquidity which, if not resolved, would endanger
to trade by keeping reserves of easily liquidated assets, a companys ability to continue trading.
such as 90-day notes, that can be liquidated easily and at
low cost if the firm needs additional financing in a hurry.
EXAMPLE 28: LIQUIDITY INSURANCE
EXAMPLE 26: ILLIQUIDITY IN THE
The importance of liquidity insurance is illustrated by the
BANKING SECTOR experience of Countrywide, a US mortgage provider. In
The credit boom was characterized by many banks August 2007, Countrywide faced a run, but claimed on its
choosing to replace low earning traditional liquid assets liquidity insurance to draw down credit lines of
with high earning structured credit products. In the 1960s $11.5 billion, which enabled the bank to continue
holdings of cash or near-cash instruments such as trading. Interestingly, the UK bank Northern Rock
government bonds stood at around 30% of total assets but appeared to hold no such insurance policies.
this proportion fell close to zero near the beginning of the
millennium. As access to inter bank credit began to dry up
in response to the sub-prime crisis, a number of banks
paid the price for their lack of liquidity. Unable to borrow, Tools and Techniques to Control Risk:
even big names on both sides of the Atlantic, such as Summary
Lehman Brothers, Bear Stearns, Bradford and Bingley and The tools and techniques outlined above for managing
HBoS were forced into liquidation or an agreed take-over. financial risks are varied and require different levels of
Even the grandest of names are not immune from liquidity
expertise in their application. There is no single ideal
problems.
answer to the question of How do we manage this
The Need for Clear Hedging Policies and The need for a clear derivatives policy
Understanding of Derivatives Trading
Underlying the above issues, the complexity and potential
Many of the tools discussed in the previous section are dangers involved in the use of derivatives instruments
derivatives, or financial instruments whose payoffs depend make it important for every firm to have a clear derivatives
on the realized values of one or more underlying random policy even if that policy is not to touch them. The need
variables. It is therefore appropriate to offer some further for such a policy is reinforced by the introduction of
advice on how derivatives should (and should not) be used. regulations on accounting for financial instruments within
FAS133 (USA) and IAS 39 (International Accounting
Design of hedging strategies Standards Board), which require the firm to document the
rationale for the use of any derivative and to disclose the
A firm needs to design hedging strategies carefully. Three
costs associated with derivatives hedging. A detailed
important issues that arise especially with derivatives
description of the financial accounting regulations is far
hedging strategies are (a) basis risk, (b) leverage, and
beyond the scope of this MAG, but it is perhaps helpful to
(c)the financing risk implied by any hedging strategy: note that the rules distinguish between derivatives held for
We have noted already that basis risk is the residual speculative or trading purposes and those held for
risk that remains once a position has supposedly hedging. The distinction requires a clear declaration of the
been hedged. Basis risk is almost always a problem, management intent behind holding a financial instrument
but it is especially pronounced in cases such as as a hedge.
credit and catastrophe (cat) derivatives, where An organizations derivatives policy should clearly specify
hedging is hampered by the difficulties of specifying why the firm uses derivatives in the first place assuming it
trigger events that closely match the actual events
does at all. The most obvious reason would be to hedge its
that firms are trying to hedge against. For instance, if
risks, but organizations might also use derivatives for
the catastrophic event in a cat derivative is not
arbitrage purposes (e.g., tax arbitrage) or speculative
carefully chosen, a firm might experience a real
purposes. This said, firms should be careful about using
catastrophe, but not the one specified as calling for a
derivatives positions to speculate or achieve lower funding
derivative payout. The hedge instrument must
costs, because they may be taking on greater risks than
therefore be carefully chosen to avoid excessive
their managers realize. There is after all no such thing as a
basis risk. A hedge with a lot of basis risk is of little
free lunch. A firms derivatives policy should also specify
practical use, and can leave the firm very exposed
which types of derivatives the firm would consider using,
without the firms management being aware of it. As
and which types it will never use. A good rule is never to
the saying goes, the only perfect hedge is in a
engage in derivatives transactions that are not understood
Japanese garden.
by someone in senior management.
Leverage is the gain or loss on a position relative
to the movement of an underlying risk factor.
Many derivatives such as futures and options EXAMPLE 29: PROCTER AND GAMBLE
offer the prospect of high leverage. This can be
A salutary lesson is provided by the experience of
useful because it enables a large position to be
Procter and Gamble in the early 1990s. They entered
hedged by a small one. However, a highly
into a leveraged interest rate swap with Bankers Trust
leveraged position magnifies losses as well as
to reduce their funding costs. However, this
gains: what goes up can also go down.
arrangement entailed a large exposure to US interest
A firm needs to manage any liquidity implications of rates of which Procter & Gambles management was
its risk management strategies. For example, a firm unaware, and the firm got hit badly when US interest
that hedges a forward position with a futures hedge rates subsequently rose. For its part, Bankers Trust
can experience significant liquidity repercussions if was subsequently fined for sharp practice.
the firm faces margin calls on its futures position. In
21
Conclusions are highly rated by many professional players, and are
priced at less than half of their traditional equivalent.
All organizations face financial risks, and their ability to
achieve their objectives (and in some cases even their In contrast to the market for classical instruments, that
survival) depends on how well they manage those risks. for hand-made guitars is growing. In recognition of this,
It is therefore critical to establish a framework that Pietrolunga entered into a joint venture arrangement in
(a) facilitates the identification and quantification of the main 2006 with a US-based company that supplies wood to
types of risk to which a firm is exposed, and (b) sets out the North American luthiers. Under the terms of the joint
main tools and techniques that the firm will use to manage venture agreement, in which costs, income, and profit
those exposures. The importance of financial risk are shared 50:50 between the two parties, Pietrolunga
management is reinforced by the very large losses reported takes responsibility for forestry management and felling,
by many institutions since August 2007, which highlight the while the US party then stores, dries, prepares, and
fact that they still have a long way to go before they can be manages the sale and distribution of the wood. Due to
said to be managing their financial risks adequately. different climatic conditions, the trees grown in the US
Financial risk management does not come cheap, but it is are not the same as those in Italy, although maturity
less expensive than the alternative. cycles are similar. The resulting tonewood is, however,
very well suited to the US guitar market.
Analysis of the accounts of Pietrolunga for the last
Case Study
two years reveals the key statistics as shown in
Pietrolunga is a small stock market-listed Italian timber chart on page 23.
merchant involved in forestry management, timber
All revenue from trade sales and transactions within
production, and the export of specialist woods used in the
mainland Europe are priced in euros, but sales to all other
production of fine musical instruments so-called singing
geographic areas are priced in local currencies. Contract
wood. The company, based in the mountains of Trentino in
prices are fixed on felling the selected trees an average of
the North Italy, has a reputation as the worlds finest
24 months before delivery. It is common practice for
producer of woods for the production of concert-grade
luthiers to use their own experts to select trees while still
grand pianos. Pietrolunga has a thirty-year contract to
growing, as the sound of the tree when knocked with a
supply all of the piano wood requirements for a leading
mallet indicates the quality of the core wood.
manufacturer based in Japan, in addition to numerous
small scale contracts with master luthiers around the world Using just the limited information given above, it is
who specialize in producing high-quality hand-made possible to draft a basic profile of Pietrolungas
classical stringed instruments from violins to double bass. exposure to financial risk, which can then be used as
the basis for developing risk management policies:
The trees used in piano production take around sixty
years to reach the required level of maturity, but the The company is very heavily dependent upon sales
maple used for the backs of the stringed instruments to one single customer and this dependence is
takes much longer, and these trees are more growing, albeit slowly. Under normal circumstances,
susceptible to disease. This long lead time requires this risk would need to be managed downwards, but
careful planning by the staff at Pietrolunga, who face the thirty-year contract term reduces this risk.
huge uncertainties about the long-term demand for such A critical question for a risk manager is how many
items. In addition, significant amounts of working capital years are remaining on the current contract.
are tied up in the forestry stocks because even once 70% of sales in 2006 and 63% of sales in 2007
felled, the slow air-drying processes mean that wood were denominated in foreign currencies,
cannot be sold for several years. therefore exposing the business to a risk of
There is also a high level of uncertainty within the exchange rate movements.
companys current business environment. The primary The bad debts to sales ratio are high at 6% in
geographic market for products is South East Asia, in the 2006, and rose even further in 2007. Credit risk is
countries of Japan, Singapore, and China, but both the clearly a problem.
European and North American markets are in decline, Although the total level of debt is not particularly high
except for cheap student-grade instruments that are now relative to the market capitalization of the company,
being produced in huge numbers under factory conditions in close to one-third of the debt is short term in nature
China. Chinese producers have also gained a foothold in and also at variable rates. This poses both a liquidity
the professional grade of instrument making, by sending and an interest rate risk to Pietrolunga.
staff over to train in the leading instrument-making schools
of Europe, and then using these masters to train local staff
At the 2007 level for short-term debt, even just
back in China. The Chinese instruments are made using
a one per cent increase in the interest rate
local, tropical woods rather than the spruce and maple
would reduce net profits by 2%. In a business
commonly used in Europe, but the resulting instruments
where margins are already being squeezed,
this poses a high risk.
The profit margin has declined from 17.5% in 2006 This list is purely indicative of the types of risks that may be
to 16% in 2007. This suggests a risk of further falls, faced by a company such as Pietrolunga, but can be used
and the causes of the drop need to be identified. to draft a table of risk exposures and possible tools for their
Is it due to pricing pressures in response to control, as shown below. This table can then be used to
foreign competition, or is it a result of increases rank risks using the likelihood of consequences matrix
in production costs, and could any of these risks explained earlier in the Guideline. In this way, efforts can
be hedged? be concentrated on those risks that are the greatest threat
The joint venture in the USA commenced in 2006, but to the business, both short- and long-term.
it is unclear how long it will be before it generates any This simple case study shows the scope for identifying
profits, and how significant these will be relative to risk from even the most basic of information. Managers
profits elsewhere within the business. who understand their business well will be extremely
The company is investing in long-term assets to adept at such an exercise, but they still need a risk
serve a market that is relatively static in global management framework to guide their thinking and help
terms, and also subject to increasing competition them use their knowledge to protect the business. This is
from China. There is a huge risk that the stock of especially important for a company such as Pietrolunga,
trees currently maturing and being newly planted which faces serious long-term risks which the
today will not be required in the same management must take account of.
marketplace in 50 years time. Some form of
contingency planning is therefore needed.
Future sales and profits depend on physical
assets that have long maturity cycles, and are
potentially vulnerable to natural damage from
disease, storms, fires, etc.
23
Nature of Risk Potential Impact on Financial Statements Tools for Control
Dependence upon Massive drop in revenues if contract lost 1) Diversification of customer base, or renegotiation of
single customer contract terms to guarantee annual extension subject to
Potentially crippling bad debt if payment preset mutually agreed criteria.
problems emerge 2) Regular updating of credit checks
3) Credit insurance
Significant proportion of Foreign exchange transaction losses/gains 1) Natural hedging via diversification of currencies receivable
sales denominated in (already being done) or invoicing in euros rather than the
foreign currencies customers currency
2) Purchase of forward or option contracts. Futures are not
applicable here because of relatively small contract sizes.
Contract prices agreed Foreign exchange losses/gains 1) Use of staged payment clauses in contracts to reduce the
2 years before delivery date period of exposure to basis risk. e.g., 10% on felling;
additional 20% after 12 months, and balance upon delivery.
2) Insertion of price adjustment clauses to revise prices
according to the movement in a defined price index over t
he period between felling and delivery.
US-based joint venture Foreign exchange losses/gains Currently, the venture may require net investment until the
first trees reach maturity. The purchase of dollar-denominated
assets could be funded through reinvestment of existing dollar
revenues, or via a dollar-denominated loan that can be repaid
with future proceeds from the venture.
Interest rate risk Earnings volatility 1) Renegotiation of the loan to include a cap/collar, or both.
2) Conversion to fixed rate medium-term debt.
3) Negotiation of an interest rate swap.
High level of bad debts Reduction in current assets 1) Customer profiling, based upon data analysis of the
characteristics of bad debtors in terms of geographic location,
Cash flow problems size of business, length of trading period, etc. This could be
done in-house via the purchase of basic profiling software,
Reduced profits or could be outsourced to a credit agency.
2) Credit insurance
3) Introduction of a credit scoring system for new customers
4) Deposit requirements for orders from specified customers
or below a certain size.
Falling profit margin Reduced profit 1) Clarification of pricing strategies and benchmarking of
prices and costs relative to key competitors.
Lower EPS and dividends per share 2) Negotiation of open-book arrangements with the
Japanese customer, to ensure consistency of margins on
Reduced potential to continue trading the main contract
if this persists over the long term 3) Sales and leaseback of forestry to release cash and reduce
capital requirements.
Vulnerability to a long-term Falling profits, erosion of reserves and the 1) Market diversification- reputation is for high-quality wood,
declining market ultimate demise of the business but is there scope for lower quality faster turnaround
production?
2) Joint venture with a Chinese company to supply lower
grade markets but at high volumes.
3) Review of the potential non-musical instrument markets
e.g., bespoke furniture
Vulnerable physical assets 1) Insurance
2) Securitization
3) Dispersal of forest assets across different regions of the world
Collar: a position created by buying a call (put) and selling Hedging: a transaction to reduce or eliminate
a put (call) option, or a cap and a floor if applied to interest and exposure to risk.
rate options. The premium earned from selling one option Historical simulation approach to VaR: an approach
helps to reduce (or even eliminate) the cost of the position. that estimates VaR from a profit and loss distribution
Correlation: a measure of the extent to which that is simulated using historical returns data.
movements in two variables are related. Leverage: the gain or loss on a position relative to
Credit derivatives: derivatives contracts with the gain or loss on the underlying risk factor.
payoffs contingent on credit events. Liquidity: the ability to unwind a position at little or no
Credit exposure: the total amount of credit granted cost. The availability of sufficient funds to meet
to a counterparty. financial commitments when they fall due.
Credit risk: the risk of loss arising from the failure Liquidity risk: the risks arising from the potential cost
of a counterparty to make a contractual payment. or inconvenience of unwinding a position. Liquidity risk
can apply to market liquidity (the risk that a market may
Credit scoring: assessment of the creditworthiness of become less liquid) and funding risk (which is the risk
an individual or company by rating numerically a number that an individual firm will not be able to meet an
of both financial and non-financial aspects of the targets obligation when it comes due).
present position and previous performance.
Margin requirements: deposits required against
Default risk: See Credit risk. the taking of risky positions.
Default-value-at-risk (Default-VaR): the largest Market (price) risks: the risks of loss arising from
likely loss from counterparty default over some adverse movements in market prices.
period and at a particular level of confidence.
Marking to market: the process of valuing and
Delta: the change in the value of a derivatives periodically revaluing positions in marketable
contract associated with a small change in the price securities to reflect their current market prices.
of the underlying.
Maximum loss optimization: a form of stress testing in
Derivatives: contracts whose values depend on the which risk factors are pushed in the most
prices of one or more other variables, known as disadvantageous directions, and then the combined
underlying variables. effect of all such changes on the portfolio are assessed.
Enterprise-wide risk management (ERM): the Monte Carlo simulation approaches to VaR: approaches
management of overall institutional risk across all that estimate VaR from a distribution of future portfolio
risk categories and business units. values that is simulated using random number techniques.
25
Netting arrangements: arrangements by which the Risk appetite: the amount of risk an organization is
parties in multiple bilateral contracts agree to owe each willing to accept in pursuit of its objectives.
other the net rather than gross amounts involved.
RiskMetrics: the analytical framework developed
Normal approach to VaR: approaches that estimate by JP Morgan to estimate VaR.
VaR on the assumption that the portfolio is a linear
Scenario analysis: a form of stress testing that
function of normally distributed risk variables.
focuses on the impact of one or more specified
Normal distribution: the Gaussian or bell- scenarios or particular states of the world.
curve probability distribution.
Scenario simulation: a procedure that uses the
Operational risks: risks arising from the failure of distribution of principal factors to simulate the
internal systems or the people who operate in them. distribution of the future portfolio value.
Option: a contract that gives the holder the right but Speculation: the process of increasing risks.
not the obligation, depending on the type of option, to
Speculative position: a position that increases risks.
buy or sell a particular commodity or asset on pre-
agreed terms. European options give the holder the Stress testing: the process of assessing the vulnerability
right to exercise the option at a particular future date, of a position or portfolio against hypothetical events.
while American options give the holder the right to
exercise at any time over a particular period. Options Swaps: agreements to swap future cash flows.
can be traded on organized exchanges (exchange- Underlying: the variable on which the payoff to
traded) or traded over-the-counter (OTC). a derivatives contract depends.
Performance evaluation: ex post risk adjustment Value-at-Risk (VaR): the maximum likely loss over some
(i.e., risk adjustment after the risks have been taken). particular holding period at a particular level of confidence.
Position limits: management-imposed limits on the Variance-co-variance approaches to VaR: approaches to
sizes of the positions that traders or asset managers are estimating VaR that make use of the variance-co-variance
allowed to take. matrix of the asset returns. These are a form of parametric
Put option: option to sell a specified underlying asset VaR method that takes account of the returns to the
at a specified exercise price on or before a specified individual asset that make up a portfolio.
exercise date. See also Call option and Option. Volatility: the variability of a price, usually interpreted
Recovery rate: the proportion of money owing as its standard deviation.
recovered from a debtor in the event of bankruptcy. Worst-case scenario analysis: a form of stress
Regression analysis: a statistical procedure that testing that estimates the worst of a number of events
seeks to estimate a relationship between one variable expected to occur over some particular period.
and one or more others.
Risk: the prospect of gain or loss. Risk is usually Endnotes
regarded as quantifiable, and is often compared against
1 Detailed discussion of such a framework lies
uncertainty, which is not quantifiable.
outside the scope of this MAG, but general
Risk-adjusted return on capital (RAROC): the ratio guidance on how to establish a risk management
of return to VaR. system is contained in Risk Management: A Guide
to Good Practice (CIMA, 2002).
Risk adjustment: in general, the process of adjusting
returns for the risks involved. However, the term is usually 2 We also gloss over the issue of how to determine
used to refer more specifically to ex ante risk adjustment the size of the hedge position, but this is covered in
(i.e., to adjustments before the risks are actually taken). all standard textbooks on the subject.
Adams, J. Risk. London: UCL Press, 1995. Collier, P. M., A. J. Berry, and G. T. Burke. Risk and
Management Accounting: Best Practice Guidelines
Alexander, C. O., and E. Sheedy (eds). The
for Enterprise-wide Internal Control Procedures.
Professional Risk Managers Handbook: A
Oxford/Elsevier: CIMA Publishing, 2007.
Comprehensive Guide to Current Theory and Best
Practices. PRMIA Professional Risk Manager, 2004. Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway
Commission (COSO). Enterprise Risk Management
Campbell, T. S., and W. A. Kracaw. Financial Risk
Integrated Framework, 2004. www.coso.org.
Management: Fixed Income and Foreign Exchange.
New York: HarperCollins College Publishers, 1993. Crouhy, M., D. Galai, and R. Mark. The Essentials of
Risk Management: The Definitive Guide to the Non-
Chance, D. Essays in Derivatives. New Hope (PA): Frank J.
Risk Professional. New York: McGraw-Hill, 2006.
Fabozzi Associates, 1998.
Group of Thirty. Derivatives: Practices and Principles.
Chartered Institute of Management Accountants.
New York: Group of Thirty, 1993.
Risk Management: A Guide to Good Practice.
London: CIMA Publishing, 2002. Institute of Risk Management. A Risk
Management Standard. London: IRM, 2002.
Chew, L. Managing Derivative Risks: The Uses
and Abuses of Leverage. Chichester: John Wiley &
Sons, 1996.
Colllier, P. M., and S. Agyei-Ampomah. Management
Accounting Risk and Control Strategy.
Oxford/Elsevier: CIMA Publishing, 2007.
27
This Management Accounting Guideline was prepared with the advice and counsel of:
Richard Benn, CMA, FCMA, CPFA Calvin D. MacIntosh, MBA, CMA, FCMA
Executive Vice President, Member Development Chief Administrative Officer
CMA Canada Professional Loss Control
Julie Davis, ACMA Denise Metcalf, MBA
Senior Management Retail Manager of Innovation & Development Services
Group Internal Audit & Risk Management Chartered Institute of Management Accountants
Alliance Boots Jim Morrison, CFO
Joe Di Rollo, BA, ACMA, MCT Teknor Apex
Founder and Director Todd Scaletta, MBA, CMA, FCMA
Almis International
Director, Knowledge Management
Mark Dixon, ACMA CMA Canada
UK CNS Finance Lead David Stebbings
Hewitt Associates
Director
Helenne Doody, ACA Head of Treasury Advisory UK
Innovation and Development Specialist PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP
Chartered Institute of Management Accountants Kenneth W. Witt, CPA
Michael Fortini, CPA Technical Manager, Business, Industry & Government
Director of Compliance American Institute of Certified Public Accountants
Pearson plc
Brian Freeman, FCMA
Management Finance Director
Haymarket Media Group Ltd.
29
For more information on other products available contact: