Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
ABSTRACT INTBODUCTION
The Dual Spacing Thermal Neutron, Decay Time log provides measurements The Dual Spacing Thermal Neutron Decay Time loglprotides Sigma (E) and
useful for cased-hole formation evaluation. This paper preser,ts the Tau (T) measurements,* as did earlier TDT” tools.* With the addition of
fcllowing examples cf its application in Texas Ccast wells:
1L. Detection of oil and gas which has migrated into a water sand
( Example VI-B ).
-l-
SPWLA FIFTEENTH ANNUAL LOGGING SYMPOSIUM, JUNE 2-5, 1974
-1201 +
.——,
c 1
i
GAS -- #
-&- — ~ q-
0
0
0
——.
A .
8
0
FIG .1-A, TYPICAL DUAL SPACING TDT EXAMPLE TO ILLUSTRATE GAS-OIL &
OIL-WATER CONTACTS
-2-
SPWLA FIFTEENTH ANNUAL LOGGING SYMPOSIUM, JUNE 2-5, 1974
The three Dual Spacing TDT measurements which respond to fluid type and
saturation changes, when porosity, water salinity , ad lithology are-constant,
are Sigma, Ratio, and the IJ1-F1Display. 7jpical responses for various con-
ditions of fluid saturation are illustrated in Fig. I-A and listed in Table 1.
TABLE 1
I Porosity**
I
I Sigma
Value
from Ratio
and Sigma
I N1-F1 Display
L_cl
I
tion (1 to 3
1 log divisions)
-3-
SPWLA FIFTEENTH ANNUAL LOGGING SYMPOSIUM, JUNE 2-5, 1974
E
BACKGROUND
FAR CQS E- capture units (cu * 103 cm*/cm’)
------ ------ 100 .
TRACEDSP
G
FIG. I-B. USING DUAL SPACING TDT TO CHOOSE A GAS OR OIL RECOMPLETION
FROM A SERIES OF PRODUCTIVE SANDS.
-4-
SPWLA FIFTEENTH ANNUAL LOGGING SYMPOSIUM, JUNE 2-5, 1974
The two zones marked “A” on the example are indicated to be gas by N1-F1
separation and low Sigma values. Log interpretation indicated the two zones
marked “B” on the example are oil. Zone “C” is water,
Zone A at 6332 to 6338 ft. was perforated and tested. The test results
were 805 Mcf/D gas, 4.7 BOPD with 58.20 API gravityj and no water. Gas/oi1
ratio was 172,000/1. This test confirmed the log analysis, and the operator
made a successful recompletion.
Another sand below the section of log shown in Fig. I-B was thought by
the operator to have 16 feet of pay in this section of the field. The Dual
Spacing TDT showed the sand to be depleted to water. This information in-
fluenced the operator’s planning on several wells.
-5-
SPWLA FIFTEENTH ANNUAL LOGGING SYMPOSIUM, JUNE 2-5, 1974
TUBINC
●
✜ ?
T
.. ??
. :.’!
: .“ ,.-.,
!.
!. ,.!
POCKET !.
:;
.. .
,,. .. .
J . . . .
-6-
SPWLA FIFTEENTH ANNUAL LOGGING SYMPOSIUM, JUNE 2-5, 1974
;----:::------’%+=
0=33 ;<1
%tJ’loo
-8-
SPWLA FIFTEENTH ANNUAL LOGGING SYMPOSIUM, JUNE 2-5, 1974
As in Example II-A, the Nl, Fl, and Sigma readings are interpreted to
detect gas and to determine whether it is in the formation or in the bore-
hole.
The operator elected to perforate Zone A for a test. The zone pro-
duced a blow of gas and a large volume of salt water. It was squeezed,
re-perforated, and tested again. This test produced 100 percent salt
water with no show of gas.
-9-
SPWLA FIFTEENTH ANNUAL LOGGING SYMPOSIUM, JUNE 2-5, 1974
---’’T’-----’-
GAMMA RAY N , cps
API UNITS MO
) 7
/
2“
7,’
.
n
1
.
m
z
<“
.;
: ...... :
A -
FIG, II-C. DUAL SPACING TDT DETECTS GAS CHANNELING BEHIND CASING
IN A PRODUCING WELL.
-1o-
SPWLA FIFTEENTH ANNUAL LOGGING SYMPOSIUM, JUNE 2-5, 1974
The Dual Spacing TM’ log of Fig. II-C was run to determine the gas-oil
and oil-water contacts in the reservoir at 6,880 to 7,080 ft. At the time
of logging, this well was producing gas and oil with a high water cut
through a screen set in open hole below the 7-in. casing. A well sketch
is shown at the left edge of Fig. II-C.
The first logging run was made with the well shut in. A positive in-
dication of the gas-oil contact is shown at 6,958 ft. by the N1-l?loverlay.
A further indication of gas in the formation is a reduction in Sigma and
Ratio above 6,958 ft.
After the shut-in log had been recorded, the well was put back on
production. After the well was produced for two hours an overlap log
was run with the well still flowing.
It is also noted on the log of Fig. II-C that F3 shows a marked in-
crease on the flowing log. The cause of this F3 response is not fully
understood; it is believed to be a function of geomet~ and size of the
channel. As additional experience is gained, this F3 response should
become more meaningful.
-11-
SPWLA FIFTEENTH ANNUAL LOGGING SYMPOSIUM, JUNE 2-5, 1974
#-
,?
NEUTRON CAPTIRE CROSS SECTION
C - copturo units (cu . 16scm*/cm*)
)------ ------ -- IQQ $5 3,0 I I Q
TR&ED SP RATIO isT FI- CJS
----- ——.
~loo~ :------ .-- —___ . ~ N, CP8 (
“.
,
2
‘t
: RATIO ‘~
,’ TRACED
\;” SIGMA
: --’- .*
‘, L,*
:
<
/<“
h 0$
?4213, -~
.
,
,:
!
:
‘.
1
i
‘s
#’
,’
\
}
,
i
:,
#
.‘,
‘..
:
,
,
t
;
$.
,’
)
:
1’
‘.
‘1
:
I
:
~
.
j
,
;
~.
);
:
1
,
:
:
‘.
.!
‘1
FIG.111-A. DUAL SPACING TOT IDENTIFIES GAS IN SHALLOW LOW SALINITY FORMATIONS,
-12-
SPWLA FIFTEENTH ANNUAL LOGGING SYMPOSIUM, JUNE 2-5, 1974
LOW-SALINITY FORMATIONS
In the upper part of Zone C the N1-F1 Display again shows gas sep-
aration (F1>N1). A calculation of water saturation by the porosity-
index-ratio method yields ~= 78 percent. This interval was not tested
because of the high water cut predicted.
-13-
SPWLA FIFTEENTH ANNUAL LOGGING SYMPOSIUM, JUNE 2-5, 1974
IEPTI
EPT}
-14-
SPWLA FIFTEENTH ANNUAL LOGGING SYMPOSIUM, JUNE 2-5, 1974
Sands of the Texas Coast Miocene and Oligocene Series are frequently shaly.
As with other logging devices the effect of shaliness on the readings of the
Dual Spacing TIYTis in proportion to the amount of shale present. The shale
responses of the various measurements can be summarized for Texas Coast for-
mations as follows:
Sigma--The higher Sigma values occur in shales. Sands have lower Sigma
values which depend on fluid type and salinity.
Ratio--Shales are indicated by the higher Ratio values. Sands are in-
— dicatedby lower values depending mainly on porosity.
Gamma Ray Log--Shales generally show the higher Gamma Ray readings, and
sands the lower.
Fig. III-B is representative of Texas Coast shaly sands. Note that the
SP on the Electric Log (right) indicates a number of sands. The maximum
resistivity noted is 2 ohm-m in Zone D. The minimum resistivity is 1 ohm-m
in Zone C. The Gamma Ray log shown on the Dual Spacing TDT (left) exhibits
very little contrast between shales and sands,
In Zones A, C, and D, Sigma reads the same, as also does Ratio. However,
in Zone B Sigma measures three C.U. more than in the other zones. Calculated
values of water saturation, shown on the log, indicate Zone B to be water
filled. Calculations in Zones A, C, end D indicate potentially productive
shaly sands.
Zone A - 3 ft. of sand, bearing gas, or oil with a high gas-oil ratio
Zone B - Wet
Zone C - 9 ft. of sand, bearing gas, or oil with a high gas-oil ratio
Zone D - 15 ft. of sand, bearing gas
Zone A was perforated from 8,070 to 8,074 ft. Initially this interval
produced 400 Mcf/D gas with no water. The production rate rapidly declined
to 50 Mcf/D, so the zone was abandoned. Subsequently, Zone Dwas perforated I
at 7,938-48 ft. Production from these perforations was 400 Mcf/D gas with
650 psi flowing tubing pressure. Production has continued at this rate
since April, 1973.
-15-
SPWLA FIFTEENTH ANNUAL LOGGING SYMPOSIUM, JUNE 2-5, 1974
T
)F
SP RATlO-+;’
k-s
,:
\ 6657
)
i
A~ 6661 ~;~
;
i $
:
\ <
-;
. ~.
: ----
; - .-:,
:
,:
:,
2
●
>
;
) . 8725 ‘:<
< 1.15 MMcf/D
; d 8729
. -,
: ;>
1 .- .s
:
‘3
---- ---
#.-
:. ---
---.,
: -.
) I .~-
! -----
! .--,
: ●.,..’
I
PRODUCTIONTES
~
\
;
r
\ ,
e-:---”
,. ~,
-.:,
[ ‘:;=
-16-
SPWLA FIFTEENTH ANNUAL LOGGING SYMPOSIUM, JUNE 2-5, 1974
Fig. III-C illustrates the Dual Spacing TDT’s ability to qualitatively in-
dicate gas in low-resistivi.tysands. Note the N1-F1 Display in Zones A, B,
and C. Each zone shows a separation indicating gas. Qualitatively, Zones A
and B have larger gas separations than Zone C.
Some of these sands can produce water-free hydrocarbons even though the
values of water saturation calculated from the logs appear abnormally high.
The magnitude of gas separation on the N1-F1 Display serves to direct the
log analyst’s attention to potentially productive zones.
Zone B, perforated from 8,725 to 8,729 ft. tested 1.15 MMcf/D gas,
no water.
Zone A, perforated from 8,657 to 8,661 ft. tested 1.4 MMcf/D gas,
no water.
Completion was made as a dual gas well in Zones A and B. These zones
had not been considered as candidates for recompletion prior to logging
with Dual Spacing TIYT,
-17-
SPWLA FIFTEENTH ANNUAL LOGGING SYMPOSIUM, JUNE 2-5, 1974
<-
,.
I------------.
WCTION
-
) Mcro NlxmOl
------------- Y -__----___.--
E
,< SN
%...->
,>-
~_____
-,=
.,
.-
,-. ..
:>
‘.,
INDUCTION
Um Pa?OsllY f .J “.. .
:t
‘ “e.- .P
: L—.._——
.3
>.
----
.. ---3 ‘:
:
,’
K
F.-:.,
,.>
-----
.
.?
..
)
,--4
L
. . .-.=
%
{
:: ‘
i,
,1..
,.. ,
s“
$.,
. . . .<
,..
---- . . . . . .. .
*- . . . . . t.
z=--
-==-
. . .--.:.. ..._.
-.
---- .-. .
5
.-
,2
*
FIG. IV-A. DLJAL SPACING TDT EXHIBITS DIFFERENT RESPONSE FOR GAS SANDS
vERSUS LOW FOROSITY SANDS.
-18-
SPWLA FIFTEENTH ANNUAL LOGGING SYMPOSIUM, JUNE 2-5, 1974
The Ratio end Sigma measurements recorded with Dual Spacing TDT are used
in an appropriate crossplot to determine a Ratio porosity. This Ratio
porosity is similar to the porosity index of a conventional Neutron log;
because, each is a measure of the formation Hydrogen Index. Therefore,
Ratio porosity has the same limitation as conventional Neutron porosity
index. However, with Dual Spacing TDT this limitation is overcome by using
N1-F1 Display to differentiate low-porosity sands from gas sands. In gas
sands N1-F1 displays a typical gas signature. In low-porosity water sands
N1 and FI count rates are both reduced. Fig, IV-A illustrates this res-
ponse. Zone A has a gas signature consisting of low Sigma, low Ratio, and
positive separation on N1-F1 display. The M?crolog* indicates this zone
to have good porosity.
Note that the Microlog also indicates low porosity in several other
zones which have a low-porosity signature on the Dual Spacing TDT.
* Trademark of Schlumberger.
-19-
SPWLA FIFTEENTH ANNUAL LOGGING SYMPOSIUM, JUNE 2-5, 1974
EACKGROWD
F,
WA
.— ___ -. Kx in
w
) NORMAL IO ~
MICROLOG
=!
GAw#A:N~Y ) I LATERAL 5 5“ I
,.,
RATIO
“
Qi’--------- L _JNJ2gcIW----
[
,-----------
Cco NI ). - —________ NORMAL ----
______
I 4
3 \ !
‘.,.
....
,.
$--
....~
.------ ”-
,>
*
RATIO j
.
u L
—
.- .
--
.--—
‘:: /’ SIZE ;
..-
,
B \
,
~
) ..
----=
..=---
‘%-
.----
.:.
w
,,-
,.‘“>
t.
>
% ...
.,
,’
ii :
‘.:
-, .. -“
{->
<,
.___ —————
I >
.
A ‘::3 .-* 1
.. a
‘:., *.>
,,‘.
L-
:
‘. ,’
,,
>
g
8
FIG. IV-B. THE MATRIX EFFECT OF CARBONATES ON DUAL SPACING TDT RESPONSE.
-20-
SPWLA FIFTEENTH ANNUAL LOGGING SYMPOSIUM, JUNE 2-5, 1974
These “limy” streaks cause a response on Dual Spacing TDT similar to that
of a gas sand, To differentiate lime sections from gas sands the log analyst
must refer to a Gamma Ray-SP comparison, the porosity from an open-hole
logging device, or a core description,
Zone A of Fig. IV-B is a carbonate section, The electric log and Micro-
log exhibit the typically high resistivities measured in carbonates. The
Gamma Ray in Zone A has the low radiation levels normally seen in carbonates.
A comparison of the Gamma Ray in Zone A with that in the high-porosity sand
of Zone B shows the differing radiation levels, normally seen between sands
and carbonates,in Texas Coast.
-21-
SPWLA FIFTEENTH ANNUAL LOGGING SYMPOSIUM, JUNE 2-5, 1974
)3 m 8 ;
--- ‘--- --
= ‘------
=... __
CONDWTIVITY
TRACED
s?
‘)-’‘,
,!
18” NORMAL
b~R& ~ ..
?!!?
<
__-__-_--—
k PRmuTm
Mu
TW
WIw
CN VAWUM.
*ANDONEO
-22-
SPWLA FIFTEENTH ANNUAL LOGGING SYMPOSIUM, JUNE 2-5, 1974
The operator tested the interval 4,411 to 4,421 ft. When this inter-
val was perforated the well “went on vacuum”. The operator estimated the
formation pressure to be 200 psi. Zone A was abandoned.
The Dual Spacing TDT shows the bottom 35 ft. of Zone B to be oil, with
the gas/oil contact at 4,236 ft. The operator perforated from 4,264 to
4,270 ft.
This interval has been pumping 22 BOPD with no water and no measurable
gas since October, 1972.
-23-
BACKGROUND NEUTRON CAPTURE CROSS SECTION INDUCTION ELECTRICLOG MI CROLOG
r
>
FAR cps X- apture units (c.=ltiacm ‘\cm’ ) ohm - m*/m duns - ins/m n
n
).—— - ____ ____ Iooc- w +0 ~ -1
Q
m
I 16” NORMAL I ) MICRO INVERSE 1‘Xl “
!!
SPONTANEOUS POTENTIAL RAT10 F, C.P5 -1
i.— P —--- -——- —.— 1 AMPLIFIED 16” NORMAL :
-——— MICRO
I NORMAL
—____ 2“____
_ ___ ___ ___
N1
DQ2 L ___l~Ojq_____]
,# r
‘1
,
.
N
I&
H- ,
:
,.
,
:
:
:
I
L
c
z
,.’ ‘1
b
;
;
I
{
-------- ---
;
,
;
!
,
;
.,’ <
,“
,
,,;
:
.’
, .-:
I
..-:
,
‘t +-
:
{ -5
‘1
..
*.
:
After ten years of oil production the reservoir pressure had declined about
800 psi. About the same time, the gas-oil ratio of structurally higher wells
began to increase. From this the operator deduced that the reservoir had only
a limited water-drive which was not enough to keep up with the oil-production
rate, and, as a result, the gas cap was expanding. This prompted the operator
to initiate water injection into structurally low wells for pressure main-
tenance.
After six years of water injection, the pressure decline had stopped and a
50-psi increase in reservoir pressure was achieved. At this time the operator
ran a Dual Spacing TDT to determine the gas-oil contact,
The Dual Spacing TIM’in Fig. V-B shows the gas-oil contact at 6,646 ft.
Subsequent Dual Spacing TDT logs will be run on the well to monitor stabiliz-
ation of the contact and also to detect the oil-water contact as it moves
into this area of the reservoir. Greatly improved oil recovery should be
assured by such an injection and monitoring process.
-25-
SPWLA FIFTEENTH ANNUAL LOGGING SYMPOSIUM, JUNE 2-5, 1974
m )
------ Induction
----- ---- q
‘p\
ii
OFFSET
% w
.-J
l-----k
l————%T—
&==--l
=i-
FIG, v-C, THE USE OF DUAL SPACING TDT INSIDE STUCK DRILL PIPE AS A CORRELATION LOG
-26-
SPWLA FIFTEENTH ANNUAL LOGGING SYMPOSIUM, JUNE 2-5, 1974
Fig. V-C shows a section of a Dual Spacing TDT log which was run through
drill pipe and the Induction Electric log in an offset well. The mud in
this well was heavily gas-cut, and the well was trying to blow out.
For clarity of presentation, not all of the curves normally recorded are
shown in Fig. V-C, just those useful to illustrate the correlation. The
SP end Tau curves have been shaded in several areas to indicate correlative
zones. Through this correlation the operator was able to determine the
relative structural position of the well.
-27-
SPWLA FIFTEENTH ANNUAL LOGGING SYMPOSIUM, JUNE 2-5, 1974
-9
%
)(
AS-OIL CONTMT ‘? I
..— — 74
E 6-72
i
,,-
<,
c
,7
.0
,. >
5“>
{
n
PRODUCTION
433 BOPD
204 BWPD
1799 GoR
\
e.
-.
. ..-”.
FIG. VI -A, DETECTION OF GAS-OIL CONTACTS IN RESERVOIRS WHERE OIL HAS MIGRATED
INTO THE GAS CAP.
-28-
SPWLA FIFTEENTH ANNUAL LOGGING SYMPOSIUM, JUNE 2-5, 1974
Fig. VI-A shows a Dual Spacing TDT which was run through several reser-
voirs where gas-cap shrinkage and updip oil migration are known to exist.
Zones A, B, C, and Dwere known to be gas-filled as late as 1971.
-29-
AM? SHORT NORMAL 0
BACK6RCUND m NEUTRON CAPTURE CROSS SECTION
SPONTANEOUS POTENTIAL 4 F5 Cps T E-cooture units (cu=lfJ3cmZ/cm3) -n
+ —
millivolts z
16’’NORMAL ~~ -------------- Icm 60 30 0 -n
•1
0+ RATIO m
64’’NORMAL G~WA RAY m
+ v- .—— ———------- API Umts la) —--— ———————
z
-1
) I
\
GAMMA RAY >
.._- z
+ ~_—— RATIO z
SP c
J
9
;. r
‘. . r
----:.
1 ,,
-.
> , .*
1 v! :
$? 1 2 .. ..
8 0 --,
:
>
?<
.--- ..>
.— / —-
A I A ‘i-;:;”
-----
c
z
m
I .-.
1
!!!
t
I I <“--~
-;-- I /
FIG. VI-B. DUAL SPACING TDT FINDS GAS 8 OIL WHlc H HAS MIGRATEo
INTO A WATER SAND
SPWLA FIFTEENTH ANNUAL LOGGING SYMPOSIUM, JUNE 2-5, 1974
Some of the more common ways that formation fluids can migrate from one
reservoir to another are:
The Dual Spacing TDT has located and identified fluids in formations
where they were neither known nor suspected to be present.
The Induction Log, of Fig. VI-B, was run in 1955. It shows Zone A to
be a water sand. The Dual Spacing TDT, run in 1972, shows that gas and
oil have migrated into Zone A and that it now has a gas-oil contact at
5,751 ft.
The increase in the gas/oil ratio during this test indicates that gas was
probably coning into the perforations, Even though the oil zone in this
well was too thin to produce, knowledge of this migration was useful in other
parts of the field.
-31-
SPWLA FIFTEENTH ANNUAL LOGGING SYMPOSIUM, JUNE 2-5, 1974
CONCLUSION
This paper presents some of the experience gained during two years of
field operation with the Dual Spacing TDT. The addition of a second
detector to the Thermal Neutron Decay Time tool has greatly improved its
usefulness and versatility.
The major use of Dual Spacing TDT in the Texas Coast has been to find
oil. In this paper most of the discussion has been directed to gas
identification. The implication is that in most cases identification of
the gas zones facilitates the production of oil.
ACKNOWLEDGMEhJT
The authors wish to thank the several oil companies who graciously
contributed the examples and production data for this paper. A publication
of this type would be impossible without the cooperation of oil company
personnel.
REFERENCES
-32-