Sunteți pe pagina 1din 5

Feature Articles

Pertussis: Severe clinical presentation in pediatric intensive care


and its relation to outcome*
Poongundran Namachivayam, MRCPCH; Kazuyoshi Shimizu, MD; Warwick Butt, FRACP, FJFICM

Objective: To describe our institutional experience in the man- sented earlier (p ⴝ .001), had longer intensive care stay (p ⴝ
agement of infants and children with pertussis admitted during a .007), higher white cell count (p < .001), lower PaO2 at admission
20-yr period (January 1985 through December 2004) and also to (p ⴝ .020), and higher mortality. Six infants out of seven needing
study the relation between method of presentation and outcome. circulatory support died (including all four treated with extracor-
Setting: Pediatric intensive care unit in a university-affiliated poreal membrane oxygenation), and all deaths (n ⴝ 7) occurred in
tertiary pediatric hospital in Melbourne, Australia. infants who had pneumonia at presentation.
Design/Methods: Retrospective review of medical records and Conclusion: Patients with pertussis, presenting as apnea (with
radiology reports of patients with a diagnosis of pertussis iden- or without cough paroxysms), treated in the pediatric intensive
tified from the pediatric intensive care unit database. care unit had 100% survival. However, pneumonia as the main
Results: A total of 49 patients (median age, 6 wks; interquartile reason for admission and the need for circulatory support is
range, 4 – 8 wks) required 55 admission episodes to the pediatric associated with a very poor outcome. A deeper understanding of
intensive care unit. Main reasons for admission were apnea with the molecular basis of Bordetella pertussis and its relation to the
or without cough paroxysms (63%), pneumonia (18%), and sei- human host might offer means for future therapies. (Pediatr Crit
zures (10%). None of the infants had completed the primary Care Med 2007; 8:207–211)
course of immunization, and 94% had not received a single dose KEY WORDS: pertussis; intensive care; children; outcome; pre-
of pertussis vaccine. Infants presenting with pneumonia pre- sentation; ventilation

P ertussis continues to be a sig- cinated (3, 4). Most of the serious com- port mechanical ventilation rates at 54%
nificant cause of childhood plications and deaths related to pertussis and 42%, respectively (4, 9), and recent
morbidity and mortality, giv- are seen in this age group (5). There is articles highlight poor outcome for pa-
ing rise to 200,000 – 400,000 general agreement that the disease is tients with severe pertussis needing ex-
deaths every year, mostly in developing toxin mediated, and antibiotics limit the tracorporeal membrane oxygenation
countries (1). The recent increase in the severity of illness only when started early (ECMO) (10, 11). Understanding the
rate of pertussis is related to short-lived in the disease process (6). Pertussis toxin mode of presentation could be crucial in
infection and vaccine-induced immunity, damages the respiratory epithelium and the subsequent management and even-
rendering adolescents and adults suscep- can also produce profound systemic and tual outcome of these children. In this
tible to reinfection (2). This reservoir of neurotoxicity. article, we offer a single intensive care
infection maintained in the adolescent Infants needing intensive care pre- unit’s experience of the management and
population subsequently causes infection dominantly present with apneas with or outcome of severe pertussis based on a
in susceptible infants, who are too young without cough paroxysms, pneumonia, review of children during a 20-yr period.
to be fully vaccinated. More than half of and seizures, and a small proportion
the severe cases requiring intensive care progress to severe respiratory failure, METHODS AND PATIENTS
manifests in infants too young to be vac- complicated by pulmonary hypertension
(7). Younger infants may also present Infants and children admitted with a diag-
with a rapid progression of disease that is nosis of pertussis to the pediatric intensive
care unit (PICU) in Royal Children’s Hospital,
*See also p. 288. so compressed and severe that the classic
From the Intensive Care Unit, The Royal Children’s Melbourne, during a 20-yr period (January
stages may not be evident. Intensive care
Hospital, Melbourne, Australia (PN, KS, WB); and the 1985 through December 2004) were included
Department of Pediatrics, University of Melbourne, management of pertussis is mainly sup-
in the study. Royal Children’s Hospital is a
Australia (WB). portive (suction, oxygen, nasal continu- specialized pediatric hospital serving a popu-
The authors have not disclosed any potential con- ous positive airway pressure, intermittent lation of 5 million in the states of Victoria,
flicts of interest. positive pressure ventilation). A recent
For information regarding this article, E-mail: Tasmania, and southern New South Wales. All
siva.namachivayam@rch.org.au
nationwide survey in Australia (8) showed patients with PICU admission or discharge di-
Copyright © 2007 by the Society of Critical Care that intensive care was provided for 18% agnosis of pertussis were identified from the
Medicine and the World Federation of Pediatric Inten- of infants diagnosed with pertussis, and PICU database using the Australian and New
sive and Critical Care Societies 56% of these infants needed intubation Zealand pediatric intensive care diagnostic
DOI: 10.1097/01.PCC.0000265499.50592.37 and ventilation. Two previous reviews re- codes. Case histories were studied in detail by

Pediatr Crit Care Med 2007 Vol. 8, No. 3 207


the authors (PN, KS). Additional information RESULTS apnea group was considerably shorter
was also obtained from the PICU database and in comparison with the pneumonia
from radiology reports. Cases with either con- A total of 49 infants and children (24 group (p ⫽ .007). Children in group 1
firmed pertussis or clinical pertussis (typical male patients) with pertussis were admit- (apnea) and group 3 (seizure) had longer
presentation plus a family member positive for ted to intensive care 55 times. The me- duration of hospital stay after discharge
pertussis) were included. Patient demograph- dian age at admission was 6 wks (inter- from the PICU, and this was related to a
ics, neonatal history and any preexisting ill- quartile range, 4 – 8 wks), and 46 patients protracted illness due to coughing and
ness, immunization status, method of presen- (94%) were ⬍6 months of age. A total of associated feeding difficulties. The PICU
tation, laboratory data, duration and type of 45 infants (92%) were of white, and there and hospital length of stay for the pneu-
respiratory or circulatory support, complica- were no aboriginal children in our pa- monia group tended to be similar. This
tions, and outcome were recorded. Of note, tient population. There was no significant reflects the severity of illness among
there were no major changes in mechanical difference in age between the three these patients, as most of them (seven of
ventilation, sedation, and muscle paralysis groups (Table 1). Of the patients, 26% (13 nine patients) subsequently died in the
guidelines during the study period. ECMO of 49) had been premature infants. Al- PICU. Infants presenting with pneumonia
therapy was introduced in our unit in 1987– most all children (46 of 49, 94%) were had raised white cell counts (p ⱕ .001)
1988 and inhaled nitric oxide therapy in 1993. unimmunized at the time of admission, and lower PaO2 (p ⫽ .020) in comparison
This retrospective review was approved as an and the remaining (6%) had received one with the apnea group. Eighteen patients
audit with our institutional review board. dose of pertussis vaccine. Three children (40%) needed tracheal intubation for re-
Based on the method of presentation sub- who presented at an older age (7, 71⁄2, 21 spiratory support (Table 2), and the indi-
jects were divided into three groups. Group 1 months) had an underlying, unrecog- cations were: severe hypoxic respiratory
(31 of 49 patients, 63%) consisted of patients nized respiratory condition at admission. failure (n ⫽ 7), progressive hypercapnia
who mainly presented with apnea (with or The first had diffuse bilateral bronchoma- (n ⫽ 2), respiratory arrest after pro-
without cough paroxysms). Group 2 (9 of 49 lacia, the second patient had co-existent longed apneas (n ⫽ 5), and seizures (n ⫽
patients, 18%) patients presented with respi- adenovirus pneumonia, and the third pa- 4). The median duration of ventilation
ratory insufficiency or respiratory failure due tient was diagnosed with congenital dia- was 84 hrs (interquartile range, 33.5–120
to pneumonia. The diagnosis of pneumonia was phragmatic hernia. Two thirds of the pa- hrs). All patients who did not require
made based on the clinical presentation and tients (34 of 49) were directly admitted to mechanical ventilation survived, and
chest radiography. All patients in this group had PICU from the emergency department or 38% of children (7 of 18) needing intu-
evidence of either focal (3) or diffuse multilo-
from another referring hospital, and the bation died.
bar (6) consolidation on chest radiographs at
remaining patients were admitted from Seven infants in the pneumonia group
admission. Group 3 patients (5 of 49 patients,
the hospital ward. Diagnosis was made by (15.5%) needed vasoactive support for
10%) presented with seizures. Four children
a combination of immunofluorescence progressive circulatory failure (manifest-
with pertussis were not included in the groups
and culture on nasopharyngeal aspirate ing as worsening perfusion, tachycardia,
either because of different methods of presen-
in 90% of the subjects (44 of 49). In and hypotension), and four among them
tation or due to presence of other underlying
three, a diagnosis of clinical pertussis was were eventually placed on ECMO. Echo-
illnesses: two with complete lung collapse due
made, and one patient each tested posi- cardiographic data were available for six
to secretions, one with congenital diaphrag-
tive for immunoglobulin A antibody and of these infants and showed one or
matic hernia, and one infant with bilateral
polymerase chain reaction from nasopha- more of the following findings: severe
diffuse bronchomalacia.
ryngeal aspirate. pulmonary hypertension (all six pa-
Statistics. Data are expressed as absolute
values (percentage) or as median (interquar- Table 1 displays patient characteristics tients), dilated and poorly contracting
tile range); significance testing was made us- within groups. The median duration of right ventricle (three patients), and
ing one-way analysis of variance with Bonfer- illness preadmission was 7 days (inter- global myocardial dysfunction (one pa-
roni t-test for all pair-wise comparisons after quartile range, 5–14 days), but on com- tient). Durations of support for the four
log transformation of original data, and Fisher parison, pneumonia subjects had signifi- infants placed on ECMO were 80, 133,
exact test was used in computing relation be- cantly shorter preadmission illness (p ⫽ 345, and 408 hrs. Six out of the seven
tween mortality and presentation. .001). The PICU length of stay in the needing circulatory assistance died,

Table 1. Patient characteristics compared within groups

Apnea Pneumonia Seizure


Variable, Median (IQR) (Group 1) n ⫽ 31, 63% (Group 2) n ⫽ 9, 18% (Group 3) n ⫽ 5, 10% p Valuea

Age, wks 5.5 (4–8) 6 (3.7–10) 5 (3.7–11.5) .837


Illness duration before PICU, days 10 (7–4) 4 (3.7–6.2) 7 (4.7–8.5) .001
ICU length of stay, hrs 39 (26.2–68.5) 186 (57–244.2) 110 (92–129) .007
Hospital length of stay, hrs 294 (208–443) 186 (76.5–382) 454 (282–577.5) .081
White cell count, ⫻109/L 25.2 (16.5–34.5) 76.5 (62.1–108.5) 64 (19.7–74.1) ⬍.001
PaO2 at admission, mm Hg 97 (71–130) 61.5 (54–75) 106 (86.5–121) .020
PaCO2 at admission, mm Hg 48 (42–59.5) 69 (56.5–91) 46.5 (44–72.5) .044
Mortality, n 0 7 0 ⬍.001b

IQR, interquartile range; PICU, pediatric intensive care unit; ICU, intensive care unit.
a
Comparison between groups 1 and 2; bFisher exact test.

208 Pediatr Crit Care Med 2007 Vol. 8, No. 3


which included all patients on ECMO. A hyponatremia in two children, and re- indication for PICU admission is pertussis
detailed description of these patients is lated to hypoxic episodes in two children. pneumonia. The majority of children
given in Table 3. Three infants received One child with severe developmental de- (seven of nine) in the pneumonia group
continuous venovenous hemofiltration lay (due to pertussis encephalopathy) died, and no deaths were seen in other
for renal support, and one patient was died at the age of 14 yrs due to worsening groups.
given both exchange transfusion and cardiac failure secondary to palliated The reported rate of pertussis pneu-
plasmapheresis for toxin clearance. All heart disease. Seven (15.5%) had feeding monia varies around 25% (12, 13). In our
seven children who died had pneumonia difficulties related to coughing episodes study, 18 patients (36%) developed pneu-
as the dominant presentation (Table 3). and needed parenteral nutrition and long monia, and in half of them, it was the
Complications occurred in 30 children hospital stay. All children after discharge presenting illness. Pneumonia evolving
(61%), and most had more than one from PICU were under the care of a re- later in the illness is associated with less
problem. Viral studies (nasopharyngeal spiratory physician. severe disease progression and often re-
aspirate for immunofluorescence and lated to secondary viral infections. Per-
culture) were available in all subjects. DISCUSSION haps the most important feature of our
The frequency and type of viral infections study is the classification of our patients
are shown in Table 4. Pneumonia was This review represents the largest into groups based on the main presenting
identified in 18 patients (36%), and half group of infants and children with per- illness, which enabled us to compare and
of these had pneumonia as initial presen- tussis treated in intensive care. The most
correlate different aspects of treatment
tation. Seizures (9) were thought to be important finding is the poor outcome
and outcome. For example, most patients
toxin induced in five children, caused by associated with this condition if the main
in the apnea group were managed with
supplemental oxygen or nasopharyngeal
Table 2. Respiratory support for different patient groups continuous positive airway pressure as
apposed to infants in the pneumonia
Apnea Pneumonia Seizure Total
(Group 1) n ⫽ 31 (Group 2) n ⫽ 9 (Group 3) n ⫽ 5 n ⫽ 45 group, who needed intubation. This is in
marked contrast to previous literature
IPPV 5 9a 4 18 (4), which report apnea as the main indi-
NCPAP 8 0 1 9 cation for mechanical ventilation. Previ-
Oxygen 18 0 0 18 ous reports (5, 14) identified prematurity
IPPV, intermittent positive pressure ventilation; NCPAP, nasopharyngeal continuous positive as a risk factor for mortality in infantile
airway pressure. pertussis. A total of 13 patients (26%) in
a
Three children initially receiving NCPAP were subsequently intubated for worsening hypoxic our study were born at ⬍37 wks of ges-
respiratory failure. tation, but only one presented with se-

Table 3. Characteristics of children who died of pertussis infection

Duration of ICU
Age, Illness, Length of Highest
Pt Wks Days Stay, Hrs Main Presentation P(A-a)O2/OI Vasoactive Infusionsa Support Cause of Death

1 3 4 21 Pneumonia 554/42 None IPPV Severe pertussis pneumonia,


PHT, severe cardiovascular
compromise; treatment
withdrawn for poor
prognosis
2 6 4 235 Pneumonia 213/17 AD 0.5, NA 0.5, IPPV, HFO, iNO, Severe pertussis pneumonia,
VASO VA-ECMO PHT
3 5 5 96 Pneumonia 454/31 DOB 10, NA 0.5, AD IPPV, HFO, iNO, Treatment withdrawn for poor
bolus, VASO, CA VA-ECMO neurological prognosis;
infusion severe pertussis
encephalopathy
4 7 3 19 Pneumonia 539/30 DOP 15, AD 3, and IPPV Severe pertussis pneumonia,
bolus circulatory failure
5 13 7 369 Pneumonia, shock 626/59 DOB 20, AD 0.4, and IPPV, VA-ECMO Multiorgan failure
bolus
6 4 14 69 Pneumonia 627/31 DOP 20, AD 2, and IPPV Multiorgan failure
bolus
7 10 4 186 Pneumonia 578/63 AD10 and bolus, IPPV, VA-ECMO Severe pertussis pneumonia,
NA1, DOP15, CA PHT, multiorgan failure
infusion

Pt, patient; ICU, intensive care unit; P(A-a)O2/OI, alveolar-arterial oxygen gradient and oxygenation index; IPPV, intermittent positive pressure
ventilation; PHT, pulmonary hypertension; AD, adrenaline; NA, noradrenaline; VASO, vasopressin; HFO, high-frequency oscillation; iNO, inhaled nitric
oxide; VA-ECMO, venoarterial extracorporeal membrane oxygenation; DOB, dobutamine; CA, calcium; DOP, dopamine.
a
Numbers indicate highest dose in micrograms per kilogram per minute.

Pediatr Crit Care Med 2007 Vol. 8, No. 3 209


Table 4. Complications seen in study patients despite various rescue measures, can be REFERENCES
very difficult to treat. The mechanism
Complications n (%)
of pulmonary hypertension in pertussis 1. Pertussis vaccines. Wkly Epidemiol Rec
remains undetermined; however, the 1999; 74:137–143
Pneumonia 18 (36) 2. von Konig CH, Halperin S, Riffelmann M, et
Seizures 9 (18) demonstration of leukocyte thrombi in
al: Pertussis of adults and infants. Lancet
Encephalopathy 5 (10) the pulmonary vein of a fatal case (11)
Hyponatremia 10 (20) Infect Dis 2002; 2:744 –750
and the correlation between leukocyto-
Acute renal failure 2 3. Ranganathan S, Tasker R, Booy R, et al: Per-
sis and mortality (7) lead one to believe tussis is increasing in unimmunized infants:
Lung collapse 2
Pleural effusion 2 that therapies aimed at reducing the Is a change in policy needed? Arch Dis Child
Pneumothorax 2 degree of leukocytosis could be benefi- 1999; 80:297–299
Pulmonary hemorrhage 1 cial. Exchange transfusion (21) and leu- 4. Gillis J, Grattan-Smith T, Kilham H: Artifi-
Pneumomediastinum 1 kopheresis therapy (22) by producing cial ventilation in severe pertussis. Arch Dis
Pneumoperitoneum 1
Feeding difficulties 7 (14.2)
cytoreduction have led to patient sur- Child 1988; 63:364 –367
vival, and we suggest these therapies 5. Vitek CR, Pascual FB, Baughman AL, et al:
Developmental delay 1
Disseminated intravascular 1 should be considered in this high-risk Increase in deaths from pertussis among
young infants in the United States in the
coagulation group.
Associated/secondary 1990s. Pediatr Infect Dis J 2003; 22:
Disease among adolescents and
infections 628 – 634
adults represent an important reservoir 6. Tozzi AE, Celentano LP, Ciofi degli Atti ML,
Adenovirus 4
Rhino virus 4 of pertussis, and administering booster et al: Diagnosis and management of pertus-
Respiratory syncytial virus 2 doses of vaccine to this population sis. CMAJ 2005; 172:509 –515
Parainfluenza 2 might prevent transmission and disease 7. Pierce C, Klein N, Peters M: Is leukocytosis a
Influenza A 1 burden in younger infants (23). The predictor of mortality in severe pertussis in-
Pseudomonas sepsis 2
Coagulase-negative sepsis 1
clinical course of pertussis in immu- fection? Intensive Care Med 2000; 26:
nized children tends to be milder (24), 1512–1514
Candida sepsis 1
and speeding up the current immuni- 8. Elliott E, McIntyre P, Ridley G, et al: National
study of infants hospitalized with pertussis in
zation schedule to deliver the first dose
the acellular vaccine era. Pediatr Infect Dis J
earlier (⬍2 months of age) could be
2004; 23:246 –252
vere disease (pneumonia at presentation) beneficial; moreover, a deeper under- 9. Lewis M, Bush GH: Ventilatory support for
and eventually died. A previous study standing of the molecular basis of Bor- children with whooping cough: Experience
conducted in Australia (8) also did not detella pertussis infection might offer with children admitted to a paediatric in-
identify prematurity as a risk factor for means for further therapies. Valuable tensive care unit. Anaesthesia 1980; 35:
mortality. information obtained from the more re- 979 –983
Pertussis is a toxin-mediated disease cently completed Bordetella genome 10. Halasa NB, Barr FE, Johnson JE, et al: Fatal
associated with several virulence factors, project (25, 26) might help in a better pulmonary hypertension associated with per-
including pertussis toxin (most widely understanding of this organism and its tussis in infants: Does extracorporeal mem-
brane oxygenation have a role? Pediatrics
studied of all), accounting for the wide- relation with the human host.
2003; 112:1274 –1278
spread variation in disease severity (15). The retrospective nature of our study
11. Williams GD, Numa A, Sokol J, et al: ECLS in
Pertussis toxin has multiple proven bi- is clearly the most important limiting pertussis: Does it have a role? Intensive Care
ological activities, some of which may factor, but dividing our subjects into Med 1998; 24:1089 –1092
account for the systemic manifestations groups based on their presentation has 12. Farizo KM, Cochi SL, Zell ER, et al: Epide-
of the disease. Severe and fatal pertussis enabled us to more clearly outline the miological features of pertussis in the United
has been correlated with the degree of management and outcome. Infants in our States, 1980 –1989. Clin Infect Dis 1992; 14:
lymphocytosis, a clear manifestation of study represent severe cases with serious 708 –719
pertussis toxin. ECMO has benefited consequences, such as pneumonia, sei- 13. Heininger U, Klich K, Stehr K, et al: Clinical
children with refractory septic shock zures, encephalopathy, multiorgan dys- findings in Bordetella pertussis infections:
Results of a prospective multicenter surveil-
(16, 17), and the role of plasmapheresis function, and death. Most pertussis is a
lance study. Pediatrics 1997; 100:E10
in sepsis is currently under evaluation relatively benign but persistent illness,
14. Wortis N, Strebel PM, Wharton M, et al:
(18, 19). Both these therapies, with and the full effect of the disease on the Pertussis deaths: Report of 23 cases in the
ECMO in particular, have shown disap- community cannot be assessed based on United States, 1992 and 1993. Pediatrics
pointing results in pertussis in our ex- our results. 1996; 97:607– 612
perience and in published literature In conclusion, pertussis pneumonia as 15. Kerr JR, Matthews RC: Bordetella pertussis
(10, 11, 20). We identified several risk the main reason for PICU admission is infection: Pathogenesis, diagnosis, manage-
factors for mortality, such as shorter associated with a very poor outcome. The ment, and the role of protective immunity. Eur
preadmission illness, pneumonia at need for circulatory support implies a J Clin Microbiol Infect Dis 2000; 19:77– 88
presentation, leucocytosis, and the very poor prognosis. Well-established in- 16. Beca J, Butt W: Extracorporeal membrane
oxygenation for refractory septic shock in
need for circulatory support. Most of tensive care therapies like ECMO have
children. Pediatrics 1994; 93:726 –729
these factors have been reported in pre- been associated with poor outcome in the
17. Goldman AP, Kerr SJ, Butt W, et al: Extra-
vious literature (5), and moreover, management of pertussis in our experi- corporeal support for intractable cardiorespi-
identifying risk factors does not neces- ence. A deeper understanding of the mo- ratory failure due to meningococcal disease.
sarily offer a solution to the problem. lecular mechanisms underlying pertussis Lancet 1997; 349:466 – 469
Severe and refractory pulmonary hyper- infection could be vital for the develop- 18. McMaster P, Shann F: The use of extracor-
tension often evolves very rapidly and, ment of future therapies. poreal techniques to remove humoral fac-

210 Pediatr Crit Care Med 2007 Vol. 8, No. 3


tors in sepsis. Pediatr Crit Care Med 2003; kocytosis, and pulmonary hypertension: Im- 24. Bortolussi R, Miller B, Ledwith M, et al: Clin-
4:2–7 provement in oxygenation after a double vol- ical course of pertussis in immunized chil-
19. Reeves JH, Butt WW, Shann F, et al: Contin- ume exchange transfusion. Pediatrics 2004; dren. Pediatr Infect Dis J 1995; 14:870 – 874
uous plasmafiltration in sepsis syndrome: 114:e264 –E266 25. Preston A: Bordetella pertussis: The intersec-
Plasmafiltration in Sepsis Study Group. Crit 22. Grzeszczak MJ, Churchwell KB, Edwards KM, tion of genomics and pathobiology. CMAJ
Care Med 1999; 27:2096 –2104 et al: Leukopheresis therapy for severe infantile 2005; 173:55– 62
20. Pooboni S, Roberts N, Westrope C, et al: pertussis with myocardial and pulmonary fail- 26. Parkhill J, Sebaihia M, Preston A, et al: Com-
Extracorporeal life support in pertussis. Pe- ure. Pediatr Crit Care Med 2006; 7:580 –582 parative analysis of the genome sequences of
diatr Pulmonol 2003; 36:310 –315 23. Forsyth K, Tan T, von Konig CH, et al: Poten- Bordetella pertussis, Bordetella parapertus-
21. Romano MJ, Weber MD, Weisse ME, et al: tial strategies to reduce the burden of pertussis. sis, and Bordetella bronchiseptica. Nat Genet
Pertussis pneumonia, hypoxemia, hyperleu- Pediatr Infect Dis J 2005; 24:S69 –S74 2003; 35:32– 40

Pediatr Crit Care Med 2007 Vol. 8, No. 3 211

S-ar putea să vă placă și