Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
JAGS 4E6-11,1999
0 1999 by the American Geriatrics Society 0002-8614/99/$3.50
IAGS IANUARY 1999-VOL. 47. NO. 1 IL-G AND DEPRESSION IN OLDER COMMUNITY DWELLERS 7
METHODS
Sample
The general description of the study sample has been
reported elsewhere.24 Begun in 1985, the Duke (or Piedmont)
EPESE has created a longitudinal database for the study of
TNF CRH community-dwelling older people. It comprises individuals
(+I living in a five-county area surrounding and including
Durham, North Carolina, in a mix of near equal proportions
of urbadrural and black/white participants. The first survey,
XRT
in 1985-1986, resulted in a sample of 4162 s~bjects.~’ Par-
BDz EIC SMT TNF
ticipants received in-person interviews every 3 years, with
RU486 E-BDz-1 yearly telephone interviews taking place between each in-
person wave of the survey. The entire EPESE survey instru-
ment covers a wide variety of personal health and well-being
MPhaee ITUTTARY characteristics, personal medical history inventory, and life-
style questions, as well as various physical measures such as
ACTH weight and blood press~re.~’
In 1992, during the third in-person follow-up wave of
(-) (+) the Piedmont EPESE, 2569 remaining living cohort members
IL-2 ANTI-CRH LPS were visited in their homes, and requests were made for
TNF IL-8 IND XRT informed consent to draw blood. Of these study participants,
CRII 269 persons were deemed to require proxies for their contin-
RU486 ued participation in the overall EPESE study (the vast major-
ity due to cognitive impairment). Their blood was not drawn,
and these persons were excluded further from this analysis.
Of the remaining 2300 persons who were deemed not to
require proxies (and were, therefore, able to provide con-
LPS, TNF, ACTH, STRESS
sent), 573 (24.9%)did not have blood drawn (due to sub-
ject’s refusal, unusable samples, or presence of a disease
condition precluding phlebotomy). The non-blood draw
CORTISOL ~ older (mean age 77.5 vs
group, as described e l s e ~ h e r e ?was
Figurc 1.Immunoendocrine dysregulatory, or Positive Feedback, 76.6 years, respectively), contained more women (78.0 vs
model of major depression. Abbreviations: LPS = lipopolysac- 65.0%) and blacks (57.8 vs 52.3%),and had poorer Instru-
charide; XRT = ionizing radiation; cachectic dz. = cachectic mental Activities of Daily Living (IADL) and self-rated health
diseases; RU486 = mifepristone; DEX = dexamethasone; scores (percentages not shown). However, this group was not
IND = indomethacin; EIC = eicosanoids; BDZ = benzodiaz- different from the final sample regarding education (8.8 vs 9.0
epines; E=BDZ-I = endogenous benzodiazepine inhibitor; years) or percentage of persons with cognitive impairment
SMT = somatostatin; HTH = hypothalamus; CRH = (12.4 vs 15.0%) or depression (8.8 vs 10.2%).24
corticotropin-relasing hormone; ANTI-CRH = anti- Of the 1727 individuals who did consent to have their
corticotropin-relasing hormone; IMIP = imipramine; TNF =
tumor necrosis factor; HYPOGLY = hypoglycemia; ACTH = blood drawn (of whom 65% were female, and 53% were
adrenocorticotropic hormone; IL-1 = interleukin-1; IL-2 = black), 41 persons (2.7%of this total, of whom 65% were
interleukin-2; IL-6 = interleukin-6. female, and 72% were black) did not answer all questions
pertaining to the modified CES-D1.26 used in the EPESE. This
left 1686 subjects (97.6% of this total, of whom 65% were
female and 52% were black) with complete demographic,
bin, albumin, serum total protein, prolactin, cortisoIy1’ and blood, and depression data. This group included 287 white
tryptophan.21 men, 303 black men, 519 white women, and 577 black
The Duke Established Populations for Epidemiologic women.
Studies of the Elderly (EPESE) is a randomly selected,
population-based At the time of the sixth Mcasurcs
follow-up survey of the study, blood samples were drawn Demographic and medical variables included weight
from 1727 consenting members of this cohort. This allowed change, body mass index, self-rated health, life satisfaction,
for an assessment of the associations between biomarkers, current smoking status, and history of cancer, arthritis, myocar-
aging, medical status, and functional status issues in this dial infarction, cerebrovascular accident, diabetes mellitus, hip
group of older people. In this population, IL-6 increases with fracture, any fracture, and hypertension. Self-reported weight
age and is associated with poorer health and functional change was analyzed on the basis of self-reported weight at the
status.z4 third in-person survey minus self-reported weight at the first
The primary hypothesis of this study was that IL-6, a in-person survey. Functional status instruments included the
proinflammatory cytokine, and other markers of inflamma- Katz, Rosow-Breslau, Nagi, and Instrumental Activities of Daily
tion (white blood cell count, albumin, globulins, D-Dimer) Living measures, as reported in previous studies on this co-
would be associated positively with depression. h ~ r t . ~ ~The
. ‘ ~Short Portable Mental Status Questionnaire
8 DENTINOETAL. JANUARY 1999-VOL. 47, NO. 1 JAGS
Table 2. Correlations With Depressiont in the North Carolina Table 3. Stepwise Linear Logistic Regression on CES-Dt Scores:
EPESE Dataset Final Model'
Eosinophils (per mm3) -0.01 Hi 11-6 B 5.0 pg/mL 22% (88) 10% (60)
Monocytes (per mm3) 0.01 Lo IL-6 < 5.0 pg/mL 12% (867) 8.5% (671)
Medical History P = .010 P = .638
Heart attack 0.05
Stroke 0.05*
Cancer -0.02
Broken hip 0.03 the relationship of plasma IL-6, D-dimer, and other blood
Broken bone 0.06* markers with depressive symptoms in a population-based
Diabetes -0.02 sample. Other health-related associations of depression were
Arthritis 0.1o*** chosen because of the number of reports suggesting immuno-
High blood pressure 0.04 logic links with depression when accompanied by weight
Weight loss (last year) -0.02 loss.
Smoker (current) -0.0001 In our study, the cytokine interleukin-6 was associated
Physical measurements independently with depression, i.e., high IL-6 levels were
Blood pressure (mmHg) associated with depression. These results are consistent with
Systolic -0.02 other studies of cytokines and acute phase reactants and
Diastolic -0.06* * ~ ~ -et~ al.
d e p r e ~ s i o n . ' ~Seidel ~ employed whole blood assays,
Body Mass Index -0.01 at time zero and at 6 weeks after initiating antidepressant
Self-ratingdfunctional status treatment, and found that mitogen-induction of interleukins
Self-health rating -0.23*** in patients was increased at time zero over controls and
Life satisfaction rating -0.21*** decreased over time with treatment.I2 Maes et al., in a series
Katz ADL score -0.1 5*** of reports on this topic, have found increased interleukin and
InstrumentalADL score -0.10"** certain acute phase protein levels in various subsets of de-
Nagi score -0.18*** pressed individuals. Strikingly, these investigators have cor-
Rosow-Breslau score -0.20*** related with increases in interleukins along the worsening
Mental status spectrum of affective illness, from minor depression to major
SPMSQ score 0.1 1*** depression to major depression with melancholia. This adds
Cognitive impairment (from SPMSQ) 0.06* further support to the hypothesis that certain subjects with
melancholia may possess quantifiable immunoendocrine dys-
t = modified CES-D' zz 9. regulation, causing various somatic symptoms commonly
note: *after a value indicates P < .05;**indicates P < .01; "*indicates P <
,001. found in this d i ~ o r d e r . ~ ~ - ~ ~
However, all of the above studies were in clinical (pa-
tient) populations. The study presented here is the first
DISCUSSION community-based report associating IL-6 and depressive
Various biologic markers, including proinflammatory symptoms in older people. The pathophysiologic mechanism
cytokines, white blood cell count, albumin, the globulins, and postulated for this association (Figure I), similar to that of
other blood markers,12J8*20*21 have been hypothesized to be clinical studies, is one of an immunoendocrine dysregulated
associated with depression. This report is the first to explore state, wherein stress causes excess IL-6 production, which in
10 DENTINOETAL. JANUARY 1999-VOL. 47, NO. 1 JAGS
turn incites CRH production, resulting in HPA system acti- and decreases in cellular levels of certain amino
vation and hypercortisolemia, which may contribute to de- acids such as tyrosine, a precursor of neurotransmitter^?^ A
pression by an as yet undetermined impact on particular postulated physiologic basis for the role of high IL-6 levels in
neural pathways. This hyperfunctional adrenal state then certain depressions might, therefore, be caused by its effect on
drives even greater elaboration of T-lymphocyte and macro- weight loss.
phage products such as TNF, IL-1 and IL-6, which further This study has limitations. While the EPESE dataset has
drives the ‘forward feedback‘ aspect of this cycle.37 This provided a very rich source of epidemiologic information in
dysregulated state may not be operative in all cases of depres- regard to the parameters affecting health, disease, and func-
sion; however, recent reports have looked at “HPA overac- tional statusz4 in older people, the analysis presented here is
tive” versus “HPA nonhyperactive” depressed patients (for cross-sectional, and, thus, cause and effect relationships can-
example utilizing the combined dexamethasone suppression not be proven. The IL-6 and other biological measures were
test/CRH stimulation test protocol):’ who respond differ- determined at only one point in time, though our previous
ently to traditional antidepressant treatment (for example studies have indicated that these measures may be quite
tricyclic antidepressants). These HPA overactive patients stable.29 This report does not show the degree of association
might also be that subgroup of persons within a depressed between aging and depression, which had been reported in
population who possess high IL-6 levels because IL-6 is a previous waves of the study.’ This may be due to the survi-
primary inducer of CRH. We have previously suggested that vorship of this cohort itself (with only approximately one-
new therapies directed to reduction of IL-6 level might be third of the original 4162 subjects remaining in this study’s
useful in the treatment of depre~sion.~’ sample), to an attenuation in the psychologic symptom en-
It is interesting in this regard that we recently reported dorsements of depression in the “0ld-0ld’’ (median age in this
that higher levels of religious activity, which have been asso- sample 76 years), or to the stronger impact of functional
ciated with lower levels of depression, are also independently status in this now older
associated with lower levels of IL-6.39 It is also possible that This study is the first report in a community-dwelling
depressive symptoms are precipitated by biologic disorders sample of older people of the association of the inflammatory
associated with IL-6 elevation, such as subclinical inflamma- cytokine IL-6 with depression. This study’s results may be
tion and multifactorial functional decline. Moreover, since one clue to the potential importance of this biologic relation-
these are not mutually exclusive of age-related immunologic ship in the etiology of this illness.
dysregulation discussed above, both mechanisms may play an
important role. REFERENCES
Another suggestion that subpopulations of persons with 1. Blazer DG, Burchctt BM, Service C et 31. The association of age and depres-
depression may be affected differentially is found in our sion among the elderly: An epidemiologic exploration. J Cerontol: Mcd Sci
report of the stronger association between depression and 1991;46:M210-215.
2. Zung WV, Broadhead WE, Rot11 ME. Prevalence of depressive symptoms in
high IL-6 levels in persons with weight loss than in those primary care. J Fam Pract 1993;37:337-344,
without weight loss. Furthermore, there was no association 3. Crum RM, Patrick L, Ford DE. Depressive symptoms among general mcdi-
between weight loss and depression, which suggests against cal patients: Prevalence and one-year outcomes. Psychosom Med 1994;56:
IL-6 being a surrogate marker for weight loss attributable to 109-1 17.
4. Sherbourne CD, Wells KB, Hays RD et at. Subthreshold depression and de-
other causes, in depressives in this sample. The independent pressive disorder: Clinical characteristics of gcncral medical and mental
bivariate association between high IL-6 levels and weight loss health specialty outpatients. Am J Psychiatry 1994;151:1777-1784.
is in agreement with the consensus of the current literature on 5. Zisook S, Shuchter SR, Irwin M et al. Bereavement, depression, and immune
this to pi^."*^' Additionally, as there may be many causes for function. Psychiatr Rcs 1994;52:1-10.
weight loss in an older p o p ~ l a t i o nthe
, ~ ~lack
~ of an indepen- 6. Blazer DG.Depression in Late Life. St. Louis: CV Mosby, 1981.
7. Morley JE, Kraenzlc D. Causes of weight loss in 3 community nursing home.
dent bivariate association between depression and weight J Am Geriatr SOC1994;42:583-585.
loss is not unanticipated. However, the significant comple- 8. Ryan C, Bryant E, Eleazer P et 31. Unintentional weight loss in long-term
mentary association between depression and high IL-6 in care: Predictor of mortality in the elderly. South Med J 1995;88:721-724.
persons with weight loss, though not in persons who main- 9. Grunfeld C, Palladine MA Jr. Tumor necrosis factor: Immunologic, antitu-
tained their weight in this study, suggests that high IL-6 levels mor, metabolic and cardiovascular activities (rev). Adv Intern Med 1990;35:
45-71.
may be more specific to these depressed individuals with 10. Ershler WB. Interleukin-6. A Cytokine for Ccrontologists. J An1 Ceriatr SOC
weight loss than to depressives in general. 1993;41: 176-1 8 1.
The somatic equivalents of major depression, especially 11. Borish L, Rosenvasser LJ. Update on cytokines. J Allergy Clin Immunol
in older people, are protean and comprise some of the most 1996;97:719-734.
12. Seidel A, Arolt V, Huntstiger M et at. Cytokine production and serum pro-
frequent major symptomatic determinants of this diagnosis, teins in depression. Scand J Immunol 1994;41:534-538.
most notably in the realm of melancholia?’ Weight loss in 13. Darling G,Fraker DL, Jensen JC et at. Cacheaic effects of recombinant hu-
and of itself is well known to be a very strong independent man tumor necrosis factor in rats. Cancer Res 1990;50:4008-4013.
predictor of mortality in older people,’ with major depres- 14. Watanobe H, Takebe K. Intravenous administration of tumor nccrosis
sion being the primary cause for weight loss in one commu- factor-alpha stimulates corticotropin releasing hormone secretion in the
push-pull cannulated median eminence of freely moving rats. Neuropcptides
nity nursing home ample.^ Cytokines have been linked to 1992;22:81-84.
weight loss. Experimentally, for example, a continuous infu- 15. Naitoh Y, Fukata J, Tominagn T et al. Interleukin-6 stimulates the secretion
sion of intravenous TNF (also known as cachectin), another of adrenocorticotropic hormone in conscious, freely-movingrats. Biochem
proinflammatory cytokine, leads to anorexia, weight loss, niophys Res Comm 1988;155:1459-1463.
edema, loss of body protein, lipid, and cell mass, and lethal- 16. Bcrnadini R, Kamilaris TC, Calogero AE et at. Interactions between tumor
necrosis factor-alpha, hypotlialamic corticotropin-releasing hormone, and
ity.13 Biochemical effects of the inflammatory cytokines in- adrenocorticotropin secretion in the rat. Endocrinology 1990;126:2876-
clude (in the short term) hyperglycemia, hypertriglyceride- 288 1.
mia, and l i p o g e n e s i ~ , ~with
~ - ~ ~increases in protein 17. Bianchi M, Saccrdotc P, Locatclli L et at. Corticotropin releasing hormone.
IAGS IANUARY 1999-VOL. 47. NO. 1 IL-6 AND DEPRESSION IN OLDER COMMUNITY DWELLERS 11
Interleukin-1 alpha, and tumor necrosis factor share charactcristics of strcss 31. SAS Institute. SAS/STAT User’s Guide, Version 6,4th Ed. Cary, NC: SAS
mediators. Brain Rcs 1991;546:139-142. Institute, Inc, 1990.
18. Maes M, Scharpe S, Meltzer HY et 31. Relationships between interleukin-6 32. Hedges LV, Olkin I. Statistical Methods for Meta-Analysis. New York: Aca-
activity, acute phase proteins and function of the hypothalamic-pituitary- demic Press, 1985.
adrenal axis in severe depression. Psychiatr Rcs 1993;49:11-27. 33. Macs M, Wauters A, Neels H ct al. Total serum protein and serum protein
19. Macs M, Melner HY, Buckley P et al. Plasma-soluble interleukin-2 and fractions in depression: Relationship to depressive symptoms and glucoconi-
transferrin receptor in schizophrenia and major depression. Eur Arch Psychi- coid activity. J Affect Disord 1995;34:61-69.
atry Clin Neurosci 1995;244:325-329. 34. Macs M, Bosmans E, Mclacr HY. lmmunoendocrine aspects of major dc-
20. Brown SL, Salivc ME, Guralnik JM ct al. Depressive symptoms in the cl- pression-relationships between plasma interleukin-6 and soluble
derly: Association with white blood cell count. Prog Ncuropsychopharmacol interlcukin-2 receptor, prolactin and cortisol. Eur Arch Psychiatry Clin Ncu-
Biol Psychiatry 1995;19:849-860. rosci 1995;245: 172-178.
21. Maes M, Meltzcr HY, Scharpc S et al. Relationships betwccn lower 35. Maes M. Evidence for an immune response in major depression: A review
L-tryptophan levels and immune-inflammatory variables in depression. Psy- and hypothesis. Prog Ncuropsychopharmacol Biol Psychiatry 1995;19:11-
chiatr Res 1993;49:151-165. 38.
22. Cornoni-Huntley J, Blazer DG, Laferty ME ct al., eds. Established Popula- 36. Maes M. A review on the acute phase response in major depression. Rev
tions for Epidemiologic Studies of the Elderly, Vol. 11: Resource Data Book. Neurosci 1993;4:407-416.
Washington, DC: National Institute on Aging, National Institutes of Health, 37. Dentino AN. A positive feedback model of immune-endocrine dysregulation
no. 90-495,1990.
in major depression: Cytokines, the HPA axis and aging. Proc Am Assoc
23. Williams TF, Korpcr SP. Forward. In: Cornoni-Huntley J, Blazcr DG,
Geriatr Psychiatry 1996; Abstract, p. 43.
Laferty ME, et al., eds. Established Populations for Epidemiologic Studies of
38. Hcuser IJE, Schwciger U, Cotthardt U ct al. Pituitary-adrenal-system rcgula-
the Elderly, Vol. 11: Resource Data Book. Washington, DC: National Insti-
tion and psychopathology during amitriptylinc treatment in elderly de-
tute on Aging, National Institutes of Health, no. 90-495, 1990.
pressed patients and normal comparison subjects. Am J Psychiatry 1996;
24. Cohen HJ, Pieper CF, Harris T et al. Plasma IL-6. The association of plasma
IL-6 levels with functional disability in community-dwehg elderly. J Ger- 153:93-99.
ontol: Med Sci 1997;52A:M201-208. 39. Koenig HG, Cohcn HJ, Gcorgc LK ct al. Attendance at rcligious services,
25. Cornoni-Huntley J, Blazer DC, Laferty ME et al. Introduction. In: Cornoni- interleukin-6, and other biological parameters of immune function in older
Huntley J, Blazer DG, Lafcrty ME et al., eds. Established Populations for adults. Int J Psychiatry Med 1997;27:233-250.
Epidemiologic Studies of the Elderly, Vol. 11: Resource Data Book. Washing- 40. Burton BE. 1L-6: Insights into novel biological activities. Clin Immunol Im-
ton, DC: National Institute on Aging, National Institutes of Health, no. 90- munopathol 1997;85:16-20.
495,1990. 41. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual, 4th Ed. Washington, DC: American Psy-
26. Radloff LS The CES-D Scale. A self-rcport depression scale for research in chiatric Association, 1994, p 193.
the general population. Appl Psycho1 Mcas 1977;1:385-401. 42. Lang CH, Dobrcscu C, Bagby CJ. Tumor necrosis factor impairs insulin ac-
27. Cornoni-Huntley J, Blazer DC, Laferty ME et al., eds. Established Popula- tion on peripheral glucose disposal and hepatic glucose output. Endocrinol-
tions for Epidemiologic Studies of the Elderly, Vol. 11: Resource Data Book. ogy 1992;130:43-52.
Appendix 11. Washington, D C National Institute on Aging, National Insti- 43. Ling PR, Bistrian BR, Mcndez B et aI. Effccts of systemic infusions of endo-
tutes of Health, no. 90-495, 1990. toxin, tumor necrosis factor, and intcrleukin-1 on glucose metabolism in the
28. PfeiffcrE. A short portable mental status questionnaire for the assessment of raf: Relatiomhip to endogenous glucose production and peripheral tissue
organic brain deficit in elderly patients. J Am Geriatr SOC1975;23:433-441. glucose uptake. Metabolism 1994;43:279-284.
29. Rao KMK, Piepcr CF, Currie MS et al. Variability of plasma IL-6 and 44. Llovera M, Lopez-Soriano FJ, Argilcs JM. Chronic tumor necrosis factor-
crosslinked fibrin dimers over time in community dwelling elderly Subjects. alpha treatment modifies protein turnover in rat tissues. Biochem Mol Biol
Am J Clin Pathol 1994;102:802-805. Int 1993;30:29-36.
30. Cohen HJ, Crawford JC, Rao KMK et al. Racial differences in the preva- 45. Llovera M, Lopez-Soriano FJ, Argiles JM. Tumor necrosis factor-alpha al-
lence of monoclonal gammopathy in a community-based sample of the cl- ters the blood compartmcntation of amino acids in the rat. Cancer Lett
derly. Am J Med 1998;104:439-444. 1993;72:71-76.