What is the future of the Syrian

Democratic Forces?
by Farah Najjar
25 Nov 2017




Founded in 2015, the SDF says it is fighting to establish a democratic and federal Syria along the
lines of the Rojava region in the north [File: Reuters]
MORE ON SYRIA'S CIVIL WAR

 Tension rises as Turkey sends troops to YPG strongholdtoday

 Turkey's troops cross over into Syria's Afrintoday
 Erdogan: Operation in Syria's Afrin has begunyesterday
 How will new front in Syria war impact US-Turkey ties?today
Two Syrian groups are at odds over the sudden departure of a high-ranking
Syrian commander who reportedly left for neighbouring Turkey last week.

The Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF), a US-backed alliance of Kurdish and

Arab fighters, and the Turkish-backed Free Syrian Army (FSA), a looseentity
of opposition rebel groups, have presented different versions of the reasons
behind General Talal Silo's departure.

Silo served as the SDF's spokesperson, and his parting marks the first major
defection among the forces' top ranks. While the SDF refuses to acknowledge
the departure as an official resignation, the FSA says his defection has been "in
the works for a very long time". Silo, who belongs to the Turkmen ethnicity,
previously served as a high-ranking general within the FSA when the group
was first created.

"We had several options in front of us, so the best and most feasible one was
for Silo to break away from the SDF towards [Turkey]," Abou al-Farouk, an
FSA spokesperson and lieutenant in the north, told Al Jazeera.

The FSA aided Turkish authorities in facilitating Silo's departure via

northern Syria, from where he was ushered to Turkey, according to Abou al-
Farouk.

There has been no official comment from Turkey, which perceives the SDF, led
by the Kurdish Peoples' Protection Units (YPG), as a security threat for its
alleged links to the Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK) separatists inside Turkey.
The PKK has waged an armed campaign since 1984 that has killed more than
40,000 people.

"In a nutshell, the SDF, who call themselves democratic, have been claiming
that they are the representatives of the people - of all the minorities and races
- from Arabs to Kurds to Turkmen," Abou al-Farouk said.

"So when we work on pulling out people like our brother Silo from the
SDF, we would have succeeded in making them lose the diversity tactic that
they promote," he added. "In this case, they used Silo's Turkmen origin to
promote that they are representatives of a minority and not just Kurds."
Initially founded by a group of officers who defected from the Syrian Armed
Forces in 2011, the FSA is a conglomeration of armed groups fighting under a
larger umbrella, without a unified, central command. Several FSA groups have
since shifted alliances, but in 2016, they were mobilised with Turkey's support
to limit the SDF's influence along Turkey's southern border.

Founded in 2015, the SDF says it is fighting to establish a democratic and

federal Syria along the lines of the Rojava region in the north. Its makeup
largely consists of Kurdish YPG fighters and smaller groups of Arab, Turkmen
and Armenian fighters.

Earlier this year, the US began arming them before an offensive to recapture
Raqqa, the de facto capital of the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (ISIL,
also known as ISIS). The Kurdish YPG and its allies have carved out
autonomous regions in the north, and they now control nearly a quarter of
Syria.

The FSA and SDF are adversaries, and are currently controlling various parts
of Syria, which is in its seventh year of war.

"We're still working on pulling out Arab leaders within the SDF," said Abou al-
Farouk, noting this has been in the works on a "high intelligence level".

Silo's defection comes after months of mounting discontent by Arabs within

the SDF, who say they have been sidelined when it comes to decision-making.

They also blame the YPG for discriminating against them, but the YPG has
denied these allegations.

Complex proxy war

Silo's departure reflects the complexities of Syria's proxy war. While the two
groups were created to fight varying enemies - the FSA against Syrian
government forces and the SDF against ISIL - each claims to represent the
"oppressed".

Aron Lund, a Syria expert and Century Foundation fellow, said that the SDF
will remain relevant as long as it controls territory and has powerful armed
forces.
"The fact that they have the US Air Force at their back makes it impossible for
Assad's government to simply ignore them or try to seize their areas with
force," said Lund. "How Assad and his allies decide to handle the SDF problem
will probably be determined by what the United States decides to do."

He further noted that since American policy under US President Donald

Trump remains unclear, the SDF would have a much "weaker hand" or "risk
military defeat" if the US signals that it wants to leave Syria.

"But American decisions will likely be informed by several factors, including

the risk of a jihadi resurgence, Turkish pressure to abandon the SDF, and
concerns in Washington over Iran's influence in an Assad-run Syria," Lund
explained.

US alliance
The US has come under international scrutiny for arming the Kurdish-led
SDF, especially since they have undertaken operations in Arab-majority cities.
The fear in shifting these regions' demography has been a point of
contestation, augmented by Silo's departure and the fact that his position, for
the time being, has been filled by a Kurd.

A spokesperson told Al Jazeera that the coalition fighting ISIL in the region
does not have any role in determining the internal staffing of the SDF, but
indicated that the US would remain in Syria supporting "its partners" for the
foreseeable future as "a lot of fighting remains to defeat remaining pockets of
ISIL".

Mostafa Bali, the SDF's media relations head, reiterated the importance of the
SDF in fighting "other terrorist groups".
"We [SDF] were not just created for the goal of fighting ISIL. We will not
simply disappear afterwards," he told Al Jazeera. "There are still many
terrorist factions that remain in Syria, and these are strong. They include
Hayet Tahrir al-Sham [former al-Qaeda affiliates] and al-Nusra Front."

The SDF considers itself the "better, more refined model" of Syria's future
army. According to Bali, the forces will "naturally" remain centred in the
Kurdish north.

But Samer Abboud, an associate professor of international studies at Arcadia

University, noted that there will be a sustained campaign by
the Astana powers - Russia, Turkey and Iran - to downplay the SDF's capacity,
despite it being "one of the strongest" armed groups on the ground.

"The confrontation with the SDF was put on hold until this later stage because
the Kurdish issue is the major one facing the regime and its allies now," he
said, referencing Silo's defection as the first stage of a "looming"
confrontation.

Abboud questioned whether the US would abandon its SDF partners to

maintain its relationship with Russia.

"We can't have it both ways - it's a threat when it's around and a threat when
it's not around," he said of the SDF. "So I think that eventually the US-SDF
link could be severed, sacrificed at the altar of US-Russian agreement on
Syria."

However, the FSA's trust in Turkey has given the group hope.

"In light of the international aggression that happened, we have to coordinate

with our biggest ally and supporter moving forward, Turkey, to rebuild
ourselves better and stronger to prepare for future battles," said Abou al-
Farouk.