Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/273711962
CITATION READS
1 2,166
1 author:
Melessaw Shanko
MEGEN Power: Consultants in Renewable Energy, Energy Efficiency, Environment and Sustainable Dev…
16 PUBLICATIONS 11 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Melessaw Shanko on 18 March 2015.
www.renewables-made-in-germany.com
www.german-renewable-energy.com
www.german-renewable-energy.com
Target Market Analysis
Ethiopia’s Solar Energy Market
www.german-renewable-energy.com
Authors
Megen Power
Melessaw Shanko
Integrated Energy Solutions (IES):
Mark Hankins
Anjali Saini
Paul Kirai
November 2009
Editor
On behalf of the
Contact
This Target Market Analysis is part of the Project Development Programme (PDP) East Africa. PDP East Africa is implemented
by the Deutsche Gesellschaft für Technische Zusammenarbeit (GTZ) on behalf of the German Federal Ministry of Economics
and Technology (BMWi) in context of the Export Initiative Renewable Energies. More information about the PDP and about
renewable energy markets in East Africa: www.gtz.de/projektentwicklungsprogramm
This publication, including all its information, is protected by copyright. GTZ cannot be liable for any material or immaterial
damages caused directly or indirectly by the use or disuse of parts. Any use that is not expressly permitted under copyright
legislation requires the prior consent of GTZ.
All contents were created with the utmost care and in good faith. GTZ assumes no responsibility for the accuracy, timeliness,
www.german-renewable-energy.com
completeness or quality of the information provided.
Target Market Analysis: Ethiopia’s Solar Energy Market V
Content
3.2 Applicable Public Sector Support / Financing Mechanisms and Sources ...........................................17
List of Tables
Table 1: Main Market Segments of the Existing Solar PV Markets........................................................................ 2
Table 2: Outline of the Sales of Solar Water Heater and the Market Structure ..................................................... 6
Table 3: Solar PV Off-Grid Market Potential in Ethiopia ........................................................................................ 8
Table 4: Number of Customers and Electrified Towns until 2006 ........................................................................ 13
Table 5: Summary of Estimated Undeveloped Market Potential for Solar Hybrid PV Systems ........................... 14
Table 6: Cost Estimates and Funding Sources for Off-Grid Electrification (in Million €) ...................................... 15
Table 7: Organisations Involved in the SWH Market ........................................................................................... 19
Table 8: List of Relevant Importing Companies in the Solar PV Market .............................................................. 20
Table 9: List of Consultants, NGOs and Non-Governmental Projects in the Solar PV Market ............................ 21
Table 10: Government and Public Sector Projects .............................................................................................. 22
Table 11: Major PV Projects ................................................................................................................................ 23
Currency
Measurement
List of Acronyms
AMES Access to Modern Energy Services (GTZ project)
BIPV Building Integrated PV
BOS Balance of System
BTS Base Transmission Station
DSM Demand Side Management
EAREP Energy Access and Rural Electrification Programme
EBG Equatorial Business Group, Private Trading Company
EEPCo Ethiopian Electric Power Corporation
EREDPC Ethiopian Rural Energy Development and Promotion Centre
ETC Ethiopian Telecommunication Corporation
GEF Global Environment Facility
GoE Government of Ethiopia
GSM Global System for Mobile Communication
GTZ IS GTZ International Service
IDA International Development Association (World Bank Group)
IFC International Finance Corporation (World Bank Group)
IGAD Intergovernmental Authority on Development
LCH Low Cost Housing
LED Light Emitting Diode
MME Ministry of Mines and Energy
MoFED Ministry of Finance and Economic Development
NGO Non-Government Organisation
PV Photovoltaic
QSAE Quality and Standard Authority of Ethiopia
REF Rural Electrification Fund
RET Renewable Energy Technology
SCS Self Contained System
SHS Solar Home System
SSA Sub Saharan Africa
SWH Solar Water Heater
TVET Technical Vocational Education and Training
UCBP University Capacity Building Programme
UEAP Universal Electricity Access Programme
UNEP United Nations Environment Programme
VAT Value Added Tax
Target Market Analysis: Ethiopia’s Solar Energy Market VIII
Summary
The Ethiopian solar market is still at an early development stage with an estimated installed capacity
of 5 MWp. Growth during the 1990s was under 5 % but has reached 15-20 % during the last few
years, primarily driven by the telecom market that constitutes 70 % of installed capacity. Five or six
companies supply 90 % of the market and some lack a specialist focus on solar PV.
The market potential is estimated at 52 MW, the majority within the solar home systems (SHS)
market and continued expansion in telecom sector. SHS has the greatest annual growth rate of 20 %
with few suppliers and driven by the extension of low-cost housing and real estate developments. In
the longer term, the growing inverter charger backup market combined with a feed-in tariff law under
revision could constitute a stepping stone to grid-connected PV. For the foreseeable future, larger
and in particular grid connected PV systems will face stiff competition from smaller hydro power
systems, including small and micro hydro power.
Donor support, the establishment of the Renewable Energy Fund (REF) and projects such as those
backed by UNEP/GEF have brought opportunities for solar PV and micro-hydro, and should continue
to be a driving force behind commercial demand for institutional and household PV systems as well
as for solar hybrid PV and village mini-grids. The political environment already turned into positive:
th
Since 14 December 2009 the Ministry of Finance and Economic Development (MoFED) lifted the
import duty fees on PV modules and balance of system (BOS).
Target Market Analysis: Ethiopia’s Solar Energy Market 1
Ethiopia has abundant solar energy resources. The national annual average irradiance is estimated to
2 2
be 5.2 kWh/m /day with seasonal variations that range between the minimum of 4.5 kWh/m /day in
2 1
July to a maximum of 5.6 kWh/m /day in February and March. The solar resource is relatively lower in
the most populous Northern, Central and Western highlands of the country while the rift valley regions,
Western and Eastern lowlands of the country receive higher annual average irradiance well above 6
2
kWh/m /day.
The Ethiopian solar energy market is at its early stage of development. For about ten years, since the
commercial market started in early 1990s, annual sales growth was under 5 %. However, in the last
four years a significant sales growth at an average rate of 15 % to 20 % has been reported by major
PV suppliers. The market is yet in its pioneer stage where there is not a distinct role for the players in
the business. Capacity building and awareness raising projects in the past - even though they were
uncoordinated in nature - seem to have created demand for solar home systems (SHS) in rural
households and businesses. In addition to this, the establishment of the Rural Electrification Fund
(REF) under the Ministry of Mines and Energy has also been a milestone for the solar industry.
In the 1990s and early 2000, the market for solar PV was mainly a tender market for procurements of
systems for NGO supported projects. The telecom sector has always been the biggest market
constitution about 70 % of an estimated installed capacity of 5 MW, supported by the Ethiopian
Telecommunication Corporation (ETC) Universal Connectivity Programme (for which BP Solar has
historically been the major supplier). Estimations based on information obtained from major suppliers,
the annual sales for the year 2008 is over 500 kWp without systems for the telecom sector. The
annual solar PV sales seem to have doubled in the last three to four years. There are about 15 solar
equipment suppliers in Ethiopia. However, over 90 % of sales are from five or six major suppliers at
the moment. Less than half of these suppliers sell solar as a primary business. For most of them solar
is not a specialised market but an additional item in their business. Compared to other countries in the
region, the developed market in Ethiopia is at the low end with major international PV companies
(such as “Solar 23”) initiating a presence.
The market for institutional PV system is developing but very slowly. NGOs support and Rural
Electrification Fund (REF) for rural schools and health institution are creating a significant market for
solar PV systems. The demand from the tourism sector is not growing as rapidly as would be
expected. So far not more than 20 kWp systems are sold to the sector and these are mainly in
national parks and resorts in off grid areas.
The solar water heater (SWH) market was started with locally manufactured products and is currently
entirely based on imported products. Technologies available in the market range from simple flat plate
collectors to evacuated tube with heat-pipes. The market for SWH is concentrated in major cities
particularly in Addis Ababa. Demand for SWH is still low but continuously growing particularly driven
by newly developed real estate businesses for residential buildings. SWH installed to date is in the
order of 2000 units with annual sales of about 200 units.
1
Solar Energy Resources, Technical Report 3, CESEN 1986.
Target Market Analysis: Ethiopia’s Solar Energy Market 2
Off-grid household > 1.2 MWp > 260 kW > 3 million Very low competition.
electrification & small scale (Approx. Euros (2008) Customer’s choice of
commercial (Solar Home 2000 to equipment is usually limited
System) 2008) by availability.
Number of players is
increasing but reliability in
products supply is still low.
Off-grid community systems > 500 kWp > 220 kW About 2.5 Supply of goods for
(including institutional, million Euros institutions has never been
worship places and pumping (2008) from stocks. Suppliers import
systems) goods after securing
contracts.
Large size supplies have
always been international
competitive bids.
Telecom > 3.5 MWp > 150 kW About 2 Telecom sector is a
million Euros Government monopoly. All
(2008) equipment is supplied by
international suppliers.
2
Estimated based on information from four major suppliers, REF tender document and UNEP/GEF Project,
previous studies by Megen Power, 2005.
3
Total system volume including complete system and installation costs.
Target Market Analysis: Ethiopia’s Solar Energy Market 3
This conveniently coincided with growing rural income over the past few years. However, this potential
market remains entirely unserved at the moment.
The total installed capacity for SHS in households and small commercial establishments is estimated
to be over 1 MWp. The present demand for SHS is in the order of 200 kWp per annum with an
average annual growth rate of about 20 %.
In summary, the relative growth in PV SHS and small commercial applications is attributable to the
following factors:
Awareness creation and capacity building efforts by donor-funded projects since 2000, even
though they were spontaneous in nature, have played significant role in creating demand and
establishing linkages between Addis based suppliers and rural retailers.
Improving rural income in many parts of the country due to favourable terms of trade for
agricultural products (i.e. coffee and chat growers) created demand for consumer electronics.
Telecommunication expansion into rural areas created new demand for smaller systems.
Presence of Rural Energy Fund (REF) created awareness about solar PV system as
alternative power supply systems at the level of regional energy bureaus which was further
propagated to districts and rural consumers.
Procurements of PV systems through regional energy bureaus (in Oromia and Southern
Peoples Regions) for re-sell at subsidised prices to rural households and businesses for
promotional purposes have sensitised the market.
As a result of the convergence of all the above favourable market conditions, the PV solar market is
set to grow. The market would grow to even higher levels if more innovative and flexible financing
mechanisms were put in place; fortunately as a step forward to the stimulation of the solar market, the
Ministry of Finance and Economic Development (MoFED) waived the tax duty from the importation of
solar energy equipment in December 2009.
Despite such favourable market conditions, however, PV equipment and accessories are not always
available in the local commercial market in quantities and sizes the market requires. Therefore, this is
an opportunity for German companies to forge partnerships with local companies and keep equipment
in stock in the required commercial market. In addition to maintaining the momentum, such
partnerships would lead the local market to grow into the next higher level of development.
At the moment, the driving force for institutional PV market is financial support from NGOs and
international donors. Procurement for religious institutions, however, is fully financed by members’
contributions. For instance, in 2008, REF alone internationally procured solar PV systems worth over
4
one million Euros in one bid. These systems are earmarked for installation in selected rural schools
and health facilities. Total capacity of equipment is in the range of 70-80 kWp. More recently it has
become a trend for religious institutions to install solar PV systems to power their sound systems and
musical instruments. For instance, in 2008 one single supplier sold PV systems in the range of 30
kWp for off-grid rural churches mainly in Southern parts of Ethiopia. An 80 Wp system has been a
typical size for rural religious institutions.
4
An Asian company won the bid at a price of about € 9.3 per Wp before tax. The quoted price includes
transportation, installation and after sales service.
Target Market Analysis: Ethiopia’s Solar Energy Market 4
The total installed solar PV capacity in off grid institutional systems including health institutions,
schools, and water supply systems is estimated to be around 500 kWp. However, in the last one or
two years demand is growing mainly due to REF funds and NGO support. During the last six months
alone international and local tenders worth over one million Euros were announced for the supply of
institutional PV systems.
Based on sales volume in the past two years, the market for off-grid community systems is estimated
to be over 200 kWp per year. Given the number of pipeline projects over the next one year or so,
installation of systems is expected to exceed the current annual estimate.
Telecommunication
The Ethiopian telecommunication sector is one of the fastest growing and largest PV market perhaps
in the whole of Eastern Africa. In 2005 total installed capacity stood at around 3 MWp which
constituted over 70 % of the total market share.
Currently, as part of the overall national development programme, the Ethiopian Telecommunication
Corporation (ETC) has been implementing a five-year-programme (Universal Connectivity
Programme) since 2005. Over 18,000 villages are known to exist in rural Ethiopia. The programme
5
aims to achieve 100 % telecommunication coverage (universal telecom access ) in the country by
6
connecting all rural villages so that rural dwellers will get telephone access within a radius of about 5
7
km. According to ETC, about 80 % of the target has been achieved so far. In order to connect the
remaining 20 % of the villages and service centres, ETC needs to install additional 6,000 to 8,000
wireless telephones. This would create additional demand for over 200 kWp systems (i.e. 8000 rural
telephones x 30 Wp) over the coming one year. Nevertheless, in some villages due to highly scattered
settlement patterns rural communities and local topography, people have to travel as far as 15 km to
get access to a telephone service. In order to reduce travelling distance for people living in scattered
settlements and improve overall access on per capita basis, ETC has planned to increase the number
of wireless telephone units from one to five in each rural village over a time horizon of five years.
Installation of additional telephone units would create an additional demand for about 1.8 MWp
systems. In off-grid locations ETC powers its rural base stations and wireless telephones with either
solar PV or generator sets.
It is worth noting that, unlike previous telecom installations which are in the range of 1-2 kWp, power
requirements of wireless telephone are smaller (between 20-30 Wp). It should also be noted that the
aggressive advance of the grid into the rural areas in recent years has resulted in a continuous
replacement of the existing solar PV and genset powered base transmission stations by grid electricity
throughout several rural parts of the country.
Tourism
Despite several tourist destinations, the tourism industry is at its early stages of development. The
industry has yet to fullfill basic infrastructure and services. Most of the tourist destinations in the North,
(historic route) are grid connected. With the exception of the Semen Mountain National Park (14 kWp
installed capacity) and few other eco-lodges in the South, other off-grid tourist destinations have yet to
develop camping facilities which may require alternative source of power such as solar PV. Therefore,
despite its considerable potential for the future, the PV market for the Ethiopian tourism sector has yet
to be developed.
5
“Access” is defined as having one telecom service station in each village. In addition to the minimum access to
telecom service, rural connectivity programme includes the provision of telecom service to rural administrative
offices, government organisations, cooperatives and investment schemes.
6
Total number of rural villages in the country is about 18,000.
7
Interview with Telecom Agency Planning Department
Target Market Analysis: Ethiopia’s Solar Energy Market 5
Other markets
Until 2003/04 the national power grid was fairly reliable. However, the utility is unable to keep pace
with the growing need for energy to fuel the growing economy in recent years. As a result, frequent
power shedding has become a common practice. In response to this power crisis, demand for
generator sets and - more recently - inverter battery backup systems is growing exceptionally. At the
moment inverter backup systems may not constitute a real PV market, but in the medium term, the
inverter charger backup market together with the upcoming feed-in tariff law may constitute an
opportunity for grid-connected PV.
There are about five or six major players in the industry which import PV systems and
components from various suppliers. Companies typically import systems in small
consignments because of two reasons. The first is fear of tying up capitals on equipments in
stocks due to limited market to absorb large imports. Secondly, companies themselves have
limited finance as solar constitutes a small percentage of their business.
New entrants to the market who have links or affiliation to international PV companies have
set their presence in the country waiting for major demands. Some of them import solar
equipments for retail while others are simply waiting for opportunities.
Few others import whenever they can but usually obtain systems locally for installation
businesses.
NGOs and regional governments such as Oromia and Southern Region are actively promoting
solar PV systems through procurement, financing and training PV installation in their
respective jurisdictions.
Locally manufactured flat plate collectors were the most common types of SWHs until they were out-
competed by evacuated-tube-type collectors (with and without heat pipes) imported mainly from
China, Israel and Italy.
Target Market Analysis: Ethiopia’s Solar Energy Market 6
Table 2: Outline of the Sales of Solar Water Heater and the Market Structure
Assessing the total potential market volume of 1000 units of SWHs per annum, this could be
considered too small a market to attract investment. However, the market is steadily growing in recent
years and such growth in the market is witnessed in the face of inexpensive grid electricity (less than
USD 0.06/kWh domestic tariff) and in the absence of enabling policy environment for renewable
energy technologies. Integrating SWHs with ongoing low cost housing and real-estate development
could provide further impetus to the SWH market. Therefore, by creating partnerships with local
businesses German companies could position themselves strategically to take advantage of the
growing market opportunities in this sector in the near future.
The predominant operator model in the SWH industry is characterised by companies engaged in
doing everything including importation, retail, installation and maintenance by them. Currently, there
are about seven companies that import and sell SWHs in large volumes.
Sizing and installations of larger systems are always conducted by in-house technicians of the
companies themselves. Lack of autonomous skilled technicians is so severe that local PV companies
are often compelled to use their in-house capacities to install even smaller SHS in some areas.
Including in-house technicians of local PV dealers, all of whom are based in Addis Ababa, a total of
about 50 technicians are believed to exist nationwide. About one-quarter of the total number of
technicians are supposedly autonomous and not necessarily attached to one or the other PV dealer.
Each PV dealer on the average maintains one or two technicians in-house. PV companies outsource
autonomous technicians only when necessary.
8
Equipment and installation cost
Target Market Analysis: Ethiopia’s Solar Energy Market 7
In summary, therefore, considerable technical capacity constraints are evident in the local market in
both PV and SWH sub sectors. Conversely, such capacity limitations present themselves as ample
opportunities for German companies who wish to either sell their skills and services or develop
strategic business partnerships with local solar companies, or both.
2 Market Potentials
2.1 Overall Sector Outlook
2.1.1 Solar PV
Market Potentials
In the past, the Ethiopian PV market was dominated by bulk purchases by the telecom industry and
donor driven large projects. Until early 2000s there was a gross misconception about commercial PV
market in Ethiopia. That is, firstly, PV is too expensive and too high-tech to be used by rural
consumers, and secondly, rural Ethiopians are too poor to afford PV. Further, the official attitude
towards PV is such that PV does not have a role to play in energising development for it does not
provide adequate motive power. Such misconceptions have improved considerably over the past
several years thanks to few ice-breaking donor supported projects which helped to unleash the
market.
Demand for PV has been growing in Ethiopia over the last ten years. Some of the favourable market
conditions that have led to current PV market growth include the following:
1. Officially, access to electricity is estimated at about 22 % with actual connection rate of only
about 6 % nationwide. This leaves massive sections of off grid communities unelectrified by
the grid. Given the distributed nature of PV solar, a good portion of this market could be
served using PV technology.
2. The majority of rural Ethiopians may be too poor to afford PV. However, due to the sheer
number of rural population, even if a minute fraction of that population is served with PV, the
absolute numbers are too significant to be ignored. Smaller products (for example solar
lanterns) will considerably increase access.
3. Despite the overall low rural incomes, there are a number of cash crop growing areas that will
constitute a considerable market for solar PV.
4. The overall Ethiopian economy has been growing by over 10 % for the past several years in a
row. Similarly, export re-orientation of the government policies have resulted in a steady rising
of rural incomes during the same period. Such growth of rural incomes has resulted in growing
demand industrial goods and services including solar PV.
Target Market Analysis: Ethiopia’s Solar Energy Market 8
5. Efforts made jointly by the Ethiopian Government and international donors to build market
infrastructure for solar PV commercialisation have led to growing awareness, some technical
capacity, and creation of linkages between various players in the industry. For instance, some
ten years ago awareness about solar PV technology among rural communities in Ethiopia was
none existent. Thanks to efforts made by IGAD/EU, UNEP/GEF, REF and regional
Governments of Oromia and Southern Ethiopia, at present, over one-third of the rural
communities have either heard about, or seen, or used solar PV.
6. More recently, there are also efforts that are aimed at building upon previous gains and
accelerate the commercial PV market growth. Key players behind recent PV commercial
market development include GTZ-AMES and the NGO Solar Stiftung (Solar Energy
Foundation).
7. The penetration of telecom services into the rural arena has given an additional impetus to
rising demand for solar PV for charging mobile and wireless phones in rural off grid areas. It
will open up new niches for different types of products and services.
In summary, the convergence of the above favourable market conditions has resulted in an average
market growth rate of about 20 % per annum during the last three years. Table 3 below presents an
indicative matrix of the potential market for solar PV systems in Ethiopia.
9
Table 3: Solar PV Off-Grid Market Potential in Ethiopia
9
Multiple sources: Own estimation based on information from Lighting Africa (2008), Central Statistics Authority
2007, information from suppliers.
Target Market Analysis: Ethiopia’s Solar Energy Market 9
Some important conclusions can be drawn from potential PV market analysis presented in Table 3
above. These are:
The total potential market for solar PV in Ethiopia is estimated to be about 52 MW. Currently,
the estimated market penetration rate is about 8 % of the potential.
Over three-quarters of the total demand comes from the household sector distantly followed
by the health institutions, rural schools and the telecom industry.
Despite its diminishing role as a major PV market, the telecom sector will continue to
constitute immediate cash market. According to ETC’s short to medium term rural connectivity
plan, the estimated PV market in the telecom sector is likely to saturate over the coming five
years or so. However, this does not mean that market for the rural telecom connectivity is
entirely exhausted. With rapidly growing urbanization and improving rural incomes demand
for solar PV to power rural telecommunication in off grid locations is expected to continue
growing.
At present, community water supply and institutional PV markets (health institutions and
schools) are financed almost entirely by donors. Out of an estimated potential market of about
10 MW in community and institutional PV market, only a small fraction (about 1 %) is currently
served. Since the bulk of the market is yet to be tapped and financing is most likely to come
from donors, demand in these sectors will continue to provide much needed incentives to the
commercial PV market growth.
As there is no local experience yet, it is difficult to estimate the potential market for grid-
connected PV. Obviously, however, PV grid connection will become hugely relevant and the
long term prospect is considerable. However, as it stands now, grid-connected PV is far from
being competitive to Ethiopia’s highly hydro dominated power supply option. Perhaps this
could be the reason why the feed-in tariff law under review did not consider solar PV grid
connect as the current and short-term generation cost per kWh can simply be several times
10
higher than the competing options.
Telecom coverage is expanding rapidly into rural areas at a rate much faster than that of grid
electricity. This has created considerable demand for electricity for charging mobile phones in
off-grid areas. An estimated one million mobile phones are believed to exist in off-grid areas.
At the moment mobile phone consumers are travelling 10-20 km to access electricity for
charging their phones. Beside the inconvenience and considerable travel effort, consumers
are paying € 0.11 per charge, or approximately € 11 per capita per year. This is equivalent to
11 million Euros business annually. At the moment, this is a cash market which is entirely
unserved. This market can best be served in the following ways:
1. Centralised mobile phone charging station: this is a multi-port charging unit with a
battery (fixed or portable) capable of charging several phones simultaneously. Such
units can be bought and owned by private small businesses as an additional income
generating activity.
10
Feed-in tariff law, Second draft, Ethiopian Electric Agency, Ministry of Mines and Energy, October 2009.
Target Market Analysis: Ethiopia’s Solar Energy Market 10
Obstacles / constraints
Currently, the global economic downturn has caused some economic difficulties including
shortage of foreign exchange to import solar PV equipments. As a result, currently local
companies are either out of stock or under stocked. This problem is expected to be only
temporal.
Another issue that will continue to pose challenges to solar PV market is the rapidly advancing
grid without clear and enforceable master plan. The grid, however, is not necessarily a threat
to potential PV market. It could even be considered as new opportunity for integrated grid
connected PV.
Still another constraint in the sector is capacity limitation both at the level of
dealers/companies and autonomous technicians. Major constraints at the level of PV
companies include: in adequate working capital, managerial skills, lack of specialisation,
limited network both upstream and downstream. Constraints on part of technicians include
lack of organisation, lack of technical skills for sizing and designing larger systems, and
inadequate skills for installation of smaller systems.
High upfront cost of solar PV systems in the face of absence or inadequate innovative
financing mechanisms.
More recently, the acute shortage of foreign currency has become a serious constraint for
supply and stocking of PV equipment and accessories in adequate quantities.
Lack of appreciation among policy makers of the role of PV as a complementary strategy in
both on-grid and off-grid electrification.
First of all, German enterprises should forge partnerships with capable local PV
companies to position themselves strategically for the growing solar PV market in Ethiopia
and the region as a whole. Such partnerships would help German companies to tap into
large scale international competitive bidding for telecom industry and donor supported
institutional PV market. Initially, such partnerships would require some investment in
building technical and managerial capacities of local partners.
Technical capacities and skills for designing, sizing and installing larger systems hardly
exist locally. Therefore, in addition to supplying PV equipment and accessories, such
constraints constitute an opportunity for German enterprises to market their expertise and
services.
While tapping into existing commercial as well as institutional solar PV market, German
companies should be vigilant and be ready to take advantage of much larger PV market
such as isolated mini grids and integrated grid connected PV which are likely to unfold in
due course.
Currently, despite a rapid expansion of mobile phone into the rural market, the market is
unable to provide innovative mobile phone charging technologies. German enterprises
could fill in this niche market. To facilitate reaching out to off-grid micro PV market, it
makes sense for German companies to forge partnership with mobile phone
manufacturers, telecom operators and local PV dealers.
Target Market Analysis: Ethiopia’s Solar Energy Market 11
On the average, two electric water heaters are installed in almost every newly built residential house.
In addition to the government financed low cost housing (condominium), dozens of real-estate
developers are engaged in constructions of residential houses in the capital as well as other major
towns. Currently, construction of tens of thousands of housing units (close to 100,000 at present) is
either completed or underway throughout the country. Therefore, even if a fraction of existing electric
water heaters is replaced by SWHs over the next several years the market would remain attractive
enough for private investment. For instance, if one assumes that only one-quarter (25,000 units) of
existing electric water heaters in the domestic sector were to be replaced by SWHs, the potential
market would be five times more than total installed capacity to-date, which stands at about 5,000
units.
An estimated 80 % of total installed capacity of SWHs is within Addis Ababa. It is estimated that the
residential housing SWH market takes the lion’s share of 90 % while the surplus goes to hotels and
tourism. Conservatively, an estimated 2000 hotels and pensions with an average number of 20 rooms
each fitted with electric geysers exist throughout all towns in the country. Given the attractive financial
incentives that SWHs would bring to the businesses, it is assumed that 100 % of them would replace
their electric geysers with SWHs. This would translate into an estimated market potential of 40,000
units of domestic size SWHs. Putting domestic and hotel potential markets for SWHs together, the
total aggregate potential market for SWHs would become about 65,000 units. Assuming a
concurrence factor of 40 % for households and 80 % for hotels on the morning hour peak demand, the
contribution of SWH to serve the peak demand is estimated to reach 50 MW.
Existing growth and estimated market potential for SWHs is in the absence of conducive policy
environment for the technology. In fact, relatively low existing electricity tariff (0.06 €/kWh), is a
considerable challenge for a wide spread market uptake. Therefore, if favourable policy environment
were created - including upward electricity tariff revision – then the total potential market would be
much higher.
Owing to delays in completion of construction of several large hydro power projects, there is an
estimated 200 MW power shortage at the moment. In response to prevailing power shortage, EEPCo,
the national power utility, has embarked upon demand side management (DSM) interventions other
than load shedding.
Target Market Analysis: Ethiopia’s Solar Energy Market 12
Undeveloped market opportunities considered in this section will focus primarily on solar hybrid PV in
the tourism, telecom sectors and village mini-grids.
Despite value addition, enhanced reliability and cost-effectiveness of energy solutions that such hybrid
systems could provide to off-grid consumers, potential markets for such systems remain largely
undeveloped in Ethiopia.
The tourism industry as a whole is not fully developed and well diversified
The majority of the destinations, particularly those in the Northern “historic” route are grid-
connected
Lodges and tourist camping facilities, which would be ideal places for solar hybrid PV
electrification, are uncommon or only coming up in recent years.
Therefore, despite growth in number of tourists in recent years, the market for solar hybrid PV in the
tourism sector is not yet developed.
Target Market Analysis: Ethiopia’s Solar Energy Market 13
For instance, the GSM and GPRS mobile networks with fibre optic backbone supplied by Nokia
Siemens Networks required the construction of some 300 new base transmission stations (BTS) in the
Northern and Central parts of the country alone. According ETC, half of these stations are located in
“hard-to-access rural areas” where there is no grid electricity to provide power. In response to this
challenge, ETC approached Nokia Siemens to come up with a sustainable alternative to diesel
generators. Nokia Siemens Networks built more than 50 solar-powered BTSs where solar PV,
including battery banks, is being used to power the stations as well as the transmission node sites for
11
the fibre optic backbone network. Therefore, all or most of the remaining 100 BTSs constitute
undeveloped market for PV hybrid.
Although the grid is advancing rapidly and hundreds of small towns and villages are getting connected
every year at present, an estimated 200 to 300, diesel powered BTSs might still exist in Ethiopia.
12
Potentially, all of these stations could be powered using solar PV, or PV-diesel hybrid. Replacing the
power supply systems for the BTSs alone with solar PV would require 1.5-2 MWp systems.
Given the faster pace of rural electrification in the past two years, the number of electrified towns and
villages might have currently reached 3000. Even then, this leaves nearly 5,000 towns and villages to
be electrified yet in the next years. Therefore, we can safely assume that there are over 10,000 rural
11
Ethiopian Telecommunications Network Powered by Renewable Energy Solutions: A Success Story,
www.nokiasiemensnetworks.com.
12
However, officials within ETC are skeptical about this because, according to them, the majority of off-grid V-
Sats and BTSs, which used to be powered by solar PV and gensets are now being replaced by grid electricity;
and this leaves no or very little room for PV hybrid application in the sector.
13
The World Bank: Electricity Access (Rural) Grid And Off-Grid Expansion Project – Phase II, May 25, 2007
Target Market Analysis: Ethiopia’s Solar Energy Market 14
villages that will remain un-electrified for foreseeable future. Even if we assume a fraction of those
villages (say 5 %) as potential market for solar hybrid PV, it constitutes a considerable market for PV.
Table 5: Summary of Estimated Undeveloped Market Potential for Solar Hybrid PV Systems
EEPCo, under its so called self-contained system (SCS), operates several mini-grids providing
electricity to dozens of rural towns. An estimated 30 to 40 small towns are currently being served by
SCS mini-grids. The SCS has a total installed capacity of about 22 MW of which only about 6 MW is
mini and small hydro and the balance diesel genset. Similarly, there are hundreds of small informal
businesses and private individuals who generate and sell electricity using gensets. Informal electricity
suppliers generate an estimated 100 MW of which some 30 % are located off-grid. Therefore, while
the bulk of thousands (5,000+) of unelectrified rural towns constitutes undeveloped market, urban
settlements with diesel-based mini-grids could be considered as immediate potential market for hybrid
PV systems.
As ambitious as it is, EEPCo’s grid-based rural electrification (implemented through UEAP) alone
might not be able to meet the energy needs of the country any time soon. This is because, firstly,
2
Ethiopia is a vast country with an estimated land area of 1.1 million km ; and secondly, the rate of
electrification is one of the lowest (6 % direct connection) even compared with Sub Sahara Africa
(SSA) standards. Challenged by those inconvenient realities mentioned above, the GoE has
recognised the need for more innovative energy solutions and flexible technologies to complement its
Target Market Analysis: Ethiopia’s Solar Energy Market 15
overall national rural electrification programme. In line with this, the GoE has established the
necessary institutional and financing frameworks to facilitate and accelerate off-grid rural
electrification. The establishment of rural electrification fund (REF) under the Ethiopian Rural Energy
Development and Promotion Centre (EREDPC) has opened up new opportunities for Renewable
Energy Technologies (RETs) particularly solar PV and mini and micro hydro power development in the
country.
Cognizant of the inherent limitations of grid-based rural electrification, the GoE, has set up the Rural
Electrification Fund (REF) to electrify off-grid rural areas. The two most important components of the
REF initiatives are promotion and support to mini-grids and solar PV for institutions such as health and
education. The mini-grid component with its initial budget of about 29 million Euros was designed to
finance about 180- 200 projects of isolated grids, with majority of renewable energy projects, i.e., mini
and micro hydro, and solar PV. It was targeted at providing electricity services to 150,000 customers,
representing a population of 750,000 inhabitants. The institutional PV component, which had a budget
of about 1.9 million Euros, was designed to support installation 1000 institutional PV systems in
selected clinics and schools. Details of cost estimates and funding sources are presented in Table 6
below. The REF is still active and running, despite its very slow process in financing RE projects.
Table 6: Cost Estimates and Funding Sources for Off-Grid Electrification (in Million €)
through increased diversity of generation options. The policy has given less emphasis towards the
application of solar energy technologies to rural development and livelihood improvement.
The Quality and Standard Authority of Ethiopia (QSAE) does not have codes of standards to solar
equipment and installation of systems. More recently, however, with appearance of finance and
support organisations (i.e. REF, NGOs, etc) in the solar PV industry, quality and standard of products
has become an issue. However, on the other hand, building the capacities of PV technicians’ both in
quality and quantity is highly required and it has to go together with the effort of setting codes of
standard for products and practices in the industry. To this effect, GTZ AMES-E and Solar Stiftung
(Solar Energy Foundation) have taken initiatives to establish solar competence centres in the country
Solar Stiftung (Solar Energy Foundation) has already established a training facility in Amhara Region
of Ethiopia. GTZ AMES-E on the other hand signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) with
Selam Technical Vocational Training Centre for establishment of a training facility in Addis Ababa.
Under Energy Access Project-I, the majority of approved and co-financed projects were diesel
generators. As diesel gensets not only unsustainable but also not favoured by government policies
(increased foreign exchange burden from oil imports), EAREP-II gives priority to Renewable Energy
projects when and wherever resource availability allows. In addition to co-financing, the REF also
assists Renewable Energy project developers in evaluating least-cost options such as solar, biomass
technologies and diesel/wind hybrid systems in areas without hydro resources.
In the last couple of years, the REF has disbursed about two million Euros for procurement and
installation of solar PV systems for rural schools (100), health facilities (200), and households (about
600). The REF floats one or two tenders annually for the supply and installation of PV system.
Target Market Analysis: Ethiopia’s Solar Energy Market 18
GTZ AMES-E
GTZ under its six-year-programme “Access to Modern Energy Services – Ethiopia” (AMES-E)
promotes solar PV system through capacity building and installation of pilot institutional solar PV
systems. GTZ has already procured solar PV modules and equipments to be installed in 50 rural
health centers in 2009. The total system size is about 75 kWp. In the coming three years, before the
completion of the project, GTZ will install solar PV systems in 50 more rural health clinics and about
30 rural schools. Moreover, in partnership with the Ministry of Mines and Energy and Selam Technical
Vocational Centre, GTZ will set up a solar PV training centre, the centre to be set up will have all the
necessary equipment needed for conducting standardized training.
Plan Ethiopia
Plan Ethiopia is the local representative of the NGO Plan International. It is involved in various
community development activities in various sectors such as health, education, water development.
As part of its social service improvement activities, Plan Ethiopia recently adopted integration of solar
PV systems into rural health facilities, schools and community water supply system. In the coming two
years it will require supply of solar PV systems of size over 90 kWp.
Others
There are several local regional governments in Ethiopia, particularly health bureaus and energy
agencies, set aside budgets for procurement of solar PV systems. For instance, Amhara Regional
Health Bureau, with support obtained from Austrian Development Cooperation, needs a supply of
solar PV systems and vaccine fridges for rural health facilities to be installed in 2009.
Lighting Africa
Lighting Africa is a World Bank/IFC funded project currently under implementation in several African
countries including Ethiopia. Currently, the project is in preparation to conduct nationwide market
assessment for solar PV lighting opportunities.
With growing demand for solar PV and SWH, the number of suppliers has also grown over the past
years. At present, there are about 15 solar PV companies at different capacities and levels of
involvement in the business. However, over 80 % of the annual solar PV sales are constituted by
about five companies. The others are opportunistic traders who sometimes import few systems
otherwise purchase from the major suppliers. Including all players in the PV market, their number has
grown by about 50 % in the last three years. Table 8 below shows the list of major solar PV dealers in
Ethiopia.
New companies are also getting into the SWH market. At present there are about ten SWH dealers in
the country. Solar water heater market is mainly the urban households market. Imported products are
of smaller sizes suitable for households. Systems with pumps and central hot water distribution for
hotels and institutions are not adapted in the country. Hotels and institutions use several smaller
modular units each having their own hot water tank. In addition to the PV dealers outlined in Table 8,
the following companies are involved in the SWH market:
Target Market Analysis: Ethiopia’s Solar Energy Market 19
Equatorial Business A multi million business company. SWH EBG Head Office
Group (EBG) account for less than 5 % of the total Debre Zeit Road
business. It takes the biggest share of P.O.Box 8964
total sales in the country. Products are Addis Ababa Ethiopia
mainly of heat-pipe technology.
Tel : (+251) (0) 11-4400103/4407492
Tel : (+251) (0) 11-4424955(PABX)
Fax : (+251) (0) 11-4422148
Email ebg@ethionet.et
Internet: www.ebg-ethiopia.com
NBA-Solar Energy & A new entrant to the SWH business NBA-Solar Energy & Security Centre PLC
Security Centre PLC specialising in SWH. Yelebe Molla Abebe
P.O.BOX 24859/1
Addis Ababa Ethiopia
2008 Importing Company description & Company strategy Major PV product PV business Equipment Contact details
company distributors sector sources
200 kWp Direct Solar Privately owned Ethiopian 100 % PV work. Aggressive marketing to Modules and controllers SHS, commercial, Mulugeta Girma
Energy company based in Addis donors. Supplies PV systems to all are mostly imported from solar pump, and Mob: (+251) (0) 911207830
Ababa. Total number of markets - households, commercial, NGO suppliers in Europe and institutional Email: directso@ethionet.et
employees less than five and government projects. Pioneer in Dubai. systems market
development of commercial sales Batteries: mainly from
outside Addis Ababa. China.
Imports equipment from
changing suppliers.
150 kWp Everbright Private Ethiopian solar PV Over 90 % PV work. Targets home Modules and balance of SHS and small Imports Tesfaye Legese
company. More than ten systems and small commercial system systems including commercial products Tel: (+251) (0) 911619474
employees markets. controllers, batteries and systems market mostly from
Has retailing shops in some rural towns. light bulbs China
40 kWp Lydetco P.L.C Private Limited Ethiopian Solar PV constitutes less than 20 % of All modules and system Institutional, PV products Dereje Walelign
Company. Number of business turnover. Company strategy is components from major PV telecom mainly from Tel: (+251) (0) 911207283 or
employees more than ten to respond to tenders also wholesales multinational PV company Europe 114 663189
and retails. in Europe Email: lydet@ethionet.et
20 kWp BETA Private Ethiopian Company. PV constitutes between 10-15 % of the Modules: Opportunistic, Household, small Mostly from Kassa W.Senbet
Electrical Total number of employees business. Electrical spares and BOS: India, Europe. commercial and India Mob: (+251) (0) 911242766
Engineering (both permanent and short engineers with operations in off-grid institutional Email: route@ethionet.et
P.L.C. term) is more than 50. areas. Strategic partnership with systems market
Those involved in solar are international finance organisation.
less than ten in number
5 kWp Ethio-Ducth Company established in 100 % PV company. It aims for large Product list includes Institutional system China and Adane W. Michael
Business P.L.C partnership with Ethiopian scale donor supported institutional modules, BOS markets Europe Tel: (+ 251) (0) 113200021
and Netherlands company systems. Email: adane@solar-man.net
(Gira Mundo/ Solar Man). Wholesales and retails equipment -
Employees less than five including home systems and small
commercial systems market.
Davis & A subsidiary of Davis Specialised in pumps and PV systems. Supplies pumps and PV Urael Bole Tele Road
Shirtliff Shirtliff Kenya Focus on institutional and wholesale systems market. Wholesale P.O. Box 170540
market. to distributers. Addis Ababa / Ethiopia
Tel: (+251) (0) 11 51 59
341/44
Fax: (+251) (0) 11 51 59 351
Email: d&s@et.dayliff.com
Target Market Analysis: Ethiopia’s Solar Energy Market 21
Table 9: List of Consultants, NGOs and Non-Governmental Projects in the Solar PV Market
Procurements
Plans in
(types of
Full name Role in sector Activities Volume kWp or € immediate Contact details
equipment/
future
services)
GTZ - AMES Promoter Installation of pilot institutional systems to rural Solar PV systems Over 75 kWp (about 1 to 3 years Joachim Gaube, or
health facilities and schools. Plans to set up a solar € 700,000 for clinics Samson Tolosa
training facility in Addis Ababa. plus between 15-30 (+251) (0) 911 429640/ 911211284
kWp for schools Email: joachim.gaube@gtz.de;
(over € 200,000) samson.tolessa@gtz.de
Solar Stiftung (Solar Promoter Promotes SHS through installation of PV systems at Samson Tsegaye
Energy Foundation) subsidised price, Tel: (+251) (0) 116 181462,
Installed over a 1000 small solar PV powered LED Mob: (+251) (0) 911 228710
system in more than 1000 homes in a rural village, Email: sccaddis@yahoo.com
Works closely with local regional governments in
Ethiopia to install SHS at subsidised price,
Established a solar PV training facility in Amhara
Regional State.
Plan Ethiopia/ Plan NGO-involved in Development of community water supply system, Institutional systems Over 90 kWp (above In few months Asnake W. Michael
International community construction of rural health facilities and schools, for rural schools, 800,000 Euros) time Email:
development child sponsorship programme. health facilities and asnake.woldemichael@plan-
activities community water international.org
supply systems
Procurements
Plans in
(types of
Full name Role in sector Activities Volume kWp or € Immediate Contact Details
equipment/
Future
services)
Rural Electrification Promotion and Assists developers on rural electrification projects, SHS for 300 homes 7 kWp system Tender already Amare Hadgo
Fund financing rural Disburse loans. in Somali regional (about 70 thousand floated Tel: (+251) (0) 116 558 654
electrification state Euros) Email: eesrc@ethionet.et
projects
Ethiopian Electric Electricity Issues operational licenses for power generation, Getahun Moges
Agency regulation distribution and sales, regulates electricity tariff.
Amhara Region Ensures provision Solar PV systems Over 7 kWp (over 70 In few months Wudu Ayalew
Bureau of Health of health services for rural health thousand Euros) Tel: (+251) (0) 582 201 722
facilities
Ethiopian Engineering Procurement of solar PV modules for telecom Solar PV modules >2 MW PV module from 1 to 5 years Tayework
Telecommunication support for ETC's infrastructure. (worth over 20 Tel:(+251) (0) 115 529 687 or
Corporation (ETC) rural telephony million Euros) 115 527579
programme
Target Market Analysis: Ethiopia’s Solar Energy Market 23
Several ongoing projects are stimulating the solar PV market in Ethiopia. As it has been mentioned in
section 2.1, institutional demand for solar PV is driven mainly by donors’ support. Such demands are
incentives for businesses with a trickle-down effect on developing the commercial market. In this
regard, solar PV support-programmes by UNEP/GEF, REF, GTZ AMES-E and Solar Stiftung (Solar
Energy Foundation) are worth mentioning.
Important Projects
The Rural Electrification Fund (REF) - One of primary purposes for the establishment of REF is to
stimulate the solar PV market through provision of financing mechanism in the form of soft loans.
Since its formation, REF has disbursed over two million Euros for direct purchase of solar PV
equipment and local technical capacity building activities. Out of the total finance made available in the
PV sector through REF, about half goes to installation of PV systems in rural health facilities and
schools. REF encourages rural communities to organise in unions/cooperatives in order to become
eligible to access REF loans. REF financed the following institutional and SHS installation:
GTZ AMES-E is implementing a six years programme with the financial support obtained from the
Dutch Government under “Energising Development Programme”. Under this programme, GTZ
promotes solar PV systems and micro-hydro power as pilot projects intended to remove barriers for
PV commercial market development. GTZ AMES-E is currently working on the installation of the
following institutional PV systems:
First-round installations: Installation of a total of 57.6 kWp (1.44 kWp x 40 institutions) in 40
health institutions is currently completed in various parts of the country.
Second-round installations: Installation of a total of 72 kWp (1.44 kWp x 50 institutions) in 50
health institutions is underway.
Community Service and Schools: Another round of institutional PV installations for community
services and rural schools is being envisaged by AMES to be completed over the coming
years.
Besides, GTZ AMES has signed a Memorandum of Understanding with Ethiopian Rural Energy
Development and Promotion Centre and Selam Technical Vocational Centre for establishment of a
solar PV training centre. The training facility is expected to start functioning over the coming three
years.
Solar Stiftung (Solar Energy Foundation) is a German NGO that works on promotion of solar PV
technologies and technical capacity building. Over the last few years, Solar Stiftung installed solar
home system in more than 3,000 households in various parts of the country. The following are PV
SHS projects under Solar Stiftung:
Rema-Dire SHS project: Installation of a total of 2,000 SHS in Rema and Dire Villages in
Amahara region.
SHS in various regions: A total of 1,000 SHS were installed in Oromia, Southern Ethiopia,
Amhara and Tigray regions.
Target Market Analysis: Ethiopia’s Solar Energy Market 25
Solar Stiftung (Solar Energy Foundation) envisages installing 49,000 SHS in various parts of
the country over the coming two years. Besides, the NGO has established a solar competence
centre in Amhara regional state. This centre is expected to increase the availability of capable
solar technicians in the country over the coming few years.
These and various other efforts by governmental organisations, NGOs and private firms are expected
to set the solar PV industry to grow in an accelerated rate over the coming years.
14
Solar 23 Pvt. Ltd Co. a local company but affiliated with Solar 23 Germany, and Davis & Shirtliff, a subsidiary of
Davis & Shirtliff Kenya.
Target Market Analysis: Ethiopia’s Solar Energy Market 26
References
Ethiopian Electric Agency (EEA): http://ethioelectricagency.org/ (July 2010).
Ethiopian Telecommunication Corporation (ETC): http://www.ethionet.et/ (July 2010).
Ethiopian Telecommunications Network Powered by Renewable Energy Solutions: A Success
Story, www.nokiasiemensnetworks.com (July 2010).
Feed-in tariff law, Second draft, Ethiopian Electric Agency, Ministry of Mines and Energy,
October 2009.
Ministry of Mines and Energy: www.mome.gov.et (July 2010).
Rural Electrification Fund (REF): http://ethiopiaref.energyprojects.net/ (July 2010).
Solar Energy Resources, Technical Report 3, CESEN 1986.
The World Bank: Electricity Access (Rural) Grid And Off-Grid Expansion Project – Phase II,
May 25, 2007.
This publication is available free of charge as part of the public relations work of the Federal
Ministry of Economics and Technology, and may not be sold. It may not be used by political parties
or campaigners or electoral assistants during an election for the purposes of campaigning. In
particular, it is forbidden to distribute this publication at campaign events or at information stands
run by political parties or to insert, overprint, or affix partisan information or advertising. It is also
forbidden to pass it on to third parties for the purposes of electoral campaigning. lrrespective of
when, in what way, and in what quantity this publication reached the recipient, it may not be used
even when an election is not approaching in a way that might be understood as suggesting a bias
in the federal government in favour of individual political groupings.