Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Henry Brodaty
Dementia Collaborative Research Centre, UNSW
www.dementiaresearch.org.au
Aetiology of BPSD
• Biological
• Psychological
• Interpersonal
• Environmental
Socio- Interpersonal
environmental
Biological Psychological
Socio-
environmental Interpersonal
Biological Psychological
Translating dementia research into practice
How to intervene: Environment
Moderate evidence
• Small unit size
– hard to differentiate effect of unit size
from staff related factors
• Opportunity to engage in ordinary
ADLs
– again, hard to differentiate from staff
support/engagement
Fleming R – www.dementiaresearch.org.au
Translating dementia research into practice
Interesting – but no good evidence
• Signage
• Display of
personal
memorabilia
Aroma therapy
Lavender Lemon Balm
• Antibacterial (eugenol)
• Antiviral (tannins)
• Mild sedative or calming
agent (terpenes)
• Antioxidant activity
Light therapy
Forbes D, Morgan DG, Bangma J et al; Cochrane Review 2004, updated 2006
Translating dementia research into practice
Socio-
environmental Interpersonal
Biological Psychological
Translating dementia research into practice
BPSD outcome
from family CG
interventions in
community
3279 dyads
17 studies ES = 0.34
(95% CI 0.20 – 0.48, p<0.01)
CG reactions to
BPSD from CG
interventions for
BPSD
12 studies ES = 0.15
(95%CI 0.04 – 0.26, p=0.006)
Chenoweth
Translatinget al. Lancet
dementia Neurol;
research into practice 2009
Kitwood PCC
• Care systems
– support needs for love, attachment,
comfort, identity, occupation &
inclusion
– enhance global sense of self-worth &
feeling valued
– reduce BPSD
Translating dementia research into practice
Person-Centred Care
• Individualised care planning
– not only clinical history
– social & functional history, needs and
preferences
– care staff sensitised to person’s
unique personality & preferences
– interpret responses & behaviours
– adjust care practices accordingly
Translating dementia research into practice
After At Follow-up
intervention
PCC $ 8.01 $ 6.43
DCM $ 48.95 $ 46.89
Socio-
environmental Interpersonal
Biological Psychological
Translating dementia research into practice
Am J Psychiatry 2005;
162:1996-2021
Translating dementia research into practice
Calming music and/or hand massage
10 min
CMAI
ratings
Humour
SMILE Study
Elder clowns & LaughterBosses reduce agitation
Clinically significant?
OR
Conclusions
• Humour therapy sustained +ve effect in
reducing agitation (2.64 pnts over 26 wks)
• Management and Laughterboss (staff)
engagement important components
• After adjustment, +ve effects on
depression and QoL
• No adverse effects
• Cannot determine what elements work
• Humour Therapy is popular
Barriers
• Time
• Money
• Staff
• Attitudes
Key elements • Training
• Engagement
• Understanding
• Time
Socio-
environmental Interpersonal
Biological Psychological
Translating dementia research into practice
baseline
Emergence post 44 *
52
baseline
Improvement post 76 *
baseline 67
0 20 40 60 80 100 [%]
* p < 0.05 versus placebo
1
Gauthier et al (2005), IJGP, 20, 459-464
DEMQOL
HTA-SADD Trial 95
90
85
14
80
CSDD Score 75
12
CSDD Score
0 13 39
10
DEMQOL-Proxy
Score
8
100
95
6
0 13 39 90
Visit
Placebo Sertraline 85
Mirtazapine 95% CI
95% CI 95% CI 80
0 13 39
Citalopram vs Perphenazine
• 17 day RCT, 85 Ss with dementia
• 31 citalopram, 33 perphenazine, 21 placebo
• Outcome: Neurobehavioral Rating Scale
• Citalopram and perphenazine improved agitation/
aggression, psychosis & lability/tension
• Citalopram also improved cognition & retardation
Citalopram vs Risperidone
• 12 wk RCT of 103 Ss with dementia:
– 53 citalopram, 50 risperidone
• Significant decrease in agitation score
(Neurobehavioral Rating Scale) for
citalopram, but not risperidone
• Citalopram & risperidone both decreased
psychosis scores (suspiciousness,
hallucinations and delusions)
Agitation/aggression in NH residents
with dementia (CMAI aggression)
baseline week 4 week 8 week 12 end point
0
-1
Reduced agitation/aggression
-2
Placebo
-3 Mean dose
-4 1.06 mls
-5
-6
-7
-8 * pRisperidone
< 0.05
*
-9 Mean dose
0.95mg
-10 *
CMAI, Cohen Mansfield*Agitation Inventory
1
Streim et al (2008): Am J Geriatr Psychiatry, 16, 537-550
CATIE-AD
• 42 sites, 421 pts randomised to olanzapine
(5.5mg), quetiapine (56.5mg), risperidone
(1mg) or placebo
• Time to discontinuation
– Overall =
– Because of lack of efficacy: OLZ & RIS <
QTP & PBO
– Because of AEs: OLZ 24%, RIS 18%, QTP
16%, PBO 5%
• CGIC – ns
Schneider L et al NEJM 2006
Meta-analysis of RCTs
• Meta-analysis from 13 studies 1:
– Mean ES in Rx group = 0.45
– Mean ES in placebo gp = 0.32
• In summary
– Effect sizes of atypical
antipsychotics for behavioural
problems are medium and not
statistically better than placebo
Antipsychotics associated
with increased risk of
cerebrovascular AEs & deaths
www.ipa-online.org/pdfs/IPA_BPSD_Module_6.pdf
Translating dementia research into practice
Psychotropic medication for
patients with dementia in NHs1
• 633 NH residents with dementia followed 1 yr
• Overall persistence of BPSD (NPI): 79%
• Individual Sx (depression, delusion, agitation/
aggression) resolved at high rate (47% - 58%)
• Persistent psychotropic drug use very common
• No difference in users vs non-users regarding
course of BPSD
1
Selbæk et al (2008): Am J Geriatr Psychiatry, 16:7, 528-536
Continuing vs stopping
neuroleptics in dementia patients?
• 12 months RCT
• Continuous use of neuroleptics vs placebo
• For most AD pts withdrawal had no overall
detrimental effect
• Continuers – worse verbal fluency (p<.002)
• Subgroup of pts with more severe
symptoms (NPI ≥ 15) might benefit from
continuous Rx Ballard et al 2008 PLOS Medicine, 5:587-599
Translating dementia research into practice
Anticonvulsants for BPSD treatment1
• Literature review of 7 RCT (2 carbamazepine &
5 valproate
• Results (treatment vs placebo):
– 1 study: sig. BPSD
– 5 studies: no sig. difference
– 1 study: sig. BPSD
– AEs more frequent in treatment groups
• Might be beneficial for some pts
• Not recommended for routine use
1
Kanovalov et al (2008). Int Psychogeriatr, 20:2
Anticonvulsants at a glance
• No or limited benifit for divalproex sodium1,2
and sodium valproate3
• Modest evidence for carbamazepine4,5 but
further trials needed
1
Porsteinsson et al (2001). Am J Ger Psychiatry, 9:58-66; 2Tariot et al (2005). J
Geriatr Psychiatry, 13:942–949; 3Herrmann et al (2007). Dement Geriatr Cog
Disord, 23:116-119 4Tariot et al (1998). Am J Psychiatry, 155:54-61; 5Olin et al
(2001). Am J Geriatr Psychiatry, 9:400–4051;
Benzodiazepines
• PBO RCTs: BDZ decrease agitated
behaviours during short-term use
• Short-acting BDZs eg oxazepam or lorazepam
that do not accumulate best
– most effective if used for short periods at
low doses (e.g., lorazepam 0.5–2.0 mg/day)
• AEs = Sedation, falls, confusion, amnesia
(Chesrow et al., 1965; Kirven and Montero, 1973;
Covington, 1975; Coccaro et al., 1990)
Translating dementia research into practice
Analgesics
• Cluster RCT, 60 NHs, 352 residents, 8 + 4wks
• Mod-severe dementia, CMAI > 39
• Stepped analgesia vs usual care
• CMAI ↓17% (9.6 vs 3.4, p<.001)
• CMAI score ↑ in four weeks after stop analgesia
• NPI, Pain scores significantly ↓
Others
• Buspirone • Hypnotics
• Trazadone • Lithium
• Adrenergic • Canabinoids
blockers • Oestrogens
• Selegiline • Androgen blockers
• Opioids
• Melatonin
Bannerjee 2009. The use of antipsychotic medication for people with dementia.
Legal consent for psychotropics
• Depending on jurisdiction a Person
Responsible must give consent (?in writing)
• Survey of 3 NHs; 77 residents without capacity
to give informed consent; on psychotropics1
• Only 6.5% written consent
• + 6.5% partial or attempted consent
1
Rendina N et al, 2009
Conclusions I
• Prevent BPSD, e.g.
– PCC, environment, titrate stimulation
– CG and staff training
• Determine cause
• Correct reversible factors
• Start with psychological & environmental
intervention(s)
– except if urgent or sometimes concurrent
Conclusions III
• Pharmacotherapy
– modestly effective for BPSD
– Prescribe judiciously
– Need medico-legal consent
– Start low and go slow
– Review regularly, at least 3 monthly
• h.brodaty@unsw.edu.au