Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
1
CSIRO Exploration and Mining, Floreat Park, WA, Australia
2
Sumitomo Metal Mining Ltd, Shimbashi, Tokyo, Japan
3
ERSDAC, Kachidoki, Tokyo, Japan
4
The Aerospace Corporation, El Segundo, CA, USA
5
CSIRO Exploration and Mining, North Ryde, NSW, Australia
March 2000
SUMMARY ............................................................................................................ 1
1. INTRODUCTION ..............................................................................................5
1.1 Hyperspectral Thermal Infrared Mineral Mapping .................................................. 5
1.2 Skarns .................................................................................................................... 7
2. OBJECTIVES...................................................................................................8
5. INSTRUMENTATION.....................................................................................22
5.1 SEBASS ............................................................................................................... 22
5.2 AVIRIS.................................................................................................................. 24
5.3 MicroFTIR............................................................................................................. 24
5.4 PIMA-II ................................................................................................................. 24
5.5 X-Ray Diffraction .................................................................................................. 24
5.6 Electron MicroProbe............................................................................................. 24
13. CONCLUSIONS............................................................................................. 63
16. REFERENCES............................................................................................... 65
The potential of hyperspectral thermal infrared remote sensing for enhanced mineral
exploration was evaluated using airborne SEBASS (Spatially Enhanced Broadband Array
Spectrograph System) image data (128 pixel wide swath @ ~3 m pixel resolution)
collected from skarn-type and porphyry-type alteration in the Yerington district, Nevada.
The 124 SEBASS bands between 7.6 and 13.4 µm enabled the spectral identification of a
range of minerals, including: quartz; grandite garnet (andradite to grossular);
clinopyroxene (diopside-hedenbergite); plagioclase feldspar (albite-oligoclase to
oligoclase-andesine); carbonate (calcite and dolomite); epidote; muscovite; kaolinite and
gypsum. Of these minerals, grandite was critical in defining the extent of the exoskarn
alteration while the plagioclase chemistry was critical in defining the calcic versus sodic
alteration associated with the meteoric versus magmatic metasomatism within the
porphyry intrusives.
The grandite Fe-Al solid-solution chemistry was found to be useful in targeting Cu-skarn
mineralisation. This parameter was measured with the SEBASS data using the
wavelength of a diagnostic grandite feature near 11.5 µm that was found in the laboratory
to be correlated with XRD and electron microprobe analyses. The SEBASS image of this
parameter showed that all the intersected Cu skarn-related mines are associated with near
pure andradite (see the figure below).
In addition, the Fe content of grandite associated with the early skarnoid phase increases
south-west from the contact with the granodiorite (main source of metasomatic fluids).
Clinopyroxene was also mapped though the associated laboratory TIR spectra. XRD
results do not conclusively identify diopside from hedenbergite, which also has a Fe-Mg
The preliminary SEBASS study of the porphyry alteration in the Yerington granodiorite
mapped a zonation pattern comprising: epidote-quartz at the contact with the adjacent
limestones; then andesine-oligoclase feldspar; and finally albite-oligoclase feldspar
consistent with the published mapping, which found a progressive Ca enrichment
(relative decrease in Na) towards the contact with the carbonate wall rocks (epidote and
quartz is possibly indicative of oxidising conditions). The other abundant minerals in the
altered granodiorite, including biotite and hornblende (largely muscovite-poor), were not
recognised in the SEBASS data.
The SEBASS data were found to be of very high radiometric, geometric and spectral
quality, though strong column-dependent instrument effects are evident in the data,
especially for the shorter wavelength bands. The restriction of conducting blackbody
calibration of the SEBASS data at the beginning and end of each flight-line did not result
in any apparent scene artefacts. The scene-dependent, “InScene Atmospheric Correction”
(ISAC) algorithm proved effective in correcting for both additive (up-welling radiance)
and multiplicative (transmission) atmospheric effects. Minor problems with this ISAC
method include no correction for reflected down-welling radiance, which results in less
surface spectral emissivity contrast, and uncorrected atmospheric-line
absorption/emission lines for “contrasting temperature” pixels. No major problems were
apparent for the lack of a path-length correction or for assuming a homogenous
atmosphere.
First, there have been engineering constraints on remote TIR system design. For
example, there is a requirement for frequent hot and cold blackbody calibration of the
sensor, as fluctuations in instrument temperature will yield different responses for the
same ground target. Another issue relates to the small amounts of electromagnetic
radiation (EMR) available for terrestrial remote sensing at these wavelengths compared
with the VNIR-SWIR. To obtain sufficiently small pixels with sufficiently large signal to
noise ratio (SNR), most multispectral TIR systems based on liquid-nitrogen cooled
mercury cadmium telluride (MCT) detectors have been designed with only a few spectral
bands (2-10) with bandwidths generally greater than 0.5 µm.
Using this low spectral-resolution design, a number of TIR remote sensing systems have
been active in the scientific community for a number of years, including: the 6-channel
TIMS (Kahle et al., 1980; Palluconi and Meeks, 1985); the 6 TIR channel Geoscan Mk
(Agar 1994); the 6 channel DIAS (Chang et al., 1993); and the 10 channel MIVIS
(Bianchi and Marino, 1994). Recently, the satellite-borne ASTER system with 5
calibrated TIR bands was successfully launched and will provide global coverage of
multispectral TIR at 90 m pixel resolution (ASTER, 2000). However, these low spectral
resolution TIR systems do not allow mapping of specific minerals but they do provide
measurement of the bulk SiO2 content (Lang et al., 1987; Sabine et al., 1994; Crowley
and Hook, 1996, Ninomiya, 1995). These systems can be used to discriminate and
separate a wide range of materials but lack the power of detailed spectral identification.
There has been a focus within geological remote sensing to map potassic-propylitic
alteration, typical of porphyry-epithermal alteration (Marsh and McKeon 1983, Fraser et
al. 1986, Feldman and Taranik 1988, Kruse 1988, Rowan et al. 1991, Zaluski et al. 1994)
and volcanic massive sulphide alteration (Cudahy et al., 1999) where OH-bearing
minerals like white mica and chlorite are important and the VNIR-SWIR is optimum for
mapping this information. However, the TIR wavelength region also merits attention for
mineral exploration applications. For example, the TIR can in theory be used to identify
different types of silica, including high temperature/pressure crystobalite and tridymite as
well as low temperature quartz, silica glass (Conel 1969) and possibly different forms of
“hydrated” silica. This is important in separating silica that formed through hydrothermal
alteration from silica formed through weathering processes (Gunnesch et al. 1994).
Garnet is another TIR-active mineral group that is potentially important in skarn systems
(Einaudi and Burt, 1982), high-grade metamorphic SEDEX (Spry and Wonder, 1989) and
diamondiferous kimberlites (Deer et al. 1976). For example, Mn-rich (Ca-poor) garnets
appear to be associated with high metamorphic grade Broken Hill-style base metal
deposits (Spy and Wonder, 1989). In contrast, Ca-rich garnets appear to be associated
with skarn base metal mineralisation in Nevada (Harris and Einaudi 1982). Similarly,
pyroxene composition can be used as an indicator for skarn deposits including the type of
metallogeny (Einaudi and Burt 1982, Nakano et al. 1994). Feldspar mineralogy is
important in mapping potential granite host rocks or the granite source of mineralising
fluids (Ishihara 1981). For example, the Proterozoic Cu-Au-U mineralisation at Olympic
Dam (Haynes et al. 1995), rare earth mineralisation (Pollard 1995) and Archaean lode Au
deposits (Wyman and Kerrich 1988) are all associated with specific types of granites.
There is also the potential for the TIR remote sensing to provide improved mapping of
“difficult” minerals like carbonates, which are often difficult in the SWIR.
Answers to some of these issues were provided with the development of an active
hyperspectral TIR remote profiling system called MIRACO2LAS (Whitbourn et al.
1987). This system has approximately 100 channels between 9.2 and 11.2 µm and was
used to map a range of silicates, including quartz, feldspars (both microcline and Na-
plagioclase), garnets (almandine and spessartine), talc, amphiboles (actinolite and
tremolite), kaolinite, carbonates (dolomite and magnesite) and dry and green vegetation
(Cudahy et al. 1999). The identification of different feldspar minerals allowed mapping
In September 1999, SEBASS data were collected from a number of geology test sites in
Nevada as part of a group shoot campaign involving Aerospace, Mackay School of
Mines, Stanford University, Perry and Associates, Sumitomo Metal Mining Company
Limited and CSIRO Exploration and Mining. The test sites included epithermal
alteration in felsic host rocks at Virginia City and Steamboat Springs (near Reno) and
porphyry and skarn alteration near Yerington. This study focuses on the SEBASS data
collected from the skarn alteration and to a lesser extent the porphyry alteration at
Yerington.
1.2 Skarns
Einaudi and Burt (1982) described skarns as being of two types, namely:
(ii) Endoskarn: These represent the replacement of “source” intrusive rocks that are
genetically related to the skarn-forming fluids. This reflects a progressive
addition of calcium with zoning towards the limestone involving biotite to
amphibole to pyroxene to garnet. Any K-feldspar disappears while biotite and
plagioclase remains throughout, except where it is replaced by garnet. In
2. OBJECTIVES
The main aim of this study is to generate a “benchmark” geological case history that
evaluates and demonstrates the potential of hyperspectral TIR remote sensing for
improved mineral mapping, especially for exploration of Cu-skarn mineralisation. The
specific objectives of this study include:
3. To assess whether TIR remote mapping of critical alteration mineralogy can be used
to target skarn base metal mineralisation;
4. To assess the complimentary role of VNIR, SWIR and TIR wavelengths for mapping
skarn alteration mineralogy;
5. To assess the instrument performance of the SEBASS system (including hot and cold
blackbody calibration);
7. To establish if other preprocessing steps are required before proceeding to the final
step of mineral information extraction from the hyperspectral TIR data (for example,
temperature-emissivity separation).
4330000 4330000
4328000 4328000
4326000 4326000
McA
rthu
r
McArthur # 4324000
4324000
4
4322000 4322000
4320000 4320000
ll
s Hi
u gl a
4318000 Do 4318000
Green
##
Ye Yerington
wood
4314000
Douglas Hill 4314000
# Lu
Casting #
#
dw 1B
ig
1A McConnell
#
#
4312000 4312000
4310000 4310000
4308000 4308000
N
4306000 4306000
300000 302000 304000 306000 308000 310000 312000 314000
# Mine
SEBASS line rhyolitic tuff
alluvium (gravels) quartz monzonite (nonporphyritic)
alluvium (sand/silt) granitie porphyry
basalt quartz monzonite (porphyritic)
alluvium metasedimentary rocks
andesite metavolcanic rocks
Figure 1: Published 1:100 000 scale geology map (NBMG, 1996) showing the
location of the SEBASS lines and the area covered by this study for the high
altitude AVIRIS scene (blue box).
The sparse vegetation cover, high relief and excellent exposure of the area are shown in
Figures 2, 3 and 4. Views of the Casting Copper, Douglas Hill, McConnell, Yerington,
Macarthur and Ludwig mines are provided in Figures 2 and 4. Close-up photos of
selected exposed rock types are presented in Figures 3 and 4.
3.2 Geology
The oldest rocks in the Yerington area are metamorphosed volcanic and sedimentary
rocks of Triassic and early Jurassic age (Proffett, 1977). These include quartz monzonites
and granite porphyry as well as the metasediments and metavolcanics in Figure 1. A
major unconformity developed in the Cretaceous and early Tertiary that was followed by
deposition of basal conglomerates and sedimentary breccias as well as Oligocene silicic
ignimbrites (rhyolitic tuff in Figure 1) and late Oligocene-Miocene volcanic extrusives
and intrusives (andesite in Figure 1) with 8-11 Mya basalts (basalts in Figure 1) and
Quaternary deposits (alluvium in Figure 1) (long sentence).
The detailed geology (Figure 5) shows that the Triassic-Jurassic metasediments and
metavolcanics (1800 m thick) include basal arkose sandstones, andesite/dacite tuff and
massive, ridge-forming limestones, which are up to 300 m thick in the Ludwig area
(Harris and Einaudi 1982). These fine to medium grained limestones are white to grey in
colour with small quantities of quartz and pyrite (light blue in Figure 5). This unit is
locally dolomitised where it weathers to a distinctive buff colour. The dolomite occurs
both as stratiform layers and as crosscutting veins, suggesting it is the product of
hydrothermal alteration. The limestone in the Ludwig area grades upwards into thinly
interbedded black silty limestone (100-130 m thick) and contains quartz, calcite,
Figure 5: Published 1:24,000 scale geology with the locations of the two SEBASS
lines examined in detail in this study (after Proffett and Dilles, 1984).
There are at least four generations of quartz monzonite dykes exposed in the Yerington
open pit porphyry Cu mine (red in Figure 5), two of which are closely related to the Cu
mineralisation and two which are younger (Harris and Einaudi 1982).
These rocks are overlain by Tertiary Volcanics, including quartz-latite and rhyolitic ash
flows and tuffs, and finally by Quaternary alluvium-colluvium (Figure 5).
3.3 Structure
The structural history of the area following Triassic-Jurassic sedimentation and volcanism
involved early faulting and folding associated with the intrusion of the batholiths. This
culminated in the tilting of the entire packet of rocks by 30° westward prior to the
Oligocene. Since the Miocene, “Basin and Range” faulting further rotated the rocks by
another 50° westward such that the originally horizontal strata are now nearly vertical
with the current exposure representing a north-south section through the entire sequence,
including the Jurassic contact metamorphism and skarn formation.
The next two periods of alteration involved metasomatic skarn development, both in the
metasediments/metavolcanics (exoskarn) and in the granodiorite (endoskarn). The depth
of formation of the skarn is estimated to be 2 km (Einaudi, 1977). The early exoskarn
stage (skarnoid) involved the development of fine-grained garnet and subordinate
pyroxene (0-30% - generally diopside, at least in the limestones). In general, the
garnet/pyroxene ratio is 4:1 or greater. In the Ludwig area, the limestone is altered to
within 1 km from the contact with the northern batholith. Skarnoid is preferentially
formed along the limestone-andesite contact with its width decreasing southward (Harris
Figure 6: Published geology and alteration maps of the detailed study area
shown in Figure 5 (after Harris and Einaudi, 1982)
The late metasomatic skarn stage involved the development of extensive areas of
pyroxene and coarse grained garnet skarn accompanied by Cu-Fe sulphides, especially in
the limestone (Harris and Einaudi, 1982). Two types formed:
(ii) Fe-rich skarn with high garnet/pyroxene ratios (typically 4/1 to 10/0). The
garnets are isotropic and unzoned and are extremely pure andradite (Ad97-Ad100).
The margins of the Mg skarn appears be associated with veins of tremolite and erratic
serpentine, which finger out into the dolomitised marble. The presence of associated
periclase and monticellite suggest temperatures of greater than 600° C (Harris and
Einaudi, 1982).
During this later skarn stage, skarnoid in the silty limestones was converted to idocrase
while andesite tuff, not previously altered, was replaced by epidote, though skarnoid in
andesite tuff was unaffected. There were also two generations of amphibole: (1) early
tremolite and then (2) later actinolite, which was coeval with the Cu mineralisation
(Einaudi 1977). Later phase coarse green salite (up to 10 cm) is restricted to garnet
zones near Mg skarn.
In the Northern Batholith plutonic rocks albite and quartz alteration initially developed,
followed by extensive (hundreds of metres) garnet-pyroxene endoskarn. Mineralogy is
highly varied but was dominated by pale-brown garnet. The timing of this endoskarn is
unclear but was probably during the skarnoid stage (Harris and Einaudi, 1982).
Alteration in the Southern batholith was less pronounced, and limited alteration occurs
within 100 metres from the contact with the sediments/volcanics. The alteration included
formation of pyroxene, chlorite and muscovite (Harris and Einaudi, 1982).
The type of main stage alteration depended on depth of formation. The propylitic
alteration developed albite + epidote + actinolite + chlorite at depths above 4 km.
Stratigraphically below this unit (3.5 to greater than 6 km), the sodic-calcic main stage
alteration resulted in oligoclase + actinolite + sphene, but no sulphides, through the
addition of Na and leaching of K, Fe and Cu). The “crosscutting” potassic main stage
alteration (2.5-4 km depth) is characterised by replacement of hornblende by biotite and
K-feldspar and is associated with Cu mineralisation.
Late stage alteration superimposed over all dykes swarms involved early sodic (albite)
and chlorite and later sericite overprints.
The 6 km vertical reconstruction of the wall rock alteration and hydrothermal fluid flow
paths of the Ann-Mason porphyry copper deposit involves four fluids of different origins
reacting with rocks through alkali exchange and H+ metasomatism (Dilles and Einaudi,
1992), namely:
(iii) High salinity (32-62%) potassic main stage fluids at 700 to <400°C; and
The saline fluids involved in sodic-calcic alteration, were non-magmatic and flowed from
the wall rock into the batholith. These fluids (?) mixed with cooling, saline magmatic
fluids within convective cells coincident with the dyke swarms. Late meteoric fluids
possibly exchanged Na for K and leached Cu.
4.1 Introduction
Laboratory TIR bidirectional reflectance spectra of selected skarn related pure minerals
show diagnostic signatures related to the shapes and wavelengths of their respective
reststrahlen bands (Figure 7). More is described on the spectral behaviour of garnets,
pyroxenes and feldspars below.
Fe-Ca grosssularite
2.5 pyrope
Al-Ca
2
Mn-Al
1.5
1 Mg-Al
0.5
0
7.5 8.5 9.5 10.5 11.5 12.5 13.5
wavelength (µm)
These garnet spectral shifts shown in Figure 8 are related to the garnet solid solution
chemistry. This spectral shift is consistent with a similar pattern in the XRD 2-d spacings
(Table 1). That is, the garnet 420 hkl reflection shows a progressive shift related to the
increase in the combined ionic radii of the cations ((Al + Mg) to (Al + Fe) to (Al +Mn) to
(Ca + Al) to (Ca + Cr) to (Ca + Fe)).
4.3 Pyroxenes
Figure 9 presents laboratory bidrectional reflectance spectra of the three clinopyroxenes,
diopside (CaMg[SiO3]2), hendenbergite (CaFe[SiO3]2) and augite
(Ca[Mg,Fe][SiO3]2{[Al,Fe]2O3}x). There is complete solid solution between the Ca-rich
pyroxenes, diopside (Mg-rich) and hedenbergite (Fe-rich) and even with the less Ca-rich
augite/ferroaugite. The TIR spectra (Figure 9) show diagnostic clinopyroxene TIR
spectral features (emissivity lows) at 8.8, 10.4 and 10.9 µm. However, unlike the garnets
(Section 4.2), there is little evidence from these library spectra that there exist variations
in spectral behaviour related to changes in solid solution chemistry.
0.98
0.96
emissivity
0.94
0.92
Diopside
0.9 Hedenbergite
Augite
0.88
7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
wavelength (µm)
4.4 Feldspars
The feldspars are a ubiquitous mineral group in the Earth's crust. There are 11 major
types of feldspar minerals each showing different structure and chemistry, the precise
nature of which is related to the environment of their crystallisation. As a consequence,
Most feldspars can be considered as part of a ternary system (Figure 10) with the three
apices of this diagram defined by Na2AlSi3O8, K2AlSi3O8, and CaAlSi3O8 1. Members of
the series between the Na and K endmembers are considered alkali feldspars (microcline,
orthoclase, sanidine, anorthoclase) and those between Na and Ca are considered
plagioclase feldspars (with increasing Ca the series comprises albite, oligoclase, andesine,
labradorite, bytownite and anorthite). The alkali feldspars can contain up to 10% Ca in
solid solution whereas the plagioclase can contain up to 10% K.
The mineralogy of the K endmember depends on the temperature of formation and hence
structure of the feldspar. The alkali feldspar that forms at the highest temperatures of
crystallisation is sanidine, which is monoclinic. Orthoclase, which is also monoclinic,
forms at moderate temperatures, while microcline, which is triclinic, forms at the lowest
temperatures. Adularia is a low temperature, K-rich (Or90Ab9An1) feldspar with variable
structure and confined to Alpine vein-type paragenesis (Deer et al., 1977). A more
complex relationship with temperature is found for the plagioclase feldspars with both
monoclinic and triclinic forms possible for all solid solution chemistries.
Figure 10: K-Na-Ca ternary diagram of the feldspar mineral group (after Deer et
al. 1977).
Various workers have measured the TIR spectral properties of feldspar minerals (Lyon
and Burns, 1963; Aronson et al., 1967; Farmer, 1974; Vincent et al., 1975; Nash and
Salisbury, 1991; Thomson and Salisbury, 1993). They have shown that the alkali-
feldspar minerals and plagioclase felspars have diagnostic spectral behaviour, especially
in the 8 to 11 µm wavelength region where there exist changes in the number and position
of the reststrahlen features.
1
Note also that Ba, NH3 and other ions and ion groups can substitute into the structure of the feldspars.
0.7
9.62 microcline (K)
8.5
0.6
9.98 orthoclase (K/Na)
9.2
0.5
sanidine (K/Na)
reflectance
0.2
9.48
0.1
0
7.5 8.5 9.5 10.5 11.5 12.5 13.5
wavelength (µm)
5. INSTRUMENTATION
5.1 SEBASS
SEBASS is a push-broom imaging hyperspectral TIR “dispersive” system that comprises
two helium cooled 128 by 128 detector element arrays (Figure 10) operating within the
2.9 to 5.2 and 7.5 to 13.6 µm wavelength regions (Hackwell et al, 1994). That is, there
are 128 contiguous spectral bands for 128 pixels for each detector array. The angular
resolution of the fore-optics is 1.1 mrad per pixel with a total field of view of 141 mrad
(approximately 8.1°). This yields pixels of approximately 2.5 metres over a 320 metres
swath at an operational flying height of approximately 2000 metres.
The SEBASS system (Figure 11) includes hot and cold blackbodies, which are swung in
front of the fore-optics at the beginning and end of each flight line. Thermal calibration
of the system assumes linear drift between these blackbody measurements.
5.3 MicroFTIR
The emissivity of field samples was measured using a portable FTIR spectroradiometer
designed and built by Designs and Prototypes (Hook and Kahle, 1996; Korb et al., 1996).
This instrument measures emissivity in the 3-5 and 8-14 µm wavelength region at
approximately 6 wavenumber resolution. The area sensed is approximately 50 mm
diameter. A correction for sky down-welling irradiance is implemented using a gold, zinc
or aluminium reference plate.
5.4 PIMA-II
The 1300-2500 nm directional-hemispherical reflectance of samples was measured using
an Integrated Spectronics field portable PIMA-II spectrometer. The spectral resolution is
approximately 8 nm in the 2.2 µm region. This instrument has its own internal light
source and internal gold reference and plastic wavelength calibration standards. Samples
are measured "in contact" with a transparent sapphire window, the area of which is
approximately 10 mm diameter.
6. DATA ACQUISITION
6.1 Airborne
Six lines of SEBASS imagery were acquired from the Yerington district (Figure 1) in
both August 1999 and September 1999. The August campaign was affected by moist,
cloudy conditions with possible wet ground. Inspection of these data revealed problems
The data reduction of the SEBASS data involved correction for instrument and
atmospheric effects using software provided by Aerospace Corporation. No details are
provided here (Aerospace response?, is it possible to express it differently assuming Jack
Hackwells later supply of algorithms?) on the instrument correction other than to confirm
that it involved hot and cold blackbody calibration of the data assuming linear drift in
detector responsivity between the beginning and end of each run when such
measurements were taken.
7.1.1 Introduction
Atmospheric correction of remotely sensed TIR data should account for:
1. Path length
2. Gas concentrations;
3. Atmospheric layering;
4. Temperature; and
5. Cloud type and position.
(i) Atmospheric-line features, which are sharp and related to water vapour and
carbon dioxide, ozone, methane and oxygen (Figure 14); and
(ii) Atmospheric-continuum absorption, which is largely related to water vapour.
Water vapour and the other gases also emit TIR radiation they absorb. The first type of
sky emission is a component of the up-welling radiance, which for a homogenous “warm”
atmospheric profile, results in a Planck “blackbody” radiation function as well as
superimposed atmospheric-line features, the intensity of which depends on the air
temperature and concentration of the gases. The second is down-welling radiance which
is also comprises blackbody behaviour as well as gas emission features, with the
combined effect being reflected from the Earth’s surface, the magnitude of which
Figure 15: Spectral plot showing the effects of sky down-welling radiance on
surface emissivity measurements. These passive TIR measurements were taken
under clear sky conditions (source ie instrument?, reference?).
Local sources of “high” radiant temperature, such as low cumulus cloud, will contribute
to the up-welling, if below the aircraft, and also contribute to down-welling radiance,
especially for those pixels near to these sources. Sun angle and cloud shadows do not
contribute directly to the “down-welling” radiance, but they affect the surface kinetic
temperature and hence the surface radiance. Thus, the optimum conditions for TIR data
acquisition are clear, cold skies and a warm, dry surface where there exists a large
thermal contrast between the sky and surface radiant temperatures.
ISAC is a scene-based correction that uses the SEBASS data itself to derive the required
input parameters for the estimation of atmospheric effects, namely: an additive effect
related to primarily to up-welling radiance (assuming a homogeneous atmospheric
profile); and a multiplicative effect related to attenuation by absorption of gases (related
to path length and gas concentrations). This can be expressed by:
Lobs ( λ , j ) = τ ( λ ) B ( λ , T j ) + Lu ( λ ) 1.
where
Lobs is the observed radiance at sensor;
λ is wavelength;
j is those pixels in the scene with blackbody behaviour;
τ is the atmospheric transmission;
Lu is the up-welling sky radiance;
B is the surface Blackbody radiance; and
Tj is the surface kinetic temperature.
From Equation 1, a scattergram of Lobs (j) versus B (Tj) for a given wavelength, λ, should
yield a linear expression where the slope of the line represents the atmospheric
transmission and the offset the up-welling radiance (Figure 16).
To solve for τ and Lu for real TIR passive data, where pixels are not necessarily
blackbodies, the following steps were developed (Johnson, 1998):
1. Calculate and record from each pixel’s radiance spectrum, its maximum brightness
temperature T’i and its wavelength λI where Ti ' = max{TB [ Lobs ( λ , i )]}λ ;
2. Sort the maximum brightness temperatures by wavelength and count the number of
brightness temperatures (“hits”) that accumulate in each wavelength bin;
3. Find the wavelength with the most number of “hits” (maximum hit method) –
reference wavelength (λr);
4. Subset those pixels with a maximum brightness at λr and give them an index “j”;
6. Calculate the Planck Radiation Function, B(λn, T’i), assuming no atmospheric effects
(no gains or offset values) at the reference wavelength for all j;
7. Plot the points defined by the coordinates Lobs(λn, j) and B(λn, T’i). Both the
“unscaled” atmospheric gains and offsets can be calculated from this data cloud
(Figure 17). A straight line resting above of the data cloud is fitted. Departure below
this line is a function of surface emissivity;
8. An additional transformation can be applied to convert the unscaled gains and offsets
to units that are less scene-dependent (closer to actual transmissivity and sky
emission) using scene derived estimates of water line absorption features (Young,
1998).
The ISAC atmospheric correction was applied to all the SEBASS lines to yield apparent
surface radiance. The result of this correction is shown in Figure 18, which compares the
radiance at sensor and ISAC corrected surface radiance spectra of a given pixel. This
shows that most, if not all, of the atmospheric-line absorptions have been removed
1300
1200
1100
radiance units
1000
900
800 12.54 µm
700
600
radiance at sensor
radiance at surface
500
7.5 8.5 9.5 10.5 11.5 12.5 13.5
wavelength (µm)
Figure 18: Comparison of the radiance at sensor versus the radiance at surface
spectra for a selected SEBASS image pixel selected from the Ludwig line.
1.5
vakue
0.5
atmopsheric gains
atmospheric offsets
0
7.5 8.5 9.5 10.5 11.5 12.5 13.5
wavelength (µm)
Figure 19: Scattergram showing the gains and offsets calculated using ISAC for
the Ludwig SEBASS line.
0.8
atmospheric offsets
y = 1.0018x-0.6887
0.6
R2 = 0.9918
0.4
0.2
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
atmospheric gains
Figure 20: Scattergram showing the correlation between the ISAC generated
gains and offsets for the Ludwig line.
Figure 21: Field photograph of the Walker River at Mason where the SEBASS
line passed.
The mean SEBASS surface radiance spectrum collected from the Walker River (Figure
21) is most closely modelled using a Planck Radiation blackbody curve for a surface
kinetic temperature of 293K (Figure 22). Overall, the shape and absolute units of the
SEBASS surface radiance data are in close agreement with the modelled response.
1000
800
wavelength (µm)
Figure 22 also shows that, in detail, there is spectral mismatch after normalising the
measured response with the modelled response (Figure 23). The closeness of the fit
between the SEBASS spectrum and the calculated blackbody spectrum becomes
increasingly poorer at shorter (<10 µm) and longer (>11.5 µm) wavelengths. It is
unlikely that this is related to non-blackbody behaviour of the river. Instead, this
departure is probably related, at least in part, to uncorrected water vapour continuum-
absorption (Figure 14), which is not corrected in the ISAC method (Figure 18).
1.01
0.99
0.98
apparent emissivity
0.97
0.96
0.95
0.94
0.93
0.92
7.5 8.5 9.5 10.5 11.5 12.5 13.5
wavelength (µm)
Figure 23: Apparent emissivity spectrum for water derived using the calculated
Planck blackbody radiation curve for 293 K and the atmospherically corrected
SEBASS spectrum of river water (Figure 21).
It was considered important to examine the effect of not correcting for atmospheric path-
length, which is not corrected using ISAC, especially as there is considerable topographic
relief (greater than 500 m) in the study area.
A section of the Douglas Hill line covering a limestone ridge with 200 m of local vertical
relief was selected for this purpose (Figure 24a). Seven training sites of 16 pixels each
and spaced from the top of the limestone ridge and down to the colluvial apron below
were collected. The mean spectra of each of these training sites (Figure 24b) shows that
all the atmospheric gas absorption-line absorptions have the same apparent intensities
across the full spectral interval from 7.8 to 13.4 µm. Only the narrow carbonate
emissivity low near 11.3 µm shows departure between the training sites, though this is
related to the surface composition (carbonate abundance) and not to the atmosphere.
Subsequent ISAC correction of this flight-line confirmed that all atmospheric-line
absorption were effectively removed for the range of altitudes considered.
Figure 24: Composite figure showing the effectivess of the ISAC atmospheric
correction is an area of 200 m local relief). Stacking the training site mean spectra
collected from the side of ridge shows no apparent differences in the relative in the
depths of the atmospheric line-absorptions. That is, local relief variations of 200 m
produce no spurious features in the atmospherically corrected data.
At VNIR-SWIR wavelengths, it is now routine to calculate and correct for water vapour
on a per-pixel basis as the atmosphere is typically heterogeneous. This is especially
important as water vapour has a major effect on a given pixel’s spectral behaviour. The
same appears to be true for the TIR (Figure 14). As a consequence, programs like
ATREM (http://www.cires.colorado.edu/cses/atrem.html) have been developed for
VNIR-SWIR data to calculate the water vapour on a per-pixel basis using the measured
depth/s of a number of water vapour line-absorptions.
Furthermore, Figure 25b shows that, apart from the enhanced instrument column-striping
noise, there is no apparent spatial variation along the flight-line that can be attributed to
heterogeneous water vapour. This is an important result and suggests there is not a
significant problem in assuming a homogeneous atmosphere with the ISAC correction, at
least for these SEBASS data under these atmospheric conditions.
Figure 26: Composite figure examining the validity of the assumption that the
atmospheric profile is constant along the length of a given SEBASS run. The top
two strips show the training sites with the bottom two plots showing the surface
radiance and the continuum-removed surface radiance (apparent? surface
emissivity).
The effects of down-welling sky radiance (Section 7.4.1) can explain this apparent
dependence of the measured intensity of the atmospheric line absorptions on the surface
emissivity (Figure 26). That is, down-welling sky radiance, especially gas-line emissions,
has its greatest effect at those wavelengths (and those pixels) that have deep surface
emissivity (reflectance) features, because of greater reflectance (Kirchoff’s Law) of this
incident atmospheric radiation. As a consequence, the significant contribution of the
reflected down-welling atmospheric-line emission features are partially, and in some
cases completely (such as at 11.0 µm in Figure 26), filling in the atmospheric-line
absorption features. This shows that a correction for down-welling radiance would
improve the mineralogy-related spectral integrity.
The suitability of the SEBASS instrument calibration and ISAC atmospheric correction
for scene-independent mineral mapping was assessed through comparison of the reduced
SEBASS spectra with ground spectra for a range of geological materials (Figure 27). The
ground validation data included microFTIR spectra of related field samples and
laboratory DHR spectra of pure minerals from the JHU mineral spectra library. As
recommended in Section 7.4.3, both the airborne and ground spectral data were processed
to remove the “hull” using ENVI’s continuum-removal routine.
The results of the airborne-ground comparison (Figure 27) show that the SEBASS data
show the same diagnostic mineral spectral features as the ground data, though the relative
intensity of the signatures are much less. This can be explained (at least in part) by the
dampening effect of uncorrected down-welling radiance which effectively fills in those
wavelengths that show emissivity/reflectance contrast (Figure 15). As explained above,
this effect is not corrected by ISAC. More importantly, the diagnostic mineral signatures
are clearly evident in the SEBASS spectra. For example, andradite (Figure 27a) shows a
narrow emissivity peak at 11.58 µm, which is positioned between deep reststrahlen
minima. In contrast, calcite shows a sharp emissivity minimum at 11.2 µm which is 100
nm shorter than a similar dolomite reststrahlen minimum (Figure 27b). Diopside (Figure
27c) has emissivity minima at 8.8, 9.3, 10.4 and 10.9 µm. These are better observed in
the plot without the DHR spectra (Figure 27d). The albite SEBASS spectrum (Figure
27e) shows relatively little emissivity contrast compared with the other SEBASS spectra,
though in the plot without the related DHR spectra (Figure 27f), the diagnostic albite
features at 8.7, 9.6, 9.7 and 9.8 µm can be recognised. The epidote spectra show
different wavelengths to the reststrahlen bands, though the diagnostic emissivity minima
are located at approximately 9.2, 10.4 and 11.3 µm with peaks at 9.9 and 10.8 µm.
These excellent results demonstrate that the reduced SEBASS spectra can be used to
accurately map diagnostic mineral signatures, without problems of scene-dependent
artifacts.
The mean and the STD of one SEBASS line are shown in Figure 28. The mean spectrum
shows the characteristic Planck Blackbody Radiation Function shape. The STD spectral
shape is difficult to interpret mainly because of the complicating and dominating effects
that surface temperature has on passive TIR signal. That is, the largest temperature
variations theoretically occurs at wavelengths <10µm for surface temperatures higher
than 293K (Figure 22). At these wavelengths, there occurs the greatest variation in
surface silicate emissivities such that the high STDs at these wavelengths (and for the
other wavelengths) cannot be uniquely related to instrument noise. The apparently
greater band-to-band variation at shorter (<9 µm) and longer (>11.5 µm) wavelengths is
more likely a function of the intensity of atmospheric-line absorptions at these
wavelengths (Figure 18).
1400
1300
1200
1100
radiance units
1000
7.832
900
7.574
800
700
600 Mean 12.264
STD*10 12.502
500 12.736
400
7.5 8.5 9.5 10.5 11.5 12.5 13.5
wavelength (µm)
Figure 28: Mean and standard deviation (*10) spectra for the Douglas Hill SEBASS run.
The MNF transformation of the culled SEBASS data (Figure 30) show more noise-free
MNF bands [e.g. MNF bands: 4, 5, 6, 7 (temperature), 8, 12, 14] though the total number
of MNF bands with apparent surface information, but also with some instrument noise,
remains the same (approximately 45 bands in both) as the MNF transformed raw
SEBASS data (Figure 29). The culled data show a lesser number of MNF bands with
instrument noise, though broad column banding (e.g. MNF bands 1, 2 and 3), sharp
column striping (e.g. MNF band 18) and slightly oblique striping are still present,
indicating that these are not dependent on isolated “noisy” channels but affect much of
the data. In summary, the removal of 52 spectral bands did not appear to result in a
significant loss of surface compositional spectral information but did succeed in removing
some but not all of the of the instrument noise.
Finally, Figures 29 and 30, show no spectral-spatial variations along the length of the run
that may suggest the thermal calibration of the data has been compromised. That is,
measurement of the hot and cold blackbody calibrations at the beginning and end of the
line only (and not regularly through the run), assuming linear drift between these two
measurements, appears to be sufficient for characterising the instrument temperature drift.
This is an important result with implications for TIR sensor design and operation
(expand).
7.3.1 Background
The atmospherically corrected SEBASS surface radiance data comprises two
components, namely: (a) Planck Blackbody Radiation as a function of the surface kinetic
temperature; and (b) attenuation of this ideal Planck Blackbody Radiation because of
2
The last four of the 128 SEBASS bands do not contain image data.
These methods were developed for passive “broadband” multispectral TIR data, which
have too few spectral bands to accurately define the background hull spectrum for each
pixel. High spectral resolution TIR data, like that from SEBASS, possibly have sufficient
bands to characterise both the emissivity lows as well as the “background”, making TES
theoretically simpler. That is, a simple correction for the background on a per-pixel basis
(continuum-removal) could be sufficient for TES. It is also possible, that wavelength-
dependent temperature could be separated crudely as endmembers and unmixed
(Boardman, 1993) as part of the spectral “background”.
Some preliminary testing by one of the authors (K. Okada) found that the effects of
temperature could be separated (in part) from the desired emissivity information in raw
SEBASS data using a simple normalisation procedure like log residuals. He also found
that the derived log residual pixel spectra could be interpreted for their mineralogy.
Appendix 3 explores this possibility a little further and confirms these preliminary results,
and describes how scene-mean-dependent spectral artefacts complicate the pixel
signatures. There also remain residual temperature effects because the log residual
normalisations do not properly account for the wavelength-dependent and pixel-
dependent surface temperature.
To test the need for TES on the SEBASS data, a segment of the Douglas Hill run over
pronounced topographic relief was examined for the effect of residual temperature effects
on partial unmixing (MTMF) products with and without TES. In this case, TES was
implemented by removing each pixel spectrum’s background hull through “continuum-
removal” available in ENVI.
The results of this comparison for three mineral-spectral endmembers (calcite, dolomite
and andradite), together with a brightness temperature image, are presented Figure 31.
The striking similarity of the unmixed products derived with TES (Figure 31b) and
without TES (Figure 31c) and the lack of any correlation with the surface kinetic
temperature (Figure 31a) indicates that TES is not required to derive temperature-
independent mineral distribution maps using partial unmixing (although I also found this
result for one of my SEBASS runs, I guess we should qualify this for our data and not
assume its always the case-requires further testing maybe for many different conditions
3
Scattering also modifies spectral behaviour.
8.1 Introduction
The extraction of SEBASS mineral information products concentrated on two methods,
namely:
1. Spectral indices using bands ratios and derivatives of fitted polynomials; and
A ratio of SEBASS bands located at 11.4 and 11.0 µm were used to locate pixels either
rich in garnet or poor in carbonate (Figure 32c and 32e, respectively). The second
spectral index used was the estimate of the wavelength position of the garnet and
carbonate emissivity peak near 11.4 µm. This was achieved by calculating the 1st
derivative of a fitted 3rd order polynomial to the wavelength segment between 11.1 and
11.6 µm. An estimate of the RMS (root mean square) error of the fit helps in the
assessment of the suitability of the measurement. Thus the same spectral index was used
to map both the garnet chemistry and carbonate mineralogy. They are easily separated
from each other because they have an opposing relationship. That is, a peak for garnet
contrasts with a trough for carbonate.
The spectral indices map a continuous variation in garnet wavelengths whereas the
MTMF yielded four (only three are presented in Figure 32b) separate garnet endmembers.
As described above, garnets comprise a complete range of solid solution chemistries (and
related TIR wavelengths - Section 9.3). Clearly, MTMF is capturing some of this garnet
wavelength variation, though it is also sensitive to the relative depths of the spectral
diagnostic features, which is important for abundance mapping, but not necessarily for
mapping mineral chemistry. This helps explain the differences between these products
(Figures 32b and 32c).
Thus, the spectral index method is arguably better suited to mapping solid solution
chemical (wavelength) information (not abundance) compared with partial unmixing,
especially if the wavelength variations related to solid solution chemistry are small.
Another advantage of the spectral index method is that it is simple to apply, unlike partial
unmixing.
Mineral maps were generated for the skarn alteration found along the Douglas Hill and
Ludwig SEBASS lines (Figures 1 and 5) using MTMF (Section 8.3). Note that the
SEBASS images or their derived products were not georeferenced to a map-base. The
results are described in detail below.
Minerals that can be identified from the SEBASS data (Figure 33a) include: four types of
garnets; pyroxene+garnet; pyroxene (diopside-hedenbergite); epidote; dolomite; calcite;
quartz+clay+feldspar; albite; and two unidentified spectra, one of which may relate to
idocrase. The associated microFTIR spectra (Figure 34) are consistent with both the
shapes of these SEBASS endmembers as well as their location on the mineral map
(Figure 33b and 33c). For example: sample sites 5 and 6 show calcite; localities 28 and
31 show dolomite; localities 3, 27 and 29 show andradite garnet; locality 30 shows
pyroxene (diopside); locality 17 shows pyroxene-garnet; and locality 10 shows epidote in
both the field microFTIR and SEBASS data.
A comparison between the published alteration map (Figure 33d) and the SEBASS-
derived mineral map (Figure 33b) shows similarities as well as differences. Near the
Casting Copper and Douglas Hill Mines, there is excellent correspondence, especially
with regard to the distribution of the unaltered limestone (brown), dolomotised limestone
(orange), andradite skarn (red) and pyroxene skarn (dark blue). Even the detail of a
“halo” of andradite skarn surrounding a thin band of pyroxene skarn near the Casting
Copper mine (A) is accurately depicted by the unmixed SEBASS data. Towards the
northeastern end of the line (Figure 33), the contact between the altered skarn and the
granodiorite is well expressed as a change from garnet-rich to quartz-albite-rich pixels in
the SEBASS data (B). A wide albite-rich felsic dyke is also mapped in both (C).
The dissimilarities between the published mapping and the SEBASS mineral map (Figure
33b and 33d) are related to the skarnoid alteraton (Al-rich garnet and/or pyroxene). The
published mapping shows a strong parent rock control on this mineralogy (Figure 5)
though this is not expressed in the processed SEBASS data. Harris and Einaudi (1982)
commented that mapping in some areas associated with complete alteration to skarnoid is
difficult. There is also the possible problem of the accuracy of the MTMF garnet
chemistry maps as discussed in Section 8.4.
Minerals that can be identified in Figure 35 include: garnet of variable solid chemistry;
pyroxene (diopside-hedenbergite); epidote; dolomite; calcite; quartz; kaolinite; and
gypsum. The associated microFTIR spectra (Figure 35) of samples from the field
localities are consistent both with the shapes of the SEBASS endmembers and with their
location on the mineral map (Figure 34). For example: sample sites 51, 52 and 53 show
quartz; localities 39A and 39C show kaolinite; localities 34 and 38 show garnet,
localities 33 and 36 show dolomite; and locality 35 shows calcite in both the field
microFTIR and SEBASS data.
0.9
emissivity
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
7.5 8.5 9.5 10.5 11.5 12.5
wavelength (µm)
1.02
1
apparent emissivity
0.98
0.96
0.94
andradite skarn
0.92
skarnoid (west)
0.9 skarnoid (northeast)
skarnoid (southeast)
0.88
pyroxene skarn
0.86
7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
wavelength (µm)
The garnet XRD 420 hkl reflection peak is the strongest of the garnet XRD features and is
sensitive to the cation chemistry (Fe-Al). The d-spacing of this XRD peak was used for
comparison with the wavelength of the 11.5 µm feature. The results (Figure 39) show
significant linear correlation, confirming this relationship between spectral properties and
XRD mineral crystal lattice dimensions (cation chemistry).
2.685
2.68
2.675
2.67
y = 0.1148x + 1.3591
2
2.665 R = 0.8348
2.66
11.3 11.35 11.4 11.45 11.5 11.55 11.6 11.65
"emissivity maximum" wavelength (µm)
Figure 39: Scattergram of the XRD 2-d spacing for the 420 hkl garnet reflection peak
versus the wavelength position of the emissivity peak for 17 garnet bearing Yerington
samples. These data show linear correlation for these two parameters related to
changes in the cation chemistry (amount of Fe relative to Al) of the garnet.
Electron microprobe chemical analyses of garnet grains from fourteen of the 17 garnet-
bearing samples in Figure 39 were measured by Sumitomo Metal Mining in Japan. This
analysis found that the garnet grains were generally unzoned. A consideration in
comparing these analyses with the XRD and spectral data is all are effectively from
different sample media (crystal versus bulk versus whole rock surface, respectively).
EPMA %andradite
1
EPMA %grossular
EPMA cation (Fe, Al) content
0.8
y = 1.5x - 15.9
0.6 R2 = 0.67
y = -1.5x + 16.9
0.4 R2 = 0.67
0.2
0
11.3 11.35 11.4 11.45 11.5 11.55 11.6 11.65
emissivity maximum wavelength (µm)
Figure 40: Scattergram of the wavelength of the microFTIR emissivity peak near 11.5 µm
versus the electron microprobe analyses of Fe and Al for a selection of Ludwig field
samples (enlarged).
y = 11.9x - 31.0
R2 = 0.70
0.6
y = -11.9 + 32.0
0.4 R2 = 0.70
0.2
0
2.66 2.665 2.67 2.675 2.68 2.685 2.69 2.695 2.7
XRD 2-d spacing (420 hkl peak)
Figure 41: Scattergram of the wavelength of the XRD d-spacing of the 420 hkl
garnet reflection versus the electron microprobe analyses of Fe and Al for a
selection of Ludwig field samples.
These excellent results show that the wavelength of the garnet TIR feature near 11.5 µm
can be used to directly measure the grandite Fe-Al solid soution chemistry.
The wavelength position of the garnet emissivity peak near 11.5 µm was calculated using
the spectral indices (described in Section 8.2) for the Douglas Hill and Ludwig SEBASS
lines. These data were then used to generate a predictive map of the grandite Fe-Al solid
solution chemistry (Figure 42).
The first point to note about Figure 42 is how well the two lines overlap both with respect
to geometry and colour. That is, this method of tracking the wavelength position of the
emissivity peak for extracting the garnet information appears to be relatively scene-
independent, that is, generates seamless maps.
The accuracy of the estimated wavelength of the SEBASS 11.5 µm garnet peak was
checked using a selection of pixels covering field sites where microFTIR spectra were
extracted. Field sites Y027 and Y029 near the Douglas Hill mine (Figure 34) have a peak
at 11.58 µm for the field data and a peak at 11.56 µm for the SEBASS data. Field sites at
Y025 and Y026 in mapped Al-rich skarnoid alteration (Figure 34) have peaks at 11.37 to
11.38 µm for the field data and 11.37 µm for the SEBASS data. These favourable results
confirm the accuracy of the measured Fe-Al solid solution chemistry as derived from the
SEBASS data.
The map of the garnet Fe-Al solid solution chemistry (Figure 42) clearly delineates those
areas of skarn-alteration and shows a progressive enrichment in Fe towards the southwest
(away from the northern granodiorite contact). This is consistent with the skarnoid
alteration zonation mapped by Harris and Einaudi (1982).
Figure 42: Mosaic of SEBASS-derived garnet solid solution chemistry images for
the overlapping Douglas Hill and Ludwig lines. 100% Fe garnet is depicted as
white and 50:50 Fe:Al in black. Grey tones represent intermediate solid solution
chemistries. The blue tones are those areas poor in garnet and was determined
using a ratio of spectra bands. The underlying brightness temperature mosaic
provides spatial context. The positions of the three main skarn-related copper
mines covered by these lines area are also annotated.
Arguably the most important feature evident in Figure 42 is that all the skarn-style Cu
mines intersected by the SEBASS lines are clearly delineated as near pure andradite.
That is, the TIR-derived garnet Fe-Al chemistry provides a potential vector towards Cu
mineralisation (at least in this area).
Figure 42 also shows that garnet and its chemical composition can be mapped in alluvial-
colluvial materials that have moved at least 2 km from their source (A). This suggests
that the provenance of transported materials can be targeted remotely with recognition of
Fe-rich garnets indicating “local” Cu mineralisation.
The results presented here are only a preliminary analysis of the SEBASS data for
mapping porphyry style alteration at Yerington. A later study of the SEBASS data will
look in detail at the alteration associated with the well exposed Ann-Mason porphyry
system which was intersected by four SEBASS runs and has available large-scale
published maps of the geology and alteration (Dilles and Einaudi, 1992).
Figure 43: SEBASS Mineral maps associated information for the Douglas Line.
Note the line has been cut in two and placed side-by-side for convenience. Strips
(a) and (g) are the published 1:24000 scale geology (Figure 5 - Proffett and
Dilles, 1984); (b) and (h) are the surface “brightness” temperature with field
sample localities annotated. Strips (c) and (i) are Fe-garnet (red), Fe-Al garnet
(green) and Al garnet (blue). Strips (d) and (k) are calcite (red), dolmite (green)
and quartz (blue). Strips (e) and (k) are epidote (red), white mica (green) and
quartz (blue), but with a lower threshold compared with (d) and (j) though is
sensitive to residual temperature variations. The green elipse on Figure (a) shows
the approximate position of the oligoclase-andesine alteration and the blue elispse
(g) shows the location of oligoclase-albite alteration mapped by Dilles and
Einaudi (1992).
The MTMF distribution of epidote and quartz (Figure 43e and 43k) shows a pronounced
relationship with respect to the position of a wedge of carbonate-rich rocks in the
granodiorite (A – Figure 43b). This wedge is characterised by a high abundance of
epidote and quartz in the SEBASS data (Figure 43e). To the southwest of this wedge,
including within the adjacent granodiorite, there is also epidote and quartz. However,
immediately to the NW of this wedge in the granodiorite, epidote and quartz are not
developed. Instead Ca-albite is dominant (Figure 43f - discussed below). Elsewhere
within the granodiorite, a weak quartz signature is developed, though this is typically
associated with residual temperature effects (topographic shading), indicating that its
level of MTMF abundance is at the “noise” limits.
Three feldspar endmembers were found in the SEBASS data (Figure 44) with all showing
narrow emissivity lows at 9.6 and 10.0 µm indicating Na-plagioclase. Two of these
endmembers also share a peak at 9.2 µm (red and blue spectra – Figure 44), consistent
with the albite signature in Figure 11, while the third has no feature at this wavelength as
well as a relatively large 10.0 µm feature (green spectrum – Figure 44). This green
spectrum is consistent with greater Ca content, as the lack of 9.2 µm feature and a strong
10.0 µm feature is similar the andesine feldspar measured by Cudahy et al. (2000). The
red and blue spectra also differ in the 8-9 µm region with the red spectrum not showing as
well developed emissivity lows at 8.4 µm and 8.7 µm. The reason for this is not yet clear
as all fresh feldspars show features at these wavelengths (Figure 11) though it may be
related to a weathering effect or a function of the continuum-removal. Thus, the SEBASS
endmember spectra appear to be of two types: (i) “Na-rich” albite (red and blue spectra in
Figure 44); and (ii) “Ca-rich” andesine (green spectrum in Figure 44).
The SEBASS image of Na-Ca feldspar composition (Figure 43f and 43l) shows a pattern
of andesine (green and red) in the SW and the albite in the centre and NW parts of the
batholith. This distribution does not correlate well with the 1:24,000 scale published
geology (Figures 43a and 43g) though does correlate with the more detailed alteration
mapping of Dilles and Einaudi (1992). Specifically, Dilles and Einaudi (1992) mapped
oligoclase-andesine alteration in the SW (blue ellipse on Figure 43a) and oligoclase-albite
in the central-northeastern part (green ellipse in Figure 43g).
The SEBASS data show that the andesine abruptly terminates against a “stoped” wedge
of sediments (A – Figure 43b), with the other side free of feldspar but rich in epidote and
quartz. This suggests some structural/stratigraphic control to the alteration.
apparent emissivity
0.995
0.99
0.985
albite-oligoclase
oligoclase-andesine
albite oligoclase
0.98
8 8.5 9 9.5 10 10.5 11 11.5
wavelength (µm)
The associated microFTIR emissivity spectra of field samples (Figures 45 and 46) are
consistent with the SEBASS spectra and the distribution of Ca versus Na alteration. For
example, the microFTIR spectra of samples from the “Ca-rich” area (Figure 45) show
relatively pronounced development of the 10.0 µm feature and relatively weaker
development of the 9.2 µm feature compared with the microFTIR spectra of samples
collected from the Na-rich area (Figure 46). Type examples of these include the Ca-
albite/andesine (XRD - Appendix 2) of Y021_A (Figure 45) and the Ca-albite (XRD –
Appendix 2) of Y042_B.
The associated field microFTIR spectra (Figure 48) are consistent with the SEBASS
endmember spectra (Figure 47) as they also show albite and quartz signatures but also a
strong emissivity low at 9.2 µm (for example, Y050_D). This 9.2 µm feature is possibly a
function of a clay-weathering product, though comparable PIMA spectra also indicate the
development of epidote. Further work is required to resolve this issue.
The high-altitude AVIRIS radiance at sensor data were reduced to surface radiance using
a CSIRO developed version of ATREM, called HYCORR. HYCORR uses the radiative
transfer model 6S for deriving corrections for all the gases except water vapour, as well as
aerosol scattering. These corrections are calculated on a per-scene basis with
consideration given to scan angle and path length. Input parameters were based on a
standard climate model. The water vapour is calculated on a per-pixel basis using the
measured depth of the 3rd and 4th water vapour combination tones, similar to ATREM. As
a final step, the reduced pixel spectra are processed using EFFORT, which effectively
removes (normalises) any residual systematic high frequency atmospheric signature.
The geological information extraction from the derived surface radiance was implemented
using MTMF. The endmembers were selected from those pixels AVIRIS data that
essentially overlapped with SEBASS runs (Figure 49).
There are other image endmembers that generate coherent image units consistent with the
published alteration mapping (Figure 6) though their spectral signatures do not contain
mineralogically diagnostic behaviour. For example, a dark green spectrum and a mauve
spectrum generate unmixed results consistent with the spatial distribution of andradite and
grossular garnet respectively though they contain no diagnostic absorption, especially at
SWIR wavelengths (Figure 49c). That is, both of these spectra, together with that of the
brown (quartz?), ochre (idocrase?) and dark blue (pyroxene?) spectra all have a broad but
shallow minimum centred near 2.3 µm. The mineralogical interpretation of these spectra
is based on their spatial context referenced to the published mapping (Figure 6). All of
these minerals are non-OH-bearing silicates, which are SWIR inactive. The
discriminatory information that separates these silicates is essentially from the VNIR
where there exist “electronic” spectral differences related to the types and proportions of
transition elements (primarily Fe). However, this is subtle and not diagnostic. Windeler
(1993) found a similar result with Geoscan Mk II scanner from the same test site where it
was possible to map garnet-rich rocks based on the VNIR response.
12. DISCUSSION
The mineral mapping results described above show that SEBASS data provide spectral
identification and mapping of:
Quartz;
Grandite including their complete Fe-Al solid solution chemistry;
Clinopyroxene (diopside-hedenbergite) though their Fe-Mg solid solution chemical is
not available;
No K-feldspars have yet been identified even though these account for up to 25% of some
of the felsic rocks.
AVIRIS data were found to be useful in mapping the OH-bearing minerals (epidote,
amphibole, white micas of different chemistry, kaolinite, gypsum and clays) and
carbonates (calcite and dolomite), though it was not suitable for the spectral identification
of the non-OH-bearing silicates (quartz, garnet, pyroxene, feldspar). In the context of
mapping the skarn-style and the porphyry-style alteration at Yerington, these non-OH-
bearing minerals are critical, especially for the Fe-Al chemistry of the grandites and the
Na-Ca chemistry of the sodic plagioclase feldspars.
The skarn-style alteration mineralogy mapped using SEBASS in the Ludwig area is
consistent with the detailed mapping by Harris and Einaudi (1982). Einaudi and Burt
(1982) propose that Cu skarns alteration zonation is characterised by the development of
grandite and diopside. The SEBASS data were used to map the distribution of grandites,
though the identification of diopside rather than hedenbergite (characteristic of Zn skarns)
was not available. Mapping grandite distribution effectively delineates both the skarnoid
and late Fe-skarn alteration in the metasdiments (exoskarn). Furthermore, the progressive
enrichment in Fe away from the contact with the Northern Batholith is consistent with
metasomatic fluids emanating from the granodiorite. The areas of most Fe-richment
coincide with Cu mineralisation.
The salient results of this study of SEBASS data collected from areas of skarn and
porphyry style alteration in then Yerington district, Nevada, include:
1. The SEBASS data are of very high quality (signal to noise and spectral calibration).
Instrument noise is essentially not apparent in the raw data but is enhanced through
methods like MNF. Most of this noise comprises column banding/striping related to
the 128 by 128 detector “pushbroom” array nature of the instrument. A slightly
oblique line striping is also apparent. Over 40 MNF bands of the 124 available
spectral bands contain geologic information. Removing 52 of the noisiest bands as
well as those at the base of atmospheric-line absorptions did not reduce the number of
good MNF bands. Nor did it remove all the column or oblique line striping;
2. The limitation of conducting blackbody calibration (hot and cold) of the instrument at
the beginning and end of each flight-line only (scanning systems like TIMS conduct it
for each scan-line) did not result in any scene artefacts;
3. The InScene Atmospheric Correction (ISAC) method for reducing the radiance at
sensor SEBASS data to surface radiance is effective in correcting for the additive
(primarily up-welling) and multiplicative (transmission) atmospheric effects. The
ISAC model assumptions of a homogeneous atmospheric profile and no changes in
path-length were not a problem even for variations in topographic relief of >200 m.
However, the pixel-spectra were compromised by a lack of proper correction for
atmospheric continuum-absorption and reflected down-welling radiance from pixels
with a large emissivity (reflectance) contrast. This meant that a Planck Blackbody
Radiation Function could not be fitted accurately to the pixel spectra and both residual
atmospheric-line absorptions and less overall spectral contrast were apparent in many
pixel spectra;
7. The solid solution chemistry of minerals like grandite Fe-Al chemistry is measured by
calculating the first derivative of fitted a 3rd order polynomial to the wavelength
segment between 11.0 and 11.6 µm.
8. The Cu skarn alteration is clearly identified and delineated by the presence of grandite
(Ca-rich garnet) and diopside. Early skarnoid shows progressive increase in grandite
Fe content away from the associated granodiorite (source of hydrothermal fluids).
11. A comparison of the mineral information content of VNIR-SWIR AVIRIS data and
TIR SEBASS data for the skarn and porphyry styles of alteration showed that AVIRIS
could be used to discriminate most of the skarn alteration zones though could not be
used to identify the non-OH-bearing silicate mineralogy.
14. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The 1999 SEBASS airborne “group shoot” campaign to Nevada was supported by
Aerospace Corporation, CSIRO EOC, CSIRO Exploration and Mining, Sumitomo Metal
Mining Co. Ltd., ERSDAC, Perry and Associates, Noranda Inc, University of Nevada and
Stanford University. Sumitomo Metal Mining, ERSDAC and CSIRO Exploration and
Mining supported the field October 1999 campaign. Masashi Endo (Sumitomo) assisted
in the fieldwork. Flight line and geological planning for the Yerington test site was
assisted by Emeritus Professor Ron Lyon (Stanford University). Professor Jim Taranik
and Amber from University of Nevada provided useful information about the regional
geology and field logistics. Stephen Young (Aerospace) provided useful information
about the ISAC algorithm while Patricia Lew (Aerospace) organised the preliminary
processing and shipment of the SEBASS data to Australia. Mark Favas (CSIRO E&M)
read the raw SEBASS data from DLT4000 tape to disk. Mike Caccetta (CSIRO E&M)
ensured that the Aerospace software worked on the CSIRO NT computers and then
processed all the SEBASS data to surface radiance. Jenny Wilson organised the copying
of all the SEBASS data to CD and distribution to other group shoot members. Mike Hart
conducted the XRD measurements. Useful discussions about the SEBASS results were
conducted with Rob Hewson (CSIRO E&M) and Ron Lyon (Stanford). Rob Hewson and
Peter Hick (CSIRO E&M) reviewed the final manuscript. To all of these people and
organisations, we extend our sincere appreciation and thanks.
1. Detailed study of the four SEBASS lines that intersect the Ann-Mason porphyry
system;
2. Collect low-altitude hyperspectral VNIR-SWIR data from the Yerington test site for
comparison with the SEBASS data at comparable pixel resolution; and
3. TIR spectral characterisation of feldspar minerals including adularia and the complete
spectrum of Na to Ca plagioclase.
16. REFERENCES
Agar, R.A., 1994. Geoscan airborne multispectral scanners as applied to exploration for
Western Australian diamond and gold deposits, Proceedings 10th Thematic
Conference on Geological Remote Sensing, San Antonio, pp. 651.
Aronson, J.R., Emslie, A.G., Allen, R.V., and McLinden, H.G., 1967. Studies of the
middle- and far-infrared spectra of mineral surfaces for application in remote
compositional mapping of the moon and planets. Journal of Geophysical
Research, Vol. 72, pp. 687-703.
ASTER. 2000. ASTER web page: http://asterweb.jpl.nasa.gov/
Barducci, A., and Pippi, I., 1996. Temperature and emissivity retrieval from remotely
sensed images using the “Grey Body Emissivity” method. IEEE Transactions on
Geoscience and Remote Sensing, Vol. 34, No. 3, pp. 681-695.
Bianchi, R., and Marino, C.M., 1994. CNR LARA Project Italy: MIVIS/MIDAS
environmental airborne hyperspectral remote sensing, Proceedings of the 1st
Airborne Remote Sensing Conference, Strasbourg, pp., 613.
Boardman, J.W. 1993. Automatic spectral unmixing of AVIRIS data using convex
geometry concepts. Proceedings 4th Annual Airborne Geoscience Workshop,
October, 25-29 1993, JPL Publication 93-26, page 11.
Chang, S.H., Westfield, M.J., Lehmann, F., Oertel, D., and Richter, R., 1993. 79-channel
airborne imaging spectrometer, SPIE, Vol. 1937, pp.387.
Conel, J.E., 1969. Infrared emissivities of silicates: Experimental results and a cloudy
atmosphere model of spectra emission from condensed particulate mediums.
Journal of Geophysical Research, Vol. 74, B6, pp. 1614-1634.
Cudahy, T.J., L.B. Whitbourn, P. Connor, P. Mason, and R.N. Phillips 1999a. Mapping
surface mineralogy and scattering behaviour uses backscattered reflectance from a
hyperspectral midinfrared airborne CO2 laser system (MIRACO2LAS). IEEE
Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing, Vol. 37 No. (4), pp. 2019-2034.
Cudahy, T.J., Okada, K., Matsunaga, T., Whitbourn, L.B., and Oikawa, N. 2000. Testing
the accuracy of temperature-emissivity separation methods using airborne bi-
directional 9-11 µm reflectance. International Journal of Remote Sensing
(accepted).
Cudahy, T.J., Okada, K., Ninomiya, Y., and Whitbourn, L.B. 2000a. Mapping feldspar
mineralogy in igneous rocks using airborne hyperspectral 9-11 µm reflectance.
International Journal of Remote Sensing (accepted).
Table A1: SEBASS band centres and selected band used (outside atmospheric line
absorptions). * is deselected; 1 is selected.
bands available selected/deselected bands available selected/deselected bands available selected/deselected
7.57447 * 10.0038 1 11.9387 *
7.63993 * 10.0532 1 11.9799 1
7.70483 * 10.1023 1 12.0209 1
7.76917 1 10.1512 1 12.0618 *
7.83298 * 10.1998 1 12.1025 *
7.89626 * 10.2482 1 12.1431 *
7.95903 1 10.2964 1 12.1835 1
8.0213 * 10.3443 1 12.2238 1
8.08308 1 10.392 1 12.264 *
8.14439 * 10.4395 1 12.304 *
8.20523 1 10.4868 1 12.3439 *
8.26561 1 10.5338 * 12.3837 *
8.32555 * 10.5806 1 12.4233 *
8.38505 * 10.6272 1 12.4628 *
8.44413 1 10.6736 1 12.5021 *
8.50278 * 10.7198 1 12.5414 *
8.56103 * 10.7658 1 12.5805 *
8.61888 1 10.8116 1 12.6195 *
8.67633 * 10.8572 1 12.6583 *
8.7334 1 10.9026 1 12.697 1
8.79008 * 10.9478 * 12.7357 *
8.8464 1 10.9928 * 12.7741 *
8.90236 * 11.0376 1 12.8125 *
8.95795 1 11.0823 * 12.8508 *
9.0132 1 11.1267 * 12.8889 *
9.0681 1 11.171 * 12.9269 *
9.12267 1 11.2151 1 12.9648 *
9.1769 1 11.259 * 13.0026 *
9.23081 1 11.3027 1 13.0402 *
9.28439 * 11.3463 1 13.0778 1
9.33767 1 11.3896 1 13.1152 1
9.39063 1 11.4328 1 13.1525 1
9.44329 1 11.4759 * 13.1897 1
9.49565 1 11.5188 * 13.2268 *
9.54772 1 11.5615 1 13.2638 *
9.59949 1 11.604 1 13.3007 1
9.65098 1 11.6464 1 13.3375 *
9.7022 1 11.6886 * 13.3742 1
9.75313 1 11.7307 1 13.4108 *
9.8038 1 11.7726 1 13.4472 *
9.85419 1 11.8144 1 13.4836 *
9.90433 1 11.856 1 13.5198 *
9.9542 1 11.8974 *
Table A2: Automatic Mineral identification of the XRD Traces of Selected Samples.
Some preliminary testing by one of the authors (K. Okada) found that log residuals (Green
and Craig, 1985) applied to raw SEBASS data yielded mineralogically interpretable
spectral signatures as well as some temperature-independent imagery.
In theory, log residuals is not well suited to correcting TIR “radiance at sensor” data to
surface emissivity. This is because log residuals implements a series of normalisations,
including: (i) pixel-spectrum-mean normalisation; and (ii) a scene-wavelength-mean
normalisation. However, TIR radiance at sensor data has at least two components that
cannot be simply corrected through these normalisations, namely: (i) an additive up-
welling radiance component; (ii) a wavelength-pixel-dependent blackbody temperature
curve. For such reasons, the “thermal log residuals” method was developed by CSIRO
(Hook and others, 1992). However, both thermal log residuals and log residuals are based
on scene statistics, resulting in pixel spectra that depend on the scene-mean spectral shape.
Figure 45f shows log residual pixel spectra of selected pixels and Figure 45g shows ISAC
corrected, continuum-removed surface radiance spectra of the same pixels from a part of
the SEBASS Ludwig line. Even though, the log residual spectra show diagnostic features
that permit their identification as quartz-rich (blue) gypsum-rich (coral) and garnet-rich
(red), all spectra show garnet and to a lesser degree quartz spectral signatures. In contrast,
the ISAC corrected spectra do not show this pervasive development garnet and quartz
features. Furthermore, the green log residual spectrum from a dolomite-rich pixel (Figure
45f), does not clearly show the diagnostic sharp, carbonate emissivity low at 11.2 µm,
which is shown by the the ISAC corrected spectrum (Figure 45g). These results emphasis
the scene-mean dependence on the log residual spectra on the strong development of
garnet and quartz in this scene which appears to have affected all pixel spectra, even
masking some diagnostic minerals features such as carbonate.
The log residual images of the Ludwig show varying success in separating the surface
temperature from the surface emissivity information. Generally, scenes without apparent
topographic effects demonstrate effective TES. This appears to be the case for SEBASS
bands between 10.5 and 12 µm (Figures 45d and 45d) which contrasts with the albedo
(brightness temperature) image (Figure 45a), and which highlights the cold and hot sides
of topographic relief. Poor TES has occurred at other wavelengths, with “positive” and
“negative” residual temperature variations being typical at shorter and longer
wavelengths, respectively (Figures 45b and 45e). These results highlight the limitations
of using log residuals for TES mainly because the wavelength-dependent nature of the
blackbody temperature curve is poorly modelled through simple normalisations.