Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
BISMA SALEEM
Supervised by
DR AYAZ AYUB
MBBS,M.P.H
Assistant Professor
Institute of Public health and Social Sciences,KMU
I certify that this thesis titled “Prevalence of refractive errors and strabismus among the
children’s of special education complex, Peshawar” is based on my own independent work,
except where acknowledged in the text by reference. No part of this work has been submitted for
a degree or diploma to this or any other university.
_________________________________________
BISMA SALEEM
Master Scholar in Public Health
Institute of Public Health and Social Sciencs
Khyber Medical University Peshawar
By Supervisor:
I hereby, certify that Bisma Saleem having KMU Registration Number:, has been working under
my direct supervision with effect from: February 20, 2017 to date in the Institute of Public
Health and Social Sciences, of Khyber Medical University, Peshawar. The enclosed thesis titled:
“Prevalence of refractive errors and strabismus among the children’s of special education
complex Peshawar” was prepared according to the thesis guidelines of KMU under my direct
supervision. I have read the thesis and have found it satisfactory for further submission and
review / viva by external examiners.
_________________________________________
Dr Ayaz Ayub
Dr Hamid Hussian
Dedication:
This research was dedicated to my parents; teachers and friends always supported
me in my educational career.
Acknowledgement:
Thanks to Dr.Ayaz Ayub and Dr Hamid Hussian for their guidance, valuable
suggestion, wise counsel and very nice attitude while completing this research.
I thanks to all the individuals who have contributed in this research and special
thanks to Special Education Complex director, who is very supportive and also the
staff members.
I thanks to my parents and family members because without their encouragement
and guidance I would not have been possible to complete this task.
Abbreviations:
Children which are school going may have many vision related problems, one on
four school age children have vision problems according to Prevent Blindness
American and if it is not treated than is will affect personality, learning ability and
adjustment in school. Some of the school going children may take part in many
recreational activities that require sharp and good vision.(4)
Children with special educational needs are more likely to have refractive errors
and visual impairment than children without special educational needs.(5)
All children who are disabled may also need some special education and also have
a right to education. The main function to provide proper education to these special
children as applies to all children. Education is about to develop in all these aspects
including, cognitive, moral, spiritual, imaginative, mentally, social, emotional,
aesthetic, and physical.(6)
Ocular and visual disorders such as refractive errors, strabismus, nystagmus,
cataract, reduced visual acuity(VA) and poor accommodation are found to be more
common in children with intellectual disabilities than in typically developing
children.(7)
REFRACTIVE ERRORS:
Refractive errors occur when the light is not directly focus on the retina so it causes
blurring of vision. The size and length of the eyeball (longer or shorter) ,aging of
the lens, change in the shape of cornea all causes refractive errors.
HYPEROPIA:
Hyperopia also called Farsightedness when the light is focus behind the retina. In
hyperopia people will see near objects blur and distant objects clear.
Many of the children including babies tend to have no blurry vision with mild
hyperopia. Both distance and near vision is clear because their eyes can focus,
gradually when the person get older it losses ability to focus(9)
MYOPIA:
Myopia also called Nearsightedness when the light is focus in front of the retina
and it causes blurring of vision. In myopia near objects become clear while the
distant objects appear to be blurring.
Myopia can run in family and it is inherited, if myopia is present in parents than
definitely you will suffer from myopia. 8 to 12 age of children were often
diagnosed with myopia and if their bodies grow the myopia become more worsen.
Myopia changes very little between the ages of 20 and 40. Low myopia is called
mild myopia while high myopia is called severe myopia. Detached retina can occur
in the children or persons who may have high myopia, and it cause blindness
because it is a severe eye problem.
ASTIGAMATISM:
Astigmatism is also called distorted vision it may blur or distorts vision for both
distant and close up objects. When the eyes were not perfectly round like a ball
than it cause astigmatism. Myopia and hyperopia is occurring along with
astigmatism.
PRESBYOPIA:
Presbyopia can occur when there is difficulty in reading near objects. It usually
begins after 40. If the person is myopic, hyperopic, astigmatism also presbyopia
can occur when the person reach at 40’s. (10)
STRABISMUS:
It is also known as squint. Crossing or misalignment of two eye is called
strabismus.
By direction the strabismus can b classify in different types including
Esotropia an inward deviation of eyes
Exotropia an outward deviation of eyes
Hypertropia upward deviation of the eyes
Hypotropia downward deviation of the eyes
The squint may be present for all the time that is called constant or when it is
present for sometimes it is intermittent. The tropia is present if the affected eye
turns when the eye is open and phoria is present if the affected eye shut or
close.(14)
CAUSE OF STRABISMUS:
Poorly control of neuromuscular eye movement is the result of strabismus.
A problem with the actual eye muscle causes less commonly strabismus.
SYMPTOMS OF STRABISMUS:
The eye is not straight is one of the main symptom. Those children whose eyes are
squint with one eye in bright sunlight or sometime focus on something may tilt
their head for clear vision.
DIAGNOSIS OF STRABISMUS:
An eye examination can be done for the diagnosis of strabismus. The
ophthalmologist, optometrist and family doctor may check strabismus before the
age of four years in children. The ophthalmologist can check the vision of the child
before the age of three years when there is positive history of squint and
amblyopia. The true and false strabismus can also identify by ophthalmologist.
TREATMENT OF STRABISMUS:
Complete examination of eyes an ophthalmologist may recommend treatment for
strabismus that works to straighten the eyes, to preserve vision, and to restore
binocular vision. The most common treatment for strabismus is to provide glasses
or advise patching in some cases if the vision of one eye is very poor. And
sometimes surgery may do to correct the unbalanced eye muscles.(16)
Special Education:
It refers a range of educational and social services that is provided by public and
other educational institutions to individuals with disabilities with the age between 3
and 21 years.(22)
Summary of Chapter 1:
From discussion it is clear that refractive errors are the major public health
problem. If refractive errors were not correctly identified especially in children it
may become more severe. So it is also necessary to identified any of eye disorder
in special education children. If not treated on time than is cause many symptoms
like amblyopia, headache, diplopia and many more.
In the next chapter a detail literature will be discussed which is taken all around the
literature of the world.
Chapter 2
Literature review
Introduction of literature review:
The aim of literature review is to show individuals that you have good grasp of
literature to addition of new knowledge and address the uncovered gaps.
This chapter includes review of past researches on refractive and strabismus in
special education schools.
Objective of literature review:
The objective of objective review was that to identify existing research,
information and gaps in the literature that need to be addressed.
Literature search:
Find the articles that are most relevant to research objectives and research question.
Research question:
To determine the prevalence of refractive errors and strabismus among the students
of special education complex, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Pakistan
Inclusion criteria:
Original articles
Abstract
Systematic reviews
Exclusion criteria:
Non English articles
Editorial
Case report
Duplication of articles
A study was done in special education schools in Wales, UK to identify the visual
status and ocular disorders. The study is divided in to three phases. In 1st phase
they send questionnaire to 44 special schools in Wales. The questionnaire is about
to what information school has according to vision or vision problem. Those who
did not response to questionnaire than telephone interview carried out. So this is
the screening test. Out of 44 schools 5 schools has reported that the vision is not
well so they have decided to have two optometrists who are specialized in
assessment of these special children. A full eye examination can be carried out by
these optometrists. If the children diagnosed with any problem than advice for
further treatment or prescribed glasses. In phase 3 feedbacks was taken from all the
schools who has participated in this and also from the parents whose children
identify with any refractive error. From this study it show that the five schools
presented with refractive errors and low vision. (5)
Another study was conducted in Osan state of Nigeria. This study is about the
cause’s enrolment of children in special schools and ocular health status of those
children. A cross sectional study done in 8 schools in which 6 primary schools and
2 secondary schools, total number of children including in this study was 472. In
this study the person with low income more affected by ocular diseases. 4.7 %
were blind, and 9.9% of students seen with abnormal ocular findings. This is a
good study because the common eye diseases can easily prevented.(23)
Visual impairment is due to refractive errors and this risk is increased if the
students suffer from cognitive impairment. In Hualien the city of Taiwan a study
was conducted in special schools. 241 students from the special school were
examined of their various eye conditions. Total numbers of children which suffer
from refractive errors were 35.4%. 34.8% children need glasses. In this study it
show that the higher prevalence of ocular disorders are more common in multiple
disability than the simple intellectual disability group.(24)
One of the major health issues which affect the quality of life is hearing disorder.
One such study was done in Iran that children with hearing impairment compare
with different eye problems. In deaf children or people vision is one of the
important senses that communicate. Cross sectional study was done in two groups
of people one is deaf children and the other is non deaf children and compared
these two groups in terms of eye problems including refractive errors, strabismus
and amblyopia. The examination was done in proper lighting and done cycloplegic
refraction in children those are not cooperative. Refraction was done with
refraction box and retinoscope, cover test is performing for squint children. This
study simply shows that the deaf children have significantly more eye problems as
compared to normal children, and the possible relation found between deafness and
eye problems. If proper treatment and attention is pay to these children than these
eye problems can easily be cured.(26)
Joshi RS and Somani AAK carried out one study that is related to ocular disorders
in mentally retard children. It was understood that vision or ocular disorders are
neglected in mentally retard children. So this study was done in India to identify
the eye problems and their relationship with degree of retardation. Diagnostic and
Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders diagnostic criteria was used for the
diagnosis of mental level and Binet Kamat was used to assessed Intelligence
quotient. A detail medical or previously history was taken. Eyes checkup
optometrist or ophthalmology, children which are cooperative using C chart,
children which are not cooperative using pictures or done objective refraction with
the help of retinoscope. The study show that 124 children suffer from ocular
disorders with mental retardation. The children with any disability have higher risk
of ocular disorders so annually checkup of these children will help them in their
future life activities.(8)
Aden the city of Yemen conducted a study on deaf and dumb students having
ocular abnormalities. The visual acuity was assessed by using snellen visual acuity
chart. Ocular mortality, anterior segment examination, alternate cover test,
pupillary evaluation conducted with the help of slit lamp. The leading abnormality
was refractive errors, Warrdenburg syndrome and pigment epithelium patches
were seen in this study. (30)
Another study was done in Rawalpindi, it was a cross sectional study on risk
factors related for refractive errors in school going children. Convenient sampling
was done using a structured questionnaire to assess the risk factors associated with
refractive errors. In this studies students was grouped in different categories i.e.
dietary habit, daily routine, ocular hygiene and personal hygiene. If all these
categories of students are maintained than there is no chance of refractive errors. A
student with good daily routine was less likely to exhibit refractive errors. (33)
Z.Atta and A.Arif carried out the cross sectional study in Madrassa students of
Haripur district. The reason for selecting these madrassa students is that they
continuously work on reciting, memorizing and reading the Holy Quran. Few
madrassas provide basic health care services to these students but majority was
neglected. Refraction was done these students including wet and dry retinoscopy.
Jack cross cylinder and blur test was used. This study shows that the myopia is
more common in children than hyperopia and astigmatism. As continue reading
increase the chances of myopia, so encourage children to take break between
readings and read at further distance.(34)
Chapter 3
Methodology
INTRODUCTION:
This chapter describes the methodology of the study in detail. It explains study
population, study design, study duration, inclusion and exclusion criteria, data
collection instrument, data collection procedure, ethical consideration, and data
entry and data analysis.
Study setting:
Peshawar:
Peshawar is the capital of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, it is the largest city of KP
province. It is most populous city in Pakistan. In 2014 the total population of
Peshawar is 1.755 million and the area is 1,257 km2. There are 39 functional
government special schools in KP. Special education complex is only one having
categories of deaf, mentally retard, physically handicap and blind. Data was
collected from this special education complex.
Study duration:
6 months.
Sampling technique:
Census was followed.
Inclusion criteria:
All the students registered in daily attendance sheet of special education complex
of Peshawar.
Exclusion criteria:
Those students who are blind.
Those students absent on the day of data collection.
Those who are unwilling to participate in the study.
As per rules of the university, approval of the study was granted by the
Advanced Studies Research Board in the 49th meeting held on 8/5/2017
(Annexure No ). The approval/permission was obtained from Khyber Medical
University Research and Ethics board in the meeting held on 4/7/2017
(Annexure No )
Summary:
In the summary, was cross sectional study and the sampling technique was census,
conducted in Peshawar, KP. Prevalence of refractive errors and strabismus were
including in this study. Technical approval was taken from Graduate Committee
and ASRB. The approval was obtained from KMU research and ethics board.
For data analysis SPSS version 20 was used. Mean and standard deviation were
calculated while for categorical variables i.e. gender frequencies and percentages
were calculated. Chi square test was used for association between variables like
gender, strabismus and refractive errors. Independent t test was used for
association of age with strabismus.
The next chapter includes the result and analysis of this study.
Snellen visual acuity chart
Child responded by sign language
Examination of eyes
Examination of eye with the help of Retinoscope
Child with Down syndrome
The child with one eye having micro cornea and ptergyium
Chapter 4
Results
Descriptive Statistics:
References:
1. PUBLIC HEALTH RESEARCH [Internet]. [cited 2017 Jul 10]. Available
from: https://www.brienholdenvision.org/public-health/public-health-
research.html
2. Pearce MG, Pearce N. Addressing refractive error visual impairment:
volunteer organisations’ alignment with Vision 2020 and public health
principles. Clin Exp Optom [Internet]. 2012 Nov [cited 2017 Jul
10];95(6):583–9. Available from: http://doi.wiley.com/10.1111/j.1444-
0938.2012.00710.x
3. WHO | Visual impairment and blindness. WHO. 2016;
4. Vision Problems of School-Age Children [Internet]. [cited 2017 Jul 12].
Available from: http://www.allaboutvision.com/parents/schoolage.htm
5. Woodhouse Margaret J, Davies N, McAvinchey A, Ryan B, Woodhouse JM,
Davies N, et al. Ocular and visual status among children in special schools in
Wales: the burden of unrecognised visual impairment. Arch Dis Child.
2014;99(6):500–4.
6. NCSE. Children with Special Educational Needs, Information Booklet for
Parents. Natl Counc Spec Educ. 2014;
7. Puri S, Bhattarai D, Adhikari P, Shrestha JB, Paudel N. Burden of ocular and
visual disorders among pupils in special schools in Nepal. Arch Dis Child.
2015;100(9):834–7.
8. Joshi RS, Somani AAK. Ocular disorder in children with mental retardation.
Indian J Psychiatry. 2013;55(2):170–2.
9. Gel V, Nerve O. Refractive Errors.
10. Words E. Refractive Errors Eye Words to Know. 2015;1–4.
11. NIH. Facts About Refractive Errors. :1–4.
12. Refractive Error and Astigmatism - VisionAware [Internet]. [cited 2017 Jul
13]. Available from: http://www.visionaware.org/info/your-eye-
condition/guide-to-eye-conditions/refractive-error-and-astigmatism/125
13. Alhammami H. Refractive Errors. Qual Eye Cent [Internet]. 2012;1–8.
Available from:
http://www.qualityeyecenter.com/Learn/RefractiveErrors.htm%5Cr
14. AL-SHIFA TRUST EYE HOSPITAL SQUINT (Strabismus).
15. Strabismus — AAPOS [Internet]. [cited 2017 Jul 13]. Available from:
https://www.aapos.org/terms/conditions/100
16. Strabismus - Clinical Services - Eye Hospital - Patient Care - L V Prasad Eye
Institute [Internet]. [cited 2017 Jul 13]. Available from:
http://www.lvpei.org/patientcare/clinical-services/strabismus-neuro-
ophthalmology.php
17. One P, Pérez M. Table of of contents. 2003;(November):2004.
18. Why Myopia Progression Is a Concern [Internet]. [cited 2017 Jul 18].
Available from: http://www.allaboutvision.com/parents/myopia-
progression.htm
19. Hypermetropia | Optometry Education [Internet]. [cited 2017 Jul 18].
Available from:
http://optometryeducation.blogspot.com/2011/12/hypermetropia.html
20. Astigmatism, Astigmatism Symptoms and Treatment [Internet]. [cited 2017
Jul 18]. Available from: https://en.excimerclinic.ru/astigmatism/
21. Light Reflex Tests [Internet]. [cited 2017 Jul 18]. Available from:
https://www.aao.org/bcscsnippetdetail.aspx?id=703d090d-b6a0-45d5-a3da-
e456c030caec
22. Special Education - average, Definition, Purpose, Description [Internet].
[cited 2017 Jul 18]. Available from:
http://www.healthofchildren.com/S/Special-Education.html
23. Isawumi M, Akinsola F. Ocular health status and causes of enrolment into
special schools in Osun State, Nigeria. Zahedan J Res Med Sci [Internet].
2016;18(12):e4960–e4960. Available from:
http://proxy.lib.umich.edu/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?
direct=true&db=lhh&AN=20173089710&site=ehost-
live&scope=site%5Cnhttp://zjrms.com/en/articles/4960.html%5Cnemail:
michaeline.isawumi@uniosun.edu.ng
24. Tsao WS, Hsieh HP, Chuang YT, Sheu MM. Ophthalmologic abnormalities
among students with cognitive impairment in eastern Taiwan: The special
group with undetected visual impairment. J Formos Med Assoc [Internet].
2017;116(5):345–50. Available from:
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jfma.2016.06.013
25. Gogate P, Soneji FR, Kharat J, Dulera H, Deshpande M, Gilbert C. Ocular
disorders in children with learning disabilities in special education schools of
Pune, India. Indian J Ophthalmol [Internet]. 2008;59(3):223–8. Available
from:
http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=3120244&tool=p
mcentrez&rendertype=abstract
26. Ostadimoghaddam H, Mirhajian H, Yekta A, Sobhani Rad D, Heravian J,
Malekifar A, et al. Eye problems in children with hearing impairment. J Curr
Ophthalmol [Internet]. 2016;27(1–2):56–9. Available from:
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.joco.2015.10.001
27. Dhungana AP. Dhungana AP. 2014;3(1):4–7.
28. Ahmed A, Abah E, Oladigbolu K. Hearing and audiometric estimates in a
blind population in North-Western, Nigeria. Sub-Saharan African J Med
[Internet]. 2016;3(1):8. Available from:
http://www.ssajm.org/text.asp?2016/3/1/8/176294
29. Chukwuka I, Adio A, Chinawa N. Screening for Ophthalmic Disorders
among Deaf School Children in Nigeria- A Neglected Population.
Ophthalmol Res An Int J [Internet]. 2016;5(4):1–6. Available from:
http://sciencedomain.org/abstract/14388
30. Salem RA., Basaleh SS, Mohammed SF. Ocular Abnormalities among Deaf
Students in Aden City, Yemen. Iraqi J Med Sci. 2014;12(3):144–7.
31. Ovenseri-Ogbomo G, Abraham C, Kio F. Visual Impairment and Ocular
Findings among Deaf and Hearing Impaired School Children in Central
Region , Ghana. J Med Biomed Sci. 2013;2(2):16–22.
32. Ali A, Ahmad I, Ayub S. Prevalence of Undetected Refractive Errors Among
School Children. Biomedica. 2007;23:96–101.
33. Full-Text.
34. Atta Z, Arif AS, Ahmed I, Farooq U, Z. A, A.S. A, et al. Prevalence of
Refractive Errors in Madrassa Students of Haripur District. J Ayub Med Coll
Abbottabad. 2015;27(4):850–2.