Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
ON
HOW TO IMPROVE PRONUNCIATION: STAMFORD
UNIVERSITY PERSPECTIVE?
1
Chapter I
Introduction
1.1 Introduction
2
According to Fraser (2000), teachers should be provided with courses and materials
that help them improve their pronunciation instruction. She continued that second
language education research should not be concerned with the significance of
English pronunciation instruction but with the methodology of pronunciation
instruction. Morley (1991) stated that understandable pronunciation is a main
objective of pronunciation instruction. In is a necessary component of
communicative competence.
The goal of pronunciation instruction is not to ask learners to pronounce like native
speakers. Instead intelligible pronunciation should be the real purpose of oral
communication. If learners want to change the way of pronouncing English words,
they have to change the way they think about the sounds of those words. This is
true both for individual sounds and the bigger parts of speech such as syllables,
stress patterns, and rhythm. Unfortunately, pronunciation instruction is sometimes
ignored in English language teaching (Pourhosein Gilakjani, 2011; Pourhosein
Gilakjani, 2016). In this paper, the researcher defines the term pronunciation,
explains the goal of English pronunciation, elaborates the importance of
pronunciation, states the role of teachers in teaching pronunciation, and mentions
some suggestions for teaching English pronunciation.
Since the English is the foreign language in our country, it is practiced in classroom.
But there is no any scope to practice it outside the classroom. There is no particular
book for practicing pronunciation. That's why students do not show their interest
for developing pronunciation. Teachers are not aware of this kind of problem. Due
to different phonetic patterns to Bangla and English language, speakers of Bangla
language are supposed to face some differences in pronouncing certain phonemes
of English.
The objective of this study is to find out the problems faced by tertiary level student
in learning pronunciation and how to improve pronunciation especially in the
department of English. This study carries out a survey based on qualitative method.
3
And the data was collected from 12 teachers and 52 students through questionnaire
from the department of English at Stamford University Bangladesh. On the basis of
this two objectives I have two questions:
4
Chapter II
Literature Review
Jahan also added that, teaching Pronunciation is the most complicated but a
significant aspect of ESL/EFL teaching at the same time (p. 1). According to her, it
5
is quite impossible for ESL learners to achieve a perfect native like accent. The
communication process will be successful if the pronunciation of the learners can
easily be understood by the efficient speakers of English (p. 2). Moreover, Hancock
(2003) said that, pronunciation is essential for speaking and listening (p. 6).
Moreover, Mumeneen (2011) added that, students with BA degree in English are
found to have problems in English pronunciation; as a result they often fail to
impress the interview board in a job market. Moreover, they also face many
problems while communicating with others in their daily lives due to this lacking
(p. 14).
On the other hand, while giving examples of other countries, Lin, Fan and Chen
and Moniruzzman (as cited in Howlader, 2010) described that like Bangladesh,
some teachers in Taiwan as well argue that English pronunciation is not actually
important. Students require to show their pronunciation skill only in few tests (p.
4).
Primary Level
6
Certificate) or HSC (Higher Secondary School Certificate) (in Hossain, Nessa and
Kafi 2015).
Secondary Level
Tertiary Level
7
appears to receive inadequate attention in both teaching and learning at tertiary level
(Moniruzzaman 2008).
Interference of L1
In Bengali and English languages there are some similarities but mainly
dissimilarities which create problem for the Bengali speakers to learn English
pronunciation (Tahereen 2015). Hai and Ball identified some differences in both
8
segmental phonemes and supra-segmental features of these two languages (in
Haque 2010). They show that there are some distinct and some common vowels in
these two languages. In Bengali there are 7 vowels and 12 in English. The chart
(Appendix-D) shows that that there are only two common vowels (/e /and /æ/).
According to their observation Bengali speakers usually get confused with 4
English vowels (/u: /, / ʌ/, / ɜ/, /ə/). They also observed that, Bengali speakers are
unable to differentiate between the short and long vowels of English. For example,
they pronounce feet /fi:t/, fool /fu:l/, half /ha:f/ (Houqe, 2010). In Bengali language
there are 18 diphthongs but only 8 in English. The diphthongs of these two
languages do not share any similarities (ibid). Hoque (2010) identifies a common
mistake made by the Bengali speakers of English is that they say only the first part
of the diphthong and ignore the second part. For example, they pronounce ‘boat’ /
boʊt/ as /bʊt/ and ‘here’ /hiə/ as /hiɑr/ (ibid).
Interference of Dialects
The non-native English users in Bangladesh use various local dialects with different
pronunciation and intonation which influence the use of English (Hoque 2010).
Bengali speakers from different local backgrounds pronounce many words
differently because of their local backgrounds (ibid). For example, the people of
Barishal often tend to do pronunciation mistakes in words beginning with ‘B’ and
9
‘V’, both in English and Bengali (Hoque 2010). In Noakhali dialect, the bilabial
plosive /p/ is not heard at all but replaced by a fricative sound similar to English /f/
(ibid). The unvoiced velar aspirated plosive /kh/ is pronounced as a fricative sound
in Chittagong and Sylhet (ibid). Hoque (2010) also gave an example of a student
from Comilla pronounced ‘victory’ /viktəri/ as /bikturi/ and another student from
Natore pronounced as /bhikto:ri/.
2.1.1 Stress:
Stress means prominence in pronunciation normally produced by four factors
loudness of voice, length- of syllables. 'pitch' related to frequency of vibration of
the vocal folds as well as to low/high tone and 'quality* of vowels functioning
individually or in combination (Roach. 2000: Maniruzzaman, 2004). Stress is
extremely important in English since the use of stress carries a different meaning
and a great deal of information. Native speakers never use stress in proper time.
They always make improper application of Bangla and English sound when they
talk to each other. Stress can show contrast according to whether the information is
new or old, the focuses of the message and other information about the speaker's
intention,
2.1.2 Intonation:
This is one of the major problems for native speakers. In speech, intonation, is the
use of changing vocal pitch (rising and falling) to convey grammatical intonation
or personal attitude. According to Wells (2006), intonation is the melody of speech.
Maniruzzaman (2006b) states that intonation is a systematic and regular feature of
speech.
10
2:1.3 Vowel. and Consonant:
English is the phonetic language, so it is very hard to know how to pronounce a
word by its spelling. In English, pronunciation is based on sounds not spelling.
Some sounds of English do not exist in other language.
11
Furthermore, Howlader also said that, English has become the compulsory course
in Bangladesh right after the arrival of CLT. It included the listening and speaking
as its curriculum but overlooked the pronunciation (p. 2).
According to Morley (as cited in Howlader, 2010), till the 1960s teaching and
learning pronunciation was regarded as pointless non-communicative drill and
exercise strategies (p. 1). Likewise, Gilbert (as cited in Howlader, 2010) also stated
that, in spite of carrying an essential link to communication through listening and
speaking, pronunciation is being overlooked in the syllabus, materials as well as in
the classroom activities (p. 2). Furthermore, Maniruzzaman (2008) also mentioned
that, pronunciation is a vital part in case of learning second/foreign language
because it directly affects learners’ communicative competence and performance.
Nevertheless, teaching EFL pronunciation is neglected in the syllabus, material and
classroom, especially in Bangladesh (p. 1).
12
tied with listening and speaking. However, pronunciation is hardly given enough
importance while teaching and learning English at the primary, secondary and
tertiary levels in Bangladesh (p. 12)
Moreover Maniruzzaman (as cited in Mumeneen, 2011) also argued that, most of
the EFL teachers avoid pronunciation instruction in the classroom by smart tricks
because they do not have the idea of useful and effective strategies to teach
pronunciation and which approach to follow when they meet a specific problem (p.
13-14).
Besides, according to Derwing and Munro (2005), the study of pronunciation has
been sidelined within the area of applied linguistics and for that reason teachers are
often left to depend on their own intuitions with little direction. Although some
teachers can successfully teach their students pronunciation under these conditions,
a large number of them are
Wei (as cited in Howlader, 2010) argues that, some teachers have poor knowledge
about the different strategies of teaching pronunciation and that is why they do not
find it interesting. This reason often makes the students lag behind in better
pronunciation and in achieving effective communicative competence (p. 4). On the
other hand, Dalton (as cited in Howlader, 2010) describes it as the Cinderella area
of the English language because according to him, the teachers and learners might
think that it will be under grasp without any effort (p. 4).
13
2.8 Possible solutions to overcome the Difficulties
To create consciousness and concern for pronunciation, Kenworthy (as cited in
Jahan, n.d) has referred that, English pronunciation is comprised of various
components like sounds, stress and variation all together, so the learners need to
recognize the function as well as the structure of it. Besides, they need to develop a
consciousness for pronunciation and also need to be aware of that their poor and
unintelligible language can make their utterances annoying to themselves and to
their listeners as well (p. 2).
Robertson (as cited in Jahan, n.d) has especially talked about the necessities of the
Asian students. According to him, Asian students should practice some
important areas of speech like- country specific complex sounds, cluster
problems, th' words, linking words and sounds. Therefore, teachers and learners
are required to have essential knowledge about those sounds, especially the sounds
related to English language (p. 1).
Pennington, Richards and Nunan (as cited in Jahan, n.d) describes the present
condition of research on teaching pronunciation from the perspective of CLT. They
have suggested that teachers should be focusing on a long-term goal to teach
pronunciation and it should be taught as an integral part of spoken language.
Besides, they also suggested that lessening the amount of native language influence
should be the aim of this teaching. According to them, since pronunciation is
associated with listening vocabulary and grammar, the teachers should focus these
interdependent aspects (p. 2).
Similarly, Morley (as cited in Jahan, n.d,) mentioned that, supra-segmental aspects
like stress, rhythm and intonation should be given importance in order to improve
pronunciation, since the aim of those not just to complement meaning but to create
meaning (p. 2). Besides, Jahan (n.d) again suggested that, in order to obtain fluency
and accuracy in speaking nonnative speakers should focus on some methods related
to speech mechanism. It would help them to pronounce the proper sounds of English
language (p. 3). 2.
14
Chapter 3
Methodology
To collect and analyze the data for this study triangulation approach was used.
According to Bryman (2010) triangulation refers to the use of more than one
approach to the investigation of a research question in order to enhance the
reliability and validity of the findings.
The sample which was used to collect the data for the study was consisting of 03
teachers and 30 students of English department from Stamford University
Bangladesh. The data were collected through interviewing 03 teachers and by
providing questionnaire to 30 students from department of English. Further data
were collected through class observation. The whole data collections were done
through purposeful sampling. All the data required for this study were collected in
both formal and informal setting.
15
3.4. Sampling
For the study, the researcher has chosen student from the department of English and
Stamford University Bangladesh as a sample unit to collect data. The participants
both teachers and students were cooperative and helpful in filling up the
questionnaire.
It was possible to get information from only 12 teachers from the department of
English. All of them were really helpful and cooperative.
3.6. Instrumentation
The researcher used separate questionnaire for both teachers and students. The
researcher organized the questions in a way so that the participants feel easy and
comfortable to answer and express their opinions. In student’s questionnaire, the
respondents had to choose and tick an appropriate option from five options for each
item\statement-
Strongly Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly Disagree
For analysis, the researcher converted the responses into mathematical figure. The
students’ questionnaire was in the form of statement, not questions. On the other
16
hand, the questionnaire for teachers (see appendix) was in the qualitative form.
There were 10 questions for students and 8 questions for teachers.
The data were collected from the teachers and students of Department of English at
Stamford University Bangladesh. For collecting data, the researcher had to contact
with the Head of the department of Department of English and tell them the purpose
of the research to get permission. The researcher also had to take permission from
the teachers, whose classes she observed for conducting teachers’ and students’
survey.
After collecting data, they were analyzed and organized very carefully. The
collected data from the students and the teachers were presented in two separate
tables. First, the researcher compiled the students’ responses and arranges those
numbers according to each statement in first table. Later on, total number of
students’ responses for each item were counted with percentage and listed in
another table. Then these were analyzed according to the central research question.
On the other hand, the researcher converted the teachers’ responses into percentage
and arranged them in another table. Besides, the elaborate responses of teachers for
each question are also discussed in the finding and discussion part.
The assessment was done to find out the key methods of improvement of English
pronunciation in the Department of English at Stamford University Bangladesh
through the separate questionnaire. By these two separate questionnaires we got to
know about the reasons from different point views.
17
Chapter 4
Findings & Discussion
As mentioned earlier that the data was collected from 30 students and 3 teachers
at Stamford University Bangladesh. The data was collected from English
Department students and teachers through questionnaire. The questionnaire is
sequentially analyzed and discussed on the basis of findings.
1.5
1
1 66.66%
33.33%
0.5
0 0 0 0 0 0
0
Agree Strongly Neutral Disagree Strongly
Agree Disagree
18
Q2. Does your department offer courses in English pronunciation for your students?
Perception No of Respondents Percentage (%)
Agree 02 66.66%
Strongly Agree 00 00
Neutral 00 00
Disagree 01 33.33%
Strongly Disagree 00 00
Total N= 03 100%
1.5
1
1 66.66%
0.5 33.33%
0 0 0 0 0 0
0
Agree Strongly Neutral Disagree Strongly
Agree Disagree
The data has calculated 66.66% of the total respondents were Agree with this
question.
19
Q3. Do you have sufficient materials to teach English pronunciation to your
students?
Perception No of Respondents Percentage (%)
Agree 01 33.33%
Strongly Agree 00 00
Neutral 02 66.66%
Disagree 00 00
Strongly Disagree 00 00
Total N= 03 100%
The question-3 has conducted 33.33% of the total respondents were agree and rest
of them were Neutral.
20
Q4. Do you have any extra activities you use to teach English pronunciation?
Perception No of Respondents Percentage (%)
Agree 00 00
Strongly Agree 00 00
Neutral 01 33.33%
Disagree 02 66.66%
Strongly Disagree 00 00
Total N= 03 100%
0 0 0
33.33%
66.66%
In reply to the question no. 4, 66.66% teachers said that they have not used any
extra activities to teach English pronunciation.
21
Q5. Do you test your students’ pronunciation skill?
Perception No of Respondents Percentage (%)
Agree 00 00
Strongly Agree 01 33.33%
Neutral 00 00
Disagree 02 66.66%
Strongly Disagree 00 00
Total N= 03 100%
The table-5 has found 66.66% teachers don't test student's pronunciation skill.
22
Q6. Do you face difficulties in teaching English pronunciation?
Perception No of Respondents Percentage (%)
Agree 01 33.33%
Strongly Agree 02 66.66%
Neutral 00 00
Disagree 02 00
Strongly Disagree 00 00
Total N= 03 100%
0
33.33%
66.66%
Above data has shown, 66.66% respondents were found strongly agree with face
difficulties in teaching English pronunciation.
23
Total N= 03 100%
Chart Title
1.2
1 1 1
1
0.8
0.6
0.2
0 0 0 0
0
Agree Strongly Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
Series1 Series2
Above data has found both agree, neutral and disagree 33.33% with this question.
24
Chart Title
33.33%
66.66%
0
0
Above data table has shown 66.66% respondents were faced all of the problems
which were mentioned in the table.
33.33%
66.66% 0
0
Influence of dialect
influence of Bengali phoneme
Lack of situation-based vocabulary
All
The above data table has calculated 66.66% of the total respondents said yes.
25
Q10. In which areas do your students face pronunciation problem?
Perception No of Respondents Percentage (%)
Listening 00 00
Speaking 00 00
Both 03 100%
Total N= 03 100%
100%
Both
3
0
Speaking
0
0
Listening
0
This table showed 100% of the respondents faced problem both listening and
speaking of English pronunciation.
26
4.1. Students’ Questionnaire Survey
Q1. Do you think the activities being used in classes to learn English, would help
the students to improve their Pronunciation difficulties?
Neutral 2 6.7
Disagree 2 6.7
Total 30 100.0
Here the data table has shown, 66.7% of the total respondents were agreed with
this question.
27
Q2. Do you think class time is not enough to work on students’ pronunciation
skills?
Neutral 12 40.0
Disagree 1 3.3
Strongly Disagree 00 00
Total 30 100.0
The above data table has shown, maximum 43.3% of the total respondents were
agreed with this question.
28
Q3. Is there any particular chapter in syllabus to practice pronunciation?
Strongly Agree 00 00
Neutral 13 43.3
Disagree 5 16.7
Strongly Disagree 00 00
Total 30 100.0
The table has shown highest 43% of the total respondents were neutral when
conducted this survey and 40% were agreed with this question.
29
Q4. Do you practice phonetic sound in your classroom or outside?
No 15 50.0
Total 30 100.0
This data has shown 50% of the respondents were practice outside and Others 50%
were said no.
30
Q5. Do you have any course regarding phonetic sound?
No 6 20.0
Total 30 100.0
Above table has shown 80% of the total respondents have course regarding
phonetic sound.
31
Q6. Teacher does not put emphasis on pronunciation while taking English classes.
Perception No of Respondents Percentage (%)
Agree 1 3.3
Neutral 10 33.3
Disagree 17 56.7
Strongly Disagree 00 00
Total 30 100.0
This table has found highest 56.7% of the total respondents were disagreed with
this question.
32
Q7. Do you think rules of stress and intonation are very important for correct
speaking?
Perception No of Respondents Percentage (%)
Yes 23 76.7
No 7 23.3
Total 30 100.0
This data table has shown 76.7% of the total respondents were said yes.
33
Q8. Do you follow any step for learning pronunciation (listening, speaking)?
Perception No of Respondents Percentage (%)
Yes 27 90.0
No 3 10.0
Total 30 100.0
The above table has shown 90% of the total respondents were said yes for this
question.
34
Q9. Do you have any concept about exact pronunciation of English sound
(Phonemes like vowel, consonant, diphthong)?
No 4 13.3
Total 30 100.0
Highest 86.7% of the total respondents were said yes and rest of them were said
no.
35
Q10. According to you, what could be the major reason behind the English
Pronunciation difficulties of Stamford University of Bangladesh?
This last question is open-ended question and the students said that the major
reasons behind the English pronunciation difficulties are - lack of proper speaking
and using English in personal life, lack of interest to learn pronunciation and lack
of practice, lack of sincerity and there has no language club in Stamford University
to practice language and no course of learning pronunciation.
36
Chapter Five
Conclusion & Recommendation
Conclusion
From the above findings it can be said that teachers should give more importance
to improve their students’ pronunciation skill. Only by developing students’ reading
and writing skills teachers cannot ensure a bright future of their students as oral
skills are equally important. Therefore, students are needed to be aware and
motivated to learn pronunciation for the job market and also for getting rid of the
interruption of the regional articulation.
37
Recommendation
On the basis of the analysis that the following recommendations can be made:
If English sounds are introduced in early education, learners will get the
knowledge of sounds and it will be easy for them to pronounce.
A specially designed course for the pronunciation will also make the
students able to have a good pronunciation skill in English.
Lots of listening practice is needed, using dictionary in mobile phone.
Confirming sounds before using can be practiced for teaching
pronunciation.
Teachers’ training, laboratory facilities and logistic support are also
suggested for teaching good command over pronunciation.
Learners should be made aware that it is not the native like variety that they
should follow; rather, they should follow the IPA (International Phonetics
Alphabet).
Students should be motivated enough to learn pronunciation, self-teaching
of reading IPA chart can help learners to have accurate pronunciation skill.
Not only for the academic conversation, but also to do well in job market
and to avoid being discriminated socially, students need to be aware of their
pronunciation.
38
References
Fraser, H. (2000). Coordinating Improvements in Pronunciation Teaching for Adult
Learners of English as a Second Language, Canberra: DETYA.
Gilakjani, A. P. (2012). A Study of Factors Affecting EFL Learners’ English
Pronunciation Learning and the Strategies for Instruction, International
Journal of Humanities and Social Science, 2(3), pp. 119127.
Hoque, M. A. (2010). The Influence of the Local Varities on the Sound Patterns of
English: A Case Study of Bangladeshi Tertiary Students. IIUC Studies, 7,
pp. 197-220.
39
Appendix- A
Teachers' Feedback Questionnaire
Years of Experience:
Name of Institution:
Your contact of E-mail (Optional):
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The following questions try to draw Teachers' suggestions regarding how to
improve pronunciation at tertiary level. These statements will be kept confidential
and are meant only for research purpose:
Instruction: Please put tick mark on your answer.
Q2. Does your department offer courses in English pronunciation for your students?
Agree Strongly Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
Q4. Do you have any extra activities you use to teach English pronunciation?
Agree Strongly Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
40
Q7. Do you get any training to teach pronunciation?
Agree Strongly Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
41
Appendix- B
Students' Feedback Questionnaire
(For Undergraduate Research)
Topic: How to Improve Pronunciation at Tertiary Level in Bangladesh.
Personal Information: (this information will be kept confidential)
Name of Institutions:
Department:
Batch:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Instruction: Please put tick mark on your answer.
Q1. Do you think the activities being used in classes to learn English, would help
the students to improve their Pronunciation difficulties?
Agree Strongly Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
Q2. Do you think class time is not enough to work on students’ pronunciation
skills?
Agree Strongly Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
Q6. Teacher does not put emphasis on pronunciation while taking English classes.
Agree Strongly Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
42
Q7. Do you think rules of stress and intonation are very important for correct
speaking?
Yes No
Q8. Do you follow any step for learning pronunciation (listening, speaking)?
Yes No
Q9. Do you have any concept about exact pronunciation of English sound
(Phonemes like vowel, consonant, diphthong)?
Yes No
Q10. According to you, what could be the major reason behind the English
Pronunciation difficulties of Stamford University of Bangladesh?
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
43