Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Treatment of Symptomatic
Cracked Teeth CE 2
Abstract: Every practice has patients who complain of cold sensitivity and Jack D Griffin, Jr, DMD, FAGD
pain on biting while showing no obvious signs of irreversible pulpitis. After Private Practice
Eureka, Missouri
loading each cusp and fossa in a symptomatic quadrant and ruling out pulp
and periodontal pathology, definitive treatment can be performed to allevi-
ate the patient’s symptoms in a consistent, conservative manner using
esthetic computer-aided design/computer-aided manufacturing porcelain
restorations. Single-appointment definitive restorations can be advanta-
geous for the patient because of the elimination of many steps involved in
laboratory fabrication of porcelain or metal restorations. Learning Objectives:
After reading this article, the
P
atients regularly complain of painful teeth, and it is prudent to deter- reader should be able to:
mine the cause and to provide correct treatment. Cracked tooth syn-
drome (CTS) refers to an incomplete fracture of a vital posterior tooth • describe clinical character-
that involves the dentin and may extend to the pulp.1 Patients often report istics of cracked teeth.
a history of teeth that occasionally give a sharp pain when biting certain • clinically distinguish teeth
foods. Sometimes they can specifically identify the offensive tooth, but often with symptomatic fractures
they cannot tell where the pain is coming from. with irreversible pulpitis
Often location and the extent of the fractures are difficult to evaluate, and from those without irre-
various diagnostic methods must be used.2 Great restorative treatment cannot versible pulpitis.
overcome a faulty diagnosis, and no treatment can succeed if the diagnosis is • discuss a diagnostic proto-
incorrect.3 Patient history, a thorough clinical exam, pulpal testing, and radi- col to specify fractured cusps
ographs all combine with training and experience to create an effective treat- needing treatment.
ment plan. Recommended treatment for cracked teeth has ranged from sim- • explain why single visit
ple occlusal adjustments to varied restorative and endodontic therapies.4 porcelain restorations may
be beneficial over tradition-
Diagnosis al full coverage crowns for
A thorough history from the patient perspective is critical. How long treatment of cracked teeth.
has there been pain? Is it worse when lying down? Is it throbbing or sponta-
neous? Does it hurt only when eating or grinding? Has the patient had pain
in this area in the past? Is the sensation occasional or constant? Does the
pain come from a specific area, or is it hard to locate? Data from patient his-
tory is assimilated and recorded to aid in a methodical diagnosis.
Diagnosis of CTS should be gathered from multiple clinical tests.
Conservative treatment of cracked teeth can only be attempted after ruling
out pulpal or periodontal pathology. If radiographic examination indicates a
periapical lesion or if the patient gives a history of lingering cold sensitivity,
heat-induced pain, throbbing, or spontaneous pain, irreversible pulpitis is
indicated and endodontic treatment should be considered.5
Only when prudent clinical testing rules out irreversible pulpitis or peri-
odontal pathology can conservative restorative options be considered.
Clinical tests of the symptomatic quadrant could include loading each cusp
with a cotton roll or bite stick, inspection with magnification, transillumina-
tion, intraoral cameras, selective tooth banding, or staining.5 The critical diag-
nostic factor is to locate the specific cusp or cusps that are causing the pain.
Figure 1—All teeth in a symptomatic quadrant are checked with Figure 2—The patient is asked to bite straight down with firm
the Tooth Slooth IIa after ruling out pulpal or periodontal pathol- pressure. Each cusp is checked and re-checked in a suspect
ogy. The dimpled end is placed on every cusp tip and held there quadrant until the symptoms the patient complained of are
as the patient closes. reproduced.
Characteristics of Cracked Tooth The Tooth Slooth IIa and the Fracfinderb
Syndrome are items used in dentistry to reproduce biting
• History of sharp pain when eating or biting forces on teeth or individual cusp tips, and can
• Sporadic pain be an important part of diagnosing and conser-
• Mild or intense nonlingering sensitivity to vative treatment planning of symptomatic
cold cracked teeth. They can be used in place of
• Absence of heat-induced sensitivity sticks, cotton rolls, or other tooth loading.9 It is
• Absence of radiating, throbbing, or lingering a 2-ended instrument, with a dimpled concave
pain end for placing directly on cusp tips and a
• Occasional pain when grinding teeth or pointed end that can put pressure in a specific
excursive movements area of a fossa.10 The instrument is adept at
• Pain repeated with bite stick, cotton roll, or identifying not only which tooth is sympto-
other clinical loading matic, but more importantly, which part of a
• Tooth segments do not physically separate tooth is causing the pain. Even if transillumi-
during clinical loading nation, photography, or magnification reveals a
• No periapical pathology on radiograph tooth fracture, the clinician must still deter-
• No periodontal pathology with probing, and mine if it is that particular fracture, crack, or
no soft-tissue swelling craze that causes the patient discomfort.
The concave end of the instrument is placed
Lingering, throbbing, or spontaneous, or on each cusp in a suspect quadrant (Figure 1).
radiographic pathology coupled with 1 or more The patient is then asked to close straight onto
of the other symptoms indicates the need for the stick and bite with firm pressure. Then the
root canal therapy.7 If any of the symptoms list- patient response is recorded (Figure 2). When
ed in Table 1 are reported, endodontic therapy loading the symptomatic cusp, the pain is readi-
is indicated and recommended.8 Once the clear ly noticeable by the patient as similar to that
need for endodontic therapy is ruled out, the which is felt when the patient eats or bites.
tooth or cusp causing biting pain should be Every cusp must be loaded methodically so that
located. Orangewood sticks, cotton rolls, burlew an acute diagnosis can be made. Every cusp is
wheels, and many other tools have been used for checked at least twice to verify the sensations;
years to simulate biting pain on a patient.1 the treatment plan should include at least that
The goal of conservative treatment is to keep cusp in the final restoration.
the cracked parts of the tooth from moving apart The pointed end of the instrument is used
from each other and causing pain while preserv- to load each occlusal restoration and every cen-
ing as much natural tooth as possible. Identifying tral fossa to determine if the tooth has a mesial-
a particular cusp or cusps allows the practitioner distal fracture (Figure 3). In the same way, the
to treat the part of the tooth that is causing the patient closes with firm pressure, trying to repli-
pain without reducing the entire tooth. a
Professional Results, Inc, Laguna Niguel, CA 92677; (949) 249-3705
b
Denbur, Oak Brook, IL 60522; (800) 992-1399
Figure 7—Initial preparation included removing the amalgam and Figure 8—After completion of the restoration there was a mini-
reducing only the symptomatic cusps. Caries indicator was then mum of 2 mm clearance in all excursive movements, and all mar-
used and the tooth was inspected for large cracks and decay. gins were rounded shoulders with no internal sharp line angles.
from radiographic and clinical examination. bonding, but the craze lines on the mesial and
distal boxes were left intact because they were
Diagnosis free of caries and well-approximated (Figure 7).
Although the patient was sure which tooth All amalgam, base material, and decay were
was causing the pain, time was taken to load removed and the symptomatic cusps were
every cusp and fossa in the quadrant with the reduced at least 2 mm occlusally to provide
dimpled end of the Tooth Slooth II. The ample clearance for porcelain thickness during
“sharp, stabbing” pain the patient experienced excursive movements (Figure 8). The buccal
during eating was reproduced when both buc- and interproximal margins were rounded shoul-
cal cusps of tooth No. 19 were loaded. Neither ders of about 2 mm to give ample porcelain
of the lingual cusps reproduced the same pain, thickness for resistance to breakage. All inter-
although the pointed end of the Tooth Slooth nal points and angles were rounded to decrease
in the central fossa of the restoration produced stress accumulation within the porcelain.
a similar pain. These cusps were checked again,
with positive results. No other teeth were sen- Treatment
sitive to this testing. There are 3 main choices for Cerec restora-
tive materials: Vita Mark IIg, ProCADc, and
Preparation Paradigm MZ100h. Vita and ProCAD are
The lingual cusps were left in place because porcelains with similar handling, bonding, and
they were asymptomatic and there was at least milling characteristics. ProCAD is very similar
1 mm to 2 mm of healthy dentin supporting the in characteristics to IPS Empressc with similar
enamel. Preparation did not include removing wear to enamel.14 Vita and ProCAD porcelains
healthy tooth structure to obliterate the craze can be polished to a high luster using various
lines on the facial, but to remove any diseased rubber polishing points and brushes. Paradigm
tooth and to cover the symptomatic cusps. is MZ100 composite, which has excellent wear
Drilling away all potential craze lines or cracks and esthetics but may not have the polish dura-
is unnecessary and may induce iatrogenic pulp bility or wear resistance that porcelain has
trauma. The cracks were removed until a sharp when occluding with a porcelain-fused-to-
explorer could not detect the separation of metal crown.15
tooth. This indicated that tooth structure on The prepared tooth was powdered with
both sides of the fracture was well-approximat- titanium dioxide reflecting powder and scan-
ed. Care was taken to remove all decay and old ned into the Cerec computer by the acquisition
restorative material within the tooth for proper unit. In about 5 minutes the restoration design
c
IvoclarVivadent, Amherst, NY 14228; (800) 533-6825 was completed in the Dental Database mode.
d
Nobel Biocare, Yorba Linda, CA 92887; (800) 993-8100 This design mode uses anatomy of adjacent
e
Dentsply/Ceramco, Burlington, NJ 08016; (800)487-0100
f
Sirona USA, Charlotte, NC 28273; (800) 659-5977 teeth and a computer stored library of data to
g
Vita Zahnfabrik, Germany, distributed in US by Patterson, St Paul, MN propose a restoration (Figure 9). The anatomy,
55120; (800) 325-3184
h
3M Espe, St Paul, MO 55144; (800) 634-2249 marginal ridge heights, and contacts were
Figure 9—Cerec “Dental Database” design mode was used. The Figure 10—After operator editing, the restoration was finished
computer proposed this design according to a library of comput- and ready to be milled. A minimum of 1.5 mm to 2 mm of porce-
er data and the anatomy of the adjacent teeth. lain was incorporated into the design for ample porcelain strength.
checked and enhanced and the final restora- for Cerec bonding and has caused virtually no
tion was inspected on the computer screen tooth sensitivity in cases like this. Simplicity
(Figure 10). Milling of Vita Mark IIg porcelain Part 1 primer was applied to damp dentin ac-
was completed in about 20 minutes. This Vita cording to the manufacturer’s directions. Next,
porcelain is reported to have excellent proper- Part 2 bonding agent was applied, air thinned
ties and great esthetics, and to wear opposing well, and cured for 20 seconds. Self-etch adhe-
teeth comparably to enamel.15 sive systems offer several advantages over tradi-
The porcelain was tried in, contacts adjust- tional phosphoric acid etch systems. The smear
ed, and fit verified with very little adjustment. layer is not removed, which may decrease the
A metal Hawe Adapt SuperCap Matrixi was potential for dentinal tubules left open, subse-
used to isolate the tooth and control the flow of quently causing sensitivity.17
the composite luting material to help ensure The Vita porcelain was hydrofluoric acid-
unhindered flossing. A Dry Tipj was placed on etched for 2 minutes, rinsed well, and thor-
the buccal to retract and control parotid mois- oughly dried. Then a silane coupler was applied
ture while a Denta Popk was inserted on the lin- and dried after 10 seconds. Simplicity Part 2
gual of the tooth to allow the patient to relax resin was applied, air dried well, and light-cured
the mandible, keep the patient’s mouth open, for 20 seconds. According to the manufacturer,
and to retract the tongue. FlexiWedgesl were Build-It FRp is a dual-cure, resin build-up mate-
used to secure the matrix and prevent crevicu- rial that has a film thickness of 30 µm. Insureq
lar leakage (Figure 11). and Calibrao are dual-cure resin luting agents
A nonetch dentin bonding system helps with low film thicknesses that work well for
reduce some of the potential causes of postop- porcelain bonding. Unfortunately, they have to
erative bonding sensitivity. Some of the reasons be hand-mixed and cannot be directly injected
why nonetch bonding systems may decrease into the preparation.
iatrogenic sensitivity are: Build-It FR was placed directly into the
• Dentinal smear layer left unviolated matrix from the automix gun (Figure 12). Before
• dentinal tubules are never “unsealed” setting of the luting material, the restoration was
• less chance of gingival bleeding from caustic vibrated into place with a Sonic Flex 2000r hand-
phosphoric acid so less chance of contami- piece with a cementation tip for 5 seconds with
nated margin firm pressure (Figure 13). This sonic vibration
• no chance of leaving phosphoric acid on i
Kerr/Hawe, Orange, CA 92867; (714) 516-7400
tooth after incomplete rinsing j
Molnlycke Health Care, distributed in US by Microscopy, Kennesaw,
GA 30144
• decreased chance of desiccation when using k
Patterson Dental, St Paul, MN 55120; (800) 325-3184
a “moist dentin” bonding system l
Common Sense, Nunica, MI 49448; (888) 853-5773
m
Apex, Sandwich, IL 60548; (877) 273-9123
Simplicitym, Clearfil SE bondn, and Xeno n
Kuraray, New York, NY 10022; (800) 879-1676
III are self-etch dentin adhesives; a separate
o o
Dentsply/Caulk, Milford, DE 19963; (800) 532-2855
p
Pentron, Wallinford, CT 06492-0724; (800) 551-0283
phosphoric acid etch step is not needed.16 In q
Cosmedent, Chicago, IL 60611; (800) 621-6729
the author’s experience, Simplicity works well r
KaVo, Lake Zurich, IL 60047; (888) 528-6872
Figure 11—A matrix was placed on the tooth and secured with Figure 12—Build-It FR is injected directly into the matrix after
wedges. The matrix provides isolation for the tooth and helps ensure the bonding agent is applied and cured.
that the luting agent will not block embrasures and hinder flossing.
Figure 13—A cementation tip on an ultrasonic scaler is used to Figure 14—The restoration following clean up and bite adjust-
ensure complete seating of the restoration and to apply pressure ment. This is followed by anatomy fine tuning with a finishing
to compensate for the thickness of the matrix band. diamond and then polished with rubber points.
helps to ensure complete seating of the restora- copious water. The porcelain was then polished
tion and may reduce the marginal cement line with wet Dialitet cups and points. A final curing
thickness and decrease the chance of voids was done for 10 seconds each from the facial, lin-
under the restoration. gual, and occlusal aspects to ensure complete
The curing light was turned on by the assis- setting of the bonding materials. From start to
tant and handed to the dentist. The tooth was finish, the restoration took a total of 30 minutes
than approached slowly to reduce negative of dentist time and 30 minutes of assistant and
polymerization forces and white lines near the anesthesia time.
margins.18 The first curing lasted 10 seconds
from the occlusolingual with an Optilux 401i Follow-up
and a turbo tip. The band was then loosened At the 2-year recall the patient remained
but not removed; curing was done for 10 to 20 symptom-free, and has had no further sensitiv-
seconds from the facial and lingual. ity to bite or temperature since the restoration
Anatomy directly from the milling machine was placed (Figure 15). After 2 years the mar-
will need fine tuning once the occlusion is gins remained stable, anatomy was very good,
checked in all excursive movements (Figure 14). the color was acceptable, and the buccal craze
The occlusion was adjusted and contours were lines had not increased in size (Figure 16).
refined with a football diamond. The final
anatomy was then placed with a finishing dia- Case 2
mond, and porcelain polishing was initiated A patient presented with a “sharp, stab-
with a white stones, high-speed handpiece, and bing pain” when eating food on one side of the
s
Shofu, San Marcos, CA 92069; (800) 827-4638
mouth, but was unsure from which tooth the
t
Brasseler USA, Savannah, GA 31419; (800) 841-4522 pain was originating. An exam revealed large
Figure 15—After 6-month recall appointment and follow-up for Figure 16—Buccal view more than 2 years after treatment shows
over 2 years, the tooth has remained symptom-free, with no eat- excellent margins, reasonable wear, and no obvious growth of
ing or drinking limitations. buccal craze lines.
Figure 17—Symptomatic tooth with sharp pain when both lin- Figure 18—There are obvious cracks on both mesial and distal
gual cusps were loaded and moderate pain when the restoration marginal ridges. The amalgam shows signs of leakage and has
and central fossa areas were loaded. Some craze lines were decay near its margins.
found on the buccal from the pit amalgam toward the gingival.
“Correlation” is another design mode in
failing amalgam with leaking margins on tooth the Cerec system that allows the practitioner to
No. 19, and a smaller occlusal-buccal amal- copy the anatomical features of the preopera-
gam on tooth No. 18. Several craze lines were tive condition of the tooth. Titanium dioxide
noticed on the facial and lingual, but all tooth powder is applied to the tooth while waiting for
segments seemed to be approximated well profound anesthesia. The non-prepped, pre-
when the explorer passed over them (Figure treatment morphology of the tooth is acquired
17). Larger cracks were seen on the mesial with the Cerec acquisition unit and will be
marginal ridge and the distal marginal ridge copied into the milling of the porcelain. This
and running vertical down the lingual (Fig- design mode is indicated if the preoperative
ure 18). condition of the tooth has adequate occlusal
anatomy, or if a “mock-up” of a broken tooth
Diagnosis has been done. Cusp shapes and heights, mar-
Irreversible pulpitis was ruled out with his- ginal ridge heights, and some buccal and lin-
tory, clinical tests, and radiographs. Percussion gual anatomy are copied into the restoration
with a mouth mirror produced slight sensitivi- well enough that seldom are more than very
ty, and loading with a Tooth Slooth II repro- minimal adjustments needed.
duced the sharp pain on both lingual cusp tips A shallow, fairly conservative amalgam was
of the first molar. The buccal cusps and central removed with a new 330 bur and the tooth was
fossa of the amalgam gave slight loading pain. examined (Figure 19). From the occlusal view a
No other cusps in the quadrant gave a positive mesiodistal crack was not obvious. Sable Seeku
response. Because of the loading pain of all 4 caries indicator was applied. After checking
cusps and the amalgam, they were all treatment twice with the caries indicator, all old restora-
planned for porcelain coverage. tive material and caries were removed, making
Preparation u
Ultradent, South Jordan, UT 84095; (800) 552-5512
Figure 19—The preparation focuses on removing all old filling Figure 20—A preparation with 2 mm clearance and all decay and
material, bases, and liners, and covers any obvious tooth cracks. filling material removed. Note the fracture running from the
mesial to the distal through the lingual cusps.
This article provides 1 hour of CE credit from Ascend Media’s Dental Learning Systems, in association with the University of
Southern California School of Dentistry and the University of Pennsylvania School of Dental Medicine, representatives of which
have reviewed the articles in this issue for acceptance. Record your answers on the enclosed answer sheet or submit them on a sep-
arate sheet of paper. You may also phone your answers in to (888) 596-4605 or fax them to (703) 404-1801. Be sure to include your
name, address, telephone number, and social security number.