Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Intestinal helminths are among the most common infectious organisms of humans, particularly in
tropical regions, and can induce the production of large quantities of IgE antibody. Part of this re-
sponse is directed against the helminths own antigens, but a polyclonal stimulation also occurs that
may increase the allergic reactivity toward environmental allergens. The importance of this in the
symptomatology of asthma in these regions is, however, uncertain. In the present study we evalu-
ated the effect of regular anthelminthic treatment with albendazol for 1 yr on a group of asthmatic
patients in a zone in which these parasites are endemic. The number of asthmatic crises, need for
maintenance therapy with inhaled steroids, and use of inhaled b2-agonists were compared both with
those in the year prior to the study for the treated patients, and with those in a group of asthmatic
subjects evaluated in parallel, but in whom the parasitic infections were not controlled. Significant
improvement in all of these indicators of clinical status occurred in the treated group, not only for the
period of anthelminth administration, but also for the year following. However, after 2 yr without
treatment, the severity of asthma reverted to the initial state. No significant changes were observed
in the control group over the entire period of evaluation. At the beginning of the study, the patients’
pulmonary function was below the levels predicted for normal individuals, but this was not changed
by the anthelminthic treatment. The patients’ total serum IgE levels, which were elevated at the be-
ginning of the study, were significantly diminished by the anthelminth administration, as were the
specific IgE antibody levels and positivity in skin tests for immediate hypersensitivity to the common
environmental allergen Dermatophagoides sp. However, the specific response to Ascaris lumbricoides,
a common helminth in the area, was maintained despite treatment. These results indicate that intes-
tinal helminthic infections can contribute to the clinical symptoms of asthma in an endemic situation.
This may occur via a direct response to the parasite and/or a nonspecific potentiation of allergic reac-
tivity to environmental allergens. Lynch NR, Palenque M, Hagel I, DiPrisco MC. Clinical improve-
ment of asthma after anthelminthic treatment in a tropical situation.
AM J RESPIR CRIT CARE MED 1997;156:50–54.
Helminthic parasites provide particularly potent stimuli for tion of IgE synthesis (8, 9). Helminthic infections of low inten-
the synthesis of IgE antibody (1), and the existence of allergic- sity can nonspecifically potentiate the synthesis of IgE anti-
type reactivity to these organisms is well recognized (2). In ad- body against environmental allergens, and thus enhance
dition, immediate hypersensitivity skin-test reactions to ex- allergic reactivity (10–13). In contrast, the excess polyclonal
tracts of these parasites are very common in situations in IgE stimulated by more intense helminthic infection can sup-
which such infections are endemic (3). For a number of years, press the allergic response by producing mast-cell saturation
however, controversy has surrounded both the possible in- (14) and inhibition of specific IgE antibody synthesis (3, 7). In
volvement of helminthic infection in the pathogenesis of respi- previous studies, we have demonstrated a direct relation be-
ratory disease (4–6) and its influence on the prevalence of al- tween helminthic infection and pulmonary function. Thus,
lergic conditions in the tropical environment (3, 7). This may bronchial challenge with helminth extracts can induce bron-
be at least partly due to the ability of these parasites to also choconstriction in clinically asthmatic children in areas in which
cause an interleukin-4 (IL-4)-dependent polyclonal stimula- helminthic infection is endemic (15). Also, nonasthmatic chil-
dren in such areas can respond significantly to bronchodilator
(Received in original form June 19, 1996 and in revised form March 10, 1997)
inhalation, and this response can be reversed by anthelminthic
treatment (16). Moreover, parasite eradication can produce a
Supported by Consejo Nacional de Investigación Cientifica y Tecnológica RPV
170041, Consejo de Desarrollo Cientifica y Humanistica/Universidad Central de reactivation of allergic reactivity toward common environmen-
Venezuela, Congreso de la Republica/Ministerio de Educación/UCV, World Bank tal allergens in children in whom this is suppressed by exces-
grant VEN/96/002/14, and grant SD.000.0309 from Astra-Draco, Sweden. sively polyclonal IgE (17).
Correspondence and requests for reprints should be addressed to Dr. Neil Lynch, Considering the complexity of the possible influence of hel-
Instituto de Biomedicina, Aptdo. 4043, Carmelitas, Caracas, 1010A, Venezuela. minthic infection on allergic reactivity, we evaluated in the
Am J Respir Crit Care Med Vol. 156. pp. 50–54, 1997 present study the effect of regular and prolonged anthelmin-
Lynch, Palenque, Hagel, et al.: Helminthic Infection and Asthma 51
TABLE 1
EFFECT OF ANTHELMINTHIC TREATMENT ON THE CONTROL OF ASTHMA
Control of Asthma*
Immunologic Evaluation significant changes were found in these parameters in the un-
Skin-prick tests for immediate hypersensitivity were performed with treated control group. Of the 39 anthelminth-treated patients,
extracts of Dermatophagoides pteronyssinus and A. lumbricoides, and 35 were followed for a further 2 yr (Years 2 and 3), during
as a positive control, with 1% (wt/vol) histamine. Wheal diameters of which time the anthelminth was not administered. Table 1
> 3 mm were considered positive. Total IgE levels were measured shows that the severity of the asthma continued to decline
with the Phadebas radioimmunosorbent test (PRIST) (Pharmacia, during Year 2, but that it reverted to the initial levels in Year
Uppsala, Sweden), and expressed as IU/ml. Levels of IgE for the fore- 3. We should note here that the four patients who were lost to
going allergens were measured with the Phadebas radioallergosorbent
long-term follow-up were not remarkable in the severity of
(RAST) test, and expressed as Phadebas RAST units/ml (PRU/ml).
As suggested by the manufacturers of the test, values > 0.7 PRU/ml
their asthma during Year 1. In Table 2 we present the fre-
(RAST Level 2) were considered positive. quency distribution of asthmatic crises in the 35 anthelminth-
treated patients who were evaluated over the entire 4-yr pe-
Statistical Analysis riod. It can be seen that before the anthelminth treatment
Owing to a high degree of dispersion of the values of most of the contin- (Year 0), the therapeutic regimen used by the asthma clinic re-
uous variables measured, nonparametric statistical tests (one-way anal- sulted in the symptoms being well controlled in 60% of the pa-
ysis of variance [ANOVA], Wilcoxon’s test) were applied, using the In- tients, moderately controlled in 28%, and poorly controlled in
Stat program of Graphpad Software (San Diego, CA). For convenience 12%. For the year following the period of anthelminth admin-
of presentation, the means 6 SEM are shown in the tables. Frequency istration (Year 2), these percentages were 80%, 17%, and 3%,
analyses of discrete variables were performed with the chi-square test. respectively (p , 0.01).
RESULTS Pulmonary Function
Parasitologic Evaluation The pulmonary function of the anthelminth-treated and con-
At the beginning of the study, 41% of the entire group of pa- trol groups was measured immediately prior to the beginning
tients were found to be infected with helminths. The predomi- of the study (Year 0) and at the end of Year 1. The spiromet-
nant parasites were Trichuris trichiura (26%) and Ascaris lum- ric results were expressed as percentages of the predicted val-
bricoides (23%). Infections were detected at some time in six ues, and in Table 3 it can be seen that no significant changes
of the anthelminth-treated patients during Year 1 of the study. were detected in either group. The FEV1/FVC ratios were also
unchanged (mean 6 SD of the treated group: 76 6 8% in
Clinical Status Year 0 and 80 6 10% in Year 1). We should note here that pa-
Owing to the low level of literacy and medical awareness of
the study group, we chose three criteria, that depended di-
rectly or indirectly on the asthma clinic, to estimate the clinical
TABLE 2
status of the patients. These were: (1) the number of months
per year that maintenance therapy with beclomethasone was FREQUENCY OF ASTHMATIC CRISES IN 35
ANTHELMINTH-TREATED PATIENTS
administered; (2) the number of metered-dose inhalers (MDI)
of salbutamol that were used electively by the patients to con- Year*
trol symptoms; and (3) the number of times the patients re- †
No. of crises/yr 0 1 2 3
quired attention in the asthma clinic for episodes that did not
respond adequately to the b2-agonist. The results of this analy- ,3 21‡ 25 28 24
sis are presented in Table 1, where it can be seen that during 3–12 10 8 6 6
. 12 4 2 1 5
the year of anthelminth treatment (Year 1), there were statis-
tically significant decreases in the number of months of main- * Year 0 5 year prior to study. Year 1 5 year of anthelminth administration. Year 2
tenance treatment (p , 0.01), the number of asthmatic crises and 3 5 the first and second posttreatment years.
†
Number of asthmatic episodes per year that required outpatient attention.
(p , 0.001), and the number of MDIs used (p , 0.001) as com- ‡
Number of patients. Only the 35 patients who were followed for 3 yr are consid-
pared with the year prior to the study (Year 0). In contrast, no ered.
Lynch, Palenque, Hagel, et al.: Helminthic Infection and Asthma 53
of the patients were selected for the maximum possible objec- 4. Turner, K. J. 1980. Is the prevalence of allergy related to parasitic dis-
tivity in a study of this nature. Possibly because at the begin- ease? In A. Oehling, editor. Advances in Allergology and Immunol-
ogy. Pergamon Press, Oxford. 279–287.
ning of the study the pulmonary function of the patients, as
5. Grove, D. I. 1982. What is the relationship between asthma and worms?
determined by spirometry, was not profoundly abnormal, the Allergy 37:139–148.
clinical improvement of the treated group was not accompa- 6. Moqbel, R., and D. I. Pritchard. 1990. Parasites and allergy: evidence for
nied by evident changes in measurements of pulmonary func- a “cause and effect” relationship. Clin. Exp. Allergy 20:611–618.
tion. In this respect, other studies have also shown that asth- 7. Lynch, N. R. 1992. Influence of socio-economic level on helminthic in-
matic patients in remission do not necessarily have normal fection and allergic reactivity in tropical countries. In R. Moqbel, edi-
tor. Allergy and Immunity to Helminths: Common Mechanisms or Di-
spirometric values (24). Of possible relevance here is a ten-
vergent Pathways? Taylor & Francis, London. 51–62.
dency that we observed in the treated group toward a lower 8. Finkelman, F., E. Pearce, J. Urban, and A. Sher. 1991. Regulation and
pulmonary sensitivity to histamine challenge, which is an indi- biological function of helminth-induced cytokine responses. Immunol.
cator of BHR. As can occur in viral infection (25), the pres- Today 12:A62–A66.
ence of helminth-derived products, either in the blood or oc- 9. King, C. L., C. C. Low, and T. B. Nutman. 1993. IgE production in hu-
curring during larval migration, may produce inflammation man helminth infection. J. Immunol. 150:1873–1880.
10. Turner, K. J., L. Feddma, and E. H. Quinn. 1979. Non-specific potentia-
and thus increase airway irritability (26, 27). Another factor to
tion of IgE by parasitic infections in man. Int. Arch. Allergy Appl. Im-
be considered is that the tables of predicted values for spiro- munol. 58:232–236.
metric parameters commonly used in Venezuela, which are 11. Joubert, J. R., D. J. Van Schalkwyk, and K. J. Turner. 1980. Ascaris lum-
based on a Spanish sample group (20), may not have been the bricoides and the human immunogenic response: enhanced IgE-medi-
most suitable for our study population. Because “normal” val- ated reactivity to common inhaled allergens. S. Afr. Med. J. 57:409–
ues have not been determined for persons of low socioeco- 412.
12. Lynch, N. R., and M. C. DiPrisco. 1984. High allergic reactivity in a trop-
nomic level in developing countries, where concurrent infec-
ical environment. Clin. Allergy 14:233–240.
tions and nutritional problems could be important variables, 13. Buijs, J., G. Borsboom, J. J. van Gemund, A. Hazebroek, P. A. van Don-
we are unable to make firm statements on this point. gen, F. van Knapen, and H. Neijens. 1994. Toxocara seroprevalence
From the immunologic viewpoint, because the intensity of in 5-year-old elementary schoolchildren: relation with allergic asthma.
helminthic infection in our study population is relatively low, Am. J. Epidemiol. 140:839–847.
we can predict that these parasites would cause both signifi- 14. Godfrey, R. C., and C. F. Gradidge. 1976. Allergic sensitisation of hu-
man lung fragments prevented by saturation of IgE binding sites. Na-
cant increases in total IgE levels and a potentiation of the al-
ture 259:484–486.
lergic response to environmental allergens. The effects of the 15. Lynch, N. R., G. Istúriz, Y. Sánchez, M. Pérez, A. Martínez, and M.
anthelminthic treatment in our study indicated that this is in- Castés. 1992. Bronchial challenge of tropical asthmatics with Ascaris
deed the case, as the total serum IgE levels, which at the be- lumbricoides. J. Invest. Allergol. Clin. Immunol. 2:97–105.
ginning of the study were moderately elevated, decreased sig- 16. Lynch, N. R., I. Hagel, M. Pérez, M. DiPrisco, N. Alvarez, and E. Rojas.
nificantly, as did the allergic reactivity to Dermatophagoides, 1992. Bronchoconstriction in helminthic infection. Int. Arch. Allergy
Immunol. 98:77–79.
one of the predominant allergens in the tropical environment.
17. Lynch, N. R., I. Hagel, M. Pérez, M. DiPrisco, R. López, and N. Alvarez.
Further studies will, however, be required to determine the 1993. Effect of anthelmintic treatment on the allergic reactivity of
degree to which this change contributed to the clinical im- children in a tropical slum. J. Allergy Clin. Immunol. 92:404–411.
provement of the treated patients. Of interest is our observa- 18. DIASPER. 1986. Informe Social 3, Sistema de indicadores sociales para
tion that the specific response to Ascaris, one of the most com- un diagnóstico social permanente. Caracas, CORDIPLAN.
mon intestinal helminths on the island on which our study was 19. American Thoracic Society. 1987. Standardization of spirometry—1987
update. Am. Rev. Respir. Dis. 136:1285–1298.
conducted, was maintained during the year of anthelminth ad-
20. Cobos, N. 1979. Valores de predicción en función pulmonar. Arch.
ministration. This probably occurred because: (1) the patients Bronco. Neumonol. 15:64–70.
received continual immunologic stimuli in the intestine through 21. Cockcroft, D. W., D. N. Killian, J. J. Mellon, and F. E. Hargreave. 1977.
the ingestion of infective eggs; and (2) because the specific re- Bronchial reactivity to inhaled histamine: a method and clinical sur-
sponse to parasite antigens is relatively independent of the vey. Clin. Allergy 7:235–243.
polyclonal stimulus, particularly in persons with an atopic dis- 22. Tanaka, K., H. Kawamura, N. Tohgi, M. Tsuji, Y. Miyachi, and A. Mi-
yoshi. 1983. The measurement of Ascaris suum protein by radioimmu-
position (unpublished observations). In fact, as the IgE response noassay in sera from patients with helminthiasis and with gastrointes-
can participate in protective mechanisms against helminthic tinal disease. Parasitology 86:291–300.
infection (6, 28, 29), it can be proposed that the allergic geno- 23. Istúriz, G. 1987. Etiopatogenia del asma de base inmunológica. Neumos.
type has been conserved in evolution because of the more ef- 5:35–39.
fective antiparasitic IgE response that it confers. 24. Perin, P. V., D. Weldon, and S. J. McGeady. 1994. Respiratory patho-
In conclusion, the results of this study are consistent with physiologic responses: objective indicators of severity of asthma. J. Al-
lergy Clin. Immunol. 94:517–522.
the possibility that helminthic infection can contribute to the 25. Bjornsdottir, U. S., and W. W. Busse. 1992. Respiratory infections and
symptomatology of asthma in an endemic situation, and that asthma. Med. Clin. North Am. 76:895–915.
this could occur both through a direct effect of the parasite 26. Kay, A. B., R. Moqbel, S. R. Durham, A. J. MacDonald, G. M. Walsh,
and through the nonspecific potentiation of allergic reactivity R. J. Shaw, O. Cromwell, and J. A. Mackay. 1985. Leucocyte activa-
toward environmental allergens. tion initiated by IgE dependent mechanisms in relation to helminthic
parasitic disease and clinical models of asthma. Int. Arch. Allergy Im-
munol. 77:69–72.
References 27. Askenase, P. W. 1992. Delayed-type hypersensitivity recruitment of T
1. Jarrett, E. E., and H. R. Miller. 1982. Production and activities of IgE in cell subsets via antigen-specific non-IgE factors or IgE antibodies: rel-
helminth infection. In P. Kallós, editor. Immunity and Concomitant evance to asthma, autoimmunity and immune responses to tumors
Immunity in Infectious Diseases, Vol. 31: Progress in Allergy. Karger, and parasites. Chem. Immunol. 54:166–211.
Basel. 178–233. 28. Hagel, I., N. R. Lynch, M. C. DiPrisco, E. Rojas, M. Pérez, and N. Alva-
2. Lynch, N. R. 1987. Immediate hypersensitivity (allergic) reactions to in- rez. 1993. Ascaris reinfection of slum children: relation with the IgE
testinal helminthic infections. Baillières Clin. Trop. Med. Commun. response. Clin. Exp. Immunol. 94:80–83.
Dis. 2:573–593. 29. Capron, A., J. P. Dessaint, and M. Capron. 1992. Allergy and immune
3. Hagel, I., N. R. Lynch, M. C. DiPrisco, R. López, and N. García. 1993. defence: common IgE-dependent mechanisms or divergent pathways.
Allergic reactivity of children of different socioeconomic levels in In R. Moqbel, editor. Allergy and Immunity to Helminths: Common
tropical populations. Int. Arch. Allergy Immunol. 101:209–214. Mechanisms or Divergent Pathways? Taylor & Francis, London. 1–16.