three sections have shown that geographical and social patterns of poverty are
constructed by processes which are simultaneously social and geographical.
12.7. Political action of the poor and its geography
In the previous three sections we have dwelt on the powerful social-geographical causes
of poverty, But these have been contested, We have seen that national and local politics
can affect poverty in important ways — through constructing terntorial regimes, or
through carrying through strategies such as neoliberalism. These politics are created
through conflicts and compromises between all social groups (see Chapter 2, sections
2.5 and 2.7). However, the political activity of the poor themselves is also important —
the poor are far from being passive victims,
As poverty is multi-faceted, the focuses for campaigns against poverty have been very
varied, as have the sections of the poor conducting these struggles. Trade unions,
especially those which have most of their members in low-paid jobs, have fought for
improvement of poor jobs, or, in recent decades, have attempted to resist their
worsening. Sometimes these battles have been conducted by workers in a particular
workplace, particularly when faced with deterioration of conditions or redundancy.
Particularly exploited groups of workers such as homeworkers have organized at local
and national levels to attempt to secure basic employment rights. Organizations of
groups strongly dependent on state benefits, particularly pensioners and social security
claimants, have campaigned for benefits to be raised above the poverty level. Pensioners
in general have had stronger and more stable organizations than claimants, But the latter
have conducted some powerful campaigns: in France in 1998-9, for example,
occupations of social security offices across the country won concessions from the
government. increases in the tax burden of the poor can elicit militant ad hoe
organization. When the British government in 1990-I introduced a poll tax which
shifted local taxation sharply from the rich to the peor, millions of poor people refused
to pay it and there were militant demonstrations. This resistance resulted in major
reform of the tax (and contributed to the departure of Margaret Thatcher as prime
minister). People with disabilities have campaigned against their commonly experienced
poverty on meny fronts: for better access to paid employment, for better support from
public services, and for changes to the built environment.
Much organization against poverty has been concerned with reproduction at the
neighbourhood scale (compare with section 12.5). Residents’ groups in poor areas have
campaigned for improvements in public and private services or against their
deterioration Fasenfest, 1993). Communities have a'so organized to provide services for
themselves: child care clubs, credit unions, and community businesses, such as repair
enterprises, are examples. While these start from self-help, they usually also make
demands for state financial support, and sometimes, as with credit unions, put political
pressure on service providers in the public or private sector (Fuller and Jonas, 2000)
Many poor communities have campaigned against pollution of their environments. Poor
218
8
x
z
8
<
3
¢
<specifically, access to transport and means of communication. This is another reason why
much organization is at the neighbourhood level. While this takes strength from the
immediacy of the issues and from bonds of friendship and trust, it is weakened by its
particularity: struggles around a particular issue can be repeated around the county at
different times with little or no co-operation or synergy between the campaigns.
However, in many fields of anti-poverty campaigning there are networks of local groups.
These may start by giving advice to local campaigns, but can develop into nationally co-
ordinated campaigns, as with the claimants’ organizations in France or the association of
outer city estates in Britain, On the other hand, campaigns over issues which are the
remit of national government, such as benefits, taxation and employment law, can
develop from the first at the national level. Finally, in recent years some transnational
campaigns of the poor have emerged, such as the Marches for Jobs in the EU. These are
to a large extent a response to the similarities between countries in the worsening of
poverty by neoliberalism, as well as the implementation of neoliberal measures by the
EU itself. Scales of organization against poverty, then, are as varied and as interlinked as
the scales of its creation,
12.8 Conclu:
Human geography and other social sciences have much to contribute to the fight against
nm
poverty. Social geography can contribute particularly by showing the complex scales and
spaces within which poverty is created, and the way in which policies against poverty
may be weakened or strengthened by such geographies. We hope that many readers of
this book will use their understanding of geography both to help develop state policies
against poverty and to support the organizations and struggles of the poor themselves
Summary
+ Poverty has traditionally been conceived in either absolute or relative terms, Recent
approaches often take a hybrid approach, and picture poverty as having many
dimensions beyond low monetary income. These definitions of poverty are
contentious and are used politically
+ Explanations of poverty are diverse. They differ in the aspects of society and the
spatial scale focused on. They include individualist, community and structural
explanations. We have argued that the latter is the strongest approach.
+ Poor-quallty jobs play a central role in creating poverty and its geography. These jobs
are generated by fundamental features of capitalist economies and class relations
+ Poverty is spatially concentrated in particular residential areas. Social life and public
and private services in these areas deepen poverty, and exacerbate the
marginalization of poor people in the labour market
+ Inaddition to class, other forms of social oppression and their operation in space play
central roles in creating poverty, particularly racism, gender, age and disability.
275Introducing Social Geographies
Economic, social, cultural and political processes at all spatial scales, from the
individual and the home to the nation and the world, play roles in creating poverty.
Processes within places where poverty is concentrated play a role in deepening it
But poverty is not generated by geography in itself, but by processes which are
simultaneously geographical and social
+ Varied groups of the poor organize against diverse aspects of poverty, These
organizations use place-specific social networks, but also organize across large scale
spaces.
Further reading
The following two publications give overviews of geographies of poverty:
+ Leyshon, A. (1995) Missing words: whatever happened to the geography of poverty?
Environment and Planning A 27, 1021-8.
+ Philo, C. (2000) Poverty, In Johnston, RJ. et al, Dictionary of Human Geography, 4th edn,
Oxford: Blackwell, pp. 627-9,
For examples of different approaches to poverty definition and explanation, and its manifestation
in different environments, see:
+ Philo, C. (1998) Offthe Map: The Social Geography of Poverty in the UK. London: Child Poverty
Action Group.
+ Merifield, A. and Swyngedouw, E. (1996) (eds) The Urbanization of Injustce. London
Lawrence & Wishart.
+ Kodras, | E. (1997) The cl
anging map of American poverty in an era of economic restructuring
and politcal reaignment. Economic Geography 73, 67-95.
+ Pacione, M. (ed) (1997) Brtain’s Cites. London: Routledge.
276