Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
PII: S0020-7489(16)30131-6
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/doi:10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2016.08.014
Reference: NS 2812
To appear in:
Please cite this article as: Diallo, Ana F., Cong, Xiaomei, Henderson, Wendy A.,
McGrath, Jacqueline, Management of childhood diarrhea by healthcare professionals
in low income countries: An integrative review.International Journal of Nursing Studies
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2016.08.014
This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication.
As a service to our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript.
The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof
before it is published in its final form. Please note that during the production process
errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that
apply to the journal pertain.
1
An integrative review
1
University of Connecticut, School of Nursing, Storrs, Connecticut, USA
2
National Institute of Nursing Research, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD, USA
3
Connecticut Children’s Medical Center, Hartford, Connecticut, USA
Abstract
Background: The significant drop in child mortality due to diarrhea has been primarily
attributed to the use of oral rehydration solutions, continuous feeding and zinc supplementation.
Nevertheless uptake of these interventions have been slow in developing countries and many
children suffering from diarrhea are not receiving adequate care according to the World Health
Organization recommended guidelines for the clinical management of childhood diarrhea.
Objectives: The aim of this integrative review is to appraise healthcare professionals'
management of childhood diarrhea in low-income countries.
Design: Whittemore and Knafl integrative review method was used, in conjunction with the
Reporting of Observational Studies in Epidemiology (STROBE) checklist for reporting
observational cohort, case control and cross sectional studies.
Method: A comprehensive search performed from December 2014 to April 2015 used five
databases and focused on observational studies of healthcare professional's management of
childhood diarrhea in low-income countries.
Results: A total of 21 studies were included in the review. Eight studies used a survey design
while three used some type of simulated client survey referring to a fictitious case of a child with
diarrhea. Retrospective chart reviews were used in one study. Only one study used direct
observation of the healthcare professionals during practice and the remaining eight used a
combination of research designs. Studies were completed in South East Asia (n = 13), Sub-
Saharan Africa (n = 6) and South America (n = 2).
Conclusion: Studies report that healthcare providers have adequate knowledge of the etiology of
diarrhea and the severe signs of dehydration associated with diarrhea. More importantly,
regardless of geographical settings and year of study publication, inconsistencies were noted in
healthcare professionals' physical examination, prescription of oral rehydration solutions,
antibiotics and other medications as well as education provided to the primary caregivers.
Factors other than knowledge about diarrhea were shown to significantly influence prescriptive
behaviors of healthcare professionals. This review demonstrates that "knowledge is not enough"
to ensure the appropriate use of oral rehydration solutions, zinc and antibiotics by healthcare
professionals in the management of childhood diarrhea.
Keywords: antibiotics use; childhood diarrhea; healthcare providers; low income countries;
prescribing behaviors; oral rehydration therapy; World Health Organization; clinical
management of childhood diarrhea.
3
1-Introduction
Ranked as the second leading cause of death in children under the age of 5, diarrhea is
responsible for approximately 578 000 deaths and 1.7 billion reported episodes each year (Liu et
al., 2015). Beginning in 1978, diarrheal-control programs led by the World Health Organization
(WHO), focused on the promotion of safe drinking water and oral rehydration solutions (ORS) in
conjunction with continued feeding (Fontaine et al., 2009). By 1988, more than 100 countries
adopted diarrheal diseases control programs following the WHO recommendation that focuses
on the promotion of oral rehydration solutions as a major aspect of management (WHO, 1989).
Diarrhea-control programs have been reported to account for substantial reductions in childhood
mortality due to diarrhea, decreasing by 20.8% between 2000 and 2013 in South Asia and by
16.8% in Sub-Saharan African during the same period (Lui et al., 2015).
As of 2004, the WHO updated its childhood diarrhea management guidelines with a new oral
demonstrated that the reduced osmolarity of oral rehydration was safer than the original oral
rehydration solutions and decreased stool output by 20% (Hahn, Kim & Garner, 2002). Oral zinc
supplementation is recommended for 10 to 14 days at 20mg per day in children 6 months and
older and 10mg per day in those younger than 6 months (WHO, 2005). It is important to note
that the guidelines included the prescription of antibiotic therapy only in cases of bloody diarrhea
or cholera.
Despite the success of the early diarrhea-control programs and the updated WHO guidelines,
many children under the age of 5 do not receive adequate treatment during an episode of
diarrhea. Recent reports indicated that only 40% of children suffering from diarrhea worldwide
received oral rehydration or increased fluid intake with continued feeding as part of their
4
management (United Nations Children’s Fund, 2013). This increase is only 10% greater
(approximately) than the 1995 global percentage of children under 5 years who received oral
The unchanged rate of use of oral rehydration solutions over the past two decades has been
linked to the diversion of international funding toward malaria and AIDS after the incorporation
(Fontaine et al., 2009). Management of diarrhea programs were moved down in the priority list
of national and international institutions. This is despite the fact that diarrhea causes more deaths
than AIDS, malaria and measles combined (United Nations Children’s Fund / World Health
training and community programming specific to diarrhea management (Fontaine et al., 2009).
Healthcare professionals (mainly physicians, pharmacists, midwives and nurses) at the public
and private levels play an important role in the management of childhood diarrhea. Recent
studies performed in South India and Sub-Saharan Africa have shown that, regardless of
receiving formal diarrhea management training, healthcare professionals treating children with
diarrhea tended to prescribe more antibiotics, injections and anti-diarrheal medications than oral
rehydration solutions and zinc (Pathak, Pathak, Marrone, Diwan, & Lundborg, 2011; Sood &
Wagner, 2014). Efforts are therefore needed to evaluate healthcare professionals’ clinical
The purpose of this integrative review is to evaluate the clinical practice of healthcare
professionals in the management of diarrhea in children. The study will answer the following
research question: What has been healthcare professionals’ management of childhood diarrhea
5
in low income countries between 1988 and 2014? The ultimate goal of the study is to explore the
clinical practice of healthcare professionals, as it occurs in the natural settings over the years and
across geographical settings. A synthesis of observational studies, completed between 1988 and
2014, will strengthen the literature and provide a broad picture of the magnitude of the problem
in the most affected regions of the world. Recommendations for how best to change practice will
also be discussed.
2-Method
Due to the global reach of the WHO guidelines, physicians’ and other advanced health workers’
training manuals for the treatment of diarrhea published in 1984 and 2004 were used to guide the
literature search. According to the manuals, healthcare care professionals’ training should be
based on three major elements: a fundamental knowledge about diarrhea; the assessment of the
clinical signs and symptoms presented by a child with diarrhea; and the clinical management
based on the different types of diarrhea. Observational studies reporting on at least two or more
diarrhea following the WHO guidelines were included. The measured outcomes were: 1)
healthcare professionals’ knowledge about childhood diarrhea and assessment of the dangerous
signs and symptoms; 2) the prescription of oral rehydration solutions, antibiotics and other drugs
Healthcare professionals were defined as any individual with some medical or pharmacological
training, including physicians, pharmacists, nurses and midwives. The review was restricted to
studies performed in low-income countries as defined by the World Bank (World Bank Group,
6
2014). The literature search included studies published between 1988, when most national
programs for the control of diarrheal diseases were established, and 2014, published in English.
Exclusion criteria were: studies reporting infections other than those causing diarrheal diseases in
children; and studies focusing only on drug therapies and the management of a population of
A comprehensive literature search was performed using five databases between December 2014
and April 2015. The databases were PubMed, CINAHL, Scopus, World Health Organization
Global Health Library and CAB Direct. The following keywords, MeSH terms and headings
prescribing patterns, knowledge attitude and practice, attitude of health personnel, physicians’
practice patterns, health care providers, healthcare professionals, nurses, midwives, physicians,
and preschool. In addition, references in retrieved articles and other related reviews were
3- Results
A total of 4,125 articles were retrieved using the different combinations of keywords, MeSH
terms and headings. Setting the limitations to years of publications between 1988 and 2015,
3,222 articles remained. After screening the abstracts, 2,971 publications were excluded
primarily because they were duplicates and did not focus on management of childhood diarrhea
7
by healthcare professionals. An additional 230 articles were removed from the review because of
their study designs or because they were conducted in a country that was not defined by the
World Bank as a low-income country. Finally, a total of 21 studies were included in the review.
Data analysis was completed following the Whittemore and Knafl (2005) method of integrative
(STROBE) checklist was used for evaluation of the studies’ findings, data extraction and
organization.
The selected publications were observational studies and reported on healthcare professionals’
management of childhood diarrhea in low-income countries. Eight studies used a survey design
while three used some type of simulated client survey, in which a member of the research team
approached healthcare professionals with a fictitious case of a child with diarrhea. Retrospective
chart reviews were used in one study. Only one study used direct observation of the healthcare
professionals during practice. The remaining eight used a combination of research designs.
The study samples varied and included one or more healthcare professional groups. Of the 21
while only one study included nurses and nurse midwives as research respondents (Figure 3).
Completed both in urban and rural settings between 1989 and 2014, these 21 studies were
representative of the three continents accounting for the highest proportion of children suffering
of diarrhea: East Asia (n = 13), Sub-Saharan Africa (n = 6) and South America (n = 2). Further
Since the study sample differs in many aspects (e.g., geography, time, study population, research
setting), the analysis needed to be based on a generalized approach allowing incorporation of all
the diverse features of the selected studies. The WHO training manuals for the treatment of
8
childhood diarrhea (WHO, 1984; WHO, 2005) were considered the reference for the formulation
of many national guidelines on the clinical management of diarrhea in children worldwide. The
analysis was therefore based on the essential elements of the clinical management of childhood
The training manuals were used to ensure an analytical approach that controlled for the diversity
of the study sample and led to the focus on three major outcomes. In addition to the initial
predetermined outcomes, a frequent theme emerged from the analysis and led to a fourth
outcome measure. These outcomes are: 1) healthcare providers’ knowledge about childhood
diarrhea and assessment of the dangerous signs and symptoms; 2) the prescription of oral
rehydration solutions, antibiotics and other drugs for the clinical management; 3) the prescription
of zinc supplementation; and 4) factors affecting prescribing behaviors. The outcomes are
presented in a chronological manner to compare and contrast management before and after the
2004 World Health Organization guidelines. This approach allows identification of changes in
In most studies, healthcare professionals’ knowledge about diarrhea was assessed at three levels:
1) the most common cause of diarrhea in children; 2) assessment of signs of severe dehydration;
etiology of diarrheal diseases and the most frequent signs of severe dehydration. Viral infections
were reported as the most common cause of diarrheal diseases in children (Berih, McIntyre, &
Lynk, 1989; Kanungo et al., 2014; Paredes, de la Pena, Flores-Guerra, Diaz, & Trostle, 1996). In
a survey study, Okeke et al. (1996) examined the knowledge of, attitudes toward and practices
with oral rehydration solutions in 91 medical providers in the state of Enugu, Nigeria. A majority
of medical providers (74%) identified the most common cause of diarrhea in children to be of
viral origin. The next most common etiology reported by the providers was bacterial (20%), then
In a more recent publication, knowledge of diarrhea and its management was also evaluated in
physicians working in the slums of Kolkata (Kanungo et al., 2014). The majority of the
participants (59.47%) cited viruses as the most common diarrheagenic pathogens (Kanungo et
al., 2014). Participating physicians recognized that the most frequent episodes of diarrhea in
children were caused by viruses. The same physicians acknowledged that, except for cases of
severe or bloody diarrhea, antimicrobial therapy was not necessary for the treatment of the
diarrhea (Kanungo et al., 2014; Paredes et al., 1996).The viral origin of the most frequent cases
of childhood diarrhea was reported by healthcare professionals before and after 2004 in countries
Assessment of signs of severe dehydration. While the results of the studies indicate that the
majority of the healthcare professionals could correctly define the most common causes of
diarrhea and identify diarrhea’s dangerous signs, inconsistencies were found in the questions
asked in health histories and physical examination characteristics. Berih et al. (1989) evaluated
the prescribing behaviors of pharmacists in Sudan using a research team member with a fictitious
10
case of a child suffering from diarrhea. The authors reported that out of 63 pharmacists, 40
(63.5%) did not perform a health history before recommending a treatment plan for the child
(Berih et al., 1989). Interestingly, pharmacists who asked at least one question pertinent to the
child’s symptoms, more frequently made referrals to a physician and were less likely to
These results are consistent with findings reported by Beria and colleagues (1998). In their study,
the authors reviewed medical reports to explore physicians’ prescribing behaviors for childhood
diarrhea in parts of Brazil. The authors found that 98% of physicians (n = 54) completed a health
history. At least 65% of the physicians performed a physical examination to assess for other
signs of severe dehydration. However, assessing or asking about the presence of blood in the
stool, for example, did not occur regularly. They found that only 22% of the surveyed physicians
checked for the presence of blood in the stool (Beria, Damiani, dos Santos, & Lombardi, 1998).
Inconsistencies in health history practices appeared to exist over time and in varied geographical
settings. They appear to be related with providers’ training and experiences. In a more recent
pharmacists who could sell antibiotics without prescriptions (type I) and pharmacies not required
to employ registered pharmacists and could only sell over-the-counter drugs (type II). In type I,
55.2% pharmacists asked questions specific to the child’s history. However, in type II
pharmacies, only 21.1% of the personnel in these pharmacies took a history of the child’s
Studies’ results indicate that healthcare professionals with a higher level of training are more
likely to assess signs of severe dehydration in children with diarrhea compared to those who did
11
not receive advanced training. Regardless of the professionals’ level of training, dates of the
studies’ publication and study sites’ locations, these studies documented that assessments of
severe signs of diarrhea and physical examinations were not performed at every encounter.
mostly occurs at home, and adequate care is ensured when caregivers receive the correct
education on dosage and preparation of oral rehydration solutions and continued feeding
the hospital and community level. Therefore, healthcare professionals’ knowledge of diarrhea
and its correct treatment is a safeguard for the appropriate management of the condition in
Overall, healthcare providers’ education related to home nutritional management for diarrhea
was reported to be “unclear” across the study findings. In a study completed by Paredes et al.
(1996), mothers described physicians’ instructions for continuous feeding to be vague. Out of 44
health professionals surveyed, only four prescribed oral rehydration solutions with correct
prescription instructions (Paredes et al., 1996). All but one of the 44 physicians recommended
continued exclusive breastfeeding for children under three months and diluted bottle milk for
In another recent study, Alam and colleagues (2003) evaluated rural medical practitioners’
diarrhea. While 79.4% of observed healthcare providers advised the caregivers on home
rehydration management, only 22% provided correct instructions to the families and more than
75% were prescribing fluids such as tea and glucose water that are not advised during
Appropriate nutritional recommendations related to both food and milk consumption were
reported by only 2.6% of Thai pharmacists interviewed by Saengcharoen et al. (2010). Taking
these strategies individually, recommendations related to providing an all milk diet (breastmilk
or formula) were provided by only 6.1%, while recommendations on appropriate food intake
were given by 12.2% of the pharmacists (Saengcharoen & Lerkiatbundit, 2010). Healthcare
professionals’ reported knowledge about diarrhea has been similar over the years and across
different countries of the world. Higher education levels appear to improve healthcare
professionals’ history taking and assessment of the signs of severe dehydration. However, the
training does not ensure the practice of these initial steps, critical in the management of
childhood diarrhea, on a regular basis. Reports on caregivers’ education follow the same trends.
Regardless of dates of the studies and the location of their sites, the studies’ findings report that
3-2 Prescription for oral rehydration solutions, antibiotics and other drugs for the
Oral rehydration solutions. The majority of the healthcare professionals reported having
knowledge about the importance of oral rehydration solutions and stated prescribing it frequently
when treating childhood diarrhea. The percentages of those recommending oral rehydration
solutions were noted to be greater than 50% of providers but rarely higher than 70% (Okeke et
al., 1996; Saengcharoen & Lerkiatbundit, 2010). Limited prescription of oral rehydration
solutions alone in the management of childhood diarrhea was described by some healthcare
professionals who reported facing challenges with acceptability of oral rehydration solutions in
children. Bitter and salty taste, disagreeable color and induced nausea and vomiting were the
13
frequent reasons physicians believed the rehydration therapy was not accepted by the patients
and their families (Gani et al., 1991). The unpalatable taste of the oral rehydration solutions was
considered to be a deterrent for caretakers to use oral rehydration solutions alone for the
management of diarrhea. For these reasons, healthcare professionals tended to prescribe other
medications considered more effective, like antibiotics or anti-diarrheal medications (Gani et al.,
Survey, observation or fictitious case studies highlighted a gap between healthcare providers’
reported knowledge about oral rehydration solutions and its prescription versus their actual
prescription during management of children with diarrhea (Beria et al., 1998; Gani et al., 1991;
Nizami, Khan, & Bhutta, 1996; Younas et al., 2009). In the study authored by Gani and
colleagues (1991), the researchers used both interviews and observation intervention to assess
prescribing oral rehydration solutions in their management of childhood diarrhea during the
survey, only 75% were actually observed prescribing the rehydration therapy (Gani et al., 1991).
With the WHO recommended change in the formulation of oral rehydration solutions published
since 2004, the hope was to increase the consumption of rehydration therapy (WHO, 2004).
However, more recent studies still report limited prescription of oral rehydration solution alone.
The same gap between reported versus observed prescription of oral rehydration solutions has
been described. Agrawal et al. (2008) reported that 73% of medical officers and 81% of interns
knew the preparation of oral rehydration solutions as recommended by the WHO 2004
guidelines. Of the medical officers and interns who were interviewed, only 31% stated giving
oral rehydration solutions, continuous feeding and zinc, while 62.5% recommended antibiotics in
The researchers (2008) also interviewed other healthcare professional groups such as auxiliary
nurse midwives, health assistants, nursing students and traditional healers. They found that 55%
of auxiliary nurse midwives, 36% of health assistants and 72% nursing students knew the
appropriate dosages for the preparation of oral rehydration solution. In terms of diarrhea
treatment, 33% of nursing students, 20% of auxiliary nurse midwives and health assistants
declared recommending oral rehydration solutions and continuous feeding (Agrawal et al.,
2008). Similar to the studies’ finding on the knowledge of diarrhea, patterns seem to exist in the
gap between knowledge and practice across the studies’ dates and geographical settings. The
diarrhea also highlight a limited knowledge about the correct preparation and consistent
Antibiotics. High prescription rates of antibiotics were reported in many of the studies,
regardless of the fact that healthcare professionals acknowledged that viruses rather than bacteria
were the most common pathogens causing diarrhea in children (Berih et al., 1989; Howteerakul,
Higginbotham, Freeman, & Dibley, 2003; Naeem, 2014). Gani et al. (1991) interviewed and
Although physicians believed the most frequent cause of diarrhea was viral, 61% reported
prescribing antibiotics while 94% were actually observed prescribing antibiotics for treatment of
The prescription of oral rehydration solutions in combination with antibiotics was consistently
high across the selected studies. A total of 70% of healthcare professionals participating in the
study led by Igun and colleagues in Nigeria (1994) reported combining antibiotics and oral
rehydration solutions in their management of the diarrheal diseases in children. However, the
15
prescription of a therapeutic combination was not evaluated in the record review completed
within this study to identify whether gaps existed between what was stated by the providers and
Almost twenty years later and with a growing concern about antibiotic resistance, the
significant. Younas et al. (2009) stated that 91.25% of children (n = 80) admitted to the hospital
for acute watery diarrhea, received antibiotics either orally or parentally. The indiscriminate
to treat co-infections, prevent complications or secondary infections and was also related to
reported uncertainty about the etiology of the disease (Paredes et al., 1996; Younas et al., 2009).
Younas et al. (2009) reported that metronidazole was given by medical officers in 61.25% of the
children treated for diarrhea. The drug was either taken in combination with other drugs or with
treatment of choice for the treatment of diarrhea (Howteerakul, Higginbotham, & Dibley, 2004;
Howteerakul et al., 2003; Nizami et al., 1996; Saengcharoen & Lerkiatbundit, 2010). This drug,
year, and prophylaxis treatment for malaria and severe bacterial infections in adult and children
taking antiretroviral treatment (WHO, 2010). The drug is not recommended nor is it needed for
children suffering of diarrheal diseases who are not infected or exposed to HIV (WHO, 2010).
childhood diarrhea (WHO, 2005). The prescription of these drugs has been linked to undesirable
and sometimes fatal side effects in children. While physicians, interviewed by Paredes et al.
16
(1996) recognized antidiarrheal as “unnecessary” in the treatment of diarrhea and were aware of
the national policy restricting its prescription, 26% believed in the effectiveness of these drugs,
The study with the highest report of antidiarrheal medications prescribed for the management of
childhood diarrhea, was performed a decade after the publication of the updated WHO guidelines
by Naeem et al. (2014). The authors compared prescribing behaviors of physicians who attended
a diarrhea training management course to those who did not. The physicians who did not attend
the training course were significantly more likely to prescribe antidiarrheal drugs (44.1%)
compared to those who attended the training course (17.4%) (Naeem, 2014). Consistent with the
conclusions drawn from the analysis of the previous outcomes, training appears to make a
diarrhea.
Parallel to the reported knowledge about diarrhea and prescription of oral rehydration solutions,
the studies’ findings indicate similarities in healthcare providers’ prescribing behaviors in the
drugs have been reported in countries located in three different continents over the last thirty
years. Although the findings indicate higher prescriptions rates of oral rehydration solutions
based on the healthcare professionals’ medical training, education does not ensure consistent
Recommendations of zinc supplementation with rehydration therapy were added in the 2004
WHO guidelines for children with acute non-dysenteric watery diarrhea (WHO, 2004). When
reported in the studies, however, zinc supplementation was either not prescribed or prescribed in
only very limited occasions (Chakraborti, Barik, Singh, & Nag, 2011; Lofgren, Tao, Larsson,
Kyakulaga, & Forsberg, 2012; Pathak et al., 2011; Younas et al., 2009). Healthcare providers’
knowledge about the benefits of zinc in the management of childhood diarrhea was low. Among
843 prescriptions to children being treated for diarrhea by surveyed physicians and pharmacists
in Ujjain district, India, Pathak et al. (2011) noted that zinc was prescribed alone in only 27% of
the cases and in combination with oral rehydration solutions in only 22% of the cases. In
addition, the authors reported that only in 6 of the 843 prescriptions did physicians follow the
national guidelines, and they included only oral rehydration solutions and zinc in their
More recently, Lofgren and her research team (2012) reviewed medical records and interviewed
staff at health centers and drug shops in a rural district of Uganda. The authors reported that, at
the time of the study, zinc supplementation was not cited in the national clinical guidelines
(Uganda) for diarrhea management and was not distributed to the health centers and the staff at
the health centers never reported zinc as part of their treatment for childhood diarrhea (Lofgren
et al., 2012). The most common reasons for the limited prescription of zinc was both institutional
(not available) and financial (too costly). Changes in policies at the national level and the lack of
funding were reported as major reasons why zinc was unavailable at the local level in health
centers and/or drug shops in Numutumba district (Lofgren et al., 2012; Pathak et al., 2011).
The majority of the countries where the studies were conducted have established clear guidelines
in the management of childhood diarrhea which mirror the WHO guidelines (Indian Academy of
18
Pediatrics, 2006; Kenyan Ministry of Public Health and Sanitation, 2010; Paediatric
Management Group (PMG) in South Africa; Bhatnagar et al., 2007; Wittenberg, 2012;
International Vaccine Access Center & Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health,
2015). National diarrhea management programs exist and are reported to focus frequently on
training community members and healthcare professionals to increase their knowledge about
these data indicate that improving knowledge does not necessarily translate into improved
practice in the studied settings. In fact, the studies’ documenting limited prescription of oral
rehydration solutions and zinc supplementation as well as the over-prescribing of antibiotics and
other drugs reflects the presence of a gap between the WHO or countries’ specific national
guidelines, on the one hand, and the healthcare professionals’ treatment choices in the
management of childhood diarrhea, on the other. Factors other than training and knowledge have
been frequently reported to significantly influence the actual practice of healthcare professionals
diarrhea
A total of 15 studies reported factors other than knowledge about diarrhea, influencing healthcare
providers’ prescribing patterns in childhood diarrhea (Gani et al., 1991; Howteerakul et al., 2003;
Saengcharoen & Lerkiatbundit, 2010). Frequently cited factors included the healthcare
providers’ training, perceived severity of the symptoms associated with diarrhea, caregivers’
expectation and related effects of financial profits (Figure 4). Each factor was frequently
Training and specialization have been described as a factor influencing healthcare providers’
prescribing patterns. Professionals with more years of medical training and those working in
pediatrics settings tended to prescribe more oral rehydration solutions and less antibiotics or
antidiarrheal drugs (Naeem, 2014; Paredes et al., 1996). With the limited laboratory resources
available to confirm the diagnosis of infectious diseases, especially shigella or cholera, many
healthcare professionals declared prescribing antibiotics and antidiarrheals whenever the child
was presenting with at least two signs of severe dehydration (Kanungo et al., 2014;
While some healthcare professionals recognized that drug prescribing practices were in some
cases unnecessary, they did not change their practice to avoid caregiver disappointment and thus,
families seeking care elsewhere. Similar caregivers’ pressure was reported in Thailand by
Howteerakul and colleagues (2003). Thai physicians noted prescription of multiple drugs to
satisfy mothers, mostly those who openly requested a specific medication (Howteerakul et al.,
2003). Satisfaction of caretakers was perceived by the participants as a way to protect the child,
to maintain the health professionals’ reputations, and most importantly to maintain a faithful
clientele.
Compared to oral rehydration solutions, drug prescriptions are more expensive and constitute a
higher profit margin for pharmacists and private providers, as in Sudan for example. Sudanese
pharmacists were reported to sell oral rehydration solutions at an average price of $ 0.68 cents
compared to antibiotics which cost approximately $2.81 (Berih et al., 1989). Financial
motivation was also cited by Nizami et al. (1996) as a reason for private practitioners to
prescribe unnecessary drug therapy for childhood diarrhea in Pakistan. The authors shared that
general practitioners in private settings were not paid and did not receive financial supports from
20
the government, so medication prescriptions were an important source of income for them
(Nizami et al., 1996). Dispensing a combination of drugs, such as oral rehydration solutions and
injectable antibiotics, was reported to provide a higher profit margin (Kanungo et al., 2014).
Caretakers’ expectations for effective and rapid treatment were perceived by the healthcare
in particular were reported to expect to receive drug prescriptions from physicians rather than
simple oral rehydration therapy (Howteerakul et al., 2003; Paredes et al., 1996; Pathak et al.,
2011). Nigerian pharmacists reported that mothers expected to receive drug prescriptions for fast
relief of diarrheal symptoms (Igun, 1994). This situation was reported to put the pharmacists in a
position where they felt pressured to prescribe drugs that were considered by the authors,
5- Discussion
Although healthcare professionals across the different studies demonstrated adequate knowledge
about the etiology of diarrhea and signs of dehydration, that knowledge did not seem to ensure
Discrepancies between healthcare providers’ knowledge about diarrhea and the actual practice
were consistently reported regardless of the year of publication, the geographical setting and the
healthcare profession. Studies that used either survey and observation or fictitious cases of sick
children, all highlighted the gap between healthcare providers’ reported knowledge about
A clear illustration of this gap was the limited practice of taking a health history before ruling out
a diagnosis and formulating a treatment plan. While the WHO guidelines advocate for a
21
thorough health history and physical assessment, especially asking about the presence of blood in
stool, before deciding to prescribe antibiotics, this practice was not reported as standard on a
regular basis. When the assessment and health history were performed and absence of blood was
reported, the findings did not prevent healthcare providers in many studies from prescribing
While the studies reported limited knowledge and prescription of zinc by healthcare providers,
knowledge about oral rehydration solutions and their role in the treatment of diarrhea seemed to
solutions alone and correct knowledge on the composition and preparation seemed low. Our
findings across these studies indicated that higher prescription rates of rehydration therapy were
noted when it was combined with antibiotics, antidiarrheal or other medicines. A combination of
oral rehydration solutions with other therapies was often due to the fact that healthcare providers
believed that rehydration therapy was not efficient or well tolerated by the children because of
High prescription rates of antibiotics and antidiarrheal were consistently reported across the
different studies. The findings mirror the unnecessary prescription of these medications reported
by other studies worldwide. In fact, excessive prescription of antibiotics has been common and
well documented over the last three decades. In a cross-sectional study done in Thailand by
Howteerakul et al. (2004), it was reported that appropriate antibiotic drugs were dispensed in
only 27.4 % of cases and that cotrimoxazole was prescribed in 51% of the case (Howteerakul et
al., 2004). These reports highlight the concerns related to the magnitude of antibacterial drug
Correct management of the disease relies on correct knowledge of the etiology, identification of
specific symptoms, and appropriate therapies. This review echoes the conclusions of many other
calls for action and publications related to diarrheal diseases. While unique in its design and
analysis, the present work reiterates what was already known about the management of diarrheal
diseases in the literature: knowledge is not enough. Because the known strategies have led to
limited results in the past 30 years, current training programs for healthcare providers are not
6- Limitations
As is with any review, limitations exist. These include the possibility that not all relevant studies
were identified because the literature search did not comprise unpublished studies and research
completed in languages other than English. In addition, almost half of the included studies did
not use a strong quality study design. The data analysis in these studies did not follow all the
methodological criteria specific to observational studies. Future research with stronger study
designs is needed. The nature of the review, an integrative review allowing inclusion of studies
with different research designs, also opens the door for potential biases in the analysis. However,
the strategies proposed by Whittemore and Knafl and the use of one study design decrease bias
In addition, the sample population, healthcare providers, included numerous professions with
different education and training. So including all these different groups of health providers at
once might have introduced confounding variables that could have reduced or exaggerated the
analysis of the data. Future reviews need to be completed focusing on single healthcare
The selected studies represented the regions of the world where children are the most affected by
diarrhea and included the healthcare professions that are the most likely to provide care to sick
children. However, nurses and midwives were mentioned in only one study, while 15 included
physicians, and five studied pharmacists’ behaviors. These findings are not reflective of the
around the world. According to the WHO, nurses and midwives constitute approximately 80% of
the healthcare services worldwide. The nurse/midwife-to-physician ratio varies from 2:1 to more
than 15:1 in every country in Sub-Saharan Africa and the majority of the countries in South Asia
(WHO, 2015).
Therefore, the current design of training and research programs on the management of childhood
diarrhea needs to be further evaluated. The programs must incorporate the different factors, other
than knowledge, influencing healthcare providers’ prescribing behaviors. These factors include
the healthcare providers’ training and experience, caregivers’ expectations and related effects of
financial profits. In addition, more research is need to address the largest healthcare provider
8- Conclusion
This integrative review shows that knowledge about diarrhea is not enough to ensure proper
solutions and zinc supplementation, while antibiotic prescriptions remain high in the
management of childhood diarrhea, indicate the limited effectiveness of the healthcare providers’
current training on the recommended clinical management of childhood diarrhea. The gap
24
between knowledge and practice, especially in the high prescription rates of antibiotics and other
drugs, has been a constant challenge for sustainable adherence to the WHO guidelines to reduce
childhood morbidity and mortality related to diarrhea. This gap cannot be resolved without re-
diarrhea.
Contribution of paper
What is already known:
Diarrhea remains the major cause of death for children under the age of 5 years.
Oral rehydration therapy, zinc supplementation and continuous feeding are cost-effective
measures accounting for the significant drop in childhood mortality in the past 30 years.
Use of these interventions is limited, and many children who suffer from diarrhea in low-
income countries do not receive oral rehydration therapy and continued feeding.
Lack of training and support of healthcare providers has been identified as a barrier for
the slow progress made in tackling childhood diarrhea worldwide.
What this paper adds: Regardless of time, geographical settings and training
Healthcare providers’ prescription of oral rehydration therapy and caregivers education
about rehydration therapy remain inconsistent;
Unnecessary prescription of antibiotics and antidiarrheal medications remains high.
Influencing factors, especially, caregivers’ expectations, healthcare providers’ experience
and perception of the severity of the disease as well as financial profit play a significant
role in the healthcare providers ’clinical practices during management of childhood
diarrhea.
While considered the largest healthcare profession, nurses and midwives are the least
represented healthcare provider groups included in studies evaluating the clinical
management of childhood diarrhea.
25
References
Agrawal, L. M., Shuaib, A. R., Alam, S., Ashraf, M., Malik, Z. K., Malik, M. A., & Khan, Z.
Alam, S., Khan, Z., & Amir, A. (2003). Knowledge of diarrhea management among rural
Barron, P. M., Ephraim, G., Hira, M., Kathawaroo, S., & Thomas, C. (1989). Dispensing habits
Beria, J. U., Damiani, M. F., dos Santos, I. S., & Lombardi, C. (1998). Physicians' prescribing
Berih, A. A., McIntyre, L., & Lynk, A. D. (1989). Pharmacy dispensing practices for Sudanese
Bhatnagar, S., Lodha, R., Choudhury, P., Sachdev, H. P., Shah, N., Narayan, S., . . . Indian
Chakraborti, S., Barik, K. L., Singh, A. K., & Nag, S. S. (2011). Prescribing practices of doctors
Fischer Walker, C. L., Fontaine, O., Young, M. W., & Black, R. E. (2009). Zinc and low
osmolarity oral rehydration salts for diarrhoea: A renewed call to action. Bulletin of the
Fischer Walker, C. L., Perin, J., Aryee, M. J., Boschi-Pinto, C., & Black, R. E. (2012). Diarrhea
incidence in low- and middle-income countries in 1990 and 2010: A systematic review.
Fontaine, O., Kosek, M., Bhatnagar, S., Boschi-Pinto, C., Chan, K. Y., Duggan, C., . . . Rudan, I.
(2009). Setting research priorities to reduce global mortality from childhood diarrhoea by
Gani, L., Arif, H., Widjaja, S. K., Adi, R., Prasadja, H., Tampubolon, L. H., . . . Jauri, R. (1991).
Goel, P. K., Ross-Degnan, D., McLaughlin, T. J., & Soumerai, S. B. (1996). Influence of
location and staff knowledge on quality of retail pharmacy prescribing for childhood
diarrhea in Kenya. International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 8(6), 519-526.
Hahn, S., Kim, S., & Garner, P. (2002). Reduced osmolarity oral rehydration solution for treating
Reviews, 1, CD002847.
Howteerakul, N., Higginbotham, N., Freeman, S., & Dibley, M. J. (2003). ORS is never enough:
Physician rationales for altering standard treatment guidelines when managing childhood
Igun, U. A. (1994). The knowledge-practice gap: An empirical example from prescription for
International Vaccine Access Center (IVAC), Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public
Health. (2015). Pneumonia and diarrhea progress report 2015: Sustainable progress in
resources/IVAC-2015-Pneumonia-DiarrheaProgress-Report.pdf
Kanungo, S., Mahapatra, T., Bhaduri, B., Mahapatra, S., Chakraborty, N. D., Manna, B., & Sur,
doi:10.1017/s0950268813001076
The Government of Kenya Ministry of Public Health and Sanitation. (2014). Policy guidelines
for the management of diarrhea in children below five years in Kenya. Retrieved from
http://guidelines.health.go.ke:8000/media/Policy_Guidelines_for_Management_of_Diarr
hoea_in_Children_Below.pdf
Liu, L., Oza, S., Hogan, D., Perin, J., Rudan, I., Lawn, J. E., . . . Black, R. E. (2015). Global,
regional, and national causes of child mortality in 2000-13, with projections to inform
10.1016/s0140-6736(14)61698-6
Lofgren, J., Tao, W., Larsson, E., Kyakulaga, F., & Forsberg, B. C. (2012). Treatment patterns of
Naeem, M., Shaukat, M. S., Naheed, I., Imdad, S., & Mirza, R. (2014). Role of general
practitioners in prescribing drugs, ORS and zinc in the Management of acute watery
diarrhea for children under 5 years of age. Pakistan Journal of Medical and Health
Nizami, S. Q., Khan, I. A., & Bhutta, Z. A. (1996). Drug prescribing practices of general
Okeke, T. A., Okafor, H. U., Amah, A. C., Onwuasigwe, C. N., & Ndu, A. C. (1996).
Knowledge, attitude, practice, and prescribing pattern of oral rehydration therapy among
Paredes, P., de la Pena, M., Flores-Guerra, E., Diaz, J., & Trostle, J. (1996). Factors influencing
may not be the clue. Social Science & Medicine, 42(8), 1141-1153.
Pathak, D., Pathak, A., Marrone, G., Diwan, V., & Lundborg, C. S. (2011). Adherence to
2334-11-32
Saengcharoen, W., & Lerkiatbundit, S. (2010). Practice and attitudes regarding the management
Younas, M., Shah, F., Khan, J., Kaleem-ur-Rehman, S., Imtiaz, M., Qureshi, M. S., & Talaat, A.
23(4), 369-372.
United Nations Children’s Fund/ World Health Organization. (2009). Diarrhoea: Why children
are still dying and what can be done. Geneva: The United Nations Children’s Fund
(UNICEF).
United Nations Children’s Fund. (2013). Childinfo statistics: Diarrhoea. Geneva: The United
Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF), World Health Organization (WHO). Retrieved from
http://data.unicef.org/child-health/diarrhoeal-disease.
World Health Organization, Programme for Control of Diarrhoeal Diseases. (1989). Seventh
World Health Organization & United Nations Children’s Fund. (2004). WHO/UNICEF joint
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK305342/
World Health Organization & United Nations Children’s Fund. (2010). Countdown to 2015
decade report (2000-2010) with country profiles: Taking stock of maternal, newborn and
30
http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/44346/1/9789241599573_eng.pdf
World Health Organization. (2013). Diarrhoeal disease: Fact sheet number 330. Geneva: World
http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs330/en/.
http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/112642/1/9789241564748_eng.pdf
Alam, S., Khan, Z., & Amir, A. (2003). Knowledge of diarrhea management among rural practitioners.
Beria, J. U., Damiani, M. F., dos Santos, I. S., & Lombardi, C. (1998). Physicians' prescribing behaviour for
diarrhoea in children: an ethnoepidemiological study in Southern Brazil. Soc Sci Med, 47(3), 341-
346.
Berih, A. A., McIntyre, L., & Lynk, A. D. (1989). Pharmacy dispensing practices for Sudanese children with
Chakraborti, S., Barik, K. L., Singh, A. K., & Nag, S. S. (2011). Prescribing practices of doctors in
Fontaine, O., Kosek, M., Bhatnagar, S., Boschi-Pinto, C., Chan, K. Y., Duggan, C., . . . Rudan, I. (2009).
Setting research priorities to reduce global mortality from childhood diarrhoea by 2015. PLoS
Gani, L., Arif, H., Widjaja, S. K., Adi, R., Prasadja, H., Tampubolon, L. H., . . . Jauri, R. (1991). Physicians'
prescribing practice for treatment of acute diarrhoea in young children in Jakarta. J Diarrhoeal
Howteerakul, N., Higginbotham, N., & Dibley, M. J. (2004). Antimicrobial use in children under five years
with diarrhea in a central region province, Thailand. Southeast Asian J Trop Med Public Health,
35(1), 181-187.
Howteerakul, N., Higginbotham, N., Freeman, S., & Dibley, M. J. (2003). ORS is never enough: physician
rationales for altering standard treatment guidelines when managing childhood diarrhoea in
Igun, U. A. (1994). The knowledge-practice gap: an empirical example from prescription for diarrhoea in
Kanungo, S., Mahapatra, T., Bhaduri, B., Mahapatra, S., Chakraborty, N. D., Manna, B., & Sur, D. (2014).
Lofgren, J., Tao, W., Larsson, E., Kyakulaga, F., & Forsberg, B. C. (2012). Treatment patterns of childhood
diarrhoea in rural Uganda: a cross-sectional survey. BMC Int Health Hum Rights, 12, 19. doi:
10.1186/1472-698x-12-19
Naeem, M., Shaukat, M. S., Naheed, I., Imdad, S., & Mirza, R. (2014). Role of General Practitioners in
Prescribing Drugs, ORS and Zinc in the Management of Acute Watery Diarrhea for Children
Under 5 Years of Age. Pakistan Journal of Medical and Health Sciences, 8(1), 204-207.
32
Nizami, S. Q., Khan, I. A., & Bhutta, Z. A. (1996). Drug prescribing practices of general practitioners and
paediatricians for childhood diarrhoea in Karachi, Pakistan. Soc Sci Med, 42(8), 1133-1139.
Okeke, T. A., Okafor, H. U., Amah, A. C., Onwuasigwe, C. N., & Ndu, A. C. (1996). Knowledge, attitude,
practice, and prescribing pattern of oral rehydration therapy among private practitioners in
Paredes, P., de la Pena, M., Flores-Guerra, E., Diaz, J., & Trostle, J. (1996). Factors influencing physicians'
prescribing behaviour in the treatment of childhood diarrhoea: knowledge may not be the clue.
Pathak, D., Pathak, A., Marrone, G., Diwan, V., & Lundborg, C. S. (2011). Adherence to treatment
Saengcharoen, W., & Lerkiatbundit, S. (2010). Practice and attitudes regarding the management of
childhood diarrhoea among pharmacies in Thailand. Int J Pharm Pract, 18(6), 323-331. doi:
10.1111/j.2042-7174.2010.00066.x
Sood, N., & Wagner, Z. (2014). Private sector provision of oral rehydration therapy for child diarrhea in
Sub-Saharan Africa. The American journal of tropical medicine and hygiene, 90(5), 939-944.
Younas, M., Shah, F., Khan, J., Kaleem-ur-Rehman, S., Imtiaz, M., Qureshi, M. S., & Talaat, A. (2009).
Clinical audit of treatment of acute watery diarrhoea in paediatrics unit, Hayatabad Medical
Figure 1 Existing WHO guidelines for preventing and treating diarrhea in children (WHO, 2010)
Prevention Give vitamin A to all children > 6 months of age every 6 months (100 000 IU for 6–12 months
and 200 000 IU for ≥12 months) up to 5 years of age.
Treatment and Treat dehydration with ORS solution (or an intravenous electrolyte solution in cases of severe
management dehydration).
With increased fluids and continued feeding, all children with diarrhea should be given zinc
supplementation at 20 mg for 10–14 days; infants < 6 months should receive 10 mg.
Use antibiotics only when appropriate (i.e. bloody diarrhea), and abstain from administering
anti-diarrheal drugs.
Ciprofloxacin is the most appropriate drug for treatment of bloody diarrhea, rather than nalidixic
acid, which leads to rapid development of resistance.
Ciprofloxacin should be used at an oral dose of 15 mg/kg twice daily for 3 days.
Advise mothers to increase fluids and continue feeding during future episodes.
Give multivitamins and micronutrients daily for 2 weeks to all children with persistent diarrhea
(folate 50 µg, zinc 10 mg, vitamin A 400 µg, iron 10 mg, copper 1 mg, magnesium 80 mg).
Give lactose-free (or low-lactose) diet to children > 6 months with persistent diarrhea and who
are unable to breastfeed.
Assess every child with persistent diarrhea for nonintestinal infections (pneumonia, sepsis,
urinary tract infection, oral thrush, otitis media), and treat appropriately.
Other related Test children of unknown HIV status, who are living in areas of where HIV prevalence is 1% or
recommendations more and who present to a health facility.
Household water treatment methods that are effective in reducing diarrhea and storage of
water in containers that do not allow manual contact are recommended for people with HIV and
their households.
Promotion of hand-washing with soap after defecation, handling of human or animal feces and
before food preparation and eating, with the provision of soap, are recommended for people
with HIV and their households.
Refer HIV-exposed infants and children for co-trimoxazole prophylaxis and HIV-infected children
for ART.
34
21 studies selected
35
10
Number of studies
9
8
7
6
5
4
3 1989-1990
2
1 1991-2000
0 2001-2010
2010-2014
Study Design
Structured questionnaires 8
Simulated client survey 3
Chart review 1
Observations 1
Combination of designs 8
Study Population
Medical doctors 15
Pharmacists 6
Nurses, midwives, nursing students 1
38
1 Barron et South Africa Pharmacists 60 To determine pharmacists’ knowledge, advice and Structure interview Survey
al. 1989 (urban) methods of treatment of acute diarrhea in young
children
2 Berih et al. Sudan (Urban) Pharmacists 63 To study the dispensing practices of pharmacists Tomson’s survey design
1989 with respects to the management of infantile
diarrhea
3 Gani et al. Indonesia Physicians 195 To investigate prescribing practices of physicians Observation
1991 (Urban) treating acute childhood diarrhea Interviews
4 Igun et al. Nigeria Pharmacists 135 To document the prescribing practices of retail Open and confederates
1994 (Urban/Rural) pharmacies for diarrhea and to analyze the surveys
implications of such practices for the diarrhea
problem
5 Goel et al. Kenya Pharmacists To examine the influence between rural versus Surrogate patient
1996 (Urban/Rural) urban location, neighborhood socio-economic technique
status and clinical knowledge of pharmacy
assistants on quality of prescribing in retail
pharmacies
6 Nizami et Pakistan General 90 To report differences in practicing behaviors Observations
al. 1996 (Urban) practitioners between general practitioners and pediatricians.
Pediatricians
7 Parades et Peru (Urban) Physicians 44 To explore the factors influencing physicians’ Exploratory research: in-
al. 1996 prescribing practices for cases of acute childhood depth interviews/
diarrhea Confederates visits
8 Okeke et al. Nigeria Private medical 91 To identify the knowledge, attitude, and practice of Structured questionnaires
1996 (Urban) practitioners oral rehydration therapy.
9 Buch et al. Pakistan General - To study on the inadequacies in the current Open ended
1997 practitioners management practices of acute diarrhea at various questionnaires
Chemists levels of practitioners
Hospital
residents
MBBS doctors
Pediatricians
10 Choudhry Pakistan General 262 To determine physicians reported practices in Semi- structured
et al., 1997 (Urban) physicians childhood diarrhea and to identify factors affecting questionnaires
this behavior
39
Table 2 Continued
# Study Country/ Participants Sampl Aim Design
Setting e Size
11 Beria et al. Brazil Physicians 33 To develop a better understanding of the dynamics Record reviews
1998 of physicians and patients’ behaviors in the
treatment of childhood diarrhea
12 Alam et al. India (Rural) Rural medical 202 To determine the knowledge of rural medical Questionnaires
2003 practitioners practitioners of the district of Aligarh about the
management of diarrhea.
13 Howteerak Thailand(Urb Physicians 38 To document the prevalence of suboptimal Quantitative and
ul et al. an/Rural) prescribing and quality of care offered to children qualitative methods
2003 and quality of care offered to children admitted as
inpatients or outpatients to government hospital
suffering from diarrhea.
14 Agrawal et India (Urban) Medical officers 362 To determine the knowledge among various levels Questionnaires
al., 2008 and interns of government health system.
Paramedics
15 Younas et Pakistan Medical officers - To estimate the frequency rate of inappropriate Retrospective study
al., 2009 (Urban) drug use and a deficiency in the knowledge and
practice treatment protocols
16 Saengcharo Thailand Pharmacists 115 To compare practice behavior and attitudes of Simulated client
en et al., (Urban) pharmacy personnel in the management of Questionnaire
2010 childhood diarrhea between type I and type II
pharmacies, between those surveyed in 2008 and in
2001, and between new- and old- generation
pharmacists.
17 Chakraborti India General - To determine the prescribing practices of doctors in Review of hospital
et al., 2011 practitioners management of acute diarrhea in children in the records
Pediatricians age group of 6 month-5 years
18 Pathak et India (Urban) Practitioners in 22 To determine the level of adherence to treatment Cross- sectional
al., 2011 pharmacies and guidelines for acute diarrhea in children up to 12 quantitative study:
hospital years and to explore the factors affecting survey
prescribing of ORS with zinc and antibiotics.
19 Lofgren et Uganda Nursing 77 To investigate knowledge and practices among staff Review of records
al., 2012 (Rural) assistants at health centers and drug shops in a rural setting in Structured interviews
Nurses/ Uganda in order to explore the scope for
Midwives improvement of diarrhea case management
Clinical officers
20 Kanungo et India (Urban) Pharmacists 20 To assess physicians’ characteristics, knowledge and Cross-sectional study
al., 2014 practice regarding diarrhea
21 Naeem et Pakistan General 380 To appraise the general practitioners in the Cross-sectional study:
al. 2014 (Urban) practitioners management of acute watery diarrhea for children semi-structured
under 5 years and to identify various factors questionnaire
contributing in the gaps of current practices of
general practitioners for the case management of
diarrhea