Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
On
Financial Performance Analysis:
A Comparative study Between IBBL and SJIBL
Acknowledgement
First of all I remember Almighty Allah for making me successful to prepare this report. I am
grateful to the Islami Bank Bangladesh Limited authority that has helped me by updating
desired information at their website. At the very outset, I would like to thank Saleh Md. Arman
(Lecturer, department of Business Administration, MIU) &MdSalehMathinCourse-Coordinator,
SPO & Faculty member of IBTRA for giving me the opportunity to know about the Islamic
Banking in Bangladesh, and without their support and direction it would never be possible for
me to make this report.
I’ve talked all the concerned officers of the Islami Bank Bangladesh Limited,
MouchakBranch, who kindly provided me the information and other handouts. Especially i
cannot but mention Rafiqul Islam sir, Assistant Vice President, Md. YasinALi, PO, Atiqul
Islam PO, Al-Amin Hossain, PO, Md. Abu jafor, and Assistant Officer of this branch.
The management of this Branch had been extremely helpful in providing necessary
documents, annual report, statements, voucher etc. which helped me to prepare this Internship
report. I express a deep debt of appreciation & gratefulness to the employees of IBBL,
Mouchak Branch.
Executive Summary
Banking system plays a very important role in the economic life of the nation. The health of
the economy is closely related to the soundness of its banking system. In a developing
country like Bangladesh the banking systems as a whole play a vital role in the progress of
economic development.
IBBL is a third generation bank in the private sector banking of Bangladesh. IBBL is the
private commercial bank that is a brain child of some successful local entrepreneurs. IBBL is
a banking company registered under the Companies Act, 1913 (At present the companies
Act, 1994) with its Head Office at 40, Dilkusha Commercial Area, Dhaka- 1000, Bangladesh.
The bank started its historical operation on the 30th March 1983. Now it has as many as 294
Branch throughout the country.
This report was originated in result of my internship, which I did, as must requirement
ofBBA program. This report was done based on my learning of 8 weeks internship in Islami
Bank Bangladesh Limited. The objective of this report was to gain knowledge from on thejob
experience and at the same time analyze the financial performance based on the knowledge
that I gathered in the BBA courses.
The report gives idea about the financial performance of the Islami Bank Bangladesh Limited
and Shajalal Islami Bank Limited. Both are islamic banks in Bangladesh. I used trend
analysis, ratio analysis and comparative analysis to describe the financial performance of
IBBL & SJIBL. So, the report will be descriptive in nature. I discussed with the officials and
executives of the IBBL, Mouchak Branch and found the approximate data which has been
used in this report. I have also collected secondary data from the annual reports and training
materials provided by the IBTRA. To analyze and present the numerical data and values I
have used column chart, bar chart, line chart, pie chart, and the formula has generated and
used in Microsoft Excel. I compare all data year wise. All sorts of analysis have been
executed, in order to analyze how efficient, liquid, profitability, secure and desirable the bank
is in terms of its finance. Then I have shown some findings from the qualitative and
quantitative analysis of IBBL.
In this report I have try to show comparative financial performance through ratio analysis,
trend analysis, vertical & horizontal analysis. Overall financial performance of IBBL is
increasing day by day. Because most of the people in our country are religious minded and
they want to transact their money according to Islamic Shariah.
Chapter One
Introduction of the report
Internship program of University is a partial requirement for the graduation of BBA students.
Every B.B.A student is appointed to learn some practical knowledge with in the pre-stipulated
period by observing the organization day to day activities. In this regard my internship program
started at 4 Oct. at Islami Bank Bangladesh Limited. This internship program was my on the job
exposure and provided me with learning experience and knowledge in several areas. I was not
only learned about the activities and operations of correspondent Bank, but also gathered some
knowledge about the basic business of banking from my internship period.
Islamic banks are unconditional and specialized financial institutions that perform most of the
standard banking services and investment activities on the basis of profit and loss sharing system
conforming to the principles of Islamic Shari’ah. Out of 50 banking institutions, 8 banks are
backed by Islamic mechanism and worldwide accepted Islamic morality and established code of
conduct.
Islami Bank Bangladesh Limited pursues decentralized management policies and adequate work
freedom to the employees. This result in less pressure for the workers and acts as a motivational
tool for them, also gives them encouragement and inspiration to move up the ladder of success.
Overall, I have experienced a very friendly and supporting environment at Islami Bank
Bangladesh Limited, which gave me the pleasure and satisfaction to be a part of them for a while.
While working in different departments of IBBL, Farm gate Branch, I have found each and every
employee is friendly to me to co-operate. They have discussed in details about their respective
tasks. I also participated with their works. I have carried out my internship in Islami Bank
Bangladesh Limited. So, as an integral part of my graduation and as a great opportunity of
acquiring knowledge about banking, this internship report has been prepared.
Shajalal islami bank is another Islamic Shari’ah bank. But there has difference between IBBL and
SJIBL. I have find out this difference and comparison financial performance between them. In
this regard I made this internship report.
1.2 Scope of the Report
Islami Bank Bangladesh Limited has 294 branches at present. Among those I have chosen
Mouchak branch. Here I have worked 45 days. The working environment of this branch is very
convenient. I have discussed the performance of IBBL and SJIBL over the years 2010 – 2014.
I think the report will helpful to know about, it’s financial performance.
In order to accomplish the broad objective following specific objectives are emerged,
1. Compare the financial performance of IBBL with SJIBL Bank through 2010-2014.
2. To calculate the ratio analysis between IBBL and SJIBL.
3. Ratio like liquidity, profitability, activity, leverage is calculated.
4. To asses Vertical Analysis.
5. To measure Horizontal analysis.
6. To show comparative Trend Analysis.
i. Column Chart,
Microsoft Excel
Microsoft word
Spss, etc
1.4.3 Data Analysis and Reporting
Both qualitative and quantitative analyses have been done while conducting this study. Microsoft
Word and Microsoft Excel were used to analyze, process and graphically represents the gathered
data.
1.4.4 Sample
The study calculated Ratio Analysis on the basis of the given formulas. Vertical Analysis
was calculated on the basis of the percentage of each segment. Horizontal analysis was
assessed in order to find out the respective change on the given particulars. The trend
analysis showed the pattern of Assets, Liabilities, Net Income and Owner’s Equity on
graphical procedure.
Chapter review
2.1 Introduction
Banks are the most important financial institution in the economy. For this reason most of the
banks are established. Islami bank is among of them which is established on March 13, 1983. This
bank is established on the basis of free of riba.Where all the banks are working with riba. But riba
is definitely haram in islam.. As it is Haram in Islam the Muslim scholars thought a plan to
establish a banking system that is free from interest and will work on the basis of profit loss
sharing. Then depending on this thought, , it is decided to establish Islamic banks through the
whole world to protect everyone from this curse.
According to Islamic banking Act 1983 of Malaysia, and Islamic Bank is a company which carries on
Islamic Banking Business Islamic Banding business means banking business whole aims and
operations do not involve any element which is not approved by the religion Islam.
In November 1982, a delegation of IDB visited Bangladesh and showed keen interest to
participate in establishing a joint venture Islamic Bank in the private sector. They found a lot
of work had already been done and Islamic banking was in a ready form for immediate
introduction. Two professional bodies Islamic Economics Research Bureau (IERB) and
Bangladesh Islamic Banker’s Association (BIBA) made significant contributions towards
introduction of Islamic banking in the country.
At last, the long drawn struggle, to establish an Islamic bank in Bangladesh becomes a reality.
Islami Bank Bangladesh Limited was established in March 1983. In which 19 Bangladeshi
nationals, 4 Bangladeshi institutions and 11 banks, financial institutions and government
bodies of the middle east and Europe including IDB and eminent personalities of the kingdom
Saudi Arabia joined hands to make the dream a reality.
2.9 Islami Bank Bangladesh Limited at a glance (As on 31st December, 2014):
There are many differences between Islamic Bank and Conventional Bank. There are discussed most
important differences.
The distinguishing features of the conventional banking and Islamic banking are shown in terms of a
box diagram as shown below:
4.1Ratio analysis
4.1.1Current ratio:Current Ratio = Current Assets / Current Liabilities
Year 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
IBBL 1.09 1.08 1.16 1.14 1.09
SJIBL 1.11 1.35 1.28 1.25 1.27
Current ratio
1.6
1.4
1.2
1
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
IBBL 1.09 1.08 1.16 1.14 1.09
SJIBL 1.11 1.35 1.28 1.25 1.27
3.00%
2.50%
2.00%
1.50%
1.00%
0.50%
0.00%
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
IBBL 1.47% 1.35% 1.27% 0.96% 0.67%
SJIBL 3.01% 1.26% 1.44% 1.00% 0.59%
Findings:Return on Asset ratio shows how a bank can convert its asset into net earnings. In this
graph we see IBBL’s ROA is decreasing gradually 2010 to 2014. ROA of SJIBL is
slightly higher 2010, 2012, 2013 from IBBL. ROA of IBBL is higher 2011 & 2014
than SJIBL. In this two year ratio indicates a higher ability to convert its asset into net
earnings than SJIBL and therefore it is an indicator of better managerial performance.
Return on Equity(ROE)
35.00%
30.00%
25.00%
20.00%
15.00%
10.00%
5.00%
0.00%
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
IBBL 19.00% 17.00% 13.00% 11.00% 9.00%
SJIBL 30.71% 13.80% 17.01% 12.67% 6.60%
18
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
IBBL 13.29 11.27 12.21 12.35 11.24
SJIBL 17.04 12.38 9.17 8.6 11.27
20.00%
15.00%
10.00%
5.00%
0.00%
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
IBBL 14.81% 12.61% 10.67% 8.82% 6.89%
SJIBL 21.79% 9.73% 9.92% 8.36% 5.65%
Findings:Graph 5 shows that net income ratio of IBBL is gradually higher except 2010 than
SJIBL. It means IBBL net income is higher than SJIBL. So, clients are eager to invest
their deposit in this bank.
120.00%
100.00%
80.00%
Axis Title
60.00%
40.00%
20.00%
0.00%
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
IBBL 90.17% 89.47% 85.18% 82.35% 79.88%
SJIBL 96.34% 93.00% 89.64% 84.32% 80.82%
Findings:Graph 7 shows that Investment Deposit Ratio of SJIBL is higher each year than IBBL.
Standard ratio of IDR is lower than 90%. IBBL’s IDR is standard for every year. In
2014 IBBL’s IDR is 79.88%. it is better in present perspective. On the other hand
SJIBL’s IDR was very higher in 2010. But recent year its IDR is very closely with
IBBL.
4.1.8 Debt Equity Ratio
Year 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
IBBL 5.34 4.03 4.20 4.62 4.77
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
IBBL 5.34 4.03 4.2 4.62 4.77
SJIBL 5.47 6.48 7.59 7.81 8.08
Findings:Graph 7 shows thatdebt equity ratio of IBBL is better than SJIBL. Debt Equity ratio
show how many debt remain a company against debt. In every year IBBL Debt
Equity Ratio is increasing except 2010, 2011. Now IBBL Debt Equity Ratio is 4.77
whereas SJIBL Debt Equity Ratio is 8.08. It’s absolutely higher than IBBL.
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
IBBL 52% 52% 48% 45% 47%
SJIBL 51.01% 38.57% 35.95% 32.23% 37.93%
Findings: Graph 10 shows that IBBL Gross profit ratio is higherthan SJIBL. In 2010 SJIBL Gross
profit ratio is approximately near the IBBL. From the next year it is very far from
IBBL. One of the reason IBBL operating income is higher than SJIBL.
4.2 vertical analysis
IBBL & SJIBL
Vertical Analysis Balance Sheet
For the year ended December 31, 2014 (Amount in million)
% of Total % of Total
Asset Amount Amount
asset asset
Balance with other banks & financial institutions 20,199 3.10% 7,643 6.03%
Placement with banks & other financial institutions 2,000 0.31% 4,234 3.34%
Liabilities
Placement from banks & other financial institutions 1.17% 3251 2.56%
7,657
Deposits & other accounts 85.94% 98601 77.78%
560,696
Mudaraba perpetual bond 0.46% ------- 0.00%
3,000
Other liabilities 5.22% 13089 10.33%
34052
Deferred tax liabilities 0.06% 117 .09%
403397
Shareholders’ equity
Findings: IBBL total asset is higher than SJIBL. IBBL cash is 7.08% of total asset whereas SJIBL
cash is 6.68%. Total liability of IBBL is 92.86% is higher than SJIBL (90.77%) of Total
liabilities & shareholders’ equity. Total equity of IBBL is 7.14% which is lower than
9.23%.
IBBL & SJIBL
Vertical Analysis Income Statement
For the year ended December 31, 2014 (In million Taka)
Particular IBBL SJIBL
Income from investments in shares & securities 1900 10.29% 304 9.63%
Operating expenses
Provision for investments & off- balance sheet exposures 4670 25.30% 1525 48.32%
Findings: Table 2 Shows that operating income of IBBL&SJIBL is respectively 148.41% & 158.9%
of the net investment income. Net profit of IBBL & SJIBL is respectively 21.69% &
22.40%. SJIBL net profit is higher than IBBL.
IBBL & SJIBL
Vertical Analysis Balance Sheet
For the year ended December 31, 2013 (In million Taka)
% of Total % of Total
Asset Amount Amount
asset asset
Balance with other banks & financial institutions 12327 2.25% 3526 2.74%
Placement with banks & other financial institutions ------------ 0.00% 7782 6.05%
Liabilities
Placement from banks & other financial institutions ------- 8300 6.46%
----------
Deposits & other accounts 86.52% 96481 75.05%
473140
Mudaraba perpetual bond 0.55% ------- ----------
3000
Other liabilities 4.96% 12683 9.87%
27133
Deferred tax liabilities 0.04% 137 0.11%
194
Shareholders’ equity
Table 3
Findings: IBBL total asset is higher than SJIBL. IBBL cash is 8.09% of total asset whereas SJIBL
cash is 7.94%. Total liability of IBBL is 92.07% is higher than SJIBL (91.48%) of Total
liabilities & shareholders’ equity. Total equity of IBBL is 7.93% which is lower than 8.52%
of SJIBL.
Income from investments in shares & securities 2047 11.92% 229 7.54%
Operating expenses
Provision for investments & off- balance sheet 3015 17.55% 174 5.73%
exposures
Table 4
% of Total % of Total
Asset Amount Amount
asset asset
Balance with other banks & financial institutions 23048 4.77% 1316 .33%
Placement with banks & other financial institutions ------------ ------------ 9253 6.96%
Liabilities
Placement from banks & other financial institutions 0.00% 14500 10.91%
----------
Deposits & other accounts 86.59% 102176 76.92%
417844
Mudaraba perpetual bond .62% ------- 0.00%
3000
Other liabilities 4.49% 6373 4.79%
21698
Deferred tax liabilities .04% 126 92.73%
238
Shareholders’ equity
Findings: Table 5 shows that IBBL total asset is higher than SJIBL. IBBL cash is 8.09% of total asset
whereas SJIBL cash is 7.94%. Total liability of IBBL is 92.07% is higher than SJIBL
(91.48%) of Total liabilities & shareholders’ equity. Total equity of IBBL is 7.93% which is
lower than 8.52% of SJIBL
IBBL & SJIBL
Vertical Analysis Income Statement
For the year ended December 31, 2012 (In million Taka)
% of net % of net
Operating Income Amount Amount sales
sales
Income from investments in shares & securities 431 2.42% 133 3.26%
Commission, exchange & brokerage income 5249 29.48% 1642 40.31%
Operating expenses
Salary & allowances 5951 33.42% 1015 24.92%
% of Total % of Total
Asset Amount Amount asset
asset
Cash in hand 40631 10.43% 9498 8.85%
Balance with other banks & financial institutions 15577 4.00% 1439 1.34%
Placement with banks & other financial institutions --------- ----------- 6835 6.37%
Liabilities
Placement from banks & other financial institutions ---------- --------- 10770 10.04%
Deposits & other accounts 341853 83350 77.73%
87.83%
Mudaraba perpetual bond 3000 ------------- ----------
0.77%
Other liabilities 16345 5084 4.74%
4.19%%
Deferred tax liabilities 192 107 .09%
0.04%
Total liabilities 361390 92.86% 9931 92.62%
Shareholders’ equity
Paid - up capital 10007 2.57% 4452 4.15%
Findings: Table 7 shows that IBBL total asset is higher than SJIBL. IBBL cash is 10.43% of total
asset whereas SJIBL cash is 8.85%. Total liability of IBBL is 92.07% is higher than SJIBL
(91.48%) of Total liabilities & shareholders’ equity. Total equity of IBBL is 7.93% which is
lower than 8.52% of SJIBL
IBBL & SJIBL
Vertical Analysis Income Statement
For the year ended December 31, 2011 (In million Taka)
% of net % of net
Operating Income Amount Amount sales
sales
Investment income 32019 235.12% 10107 370.08%
Operating expenses
Salary & allowances 4646 34.11% 943 34.52%
Rent, taxes, insurances, electricity etc. 503 3.69% 212 7.76%
Legal expenses 15 0.11% 0.8 0.02%
Postage, stamps and telecommunication etc. 94 0.69% 27 0.98%
Stationery, printing and advertisement etc. 198 1.45% 40 1.46%
Chief executive’s salary & fees 5 0.03% 12 0.43%
Directors’ fees & expenses 9 0.06% 4 0.14%
Shari’ah supervisory committee’s fees & expenses 2 0.01% 0.1 0.01%
Auditors’ fees 1 0.01% 0.3 0.01%
Charges on investment losses ----------
---------- ---------- ----------
Depreciation and repair to bank’s assets 407 2.98% 114 4.17%
Zakat expenses 262 1.92% 59 2.16%
Other expenses 1121 8.23% 217 7.94%
Total operating expenses 7263 53.33% 1629.2 59.65%
Profit before provision 2998.8
12736 93.52% 109.80%
% of Total % of Total
Asset Amount Amount asset
asset
Cash in hand 39053 11.81% 7199 9.16%
Balance with other banks & financial institutions 6679 2.02% 1,157 1.47%
Placement with banks & other financial institutions ------------ 0 4,336 5.51%
Investments in shares & securities 12268 3.71% 2,522 3.20%
Investments 263225 79.62% 61,440 78.19%
Fixed assets including premises 6748 2.04% 1,472 1.87%
Other assets 2610 0.78% 446 0.56%
Non-Banking asset 0 0 0 0
Total asset 3,30,583 100% 78,572 100%
Liabilities
Placement from banks & other financial institutions -------------- ------------ 5,732 7.31%
Deposits & other accounts 2,91,934 88.30% 62,514 79.79%
Mudaraba perpetual bond 3000 0.90% ---------- ---------
Other liabilities 11,994 3.62% 3278 4.18%
Deferred tax liabilities 162 0.04% 76 .09%
Total liabilities 307,090 92.89% 71600 91.39%
Shareholders’ equity
Paid - up capital 7,413 2.24% 3425 4.31%
Statutory reserve 7,934 2.40% 1774 2.26%
Other reserves 5,551 1.67% ---------- ----------
Retained Earnings 2,594 0.78% 1548 1.97%
Total stockholder equity 23,492 7.11% 6747 8.61%
Total liabilities & shareholders’ equity 330,582 100% 78,347 100%
Table 9
Findings: Table 9 shows that IBBL total asset is higher than SJIBL. IBBL cash is 10.43% of total
asset whereas SJIBL cash is 8.85%. Total liability of IBBL is 92.07% is higher than SJIBL (91.48%)
of Total liabilities & shareholders’ equity. Total equity of IBBL is 7.93% which is lower than 8.52%
of SJIBL
Horizontal Analysis
Liabilities
Income from investments in shares & securities 1900 2047 (147) (7.18%)
Balance with other banks & financial institutions 12327 23048 (10,721) (46.516%)
Placement with banks & other financial institutions ------------ ----------- ------------ ------------
Liabilities
Placement from banks & other financial institutions ---------- ---------- ---------- ------------
Deposits & other accounts 473140 417844 55,296 13.23%
Mudaraba perpetual bond 3000 3000 0 0
Other liabilities 27133 21698 5,435 25.04%
Deferred tax liabilities 194 238 -44 (18.48%)
Placement with banks & other financial institutions ----------- ----------- ---------
700000
600000
500000
400000
IBBL
300000 SJIBL
200000
100000
0
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
3.3.2 Liability
700,000
600,000
500,000
400,000
IBBL
300,000 SJIBL
200,000
100,000
0
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
3.3.3 Equity
50,000
45,000
40,000
35,000
30,000
25,000 IBBL
SJIBL
20,000
15,000
10,000
5,000
0
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Chapter 4
Recommendation & conclusion
6.1 Recommendation
Current ratio of IBBL is lower from 2010-2014 than SJIBL. IBBL should increase their asset
against liability.
ROA of IBBL is lower except 2011 & 2014 than SJIBL. IBBL should incease their total asset
sothat they can return asset into net earnings.