Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
September 2012
Figueroa Press
Los Angeles
BUDDHIST DIPLOMACY: HISTORY AND STATUS QUO
Juyan Zhang
Published by
FIGUEROA PRESS
840 Childs Way, 3rd Floor
Los Angeles, CA 90089
Phone: (213) 743-4800
Fax: (213) 743-4804
www.figueroapress.com
Notice of Rights
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmit-
ted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying,
recording, or otherwise, without prior written permission from the author,
care of Figueroa Press.
Notice of Liability
The information in this book is distributed on an “As is” basis, without
warranty. While every precaution has been taken in the preparation of this
book, neither the author nor Figueroa nor the USC Bookstore shall have
any liability to any person or entity with respect to any loss or damage
caused or alleged to be caused directly or indirectly by any text contained
in this book.
Figueroa Press and the USC Bookstore are trademarks of the University
of Southern California
Designed for both the practitioner and the scholar, this series will
illustrate the breadth of public diplomacy—its role as an essential
component of foreign policy and the intellectual challenges it
presents to those seeking to understand this increasingly significant
factor in international relations.
Introduction
to the Sangha. The Kosala King Pasenadi and his wife Queen Mallika
also became followers of the Buddha.6 King Pasenadi frequently
sought advice from the Buddha. He also made confessions to him
on his wrongdoings.7 After Magadha Prince Ajatashatru imprisoned
and starved his father King Bimbisara to death to take his throne,
he repented of his sin and made confessions to the Buddha. The
Buddha converted him into a follower.8 On one occasion when
King Pasenadi fought and captured King Ajatashatru, the Buddha
personally persuaded King Pasenadi to release King Ajatashatru.9
When King Ajatashatru planned to invade the Vajji Republic, he sent
his Prime Minister Vassakara to the Buddha to indirectly discover
whether in the Buddha’s view there were any chances of conquering
the Vajjians. The Buddha said that as long as the Vajjians practiced
the seven conditions of prosperity, they would prosper rather than
decline. As a result, a potential invasion was diffused.10
During the Buddha’s life time, he not only sent his disciples to
the kingdoms to spread the message of the Dharma, he personally
wandered from one kingdom to another to teach the Dharma. For
example, the Samyutta Nikaya records that a minister of the Kosala
court said that he felt extremely sad to learn that the Buddha was
leaving Kosala for other kingdoms to teach Dharma, because he
would not be able to see the Buddha for a good period of time. The
kingdoms included Kāśi, Malla, Magadha, Anga, Samatata, Bentara,
and Kalinga.11 Throughout his forty-five years’ of teaching, many
kings, queens, princes and nobles became the Buddha’s followers,
along with numerous people of low castes, from beggars to
prostitutes.12 The Digha-nikaya reports that six peoples in the sixteen
kingdoms followed the Buddha’s teachings during his lifetime.13
In the first rainy season after the Buddha’s nirvana (circa 543–
542 BCE), the Sangha convened its First Council, sponsored by
King Ajatashatru of Maghada, to review the Buddha’s teachings
so as to preserve them.16 This is when two of the “Three Baskets”,
or Tripitaka, were first formed, respectively the Vinaya-pitaka
(the monastic disciplines) and the Sutras-pitaka (the Buddha’s
discourses).17 The Sangha operated for more than one hundred years
under the disciplines the Buddha set until a dispute over interpretation
of the disciplines caused it to split into the Sthaviravadins and the
Mahasamghikas, or the school of orthodox elders and the school of
young reformers. This is the first schism of the Sangha. The Second
Council was convened at around this time to resolve the dispute.
This is also the beginning of sectarian Buddhism when the Sangha
started to split into many sects.18 When King Asoka (ca. 304–232
BCE), the third monarch of the Mauryan Dynasty, united the India
subcontinent, he sponsored the Third Council to expel bogus monks
from the Sangha. As a zealous Buddhist, he deployed nine Buddhist
BUDDHIST DIPLOMACY: HISTORY AND STATUS QUO 9
Burma until the 5th century CE. Early Buddhism in Burma was
Mahayana Buddhism rather than Theravada. Around 1075 CE, King
Anawrahta Minsaw, the founder of the Pagan dynasty, requested for
the Tripitaka from the king of Thaton, but he was turned down. The
enraged king attacked and conquered Thaton and brought Buddhist
scriptures and Theravada Buddhist clergy back to Burma. Hence
Burma became a center for the orthodox Theravada Buddhism,
which became the dominant state religion and played significant role
in its social and political life.30
When the first five monks were ready to teach Dharma, the
Buddha told them, “For the benefit and happiness of the largest
number of people, for the world, no two of you should travel
to the same place.”60 This command for the Sangha became the
first push for the active dissemination of Buddhist messages. The
Sangha was formed on the principles of celibacy, simple livelihood,
brotherhood, honesty, and self-responsibility.61 They are required to
follow numerous strict rules (vinaya) to live in the Sangha, such as
developing reverence and suaveness towards co-associates, being
respectful, avoiding loose talking, etc. The vinaya served as controls
imposed by the Sangha.62
9. Localization of Buddhism
India has become the ninth largest economy in the world in terms
of its nominal GDP,94 one of the fastest growing emerging economies,
and a member of BRICS (Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South
Africa) emerging nations. In tandem with its economic growth it has
sought to boost its soft power in the global arena. China’s aggressive
public diplomacy employing Buddhism has also drawn India into
a competition to assert its place as the center of Buddhism.95 As
one Indian diplomat put it, “China has sought to keep India out of
regional arrangements in Southeast Asia by portraying India as an
outsider. By underlining the multi-millennia-old bond of Buddhism
that it shares with these regions, India is quietly clarifying that it
is not a gatecrasher.”96 India’s governmental and non-governmental
Buddhist diplomacy initiatives focus on the following aspects.
When the 14th Dalai Lama fled Tibet in 1959 after a botched
uprising, Indian Prime Minister Pt. Jawaharlal Nehru allowed him
and his followers to settle in Dharamsala in northern India. This to
an extent has helped build India’s international image as a humane
protector of the Tibetans and a preserver of Tibetan culture and
identity. In addition, it helped strengthen India-U.S. relations during
the Cold War, when Nehru secretly aligned India with the United
States on the Tibetan issue.97 On the other hand, the Dalai Lama’s
BUDDHIST DIPLOMACY: HISTORY AND STATUS QUO 25
China has also used Buddhist art for diplomatic purposes. The
country’s National Museum held an exhibition of ancient Chinese
sculptures of bodhisattva Guanyin (Avalokitasvara) in Mexican
City. The Mexican Foreign Ministry organized a foreign diplomatic
missions to Mexico for a tour of the exhibition.118 In April 2010, the
Chinese government sent a 160-member Buddhist Orchestra Group
to India to celebrate the 60th anniversary of Indo-China diplomatic
ties. The group has also been sent to South Korea, Singapore,
Indonesia, and Malaysia.
After the World War Two, separation of church and state in the
new constitution prompted resurgence, modernization, and overseas
expansion of Japanese Buddhism.124 D.T. Suzuki (1870–1966),
along with many Zen teachers who emigrated to the United States
and Europe, “repackaged” Japanese Zen Buddhism for the West.125
Suzuki’s effort was reportedly funded by the Japanese government.126
Jodo Shinshu, or Shin Buddhism, which started to spread to North
America in the 19th century, also increased its westward expansion
after the War. Its affiliated organization, the Buddhist Church of
America, currently has over 60 independent temples and a number
of Fellowships and Sanghas with approximately 16,000 members
throughout the United States.127 Nichiren Shoshu Buddhism built
a worldwide network along with its lay organization Soka Gakkai.
32 BUDDHIST DIPLOMACY: HISTORY AND STATUS QUO
The Korean Peninsula was split into two countries after the
WWII, and for decades Korean Buddhism was isolated due to the
situation on the peninsula, with factional strife in South Korea’s
Buddhist community and draconian control of monks and temples
by the government in North Korea.138 However, as South Korea
has become a major player in the global economy in the past two
decades, the country sees the need to boost its soft power.139 South
Korea’s Buddhist diplomacy is conducted through government and
non-government collaborations.
34 BUDDHIST DIPLOMACY: HISTORY AND STATUS QUO
Since 2011, South Korea’s largest Buddhist sect Jogye Order has
been actively globalizing Korean Buddhism through overseas visits
and the establishment of administrative networks in the world. Its
leader Ven. Jaseung consciously related Korea’s Buddhist diplomacy
to South Korea’s nation branding. He said, “if Korean Buddhism
was known to the world, the national brand and status could be
spontaneously uplifted together”.140 He told the media at a press
conference in Paris that the Order would concentrate on promoting
Korean Buddhism to the world through a long-term plan to come to
fruition either 10 to 20 years or 40 to 50 years later.141
In June 2012, the Jogye Order and its Central Council of the
Laity organized the 26th World Fellowship of Buddhists Conference
in Yeosu city of South Korea. About 400 delegates from 30 countries
attended the conference. However, a dispute occurred when the
Chinese delegation abruptly returned home in protest against
Tibetan participation of the conference. The Jogye Order accused the
Chinese delegates of “lacking the least respect and consideration”
by politicizing a religious event and demanded an apology. It also
36 BUDDHIST DIPLOMACY: HISTORY AND STATUS QUO
The first sign of a sour relationship between the Dalai Lama and
the Chinese government emerged in 1956 when he went to India to
attend the 2500th anniversary of the Buddha’s nirvana. The Dalai
Lama was reportedly planning to settle in India after the event.
The then Chinese premier Zhou Enlai went to India, with help
from Prime Minister Nehru, and persuaded him to return to Tibet.
Three years later, in 1959, the Dalai Lama fled to India after a failed
Tibetan uprising. Since then, he has gradually shifted from a symbol
of Tibet and Tibetan Buddhism to a symbol of the Tibetan cause and,
eventually, to a symbol of Buddhism in the world.164 Throughout the
years, Tibetan Buddhism has become a fundamental venue through
which the Dalai Lama and his associates have gained international
sympathy and support for their political cause.
Since 1959, the Dalai Lama has made extensive travels and
met with many celebrities in the world. He has received numerous
awards and honors, the highest of which is the 1989 Nobel Peace
Prize. His autobiographies in English and the Hollywood movies
based on his life, such as Kundun and Seven Years in Tibet, helped
in the projection of his globally popular image. He has delivered
numerous speeches on Buddhism, compassion, environment, the
middle-way approach, world peace, religious harmony, and Tibet to
a worldwide audience. He has hosted numerous Tibetan Buddhist
rituals such as “kalachakra” in many countries. All these have
been powerful marketing instruments for Tibetan Buddhism.165
Tibetan monks have set up many monasteries and centers of Tibetan
Buddhism in the West. Their missions focused on the universality
of Buddhist teaching, and as a result the Tibetans have successfully
portrayed themselves to Westerners as a deeply religious and non-
violent people and the hapless victims of Chinese oppression.166
the United States since the Cold War era.167 In 1991, as the Soviet
Union was disintegrating, the Dalai Lama made a historic visit to
the Russian Buddhist republics of Buryatia, Aginski and Kalmykia.
However, when he planned to make another visit in 2010, the
Russian government assured the Chinese government that he would
not be granted a visa.168 In 2011, the South African government
denied the Dalai Lama’s request for a visa allegedly under China’s
pressure.169 Second, some of the Dalai Lama’s followers, including
monks and nuns in Tibet, have showed signs of radicalizing their
cause by engaging in riots (including the 2008 Lhasa unrest) and
by committing a series of self-immolations since 2011, which
have gained sympathy for their cause but may stray away from the
middle-approach that the Dalai Lama advocates. It is likely that
some activist groups of Tibetan monks and nuns may give up the
non-violent approach, which will pose great challenges to both the
Dalai Lama and the Chinese government. Lastly, the 14th Dalai
Lama’s reincarnation will almost certainly become an issue for the
major powers’ diplomacy. As the Chinese government insists that
a reincarnated 15th Dalai Lama must get its approval, the 14th
Dalai Lama has claimed that his successor could be female or found
outside Tibet.170 Foreseeably, if the 15th Dalai Lama is found in the
United States, India, Mongolia, or Russia, he or she would certainly
become a flashpoint between China and the concerning countries.
U.S. officers in Tibet. The letter was addressed to the Dalai Lama “in
his religious capacity, ‘rather than in his capacity of secular leader
of Tibet, so as not to offend the Chinese Government which includes
Tibet in the territory of the Republic of China’”.171 In the 1950s and
1960s, the U.S. government provided financial and military aid to
Tibetan guerrilla forces as part of the its effort to contain Chinese
communists, but it cut official contact with the Tibetan government-
in-exile in the 1970s and 1980s when it established diplomatic
relations with China.172
living in the United States,180 and the country is the top destination
for Buddhist immigrants.181 Such immigrant Buddhists may help
forge enduring religious, cultural, and political links to their Asian
homelands.182
As the world’s only superpower, the United States has been the
top destination of Buddhist immigrants. Although the predominant
religion in the United States is Christianity, ironically it may be
the only country in the world where all sects of Buddhism could
be found. In the past decades, many eminent Buddhist monks have
immigrated to the United States, founded temples and taught Dharma.
Top universities in the United States, such as Harvard University, the
University of Chicago, Yale University, and Columbia University,
have hosted the best academic programs and prominent scholars on
Buddhist research. In this sense, the United States boasts very rich
Buddhist resources. Some even argued that an indigenous American
form of the Dharma, or “American Buddhism”, will emerge.186 With
BUDDHIST DIPLOMACY: HISTORY AND STATUS QUO 43
Endnotes
1. This research uses “Dharma” (translation from Sanskrit), except when
citing directly from text translated from the Pali tradition, which uses
“Dhamma.”
2. Majjhima Nikaya.26; also see The Mahavagga. 5
3. Some argue that this number is grossly underestimated. Statistics on
the Buddhist population in the world vary depending on the definition
of being a Buddhist. The Asoka Mission, an NGO devoted to Buddhism
research and propagation, states that “a fifth of the world population
devotedly follow” the Buddha’s teaching (http://asokamission.in/
sites/default/files/Brochure%20-%20GBC.pdf). Some estimate the
number to be as high as 1.2 billion (See “Buddhists around the world”
at http://www.thedhamma.com/buddhists_in_the_world.htm.)
4. Johnson & Johnson, 2007, p.6
5. Mahavagga.22; Zhong Ahan Jing. 62
6. MN.87; Zhong Ahan Jing. 216
7. AN. 5.49, AN. 10.30, SA. 3
8. Chang Ahan Jing. 17.27; DN. 2
9. SA.3.2.5
10. AN.4.17; DN.2.72; Zeng Yi Ahan Jing.40.2
11. SN. 55.6
12. see Zeng Yi Ahan Jing, 6.3
13. DN.15.22
14. Zen Yi Ahan Jing. 34.2
15. DN.16
16. Cullavagga. 11.12
17. Mahavamsa. 3
18. Mahavamsa. 4
19. Mahavamsa.5
20. Sen, 1999, p. 150
21. Dhammika, 1993
22. Bhikku Pesala, 1991
23. Minor Rock Edicts
BUDDHIST DIPLOMACY: HISTORY AND STATUS QUO 45
54. DN.21
55. SA.35.88
56. see SN.55.1; also see Zeng Yi Ahan Jing 39.8
57. Williams, 2009, p. 11
58. Sen, 2004, p.62, 80
59. 2002, p. 2
60. Vinaya. 1.21, cited from Mettanando, 2000
61. Mettanando, 2000
62. Hirakawa, 1990; MN.69
63. Gao Sen Zhuan, or Biographical Collection of Eminent Monks. 2
64. see AN.8.12; MN.101; AN.4.195
65. Shi Xiang Mai, 2002
66. SN.10.8
67. Neelis, 2011
68. Sinor, 1995
69. Mahavagga.22
70. Sen, 2004, p. 106
71. Williams, 2009, p. 84
72. Sen, 2004, p.108
73. Asoka Mission, 2011
74. Hinuber, 2004, 2010; Salomon, 1995; Sinor, 1995
75. Xiu Ming, 2000
76. Xiu Ming, 2000
77. Sharf, 2011
78. Mahavamsa.18
79. The History of the Qi Dynasty.39
80. Sen, 2004, p. 57
81. Harris, 2005, p. 5
82. Tong, 2010
83. Tong, 2010
84. Sen, 1999, p. 88
85. Barua, 1999; Eliot, 1962
BUDDHIST DIPLOMACY: HISTORY AND STATUS QUO 47
References
Abdi, S. (2007, August 14). Buddhist legacy secures Beijing’s backing for
Indian institution’s rebirth. South China Morning Post, p. 14.
AFP (2012, June 14). S. Korea Buddhists slam China boycott of event.
Retrieved from: http://my.news.yahoo.com/korea-buddhists-slam-china-
boycott-083231348.html.
Audi, T. (2012). U.S. top draw for Christians and Buddhists. The Wall Street
Journal. Retrieved from: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970
204781804577269300274411704.html.
Baumann, M., and Prebish, C.S. (2002). Paying home to the Buddha in
the West. In Prebish, C.S. and Baumann, M. (eds.). Westward Dharma:
Buddhism beyond Asia: p. 1-13. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Bary, W. (ed.) (1972). The Buddhist tradition in India, China & Japan, p. 1.
New York: Random House.
BBC Worldwide Monitoring (2009, August 23). Burma, South Korea strive
to enhance bilateral ties.
Cho, C. (2012, February 8). Korean Buddhist temple food to go global. The
Korea Herald.
Chung, A. (2011, May 9). Seon Buddhism seeks spiritual guidance. Korea
Times.
Chung, A. Ven. (2011, October 2). Korean Buddhist culture lures Parisians,
Korea Times.
Conboy, K., & Morrison, J. (2002). The CIA’s secret war in Tibet. Kansas:
University of Kansas Press.
BUDDHIST DIPLOMACY: HISTORY AND STATUS QUO 53
Do, J. (2011, October 4). Bridging Korean Buddhism and the West. Korea
Times.
Do, J. (2012, January 18). Ven. Jinje to visit US. Korea Times.
Giri, A. (2010). Chinese minister hands Nepal new draft treaty on cultural
ties, December 6. BBC Monitoring South Asia.
Goldstein, M. (1999). The snow lion and the dragon: China, Tibet and the
Dalai Lama. Berkeley: The University of California Press.
Goldstein, M. (2006). The United States, Tibet, and the Cold War. Journal
of Cold War Studies, 8(3), 145-164.
Han, S. (2009, November 23). Buddhist experts stress need for books in
English. Korean Times. Retrieved from: http://www.koreatimes.co.kr/
www/news/art/2011/03/293_55962.html.
54 BUDDHIST DIPLOMACY: HISTORY AND STATUS QUO
Harris, I. (1999). Buddhism and politics in Asia: The textual and historical
roots. In Ian Harris (ed.). Buddhism and politics in twentieth-century Asia:
p. 1-25. New York: Continuum.
Jacob, J. (2011, December 8). A tale of two coalitions. Daily News Analysis
(DNA). Retrieved from: http://www.dnaindia.com/analysis/column_jabin-
t-jacob-a-tale-of-two-coalitions_1622819.
BUDDHIST DIPLOMACY: HISTORY AND STATUS QUO 55
Lee, C. ( 2012, January 17). Jogye Order emphasizes harmony and peace.
The Korea Herald.
Lee, J. (2010, March 30). Buddhists seek return of Korean assets from U.S.
The Korea Herald. Retrieved from: http://www.koreaherald.com/national/
Detail.jsp?newsMLId=20090106000084.
Lee, K. D. (2007). The Prince and the Monk: Shotoku Worship in Shinran’s
Buddhism. Albany: State University of New York Press.
Lee, S. (2007, June 20). George Yeo joins panel to revive historic Indian
varsity. The Straits Times (Singapore).
McMahan, D. (2002). Repackaging Zen for the West. In Prebish, C., and
Baumann, M. (eds.), Westward Dharma: Buddhism beyond Asia: p.218-
229. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Min, I. (2010, November 5). Won Buddhism to bring ethics to G20 politics.
Korea Times. Retrieved from: http://www.koreatimes.co.kr/www/news/
art/2012/04/293_75833.html.
MOFA (2011, November 21). State visit of their Majesties the King and
Queen of Bhutan to Japan. Retrieved from: http://www.mofa.go.jp/region/
asia-paci/bhutan/visit_1111.html.
Naylor, B. (2007). Congress, Bush give Dalai Lama gold medal. National
Public Radio. Retrieved from: http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.
php?storyId=15374199.
Noi, G.S. (2006, November 14). S’pore asked to help revive ancient varsity.
The Straits Times (Singapore).
Overdorf, J. (2012, January 19). China vs. India: the battle for Buddha:
China and India seek to leverage their ties to Buddhism for soft power
in the region. Global Post. Retrieved from: http://mobile.globalpost.com/
dispatch/news/regions/asia-pacific/india/120118/nepal-buddhism-dalai-
lama-china-tibet.
Pal, A. (2006). The Dalai Lama interview. The Progressive. Retrieved from:
http://www.progressive.org/mag_intv0106.
People Daily (2002, December 16). China’s sacred tooth relic of Buddha
arrives in Thailand. Retrieved from: http://english.peopledaily.com.
cn/200212/16/eng20021216_108502.shtml.
58 BUDDHIST DIPLOMACY: HISTORY AND STATUS QUO
People Daily (2006, November 22). Writethru: China, India sign wide-
ranging joint declaration. Retrieved from: http://english.peopledaily.com.
cn/200611/22/eng20061122_323925.html.
Ramachandran, S. (2007). India has its own “soft power”- Buddhism. Asian
Times Online. Retrieved from: http://www.atimes.com/atimes/South_Asia/
IG04Df02.html.
Salomon, R. (1995). On the origin of the early Indian scripts. Journal of the
American Oriental Society, 115(2), 271.
Sen, S. (1999). Ancient Indian History and Civilization (2nd edition). New
Dheli: Age International Publishers.
Shi Xiang Mai (2003). Da Yuan Zhi Yuan Bian Wei Lu (Record on Refuting
the Falsehood in the Year of Zhiyuan of theh Great Yuan Dynasty). Beijing:
Beijing tu shu guan chu ban she (Beijing City Library Press).
Singh, N. K. (2007, July 22). Reviving the open society. The Indian Express,
Retrieved from: http://www.indianexpress.com/news/reviving-the-open-
society/206144/.
Sharf, R. (2011). The Buddha’s finger bones at Famensi and the art of
Chinese Esoteric Buddhism. The Art Bulletin, 93(1), 38-59.
Song, S. (2011, September 21). Seven religious leaders visit North Korea.
The Korea Herald.
Spiro, M. (1982). Buddhism and society: a great tradition and its Burmese
vicissitudes. Berkeley: University of California Press.
The New Zealand Herald (2012, March 20). Washington DC: One hundred
years of cherry blossoms.
The Telegraph (2012, April 6). Dalai Lama behind Tibet protest self-
immolation, says China. Retrieved from: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/
news/worldnews/asia/tibet/9168885/Dalai-Lama-behind-Tibet-protest-
self-immolation-says-China.html.
Tsering, T. (2010). No visa for Dalai Lama, says Russian Envoy. Phayul.com.
Retrieved from: http://www.phayul.com/news/article.aspx?id=27505&t=1
Victoria, B. (2006). Zen at War (2nd edition). Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield
Publishers.
Wales, T. C. (2003). The CIA’s secret war in Tibet. The Journal of Military
History, 67 (1), 294-295.
Wong, E. (2010). No leeway given in picking Dalai Lama. The New York
Times, March 8, p. 6.
Xinhua News Agency (2009, March 3). White Paper on the 50 years’ of
democratic reform in Tibet. Retrieved from: http://www.gov.cn/test/2009-
03/03/content_1248830.htm.
Xinhua News Agency (2009, March 28). World Buddhist Forum discusses
building of world harmony. Retrieved from: http://www.wbf.net.cn/english/
news/11189.htm.
Author Biography
2009/3 The Kosovo Conflict: U.S. Diplomacy and Western Public Opinion
by Mark Smith