FIRTY QUESTIONS

FOR ENGINEER
ALI MIRZA IN
REGART TO HIS
VIEW OF TAKFIR
HUSAM
ENGINEER ALI MIRZA IS ASKE FIFTY QUESTION IN REGARD
TO HIS CONCEPTS OF TAKFIR,KUFR AND KAFIR IN THE
NOMENCLATURE OF ISLAM.

AHLUSSUNNAH

AHLUSSUNNAH WAL
JAMA:”AH

AHLUSSUNNAH VS ALI
MIRZA OF JHELUM

REFUTING ALI MIRZA

3/31/2018
Page 2 of 13
 Page 3 of 13

Engineer “Ali: Mirza: is of the view that if a person reciteth Kalimah, believeth in few articles of ‘Islam,
claimeth to be a Muslim and Doeth not declare any Muslim as a Ka:fir then he continueth to be a
Muslim even if he believeth in some article of Kufr or Shirk or both. In the case of Qa:diya:niah be doeth
not declare them as Ka:fir in the ground that they disbelieve in the finality of Holy Prophet but on the
ground that they declare Muslims as Ka:fir. Similarly Engineer “Ali: Mirza: doeth not declare Nus:airiah
[also known as “Alavites of Syria] as Ka:fir on the graound that they believe Saiyiduna: “Ali: RD: as God
Incarnate or Incarnated God but due to the reason that they declare Muslims as Ka:fir.

Not to declare a person as Ka:fir on the belief of Kufr is a Kufr in itself.

Below fifty questions are asked with some conditions imposed so that the Heresy and Apostasy of the
Engineer “Ali: Mirza: is exposed even to those who have not studied his code of believes strictly,
critically and logically.

It is suspected that instead of answering properly Engineer of Jhelum is suspected to refute these
believes and doeth not declare those how hold these beliefs as Ka:fir.

He may say that these are just the supposed cases. But such tactics only exposeth his belief that he
doeth not consider a person as Ka:fir even if he holdeth some Articles Of Kufr or Shirk or Both under the
following conditions:=

1] Recitation of Kalimah. 2] Believing in few article of ‘Isla:m. 3] Claimimg to be Muslim.4] Doeth not
declare any Muslims as Kafir.

Fifty questions ARE ASKED with these conditioned imposed and it is asked to the respected Engineer
[Respected as a Human Being] just to answer whether he considereth such a person as Kafir or not as a
Ka:fir in the Nomenclature of Shar”..He is not allowed to take the literal meaning.

Let it be seen what are the limits of the Engineer of Jhelum and his sectarian and religious system.

He is requested to answer either in affirmation or negation. No further answer is required.

In each question If such a person existeth then according to ‘Isla:mic Teachings such a person cannot
be a Muslim since if a person believeth in all the articles of ‘Isla:m and believeth in atleast one article of
Kufr/Infidelity then he is not a Muslim. If not a Muslim then a Ka:fir/Infidel.

Any other person who doubts in the Infidelity of such a person is infidel beyond doubt.

Each question is an independent question. So if a Person is supposed such that he believeth in to or

more such belief is also an infidel.

How ever for sake of simplicity each question is independent or the other even if there are some
similarities among some. But similiralities if it existeth among some doeth not effect the independency
of each and every question.
 Page 4 of 13

THE
QUESTIONS
1] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

some THE Divine Knowledge and the Knowledge of the Created Being are exactly Equal with the only
difference that the Divine Knowledge is Essential [Dh:a:ti:] and The Knowledge of the Created Being is
Bestowed [“At:a:’i].

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:f-rullah]

2] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case be believeth that

Some Created Beings have Finite but Essential Knowledge [‘Al “Ilm ‘Adh: Dh:a:ti ‘Al Mah:du:].

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:farullah]

3] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

Qur’a:n that is conveyed to us is Z:anni [Naqlan ‘Ilaina Z:annan].

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:farullah]

4] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that
 Page 5 of 13

Believeth that Parousia Of Saiyiduna Masi:h: doeth not occur.

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:farullah]

5] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

Not a single tradition of Bukh:ariShari:f is reliable.

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:farullah]

6] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

Each one of the Tradition of Holy Muslim is M-h:arr-f as there is Tah:ri:f in Divine Books of Past.

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:farullah]

7] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

Fats of Swine and Pigs are H:ala:l but their meat is H:ra:m.

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:farullah]

8] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

Circumcision is H:ara:m.

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:farullah]

9] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

Beatific Vision of God in Jannah is impossible and shall not occur.

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:farullah]
 Page 6 of 13

10] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

Not a Single H:adi:th: which is accepted as S:ah:i:h: by Muh:addith:u:n is H:ujjah.

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:farullah]

11] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

Divine Knowledge is neither Eternal nor Essential nor Comprehensive , in addition Divine Knowledge is
Mutable.

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:farullah]

12] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

God is Essential Rabb [‘Ar Rabb ‘Adh: Dh:a:ti:] of all the Worlds and Holy Prophet is Bestowed Rabb [‘Ar
Rabb ‘A:a:’i] of all the Worlds.

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:farullah]

13] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

‘Abu: Jahl was not a Ka:fir

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:farullah]

14] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

There are some Hypostases in the Divine Essence of God.

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:farullah]
 Page 7 of 13

15] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

The word Qul in the Su:rah ‘Ikh:la:s: is not a part of Qur’a:n.

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:farullah]

16] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

God can incarnate in Human forms.

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:farullah]

17] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

God can assume Human Natures.

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:farullah]

18] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

God can incarnate in Animal Forms.

19] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

God can assume Animal Natures.

20] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

God can incarnate as a Woman.

21] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

God can assume a female human nature.

22] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that
 Page 8 of 13

Jibri:l “AS is a Manifestation of God.

23] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

God Manifests in Jibri:l “AS.

24] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

Holy Prophet is Manifested God.

25] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

God can die.

26] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

There is Only One Essential God [‘AL ‘ILA:H ‘ADH: DH:ATI: ] and there are several Bestowed Gods [‘AL A-
L-H-H ‘AL ‘AT:-‘IAH]. The Verses in Qur’a:n about Divine Unity means Unity of the Essential God; and that
it is not Shirk to believe in Bestowed Gods but it is Shirk to believe in Essential Gods?

27] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

Prophet “I:sa: “AS was not Elevated above but only His Soul/Spirit was Elevated above?

28] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

”I:sa: “AS was impaled on Cross/Torture Stake but was not crucified on it. He was latter rescued either
by Romans or by his Disciples.

29] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

There is no heaven [Sama:’] above but just an illusion.

30] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

There is neither Paradise nor Hell in Heavens [Sama:va:t] .

31] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that
 Page 9 of 13

One can ask for assistance from Gh:airullah in beyond reason acts [Ma: Fauq ‘Al ‘Asba:b].

32] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

God Hath Bestowed Power to Holy Prophet to make any change in Qur’a:n depending opon his choice
of Will , but Holy Prophet never Exerciseth this Bestowed Power [‘AL QUDRARUL “AT:A’IAH].

33] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

Holy Prophet is not a Human Being but some thing unknown to all Human Minds yet in form of a
Human Being and to be in form of a Human Being doethnot imply to be a Human Being.

34] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

Qur’a:n is Created by God .

35] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

No Human Voluntary Act is Created by God, and these acts are not Creations of God neither in Primary
meanings and nor in Secondary meanings.

36] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

Jibri:l Committed a Mistake in Revealing Qur’a:n to Holy Prophet.

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:f-rullah]

37] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

Saiyiduna “Ali: RD: is Exalted above Holy Prophet “AS.

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:f-rullah]
 Page 10 of 13

38] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

God is only the Creator Of Holy Prophet and the rest of things are Created by Holy Prophet and not by
God neither in the Primary meaning nor in the Secondary meaning.

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:f-rullah]

39] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

God Neither Can See Nor Can Hear a single thing/Sound.

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Asthagh:f-rullah]

40] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

God Hath no Power to forgive a person who died on Kufr and Shirk but Holy Prophet Hath this Power.
How ever Holy Prophet shall never exercise his Power.

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:f-rullah]

41] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

‘Us:ul ‘Al Ka:fi: is more Authentic then Bukh:ari: Shari:f.

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:f-rullah]

42] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

It is H:la:l/Muba:h: to borrow a boundmaid from her owner for sexual activities with the due permission
of her Owner.

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:f-rullah]
 Page 11 of 13

43] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

It is not necessary to Offer Prayers in direction of Ka”bah, it can be any Arbitrary Direction depending
on the will of one who offereth prayers.

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:f-rullah]

44] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

The ‘A:yah << ‘I:YA KA NA”BUDU VA ‘I:YA:KA NASTA”I:M >> of Su:rah Fa:tih:ah is Mansu:kh: either
totally or partially.

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:f-rullah]

45] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

All the Traditions in regard to Dajja:l are incorrect and falsely ascribed to Holy Prophet with out an
exception.

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:f-rullah]

46] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

The “Water is Uncreated and Eternal and was not Created by God in the Beginning of Creations.

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:f-rullah]

47] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not
declare any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

The Creator Exists in some of His Creations [Not in All Creations say Saints etc].

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Asthagh:farullah]
 Page 12 of 13

48] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

There are some Metaphorical Sons Of God but no Real Son Of God, and the verses denying Son(s) of God
are in the meaning of Real Son(s).

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:f-rullah]

49] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

God is Not Eternal but H:a:dith: Bila: Muh:d-th: [Temporal without a Cause /Maker].

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:f-rullah]

50] If a person reciteth Kalimah [K-l-m-h] , believeth in few articles of ‘Isla:m ,claimeth to be a Muslim and doeth not declare
any Muslim as Ka:fir then the person is Ka:fir or not in the case he believeth that

It is not Necessary to believe in the Holy Prophet, one must believe in God and Doomsday/Day of
Resurrection to get salvation.

[Na”udh:ubillah Va ‘Astagh:f-rullah]

Note :Assuming of a Created Nature is a Special case of incarnation which is a special case of Manifestations.

That is why these questions are asked differently.

THANKS

DISCLAIMER

THE AUTHOR IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY MEANING DUE TO ERROR OF THE TYPIST.

THANKS

DISCLAIMER

TO THE MUSLIMS OF THE WORLD

 Page 13 of 13

AS IT IS SHOWN THAT ENGINEER “ALI: MIRZA

IS A HERETIC AND AN APOSTATE, FOR THE
SAKE OF GOD PLEASE DO NOT LISTEN TO HIS
LECTURES UNLESS AND OTHERWISE YOU
HAVE SUFFICIENT KNOWLEDGE TO DETECT
HIS FALLACIES AND APOSTASIES IN HIS
LECTURES. He does not speak truth but he
speaks falsehood and often accuses with
out proper investigation. This is a sufficient
proof that Engineer is a Ka:dh:ib [Speaker of
Falsehood] .
[Note: We do not like to use the words lie and liar, so we are compelled to use the expressions like speaks falsehood or speaker of falsehood]

TO THE FOLLOWERS OF ENGINEER “ALI

MIRZA

HOW MANY PROOFS AND EVIDENCES DO YOU REQUIRE TO CONVINCE YOU

THAT THIS MAN FROM JHELUM IS A APOSTATE, AN INNOVATOR AND A HERETIC
. PLEASE THINK AGAIN. HE IS A PERSON WHO CAN DESTROY YOUR FAITH.