Sunteți pe pagina 1din 6

UHM 2018, Vol. 45, No.

1 – HBO2 THERAPY FOR WOUND COMPLICATIONS AFTER VULVAR MALIGNANCY

Research Report
Hyperbaric oxygen therapy as adjuvant for treating wound complications
after extensive resection for vulvar malignancy
André Lopes, MD 1; Ronaldo Lúcio Rangel Costa, MD 1; Gabriel Lowndes de Souza Pinto, MD 1;
Mariana Camargo Guimarães Forghieri, MD 1; Ailma Larrè, MD 1; Thais Gomes de Almeida, MD 1;
Carla Baltazar de Souza, MD 1; Vivian Sartorelli, MD 1; Francisco Ricardo Gualda Coelho, MD 1;
José Ribamar Branco, MD 2
1 Gynecology Department, Instituto Brasileiro de Controle do Câncer, Sao Paulo, Brazil
2 Hyperbaric Medicine Department, Instituto Brasileiro de Controle do Câncer, Sao Paulo, Brazil
CORRESPONDING AUTHOR: André Lopes – andrelopes1002@hotmail.com
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

ABSTRACT INTRODUCTION
Wound breakdown, necrosis, and infection are among
Introduction: Necrosis, wound breakdown, and infection the major complications associated with radical
represent major complications associated with radical vulvec- vulvectomy for malignant neoplasms. Large resections
tomy. We aimed to analyze the feasibility of hyperbaric oxygen may be required to obtain clear margins, and the use
(HBO2) therapy as an adjunctive treatment for such complica- of surgical flaps is sometimes necessary, whether
tions. for perineal reconstruction or restoration of sexual
Methods: We performed a retrospective analysis of the function, resulting in an extensive wound [1–3].
medical records, clinical charts, and operative records of The aggressive surgical strategy adopted in vulvar
vulvar cancer patients who underwent hyperbaric oxygen cancer is associated with a significant rate of wound
therapy after extensive surgical resection in our institute between complications, which is even higher in patients with
2012 and 2016, with a comparison of the clinical out- large tumors, previous radiotherapy, or preoperative
comes of patients with similar surgical procedures and infection of the surgical site. Such complications
severe wound complications who did not undergo HBO2. may lead to poor wound healing and may com-
Results: A total of 16 patients were included in the study. promise the surgical outcome [4].
In the subgroup treated with HBO2, seven patients were
Hyperbaric oxygen (HBO2) therapy, which consists
identified. Two patients had primary surgery, while five had
of administering 100% oxygen at pressures higher than
recurrent surgery (of these, two had previously undergone
normal atmospheric pressure, enhances the amount
radiation therapy). Six patients received reconstructive flaps
of dissolved oxygen in the plasma, increasing O2
(five myocutaneous and one fasciocutaneous), while one patient
delivery to the tissue. HBO2 therapy has been used
had primary suture. Dehiscence, ischemia and necrosis were
in the treatment of various conditions, including ischemia
estimated to cover 30%-80% of the surgical surface area.
in surgical flaps, wound dehiscence and wound in-
Surgical debridement was performed in six patients. Daily
90-minute sessions in the hyperbaric chamber were per- fection, as well as to promote the recovery of
formed at a pressure of 2.2 atmospheres absolute, with partial radiation-injured tissue [5].
oxygen pressure of 1672 mbar. Infection control and sat- In the present study, we aimed to describe the key
isfactory healing were achieved using 10-61 sessions. All clinical and technical aspects related to the use of
patients in the subgroup who did not receive HBO2 re- HBO2 as an adjunct treatment for wound complications
quired surgical debridement due to partial or near-total flap after extensive vulvar resections.
necrosis, with two reconstructive interventions required.
Conclusions: Hyperbaric oxygen therapy was an efficient METHODS
adjuvant for wound healing and infection control in manag- The study consisted of a retrospective analysis of the
ing wound complications after extensive vulvar resections. records of patients with vulvar carcinoma treated via

_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

KEYWORDS: vulvar cancer; wound complications; hyperbaric oxygen therapy

Copyright © 2018 Undersea & Hyperbaric Medical Society, Inc. 27


UHM 2018, Vol. 45, No. 1 – HBO2 THERAPY FOR WOUND COMPLICATIONS AFTER VULVAR MALIGNANCY

____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Table 1. Demographic, clinical, and operative characteristics of seven patients


with vulvar carcinoma treated with surgical resection and hyperbaric oxygen therapy
characteristic _______________________________ patient ________________________________
i ii iii iv v vi vii
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

baseline characteristics
age, years 42 57 70 85 93 76 79
previous radiotherapy no no no no yes no yes
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

comorbidities
diabetes mellitus no yes yes yes no no yes
overweight status no obese overweight no overweight no overweight
hypertension no no no no no yes no
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

operative details
treatment recurrent primary recurrent primary recurrent recurrent recurrent
histology squamous melanoma squamous squamous squamous squamous squamous
stage ii iiic iiic ib iiic iiic iiia
tumor size, mm 35 45 60 22 75 75 56
surgical flap bilateral bilateral unilateral primary unilateral unilateral bilateral
suture
flap type fascico- myocu- myocu- - myocu- myocu- myocu-
cutaneous taneous taneous taneous taneous taneous
flap source local gracilis tensor - gluteus gracilis gracilis
fascia lata maximus
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

postoperative course
days to dehiscence 12 6 16 12 10 5 20
area of dehiscence, 80 60 40 80 30 60 50
ischemia, and necrosis, %
HBO2 sessions 10 30 10 11 22 61 40
hospitalization, days 6 63 10 24 31 31 133
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Vulvar melanoma was staged according to the 7th edition of the staging manual published by the American Joint Committee on Cancer.
Other vulvar cancers were staged according to the system put forth in 2009 by the International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics.

surgical resection in our institution between October A comparison of the clinical outcomes of patients with
2012 and March 2016, followed by HBO2 for the treat- similar extensive vulvar resection and severe wound
ment of wound dehiscence, ischemia and infection. complications who did not undergo HBO2 therapy was
Data regarding the characteristics of the patients, asso- performed. Regarding HBO2, the analysis included
ciated clinical conditions, and features of the vulvar technical aspects such as the number of sessions in the
neoplasia were collected. With the exception of vulvar hyperbaric chamber, as well as data regarding tolerance
melanoma, which was staged as skin melanoma to the treatment, clinical evolution and adverse effects.
according to the 7th edition of the staging manual pub-
lished by the American Joint Committee on Cancer, RESULTS
other types of vulvar cancer were staged according A total of seven patients with vulvar carcinoma were
to the system put forth in 2009 by the International treated with extensive surgical resection in our insti-
Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics [6,7]. Details tution between October 2012 and March 2016 and
regarding prior treatment, type of surgical procedure received HBO2 for the treatment of wound dehiscence,
performed, and use of flaps for reconstruction were also ischemia and infection (Table 1). Among these seven
recorded, together with the results of the clinical evalu- patients included in our analysis, six were histologically
ation and further treatment of wound complications. diagnosed with squamous cell carcinoma, while one

28 Lopes A, Costa RLR, Pinto GLS, et al.


UHM 2018, Vol. 45, No. 1 – HBO2 THERAPY FOR WOUND COMPLICATIONS AFTER VULVAR MALIGNANCY

_________________________________________________________________________________________

Table 2. Overview of clinical outcomes in patients


with vulvar carcinoma treated with surgical resection,
with or without hyperbaric oxygen therapy
patients hospital stay total surgical flap recurrent
median/days debridements loss disease
HBO2 7 27 6 0 3
No HBO2 9 31 10 2 3
_________________________________________________________________________________________

HBO2 = hyperbaric oxygen therapy

was diagnosed with malignant melanoma. The average Sessions in the hyperbaric chamber took place daily,
age in our study population was 70 years (age range, lasted 90 minutes, and used a pressure of 2.2 at-
42-85 years). Two patients had primary surgery, while mospheres absolute, with a partial O2 pressure of
five had recurrent tumors, and two such patients had 1672 mbar. The minimum number of HBO2 sessions
previously undergone radiation therapy. Type II diabetes required to achieve infection control and satisfactory
mellitus was noted in four patients. Overweight status healing was 10, while maximum number of sessions
or grade I obesity was also noted in four patients. was 61, with a median of 22 sessions. No adverse
Preoperative infection of the surgical site was noted effects related to HBO2 were reported.
in six patients, who were treated with antibiotics both We also performed a comparison of the clinical out-
pre- and postoperatively. comes of patients who were also treated with extensive
Five radical vulvectomies were performed, two of vulvar resection and had equally severe wound com-
which involved bilateral inguinal lymphadenectomy and plications but who did not undergo HBO2 therapy.
en bloc resection with butterfly incision. Another patient Nine such patients were treated between 2001 and
received wide perineal resection for recurrent disease 2014, four of whom had prior radiation treatment, and
after vulvectomy, and the remaining patient underwent three had recurrent disease. The patient characteristics
resection for lymph node recurrence in the inguinal and clinical features were similar in patients treated
region. Of the seven patients included in the analysis, with HBO2 and those not treated with HBO2.
five underwent inguinal lymphadenectomy during the Among the nine patients who were not treated with
same surgical procedure. Reconstructive flaps were HBO2, all received radical vulvectomy, two involving
used in six patients, as follows: three patients received bilateral inguinal lymphadenectomy and en bloc resec-
a gracilis myocutaneous flap (bilateral in two patients tion with butterfly incision. The median length of hos-
and unilateral in one); the remaining three patients pitalization was 27 days (range, eight to 55 days). All
received a myocutaneous gluteus maximus flap, a myo- patients received antibiotics. In seven of nine patients,
cutaneous tensor fascia lata flap, and a bilateral fascio- at least one myocutaneous flap was necessary, and all
cutaneous local flap, respectively. The remaining patient such flaps required surgical debridement due to partial
had primary suture. Three patients had distant meta- flap necrosis (in one case, two surgical procedures
stasis, one of whom also developed a local recurrence. were required). A fasciocutaneous flap was performed
Wound breakdown occurred between the fifth and in the remaining two of nine patients, both with near-
20th postoperative days. The estimated area of dehis- total necrosis of the flaps requiring surgical interven-
cence, ischemia and necrosis ranged from 30% to 80% of tion. One of these patients required not only debride-
the flap surface area. Surgical debridement of necrotic ment but also a myocutaneous gluteal flap, whereas the
tissue was performed in six patients. Postoperatively, all other patient had surgical debridement with Z-plasty
patients received antibiotic therapy for a period of time. and suture. No perioperative deaths were recorded
The median length of hospital stay was 31 days (range, among the nine patients who did not receive HBO2, but
six to 130 days). New surgical flaps were not required three patients had recurrent disease (one within less
in any patient. A representative example of the clinical than six months from the initial treatment) (Table 2).
course for patients included in our analysis is provided
in Figure 1.

Lopes A, Costa RLR, Pinto GLS, et al. 29


UHM 2018, Vol. 45, No. 1 – HBO2 THERAPY FOR WOUND COMPLICATIONS AFTER VULVAR MALIGNANCY

A B C

D E F

Figure 1. Peri- and postoperative photographs documenting the course of a recurrent squamous cell vulvar carcinoma
in a 79-year-old woman with a history of surgery and adjuvant radiotherapy (patient VII).
(A) Pre-operative state. (B) After radical resection. (C) After reconstruction with a bilateral myocutaneous gracilis flap. (D) Postoperative
wound breakdown, infection, and ischemia of the surgical flaps. (E) Wound healing and infection control after antibiotic treatment,
surgical debridement, and 40 sessions of hyperbaric oxygen therapy. (F) State at final follow-up (60 days after the end of the treatment).

DISCUSSION therapy encounter problems with wound healing.


Following radical surgery for malignant neoplasms of Irradiated tissues result in reduced wound strength,
the vulva, early complications are most frequently re- poor vascularization, diminished collagen deposition
lated to wound breakdown, infection and necrosis. and impaired formation of fibrotic tissue. These long-
Such complications are associated with considerable term effects of radiotherapy may result in delayed
morbidity, and their incidence has been reported to be or even non-healing wounds with difficult clinical
up to 60%. However, limited information is available management. HBO2 treatment has proven to be very
regarding the management of such complications [2 8]. useful in enhancing the vitality and aiding the recovery
Locally advanced tumors, en bloc resection, radical of previously irradiated affected tissues [9, 10].
surgery, diabetes mellitus, history of malignancy, and Ischemia and necrosis of the surgical flap represent
previous radiotherapy represent factors associated with serious complications after extensive vulvar resection.
an even higher rate of complications. The management HBO2 therapy has been found to promote flap salvage
of such patients poses a real challenge, as these local and reduce the need for a new flap. Hyperbaric oxygen
complications may evolve into systemic manifestations improves the viability of compromised irradiated tissues
such as sepsis, which carry a high risk of death [8]. In or that of tissues with hypoxia and decreased perfusion
particular, patients who previously underwent radio- [11]. Although surgical debridement of devitalized tis-

30 Lopes A, Costa RLR, Pinto GLS, et al.


UHM 2018, Vol. 45, No. 1 – HBO2 THERAPY FOR WOUND COMPLICATIONS AFTER VULVAR MALIGNANCY

sue was necessary in six of the seven patients included whom also had local recurrence. All three patients
in our analysis, there was no need for a new surgical with recurrence had poor prognosis, with locally ad-
flap. As our analysis involved a small number of patients, vanced disease and lymph nodes positive for macro-
our observations do not have sufficient statistical power metastasis. Only one patient had a disease-free interval
to indicate that HBO2 was the sole contributor to the of less than six months after HBO2. Therefore, it is
favorable outcome of the surgical flaps. Nevertheless, unlikely that the observed recurrences were related
based on literature reports, the contribution of HBO2 in any way to the use of HBO2 [10,12,13,14].
in the recovery of devitalized tissues cannot be denied. While HBO2 therapy is usually well tolerated, ad-
It should be noted that, while HBO2 therapy represents verse effects may occur during the treatment, including
a well-established strategy for the management of in- feelings of anxiety and claustrophobia, as well as dis-
fections and soft tissue necrosis, and moreover, is well comfort related to the difficulty in equalizing pressure
accepted as an adjunct treatment in surgical debride- in the middle ear. Oxygen-induced side effects may
ment, HBO2 is neither required nor recommended in also occur, including myopia (usually temporary)
patients with uncompromised flaps [9]. Overall, our and convulsions, the latter being less frequent but
results indicate that HBO2 can play a significant and more serious. In our study, good tolerance for HBO2
positive role as an adjunct in the treatment of wound was observed in all patients, and none of the treat-
complications. Surgical debridement of devitalized ments was discontinued because of adverse effects [5].
tissues, antibiotic therapy, and daily care of the
surgical wound were equally important factors in CONCLUSIONS
the surgical outcome. Our retrospective analysis of clinical records of vul-
The physiological action of HBO2 is related to the var cancer patients treated with surgical resection re-
increased oxygen supply. Short-term effects of HBO2 vealed that HBO2 used as adjunctive treatment may
therapy include vasoconstriction and reduction of ede- have played a key role in the control of surgical site
ma, which translates into anti-inflammatory activity infection, in the healing process, and in the recovery
and phagocytosis activation with bacteriostatic and bac- of ischemic flaps. Based on the results of our present
tericidal effect. Long-term effects of HBO2 treatment study, we conclude that HBO2 can provide good results
are related to the high concentration of oxygen present in the treatment of wound complications after exten-
in the plasma during administration of HBO2, which sive vulvar resections. As our study had a retrospec-
promotes neoangiogenesis and stimulates collagen pro- tive design and included a very small sample, further
duction by fibroblasts. Clinically, these effects translate research is warranted to confirm the generalization of
into faster wound healing, better infection control and our findings for vulvar cancer patients and to determine
enhanced recovery of previously irradiated tissues [9,11]. the effect of HBO2 on certain types of cancer, as well
Regarding the possible recurrence of the disease in as to clarify the mechanisms underlying these effects.
oncological patients exposed to hyperbaric oxygen,
HBO2 is considered safe for use in patients with malig- Acknowledgments
nant neoplasms, as indicated by several research articles This research received no support from a specific grant in the
public or private sector.
and systematic reviews. There is currently no evidence
indicating that HBO2 acts as a stimulator of tumor
The authors declare no conflicts of interest exist with this
growth or recurrence, although limited data are avail- submission.
able regarding the use of HBO2 in patients with vulvar
cancer. Of our seven patients who received HBO2
therapy, three developed distant metastasis, one of

Lopes A, Costa RLR, Pinto GLS, et al. 31


UHM 2018, Vol. 45, No. 1 – HBO2 THERAPY FOR WOUND COMPLICATIONS AFTER VULVAR MALIGNANCY

_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

REFERENCES

1. Höckel M, Dornhöfer N. Vulvovaginal reconstruction for 9. Kalns JE, Dick EJ Jr, Scruggs JP, Kieswetter K, Wright JK.
neoplastic disease. Lancet Oncol. 2008; 9: 559-568. Hyperbaric oxygen treatment prevents up-regulation of angiogenesis
2. Leminen A, Forss M, Paavonen J. Wound complications in following partial-thickness skin grafts in the pig. Wound Repair
patients with carcinoma of the vulva. Comparison between radical Regen. 2003; 11: 139-144.
and modified vulvectomies. Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol. 2000; 10. Feldmeier J, Carl U, Hartmann K, Sminia P. Hyperbaric oxygen:
93: 193-197. does it promote growth or recurrence of malignancy? Undersea
3. Baiocchi G, Mantoan H, de Brot, et al. How important is the Hyperb Med. 2003; 30: 1-18.
pathological margin distance in vulvar cancer? Eur J Surg Oncol. 11. Bennett MH, Feldmeier J, Hampson NB, Smee R, Milross C.
2015; 41: 1653-1658. Hyperbaric oxygen therapy for late radiation tissue injury.
4. Hampson NB, Holm JR, Wreford-Brown CE, Feldmeier J. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2016; 4: CD005005.
Prospective assessment of outcomes in 411 patients treated with 12. Feldmeier JJ, Heimbach RD, Davolt DA, Brakora MJ,
hyperbaric oxygen for chronic radiation tissue injury. Cancer. 2012; Sheffield PJ, Porter AT. Does hyperbaric oxygen have a cancer
118: 3860-3868. causing or -promoting effect? A review of the pertinent literature.
5. Weaver LK. Hyperbaric oxygen therapy indications. 13th ed. Undersea Hyperb Med. 1994; 21: 467-475.
North Palm Beach, FL: Best Publishing Company, 2014. 13. Daruwalla J, Christophi C. Hyperbaric oxygen therapy for
6. Edge SB, Compton CC. The American Joint Committee on malignancy: a review. World J Surg. 2006; 30: 2112-2131.
Cancer: the 7th edition of the AJCC cancer staging manual and the 14. Moen I, Stuhr LEB. Hyperbaric oxygen therapy and cancer—
future of TNM. Ann Surg Oncol. 2010; 17: 1471-1474. a review. Target Oncol. 2012; 7: 233-242.
7. Pecorelli S. Revised FIGO staging for carcinoma of the vulva, ✦
cervix, and endometrium. Int J Gynaecol Obstet. 2009; 105: 103-104.
8. Reedy MB, Capen CV, Baker DP, Petersen WG, Kuehl TJ.
Hyperbaric oxygen therapy following radical vulvectomy: an
adjunctive therapy to improve wound healing. Gynecol Oncol. 1994;
53: 13-16.

32 Lopes A, Costa RLR, Pinto GLS, et al.

S-ar putea să vă placă și