56
‘Tom Alexander
Southwestern Energy Company
‘Moncton, New Brunswick, Canada
Jason Baily
‘Sugar Land, Texas, USA
Chuck Boyer
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA
Bill Clark
George Waters
(Oklahoma City, Okehoma, USA
Valorie Jochen
Coitege Station, Taxes
Jost Le Calvo
Houston, Texas
Rick Lewis
Camron K. Miller
Dattas, Texas
John Thaelor
Southnestorn Energy Company
Houston, Texas
Brian E.Toollo
Denver, Colorado, USA
‘ais Rv tn 70.8.
Coop 208 Sesoborge,
aan af ta re, ants Dog
/ Waren Puan Danaea and, Jane Weln
er Marmron Fanaa, Oma
(hy Denon Acar aah Hayat Hout.
(0, EUPSE eoseape, Es, LAN, HA cS,
RA HRA Pa, Pam rae, Sve Sean,
Sonedcope SpecveLtn Stnntar, SinMAP LIVE TRA
‘rd ISABE are ars Searbrge
"Gola enzal conser suri pailes
et trsetane tobe oy sie Spr
‘ange a abauca to 623 irra
2 Syn OH wn do Feoae NA Geof Enlosrs
Jot bang Hasse USB Satrwer
Heinenaen,
Shale Gas Revolution
Around the globe, comp:
‘to find the next Barnett Sh
resources req
‘more than just finding organi
9S are aggressively pursuing shale resource plays, hoping
But developing and producing from these enigmatic
th shales and hydraulically
‘fracturing them, As the shale gas revolution gains momentum globally, exploration
companies are discovering that an integrated approach is essential to success.
‘Learning from past experience:
3nd continually improving methodologies may not
‘quarantee success, but ts likelihood is greatly improved.
From the advent ofthe moder ol and gs indus
‘ny petroleum geolgtts have followed a conven
‘sonal routo for exploration: look for hpdrveasbon
souroe rocks, find reservoir quality roeks where
Ihydoocarbons ean accurate, identify @ trap-
phgmeetanism and then dil a wel, But a revo
Ito talking place inthe &P industry. Rocks
that in the past were of ite interest, other than
aspotental sourc rocks, are today being actively
pursed as potential resorts, When considering
‘unconventional resourc play, the foes is on
nding organic shal.
‘Tae Barnott Shalo of contra! Tas, USA, is
recognized asthe play that initiated the recent
Ingavest in developing shales as producing reser
‘ors, This development represen a fndamen-
tal. shift in the way exploration companies
‘consider resource plays Te two main enabling
technologies that have made shale plays econom-
ical sro extonded reac horizontal iting and
rovlistage hydraulic facture stimulation
However, operators have discovered that there is
much more to produeing gas from source rocks
than drilling horizontal wells and Bydraulically
fracturing them,
Engineers and geologists studying shale gas
resources find that having a groaior undor
standing of a reservoir can lead to process
‘adapiation and roinement of toehniques. I is
important to integrate data from many sources
and at mang soale to optimally dr, complete
and stimulate wells to ptoduee lydrocarbons
‘rom their source rocks,
‘This arlile reviews lessons lesrnod from 80
years of shale development and Joks a some of
{he tools used to annlyzo shales Taking an into
‘rated approach to developing its Payotteile
Shale play, one operator was rewarded for its
cffors, ms ovidoneed by increased gas produc
tion and improved operational efficiencies, In
snother example, a large production lg study
using data from sx major shale basins in the US,
uncovered roslts that may impact rilng and
stimulation practices.
Shale Reservoir Charnetersties
‘Shales are ine-grainod rorks that form from te
compaction of it and ela-sz0d parties: Sit
‘oreent ofthe Kart’ sedimentary crust consist
of shale, and it is the primary source rock fo
rmostof the conventional yrocarbon deposis in
‘tho work? Beesuso shales ar formed from mud
‘hey are often roferted to as mudstones, Shal
are differentiated from olher claystones and
smudstones in that they are laminated—sinel
layered—and fissile, which means they eana
5
2a
cael
oe
cr
ra
a
=
cn
J
cel
cat
oa
=
Compl
came
project
re
my
re
ect
oe
coe
sxe
sate
Ered
veh
China
doysee
fom
nat
Deve
Pita)
bie
tes)
‘Organic shales. St
are fine-grained file sedans found in lyors. They may be fractured and
ray breakin sheets along cher laminations (inset). Grganierich shales ae characterized by higher
ie earbon than other sh
are the primary targets
levels of total org
organie-sich sha
inthe rango of 2% t0 10%. Thermally matura
poration
wa | a per es
Pecod ‘america | Amorica | £0"P® | Canral Asia | ATE® | ‘and Asia
ore
Pe 1
ee eal apa ae eile
|esetad saat -
me |e r 7
i
Tim
: :
=e
La
= ate =
{ % — hema
Soni ace fi
Lie
sume | 7
L
cate
L ow
a
Porn ea cat ieee aati
om
‘Global distribution of organic merino shales by geologic peviod. Tectonics, geography and climatic
conditons contribute tothe deposi of arganic-ich sedimans. Organie-ich marine shales e
found across the globe. (Black circles roprosent the number of occurrences for each age}
Exploration companies have focused on marine sediments that have sufficient thermal maturity to
‘convert kerogan inta hydrocarbon to develo as recoureo plays. Lecustine shales from shallow,
freshwater dapasits (not shown) are also targets of expiration but have not yet proved tobe as
prolife as their maine counterparts. (Adapted fram Tourtlo, eference 4)
2
broken or split info sheets along their lami
ors (Jef). Depending on their maturity an
mineralogy they may also be easily fractured.
For all oir abundance, few shale deposi
‘ean be developed as ydrocarbon resoutee pl
"The targts for gas shale exploration are ong
rich sediments that were doposived in such
mamer as to preserve a signifleant fraction
the original organic mater tat eventually ser
a5 the feedstock for hydrocarbon generat
Once generated, much of the hyétorarb
remains trapped in the uilralow:permeabii
‘oek matrix, unable to migrate,
‘Organi ie shale formations form under
ceil eonitions—tigh levels of onganic matte
and law levels of exggen— Modern anelog for orgenic-ic shel. Decay f organic meterilis a bactral process thet occurs
under aerobic conditions; imitad anaerobic bacterial atv can also occur under anoxe condons.
The Black Sea's stratified with an upper oxdzed layer anda lower anoxic zone Freshwater (green
arrows) lows in fram vers, an denser seawtor bie arrow) flows in fram the Medterranoen Sea
via the Bosporus Svait Because ofthe efferent salinities and densites, ming is imtod tothe
uppermost 100 to TE0 (230 to 490. The mixing botween surface water and bottom water i strongly
rastictod tha wotor at the bottom is exchanga¢ aly cnca in e thousand year. Blac, organic
sediments accumulate on the bottom. Anaerobic bacteria stp oxygen from suites and give off
hnyrogen sud [HS] 98a waste product. The hydragon sulle may react with ron inthe sediments
tof rte Fes, whichis raqony cbsaredn anh shale een Adare ron
Bogen
yoartone generis —>
aan
Moraga
Tarsince [Ondo —
Crgeness
Dagrase
Inoaing apt and ong
‘Maturation stages in hydrocarbon generation. The processes of burial,
conversion of organic matter and generation of hyétocarbons ean be
‘summarized in thre steps, laganesis:cherectrtzed by lon-tampareture
below 8080 [122°F|—corversion of orgaric mater to kerogen, Beeteria may
Aigestand convert some of tho organic mattar into biogenic methane.
Ccatagenasis: ganerally occurs as further burial asus in more pressure end
Increased heat in the range of 50°C to 150°C [122 to 302], which causes
cherical bonds to braak within the shale and the kerogen Metagenesiesthe
final stage, invihich heat and chemical changes transform keragen to
‘carbon, During tis stage, lata methane, or dry gas, evolves, alongwith other
gases, including COs, Nz and HS. Hydrocarbons produced in earn stages,
feventualy convert to mathene, as wall. Temperatures range fom about
OPC to 200°C [302° to $82"F and highor.
“eal Organi Carbon Weight % Resour Pour
<05 Vero
wi Peer
tz ai
Za tod
a0 Way gn
31) Wain
‘The relationship borwo
total organic carton and resource potenti.ager
ars
ow
‘The total carbon in shale sample fncludes
both inorganic and organic eaxbon. To quantify
organic. carbon, enginoors use a combustion
fechnique.’ small portion of tho rock sample is
first treated with phosphoric scid to remove
inorganic carbon. Sediments are dried and then.
combusted ai 1860°C (2462°F] in an owgen-
rich envionment. The organic carbon is oxidized
fo form C0, which lows through a nondisper
sive indvared detection cell tne to respond to
(00>, The measured gas volumes are conver to
‘TOC measurement and recorded as a weight
pereent of the rock
‘TOC values may vary greatly across a reser.
volt section, But because it Is not feasible to
‘qulte and thon analyze cores over long into.
vals, petrophysiests commonly use downhole
dala fom gooehercal and conventional lasing
sults to quantify tho volume of kerogen in tho
rock and then compute TOC values from these
dats To validate the models used fo measure
706, seientiss calibrate petrophysieal dats to
‘core deriv values,
Gas wokame aod capacity Gas is adsorbed
‘on te sic ofthe kerogen in the shale and is
‘abo ftely distributed in te primary and second:
ary porosity. The total gas in place (IP) isthe
‘combination of slsoebe and fee gas, Depenling
‘on the initial pressure ofthe reser 2s fee gas
{s produned and the pore pressure fll, adsorbed
‘sill liberated, or desorb, rom the suince of
the kerogen. Howerer, recent research indicatas
tat desorption is ls a function of he shale pore
sae, which seientists must consider when estima
ng resource potential!
‘Selentst sometimes use eanister desorption
‘sts to determine the total GIP from cores.
[nmediatoly upon retetoval, freely cut oro sa
ples are sealed in canisters and sent to the labo-
‘ator for testing. The gas fs removed from the
‘anlster, volumetrically measurod and compost
‘tionally analyzed asa funtion of time. A plot of
gs produced overtime ean be used to estimate
‘the GIP forthe core sample at reservoir conde
tions, This analyis i snetive to the amount of
‘ime it takes to eerie the core from downhole
‘To determine adsorbed gas volume for shales,
engineers use prossare relationships that estimate
the sorptive potential ofthe rock. Samples re pak
‘vere to maximize surface area ard then heated
(o deivo off any adsorbed gas. Samples are then
‘exposed to methane at increasingly high pressure
wile held at a constr temperature. The volume
of gas adsorbed by tho roek samplo, prosonted
‘n units of stadasd evbie footton (Seton), is
sero by a Langan thor eure nn
Onco an isotherm is established, the storage
capacity of the rock ean be determined by refer-
encing the pore pressure othe formation, whichis
representative of to in sity reserie pressure.
Enginoers ase the Langrirfsothors frome
care data to compute the adsorbed gas from log
derived T0C data. They compute free gas lunes
from logderved effective porosity ad gas satu
ration, after subtracting the computed pore
ume oocupied by the adsorbed gs, Pr
cmluation requires geochemical and petropt
cal input inetuing elay content an type, ma
density formation water and bound water 1
‘iste, affective porslty and gas saturation
‘Thermal maturity Thermal maturity |
function of depositional history. AS keroge
‘exposed 10 progressively higher temperat
‘over time, vitrinto—eellvall materia
‘woody plant tissue preserved inthe rock —un
oes imewerible alteration and dove
Increased rollectance, ‘Tho measurement
ite reflectance (R,) was originally de
oped to rank coal maturity.
‘Ry is determined by microscope meas
ments ofthe reflectivity of af Least 90 gain
itrinte from a roek sample: Values ype
‘ange ftom OX to 8% Moasuroments in exces
1.5% aze a. sign of dry gas-generating so
ca past indleator fr gas shales, ran
of 06% to 08% indleat ol and rangos of 0.
1.18 indicate wot gas. Initial, ol and con
sate wore oonsidered negative indicators
‘Shale development bwrver, some operators i
‘nad sneoes proscing ot) and condensate i
shale and lower Ry values can be consdere
sitive indicator in these cases. A reflect
value below 0.6 i indativ of kerogen tha
immature, not having been exposed to sufi
thecal conditions over adequate time fr «
version ofthe organi material to tydtocarbo
es *
Cag tri
sens ape
wl stl — sree 4
ite
a} heen Et
3 Z Sw -
: Gasca stor q ae
aq 5 a
al : al ea
Car pavoft)= |
suneoee ce
ae an eam 8 a a
Twos. es
‘Langue isothe
and gas storage
bhottomfie flowing pressure dectines.
“
city. The Langu isotherm (gold, oft s derived trom crushed rock samples and quantifies a rock's adsorb
storage eapaeity. The Langmuir volume, (od line, is he theoretical int for gas adsorption at infin
can be determined from tho plot. The Lingmuic pressure, A, (vorical blue lng) is the pressure aha the Langmuir volume. Using the Langmult isotherm
‘otal IP imagent; right for a spociic reservoir can be detarrined as a function of pressure. The total gasis the gas adsorbed to kerogen (gol) andi
26 storadin poras (blu). At ow prossure, adsorption is an ofactive gas storaga mochanism. As the pressure increasos, pore gas corraspondingly
increases. Productty of most ofthe organic shale reservoirs being developed today is civen by volume of pre ges. Desorption becomes important as
rossure. Storage capacty ata gwen prassue,
oiielaPormenbility—One of the most difienlt
properties to quanti when characterizing
shales is permoabiliy to gas, which ean range
fromm 0001 to 0:9000001 mD. Permeability is 2
fonction of efiective porosity, hydrocarbon sat
ration and mineralogy. Conventional reservis
have permeabilities inthe hundeds of mllidar
ies, several orders of magnitude greater chan
‘that observed in shales, Engineers measure por-
reabilty of conventional rocks by forcing, id
through cores and measuring the volume and
rate of fluids a8 they pass through the sample.
‘Shale permeabilities inthe nanodaxey range pre
‘elude this conventional apprvach,
‘Trea dovolopod the TRA tight rock analy.
‘is pyrolysis tachnique to quantify ultralow per
resbiliy in unconventional formations’ Ta
dalton to permesbily, the TRA technique pro-
vides bulk and grain denaity, total and effective
porosity, water and hydrocarbon saturation, gas-
Aled poosty, bound Iydeocarbon saturation and
clay-bound water volume
Reservar permeability can aso be estimated
from short duration nittogeninjection falloit
tests, These tests provdesysiem permeability and
take into account not only the matrix permeability
Dbutaso the infuence of natural fractuces,
Minoralogy-—Shales can have eomplex mix:
‘ures ofminorls, and the relative concentrations
of te constituents have the potential to make or
Droaksa potential nesouroe play. Core samples can
provide & wealth of information about the geo
chemistry and minerlogy, but are limited t the
specific location whore the saraple was retrieved
Mineralogy is more often determined from poo
physical data acquired ftom dowatole logging
tools, which are calbrated to core data
Petrophysical Date
‘The primary data used for petrophyseal analysis.
of shale formations are the same as those used
{or conventional reservotranalysis—gamma ry,
resistivity, porosity and acoustio—vith he ad
ton of neutron capture spectroscopy data Just
ss conventional oll and gas wes have key indiew-
‘ors for production, shales with hydrocarbon pro
Action potential display speciic characteristics
‘hat sot thom apart fom shales wih litle or no
tential (above mihi),
Petrophysical analysis of shales beans with
‘one ofthe most basic measurements: the gamma
raylog. may provide ono ofthe firs indicators
of the presence of onginictich shale, Organic
raiter eommonly contains higher levels of nto
rally geoung radleacitve materals—thoriam,
Potassium and uraniam—than do conventional
‘Auurna 2011
Gamay
we
Rasiny
ie
Dey Foy iain
a x
NeoPa reste
‘Prospecting with exiting laguing data. Petrophysicists use conventions
triple-combo logging date to identity potential organi shele deposits. The
bot 50 fof this lg spans e conventional shele (sue shading). The ganna
ray Track 1) reads (oss than 180 gAPL The rasisvty (Tack 2)is low and has
‘consstont valu, The density and neutron porosts [Track 3) are separated
and exhibit litle variety. Compared with the conventional shal, the
‘organic shale section red sheding) has a higher gamma ray reading, higher
‘and variable resistivity values and higher density porosity, the neutron
porosity nasa higher dagreo of varibil
‘The nautton porosity is eften lowor
Inorganic shales bocause they nave a lower volume of bound water.
reservoir minerals. Because they have a higher
‘concentration of organie matter than other sedl-
smonta,organitich sholes often cxhihit gamma
ay opunis in excess of 150 gAPL Petrophysicists
use high gumma ray counts to Monty organic.
rich shale formations; howover, somo formations
‘of Oretaceous, Mesovoie and Tertiary ag nay not
spay this artifact,
‘Thiple-combotoostrings, such asthe Platform
Expross infagrated wireline logging tool, provide
resistvity and porosity measurements. They also
provide petrophysleal characteristics to help log
analssts iontify potontial gas-bearing shales,
Pr instance, the resistivity measurements in
‘s-bearng shales aro usually higher than those
‘nurrounding shales tha have no gs potontia
1. Bead 88, Send Wand Boats "Deteeatan
‘Tt Cahn, al rane Cahn arpa
Caan in Samant,” Ctege Stor, Tse, USA,
‘Dla eter and BAS Lars ea,
gdb cen sie. cresleterrel
NOK muthocsTO pet incest Det 22
{ Anbeso Ri Harnse Riz Cae MAY
‘td Sonera Hon Pare-Sel Carano
Sle Gin Pace Caeustons paper Se 18172
[sserted athe SPE Uncorveniona Ses Coven,
Prtsbrgh, Punter USD Fabry 22,200.
8 BojersertarancePorosity measurements also have distinct
‘characteristics in gas-bearing shales, In general,
‘conventional shales exhibie a uniform separation
bebwrocn tho donsiyporestiy and neutron poras-
ity measaroments. Organicrich shales with
hydrocarbon production potential, howerec,
coxhibit more variability, higher density porosity
and Tower neutron porosy. This response is
paraly a result of the presence of gas inthe roe,
‘veh lowers the Bydrogen index and the resul-
Ing neutron porosity. A ower neutron porosity
‘may also oocur in organi shales because of the
lower clay-mineral content in organic: shales
compared with typical shales.
‘As forthe density porosity measurement, the
constituent materials that make up shales gone
ally have higher bak densities then those of co
‘yentonal reseivirroeks sock as sandstone oF
Imestone In conteas, kerogen has a much Lower
Dall density (2 gm?) than sandsione okie:
stone, and is presence ean Tead toa higher eom
puted porosity, Toaecurstely compute the density
porosity of a shale, engineers must know the
sain density ofthe rock in question, The grain
density is primarily derived fom the BOS ele-
‘menial capture spectroscopy foal, The BCS too!
alo provides kerogen estimation fr correcting
‘tho grain density.
Pormation evaluation to characterize uncon-
ventional reservoirs depends heavy on under
standing the mineralogy of rocks, The
charaeteration ean bo done by analysing cores,
but this method is neither efiiont ror eost-
fective over Tong depth intervals, Continuons
measurements from logging tools suchas the CS
tool provide elemental yields that lead othe est-
tation of weight percent for various minerals
‘hat are common to organic shales
‘The primary outputs from the spectrosoony
toot include silicon [Si], calcium (Cal, iron
[Po sulfa (8) ttandur (7), gadolinium (Gd)
‘and potassium [K] Sohlumberger engineers use
SpectroL.ith thology provessing of spectra from
neutrorinduiced gamma ray spectroscopy tools
to compute the mineralogy and geochemical
data, Tey then calibrate SpectoLith outputs
‘with empirical relationships derived from an
cxtonsivo core chemistry and mineralogy data-
base, Matrix grain density can be determined
fom these data and used forthe porosity com
‘putation, Cartan types and quantities of miner
tals may indleate rocks that break or fracture
nore easily og anelpsts uso this information to
‘identify intervals for placing both vertical and
horizontal wellbores and initiating fydraulic
facturing, Spectroscopy data can also be
uoquired while dling using the BeoScope mul:
{ifunetion Jogging while driling service
‘Along with mineralogy daia, spectroscopy
moasurements provide information on elay types.
Tneincors uso cay type to predict sensitivity to
fracturing fui and to understand the fractuving
‘eharacterstles of the formation, Contact with
ater will ezuse some clays tn swell, which inhib-
its gas production and creates numerous opera-
tional issues, Smeetite Is the most common
‘swelling ela. Fuld sensitivity may be interred
‘rom clay typing bu ests on coves from the res
crv provide the most accurate information.
‘In adeition to iicatng uid sensitivity, lay
‘ypoisan indicator rocks tat are dete, thas
do not fraaure easily. Ductile shales are more
Likely to embed proppant, Other shale types may
be brittle and are more easily fractured, The
‘presence of Hite is preferred for Rydraule fac-
turing because it Is often indlative of brittle
rocks that are not reactive with water. The pres-
‘enge of smectite usually indioats ductile clay.
Acoustic measurements, especally those
‘that provide mechanical properties fer anisoto
pic shale redla, are also a significant need for
anderstanding the long-term productivity of
shale gas wells, The Sonic Scanner acoustic
searing platform provides dats that are wed
‘tn enhance mechanleal earth models and opt
nie dling and stimulation, Nechunteal prop-
ectlos that can be derived fom acoustic tols
include bulk saodulus, Posson’s ratio, Young's
‘movilus, yold strength, shear modulus and
compressive strength. These values are com
puted fom compressional shear-and Stoney
‘wavo moasurements
In highly laminated, agilieeous shales, the
‘Young's modulus and Poisson's ratio are a fine
tion of the orfentaton of the measarerent rela
tive to that of the formation bedding planes
‘These anlsotcopie mechanical propetie intu-
‘ence the elosuzestressand therefore the hydra
tie factate eight, Sonle Seamer data are used
+o estimalo anisotrople mechanleal properties
and thas provide arealisti determination ofthe
In sis rock sresses.
‘When a lage atforenco ovcurs between the
vertically and horizontally measured Young's
moduli, the elosuze stress willbe higher than
that in Sstrople weeks. Meso anisoteopte inter
‘vals are normally associtod with rock that have
higher ely volume 2s well as with expandable
‘lays. These cly-rich rocks are poor candles
{or both horizontal well placement and hydraulic
fracture simulation. Stresses in these intervals
will be higher, and it wll be more diicalt to
rotaln fracture conductivity during production
because the proppant is moze likely to embed
‘nto the ductile formation,
Sonie porosity is another acoustle messure-
rent that i beuecial in shale analysis, For
shales, sonic porosity s usually much lower than
roatron porosity. Tis isa function ofthe high
clayound water volume thal is common in
shales. When tho sonle porosity is much higher
‘han the neuron porosiy, is may indicate that
fs, rather than wator, is present in the pore
spaces, When the sonie and neutron porosity val-
‘sare sila the shale may be ol prone
‘og analysts. also use wireline borete image
logs, such as those fom tho FMI fullbre forex
tlon mierolmage too, to Wentify te presence of
ntural and deilingindueed fractures and to
define their orientation and concentration.
Interpreters can detormine from these dats
whether the natural fractures are closed (miner
alized) or open. Engineers use this information so
‘optimize lateral placement ond select perore:
tion ester locations along a horizontal wellbore
‘By analyzing diling induced fractares, thay can
also infer ho stato of near-ellbore stresses.
‘Although thee are methods for acquiring pet-
ropiysieal data In lateral wellbores, most wells
‘are dill vertieally and logged with full suite
of tools prfor to ailing the lateral setion. Dat
‘ean be acquired using LND tools, which have tho
aulded benefit of allowing directional drillers to
optimally ioe to bit inso potential set spots
‘The geoVISION imaging-while-driling, service
can provide vesstivity along with images for bed
ding and fracture ierteation; the SonieScope
multipole sonie while dling tool ean provide
acnustie measurements
‘The measurements from these various tools
‘canbe combinedin an integrated display such 3
{he shale montage og provided by Schlumberger
‘The formation properties are presented using a
‘common platform, and geologists can directly
compare the quality of the s00ks (next page).
Free and adsorbed gas aro computed and pre
sonted in ails of sefton, a common unit of mea
sorement in. ooal mining operations. Some
operators prefer adsorbed, free and total gs to
be presented in Ben, Gas resouree concentra
tion presented in a Bffsetion helps quantify the
total potential or a prospective shale resent,
‘eld Reviewas ie
Trower | 10S
ereaniagl
i ea
Trio [tetas omy
elon
anton
cae
lan® gem? 20]
|20% get 29]
Shona
anc Saren
‘Shale montage log. Water saturation and porosity ae computed from conventions resistivity Track 2) and porosity Track 3 logging tools. The ECS tool
Provides mineralogy (rack 6) and mati density Treck 4 for improved porosity computation snd diferenbates TOC rom pores (pink sheding). The grain
‘density of te rocks con also be computed and use to correct the density porosity (Track). Data from care samples provide Langmuir isotherms for 938,
‘storage capacity and confirm computed data io ensure model-based outputs such as matrix and bulk density, water saturation, tata porosity nd TOC.
Icicles, Tracks 4,6 and 7 are valid. Fuld saturations, corrected fr lithology, ar prosented in Track 8, Geoleget ee totel GIP, edsorbod gas and ree gas
Track), to determine the potential forthe reser. Adora features o! the shale montage ag are tho numerical outputsin Tracks 4,6, and 8 which
allow the geologist to reac valves erect trom the og For example, at XX ft the affective permecbilty red numbers, reck7)is 313 aD an the
‘cumulative free gas volume (blue numbers, Track) i 2 sefhon. In his interval, contrary to most organic sales, the gem ray (teck 1) sna a
‘9xces8 oF 150 gAPL
tua 2011 ”‘Tho integrated produc, ation to charac
terizing the petrophysiesl and. geomechanical
Droperties ofthe reser, hop engineers deter.
tine the depth to land the lateral for horizontal,
ring (below). Th preferred strategy sto di
‘in the minimum horizontal siress divecion,
‘which s perpendicular to the maxima horizon
tal toss,
Quality Rocks
‘Astudy in 2007 concluded that fewer than 908 of
Barnett Shale wells would! bo profitable at com-
‘modity pricing levels that ested at that time.®
“Much ofthe data wero tan fom wels that were
completed smile operaters were stil leemnig
how to properly exploit shales. Production log
(PL) data trom sevoral Barnet Stale wells inl
‘ated that 90% ofthe perforations provided 70%
ofthe total gss flow, and in some wells, 50% ofthe
Perforations were at lowing at the time of log:
‘ing Taking into account all the basins, the PL,
study showed that approximately 90% of pefora-
tion clusters were not cotaibutng to prodtion,
‘Those statistics iustate that, when og dats are
Jacking, cling blindly and hydraulically fretur-
‘ng geometrically staged intervals may not be the
optimal strategy,
‘Lending the lateral. Characterizing the rasarvois a crucial ste in daveloping ges shale
Prior to dilting, geologists and engineers
should identify layers Uhat have superior oser-
voir and geomechanies) characteristics, thon
rll and complete within these high-quality
Intervals, Shale resource plays typically cover
lacge geographic aren and thoi log characteris
fies may not change much laterally aaross the
basin, Howoves, subile, and sometimes not so
subile, lateral eterogenelty within these
sxuences results in areas with characteristics
that promote betor production and hyrraue
fracture stimulation, These sweet spats inclade
ones with high gas potentisl—good resorvait
quality (RQ)—and those that can be optimally
stimulated—aood completion quality (CQ).
Geologists build detalled models to simulate the
reservoir an attempt to identify he pats ofthe
eserole with the bost RQ and OQ, These models
an be refined as wells are drilled an more data
become availabe
Geologie features, especially naturally oocur-
ring ftactures, infuence well produetiviy
Knowledge of fracture density and oxienation
and in situ stress properties ean help engineers
‘make decisions on woll placement and spacing,
UR mes,
sate
rar
oxi
zai
pani
2a
22x
ut org
the lateral elles on mars than petophysies and geochemisty. Key parameters tret contol competion
‘ual (C0),
‘modulus is mer
ust be taken into account. The bulk modulus i one indcatr of £0. Rack of hig
likely to possess ower clay content end therefore hve # lower closure stess along
witha lowerpropeasty fr roppantambecment during production. This figure shows all patie,
‘against e projection of pool
that
only was the sinulation of tha toe seven more di
ic structure and bulk modulus. Tho fist two-thirds ofthe lataral we
nt ntorval. Th toe section isin ocks of lover buk modulus, which eve poorer producers. Not
cutthan the rest ofthe lateral, production from
‘he lowe bulk modulus intervals wes fess than that from the setter quality ck.
as woll as optimize a fracture stimulathon pro.
stam, Conventional reservoirs ean be drained
across long distances, but ecovery rom resouzee
plays depends on optimal wol spacing and maxi-
rmisng the fracture stimmlated volume.
‘The local ste regime Is important fr both
ring and stimulation. Stresses long. the
wellbore are a funetion of tectoni frees, depth
‘nd formation thickness In addition to changes
"resulting fom previous slimlation and produe-
‘lon of nearby walls, For optimal wellbore stil
‘ty ding shouldbe oriented inthe rection of
‘minimum principal stress. I¢ Is important to
‘understand how the rosoroi, including existing
natural fracture notwoeks, will react a8 itis
stressed during deing, stimulation and produc
tion, Changes in the rxervoir from production
and induced stresses will indluenco stimulation
‘stage organtzaton, perforation placement and
wel spacing decisions. This type of information
an be quantified in geomechanical studies,
Goomechanies isa branch of engineering that
applies solid meehanies, mathernates and phys.
fies to prediet how roeks respond te extoral
forces.” Folowing the lead from mining and cli
nginocring—dsciplines that have long used
‘omechanies to predict and avoid extatrophie
consequenees—driling. and production engl
neers are more frequently applying these con
cepts to reservoir development, These practioas
all for measuring and estimating sixesa and
‘examining how matorals respond to tess.
regions initial stato of stress reslts fom
its tectonic and sedimentary history. Stossee
are also induced by a variety of processes cort-
‘mon to ollie operations, including te effects
of drilling and changes infu pressure caused
by injection and prodtion. Al ofthese effects
can be simulated using SD and 4D earth noes,
allowing engineers to predit behavior ofthe res.
env in response to dling, sianlation and
future produetion,
Geophysics and engineers at Schlumberger
‘ayo built mechanical earth model inthe Pott
selsmie-tosimulation software that integrates
eta from ECLIPSE reservoir simulation soft
ware. Enghneors use these models for well pan
ning and to determine initial stress tates,
3By coupling the ECLIPSE SD shnulation with
the VISAGE Modelo, geophysics can eraio a
4D model, which simulates changes in the magn
tare and orientation of downhole stresses that
Oot Review‘Will Loge, Cores Cluster Ansss,
Mechanical Eat del
‘Stare and Fouts
‘Geomachanics in wel design. The VISAGE Modolarusos seisme Gata (top ight), 30 modk
data from woll logs and core
Seismic Ierton ECLIPSE Dts,
Propet Modeling with HRA
Hetoropeneous Rock Analye'sPrecesting
orion, riding
‘raat in the Pore program bowar of, bottom righ) and
eft to construct a geomechanical madel thet includes present-day tzesses and mechanical properties (canter
mento time can be added, croating 24D model. Changes in stresses affect eiling end impact the effectiveness
ofthe simulations, which great influences productivity,
‘cecur ovr time (above), The fall production his-
tory fora single well, multiple wells or an entie
field can be simulated and visualized using the
combination of BCLIPSE und VISAGE software.
‘The identification of potential driling time
lation sn production hazards is anothor crucial
blocs of information gleaned from seismic data,
Existing faults can be espocally troublesome
When an operator is hydzuuleally fracturing a
shale interval. A faut can effectively dominate
he fracture growth and redret al the energy of
ths treatment into te fault sytem and out ofthe
tangot zone. Subsequent frachre stages may grow
into previously stimulated fats, adding litle to
‘the total stimulated volume. Faults also serve
conduits that direct the hydra facta toat-
‘ments into zones that produce wate, which can
otenlally il or rently reduoe gas produetion
‘Basod on knowledge gained from 30 years of
Bameit Shale development, engineers have
Tearned to account for several considerations
‘when developing resource plays. These Include
Inoving the present-day maximom horizontal
stress direction to determine optinal wellbore
Alretion; quantifying natural fracture density,
nature and orientation relative tothe maximum
horizontal stress direction; having suffclent
‘knowledge of geomechanies to dasign comple
ons that promote maximum hyétaulle factore
surface area and compleity, and understanding
the fracturetofracture interference from both
‘multiple stages and multiple well, Completion
engineers must balance the cost of stimulation
and dling against the addition of wells or tre
ture stimulation stages. These decisions are
srealy aided by the 3D and 4D models,
Hyeraulle Fracturing
‘Sucoess in developing the Barnett Shale has boon
attributed in part to the use of costetfective
slickwater facturo treatments" Howeve,slick-
wala Is rot tho only type of teatment utilized
during dovelopment and may not be the coroct
‘uid ehotce for some shale ‘ypes:* Gelled, gss-
assisted and hybrid fracture stimulations hae all,
Deen tested in the Barnett Shale as wo asin
other shale plays.”
Thero i no single solution forall shale reser
voles For instance, although sllekwater has been.
sn effective technique inthe Barnott Shale, the
Tower sand-carrying capacity of hose systems, 28
‘compared with gelled systems, and the propen
sity for proppant stting can limit Row capacity
for induced fractures. The limited contactor loss
of conductivity within the simulated area can,
also cause produetion eats to plummet.
10 Berman A What's New n Exatn” Want ab
‘rina Novente IT mo P68 SNE
itis ecassed Dette 9 2
li Wars Ban yan “Eaton
Praaeto on Dts or atonal ets Oot
Cue Sats” papor SPE 125, rend at
the SPE Hons roe Uneanvorara Ces,
Carfarene ane Bon The Weodont,eas,
dine i218. 2.
‘Autumn 2011
12 Zook MO: Reservar Geanechonc, NewYork Ch
Charge Univers Pos 20
1 ing E:T Yonrs of Gas Ste Fracting at
ave Wa ewe?” par SE 55 pcorad the
SPE Anne! Tochneal Coslernce a hbo,
Forney Septonbar 1-72 20,
1 Siehuneracieg ie ar comaooe of sr
an yo aly pera) ota
tho Fieon roseuro when pao te od
‘troup eaul
15K retrnee
pole carg hey
fencers popprtarusod tan he
rerwaiee reper
0'AWicrossismi monitoring of muitile-stage hydra fracturing across a lataral, Analysis of
‘riovosvsmi data, a8 inthis SUmMAP hydraulic facture stimulation slagnostes presentation, can
provide operators wth information cbout the eflotiveness of hydraulic facturing treatments. In tis
beample vo stages were pumped from tha treating wal (od fine) wile monitored fram a scone
‘nal (gree tne vath location of geophones shown 8s groen cirlas). The fs tage {yellow dos)
Utthe tow ofthe lateral crectes 9 complex facture network; however, the ond stage flue dts)
‘veriaps tho simulated volume from th fist stage. Tho thid and ith stages (red and magenta dts)
‘Sovelop complex fractures. Th fourth stage (cyan dot) hase preferentil erection thatleaves some
ofthe fecmationuntouchod Iti imporant to identify hese venation in freeture quality to optimize
{ure stmulaton designs, well placement and wel spacing, Tools suchas StimMAP LIVE realtime
tniroseismic fracture monitoring service may alla complaton engineers the opportunity to adjust
‘operation dung the execution of tha jb to nprove the effectiveness ofthe weatmont
‘Fayeteuill Shale, Arkoma basin, Southwastarn Enorgy developed a Fayetavile Shel play located
jnnorth central Arkorsas, USA, The company acreage (rad box) includes formations with complex
‘structure as arasult of regional fing and upit.
0
Another concern with slickwater fracturing is
shale ld sensitivity becuse some clay types
have a tendency to swell when they come into
contact with water, ss and foam Aids seem to
fer an doa alternative to sliekwater and gelled
stems; however, they are not extensively used
‘ecanse of thelr higher cost, nied avalbility
and the fact that they aro traditionally deployed
for small jobs. Tho conundrum faced by opera
{orsisto find the best system forthe spotie shale
‘sll minimizing the expense of trial and erro.”
Recently scientists at the Schlumberger
‘Novasbizek Technology Center in Russia dovel
ped a novel approach to hydraulic facture
design The HIWAY Now