Sunteți pe pagina 1din 6

REPORT SUMMARY Date: 11/17/2017

Page 1 of 6

In addition to this summary, this report includes the following forms:


Report Summary
Rating Criteria and Classifications
J1739 (2009)
Actions

Xfmea Report Sample – Machinery FMEA


This report was generated with ReliaSoft Xfmea by HBM Prenscia software in Microsoft Word. Similar
reports can also be generated in Microsoft Excel. You can easily replace the Xfmea logo graphic with
your own company logo. Within Word and Excel, reports can be edited/annotated, if necessary, and
generated in PDF and/or HTML format for easy distribution.

This report includes:

• A summary of the rating criteria (Severity Scale, Occurrence Scale, Detection Scale) and
classifications that were used in the analysis.
• The Machinery FMEA (MFMEA) spreadsheet report in the SAE J1739 reporting format.
• A summary list of the recommended actions identified during the analysis.

The report is based on the sample analysis provided in the SAE J1739 guidelines, on page 45.

Non-proprietary and non-confidential information.


Date Created: 11/17/2017 Creator: HBM Prenscia Generated by ReliaSoft Xfmea http://www.reliasoft.com
RATING CRITERIA AND CLASSIFICATIONS Date: 11/17/2017

Page 2 of 6

Severity Rating Scale Occurrence Rating Scale


# Description Criteria 1 # Description Criteria
1 None No discernible effect. 1 Remote: Failure is unlikely <= 0.01 per thousand vehicles/items
Fit and finish/Squeak and rattle item does not conform.
2 Very Minor Defect noticed by discriminating customers (less than 2 Low: Relatively few failures 0.1 per thousand vehicles/items
25%).
Fit and finish/Squeak and rattle item does not conform.
3 Minor 3 Low: Relatively few failures 0.5 per thousand vehicles/items
Defect noticed by 50% of customers.
Fit and finish/Squeak and rattle item does not conform.
4 Very Low 4 Moderate: Occasional failures 1 per thousand vehicles/items
Defect noticed by most customers (greater than 75%).
Vehicle/Item operable but Comfort/Convenience item(s)
5 Low 5 Moderate: Occasional failures 2 per thousand vehicles/items
inoperable. Customer somewhat dissatisfied.
Vehicle/Item operable but Comfort/Convenience item(s)
6 Moderate 6 Moderate: Occasional failures 5 per thousand vehicles/items
inoperable. Customer dissatisfied.
Vehicle/Item operable but at a reduced level of
7 High 7 High: Frequent failures 10 per thousand vehicles/items
performance. Customer very dissatisfied.
8 Very High Vehicle/Item inoperable (loss of primary function). 8 High: Frequent failures 20 per thousand vehicles/items
Very high severity ranking when a potential failure mode
affects safe vehicle operation and/or involves
9 Hazardous with warning 9 Very High: Persistent failures 50 per thousand vehicles/items
noncompliance with government regulation with
warning.
Very high severity ranking when a potential failure mode
affects safe vehicle operation and/or involves
10 Hazardous without warning 10 Very High: Persistent failures => 100 per thousand vehicles/items
noncompliance with government regulation without
warning.
Detection Rating Scale Classification Options
# Description Criteria 1 Abbreviation Description
Design Control will almost certainly detect a potential
1 Almost Certain C Critical
cause/mechanism and subsequent failure mode.
Very High chance the Design Control will detect a
2 Very High potential cause/mechanism and subsequent failure KI Key Intermediate
mode.
High chance the Design Control will detect a potential
3 High KLd Key Leading
cause/mechanism and subsequent failure mode.
Moderately High chance the Design Control will detect a
4 Moderately High potential cause/mechanism and subsequent failure KLg Key Lagging
mode.
Moderate chance the Design Control will detect a
5 Moderate potential cause/mechanism and subsequent failure S Significant
mode.
Low chance the Design Control will detect a potential
6 Low KPC Key Product Characteristic
cause/mechanism and subsequent failure mode.
Very Low chance the Design Control will detect a
7 Very Low potential cause/mechanism and subsequent failure KCC Key Control Characteristic
mode.
Remote chance the Design Control will detect a potential
8 Remote
cause/mechanism and subsequent failure mode.
Very Remote chance the Design Control will detect a
9 Very Remote potential cause/mechanism and subsequent failure
mode.

Non-proprietary and non-confidential information.


Date Created: 11/17/2017 Creator: HBM Prenscia Generated by ReliaSoft Xfmea http://www.reliasoft.com
RATING CRITERIA AND CLASSIFICATIONS Date: 11/17/2017

Page 3 of 6

Design Control will not and/or cannot detect a potential


10 Absolute Uncertainty cause/mechanism and subsequent failure mode; or there
is no Design Control.

Non-proprietary and non-confidential information.


Date Created: 11/17/2017 Creator: HBM Prenscia Generated by ReliaSoft Xfmea http://www.reliasoft.com
FAILURE MODE AND EFFECTS ANALYSIS
Vacuum Pump
Item 1.1 - Vacuum Pump FMEA Number MF112
Model Year(s)/Program(s) 201X/AllStar Key Date 4/14/2017
Design Responsibility Firebrakes (supplier) Prepared By 5/2/2017
Core Team Mike Brake, John Doe, Jim Dominion (supplier) FMEA Date (Orig.) 2/2/2017
Support Team

Action Results

Classification
Potential Potential Current Design Current Design
Name / Potential Recommended Responsibility & Planned

RPNi
OCCi

DETi
SEVi
Effect(s) of Cause(s)/Mechanisms Controls Controls Actions Taken &

RPNr
OCCr

DETr
Function Failure Mode Action(s) Completion Date

SEVr
Failure of Failure (Prevention) (Detection) Actual
Completion Date

Vacuum Pump
Provides vacuum Partial or Moderate 4 Flexing, rubbing of 6 Robot dressing 5 120 Investigate longer Jim 3/30/2015 Selected cables and 3 4 4 48
to evacuate brake complete loss of downtime in cables, jumpers and practices. life cables, hoses Manufacturing, hoses with longer
system. Achieve X air, water, and replacing the hoses with each other Recommended and jumpers. Mike Cable, life than originally
millimeters in Y power supply to dressing. during welding. jumper and cable (Reduces Supplier specified. -
seconds as the the weld gun. Downtime varies lengths. occurrence) 3/30/2015
furthest wheel from 10-30 Preventive
from the vacuum minutes for maintenance.
source. replacement. Water Savers
Machinery
Controls stop the
process.

Investigate use of Joe Dressiing, 3/13/2017 Abrasion resistant


abrasion resistant Supplier sleeves to be used
protective covering at points that are
for cables and subject to high wear
hoses. (Reduces and tear.
occurrence) - 3/13/2017

Split cabling for Joe Dressing, 3/13/2017 Completed.


water hoses/cables Supplier - 3/13/2017
to minimize length
of replacement.
(Reduces
downtime/effects
severity)

Utilize infrared Joe Dressing, 3/13/2017 Infrared


thermography to Assembly Plant Thermography
predict robot 123 incorporated into
dressing failure. predictive
(Improves maintenance plans.
detection) - 3/13/2017

Non-proprietary and non-confidential information.


Date Created: 11/17/2017 Creator: HBM Prenscia Generated by ReliaSoft Xfmea http://www.reliasoft.com
ACTIONS Date: 11/17/2017

Page 5 of 6

Planned Expected Review Last Potentia Potential Potential


Actio Action Recommended Responsibilit Actions Planne Reviewe Actua Revie Last RPN RPN
Completio Completio Comment Updated Name Function l Failure Effect(s) Cause(s)/Mechanism
n ID # Action(s) y Taken d Cost r l Cost w Date Updated i r
n Date n Date s By Mode of Failure s of Failure
5 1.1.1.1. Investigate Jim 3/30/2015 3/30/2015 Selected 0 0 ReliaSoft 7/29/2015 Vacuu Provides Partial or Moderate Flexing, rubbing of 120 48
1 longer life Manufacturing, cables and Corporatio 10:53 AM m vacuum to complete downtime in cables, jumpers and
cables, hoses Mike Cable, hoses with n Pump evacuate loss of replacing hoses with each other
and jumpers. Supplier longer life brake air, the during welding.
(Reduces than originally system. water, dressing.
occurrence) specified. Achieve X and Downtime
millimeter power varies from
s in Y supply to 10-30
seconds the weld minutes for
as the gun. replacement
furthest .
wheel
from the
vacuum
source.
6 1.1.1.1. Investigate use Joe Dressiing, 3/13/2017 3/13/2017 Abrasion 0 0 HBM 11/17/201 Vacuu Provides Partial or Moderate Flexing, rubbing of 120 48
2 of abrasion Supplier resistant Prenscia 7 9:14 AM m vacuum to complete downtime in cables, jumpers and
resistant sleeves to be Pump evacuate loss of replacing hoses with each other
protective used at points brake air, the during welding.
covering for that are system. water, dressing.
cables and subject to Achieve X and Downtime
hoses. (Reduces high wear and millimeter power varies from
occurrence) tear. s in Y supply to 10-30
seconds the weld minutes for
as the gun. replacement
furthest .
wheel
from the
vacuum
source.
7 1.1.1.1. Split cabling for Joe Dressing, 3/13/2017 3/13/2017 Completed. 0 0 HBM 11/17/201 Vacuu Provides Partial or Moderate Flexing, rubbing of 120 48
3 water Supplier Prenscia 7 9:14 AM m vacuum to complete downtime in cables, jumpers and
hoses/cables to Pump evacuate loss of replacing hoses with each other
minimize length brake air, the during welding.
of replacement. system. water, dressing.
(Reduces Achieve X and Downtime
downtime/effect millimeter power varies from
s severity) s in Y supply to 10-30
seconds the weld minutes for
as the gun. replacement
furthest .
wheel
from the
vacuum
source.

Non-proprietary and non-confidential information.


Date Created: 11/17/2017 Creator: HBM Prenscia Generated by ReliaSoft Xfmea http://www.reliasoft.com
ACTIONS Date: 11/17/2017

Page 6 of 6

8 1.1.1.1. Utilize infrared Joe Dressing, 3/13/2017 3/13/2017 Infrared 0 0 HBM 11/17/201 Vacuu Provides Partial or Moderate Flexing, rubbing of 120 48
4 thermography to Assembly Plant Thermograph Prenscia 7 9:15 AM m vacuum to complete downtime in cables, jumpers and
predict robot 123 y Pump evacuate loss of replacing hoses with each other
dressing failure. incorporated brake air, the during welding.
(Improves into predictive system. water, dressing.
detection) maintenance Achieve X and Downtime
plans. millimeter power varies from
s in Y supply to 10-30
seconds the weld minutes for
as the gun. replacement
furthest .
wheel
from the
vacuum
source.

Non-proprietary and non-confidential information.


Date Created: 11/17/2017 Creator: HBM Prenscia Generated by ReliaSoft Xfmea http://www.reliasoft.com